This is an auditing operation to determine the extent to which TikTok is a national security threat.
If you read the article though the actual content does not suggest they were asking for anything other than the ability to ensure TikTok/Byte Dance weren’t doing anything nefarious… and anyway it fell apart when it became obvious how hopeless that was because of how shady they (Byte Dance) are.
Can you share evidence that US regulators are holding US-based social media companies to all of these same requirements?
This moves goalposts. American social media companies don’t have CCP members in their senior ranks.
The problem is the “records and servers” bit could let the Feds execute illegal searches on any American’s data with zero oversight. Not that we’re being mean to TikTok.
Here comes the moronic ccp nonsense. Like clockwork.
This isn't an argument.
Again, this isn't an argument.
There are credible questions regarding ByteDance's independence from the CCP [1][2][3]. They have a track record of censoring anti-Chinese content, e.g. regarding the Tianamen Square massacre [4][5]. Anyone claiming claims of CCP infiltration into ByteDance are "nonsense" is operating outside the window of evidence.
[1] https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/03/24/problem-tiktoks-claim-in...
[2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/former-bytedance-executive-clai...
[3] https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/doj-investigating-tiktok-own...
[4] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-49826155
[5] https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/13/21366488/bytedance-censor...
No there isn't. There is no question at all that any major company - tech, media, oil, banking, etc is independent. All major companies, anywhere in the world, are state corporations.
> They've shown a troubling bias in censoring anti-Chinese content
They've got to fight disinformation somehow. Right? It's funny how you, one of the biggest champions in the fight against disinformation, is upset when the chinese do it.
> Anyone claiming claims of CCP infiltration into ByteDance are "nonsense" is operating outside the window of evidence.
Morons who watch too much youtube nonsense spout ccp nonsense. That a major tech company is 'infiltrated' by the state is nonsense because as I said, all major tech companies are state companies. It would be like morons watching chinese version of youtube and spouting nonsense like google or facebook is 'infiltrated' by US state actors. Google and facebook are US state actors, they aren't infiltrated by us state actors.
It's funny how you just 'randomly' started spouting ccp nonsense as soon as the media and 'alt'-media started spouting the ccp nonsense. Hmmm.
What’s the claim here?
isnt debating fun?
Who added those goalposts? Chinese social media companies don't have FBI, CIA, and NSA members in their senior ranks, either.
This is whataboutism, but I'll answer anyway.
This article concerns the actions of a US governmental agency known as CFIUS.
CFIUS is not concerned with domestic issues, but rather foreign intrusions that impair national security: foreign businesses spying on US soil, foreign entities buying controlling interests in US companies and technologies, foreign real estate purchases near sensitive locations, etc. It is a regulatory body that can block sales and mergers and put a stop to such activities.
CFIUS wants the ability to audit TikTok so that it can ascertain the extent to which is or can be used to spy on US targets. From this data, they can themselves block certain business activities or recommend further actions to be taken by the government.
The Chinese do not think that they are doing anything nefarious either.
"Nefarious" is very dependent on context. The CIA spying on China is what the CIA is _supposed_ to be doing -- it's not nefarious in the US context, but surely, to the Chinese, it's "nefarious activity" and the CIA is aware of that. Surely the Chinese know that they're up to no good from the US point of view, even if it's ethically fine from their point of view.
We aren’t at war with China, but the possibility is taken seriously by the US foreign policy establishment, which knows more about the situation that you or I do. The most reliable way to avoid war is to be impossible to beat. So preempting the ability of potential enemies to collect data about our citizens reduces the chance of war.
- your country spying on your own citizens
- your country spying on foreign citizens
- other countries ability to spy on your own citizens
American GEOINT, MASINT, SIGINT and TECHINT are likely the best in the world. American HUMINT, OSINT and--somewhat paradoxically--FININT are atrocious. Unfortunately, we frequently ascribe confidence intervals to our clandestine services based on experience with e.g. the NRO.
That Osama was hiding there. Which he was, at the time. And that he had carried out 9/11. Which he did.
The Irag and Afghanistan wars were not the same. Practically everyone supported the US in Afghanistan. Practically no one followed the US into Iraq.
Afghanistan? The Iraq War? The people we drone strike every day?
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American-led_intervention_in_t...
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_military_intervention...
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_military_intervention...
The US is trying to determine to what extent TikTok is a domestic security threat.
CFIUS is an organ of the US government designed to prevent foreign intrusion that risks national security. That's the entity involved here. They don't touch ordinary US citizens.
This is not domestic spying. It's investigating the capabilities of a foreign power on US soil.
