News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:45PM (#37284342)
I don't get why the SEC doesn't enforce a minimum tick rate of one second. Heck, even one whole minute would barely exceed the noise floor. High-frequency trading doesn't need to exist, and the brilliant minds bashing their heads against the problem could be pursuing far more productive endeavors.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by 542458 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:54PM (#37284426)
> High-frequency trading doesn't need to exist

Neither does most of the stock market, for many definitions of “need”. But on the flip side, nobody has ever really demonstrated strong negative effects from HFT and many studies show positive effects, so bans seem very kneejerk to me.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by hhs on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:07PM (#37284564)
> But on the flip side, nobody has ever really demonstrated strong negative effects from HFT and many studies show positive effects

If interested, this is a paper published in January 2023 called "Does high-frequency trading actually improve market liquidity? A comparative study for selected models and measures" [0].

And the abstract notes: "By comparing a variety of regression models that associate various measures of market liquidity with measures of high-frequency activity on the same dataset, we find that for some models the increase in high-frequency activity improves market liquidity, but for others, we get the opposite effect. We indicate that this ambiguity does not depend only on the stock market or the data period, but also on the used HFT measure: the increase of high-frequency orders leads to lower market liquidity whereas the increase in high-frequency trades improves liquidity. We hypothesize that the observed decrease in market liquidity associated with an increasing level of high-frequency orders is caused by a rise in quote volatility." [0]

[0]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027553192...

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:33PM (#37284830)
The stock market provides an efficient medium for the allocation of capital. This means that corporations can more easily and safely raise capital from the public and that the public can participate in the positive-sum growth of publicly traded companies and the economy at large. Moreover, the stock market, like any market efficient enough to be worth its salt, provides a uniquely effective information aggregation mechanism via price discovery, facilitating more accurate and more precise forecasting and prediction for nearly any process which interacts with the greater economy.

Studies of high-frequency trading have yet to show benefits to these processes above and beyond those provided by a slower static tick rate, and in fact, more recent studies seem to suggest that HFT may even exist only to the detriment of these processes, all while wasting undue resources, both physical and intellectual, on an endless arms race over ever decreasing trading latency[1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-frequency_trading

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by j-pb on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:23AM (#37290500)
> The stock market provides an efficient medium for the allocation of capital.

Only if P=NP.[1]

Besides

  Efficiency: the ratio of the useful work performed by a machine or in a process to the total energy expended or heat taken in.
This also begs the question: "To efficiently allocate capital (energy) for what goal (work)?"

And it doesn't look like the answer to that is "the betterment of humanity", but to push the bell curve of wealth as far to the left as possible with the longest tail possible, externalities be damned.

The stock market isn't a usefull tool for society like kickstarter, but a wealth extraction mechanism for the wealthiest.

So I'd argue that HFT isn't any more immoral than T.

1: https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:58AM (#37290739)
> Efficiency: the ratio of the useful work

And then you merely link a proof that the efficiency is not 100%. That's effectively meaningless.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by consilient on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:49AM (#37291064)
That's not what efficiency means in this context. People who say the market is efficient mean one of:

- You can't beat the market

- You can't beat the market without insider information

- You can't beat the market using only information about historical prices.

(Insert "approximately" and "by enough to be worth it" as appropriate)

1 is certainly false, 3 is probably true, 2 is controversial.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:57AM (#37291122)
Yeah, I know, but they quoted that one so I used it.

The paper is basically proving 3 can't always be true for actors with unlimited computational power, and without any "approximately" or "by enough to be worth it". It's a cute math trick, not something useful.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:56PM (#37303022)
You hit the nail on the head, thank you. I probably should have qualified my use of the word "efficient" with "highly" or even "incredibly" to make this more obvious.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:24PM (#37312609)
The paper doesn't prove you can't be highly efficient in real markets. It proves you can't be perfect.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by aleph_minus_one on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:26AM (#37293592)
> Only if P=NP.[1]

The statement of P vs NP is different from what most non-mathematicians and non-computer-scientists think:

- It is possible that P=NP, but the the asymptotically fastest algorithm is provable, say, O(n^(2^64)).

- It is possible that P≠NP, but there exists an algorithm of O(n^(log log log log log log log log n)) where the constant in O(...) is small.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by shw1n on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:40PM (#37284898)
I thought they did find negative effects?

I’m not necessarily for or against but didn’t the creation of dark pools lead to front-running and worse prices for customers?

Michael Lewis covered this beautifully in Flashboys

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:44PM (#37284939)
Can you explain how "dark pools lead to front-running and worse prices for customers"?

I would agree that the price discovery works best when liquidity is lit up on a single CLOB, but claims about HFT leading to front-running or worse prices for customers (I assume you mean retail investors?) need justification.

What do you mean when you say "front-running"? It has a fairly specific definition, but it is often used inaccurately in discussions around HFT.

If by front-running you mean "HFT firms accept instructions as agent and then deal as principle prior to executing their client's instructions so as to benefit from the price move their client's order may induce" then you would be using the term correctly, and the SEC would be very interested, but this isn't what HFT firms do.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:26PM (#37285320)
That's my (naive) understanding of front-running. But I'm not familiar with the argument that HFT facilitates it.

The best argument is that HFT serves no legitimate purpose, and is just a pointless arms race. Money should flow to better trades, not faster ones.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:38PM (#37285419)
Usually when people claim that HFT strategies “front-run” then are talking about aggressor/taker strategies that are trying to shave off every nanosecond of latency to increase the chance of a fill at the best possible price.

Because these strategies are actively racing other participants for a fill, some people (inaccurately) call this “front-running”, presumably because they are “running in front” of other participants, but this isn’t what is usually meant by front-running.

As another commented has pointed out, front-running (in the sense I described it in my previous comment) is explicitly prohibited by regulation in the US, so to misuse the term in this way is to accuse someone of acting illegally without actually understanding what the terms mean.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#37285017)
Just my own tangent but I found that Flashboys was a little too sensational and the book Darkpools did a much better job at going over what led up to some of the issues in the market. Not that you made this point but I found Darkpools to give a view that it is a lot more nuanced.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by gruez on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:06PM (#37285168)
Since we're playing "just asking questions"

>I’m not necessarily for or against but didn’t the creation of dark pools lead to front-running

How does creation of dark pools lead to front running? Isn't that explicitly banned by the SEC?

>and worse prices for customers?

How so? Regulation NMS forces brokers to provide equal or better prices than the national best bid offer.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Redoubts on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:27PM (#37285816)
> Michael Lewis covered this beautifully in Flashboys

That was actually quite a bad book

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00P0QI2M2

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by stefan_ on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:03PM (#37284516)
The point is that whatever function you think HFT serves can be done just as well at fixed tick rates. This whole latency optimization mini game is just a pure waste.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Enginerrrd on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:37PM (#37284864)
I don't think this would really get rid of HFT. You'd still have price discovery and a fight to reduce latency happening on some HFT time scale before each tick.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:43PM (#37284933)
And that's fine. Most of that activity would be happening off-exchange, meaning less market noise, less price volatility, and less need to consume limited resources like radio spectrum and New York City real estate.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by super256 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:33PM (#37284835)
[delayed]
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:56PM (#37285076)
> Btw, a "tick" in trading is the minimum up/down movement of an asset (e.g. 0.25 points on NQ, or 0.01 on TSLA).

This is true, but the term is overloaded: if I say "the exchange slid the price one tick to comply with Reg. NMS" then I'm using it in the sense you mean; if I say "the model recomputes on each tick" then I'm using it in the sense of the GP.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by elictronic on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:58PM (#37285094)
Randomize the queue.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:26PM (#37285321)
That'll make everything more expensive, as every trade now has to price in the risk that it won't actually happen.

