People come to the question of voting assuming it's easy to understand...We've never had to deal with complexity around the concept so we expect it to be simple.
Introducing an algorithm plays into the fears of people who believe in a deep state which is secretly trying to manipulate people.
We deeply need a better voting system, but one of the core requirements must be that one can explain it to a middle schooler in 30 seconds.
With any RCV method, you win because math says so. In a normal election you count.
It's basically 100% guaranteed that someone who won most first choices but lost the election will try to delegitimize the election with stupid populism.
The first and most important job of an election is to ensure peaceful transfer of power.
My favorite alternate system is approval voting. Vote any number of candidates rather than just one. Most votes wins. 5 seconds and no nerd required.
The multiple choice question was: which of these answers lists the planets in order from smallest to largest diameter?
This was for a high school diploma equivalent! I was stumped for a while wondering if I was understanding the question correctly.
Anyway, I passed the test, but the fact this question was on there gave me serious doubts as to the general skill of the populace. I'm a fan of RCV over the current system, but I know it's going to trip a lot of people up.
And yet it’s happening in NYC:
_“The first Ranked Choice Voting election was on February 2nd, 2021 in a special election for NYC Council District 24 (Queens).”_
If you can make it in NYC, you can make it anywhere.
https://www.nyc.gov/site/civicengagement/voting/ranked-choic...
Not only that, it doesn't allow for distributed counts [2], it can wreck the secret ballot [3], and it is not monotonic [4]. Arrow gives us an impossibility result for elections but monotonicity is the worst criterion to give up, especially when the system has so many other flaws.
[0] https://rangevoting.org/TarrIrv.html
[1] see examples cited in https://rangevoting.org/NoIrv.html
[2] sure, you can transmit the contents of all of the ballots, but then it's still a centralized count...
[3] n! grows much much larger than population, so you can encode ballot ID
[4] http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/