News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:42AM (#37294804)
> You said > * HTF provide liquidity. > * HTF beeing invited into markets formerly excluding them. > * Regulation attempts on HFT hit retail traiders too. > * You disagree, that HTF is rent seeking?

> Imho, all those statements are weak.

> Providing liquidity in markets is essential but markets worked long before HFT was a thing.

Correct, but the previous incarnation of liquid providers (mostly humans on stock exchange floors) was far more expensive and less efficient than HFT. This is why HFT was able to compete on price of liquidity provision (i.e., the spreads came down) and win.

These legacy firms did lose out from HFT (and are actually behind some of the anti HFT rhetoric out there) but I assume people in HFT see technological disruption as a good thing, even if bad for some incumbents.

The idea that retail traders or institutional investors are the ones that lost out from HFT lacks any evidence, AFAIK.

> FTH is just another way of going "meta" (for VC?) simply beeing faster. Until they are the market.

Your wording is a bit unclear, but if you are hinting that HFTs are operating at a loss until they capture sufficient market share, this is demonstrably false. HFTs make a lot of money (you can look up Virtu's financial statements for proof since it is a public company).

> The big question, as you too said is.

> > It is still possible that changing market structure or regulation [...] could be somehow beneficial for markets or society as a whole, but this is far from obvious.

> To me, it is rent seeking.

It would be if it was true. I admit it's a theoretical possibility, but I am yet to see a convincing argument of it.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @01:25AM (#37303823)
> It would be [rent seeking] if it was true. I admit it's a theoretical possibility, but I am yet to see a convincing argument of it.

As i see it, you already provided all aspects to label HFT as such. Except one: the physical foundation of running such a business.

They provide faster and more cost efficient liquidity, thus "bringing down the spread" which will push out maybe not all but certainly the lesser privileged conventional traders. This is foremost negative for the effected traders and not per se for the public but as the pessimist that i am, i cannot help it but see it as just another way of market consolidation, of monopolization in the worst case.

The only way to seriously compete with such HFTs, is to do it as they do, which requires the same physical accesses to the markets. Previously, the access to valuable (insider) information was a privilege for slow traders and a way to get an edge. Speed and algorithms are imo just a new privilege, enabled by technology.

The simple reason why insider trading is illegal, because it puts other marketeers at a disadvantage, they have no means to compensate. The same is true for HFT. You cannot rent the rack next to the markets machines when its already occupied.

What would you reply to such a statement: HFT is just front running but from the client side.

But to be fair, i have to see convincing evidence for my pessimistic worst cases too.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:11PM (#37311685)
> They provide faster and more cost efficient liquidity, thus "bringing down the spread" which will push out maybe not all but certainly the lesser privileged conventional traders. This is foremost negative for the effected traders and not per se for the public but as the pessimist that i am, i cannot help it but see it as just another way of market consolidation, of monopolization in the worst case.

They are only "pushing out" other liquidity providers. If you are a medium/long term investor you are not competing with HFTs. Yes, if you want to be day trader HFTs might make your life harder, but I think from society's point of view that's fine.

> The only way to seriously compete with such HFTs, is to do it as they do, which requires the same physical accesses to the markets. Previously, the access to valuable (insider) information was a privilege for slow traders and a way to get an edge. Speed and algorithms are imo just a new privilege, enabled by technology.

> The simple reason why insider trading is illegal, because it puts other marketeers at a disadvantage, they have no means to compensate. The same is true for HFT. You cannot rent the rack next to the markets machines when its already occupied.

There is no principle that all market participants must been on equal footing. That would be impossible to enforce, and counterproductive to boot. If you are a slow (non HFT) trader at a big fund or bank you also have a lot of advantages over a guy doing it from home: better financing rates, more market access, a whole infrastructure to provide you with information and analysis, etc. Should that be made illegal as well?

What about if you are just a better trader? Should you be somehow given a handicap so others can compete with you?

As I said in another reply, in every field of human activity, professionals are advantaged over hobbyists, and that's fine.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:03AM (#37320182)
> What about if you are just a better trader?

If it was _only_ human ability / trade craft, that makes good traders (hft or conventional), imo those traders would have earned their cut. Honoring such a market making service and economic foresight with profits is reasonable for the public.

Unfortunately, the difference between a good trader and a successfull one is not ability alone but privilege! Be it insider information or better latency, its the same thing here!

> There is no principle that all market participants must been on equal footing.

This statement is objectively false, when you take "equal footing" as "equal access".

> in every field of human activity, professionals are advantaged over hobbyists, and that's fine.

The gap between professionals and hobbyists is the same between professionals and customers, its the main reason of trustee obligations / market regulations. So something about this issue is not fine.

My point is, privileged market access leads to growing power asymmetries, which a newcomer can never compensate with genius abilities alone. This kind of market capture is similar to institutionalized corruption btw.

Once a vital service provider gets too dominant or the power gap gets too wide, regulators must step in. See health care (medical complexity), legal systems (cost of equal representation) or basically all infrastructure (obligation of contracting).

...

I replied to your stronghold statements, didnt i?

Now, is HFT just a client side approach of front running? Which is an insider privilege and illegal.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontrunning

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:31PM (#37328589)
> Unfortunately, the difference between a good trader and a successfull one is not ability alone but privilege! Be it insider information or better latency, its the same thing here!

> The gap between professionals and hobbyists is the same between professionals and customers, its the main reason of trustee obligations / market regulations. So something about this issue is not fine.

> My point is, privileged market access leads to growing power asymmetries, which a newcomer can never compensate with genius abilities alone. This kind of market capture is similar to institutionalized corruption btw.

And my point is that you are holding trading to a different standard. Is it a problem that Apple has so many resources that a hobbyist has no chance of competing with at making smartphones? Or Google and search engines, Chipotle and burritos, etc?

Of course not. Those companies have earned their market shares by investing in the right places, innovating, good strategy, etc. Same is true for HFT firms.

There would be a problem if either Apple or Citadel had a monopoly or was breaking the law. If there's proof that's the case, we have courts and regulators to step in.

> I replied to your stronghold statements, didnt i?

> Now, is HFT just a client side approach of front running? Which is an insider privilege and illegal.

According to the legal definition, front running is when you have orders you are executing for clients and you trade ahead of them on your own account. HFTs do not have client orders, ergo they cannot possibly front run anything.

If you use some expanded definition of front running, then it depends on the details of the definition. For some sufficiently broad definitions, probably yes. But then it's of course not illegal and possibly not even bad.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by throwawayqqq11 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:08PM (#37329161)
> But then it's of course not illegal and possibly not even bad.

Unless regulations apply or no monopoly emerges.

I guess i dont trust institutions or companie as you do.

To end it on a different upside. To some degre, your company and eg amazon are realizing cybernetic socialism . With enough trust, we could regulatorily capture the whole thing ;)

I agreed to your point.

> "pushing out" other liquidity providers. [… is fine ] from society's point of view.

Thank you for the conversation.

Re:Ham radio enthusiasts vs. High-frequency traders: A battl... by toth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:24PM (#37329350)
> Thank you for the conversation.

Likewise. It's disappointingly rare to be able to have a civil discussion with someone you have very different opinions from.