Increasing market friction is not a good idea.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:55PM (#37285560)
Given that randomization need only apply to orders placed simultaneously at identical prices, I don't see how it would increase market frictions enough to significantly limit their utility in price discovery, long-term investing, and the raising of capital. Individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#37285634)
By simultaneously, I assume you mean "within one time interval". I suspect you'd be surprised how many orders at the same price can happen in a very very short time window.

As for price discovery, a lot of information can happen in one second. Quantizing just adds risk, which adds cost, which harms everyone.

> Individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals.

No, but they're benefitting significantly from the fact that the cost of trading is now minuscule compared to what it used to be.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:31PM (#37285854)
> Quantizing just adds risk, which adds cost, which harms everyone.

No, it adds risk at the scale of the quantum, adding cost for those trading at the scale of the quantum, harming a very small subset of traders who would normally benefit from trading at or below the scale of the quantum, like HFT firms and short-term market makers. Should such institutions cease to exist because the cost of trading at such scales becomes prohibitively expensive, I highly doubt that society will suffer.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:47PM (#37285978)
We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

The spread represents the amount of uncertainty and risk associated with a price. Every bip away from the midpoint your bid/ask sits is pure cost to the participant, and that's true for all participants.

Even if I only come to market once a year to splurge my bonus on GME, I'm worse off paying 20c over the midpoint than I am paying 1c.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:35AM (#37290159)
> We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

Would this really hold true linearly across trading frequencies?

As we get to shorter and shorter delays, the technological cost for participating in HFT will just keep going up (e.g. building your own microwave transmission towers et. al. sillyness), decreasing the amount of potential participants.

Won't this at some point start having the opposite effect - limiting participants in the market to those with enough cash to play? Wouldn't there be some theoretical level of trading delay that should be regulated in order to ensure optimal liquidity as well as market participation?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:18AM (#37290874)
> We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

Okay, can you please use this evidence to say how much the interval has to increase for spreads to increase by 1 cent?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:45PM (#37285469)
> And in which order would orders be executed when they come in and get queued?

That's easy! Come time to match and fill for orders placed at identical prices, there's no reason a random number generator couldn't do the trick. Trading second-by-second need not be reliably profitable in the extremely short term to ensure an orderly and efficient market. The whole point of a static tick rate is to disincentivize such myopic trading in the first place!

I agree, though, that the logical conclusion of all this would be to replace the trading session with a market auction. However, while I appreciate the superior allocative efficiency of a Vickrey-style sealed-bid second-price multi-unit double auction[1] as much as the next guy, I have more faith in iterative improvements coming to pass before revolutionary ones.

> Btw, a "tick" in trading is the minimum up/down movement of an asset (e.g. 0.25 points on NQ, or 0.01 on TSLA).

Right, I apologize if I confused anyone with overloaded terms, but I think it's appropriate to expect the average Hacker News reader to correctly parse "tick rate" in the context of telecommunications and networking rather than confuse it with the trading concept of "tick size."

[1] https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~softagents/papers/Emarket.pdf

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:51PM (#37285530)
> > And in which order would orders be executed when they come in and get queued?

> That's easy! Come time to match and fill for orders placed at identical prices, there's no reason a random number generator couldn't do the trick. Trading second-by-second need not be reliably profitable in the extremely short term to ensure an orderly and efficient market. The whole point of a static tick rate is to disincentivize such myopic trading in the first place!

Adding deliberate randomness to the market makes it neither more orderly nor more efficient.

And you're confusing "myopic" trading with market making. Buying now and selling 10 minutes from now brings together two other participants who want to trade but not at the same time. That seller may have needed to have accepted a worse price in order to execute when they needed to.

But if you just look at the market maker, they briefly held onto something they didn't need for 10 minutes. What's the point!

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:18PM (#37285756)
Repeating my reply from elsewhere in the thread, individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals. Few even make tradable decisions at intraday intervals. Given that randomization need only apply to orders placed simultaneously at identical prices, I don't see how it would increase market frictions enough to significantly limit the utility of markets in price discovery, long-term investing, and the raising of capital.

Submit a limit order at a price you find fair and wait your turn or just take whatever's available on the other side of the order book. Markets have long functioned productively and efficiently on slower, human-speed timescales without the need for day traders or intrahour market makers.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:29AM (#37290118)
The alternative is we take this current mini-game to its conclusion and find some limit in physics and/or materials science that causes delays between markets to hit a floor. Then we're doing the same thing, applying a minimum tick rate to trading, except to achieve this tick rate you have to spend X to get the technology.

For these sort of things were you know there will be an end with a minimum achievable delay, it just makes way more sense to arbitrarily decide it's X and call it a day and let humanity use its resources on better things, than let this waste of resources continue.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by consilient on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:55AM (#37291106)
> Then we're doing the same thing, applying a minimum tick rate to trading, except to achieve this tick rate you have to spend X to get the technology.

Not quite, because the next step is being physically closer to the exchange, and there's only so much real estate to go around.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by wbl on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:16AM (#37294358)
The broker dealers were robbing their customers blind. 12 cent spreads, high trade fees, rooms full of people using hand signs that in case of a dispute couldn't be reviewed. Decimalization was great.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:05PM (#37285638)
You are intentionally exaggerating. He didn't say to add "deliberate randomness" and he didn't say "10 minutes."

A one microsecond or one millisecond time window would serve all legitimate trading purposes.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:13PM (#37285702)
> You are intentionally exaggerating. He didn't say to add "deliberate randomness" and he didn't say "10 minutes."

Sorry, does a "random number generator" mean some other type of randomness? And what's true for 10 minutes is also true for one second.

> A one microsecond or one millisecond time window would serve all legitimate trading purposes.

The fact that you're throwing around quantizations that are three orders of magnitude different and just saying "this'll do" makes me think you don't actually understand how trading works.

Which then? A millisecond? Why not a microsecond? If a microsecond is fine, why not a nanosecond?

Why are you so keen to put arbitrary restrictions on when people can buy/sell things from each other?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:44PM (#37285952)
"deliberate randomness" to me means prices or share counts change randomly. I think many or most people would see it that way.

> makes me think you don't actually understand how trading works

whoo-hoo! Getting snooty there, aren't you? I think I understand it as well as you do.

> Why are you so keen to put arbitrary restrictions on when people can buy/sell things from each other?

that's called "market regulation." That's what the SEC's mission is. It's intended to convince unsophisticated investors that they're not being cheated by slick operators.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:14PM (#37286238)
> whoo-hoo! Getting snooty there, aren't you? I think I understand it as well as you do.

shrug

You're proposing fundamental changes to the way that markets operate, which would have profound (and mostly negative) effects on the economy, but being entirely casual about the pretty important details across multiple orders of magnitude (a millisecond here, a microsecond there, what's the difference?).

I'm not sure you do understand it.

> that's called "market regulation." That's what the SEC's mission is. It's intended to convince unsophisticated investors that they're not being cheated by slick operators.

Sure, but you have not in any way made any case about how quantizing the market stops unsophisticated investors from "being cheated by slick operators.". What does "slick" mean? What does "cheating" mean? If I buy a computer and colo it with my local exchange to get better latency, is that being "slick"? How about if I hire an army of PhDs to do extensive market analysis, am I "cheating" the unsophisticated investor then?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:36PM (#37287736)
> I'm not sure you do understand it.

shrug. you do you. If not agreeing with you is "not understanding," then you're right. I think you're the one who doesn't understand the US securities market.

Nitpicking the precise meaning of every word is a good working definition of "slick."

We're done here.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:27PM (#37288977)
Kind of disappointing to see HN devolve into this. You have brigaded this thread. You continue to throw around unsupported statements, your solutions are naive and when people try to call you out it you just talk down to people and then say you’re done.

