News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:28AM (#37279661)
> So basically they're just idiots.

Because they’re asking for more access to public transit, reconsidering the US car culture, and improving quality of life in the city in general? Less cars means less pollution, less noise, less traffic, better health, more livable districts… How is that idiotic?

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by imgabe on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:30AM (#37279678)
And driverless cars, if they are allowed to be developed, will eventually be public transit that takes you from door-to-door running 24/7, way, way better than any train or bus.

But idiots just need something to be against.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:41AM (#37279724)
How?

They also point out that these automated cars, if they end up actually working right, make zero effort to be handicap accessible, unlike existing and currently working public transit (which also happens to be delayed and hampered by these same semi functional, automated cars)

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by imgabe on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:47AM (#37279757)
You'd have a fleet of driverless cars driving around the city and summon one with an app. With no drivers they would only need to stop to recharge/refuel and for maintenance.

If you can automate a car, you can automate a handicap accessible van. Just because they haven't yet doesn't mean they wouldn't.

Public transit is great, but it means you have to go to a specific stop and wait there, and then go from wherever you get dropped off to your final destination, which is probably not the bus stop / train station. That's not very handicap-accessible, since it often means navigating escalators / elevators that end up being broken half the time.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:53AM (#37279785)
These cars would be privately owned and follow the whims of shareholders. We all know how well that goes.

These issues with public transit are correctable. Stops could be added in between, infrastructure made more accessible… Handicap accessibility is a mandate for public transit. For a private car fleet, it’s an afterthought and token gesture.

Also, the public transit network is already there and works. Why not invest in that instead while also encouraging active Mobility by walking or cycling instead of more cars?

I still fail to see how what they’re demanding is idiotic. You might not agree with it, or it might make you uncomfortable about your transportation choices, but it’s the opposite of idiotic.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by imgabe on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:30AM (#37279962)
What is stopping the city from buying and operating driverless cars? Their money is just as good and I'm sure the companies selling the cars would be happy to sell to them. Oh, the only thing stopping them are "activists" who demand inferior solutions to transit.

The public transit network is "there" in some places, and kind of works. If you happen to live near a stop and your schedule allows you enough time to wait for a bus / train to arrive, then sure. If you don't live in one of those places then you're SOL. Good luck waiting for the city to add a new train line. It took NYC over 100 years to build the second avenue line...

Meanwhile the infrastructure for cars is there, and actually does work and goes from point-to-point from almost every single residence / place of business in the entire country.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by abenga on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:22AM (#37280223)
> What's stopping the city from buying and operating driverless cars?

Cost and inefficiency? The city should invest in and expand access to efficient public transit, not spend money on expensive multi-ton vehicles that can move one fare at a time. The solution to "some people live far from bus stops" should first be "local government adds more bus stops", not "local government spends billions on small cars."

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lotsoweiners on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:23PM (#37284130)
There is no way that a city could have enough bus stops and routes to service most sprawling American cities. This is especially true when you consider that a sizable portion of the population wouldn’t be caught dead on a bus. Building more routes and stops might work in dense cities but is not a one size fits all solution.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:44PM (#37284331)
> a sizable portion of the population wouldn’t be caught dead on a bus.

Yep that’s another part of the problem. Easy answer is for official to through their hands up and make way for more individual cars rather than addressing the root problem and do the hard work of making public transit attractive.

I’m in Switzerland at the moment for example, a large chunk of people don’t own cars, you can go by train and bus everywhere (literally, I can go across the country on one ticket, go to ski by train, or to the top of mountains by train and mountain trains), and the bus isn’t the social stigma it is in the US.

There is no reason why the Us can’t get their act together and do the same thing other than lack of will to do so. Instead, you have multilevel 12 lanes freeway monstrosities and insane traffic.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lsaferite on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:01PM (#37285612)
Spoken like someone that lives in a high-density area. Switzerland is 223 per Km2 while the US is 37 per Km2. In the EU, only Finland, Sweden, Latvia, and Estonia have a lower population density. There average across the EU is 109.56 per Km2. GB is 280 per Km2.

Solutions to transportation in the US need to factor in the density and account for the low-density areas as well. Politically, those low-density regions are, IME, the ones most likely to fight against changes that would move towards mass-transit because they feel like they are being ignored.

Beyond that, SDVs and Mass-transit aren't at opposition. Busses can and should be SDVs as well. As mentioned by another poster, small handicap-accessible SDVs that do point-to-point transport are _better_ than mass-transit. If vehicular mass is a concern, with ubiquitous SDV integration into an urban transit system you can and should design purpose-built transporters with lower mass. With central EV charging and remote power generation you are already moving the pollution point to a smaller number of locations that are easier to optimize and monitor.

