News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by stefan_ on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:03PM (#37284516)
The point is that whatever function you think HFT serves can be done just as well at fixed tick rates. This whole latency optimization mini game is just a pure waste.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Enginerrrd on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:37PM (#37284864)
I don't think this would really get rid of HFT. You'd still have price discovery and a fight to reduce latency happening on some HFT time scale before each tick.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:43PM (#37284933)
And that's fine. Most of that activity would be happening off-exchange, meaning less market noise, less price volatility, and less need to consume limited resources like radio spectrum and New York City real estate.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by super256 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:33PM (#37284835)
[delayed]
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by denotational on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:56PM (#37285076)
> Btw, a "tick" in trading is the minimum up/down movement of an asset (e.g. 0.25 points on NQ, or 0.01 on TSLA).

This is true, but the term is overloaded: if I say "the exchange slid the price one tick to comply with Reg. NMS" then I'm using it in the sense you mean; if I say "the model recomputes on each tick" then I'm using it in the sense of the GP.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by elictronic on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:58PM (#37285094)
Randomize the queue.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:26PM (#37285321)
That'll make everything more expensive, as every trade now has to price in the risk that it won't actually happen.

Increasing market friction is not a good idea.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:55PM (#37285560)
Given that randomization need only apply to orders placed simultaneously at identical prices, I don't see how it would increase market frictions enough to significantly limit their utility in price discovery, long-term investing, and the raising of capital. Individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#37285634)
By simultaneously, I assume you mean "within one time interval". I suspect you'd be surprised how many orders at the same price can happen in a very very short time window.

As for price discovery, a lot of information can happen in one second. Quantizing just adds risk, which adds cost, which harms everyone.

> Individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals.

No, but they're benefitting significantly from the fact that the cost of trading is now minuscule compared to what it used to be.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:31PM (#37285854)
> Quantizing just adds risk, which adds cost, which harms everyone.

No, it adds risk at the scale of the quantum, adding cost for those trading at the scale of the quantum, harming a very small subset of traders who would normally benefit from trading at or below the scale of the quantum, like HFT firms and short-term market makers. Should such institutions cease to exist because the cost of trading at such scales becomes prohibitively expensive, I highly doubt that society will suffer.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:47PM (#37285978)
We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

The spread represents the amount of uncertainty and risk associated with a price. Every bip away from the midpoint your bid/ask sits is pure cost to the participant, and that's true for all participants.

Even if I only come to market once a year to splurge my bonus on GME, I'm worse off paying 20c over the midpoint than I am paying 1c.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:35AM (#37290159)
> We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

Would this really hold true linearly across trading frequencies?

As we get to shorter and shorter delays, the technological cost for participating in HFT will just keep going up (e.g. building your own microwave transmission towers et. al. sillyness), decreasing the amount of potential participants.

Won't this at some point start having the opposite effect - limiting participants in the market to those with enough cash to play? Wouldn't there be some theoretical level of trading delay that should be regulated in order to ensure optimal liquidity as well as market participation?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:18AM (#37290874)
> We already have evidence from history (where trading latencies and intervals were much higher) that the spreads become much higher as trading frequency goes down.

Okay, can you please use this evidence to say how much the interval has to increase for spreads to increase by 1 cent?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:45PM (#37285469)
> And in which order would orders be executed when they come in and get queued?

That's easy! Come time to match and fill for orders placed at identical prices, there's no reason a random number generator couldn't do the trick. Trading second-by-second need not be reliably profitable in the extremely short term to ensure an orderly and efficient market. The whole point of a static tick rate is to disincentivize such myopic trading in the first place!

I agree, though, that the logical conclusion of all this would be to replace the trading session with a market auction. However, while I appreciate the superior allocative efficiency of a Vickrey-style sealed-bid second-price multi-unit double auction[1] as much as the next guy, I have more faith in iterative improvements coming to pass before revolutionary ones.

> Btw, a "tick" in trading is the minimum up/down movement of an asset (e.g. 0.25 points on NQ, or 0.01 on TSLA).