Surely you must realize that regulating the markets is not as simplistic as you make it out to be. There are certainly always improvements to be had but they have to be carefully thought out because every rule and truly cause new imbalances.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:33AM (#37290147)
> Kind of disappointing to see HN devolve into this.

Agree, but to both sides of the above discussion. The other guys literally just says "you don't understand". And I have to say, I don't understand either. If there's someone here who actually understands HFT and has done it, it would be nice to hear your thoughts on the matter.

What do YOU think would happen if we placed and arbitrary minimum tick rate at say 1 second? 1 microsecond? 1 nanoescond? 1 femtosecond?

Why would the US securitieis market collapse? Would it collapse? Why do we need extreme liquidity at the nanosecond level? Where can I get a loan for a nanosecond?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:49AM (#37291433)
The reason why I think statements like "hey, lets just quantize the market" is that it ignores all the other stuff that you now need to decide. It's half a solution.

As mentioned elsewhere, lets say you quantize. How do you decide which of two orders that arrive within the same interval at the same volume and price gets filled? Unless your proposal to quantize the market also acknowledges that there's now significant, basic questions to be answered about how a matching engine would even work, then it's not a serious proposal. It betrays the fact that the proposer hasn't fully thought through the impact of what they're suggesting.

But, to answer your question: Quantizing the market will aggregate and dilute market information into the size of your interval. The enforced delay between your order and execution will fundamentally add some uncertainty and risk into every trade, which will increase spreads and the cost of trading. This will obviously happen less at smaller intervals, but I find it hard to see any offsetting benefit whatsoever.

What'll actually happen is that no-one will place orders until just before the interval boundary, so you either have an open order book (and still have an arms race so that you can see the book, process it and submit an order before the deadline), or you have a closed book, in which case you're now running a dark pool. (People tried dark pools, and discovered liquidity fell through the floor, and the thing that market customers really want to be able to do is trade. So they invited a bunch of HFTs to come along and participate in the dark pools, and everyone's now wondering what the point was).

Finally, unless you form a World Government, you'll discover that different markets will end up operating on different quantizing intervals and rules, which will lead to enormous structural arbitrage opportunities across different venues.

> Why would the US securitieis market collapse? Would it collapse?

Of course not. We used to have high latencies and high costs in the olden days. I think it was worse then.

> Why do we need extreme liquidity at the nanosecond level

Because I want to come to market and buy right now based on the available information in the universe right now. I don't want the risk that something will change in the next 500ms (or whatever) factored into my price.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:14AM (#37290836)
> fundamental changes to the way that markets operate

The way they operate right now. There used to be plenty of seconds of delay.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:02PM (#37285617)
Someone else here said "random" for choosing which of two or more identical trades to execute. As it is now, it's "first one to arrive, measured in nanosecond time."

I think the SEC decreeing "random" for trades within some time window (is the window of millisecond size? microsecond size? not sure) would be totally legit, and it would redirect financial resources to better trades, not faster ones.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Ekaros on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:21PM (#37286292)
Disallowing fill or kill could solve this. So any sell order is split between buy orders matching.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by tmn on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:07PM (#37285173)
It’s my naive understanding that HFT makes money at the direct expense of other market participants. Is this not a downside? I’m genuinely curious to the arguments against this.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:24PM (#37285304)
They're providing service at a cost.

Like many service providers, to a lot of people the service provided is worth more than the cost.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by civilitty on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:46PM (#37285487)
> Like many service providers, to a lot of people the service provided is worth more than the cost.

Does the average trader whose orders these HFT firms fill actually have a choice in the matter?

Certainly big institutions do with desk trading, but to my knowledge the vast majority of us do not have any choice in who fills an order or whether to wait a little longer not to participate in market making.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:55PM (#37285559)
Sure, you can trade OTC. Just phone your friends / neighbours and ask if they want to buy your stuff. Maybe put an ad in the local paper.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by civilitty on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:02PM (#37285615)
Then HFT firms aren't service providers that I have the option of associating with, I'm actually forced to use them in order to participate in the public stock exchange.

Nice stock you have there, it'd be a shame if ya couldn't sell it...

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:06PM (#37285649)
What is "the public stock exchange"? They're all private entities with their own membership rules. You can buy/sell the same instrument at hundreds of different venues, no-one's forcing you to use any specific market.

Take your pick. Start your own.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:05AM (#37290789)
There are massive barriers and costs to selling stocks that way, and you know it.

This is like saying you have the free choice not to have a phone number or email address. Yeah, technically you do, but effectively you have to use the system. And for the most part you get that from private entities too.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Twisell on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:24AM (#37290503)
You are maybe confused because HFT refer to a very specific trading hack that is not available to general public.

What you refer to sound more like brokers that offer online trading services, it's "instantaneous" but not fast enough to enable the latency scam used in HFT.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:17AM (#37291963)
> HFT refer to a very specific trading hack

Maybe 10 years ago, but these days (outside of very specific markets) most of the big “HFT”s are really doing quantitative trades or market making.

> that is not available to general public

Collocating with a venue is expensive and clearing membership of an exchange has capital requirements, but it’s not some old-boys club; anyone with sufficient funds can take part.

It’s not available to the general public to exactly the same extent that exchange membership isn’t available to the general public.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:15AM (#37291949)
> but to my knowledge the vast majority of us do not have any choice in who fills an order

Why on earth do you care who fills your order?

If you place a GTC/Day limit order, it will fill at the price you deem fair, or better.

If you enter a transaction to deal a quantity of a security at the price you deem fair, what difference does the nature of the counterparty make?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by jdsully on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:19AM (#37294417)
The “or better” is doing a lot of the heavy lifting here. Your choice of counter party has a large impact on the price improvement.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:29PM (#37297586)
> The “or better” is doing a lot of the heavy lifting here.

I disagree, I think I could have skipped the "or better" without making a substantive change to my point.

Is your argument that the presence HFT participants (or really electronic market makers) leads to reduced price improvement for other participants?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by qeternity on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:22PM (#37285290)
You can’t state it’s at the expense without stating how.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Ekaros on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:17PM (#37286263)
They make money/"wealth". That must come from either the seller or buyer or both. Unless existence of HFT directly leads to higher appreciation of assets traded.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by qeternity on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:17AM (#37290861)
All trading is zero sum.

If I own shares in a company for 20 years, that means someone else who sold them to me doesn’t own those shares and doesn’t earn those returns.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by rcxdude on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:59AM (#37291490)
In the absence of a market maker (human or algorithmic), a much larger fraction of the value of a transaction is effectively randomly distributed between the buyer and seller. And it turns out buyers and sellers don't really like this much, and are happy to pay a small fraction of the transaction for a more predictable outcome.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by bobbylarrybobby on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37287844)
Even if you're right about the market, HFTs will make you a little less right for no reason other than that they've invested billions of dollars into being faster than you.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by lotsofpulp on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:59AM (#37289944)
And they will give you a little more liquidity.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by qeternity on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:18AM (#37290870)
What are you talking about?
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by rcxdude on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:48AM (#37291430)
HFT replaces massive floors of human traders doing basically the same job but at much lower cost. The competition between HFT firms for microseconds isn't particularly useful to anyone else but what they do (reduce the spread between buying and selling and the price difference between markets) is useful to most market participants not planning to extract money from the market in the same way HFT firms do.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by consilient on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:17AM (#37291959)
> HFT replaces massive floors of human traders doing basically the same job but at much lower cost.

HFT is just one form of algorithmic trading, they're not the same thing.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by BurningFrog on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:44PM (#37285454)
The clear negative effect is the many billions spent on shaving communication milli- and microseconds to win zero sum games.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:52PM (#37285536)
Bernie has a great proposal to tax these transactions, and fund some wonderful social programs with the money.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by PoignardAzur on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:48AM (#37291060)
> and fund some wonderful social programs with the money.

