News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ipnon on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:01AM (#37171530)
There are many real estate giants and so-called "trust" companies who are incapable of repaying debt right now. Some of these companies have trillions in RMB on their balance sheets. The central bank can bail them out but at the expense of the assets of the middle and lower class. This would only further incentivize cash hoarding, and tighten the middle income trap. It is not an enviable situation.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by dragonelite on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:38AM (#37171701)
China will not be captured by the middle income trap because it has already escaped the middle income trap. The middle income in my opinion has a different reason countries get stuck there and its by design. Because the road to high income is protected by western IP protection. Patents are way for the west to forever license fees for their high end technology, China is beating the west in new IP generation and hence will get an ever bigger share of the high end technology fees income. If one thing i expect western nations most likely EU nations to slip back into middle income status and get trapped their with their suicidal foreign policy.

I got this insight in 2016 when the US started its suicidal trade and tech war with China which they claimed would be easy to win. It was never about money or trade it was all about keeping asians down and dependent.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by kristofferg on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:54AM (#37171776)
Some bold claims with little evidence. GDP capita flattened at 13k is hardly “escaped the middle income trap”. IPs can be harmful to growth but then again China has never shown any intent to enforce IPs of western origin. There are no evidence of the US wanting to “keep asians down” - many of USAs asian trading partners enjoy less trade regulation. The “trade war” might be counterproductive but was a, imo mild, response to the extreme levels of protectionism exhibited by the chinese communist party.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by geysersam on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:46AM (#37172107)
> GDP capita flattened at 13k

Flattened? It's growing something like 5% per year.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:50AM (#37172127)
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:26AM (#37172338)
You can cherry pick negative news all you want. But if you a clear picture look at the aggregate for longer terms.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by dmix on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:58AM (#37172578)
The article explains there are multiple signals which suggest we can't trust the growth numbers coming out of China. People have been ringing that bell for years. That still applies in aggregates and recent history.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by misja111 on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:55AM (#37173913)
The CDS (credit default swap) on Chinese government bonds went up over 30% during the last week. This means that the market believes that the chance for a default on bond payments went up considerably.

If you believe you are right and the market is wrong, you should short-sell CDS'es and get rich.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by nradov on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:31AM (#37174750)
We really don't know how fast the Chinese economy is growing. The numbers are largely made up by Party functionaries with no oversight; they often exaggerate and falsely claim to be meeting goals in order to keep their jobs. Independent analysis based on satellite imagery and import/export volumes indicates the growth rate is probably lower, but no one knows for sure.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:11AM (#37172266)
1. 13K is technically the point where a country goes from middle to high income.

2. The Chinese economy is still growing more than most countries.

3. The US is clearly engaged in zero/negative sum economic warfare against China at the moment - for example read this article and the quoted views by admistration officials therein:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/12/magazine/semiconductor-ch...

‘An Act of War’: Inside America’s Silicon Blockade Against China

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway2037 on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:41AM (#37172438)

    The US is clearly engaged in zero/negative sum economic warfare against China
I suggest that you read the history of post war trade relations between US and Japan. It was a bumpy ride! One big difference: General adherence to IP laws (China does whatever they want), plus both are democracies.

Related: Do you think China can catch-up to developed world in fab tech? I do not. They are hopelessly behind.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwawayqqq11 on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:16AM (#37172694)
... ehem, taiwan.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway2037 on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:58AM (#37176593)
Invasion or naval blockade? Your choice. Sure, for a few days, before multiple US carriers float into these waters. It won't last a month if it happens. You would have every high developed country in the world ready to support Taiwan in the event of an "unfortunate incident" with Mainland China. Plenty of people in the US are "itching" for a small military confrontation with M/C. If you think the support for Ukraine has been strong, it will be multiple times stronger for Taiwan, if only for economic (TSMC) reasons.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:34AM (#37172823)
Yes. I know the history; the US is absolutely ruthless against friend and foe in keeping its hegemony. And it has a long history of having its natsec apparatus integrated into its largest corporations.