Granting access to TikTok servers to multiple US agencies is 100% about letting the US spy on users (just as they have the right to under US law, such as the US CLOUD Act, and also via the well-documented and illegal warrantless surveillance programs we all know about). Blocking executive hires is clearly so they can prevent whistleblowers from working in the organization, and is exactly what the US did when it was using Crypto AG to spy on its allies:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/national-...
Anyway, I'm against a ban of TikTok for the same reason that laws that target specific companies or individuals are unconstitutional. Instead, we should ban the things TikTok does that we think should be illegal, and then apply the law equally to US and foreign social media companies.
"We veto all your choices. But what about this guy... Relocating from Langley, VA wouldn't be hard for him."
This is how the previous "Ban Tiktok" bill basically made VPNs illegal.
Do you have a link for this? If you're referring to bills of attainder, my understanding wasn't that they're as broad as just "targeting".
This would would destroy billions of dollars in profits, take down most of the ad-tech industry, which is why I suspect it will never happen. It's much easier to target individual companies like TikTok, or Cambridge Analytica while leaving the gravy train going.
For the record, I fully agree with you on what the remedy ought to be - just cynical about viability.
This is a misunderstanding. The constitution prohibits “bills of attainder”, which are laws that short-circuit the justice system and punish past behavior legislatively rather than via the judicial system, basically declaring “it is the law that x is guilty of crime y (and will be punished with z)”. Targeting an individual or small group is only one of the several criteria that need to be satisfied for such a law to be unconstitutional.
https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S9-C3-2/...
Government spying isn't a "right," the government doesn't have rights. Just a fine point but important.
I don’t use any social media, so apologies if this is a dumb question. What is TikTok doing that other ones like YouTube, Instagram, Facebook isn’t? The only difference I am seeing is that the parent company is China. Misinformation is omnipresent across all those channels too. So on what basis should we ban them?
- A whole lot of blackmail material. E.g. evidence of affairs, illegal drug use, information that is technically fine but that someone really wouldn't want their family to know. - Financial and other sensitive personal info. People will send each other pictures of checks, passports, passwords. - Nationally sensitive info, e.g. "hey Bob, what's the password for the power grid again?"
Yes, I know, you would never do any of this. Other people do. Imagine it being used during war:
- Important actors are blackmailed. - Massive financial fraud is committed, against as many citizens and companies as possible. Transferring all their money, selling all their stock (can that even be reversed?), identity theft. - Cyber attacks against the power grid, etc.
Outside of war it's a lot less scary, but I imagine China does a lot of trade secret theft and some very occasional blackmail?
A canary blog series kicked off by the company itself is worth keeping an eye on to see the 'myths' they want to debunk most scrupously (such as keytracking)[8].
[1]: https://www.nullpt.rs/reverse-engineering-tiktok-vm-1
[2]: https://krausefx.com/blog/announcing-inappbrowsercom-see-wha...
[3]: https://app.urlgeni.us/blog/new-research-across-200-ios-apps...
[4]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/05/business/media/tiktok-alg...
[5]: https://www.afr.com/technology/tiktok-admits-collecting-loca...
[6]: https://au.reset.tech/uploads/resettechaustralia_policymemo_...
[7]: https://www.npr.org/2021/02/25/971460327/tiktok-to-pay-92-mi...
[8]: https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/tiktok-truths-a-new-series...
B: TikTok has different algorithms for different countries, the algorithm in China is tuned to show young people science, technology, and inspirational content, which was dictated by the CCP. The US algorithm shows young people anything that will keep them "engaged", which usually includes ragebait and all kinds of unhealthy things.
You're totally right and that is a huge problem as well. But I would say a slightly different one.
If you computed the results of this problem, the next question I ask is whom are you at more risk from?
Moreover any such Chinese agents if caught will go through some rather unpleasant processes, does not seem usually the case for American cops even brazenly caught in various misdeeds.
I’m not talking about while I’m in America. I travel outside of the country.
If the CCP can make billionaires disappear, they can make you disappear too.
This level of narrative and dogmatic belief is how governments gain influence. They're simply the local bullies. If you need proof, look at how much they put into caring about struggling people. I.e. next to nothing. Our country betrays us daily and has the gall to demand obedience. We are not dogs.
> Two Arrested for Operating Illegal Overseas Police Station of the Chinese Government
Edit: example stats for 2016 sourced from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St...
In 2016, there were an estimated 1.2 million violent crimes committed in the United States.[88] Over the course of that year, U.S. law enforcement agencies made approximately 10.7 million arrests, excluding arrests for traffic violations.[88] In that year, approximately 2.3 million people were incarcerated in jail or prison.[89]
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/11/23/cops-...
The article is from 2015, but nothing's been done to reverse the trend. I wonder what they've gotten the ratio up to in the last eight years.
That's redundant and repetitive.