Really, these people seem to be saying "We don't like this, so you shouldn't be allowed to do it" and then they use flimsy excuses as justification. That makes them just like all the other people that want to force their world-view on me. Maybe instead of doing that they could spend all of that energy on moving the needle on the core issues that are possible in the short term and will make a difference, like moving to green renewables for power generation.

Sorry if this seems overly cranky, but it's frustrating to see people that think interfering with SDV operation is a 'good thing' in any way, shape, or form.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by developer93 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:57AM (#37280414)
So you argument is that because it's currently being dine badly it can't be done?
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by imgabe on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:03AM (#37280808)
It could be done well. It would require some people with a better plan than "let's put cones on driverless cars hurr durr durr".

That doesn't seem forthcoming, though.

There's also no reason you can't have both. Private companies testing driverless cars are not preventing the city from building other public transit.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:46PM (#37284351)
> they’re not helping

They’re getting a discussion around these issues started at the very least, like in this thread. Aside from their methods and whether a particular individual agrees with them or not, it doesn’t do nothing at all. Awareness and discussion is a necessary step.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by badpun on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:04AM (#37280463)
> These cars would be privately owned and follow the whims of shareholders. We all know how well that goes.

The state can easily legislate that fleets of self-driving cars needs to have x% of their cars be wheelchair-accessible, just as it has legislated that the newly built buildings (public or private) need to be wheelchair accessible.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:47PM (#37284360)
The state could also mandate more public transit and more stops. Yet here we are.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lsaferite on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#37285632)
If it were simply "add more stops" or "add more trains/busses", then it would have been done a long time ago. The calculus there is much more complex and you are hand-waving away those issues.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lotsoweiners on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:14PM (#37284048)
> Also, the public transit network is already there and works. Why not invest in that instead while also encouraging active Mobility by walking or cycling instead of more cars?

I have no idea where the nearest bus stop to my house is but I’m guessing it is over a half mile away. According to my Apple Watch it is supposed to be 110 degrees outside today. Does that help clarify why people might want door to door service if they were getting a ride whether public transportation or taxi?

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ornornor on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:40PM (#37284294)
It’s hard to overlook the irony. It is so warm partly because we’ve been pushing polluting convenience over a little extra effort with less pollution. You should be agitating your government to make public transit an attractive alternative (because walking half a mile to the public bus stop in 43C weather is absolutely unreasonable). As long as public transit in the US is so crappy and unattractive, it’s a slam dunk for building more car infrastructure and exacerbate the problems further.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by frumper on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#37285637)
The privately owned car owners that offer a public good without following ADA will get sued. It should even be relatively easy to find the owner through the license plate.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by pharmakom on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:18AM (#37280212)
> You'd have a fleet of driverless cars driving around the city and summon one with an app. With no drivers they would only need to stop to recharge/refuel and for maintenance.

Yep, and so the city will be flooded with cars.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by fastball on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:01AM (#37279825)
We shouldn't have nice things because some sub-10% portion of the population might not be able to use them is the dumbest argument. You can have public transit and driverless cars.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by abenga on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:15AM (#37280190)
That's not GP's argument though, they said driverless cars _are_ public transit.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by berdario on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:22AM (#37280227)
Will they?

AFAIK, Waymos thought of wheelchair users:

https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/10656347?hl=en

See also:

https://www.theverge.com/2022/8/9/23298488/waymo-accessible-...

(They mention that the WAV trips in SF had been manual, it's unclear to me if that was the case also in Phoenix)

Anyhow, while I think that "zero effort" is hyperbole, the risk that they are not going to invest enough is a very real risk...

And also, if the argument is that 100% of their fleet should be (wheelchair?) accessible, that's a valid concern, since it seems that all players are currently failing at it

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by LeeroyWasHere on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:55AM (#37280404)
Airbnb for cars, what could possibly go wrong.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by Kerb_ on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:40AM (#37279718)
[delayed]
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by Fricken on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:00AM (#37279815)
Same goes for you idiots
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by duskwuff on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:12AM (#37279874)
Driverless cars are not "public transit". At best, they're slightly cheaper taxis.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by piaste on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:25AM (#37279938)
Mass taxis would still be an improvement over individual cars, which are idle 90% of the day and require parking space in the most valuable parts of the city.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by duskwuff on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:30AM (#37279965)
> Mass taxis would still be an improvement over individual cars

No, they'd actually be substantially worse. Personal cars are poorly utilized, but they at least spend all of their time carrying at least one person (the driver), and stay off the roads when they aren't in use. A taxi will, necessarily, spend less than 100% of its time carrying a passenger; if it's being used primarily by commuters, it's likely to spend at least 50% of its time with no passengers at all (because it's deadheading back into a city to take workers home, or vice versa).