As for China "catching up":

1. China is indeed far far behind the US-controlled West if the criteria is purely Chinese designed and manufactured semiconductors using purely Chinese designed and manufactured equipment.

2. The extreme nature of the US semiconductor blockade has surprised even me (and I was kinda expecting the worst).

However:

3. China is developing along a path already throtten by Western companies; far easier than developing on the leading edge.

4. The Chinese market (plus Russia, Iran whoever is on the US shit list) is massive. It can sponsor a lot of technological development.

In the end there is no magic in tech.

Whatever company is at the top seemingly untouchable is there because of a "natural monopoly" created by massive fixed cost and little marginal cost. History is full of tech companies that were at one point dominant but no longer is: Digital, Microsoft, Intel, Google ...

The companies that are used as chokeholds today: NVDIA, ASML, TSMC will at one point join that list. In fact using them as chokeholds probably makes it happen faster.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by dragonelite on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:15AM (#37173106)
TSMC 3~5nm is quiet dependent on Apple, Nvidia, AMD products also being able to reach Chinese consumers. Or else the economic off scale that makes using EUV plausible breaks down. With Europe going down the drain and American consumer having a tougher time to make ends meet. Losing the Chinese consumers might as well break TSMC.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:37AM (#37176250)
That’s a really interesting point, it would be fascinating if China decided to block any products that used TSMC 4nm nodes and below in response.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bakuninsbart on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:44AM (#37172464)
There are enormous economic differences within China and given the scale of the country it is much harder to make these kinds of broad-stroke arguments. Looking at gdp per region [0], the main tier one cities are already clearly a cut above middle income countries, even a province like Jiansu with 23k$ in GDP per capita has a higher GDP/capita than Poland and a larger population than Germany or the UK.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_administrative...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by refurb on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:43AM (#37172876)
The problem with GDP per capita is that it doesn't necessarily correlate with wages (which is what we're talking about with middle income trap).

You can look at Singapore or Ireland for another example. They have higher GDP per capita than the US, but a lot of it's due to multi-nationals storing IP in those countries, and funneling cash through for tax purposes. It's not GDP that gets converted to local wages.

And in the case of certain Chinese regions, if you have companies headquartered there (with multiple sites at satellite cities), GDP measures are going to assign national GDP to that one region, so again, it doesn't necessarily reflect local wages.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jsiepkes on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:55AM (#37171780)
> It was never about money or trade it was all about keeping asians down and dependent.

Thats way too much simplification. For starters there isn't a level playing field. Any Chinese company can start a company in the west but if a western company wants to start a company in China you can either start a "second class" entity (a WFOE) or if you want a level playing field with the locals you can use a joint venture but then a Chinese national must have 50+% stake in your business.

Just ask ARM what can happen if you go for a joint venture.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by justinclift on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:04AM (#37172223)
> ... then a Chinese national must have 50+% stake in your business.

Didn't they drop that requirement last year?

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oreally on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:20AM (#37173147)
> For starters there isn't a level playing field.

Think about it, who determines what is a 'level playing field'? That's right, the US in this context. Every country has the right to determine it's own policies, and the US shouldn't have any say, and yet is applying pressure for it's own benefits.

The same goes when China insists on one-on-one bilateral country negotiations on the issue of the south china sea instead of multilateral negotiations.

Historically the number one country will always be putting pressure on potential the upstart countries, and Big countries will be big countries. The US especially is adapt at spinning up narratives, so calm down and take a look at the different perspectives.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by krona on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:54AM (#37173908)
The US is still nominally governed by and accountable to the rule of law.

Companies cannot use the court system in China to hold the government to account, the government is accountable only to itself.

This difference is irreconcilable.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oreally on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:31AM (#37174254)
> The US is still nominally governed by and accountable to the rule of law.

You mean the rule of law that it imposes upon others that they didn't agree on? And they'll bring it up only when it's convenient.

