You just said they were the same.
So if time of quote has zero value, then how should the market decide which two orders at same volume and price gets executed?
I find these threads are the opposite of Bitcoin threads. It brings out the wild opinions about financial markets.
"Time" in a computer is not a real number in the mathematical sense. It's quantized. So simply set the quantum unit appropriately and call all trades within that unit "the same time."
Then the choice is between N identical trades that come in at the same time. Random seems as good a method as any.
You are making blanket statements without any substance. I was simply pointing out that it is silly to make blanket statements that people should not be focusing their efforts on financial markets. It is a complex benefit and problem and it demonstrates the lack of education by saying timing is not an important aspect of price discovery. I agree there are probably negative aspects but I think it’s a complicated problem to unravel.
That doesn't deserve any more of an "elevated" answer.
All I am saying is it’s a lot more complex then just saying it’s bad and serves no purpose. I think there is probably a middle ground too but I would not even know how to get there. IEX still serves very little volume so I would say the market is not concerned about the current setup. Would love to know why you think it’s so bad.
The SEC can quite legitimately rule that:
1) Traders competing to make better trades: serves a purpose.
2) Traders competing to make the same trades, but a microsecond faster: serves no purpose at all.