Right, I apologize if I confused anyone with overloaded terms, but I think it's appropriate to expect the average Hacker News reader to correctly parse "tick rate" in the context of telecommunications and networking rather than confuse it with the trading concept of "tick size."

[1] https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~softagents/papers/Emarket.pdf

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:51PM (#37285530)
> > And in which order would orders be executed when they come in and get queued?

> That's easy! Come time to match and fill for orders placed at identical prices, there's no reason a random number generator couldn't do the trick. Trading second-by-second need not be reliably profitable in the extremely short term to ensure an orderly and efficient market. The whole point of a static tick rate is to disincentivize such myopic trading in the first place!

Adding deliberate randomness to the market makes it neither more orderly nor more efficient.

And you're confusing "myopic" trading with market making. Buying now and selling 10 minutes from now brings together two other participants who want to trade but not at the same time. That seller may have needed to have accepted a worse price in order to execute when they needed to.

But if you just look at the market maker, they briefly held onto something they didn't need for 10 minutes. What's the point!

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by cosmojg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:18PM (#37285756)
Repeating my reply from elsewhere in the thread, individuals and corporations aren't making tradable decisions at subsecond intervals. Few even make tradable decisions at intraday intervals. Given that randomization need only apply to orders placed simultaneously at identical prices, I don't see how it would increase market frictions enough to significantly limit the utility of markets in price discovery, long-term investing, and the raising of capital.

Submit a limit order at a price you find fair and wait your turn or just take whatever's available on the other side of the order book. Markets have long functioned productively and efficiently on slower, human-speed timescales without the need for day traders or intrahour market makers.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:29AM (#37290118)
The alternative is we take this current mini-game to its conclusion and find some limit in physics and/or materials science that causes delays between markets to hit a floor. Then we're doing the same thing, applying a minimum tick rate to trading, except to achieve this tick rate you have to spend X to get the technology.

For these sort of things were you know there will be an end with a minimum achievable delay, it just makes way more sense to arbitrarily decide it's X and call it a day and let humanity use its resources on better things, than let this waste of resources continue.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by consilient on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:55AM (#37291106)
> Then we're doing the same thing, applying a minimum tick rate to trading, except to achieve this tick rate you have to spend X to get the technology.

Not quite, because the next step is being physically closer to the exchange, and there's only so much real estate to go around.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by wbl on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:16AM (#37294358)
The broker dealers were robbing their customers blind. 12 cent spreads, high trade fees, rooms full of people using hand signs that in case of a dispute couldn't be reviewed. Decimalization was great.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:05PM (#37285638)
You are intentionally exaggerating. He didn't say to add "deliberate randomness" and he didn't say "10 minutes."

A one microsecond or one millisecond time window would serve all legitimate trading purposes.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:13PM (#37285702)
> You are intentionally exaggerating. He didn't say to add "deliberate randomness" and he didn't say "10 minutes."

Sorry, does a "random number generator" mean some other type of randomness? And what's true for 10 minutes is also true for one second.

> A one microsecond or one millisecond time window would serve all legitimate trading purposes.

The fact that you're throwing around quantizations that are three orders of magnitude different and just saying "this'll do" makes me think you don't actually understand how trading works.

Which then? A millisecond? Why not a microsecond? If a microsecond is fine, why not a nanosecond?

Why are you so keen to put arbitrary restrictions on when people can buy/sell things from each other?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:44PM (#37285952)
"deliberate randomness" to me means prices or share counts change randomly. I think many or most people would see it that way.

> makes me think you don't actually understand how trading works

whoo-hoo! Getting snooty there, aren't you? I think I understand it as well as you do.

> Why are you so keen to put arbitrary restrictions on when people can buy/sell things from each other?

that's called "market regulation." That's what the SEC's mission is. It's intended to convince unsophisticated investors that they're not being cheated by slick operators.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:14PM (#37286238)
> whoo-hoo! Getting snooty there, aren't you? I think I understand it as well as you do.

shrug

You're proposing fundamental changes to the way that markets operate, which would have profound (and mostly negative) effects on the economy, but being entirely casual about the pretty important details across multiple orders of magnitude (a millisecond here, a microsecond there, what's the difference?).

I'm not sure you do understand it.