I'll say it again: Big countries will be big countries.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by krona on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:45AM (#37174892)
Name a law passed by a foreign government against its own will at the behest of the US.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oreally on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:29PM (#37185207)
Plenty of laws touched by government takeovers that involve the USA, trade deals with Japan against Japan's own interests, and even more. Go look it up.

Now that I've answered your question, do you believe the US hasn't had abuses of it's power in the decades it's been at the top? And if not, can you name an instance of it?

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by inemesitaffia on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:47PM (#37190627)
Switzerland, Bahamas and back secrecy laws.

Not just a law but a constitution

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:28AM (#37176131)
Law is imposed on others that don’t agree with it, that’s kind of the definition.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oreally on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:37PM (#37185258)
And what is a law selectively enforced and conveniently brought up in times of contention?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by wenyuanyu on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:19AM (#37173635)
The previous mandate of a 50% joint venture in the automotive sector is outdated. Take for example Tesla in China, which operates without a joint venture. Similarly, BMW's Chinese operations are only 30% owned by a local entity, deviating from the earlier 50% norm. Despite certain industry-specific regulations, it's essential to recognize that China aligns well with its WTO obligations—a framework that the U.S. and other Western nations have both agreed upon and ratified.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by CryptoBanker on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:35AM (#37173766)
The BMW joint venture was 50% owned by a Chinese auto company and the government when it was initially created
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jsiepkes on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:21AM (#37174649)
> it's essential to recognize that China aligns well with its WTO obligations

There is no way in hell I (as a foreigner in China) will win an intellectual property dispute from a Chinese company in China.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by aylmao on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:45AM (#37172095)
Not sure why this comment is getting downvoted. I think it's relevant to the discussion, whether people agree with it or not.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:50AM (#37172126)
> it was all about keeping asians down and dependent.

Probably because of this. The US is allied to several prosperous Asian countries.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by berdario on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:20AM (#37172310)
Yes, prosperous. But as prosperous as the US?

And being prosperous doesn't mean not being dependent.

Japan agreed to the Plaza accords

https://youtu.be/pU_yyadYgG8

Other Asian countries probably are going to be careful before signing up for something equivalent.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:49AM (#37172924)
Is the US supposed to make these countries as prosperous as itself?

Please do list all the prosperous Chinese or Russian allies.

I'll wait.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:53AM (#37173421)
Many have gotten rich of the Chinese boom - from Singapore to Australia - from Apple to Tesla.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:13AM (#37174584)
I said allies.

Those people you tell, in writing, signed by your highest authorities: if your people start dying, our people will start dying with them.

Talk is cheap.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:37AM (#37175455)
China does not have allies in that manner.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:50AM (#37176459)
Which is my point.

China doesn't have friends.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by berdario on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:35AM (#37187723)
China does have one such alliance:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-North_Korean_Treaty_of_Fr...

Of course "talk is cheap" is an hyperbole, since there can be a lot of mutually beneficial agreements that don't involve military sacrifice

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Sino-Russian_Treaty_of_Fr...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Cooperation_Organisat...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by aylmao on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:01PM (#37183240)
China is putting a lot of money down with its Belt and Road initiative, and specifically has tried to attract partners/allies calling it vehicle for prosperity [2]. In Africa, they've been building infra and haven't shied away from forgiving debt [1].

This certainly plays in their interest. The USA's support for global trade and the economic prosperity of countries key in their trade network (like Japan, for example) are similar ventures. I'm not saying China is making countries as prosperous as itself, but it is certainly working to make being a Chinese ally economically attractive.

[1]: https://www.voanews.com/a/china-cancels-23-loans-to-africa-a...

[2]: https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/views/opinions/chinas-eff...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:13AM (#37172282)
Who all got seriously smacked down when they got too independent (from the Vietnam war to the Plaza accord).
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by dmix on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:55AM (#37172541)
Neither the Vietnam war nor Plaza Accords were about "keeping Asians down". Unintentional side effects is not intention. A very important distinction.

Japan's recent Stagflation has plenty of obvious internal causes. Blaming the west for that is some weird cope.

