News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by jliptzin on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#37703854)
It is how it’s supposed to work. She was 85 when she got elected the last time. If voters don’t want 90 year olds in office, maybe they shouldn’t vote 85 year olds in for a 6 year term. If she can’t be beat in a primary, then we need something like ranked choice voting so people can safely vote for an alternative third party without risking spoiling the election for a candidate they definitely don’t want.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by anonymouse008 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:33AM (#37703993)
I encourage you to run a campaign, just in a local county. You will find there are things one can't see from the outside that make this sentiment naively false.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:35AM (#37704019)
List them here! You aren't actually saying anything.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by paulgb on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:00AM (#37704373)
My wife was part of a congressional primary campaign so I got to see some of this close-up. It’s hard to list all the reasons, but there is definitely a sort of institutional inertia that makes it hard to primary someone on the story of merely being the better candidate, unless there is an a prior consensus among voters that the incumbent needs to go.

Some examples:

- Congressional elections are expensive; incumbents have deeper-rooted donor networks to tap.

- Civic groups that are already working with the incumbent want to continue the relationship.

- General voter apathy around primary elections; even regular voters often skip primaries so finding people who will actually vote gets harder.

- Name recognition; if someone shows up to the polls to vote for another ballot item but hasn't followed the congressional race, they'll probably put a box next to the incumbent unless they have a particular reason not to.

I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing -- high turnover of elected officials is disruptive to the system -- but there are clearly cases in which it overcorrects.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by philipov on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:43AM (#37705054)
The part about voter apathy towards primaries is important. It means that the sort of people who vote in primaries don't represent an unbiased sample of their party: they skew towards the extremes, because those people can be more easily mobilized. This means that primaries don't produce candidates capable of representing the median voter very well, and we end up with a choice between the canonical Giant Douche and Turd Sandwich. That's why the Freedom Caucus doesn't want McCarthy to use funding to influence primaries in their states; it would allow him to enforce party discipline on them.

This becomes even worse when combined with "safe" districts where whoever wins the primary for the district's ruling party is nearly guaranteed to win the general election as well. It makes one wonder how democratic we should consider such an election to be.

All this is to say that it's important to not just look at whether an institution is democratic in form, but whether it is also democratic in outcomes. The Law of Unintended Consequences will be obeyed.

[https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/UnintendedConsequences.h...]

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:52AM (#37705165)
I feel that in the last 20+ years or so, the candidates have seem to forgotten the "appeal to the crazies in the primaries, pivot for the general".

Then again, the whole point of democracy is that the voters will get what they want and get it good and hard.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by philipov on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:13AM (#37705450)
The voters don't get what they want, they get what you offer them. With a good marketing budget, you might be able to convince voters to want what you're offering them. That's called Manufactured Demand.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by anonymouse008 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:08AM (#37704506)
Other comments have gotten at the nuts and bolts of administrations, and here's the PR side of it:

Do the 'Mom Test' on any candidate and you will see why 9 out of 10 times a challenger to an incumbent fails [0]. The only challengers who succeed beat the 'good enough test' while simultaneously fending off the current administration's inertia (aptly put by paulgb)

[0] https://www.momtestbook.com/

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ImPostingOnHN on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:24AM (#37704741)
what is "the mom test"?

the link seems to be an entire marketing campaign selling a book and a brand, with no "test" clearly specified - can you summarize it, please?

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ativzzz on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:40AM (#37705015)
From chatGPT: "What is the mom test?"

The "Mom Test" is a term from a book by Rob Fitzpatrick titled "The Mom Test: How to talk to customers & learn if your business is a good idea when everyone is lying to you". It is about customer development and strategies for entrepreneurs to properly validate their business ideas.

The title refers to the notion that even your mom, who generally loves you unconditionally, would lie to you to spare your feelings if your business idea wasn’t good. So, the "Mom Test" suggests a method of asking the right questions to get honest and useful feedback from people, including those who might be predisposed to be nice to you.

The key principles of the Mom Test are:

    Talk about their life instead of your idea: Ask about specific behaviors and thoughts in their past and present, not about hypothetical futures. Avoid asking whether they think your business idea is good. Instead, focus on their problems, pains, and needs related to the area your business is focused on.