That's silly. The whole point is they're a zero-sum game with semiconductor-thin margins. Any meaningful taxation will make them evaporate.

That doesn't mean they shouldn't be taxed! But it would be a pigovian tax, the kind that serves as a soft interdiction and not as government income.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by epx on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:05PM (#37284539)
One day the market itself will reach this conclusion, that one auction-trade a day is all it's needed.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by DwnVoteHoneyPot on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:11PM (#37285194)
No. Trades happen because people disagree with the value of the company. One person thinks the value is higher, other thinks it's lower. They are arguing and they're willing to put money behind their opinion. Faster the argument, the faster the price discovery is.

An analogy would be operating Hacker News by publishing all the opinions once a day like a print newspaper. The back and forth arguments would take weeks... you post, some responds the next day, you respond the third day. Not good.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by rytis on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:00PM (#37285599)
> The back and forth arguments would take weeks... you post, some responds the next day, you respond the third day. Not good.

Is it really not good?.. Now just thinking about what you said reminded me good old FidoNET days. You’d get mail once a day (typically), read/respond and that’s it, done for the day, on to do some work. Procrastination problem solved :)

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Animats on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:13PM (#37285209)
Doesn't help. Then you have auction sniping, like eBay.

If the auction is sealed bid, then price discovery is terrible.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by xwdv on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:28PM (#37284782)
Sports don’t need to exist either.

For programmers obsessed with speed and never ending optimization to get the extra edge, HFT is the ultimate sport.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:40PM (#37284903)
I prefer sports with fewer negative externalities, and I certainly believe trading can continue to be fun with a slower tick rate. Heck, the additional skill required to succeed in a more efficient market should make the sport of trading even more fun!
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by qeternity on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:29PM (#37285348)
The additional skill is the speed. It’s just a skill you and I don’t possess. It’s like saying there should be a height limit and basketball and that should make it more fun for really tall players who now have an extra challenge. It just benefits shorter players, or slower in this case.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:57PM (#37286058)
No, it isn't. Extremely tall players have not dominated in basketball. Steph Curry is only 6' 4", while Manute Bol (7' 7") was successful but not a GOAT.

Secondly, basketball has all kinds of rules to even the competition, e.g. zone defenses, shot clocks, etc.

Baseball has umpires checking pitchers' hands for sticky substances. Rules are a part of fair competition.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by xwdv on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:35PM (#37286840)
Regardless, the point still stands. The sport is ruined if you put limits on how skilled players are allowed to be.

HFT is only for the best and fastest of programmers backed by the best resources. Elites.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#37287721)
No, it doesn't. Cheating is not skill.

Anymore than having Spider Tack on your hand is "skill" for a baseball pitcher.

http://www.spidertack.com/

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by qeternity on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:15AM (#37290842)
6’4 is extremely tall. That’s my point.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:06PM (#37315895)
Your point is what -- being average height among basketball players is good, somehow?
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @12:34AM (#37303603)
The NBA bans the use of steroids. One could argue that this regulation benefits only those unable or unwilling to risk their health for the sake of competition, or one could argue that focusing on traditional athleticism, whether through practice or genetics, makes for a more fun and entertaining game while facilitating the overall welfare of participants.

Unlike basketball, the stock market happens to be a game with extraordinarily significant consequences, not just for players but for society at large, and it just so happens that society has a lot more to gain from a stock market where traders spend less time competing on speed of execution and more time competing on quality of information. Similarly, there exist many valuable alternative use cases for the real estate, electromagnetic spectrum, and other fixed-supply resources consumed by HFT that would likely contribute more to overall human welfare.

No matter how you spin it, better rules make for a better game.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by ImJamal on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:43PM (#37284928)
>High-frequency trading doesn't need to exist

Technically speaking no job needs to exist. I'm not sure why that matters though? Just because it would be better for society doesn't mean the job shouldn't exist. I'm sure there is a job where you could be more productive as well.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:29PM (#37285346)
The SEC regulates financial markets, and that's key to investors' trust in them. A job in financial markets is not the same as a job in, say, sports.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:43PM (#37303336)
Ironically, I'm currently interviewing for a job at a high-frequency trading firm! I happen to be one of those altruistic weirdos who donates a substantial fraction of their wealth to effective charities, and it turns out that there are few gigs outside of HFT that will facilitate my ability to "earn to give" to the same extent. I genuinely believe that HFT presents a variety of fun and interesting problems and challenges, and I look forward to it! Still, that doesn't mean that I can't have fun and make bank elsewhere.

I repeat: high-frequency trading doesn't need to exist.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:16PM (#37285232)
Who are you to say people should not focus on what they want?

Like all things in life there are more shades of gray than just black and white. You think it is as easy as setting a law. Your law would not only have unknown consequences. It would also most likely have negative consequences as the market would quickly adapt.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:22PM (#37285288)
Like it or not, the SEC regulates the financial markets. That is a primary reason why people trust them with their money. "Who are you to say people should not focus on what they want?" is fairly dumb. This isn't like stamp collecting.

The SEC can quite legitimately rule that:

1) Traders competing to make better trades: serves a purpose.

2) Traders competing to make the same trades, but a microsecond faster: serves no purpose at all.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:41PM (#37285440)
If two traders want to buy 100 widgets at the same price, but there are only 100 for sale at that price, whose trade should 'win' that competition? Which is the 'better' trade?
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:55PM (#37285561)
> Which is the 'better' trade?

You just said they were the same.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:59PM (#37285597)
> 2) Traders competing to make the same trades, but a microsecond faster: serves no purpose at all.

So if time of quote has zero value, then how should the market decide which two orders at same volume and price gets executed?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:33PM (#37285869)
Just randomly pick it. /s

I find these threads are the opposite of Bitcoin threads. It brings out the wild opinions about financial markets.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:52PM (#37286031)
Good point.

"Time" in a computer is not a real number in the mathematical sense. It's quantized. So simply set the quantum unit appropriately and call all trades within that unit "the same time."

Then the choice is between N identical trades that come in at the same time. Random seems as good a method as any.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:11PM (#37288859)
That would be a naive solution. This is why I have stated there is no easy solution to these problems. Randomizing it would lead to actors gaming it. How would you randomize it? Random why order? Then I will just place more orders maybe. Random across actors? Then maybe I add more actors to the pool. Instead of stroking your ego talking about time, I hope you realize that the solutions to fair market participation can be challenging and it’s not as easy to just make a blanket statement.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:18PM (#37285757)
Sorry not going to stoop at your level of calling your comment dumb but next time you should try to elevate yourself.

You are making blanket statements without any substance. I was simply pointing out that it is silly to make blanket statements that people should not be focusing their efforts on financial markets. It is a complex benefit and problem and it demonstrates the lack of education by saying timing is not an important aspect of price discovery. I agree there are probably negative aspects but I think it’s a complicated problem to unravel.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:47PM (#37285982)
"dumb" is making junior-high level statements like "Who are you to say people should not focus on what they want?"

That doesn't deserve any more of an "elevated" answer.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:44PM (#37286906)
Ahh more insults and no evidence. Well done. I don’t know who hurt you or how I said anything to cause such a reaction but please relax.

All I am saying is it’s a lot more complex then just saying it’s bad and serves no purpose. I think there is probably a middle ground too but I would not even know how to get there. IEX still serves very little volume so I would say the market is not concerned about the current setup. Would love to know why you think it’s so bad.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by freshpots on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:42PM (#37287342)
That's their MO. Insults, and playing the victim, with very little contribution to the conversation at hand beyond those two things.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37287753)
"people should not focus on what they want" is so adolescent that it doesn't require any further dismissal.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:14PM (#37288879)
My whole point is it’s naive for anyone to just say something is a waste of time and we should just do x to solve it. Who are we to make such baseless statements without critical and constructive arguments. I am sorry instead of having dialog that you have went down this nasty path of name calling but I hope you relax and back off a little.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by lost_tourist on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:32AM (#37290143)
I agree and it gives an unfair advantage to those who have a lot more money and resources to game the system. A 1 second tick seems plenty fast enough as someone else suggested.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by OnlineGladiator on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:25PM (#37285313)
> It would also most likely have negative consequences as the market would quickly adapt.