China is an expert at manipulating their currency and internal markets for global advantage. Countries reacting to China's top-down aggressive self interest in a global market is only logical. Other countries engaging in those markets aren't there for charity and nor is China.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by modo_mario on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:16AM (#37173116)
>Japan's recent Stagflation has plenty of obvious internal causes. Blaming the west for that is some weird cope.

I don't think it extends so far since it's the 80's but I can see why one would blame the US there. Around this time Japan was forced to do technology transfers to the US, to have minimum marketshare in japan for US cars and semiconductors, to have unfavorable monetary policy.

That smells equivalent to being a vassal at gunpoint. Of course European countries helped pressuring and it being the cold war japan did not have much developed (or allowed alternatives) for it's export based economy even if it did have an army, more independence and a more varied political landscape.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by aylmao on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:12PM (#37183358)
I'm from Mexico. Given the landscape with energy worldwide, the current president has been overhauling the energy sector to keep foreign influence low. It makes sense in the current geopolitical climate, which really shook the energy market worldwide. I mean, France straight-up nationalized Electricite de France for example [1].

The USA is not happy about this [2]. Understandably, this affects American companies' business in the country. The USA is happy do take action in defense of its national security and its national industries, but fights back when other countries do the same.

[1]: https://www.neimagazine.com/news/newsfrench-government-wins-....

[2]: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/1/6/whats-behind-the-ene...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:28AM (#37173207)
Yes, the famous Asian Vietnamese ally, the Soviet Union.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway4good on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:41AM (#37173292)
South Vietnam was a US ally; subject to US sponsored coups when they didn't behave and ultimately were abandonned when the cost of war got too high.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:55AM (#37174981)
And North Vietnam was... ?

A beacon of self determination and lack of foreign and imperial influence?

Oh, wait!

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwawayqqq11 on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:11AM (#37172663)
The US is chasing hegemonial "interests overseas". Every other country, that tries to develop a sovereign position in too many industrial sectors contradicts that. Thats how the US justify their industrial/political espionage on basically all their "allies".
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:48AM (#37172915)
LOL at accusing the US of industrial espionage in a discussion about China :-))

Nota bene, I'm convinced the US is spying. It's just what China is doing in terms of spying and forced industrial transfer makes the US stuff look kiddie play.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by woooooo on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:54AM (#37174427)
If that's true, it just means we're losing our edge.

I'd say we're still tied, personally. Arizona and mainland China are both getting a TSMC plant.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:57AM (#37174999)
The US doesn't do as much industrial espionage, I'm fairly certain of it.

Why?

The US just brain drains countries.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:32AM (#37176184)
The US still attracts the best and brightest _better_ than other countries (on average, hence the net source/drain of brain).
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by oblio on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:50AM (#37176449)
So we're in agreement.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ethbr1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:22AM (#37174183)
Japan and South Korea?

Given China's rise and size, US Asian hegemonial interests primarily trend towards making any not-China country in the region as economically strong as possible.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by unstatusthequo on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:51AM (#37173875)
“Beating the west in new IP generation” is highly misleading. China is probably the best at IP theft, and they are certainly beating everyone at that game. Have a look at their EV cars that look like BMWs and Fords. Or their completely stolen Boeing plans. I sure as hell would not get on a fake Chinese plane, that’s for sure.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:14AM (#37175899)
Um, no.

China killed itself off with its own policy of ‘for every two of us there should be one of us’.