No. It's not a measurement problem or a propaganda issue. It's just the truth. USG just literally doesn't 'disappear' US residents in modern times. It happens with nontrivial frequency in China.
When you point your finger at someone, you have 4 pointing back at yourself.
This is the problem with the original comment, it’s way to vague, or I’ve failed to make sense of it.
1. Build platform teens love 2. ??? 3. Compromise national security.
Fundamentally, the product isn't an effective way to get into secure spaces. Its core audience does not generally have direct access to those spaces, and if they did, that feels like an institutional security breakdown that they allowed any personal devices or software there.
At this point, War Thunder and Discord have both proven to deliver more high-secrecy documents than TikTok has, yet nobody's demanding widespread bans.
"Ooh, but it will spread propaganda or filter things in a way Beijing likes." And if that happens, the audience moves on. Haven't we noticed that social platforms are hyper-fickle, especially for ones targeted towards a youth and entertainment market? How many "look at China's awesome high-speed rail" videos can you slip into the feed before the kids say "screw this, I'm moving to this new platform which pioneered the Drink An Entire Litre of Bleach challenge"? They actually built a very non-sticky platform compared to Facebook (which will persist for decades because people need to talk to Aunt Bertha who never learned any other platform) or YouTube (which has long-form content of value even if the firehose of new content starts winding down)
It all just reeks of sour grapes. We were perfectly happy with China when they were a passive trading partner, a convenient "elsewhere" to offshore all that pesky polluting manufacturing to. But when they start to represent a real economic and political counterweight, producing a high-margin and culturally relevant product that's outcompeting our own offerings, we immediately start rattling sabres. I figure it's the same spiel as with Huawei and ZTE; if domestic products had been compelling enough to win on their own merits, there would be no meaningful market penetration and we'd never even be discussing a ban in the first place.
I wonder if the Vine people feel vindicated now, it feels like they could have been TikTok 10 years ago.
For what it's worth, this idea that propaganda is noticeable is itself propaganda.
Even a "pure entertainment" product that doesn't need to do any particular ideological heavy lifting has a hard time. If you're taping an episode of a sitcom today, the language you use might have passed to "cringy" by the time it airs, and the trend you used as a plot device might have fizzled.
Social media's ability to stay relevant is managed by constantly eating its own-- people fall in and out of trend. That makes it harder to use as a means to inject a specific message; you'd need to be constantly generating new users and getting them into closed circle communities as the old ones wear out their usefulness. Note I don't say impossible, but it's an interesting set of challenges and probably pretty different from the ones the guys running Radio Havana face.
I support the ban from a competitive perspective. Until meta can spy on Chinese citizens, why should the Chinese spy on Americans?
Also I support it from a privacy perspective. We can’t as easily ban American companies from spying on us, but we should use any power to limit other companies from starting business spying on Americans. Make it less profitable globally.
*https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2023/china-...
Foreign attacking agents can do much worse than garnish your wages. They can get a no-knock raid sent to your home if they have your info and you're a target of theirs. That's relatively easy. They can drive the US system to attack you by screwing with your life from outside the US where you can't do anything to stop them. And that can be done in so many ways it's rather obscene. Let's talk about the IRS economic ways they could do it; let's talk about the child protective services way they could do it; let's talk about the no-knock SWAT raid way they could do it; let's talk about the way they could go after your identity and bank accounts; let's talk about how they could focus in on your job, boss, co-workers, etc. and try to make your life hell there; and on and on and on it goes.
Yeah right. I dare anybody on HN to proclaim that, I want to see the supporting premise where the foreign party like Russia having all your info is not as big of a deal.
The notion that the FBI would do worse things from that position than Russia would is absurd, given what we've seen out of Russia. And China is absolutely no different in terms of its willingness to attack the US opportunistically (the Obama Admin had to obtain a cease fire agreement with China in regards to aggressively attacking the US re hacking, recall).
There are no chains at all on what Russia can do to screw with the US citizenry, given the information. And more advanced AI systems should make it even easier for them to do it in the near future.
If Russia could push a button and blank out 30 million US bank accounts, via a hacking plausible deniability means (anything that gives them the required minimum cover), they'd do it immediately. There's so little downside from where Russia is sitting these days, it'd be a no-brainer for them. What are you gonna do? Sanction them? We're sure as hell not going to war with Russia over that.
Imagine if the US wasn’t a police state, and the average person had good social/financial protections. We’d make China and Russia powerless according to your logic.
This is a foreign government we have a decent chance of being in a great power military conflict with, the first of such since the Second World War. It is so obviously a tool that would be used in such a conflict that I have a hard time accepting this is a good faith question you’re asking. If it is, then you need to stop thinking of it as a social media platform and remember that’s just the front end of the network.