What would be the negative consequences from a more equal playing field?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:31PM (#37285857)
I don’t know and I suspect most people in this thread do not know.

A little more specifically, I find that when governments create knee jerk legislation there are always loop holes and new routes around it. Sure not always but it happens.

I am also trying to say I don’t know the full degree of benefits and disadvantages of markets today. What I can see is over the past 40 decades, spreads have tightened, and liquidity has increased. I am sure there are negatives that come from the current setup with market makers but from the retail side I dont feel the pain. What unequal playing field do you feel? Are HFT harming you?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by RecycledEle on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:26PM (#37285328)
Before I checked HN today, I was thinking: There are 2 kinds of people in the world today.

The first class is constantly rent seeking. They want to be in charge and want something for nothing. They do not care if the person they are contracting with looses on the deal, in fact they prefer it that way. This class is mostly MBAs and welfare recipients. High frequency traders fall into this category.

The second class is people who want to work and only ask for a fair deal. They strive to increase the size of the pie for everyone.

Our situation today is very similar to Germany's Weimar republic, where an elite class that knew how to manipulate the workers could take advantage of a predictable economic collapse and predictable hyper-inflation to gain power.

I hope our correction does not follow the NAZI German example.

We could go that way. Many of the working class realize that if someone plays negative-sum-games at work, society is better off putting them in a labor cap and teaching them to do manual labor.

I suggest that US federal law should require that workers compensation be linked to how much they increase the well-being of the human race. Leave a loophole that says you are exempt if you work for yourself. The rent seekers will be so busy squabbling over pennies and clauses in contracts that they will have little time left to screw the rest of us.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by shreyshnaccount on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:39PM (#37285428)
I don't really fully agree with this but that's not the point. What worries me is that even if you are right, the first class makes the rules and wouldn't lead the transition into the system you describe
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:54PM (#37285553)
Correct. Read Animal House for a fairly accurate portrayal of what happens.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by NoZebra120vClip on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:03AM (#37289612)
Yeah, fraternity members have drunken toga parties. Shivers

I wasn't aware it was novelized, though. Only saw the film.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:04PM (#37296261)
I’m a moron. Should have been Animal Farm
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by aziaziazi on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:49AM (#37291065)
Are you talking about “animal farm - a fair story” (loves the subtitle) by George Orwell ? A great read indeed, brings both brain food and entertainment.

Mostly became a vegan anarchist after reading it. It directly criticize revolutions and totalitarianism but the parallel with any regimes is logical. The roots of injustice is in power and control, which happens in any regime even the most democratic and liberal ones.

Not saying we should abandon laws and governments, but let’s not defend them in the sake of justice and fairness.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:04PM (#37296253)
Hahahaha. Yup I was. My brain is broken from lack of sleep.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by dist-epoch on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:45PM (#37285468)
That was quick, going from HFT to NAZI in a few sentences.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:50PM (#37285526)
This is a pretty novel application of horseshoe theory, where somehow MBAs and the poorest among us are in the same bucket?

Stalin would be proud. Send them all to the salt mines.

Hahaha. Pretty awesome to read this on HN, the juxtaposition is quite funny.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MrOwen on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:30PM (#37285848)
I didn't get "poorest" out of gp's mention of welfare recipients. I took it to mean corporations who rely on government subsidies to make a profit, a good example being the huge percentage of Walmart workers on gov food assistance. I think you also get tax breaks for hiring people on welfare programs so it's almost like double dipping welfare on Walmart's end.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by RecycledEle on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:48PM (#37287397)
By "welfare recipients," I mean poor people on welfare who could work if they had a better attitude.

I mean the kind of people that were offended when I offered them each a cheap flashlight during a power outage. (We were all standing outside.) One of them said he would take what he wanted. He demanded the very best flashlights that money could buy. I declined, and I guess he thought I was tougher than him, so he eventually left after some more posturing. I never got his name.

I mean the kind of people who fake injury claims and collect disability for the rest of their lives, under 8 different identities. Their names were Tony and Theon.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toofy on Monday August 28, 2023 @08:12AM (#37292850)
do you also see, as the parent brought up with “… huge percentage of Walmart workers on gov food assistance.” and i’ll stick with walmart here for the sake of continuity, the other well know instance where walmart has a significant drain on local police departments. target brand stores, in the same neighborhoods don’t have this problem. target stores have significantly more people employed, which leads to a significant reduction in theft—would be thieves see an employee organizing, cleaning, stocking, etc… in just about every direction they look which discourages them from stealing. walmart just externalizes the cost onto the local police departments allowing walmart to bring in more profits.

do you consider what the parent pointed out, intentionally hiring below poverty wages, and the externalizing basic business costs onto local, often small town, police to be “welfare leeching?”

what about the companies who go out of their way to hire armies of accountants and lawyers to play games in order not to pay taxes?

what about the companies who engage in wage theft? there has been a number of reputable studies which show that wage theft may absolutely dwarf other forms of theft such as shoplifting.

if you consider these things leeching, then i think your point probably stands. but if one of those groups is not a leech, yet the other is, i don’t think your point stands at all.

if you do consider the instances i brought up to be leeches, which do you think “leeches” more? companies across the board who go out of their way to avoid taxes, wage theft, and externalizing costs? or poor people on welfare?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by pjc50 on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:55AM (#37296085)
> One of them said he would take what he wanted. He demanded the very best flashlights that money could buy

This is such a bizarre encounter that it's hard to take it as representative of anything other than one weirdo.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by RecycledEle on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:42PM (#37287343)
I group those who do not contribute to society into the group that does not contribute to society.

This group ranges from Congress to homeless drug addicts.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by MarkMarine on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:55AM (#37290291)
Welcome to the revolution brother. Read about the Bolshevik Revolution, the theory and literature behind it, the thoughts and goals of the people behind it and I swear you’ll find kinship.

Personally, when I see someone who needs help, be it neighbor with a flat tire or a homeless person asking for a couple bucks as I walk by, I try to provide it. I often talk to people with some Venn Diagram intersection with your world view (as I know it thus far) and usually they’d literally give the wheel off their car to help the first subject in that hypothetical, and sometimes even go out of their way to give a sandwich to the second… but when it comes to policy they are so much more cruel. That’s my word for it, others call it pragmatic, or the free market.

I’m not saying that because I think I am one of the group who contributes, or one of the better, or what have you. Honestly, the sum total of my life has been going to war as a combatant, working for a defense contractor making missiles, working for a couple startups and large companies that you could sun up as selling advertising in novel ways, selling makeup, and getting people to pay slightly less for college if it’s online. Recently I’ve made a couple of new people that I hope to raise to be better contributors than I. But that’s it, I have no illusions that I’m some saint.

So, long preamble, but my point is that many of us don’t contribute to society, and don’t contribute in far more pernicious ways than a homeless drug addict. In comparison with a homeless drug addict my contribution to society has probably been markedly more detrimental, considering I used automation to deploy it on a mass scale.

In closing, look in the mirror, and unless you’ve been curing cancer, maybe cut the drug addict a break.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by foooorsyth on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:58PM (#37285592)
>I suggest that US federal law should require that workers compensation be linked to how much they increase the well-being of the human race

Ah yes, I can’t wait for our future Bureau of Labor Assessment that will magically and accurately measure every profession’s impact on human well-being, and then also magically enforce some kind of earnings grab from the baddies. Sounds like a great plan!