Now their work force is shrinking and costs are rising fast. They aren’t competitive and the future is with India and Africa.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by AnthonyMouse on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:15AM (#37171915)
Are they actually underwater or do they just have higher loan payments than rental income? If it's the latter, let them sell some properties or transfer them to the bank in lieu of loan payments.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by HWR_14 on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:54AM (#37172165)
Underwater. Totally underwater.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by Zetobal on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:55AM (#37172171)
The problem they have is that nobody buys their properties...
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jldugger on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:57AM (#37172184)
Only in the sense that the problem with pyramid schemes is that people stop buying in.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:36AM (#37175429)
Hard to rationalize with land rights that expire. You are just playing with government land for a while.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by lmm on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:06AM (#37172232)
Who says those properties are worth their book value? This is how a crash happens these days - distressed asset holders forced into fire sales of the assets themselves, lowering asset values and putting more of the holders into distress.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by AnthonyMouse on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:05AM (#37172611)
They don't have to be worth book value to be worth more than the outstanding loan principal. This is also why it can make sense to pay the bank in real estate. The bank doesn't need to sell it immediately because they don't need to pay a mortgage so they can just sit on it and collect rental income until they can find a buyer.

Another alternative is for the real estate trust to sell new shares into the market and use the money to pay the bank, or pay the bank in new shares. That dilutes the existing shareholders but doesn't force a fire sale of the properties.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by worrycue on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:33AM (#37173239)
Evergrande has more debt than assets - including property - I believe. They can sell everything at book value and they will still owe money.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bartvk on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:35AM (#37173767)
Does this actually happen? A bank that owns real estate and collects rental income on it?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by nradov on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:11AM (#37174561)
That happens all the time in the US and other countries. Banks typically try to sell off those repossessed real estate assets fairly quickly because they aren't really in the landlord business, but when there's a supply glut they may have to hold for several years.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by slv77 on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:42AM (#37174856)
US regulators also require banks to move non-performing loans and assets off the balance sheet. Allowing banks to hold them makes the balance sheet murky and hard to determine if the bank is solvent. In the 2008 financial crisis banks sold houses off in blocks of 1,000 at a time to hedge funds.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by the-dude on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:17AM (#37174614)
This happens all the time, they pony up the money and you pay interest on the loan.

In Dutch, interest is actually called 'rente'.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by tacker2000 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:35AM (#37175418)
Of course. Some banks have their own real estate arms that sell/rent/manage these types of assets
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by thechao on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:13AM (#37174583)
Until people demand their RMB, and all the bank has is piles of building materials…
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by chasd00 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:20AM (#37175230)
> Until people demand their RMB

It's China, the authorities will just say "no." and then jail anyone who asks again.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by AnthonyMouse on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:34PM (#37178123)
Banks don't actually have as much cash as they have deposits. When you take out a loan they just credit your checking account and debit your mortgage account, which cancels out. When you pay the seller they debit your checking account and credit theirs. The amount of cash they hold hasn't changed.

Whether thing backing the credit to the seller's checking account is a mortgage loan or the deed to the property likewise has no effect on the amount of cash in their vault.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jncfhnb on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:39AM (#37174828)
If you sell one building at a large discount to pay your bills, the market is likely to rapidly devalue the rest of your buildings
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by AnthonyMouse on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:47PM (#37178360)
That's assuming your sale is the only data they have about the value of your assets. But real estate sales happen all the time.

Now, if everybody is selling every building at a large discount, that's a housing crash, and highly-leveraged real estate companies are toast. But that should only happen if there is a real estate bubble, in which case a market correction is ultimately necessary and the entities that buy at the peak of the market are supposed to lose their shirts.

What you want to do in that case is not to save them. They're done. What you want is to prevent a cascading failure into the rest of the economy.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jncfhnb on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:11PM (#37178772)
There is a real estate bubble, and everyone, especially government entities, are deeply invested.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by RugnirViking on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:50AM (#37172510)
there is deflation in china right now. Why would you buy a house today if the money you have today would buy a bigger house tomorrow?

As a result, nobody can sell. The only way to move any inventory is to dramatically slash the price. Everyone is doing this, so you gotta do it even more than the next guy (or just hold on to the property but what if you need the money/can't maintain the property?). I've heard of 2mn rmby apartments in beijing going for 100k

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by misja111 on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:44AM (#37173825)
Typically real estate companies use properties as collateral for loans. So they can't sell those properties unless they pay back the rest of the loan at the same time, which they probably can't.