    Ask for specifics in the past instead of generics or opinions about the future: People's predictions about their future behaviors are typically inaccurate. By asking about their past actions, you can gather more reliable information.

    Talk less and listen more: This is about them, not about you or your idea. The goal is to gather insights, so avoid leading questions and let them do the talking.
By following these principles, entrepreneurs can gather real insights into customer needs and challenges, which is crucial for validating and improving business ideas.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by anonymouse008 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:35AM (#37704927)
“Is it good enough”

It’s running through questions like so: When you have an issue with county government, how do you handle it?

Their answer will tell you many things. Is it actually a concern the county can address? If it is not an issue the county can address, why do they think it is? If it’s a strong held belief, what experiences solidified it (buying a lot and being told one thing by a realtor, for example) - etc. you then use all of that to create a product (a campaign messaging) that aligns with the candidate and public’s opinion / current default mode.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by hobotime on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:45AM (#37704146)
I ran for a city councilmember:

1) You opponents campaign manager will lie about their candidate without qualms. 2) Donors will give money to a scoundrel, as long as they think the scoundrel will win. 3) Voters are actually good at picking up bullshit - in aggregate. 4) Rich white liberal female voters will not vote for a man. 5) Plenty of Black, Asian, and Immigrant voters are conservative, but many reflexively vote liberal. 6) Do it, even if you lose by a small amount like I did, you'll learn a lot and have a lot of fun

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by SamPatt on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:45AM (#37705077)
That doesn't sound even the tiniest bit fun. I'm genuinely curious about what made it fun, presumably something you didn't mention?
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by hobotime on Monday October 02, 2023 @03:45PM (#37743445)
I grew a lot and made a lot of friends in so many communities, and I learned from immigrants about the values my great grandparents also had.

I'm conservative and found that I have so much in common with so many people that I'm sort of pissed that our culture has done it's best to keep us apart.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by rdedev on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:56AM (#37705211)
Thanks for this analysis. I feel like there is a big diconnect between what groups of people are assumed to be like vs what they actually do. Point 5 being the most apparent for me
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by Enginerrrd on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:30AM (#37703958)
I'd rather see a proportional system.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by wolfram74 on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:34AM (#37704000)
The problem is first past the post is in the running for the worst way to run a democracy, so basically any reform option would work, and it's hard to get consensus around change.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by mcphage on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:39AM (#37704064)
Are you saying that First Past the Post won at being First Past the Post? :-)
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by grotorea on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:52AM (#37704254)
(Closed-list) proportional system wouldn't stop an unfit party insider being put at the top of the list.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by davidw on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:41AM (#37705037)
Proportional has other flaws too, like small parties playing 'kingmaker'. As in: say the two major parties each get 45%, and I run an outfit that got 10%. To have a majority, you're going to have to deal with me, so I'm going to have way more influence than my 10% would warrant.

I've seen this happen in the real world in Italy.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by banannaise on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:54AM (#37704281)
A proportional system will still have one of the primary issues with the current system: the parties choose their representatives, and the two major ones will continue to trot out just the worst people they can find.

(Yes, there are primaries, but the DNC and RNC hold an astronomical amount of power in picking the candidates and influencing the winners.)

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by HDThoreaun on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:28AM (#37705667)
But that's not a problem when you can just defect from the major parties with no penalty. The major parties are only able to continually put up garbage candidates because there are no other options.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by mcv on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:14AM (#37704594)
Ranked voting for single offices (president, governor, etc), and proportional for any representative body, like the House and Senate.

Or, if the Senate is really meant to represent the states rather than the people, it should only be concerned with state issues: which issues belong at the federal level, and which at the state level, for example.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by bombcar on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:01AM (#37705284)
I'd be fine with a literal random selection with the people being able to trigger "no-confidence" at set intervals.

Can't be much worse and statistically it should have basically the same outcome.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by pxx on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:14AM (#37704591)
Ranked choice voting (the brand name for Instant Runoff or Hare voting) neither theoretically [0] nor empirically [1] has the outcomes for third parties that you think it does. This combined with its other flaws makes it worse than plurality.