You realize you can’t hand wave this stuff, right? Doesn’t work.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by RecycledEle on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:41PM (#37287333)
You have an excellent point.

There needs to be some kind of fix for the amount of energy wasted on zero-sum and negative-sum games.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by WeylandYutani on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:37AM (#37292108)
Right now it knows that teachers and nurses aren't sociopaths and it uses their empathy against them. The cliché about teachers buying school supplies with their own money is sadly true. And when COVID hit healthcare workers didn't strike for higher pay.

Capitalism was never a values system and it doesn't reward nice guys.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:07PM (#37285655)
I'm amused by the idea that HFT people are rent seekers, but I think they're more like plaintiff lawyers: gaming the system, rather than lobbying to change it (although they probably are doing that, too).
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by euroderf on Monday August 28, 2023 @05:00AM (#37291496)
It's a mafia of skimmers.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by kashunstva on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:47AM (#37291421)
> US federal law should require that workers compensation be linked to how much they increase the well-being of the human race.

Define “well-being” in a way that would satisfy the putative crowds of proletarians clamouring to send the unproductive to labour camps. I’m a musician who makes nothing tangible; would your requirement send me to the Gulag, or is art still a positive contribution to society?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by malcolmgreaves on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:55AM (#37294014)
Almost a great take, but how can you logically you lump poor people into this mix? How is a poor person a rent seeker?
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by pjc50 on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:53AM (#37296073)
> Germany's Weimar republic, where an elite class that knew how to manipulate the workers could take advantage of a predictable economic collapse and predictable hyper-inflation to gain power.

Not sure it was "predictable" or "an elite class"; the Nazi party were to a great extent outsider-populists, and they won the middle class by pitching themselves as the less drastic change than the Bolsheviks. Certain markers of the old elite got banned under Nazism. "Mensur" fencing. Especially insanely: banning the old German font https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraktur

The hyper-inflation was merely an incredibly stupid response to a forex crisis caused by the reparations. The country was legally obliged to hand over gold marks; it attempted to print Reichsmarks in unlimited quantities to buy goldmarks, which of course caused a forex collapse.

There is, of course, no US forex crisis or inflation crisis, just a rather nasty transient bump caused by the war disrupting global natural gas prices. The US is doing rather well. It's Europe where we need to watch out for far-right parties who think they can solve the problems with mass murder (usually of refugees).

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by theyknowitsxmas on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:47PM (#37298730)
Not true. The most effective thing against first class is not working a job or paying taxes, hilariously geared towards SKILL and these doctor/MBA hacks with all their education, state and media control can't stop it. The universe enjoys hilarious irony.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by anigbrowl on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:44PM (#37301341)
There's actually 4-5 if you believe the first paper in my bio, which I do. i think you'll get a lot out of it.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Gibbon1 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:00PM (#37285600)
Just charge a 0.1% excise tax on trades.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @12:49AM (#37303667)
Trading in and of itself isn't the problem. Far from it, in fact, given how much well-regulated markets contribute to the overall well-being of society. The problem is the race to the bottom unique to high-frequency trading which squanders otherwise productive human capital and consumes fixed-supply resources like real estate and electromagnetic spectrum. This also happens to be a case where a direct rule change can be implemented cheaply enough to provide more benefit at less cost than even an indirect tax, especially considering the overwhelming evidence that taxes on transactions of any sort are far from Pigouvian in nature.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by SkipperCat on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:27PM (#37285818)
I work in HFT. A lot of the folk we've hired came from places like Twitter, Facebook and other social media tech firms. Its not hard to make the argument that social media is just as toxic or even worse.

On the other hand, due to advancements in trading tech, I've seen commissions drop to zero. I've see better price discovery available to professional and retail traders and there has been a lot of people introduced to stock markets because it was accessible via their phone.

This is not a perfect world. HFT and Fintech are not godly, but its not without merit.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by bboygravity on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:30AM (#37290547)
Better price discovery? You've got to be joking. There is no price discovery.

Source: GME in Januari 2021 when the buy button was turned off for household investors only, while the rest of the market (shorts) where allowed to keep trading. That and the fact that the stock moved the way it did with the trade volume it had tells me all I need to know about price discovery: there is none.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:54AM (#37290712)
> Its not hard to make the argument that social media is just as toxic or even worse.

That's a very low bar.

> better price discovery

I expect that price discovery would be perfectly fine with a 1 second or 1 minute tick.

Trading tech isn't going to regress. Low commissions are about automation more than anything else.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by SkipperCat on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:34PM (#37302899)
Even if there were 1 second ticks, there would be a race every second (or minute) to get in queue for specific trades. And therefore the speed race would continue as it is now. It would just happen on the edge of every second instead of continuously.

As long as you have markets, you are going to have market makers and takers trying to get edge. It happens on Wall Street and also every other market place you can think of. I agree that there is rent seeking in this setup, but the overall value of free and open markets greatly overshadows that cost.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:46PM (#37302973)
This is trivially solved by randomizing the queue for identically priced simultaneous orders.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by SkipperCat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:29AM (#37306736)
What happens when you have 10 bids against 2 asks? 8 orders are not going to get filled even though they were the first to transact. Some would call that not fair.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by consilient on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:43AM (#37291027)
> On the other hand, due to advancements in trading tech, I've seen commissions drop to zero. I've see better price discovery available to professional and retail traders and there has been a lot of people introduced to stock markets because it was accessible via their phone.

Ok, but how much of that is due to HFT specifically? Or more relevantly to the article, ultra-low latency HFT? A bit of the price discovery, maybe, but retail commissions hit zero because Schwab decided to finish turning into a bank and their competitors had no choice but to follow.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by pseudocomposer on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:36AM (#37292106)
> On the other hand, due to advancements in trading tech, I've seen commissions drop to zero. I've see better price discovery available to professional and retail traders and there has been a lot of people introduced to stock markets because it was accessible via their phone.

Enabling more people to move to the rent-seeking class is not really a net benefit to humanity. I would argue it’s quite the opposite.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by hakfoo on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:31AM (#37293666)
It seems like price discovery and liquidity are seen as undeniable good, but I've always been skeptical.

Price discovery tends to be awkward for some institutions, because we're not great at pricing future value and resiliency. I've always blamed the "price discovery" mentality for the breakdown of the conglomerate model in the US markets-- people don't want a GE or a Honeywell (or a Samsung), they want to buy the one unit that makes money TODAY, neglecting that the other units may be providing buffering for different economic conditions, or allow the bankroll of moonshot R&D that won't fit nicely on a single quarter's balance sheet. So now we've driven GE's stock price to near zero (note: this is why I should not have taken stock advice from my Mom) and finally split the company into a bunch of shards that can be independently price-discovered.

Infinite liquidity seems to create a market with a significant amount of noise, and I'm not sure the noise has value here. The practical price may be $5, but you'll end up with a million back and forth trades chasing when it hits $4.99 or $5.01. The long term consensus got the price to $5, but HFT/infinite liquidity adds the noise. Maybe they got it to $5 faster, but I'm not sure even there. These are not actually investing in the business as a business, expecting the shares to go to $1 or $10, they're investing in it as a horserace, a psuedo-random event that lasts a couple of minutes they can handicap and hopefully pull a return from reliability. Dothey make meaningful contributions to corporate governance, when they hold the shares for less time than it would take to load the proxy voting website?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by jdsully on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:14AM (#37294333)
The problem with conglomerates is they tend to be inefficient over the long term. They use winning businesses to subsidize losing legacy businesses that management has an attachment too. This eliminates the pressure they would normally have to fix the underperforming business and investors lose some of the benefit of the well performing business that is siphoned off.