They might have some properties that are not collateral, but even selling those imposes a problem: in the current market, most likely they will be sold well below book value. This automatically devaluates the value of any other property which they would like to use in the future for collateral and it will make existing lenders very nervous as well.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:12AM (#37174084)
They are massively underwater.

They have hundreds of thousands of unfinished apartments, and no money to finish them.

And even if they could, no one wants to buy the unsold apartments.

The average person in China owns more housing than the average person in the US or the EU.

This, with house prices being roughly equal but incomes being 1/6th on average, and there being about ~2.5B unfinished sqft of space (~2 sqft per person), and a rapidly shrinking population.

You do the math. Houses have been in a massive bubble in China for a long time, on nearly the same level as the Japanese bubble.

Who knows if it's finally going to pop. But the writing definitely seems on the wall now.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jacquesm on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:10AM (#37174547)
They are so far under water that there simply are no buyers, at all, and there likely never will be buyers. A lot of this construction was just to keep the wheels spinning. There are entire cities that are empty.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by throwaway2037 on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:21AM (#37172317)

    Some of these companies have trillions in RMB on their balance sheets.
I don't understand this sentence. It is nonsensical to use balance in this way. You wrote "trillions in RMB". Let's assume (your hand-wavy use of the term) balance sheet means: outstanding debt. Further, each 1T RMB is 137B USD. How many companies in the whole world carry more than this much debt? Let alone Chine property developers? Wildly overstated.

Also, central bank's can print money, by definition. They can also buy debt issued by these companies to repay maturing debt. Then they can forgive this debt. Why would this harm "the assets of the middle and lower class"? The misunderstanding of monetary theory appears weak here.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by hurril on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:35AM (#37172405)
Moral hazard and inflation. If I know that I will be bailed out with a certain probability, then my actual cost of capital is much lower (since I am not expected to pay the entire volume of interest.)

For instance: why not make the investors whole again instead by giving them the "printed money" instead of going through the middle-man of propping up these failed giants?

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ksey3 on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:50AM (#37172512)
In the US sure, where its blasphemous to slit the throats of the leisure classes for their excesses. In China they made Jack Ma disappear.

Through out history when it gets time for the Kings & Queens to waive the debt of the plebs away, cause they have nothing left to pay, the Rentier classes take the haircut.

In the US the rentiers have owned the Kings & Queens for a long time. To the point where any American institution cant touch them. This is not the case in China. There will be mass disappearances and cullings (already have been).

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:15AM (#37172684)
Well, start with the first 10, then remaining ones will emigrate and simply assign bounty for any head of CCP member based on the rank - until the Party is eliminated. How about that? Don't underestimate the money - it goes the long way.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ksey3 on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:22AM (#37172736)
You think Jack Ma didnt try that?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:29AM (#37172777)
Still, human history shows us that money always wins. People have natural instinct to acquire wealth. No political regime has remained viable for a long time if it tried to go against this instinct. Authoritarianism works fine; in fact i am even in a bit of doubt about democracy being the better social order, in any case our empirical data to confirm that is insufficient - but even authoritarian society should exploit, rather that try to suppress, this basic motivator of the people.

So far we can't see CCP making this mistake - which sort of confirms that Party has a healthy self-preservation instinct. Let's say, they are trying to do everything to avoid collapse of real estate prices because that will hit retirement savings of too many people, and they seem to accept lower rates of economic growth if that will be necessary to achieve that.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by vkou on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:44AM (#37172887)
> Still, human history shows us that money always wins.

Human history has shown us that whomever controls the army usually wins.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:58AM (#37172988)
Still, you need money to control the army and keep it interested. Then there comes a choice of either being unable to do it because of not raising enough cash from society to make a sufficiently big army to keep population in check, being able to have better income they can have in civilian life; or doing it and ruining the competitiveness of the overall economy - like the good old Soviet Union.

Now, in the post-industrial era, we have a third threat. Extinction. And China may actually combine all three.