Having everyone drive cars everywhere isn't sustainable, but making those cars into taxis isn't the solution either.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by piaste on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:37AM (#37280658)
Good point. I was already thinking that taxis have an issue with peak demand, but I was only thinking of the capacity, I didn't consider the return trip.

One option is to mix public transport with driverless taxis - consolidate public transportation into fewer, bigger routes (knocking down costs), then use driverless taxis for short trips to the station. A little inconvenient to add 1-2 extra transfers to your trip, though.

There's also the opportunity to automate carpooling, but that's not quite the same - it's just moving a little further on the flexibility <-> efficiency scale of transportation (where individual vehicles are furthest left and trains are furthest right). Even if you're just sharing a taxi with 2-3 other commuters, you're still sacrificing the convenience of leaving at the time of your choice and having privacy during the trip - though of course for a big price discount.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by badpun on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:06AM (#37280471)
Dunno about "slighlty". In a typical taxi, the driver's salary/profit is most of the cost.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by harambae on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:05AM (#37281843)
While this is true, the typical taxi’s vehicle doesn’t cost a quarter million dollars (radar, LiDAR, high performance compute system, special calibration).

I am curious how much cheaper the robotaxis will actually be for the user (right now they’re all at a loss)

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by inhumantsar on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:35AM (#37282579)
The median annual income for cab drivers is about $35k. Assuming a car is shared across three shifts a day, 7 days a week, then you're looking at about $105k/yr in savings.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by duskwuff on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:42AM (#37283729)
> Assuming a car is shared across three shifts a day, 7 days a week

Assuming that a cab can make the same income in the dead of the night as it does during peak periods is a rather bold assumption.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by inhumantsar on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:43PM (#37285452)
What? How do you get that from what I wrote? My entire comment is about the cost of operating cabs averaged out over the course of a year.

How much revenue a cab, whether human-operated or autonomous, generates at 1am vs 1pm is entirely irrelevant.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by duskwuff on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:46PM (#37285966)
> My entire comment is about the cost of operating cabs averaged out over the course of a year.

And you're assuming that all cabs are operated 24 hours a day, in three shifts. They are not.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by sdeframond on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:48AM (#37280368)
Being autonomous does not change the fact that a car weighs 1000kg and occupies about 10sqm, just to move a single 70kg person. Or even no one at all, since they are autonomous.

It's a gigantic waste of space and energy.

In this regard, it is in no way comparable to trains, buses etc.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by badpun on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:56AM (#37280408)
> a car weighs 1000kg and occupies about 10sqm, just to move a single 70kg person.

> It's a gigantic waste of space and energy.

So were horses and buggies before car was invented. Interesting, waste of neither space nor energy was not raised as an issue back then.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by cr3ative on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:19AM (#37280552)
I can almost guarantee it was raised by someone back then. That’s a strange claim to make. Even just dealing with the poo was a logistical nightmare for a city!
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by Xylakant on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:46AM (#37282679)
Indeed:

> Just because all roads lead to Rome doesn’t mean you can get in — at least not on wheels. During Julius Caesar’s reign, daytime access to the Eternal City was restricted, with travelers required to hitch their carriages outside the city gates.

https://www.sciencenews.org/article/ancient-rome-forbade-dow...

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by twoodfin on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:05AM (#37281839)
If it’s truly a waste, producing no value, no one will pay for it. But obviously many, many people value things like

- The time savings of direct, immediate, door-to-door transportation

- Dedicated storage capacity

- Configuration flexibility, e.g. children’s car seats, foldable seats, luggage racks

- Style and comfort options

- Privacy

…and direct their dollars accordingly.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by OccamsMirror on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:38AM (#37282110)
Except there’s an obvious failure of the market when the true cost of something is not borne by the producer or the consumer. Negative externalities lead to an overproduction and overconsumption of goods or services because the market price does not reflect the true social costs. Which can have detrimental effects on society and the environment. Not to mention the misallocation of resources that one day we may well bitterly regret.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by yodelshady on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:18AM (#37282437)
And you think correcting that failure will be harder when the consumer has zero personal investment (financial or emotional) in that thing?
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by oldnetguy on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:17PM (#37286260)
you mean like public transit?
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by twoodfin on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:01PM (#37286605)
Sure, pass a serious carbon tax.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by maest on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:39AM (#37282115)
People really enjoy not paying for externalities.

Cars have utility but also disutility - a lot of the latter is not priced in.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ehnto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#37285677)
The cost is not bourne entirely by the driver though, that is why it riles people up I think. Taxes subsidize all the infrastructure for cars, even if the taxee doesn't drive, yet it isn't a service for everyone. It also vastly degrades the usage of the space for everyone else. The fact thst the city stinks, is loud, hard to get around and real estate is more expensive can all be linked to impact of cars.