Even tech isn’t immune to this, Amazon would be way more valuable if it split into separate retail and cloud businesses.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by hakfoo on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:28PM (#37299240)
You trade flexibility for that promise of efficiency.

Since AWS prints money, Amazon-Retail could afford to experiment with stuff. For example, I'd argue that Prime Video hit the market a few years ahead of viability, when we were still in the "I have Netflix and it has All The Things" era of the market. Now they've got a ready-to-go platform and content while other players scramble.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by ifdefdebug on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:57PM (#37286056)
What does that even mean? If you halt the match engine for one second, you can expect 100000 order placement requests to queue up until that second is over. And then what? If you process the whole queue and then rest another second etc., then you change the HF game only a little, the fight is now about your spot in the queue.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by jimmydef on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:12PM (#37289280)
i guess they can randomize the queue order so no one gets aan advantage by being in the queue first.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:39AM (#37290182)
There are still issues to solve. With a randomized queue order of matching trade pairs, in order for you to maximize the probability of your trade succeeding you could flood the market with buy or sell orders with price x and amount y.

Though I guess you could group orders by price & amount, which would negate some of this. Per trade fees could also help mitigate it.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Monday August 28, 2023 @07:14AM (#37292336)
I work in HFT, so feel free to dismiss what I say as biased...

There is this widespread perception that HFT traders are rent seekers, and bad for markets, and in particular for retail traders. Anyone well informed knows this is completely wrong:

  - HFT is not rent seeking, it is providing a valuable service (liquidity provision) that people are willing to pay for. Over the years, there are been multiple attempts to set up trading venues that exclude HFT traders and they all end up inviting them in because without them there's no liquidity and very little trading.

  - There are multiple studies that show that regulatory interventions aimed at reducing HFT, such as financial transaction taxes, increase volatility and spreads and raise effective trading costs for retail traders.

It is still possible that changing market structure or regulation to reduce the incentives for HFT (and in particular the speed race aspect of it) could be somehow beneficial for markets or society as a whole, but this is far from obvious.

As for having regulation steer what "brilliant minds" go into, you have to have a lot of faith in the foresight of regulators to argue for that. Could say a lot of similar things about different industries, such as the usual quip about the best minds of our generation working on maximizing ad click through rates.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Monday August 28, 2023 @07:30AM (#37292462)
You said

* HTF provide liquidity.

* HTF beeing invited into markets formerly excluding them.

* Regulation attempts on HFT hit retail traiders too.

* You disagree, that HTF is rent seeking?

Imho, all those statements are weak. Providing liquidity in markets is essential but markets worked long before HFT was a thing.

FTH is just another way of going "meta" (for VC?) simply beeing faster. Until they are the market. The big question, as you too said is.

> It is still possible that changing market structure or regulation [...] could be somehow beneficial for markets or society as a whole, but this is far from obvious.

To me, it is rent seeking. What would you reply to the scenario ofa strong FTH monopoly, which the tech sector is in hot pursuit of.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:42AM (#37294804)
> You said > * HTF provide liquidity. > * HTF beeing invited into markets formerly excluding them. > * Regulation attempts on HFT hit retail traiders too. > * You disagree, that HTF is rent seeking?

> Imho, all those statements are weak.

> Providing liquidity in markets is essential but markets worked long before HFT was a thing.

Correct, but the previous incarnation of liquid providers (mostly humans on stock exchange floors) was far more expensive and less efficient than HFT. This is why HFT was able to compete on price of liquidity provision (i.e., the spreads came down) and win.

These legacy firms did lose out from HFT (and are actually behind some of the anti HFT rhetoric out there) but I assume people in HFT see technological disruption as a good thing, even if bad for some incumbents.

The idea that retail traders or institutional investors are the ones that lost out from HFT lacks any evidence, AFAIK.

> FTH is just another way of going "meta" (for VC?) simply beeing faster. Until they are the market.

Your wording is a bit unclear, but if you are hinting that HFTs are operating at a loss until they capture sufficient market share, this is demonstrably false. HFTs make a lot of money (you can look up Virtu's financial statements for proof since it is a public company).

> The big question, as you too said is.

> > It is still possible that changing market structure or regulation [...] could be somehow beneficial for markets or society as a whole, but this is far from obvious.

> To me, it is rent seeking.

It would be if it was true. I admit it's a theoretical possibility, but I am yet to see a convincing argument of it.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:25AM (#37303823)
> It would be [rent seeking] if it was true. I admit it's a theoretical possibility, but I am yet to see a convincing argument of it.

As i see it, you already provided all aspects to label HFT as such. Except one: the physical foundation of running such a business.

They provide faster and more cost efficient liquidity, thus "bringing down the spread" which will push out maybe not all but certainly the lesser privileged conventional traders. This is foremost negative for the effected traders and not per se for the public but as the pessimist that i am, i cannot help it but see it as just another way of market consolidation, of monopolization in the worst case.

The only way to seriously compete with such HFTs, is to do it as they do, which requires the same physical accesses to the markets. Previously, the access to valuable (insider) information was a privilege for slow traders and a way to get an edge. Speed and algorithms are imo just a new privilege, enabled by technology.

The simple reason why insider trading is illegal, because it puts other marketeers at a disadvantage, they have no means to compensate. The same is true for HFT. You cannot rent the rack next to the markets machines when its already occupied.

What would you reply to such a statement: HFT is just front running but from the client side.

But to be fair, i have to see convincing evidence for my pessimistic worst cases too.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:11PM (#37311685)
> They provide faster and more cost efficient liquidity, thus "bringing down the spread" which will push out maybe not all but certainly the lesser privileged conventional traders. This is foremost negative for the effected traders and not per se for the public but as the pessimist that i am, i cannot help it but see it as just another way of market consolidation, of monopolization in the worst case.

They are only "pushing out" other liquidity providers. If you are a medium/long term investor you are not competing with HFTs. Yes, if you want to be day trader HFTs might make your life harder, but I think from society's point of view that's fine.

> The only way to seriously compete with such HFTs, is to do it as they do, which requires the same physical accesses to the markets. Previously, the access to valuable (insider) information was a privilege for slow traders and a way to get an edge. Speed and algorithms are imo just a new privilege, enabled by technology.

> The simple reason why insider trading is illegal, because it puts other marketeers at a disadvantage, they have no means to compensate. The same is true for HFT. You cannot rent the rack next to the markets machines when its already occupied.

There is no principle that all market participants must been on equal footing. That would be impossible to enforce, and counterproductive to boot. If you are a slow (non HFT) trader at a big fund or bank you also have a lot of advantages over a guy doing it from home: better financing rates, more market access, a whole infrastructure to provide you with information and analysis, etc. Should that be made illegal as well?

What about if you are just a better trader? Should you be somehow given a handicap so others can compete with you?

As I said in another reply, in every field of human activity, professionals are advantaged over hobbyists, and that's fine.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:03AM (#37320182)
> What about if you are just a better trader?

If it was _only_ human ability / trade craft, that makes good traders (hft or conventional), imo those traders would have earned their cut. Honoring such a market making service and economic foresight with profits is reasonable for the public.

Unfortunately, the difference between a good trader and a successfull one is not ability alone but privilege! Be it insider information or better latency, its the same thing here!

> There is no principle that all market participants must been on equal footing.

This statement is objectively false, when you take "equal footing" as "equal access".

> in every field of human activity, professionals are advantaged over hobbyists, and that's fine.

The gap between professionals and hobbyists is the same between professionals and customers, its the main reason of trustee obligations / market regulations. So something about this issue is not fine.

My point is, privileged market access leads to growing power asymmetries, which a newcomer can never compensate with genius abilities alone. This kind of market capture is similar to institutionalized corruption btw.