Money is the force of reason, ignoring it comes at one's own peril regardless of the force one controls: it means going against common sense that established itself through the power of competition, in favour of some arbitrary political theory or just someone's wits. Even if it succeeds for a while, it always reduces overall quality of the system and increases it's vulnerability.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by vkou on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:17AM (#37173127)
> Still, you need money to control the army and keep it interested.

Making payroll is never an issue for a sovereign that controls a central bank that controls their own currency. You're completely missing the point, because you're thinking in terms of money. A country isn't a business, or a household, it doesn't budget in the way you think.

> Money is the force of reason, ignoring it comes at one's own peril regardless of the force one controls:

Money is a floating-value paper proxy for material wealth. When there's a shortage of material prosperity - when people aren't building stuff, that's when you get a problem. Your position has just as many ideological blinders on as the one you think you are making arguments against.

The USSR collapsed because it failed to provide material prosperity. China, by any metric you could measure, is wildly succeeding at providing that material prosperity. That is what the party is focused on, because that's what's going to keep them in power.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ethbr1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:16AM (#37174121)
For counterexamples of the primacy of money, see also: North Korea, Iran, Russia, Pakistan.

You have to have bases of power, who are compensated and secured.

It's less stable, but doable with the right mix of alternatives, to ignore "the people" as one of those bases of power.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#37174313)
Idk how you can include any of those but North Korea in the list (North Korea only exists because China secures it). Russia at least, is a good example of the opposite: give people chance to earn and invest money and enrich themselves and they will give no shit about even the most ridiculous things government does.

Soviet Union has collapsed while having whole lot more economic power and raw output of just about every industry, and was much more up to date technologically, but it deprived people of their basic instinct: to save and invest money and grow rich. Today's Russia allows and encourages that. Moreover, it even allows people say, to blatantly ignore taxes on all levels (i know people who make millions bucks per year in Russia and they don't know what tax number is, receiving and spending money through the banks in the open - and banks even help then when they need to make that money look legit abroad). As long as you don't try to oppose the great Pu or mess with politics overall, the regime has nothing against people enriching themselves - so the support base is rock solid and need for violence to maintain internal order is next to nonexistent.

Russia isn't democratic, but it is capitalist in the sense: you can own capital and government wants you to, and sees people who have capital as by default more well-behaved and loyal than those who don't. The sickest shit Putin may say on TV is shrugged by those people as "Pu just wants to make those peasants happy", and they may be even right.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ethbr1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:54AM (#37174418)
Those are all countries in which I'd hazard a free and open election, without a thumb on the scales and voted in by all citizens, would topple their governments.

Your description of Russia seems accurate, ~1995 to ~2010.

However, policies appear to be changing into tighter, more direct state control of oligarchs, in an effort to ensure civil stability.

Additionally, Putin is now 70... which is getting to the age that more laissez faire dictators turn increasingly autocratic in response to any external disturbances of their social control.

At some age and tiredness, it seems like the blunt approach trumps finessing a solution between multiple competing interests.

And... not to put too fine a point on it, but Putin did just survive a coup attempt, which wouldn't have launched if there weren't some support for it among the myriad power brokers in Russia.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:23AM (#37175269)
I don't mean oligarchs. I mean everyday men and women. People don't want to be politically active because they know that Putin allows and wants them to acquire wealth (and even has no problem with them exporting that wealth abroad); and they also know that the masses don't want them to be allowed that, and if Putin is out, most probably masses will have it their way.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ethbr1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:27AM (#37176928)
Everyday men and women, which I take to mean middle class, aren't a threat or power base in modern Russia.

They don't have voting power.

They don't have demonstration power.

They don't have access to mass media and free speech.

Short of outright rioting, there's little they can do that matters to the Russian government.

Which means than in a trade-off between {what the people want} and {what those with power want}, the people are going to be ignored.

> (and even has no problem with them exporting that wealth abroad)

"...discuss reintroducing some capital controls to help prop up the struggling rouble."