Not only that, it doesn't allow for distributed counts [2], it can wreck the secret ballot [3], and it is not monotonic [4]. Arrow gives us an impossibility result for elections but monotonicity is the worst criterion to give up, especially when the system has so many other flaws.

[0] https://rangevoting.org/TarrIrv.html

[1] see examples cited in https://rangevoting.org/NoIrv.html

[2] sure, you can transmit the contents of all of the ballots, but then it's still a centralized count...

[3] n! grows much much larger than population, so you can encode ballot ID

[4] http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by iambateman on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:43AM (#37705056)
The real problem with RCV is that it doesn't intuitively make sense to an average person. I wrote a web app for RCV and spent months trying to build a user experience that would help people understand the concept and it just doesn't work.

People come to the question of voting assuming it's easy to understand...We've never had to deal with complexity around the concept so we expect it to be simple.

Introducing an algorithm plays into the fears of people who believe in a deep state which is secretly trying to manipulate people.

We deeply need a better voting system, but one of the core requirements must be that one can explain it to a middle schooler in 30 seconds.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by qsort on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:32AM (#37705729)
An additional problem is trust.

With any RCV method, you win because math says so. In a normal election you count.

It's basically 100% guaranteed that someone who won most first choices but lost the election will try to delegitimize the election with stupid populism.

The first and most important job of an election is to ensure peaceful transfer of power.

My favorite alternate system is approval voting. Vote any number of candidates rather than just one. Most votes wins. 5 seconds and no nerd required.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by matt-attack on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:52AM (#37705167)
How is it hard to explain: please put these names in a row from best to worst.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by beej71 on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#37705696)
When I tested out of high school, one of the test questions gave you a list of planets and their diameters.

The multiple choice question was: which of these answers lists the planets in order from smallest to largest diameter?

This was for a high school diploma equivalent! I was stumped for a while wondering if I was understanding the question correctly.

Anyway, I passed the test, but the fact this question was on there gave me serious doubts as to the general skill of the populace. I'm a fan of RCV over the current system, but I know it's going to trip a lot of people up.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by taylodl on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:04AM (#37705333)
Citizens of other countries have figured it out. Which means, of course, Americans can't. And yes, I'm an American.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by nvm0n2 on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:59AM (#37714022)
It's the way this leads to a specific outcome that's hard to explain.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by xtiansimon on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:52AM (#37706034)
> “The real problem with RCV is that it doesn't intuitively make sense to an average person.”

And yet it’s happening in NYC:

_“The first Ranked Choice Voting election was on February 2nd, 2021 in a special election for NYC Council District 24 (Queens).”_

If you can make it in NYC, you can make it anywhere.

https://www.nyc.gov/site/civicengagement/voting/ranked-choic...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by paradoxyl on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:30AM (#37704839)
When do you think some third party is going to arise out of the broken cesspool of one-party machine politics in the state of dementia known as California? Please, fill us in.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by swasheck on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:45AM (#37705927)
no need to single out california. this is prevalent in so many places. texas. south carolina. wyoming. new mexico.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by mc32 on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:41AM (#37705038)
We should have the ability to do a recall when mental faculties come into question. Have a bare minimum mental fitness test: Time awareness, location awareness, action consequence relationship, grade 6 comprehension and control over bodily functions

Weekend at Bernie's should remain a farce and not a commentary on reality.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by yboris on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:46AM (#37705103)
Putting it on your radar: Approval Voting

Has many advantages over RCV / IRV (Ranked Choice Voting / Instant Runoff Voting). For one - no need to change ballots; educating the public is a single sentence rather than a more-complicated explanation.

https://electionscience.org/library/approval-voting/

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by matt-attack on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:58AM (#37705241)
Doesn’t seem to allow people to express their natural feelings. RCV does. I absolutely have a favorite. And I want to be able to encode that. I also have a 2nd choice, and so on.

Imagine a case where I really really want one guy, and between the remaining two I have a strong preference for one over the other. RCV lets me express that.