Once a vital service provider gets too dominant or the power gap gets too wide, regulators must step in. See health care (medical complexity), legal systems (cost of equal representation) or basically all infrastructure (obligation of contracting).

...

I replied to your stronghold statements, didnt i?

Now, is HFT just a client side approach of front running? Which is an insider privilege and illegal.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontrunning

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:31PM (#37328589)
> Unfortunately, the difference between a good trader and a successfull one is not ability alone but privilege! Be it insider information or better latency, its the same thing here!

> The gap between professionals and hobbyists is the same between professionals and customers, its the main reason of trustee obligations / market regulations. So something about this issue is not fine.

> My point is, privileged market access leads to growing power asymmetries, which a newcomer can never compensate with genius abilities alone. This kind of market capture is similar to institutionalized corruption btw.

And my point is that you are holding trading to a different standard. Is it a problem that Apple has so many resources that a hobbyist has no chance of competing with at making smartphones? Or Google and search engines, Chipotle and burritos, etc?

Of course not. Those companies have earned their market shares by investing in the right places, innovating, good strategy, etc. Same is true for HFT firms.

There would be a problem if either Apple or Citadel had a monopoly or was breaking the law. If there's proof that's the case, we have courts and regulators to step in.

> I replied to your stronghold statements, didnt i?

> Now, is HFT just a client side approach of front running? Which is an insider privilege and illegal.

According to the legal definition, front running is when you have orders you are executing for clients and you trade ahead of them on your own account. HFTs do not have client orders, ergo they cannot possibly front run anything.

If you use some expanded definition of front running, then it depends on the details of the definition. For some sufficiently broad definitions, probably yes. But then it's of course not illegal and possibly not even bad.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:08PM (#37329161)
> But then it's of course not illegal and possibly not even bad.

Unless regulations apply or no monopoly emerges.

I guess i dont trust institutions or companie as you do.

To end it on a different upside. To some degre, your company and eg amazon are realizing cybernetic socialism . With enough trust, we could regulatorily capture the whole thing ;)

I agreed to your point.

> "pushing out" other liquidity providers. [… is fine ] from society's point of view.

Thank you for the conversation.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:24PM (#37329350)
> Thank you for the conversation.

Likewise. It's disappointingly rare to be able to have a civil discussion with someone you have very different opinions from.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by anigbrowl on Monday August 28, 2023 @06:37PM (#37301281)
HFT is not rent seeking, it is providing a valuable service (liquidity provision)

Skkkkkritttttt

'Liquidity provision' is just 'fast cash for your distressed equities'. Yes, if prices are trending in an unfavorable direction investors/speculators would suffer a greater loss in a market without HFT as orders took minutes rather than seconds to clear. But you are indirectly collecting economic rents by trading so fast that retail investors can't connect with each other, they always end up connecting with the HFT. So in that sense you are collecting rent on the expensive high speed trading infrastructure by getting to the front of every queue. A brilliant/knowledgeable retail trader is unable to monetize their comparative advantage because they can't compete with the HFT operator on execution speeds.

The whole thing is built on FOMO, and creates the illusion of value by endlessly accelerating transaction speeds. This is like arguing that people who drive way above the speed limit are creating value by arriving at their destination sooner (leaving more road space available) and encouraging others to drive fast (making the road transport system more efficient). Accidents that occur int he vicinity of speeding drivers' trajectory can be blamed on inferior driving standards.

regulatory interventions aimed at reducing HFT [...] increase volatility and spreads and raise effective trading costs for retail traders

Good. Volatility is opportunity for the smart and risk-tolerant, and trading costs are a good proxy for risk. This is how financial markets are supposed to work, offering the opportunity of a good payday for clever traders and discouraging the mediocre with excessively low or high risk tolerance before they can drag or blow up too much. Trading is meant to be a human activity that serves human needs. The more it is automated and accelerated, the more it tends toward monopolistic concentration of capital in corporate entities and increases overall fragility of the system.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:01PM (#37311555)
> 'Liquidity provision' is just 'fast cash for your distressed equities'. Yes, if prices are trending in an unfavorable direction investors/speculators would suffer a greater loss in a market without HFT as orders took minutes rather than seconds to clear.

Liquidity provision is more than that. Without market makers/liquidity providers prices fluctuate a lot more because the balance of natural buyers/sellers varies over time. Liquidity provision is a shock absorber to those imbalances.

> But you are indirectly collecting economic rents by trading so fast that retail investors can't connect with each other, they always end up connecting with the HFT.

You are right that retail traders trade against HFTs most of the time. This is actually true for institutional investors as well, simply because HFTs provide almost all of the liquidity in stock market. I.e., it's not because HFT as are reacting to incoming orders faster (it is impossible to react to a marketable order before it trades by design), but because HFTs are the ones posting at the bid or ask.

For retail traders there's the extra step that most (all?) retail brokers have agreements with HFTs where they send them their retail orders before they hit the markets. The HFTs can opt to trade against the retail trader but only if they give them a better price than they could have gotten at the exchanges.

There is some unfounded misperception that this practice must be nefarious, based on the idea that the HFTs can only be doing this if they are pulling one over the retail traders. This is wrong, the reason HFTs like to trade against retail is that it is unlikely that a retail order is part of a large multi-million share meta-order that is going to push the price against the liquidity provider. This means that they can give retail traders lower spreads and still make money, both parties win. The party who loses in this are the institutional traders - since HFTs manage to segregate part of the retail flow, they end up using higher spreads for the rest of the flow.

> So in that sense you are collecting rent on the expensive high speed trading infrastructure by getting to the front of every queue.

This is stretching the definition of rent. If I own a well-run restaurant, am I collecting rent on expensive food preparation infrastructure that lets me prepare good food at a lower cost that my competitors?

> A brilliant/knowledgeable retail trader is unable to monetize their comparative advantage because they can't compete with the HFT operator on execution speeds.

They also have a hard time competing against traders working at big banks or hedge funds even if they don't use HFT infrastructure. In every field of human activity, professionals have big advantages over hobbyists, and that's fine.

Also note that if you are a retail trader buying stocks with a long/medium term outlook HFT is good for you (lower trading costs!). If you want to be day trader, HFT might make your life harder, but it's not clear to me that's a bad thing.

> The whole thing is built on FOMO, and creates the illusion of value by endlessly accelerating transaction speeds.

Transaction speeds are not endlessly accelerated. There's a misapprehension that HFTs are trading in and out of positions in a millisecond time scale. That's absurd, you'd never make money that way. They care about their latency down to the microsecond or hundreds of nano-seconds because that lets them cancel orders quickly when it looks like the market is going to move against them and avoid adverse selection, the bane of the liquidity provider.

> This is like arguing that people who drive way above the speed limit are creating value by arriving at their destination sooner (leaving more road space available) and encouraging others to drive fast (making the road transport system more efficient). Accidents that occur int he vicinity of speeding drivers' trajectory can be blamed on inferior driving standards.

For the faster drivers, there is clear downside: the increased accidents. For HFT, what is that?

> [...] The more it is automated and accelerated, the more it tends toward monopolistic concentration of capital in corporate entities and increases overall fragility of the system.

HFT firms require very little capital compared to things like big banks or large hedge funds. I don't have the numbers but I am sure their combined capital is tiny fraction of the rest of players in financial markets.

They don't hold large books ever, so if they go under, there is no fire sale that drives asset prices down and cause a crisis. They don't present a big systemic risk.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by wbl on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:09AM (#37294240)
The tick rate doesn't remove the impact of faster communication as you can remove a bad price faster.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by jaybny on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:27PM (#37302451)
Sidepit.com soon
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by jaybny on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:41PM (#37302525)
here is the solution. funding public goods is the problem. building this now

https://drive.google.com/file/d/13edfo0uhuG5JAaP6i2VTOJho1lP...