> that's called "market regulation." That's what the SEC's mission is. It's intended to convince unsophisticated investors that they're not being cheated by slick operators.

Sure, but you have not in any way made any case about how quantizing the market stops unsophisticated investors from "being cheated by slick operators.". What does "slick" mean? What does "cheating" mean? If I buy a computer and colo it with my local exchange to get better latency, is that being "slick"? How about if I hire an army of PhDs to do extensive market analysis, am I "cheating" the unsophisticated investor then?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:36PM (#37287736)
> I'm not sure you do understand it.

shrug. you do you. If not agreeing with you is "not understanding," then you're right. I think you're the one who doesn't understand the US securities market.

Nitpicking the precise meaning of every word is a good working definition of "slick."

We're done here.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by infecto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:27PM (#37288977)
Kind of disappointing to see HN devolve into this. You have brigaded this thread. You continue to throw around unsupported statements, your solutions are naive and when people try to call you out it you just talk down to people and then say you’re done.

Surely you must realize that regulating the markets is not as simplistic as you make it out to be. There are certainly always improvements to be had but they have to be carefully thought out because every rule and truly cause new imbalances.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Maxion on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:33AM (#37290147)
> Kind of disappointing to see HN devolve into this.

Agree, but to both sides of the above discussion. The other guys literally just says "you don't understand". And I have to say, I don't understand either. If there's someone here who actually understands HFT and has done it, it would be nice to hear your thoughts on the matter.

What do YOU think would happen if we placed and arbitrary minimum tick rate at say 1 second? 1 microsecond? 1 nanoescond? 1 femtosecond?

Why would the US securitieis market collapse? Would it collapse? Why do we need extreme liquidity at the nanosecond level? Where can I get a loan for a nanosecond?

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by growse on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:49AM (#37291433)
The reason why I think statements like "hey, lets just quantize the market" is that it ignores all the other stuff that you now need to decide. It's half a solution.

As mentioned elsewhere, lets say you quantize. How do you decide which of two orders that arrive within the same interval at the same volume and price gets filled? Unless your proposal to quantize the market also acknowledges that there's now significant, basic questions to be answered about how a matching engine would even work, then it's not a serious proposal. It betrays the fact that the proposer hasn't fully thought through the impact of what they're suggesting.

But, to answer your question: Quantizing the market will aggregate and dilute market information into the size of your interval. The enforced delay between your order and execution will fundamentally add some uncertainty and risk into every trade, which will increase spreads and the cost of trading. This will obviously happen less at smaller intervals, but I find it hard to see any offsetting benefit whatsoever.

What'll actually happen is that no-one will place orders until just before the interval boundary, so you either have an open order book (and still have an arms race so that you can see the book, process it and submit an order before the deadline), or you have a closed book, in which case you're now running a dark pool. (People tried dark pools, and discovered liquidity fell through the floor, and the thing that market customers really want to be able to do is trade. So they invited a bunch of HFTs to come along and participate in the dark pools, and everyone's now wondering what the point was).

Finally, unless you form a World Government, you'll discover that different markets will end up operating on different quantizing intervals and rules, which will lead to enormous structural arbitrage opportunities across different venues.

> Why would the US securitieis market collapse? Would it collapse?

Of course not. We used to have high latencies and high costs in the olden days. I think it was worse then.

> Why do we need extreme liquidity at the nanosecond level

Because I want to come to market and buy right now based on the available information in the universe right now. I don't want the risk that something will change in the next 500ms (or whatever) factored into my price.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:14AM (#37290836)
> fundamental changes to the way that markets operate

The way they operate right now. There used to be plenty of seconds of delay.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by AlbertCory on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:02PM (#37285617)
Someone else here said "random" for choosing which of two or more identical trades to execute. As it is now, it's "first one to arrive, measured in nanosecond time."

I think the SEC decreeing "random" for trades within some time window (is the window of millisecond size? microsecond size? not sure) would be totally legit, and it would redirect financial resources to better trades, not faster ones.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by Ekaros on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:21PM (#37286292)
Disallowing fill or kill could solve this. So any sell order is split between buy orders matching.