And then you merely link a proof that the efficiency is not 100%. That's effectively meaningless.
- You can't beat the market
- You can't beat the market without insider information
- You can't beat the market using only information about historical prices.
(Insert "approximately" and "by enough to be worth it" as appropriate)
1 is certainly false, 3 is probably true, 2 is controversial.
The paper is basically proving 3 can't always be true for actors with unlimited computational power, and without any "approximately" or "by enough to be worth it". It's a cute math trick, not something useful.
The statement of P vs NP is different from what most non-mathematicians and non-computer-scientists think:
- It is possible that P=NP, but the the asymptotically fastest algorithm is provable, say, O(n^(2^64)).
- It is possible that P≠NP, but there exists an algorithm of O(n^(log log log log log log log log n)) where the constant in O(...) is small.
Only if P=NP.[1]
Besides
This also begs the question: "To efficiently allocate capital (energy) for what goal (work)?"And it doesn't look like the answer to that is "the betterment of humanity", but to push the bell curve of wealth as far to the left as possible with the longest tail possible, externalities be damned.
The stock market isn't a usefull tool for society like kickstarter, but a wealth extraction mechanism for the wealthiest.
So I'd argue that HFT isn't any more immoral than T.
1: https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284