Approval would have been stuck. Should I mention the 2nd guy? I do want them if it came to having to choose but I’d hate to place them on even footing with my top top pick.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ClayShentrup on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:42PM (#37721409)
this is a common intuition-based fallacy. i'm an expert with almost 20 years of experience working in this field with various phd's in political science, math, and game theory. i explain this here:

https://medium.com/election-science/expressiveness-6ef8c034b...

tl;dr - for any two candidates, X and Y, the voters who approve only one of them express a "ranked preference" between them. and because those voters are, on average, a good statistical sample of the X-vs-Y preference of the entire electorate, approval voting turns out to measure voter preferences very accurately.

whereas instant runoff voting can actually have much bigger problems in preference detection because it only looks at one layer of preferences at a time. for example:

35% left center 33% right center 32% center

in this example, center is preferred to both the left and the right by a LANDSLIDE 2/3rds majority, yet is the first candidate eliminated. this happens because of "vote splitting" (spoiler effect) between the two more partisan candidates. so it might _feel_ like you expressed your preferences better. but you didn't really.

and what about STRATEGIC VOTING?

if right wins, then the left supporters will wish they had strategically voted for center to prevent that. and if left wins, then right supporters will wish they had strategically voted for center to prevent that.

approval voting satisfies the "favorite betrayal criterion", which means it cannot possibly hurt you to support your sincere favorite candidate.

for these and many other reasons, approval voting is vastly superior to ranking. https://electionscience.org/library/approval-voting-versus-i...

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by panax on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:17PM (#37706387)
Another system similar to this but with more information is STAR voting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting

They all have different strengths and weaknesses. We should be trying to move to more optimal systems.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by margalabargala on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:45PM (#37706782)
A major, important difference between the two is that a median HN user can read the Wikipedia page on STAR voting and come away not fully understanding it and have further questions (do score difference magnitudes matter in the runoff? Or only which is higher?).

Meanwhile approval voting is exhaustively explained by "vote for as many candidates as you like. Candidate with the most votes wins."

A "more optimal" voting system doesn't exist in a vacuum, public understanding and trust make a voting system more optimal. Just not more mathematically optimal.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by ClayShentrup on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:45PM (#37721423)
cardinal (rated) voting methods are better than ordinal (ranked). so score voting, approval voting, and star voting are all good.

approval voting is just score voting on a 0-1 binary scale. star voting is score voting on a 0-5 scale, followed by an "instant runoff" between the top two highest rated candidates.

> public understanding and trust make a voting system more optimal.

star voting: score the candidates from 0 - 5 and the winner is the majority favorite between the two highest rated overall.

there's no risk with public understanding here. i've worked on this subject since 2006, and conducted exit polls with score voting ballots within months of getting into this issue. people understand it just fine. it's radically simpler than ranking.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by SllX on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:51AM (#37705156)
And there is an additional check: the Senate itself can expel individual members. We elected her, and they didn’t expel her. RIP Senator Feinstein.
Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by the_snooze on Friday September 29, 2023 @10:56AM (#37705212)
RCV advocates miss the point entirely. It's not that people want to vote for third parties but can't. It's that the candidates that survive the major parties' primary elections have only to pander to their insane bases. In California where no-party-indicateds outnumber Republicans, the top-2 system is effectivley a Democratic primary.

Alaska has the right idea: a jungle primary where the top-4 advance, followed by an RCV general. RCV by itself doesn't do much. You have to weaken the primary electorate, as Alaska does.

Re:Senator Dianne Feinstein Dies at 90 by roenxi on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:06AM (#37705348)
If you're going to lay responsibility at the feet of the voters it isn't fair to throw out a "It is how it’s supposed to work.". The voters decide how it is supposed to work by making arguments and talking to each other and expressing opinions. If voters have power then expressing what qualities a politician should have helps the process.

And while ranked choice voting is probably superior, it'd be a lot easier for one of the parties to implement RCV internally then call it a day. The major problem is that the primary system is too incumbent-friendly, making it hard for challengers to grow organically.

And I don't buy the argument that the US Congress Regulars have done a good job. They look like they've mucked a lot of stuff up, badly, and left a series of ruins behind them. Literally in many cases.