Not defending TikTok but there’s a wealth of public real time data from not just the US, but the entire world, some public api calls or scraping scripts away. Tiktok isn’t any more invasive than any other social media post, many of which are public and anyone in any country who wants to use the data can do so easily.
What trove of intelligence is being gathered by self obsessed videos of people mouthing a clip of some song or inspirational talk while begging for attention in the form of likes and follows?
I haven’t seen any sign of intelligence on TikTok that they even could gather lol, and if anything the app’s purpose isn’t to spy on us, it’s to make us dumb, inattentive, mindless consumers who all fight over everything and can’t compromise or work together.
My dad literally comes home from his job and scrolls TikToks of increasingly radical political rants and half naked chicks before inevitably passing out in his chair, phone in hand, mouth open, and whatever TikTok was on screen when he fell asleep playing on loop until he jerks awake or the phone dies. He’s not unique. So much of people’s lives are wasted on social media and it does them no positive
1. For now 2. ...unless you have family abroad, particularly in China 3. ...also assuming you don't need to travel to said country (now / in the future)
one example:
arbitrary seizure of private property? turns out that isn't just the domain of pretend communists, its a tenet of our society too
There was an elite outcry.
That's just the kind of overheated hyperbole derailing so many of our civic discussions nowadays.
FBI and CIA have far more effective tools at their disposal. They'd nearly always decline to use the journeyman tools China has in its cyber arsenal.
Go read Spyfail. What a joke.
> There's a level of admiration I actually have for China. Their basic dictatorship is actually allowing them to turn their economy around on a dime.
I don't think that's wrong? Although it is certainly in bad taste for a prime minister.
"Rome demands victory from her Generals" .. and those who tried and failed, were publicly killed. As they still do in China actually.
we can do better than this
Leave room for nuance and discussion.
It's wrong, too - the Chinese economy is in trouble, and has been since Covid. Xi has accumulated more autocratic power, but if he's able to use it to "turn their economy around on a dime" then he's not doing so.
I'm a major fan/paying contributor to the EFF, but that seems absurd to me. We don't have to equate the US with China in order to say the US is doing terrible things and needs to stop. In fact doing so just distracts from the issue by changing it into an argument about something else.
And yes, the US and China are not the same. But they both have the same capabilities. Parent poster argued that the Chinese government had a greater capacity to spy on their citizens("better tools"). I simply pointed out that it's false.
China also has a lot more surveillance and filtering controls, especially with traffic leaving/entering the great firewall. They have the social credit system and things as well, which the US could have with credit card and banking information, but (at least for now) the US has to get a warrant whereas the Chinese just gobble all of it up. That's probably moot though since the banks will store that info forever so a warrant can be gotten later. Anyway we could debate whether those are "tools" or not. But overall I'd bet we agree on the vast majority of things. Even if I think you're being a bit hyperbolic, it always makes me happy to see other people passionate about this topic, so thank you!
If it was about preserving privacy or any moral argument, they would also ban domestic social media. They have no reason to do this since they already have access to domestic data.
A second reason might be to mitigate foreign influence and propaganda, but this is also rampant on domestic social media, and they apparently have no desire to prevent this either. This seems ludicrous to me, as these tools are the primary weapons of information warfare.
The PATRIOT act does this by just existing and continually being extended. Room 641a. Julian Assange's case. Mortal authority left the building in the early 2000s.
"Letting it expire" is not some accomplishment other than kicking the can further down the road.
The state ran media calling actually peaceful american flag waving re-opening protestors terrorists and murderers for spreading COVID, then literally a matter of days later called the costliest riots in U.S history mostly peaceful protests that were incapable of spreading COVID. This was probably the sign that it was all over and we had entered the biological terrorism era.
It is better to think that the gov is incompetent than outright malicious (which is definitely the case). Gor some reason they NEVER drop the ball into giving more freedoms but they ALWAYS drop the ball on taking some away.
I didn't believe for a second that the MS Exchange vulnerability was not known & abused since forever. Now the Chinese have created what Zynga, Facebook, Pinterest, and the rest of the silicon valley failed to succeed. Get everyone meth-ed on an app. 150m Americans is nearly half the population. If you leave out the under 4 and the over 70, that's the majority of active population, having a homing beacon in their pocket reporting to China.
This puts Room 641A to shame..
This is so naive. Let me introduce you to the security industrial complex.
A hard no from me. But it doesn't seem to make a difference what I say.
I support a domestic ban on TikTok, and this is embarrassing. You're not supposed to be worse than the country you say is spying on your citizens. This undermines any moral authority they could claim, and makes their argument look like: "we want to ban you because we can't stand anyone doing a better job spying on Americans than us".