I think people would hate on cars less if there was a fair focus on other infrastructure as well. We could have the best of both worlds.

I love the freedom to drive but I would rather we all have freedom of movement with mass transit and cleaner, quieter cities.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by brightlancer on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:59PM (#37286590)
> Taxes subsidize all the infrastructure for cars, even if the taxee doesn't drive, yet it isn't a service for everyone.

Gasoline taxes pay for a lot of road infrastructure; except for people buying gasoline for their lawn mowers and leaf blowers (not applicable in California), the taxes are being paid by folks using the infrastructure.

If no one in the household drives, they likely use taxis and delivery services, both of which depend upon road infrastructure.

I've never heard of a government bus service which paid for the general (not segregated) road infrastructure they use; if some do, I'd love to be corrected.

And bicyclists also use general road infrastructure.

Roads are broadly used by the people. Why shouldn't the people broadly pay for it?

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ehnto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:08PM (#37288841)
You missed my point I think, which was mostly the below.

> I think people would hate on cars less if there was a fair focus on other infrastructure as well. We could have the best of both worlds.

It's fine that we all pay for it, it would just be nice if that's not all we paid for. It would also be nice to slide the balance toward pedestrian focus once you get into CBDs and once you get to residential areas. You still need roads, absolutely, but we should do better at matching the roads to their spaces.

> And bicyclists also use general road infrastructure

This is more of an aside to be honest, but cyclists don't want to be on the road as much as drivers don't want them to be. Added bike lanes are a compromise, no one wants them, they get people mad, they get people killed. Separated bikelines is one of those "other infrastructure" pieces, which can be built next to mass transit lines for cost efficiency, everyone would prefer that.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by oldnetguy on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:15PM (#37286242)
Public Transit is a public good yet the same anti car people don't want to pay for the service.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by Xylakant on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:55AM (#37282750)
Just for a comparison of efficiency: The M10 Tram in Berlin runs every 5 minutes during daytime, each car with a capacity of around 300 passengers. That’s equivalent to roughly a kilometer of cars, parked end to end with no space in between.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lotsoweiners on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:04PM (#37283952)
Cool. Does it pick me up at me house and keep others away from me? No? Then not interested in how often it runs.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by intr1nsic on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:04PM (#37285152)
Every 5 minutes seems inefficient. Does it run if only 1 person boards?

1km of cars is 1/9 the total length of the M10. Not following the argument here.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by Xylakant on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:05PM (#37286139)
It’s usually pretty full in the M10. I don’t get the comparison with the total length of the track - you could compare with the length of a tram, which would be 50 meters.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ehnto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:03PM (#37285627)
More like 1700kg, trending heavier each year. Bigger is safer until everyone is the same size, pedestrians are literally losing that battle. Death tolls are up in city centres, some cities are considering taxing SUVs/high GMV commuters that enter the city.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by tetris11 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:53AM (#37280394)
And there will be hundreds of them on the road at any one time, empty vehicles idling behind one another because the company decided that was the "safest speed" to maximise their profits, taking up the roadways to hinder much more efficient public transit, and slowing everything right down. The companies will then likely pay off the city to let them use mass transit lanes, or to allow them some priority over other drivers. If you think this is hyperbole, consider Netflix's great win in the Net Neutrality fight.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by zecg on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:24AM (#37280584)
> And driverless cars, if they are allowed to be developed, will eventually be public transit that takes you from door-to-door running 24/7, way, way better than any train or bus.

Driverless cars still take space both to move and to stand still.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by imgabe on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:15AM (#37280862)
You mean like all physical matter?
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by aydyn on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:23AM (#37281239)
No shit sherlock
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by ehnto on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:54PM (#37285555)
To barely scratch the surface here, mass transit helps solve congestion issues, something almost all car-centric cities suffer from. Forget the word public, I know that scares some people. We are talking about space and efficiency now. How would putting everyone back in cars help? Autonomous or not, tightly following or not, super syncronous (good luck with company interop and human drivers on that one) it's a lot of energy and space for 1-4 people, and we already know most city's road infra can't support everyone.

You'll just be stuck in traffic autonomously instead of on a train moving more people more effectively.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by fastball on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:04AM (#37279839)
All of the things you say they're asking for weren't mentioned in the actual quote that I quoted.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by olgeni on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:25AM (#37283561)
> How is that idiotic?

Well, it sounds strangely like a "15-minute city" agenda, where you have less pollution, less noise, less traffic, and are stuck living in your block :D

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by AmpsterMan on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:19PM (#37284095)
This "15-minute city" meme is the latest example of how conservative propaganda and misinformation make it around the world before the truth has even put on its shoes.