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/aug/16/putin-meeti...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Saturday August 19, 2023 @08:36AM (#37188136)
Ironically, today the idea of reintroducing capital controls was rejected, officially, "because it was obvious that people will quickly find ways around it anyway". Simply put, there is no need to further increase already terrible level of corruption by introducing another useless but corruption-inducing regulation.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by vkou on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:04PM (#37177607)
> Soviet Union has collapsed while having whole lot more economic power and raw output of just about every industry, and was much more up to date technologically, but it deprived people of their basic instinct: to save and invest money and grow rich.

The Soviet Union pissed half of its economy away into its military, and the other half into its particular brand of waste, inefficiency, and corruption. It had a shortage of housing, basic consumer goods, and appliances - a shortage of material wealth, which became untenable by the time the fourth post-war decade rolled around, and everyone started wondering why the country has 12,000 nuclear warheads, but is still so goddamn poor.

If material wealth weren't the problem, or if Gorbachev didn't decide to stop imprisoning people for complaining about it, it would still be around today.

The world's three meals away from anarchy, if there were serious material shortages in the US today, nobody would give a crap about what monetary policy it follows, or whether or not you can save. King Bread is a ruler you swear fealty to, compared to him, King Dollar is something that comfortable philosophers build elaborate arguments and temples to.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by ethbr1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:15PM (#37178853)
Or as someone wryly observed: most French revolutions started when Paris ran out of bread.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by albatruss on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:48AM (#37172912)
> Still, human history shows us that money always wins.

Are you aware of what happened to the landlords in China or do you mean the landlords weren't human?

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by anovikov on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:55AM (#37172970)
It only shows us that current Chinese regime is a civilisational dead end. Also, by that point, they didn't have the money. China was overpopulated and did not have marginal income to pay them, and the productivity was overall too low. No one in China had money, so force ruled.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by Eisenstein on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:12AM (#37173591)
> It only shows us that current Chinese regime is a civilisational dead end.

Creating an all-encompassing historical 'rule' like 'money always wins' and then discounting evidence of a blatant counter-example is not generally a method that ends in good outcomes.

See: all major failed political movements based on an ideology that refused to adapt to conditions that did not line up with its dogma.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by vkou on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:43AM (#37172880)
> then remaining ones will emigrate and simply assign bounty for any head of CCP member based on the rank

This is a fantasy.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by modo_mario on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:03AM (#37173025)
>until the Party is eliminated

The party has 98 million members

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by tibbydudeza on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:01AM (#37173498)
The Soviet Communist Party also had millions of members, but we all know how that ended - hardly with a bang and a whimper.

Folks join not for ideology but for the social standing and future career prospects - you not going to be a senior bureaucrat or military officer if you ain't a member.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by worrycue on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:26AM (#37173193)
Jack Ma disappeared because he openly criticized the government.

The "leisure class" (of which many party members are part of) operate with impunity as long as they stay in the good graces of the party leadership.

You will only hear what the CCP wants you to hear. The rest of the "leisure class" flies by under the radar.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#37175873)
The ‘Jack Ma’s that are aligned with Xi have their corruption protected. It’s still politics.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by contravert on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:38AM (#37172839)
You definitely won't see anything like this in the US: https://www.businessinsider.com/china-tells-evergrande-found...

Like in 2008, bankers made a killing selling toxic products and socialized all the losses when everything came crashing down.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by worrycue on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:29AM (#37173215)
Actually it's the US government that made a killing with TARP loans and acquisitions.

Bankers lost their shirts in the whole thing - having to pay interest on those TARP loans or had to sell their shares to the government to get capital to survive.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jibe on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:11AM (#37175131)
List of banks acquired or bankrupted during the Great Recession

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banks_acquired_or_ba...

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bakuninsbart on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:34AM (#37172398)
From a quick google Evergrande (officially) has 2.4 trillion Yuan in debt, and 1.7 trillion Yuan in assets. Assets seem to have lost more than 20% of their value since 2019.

It is the largest one of the Chinese real estate developers, but there are a couple others that might break through the 1T Yuan mark.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by blackoil on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:43AM (#37172452)
That is 90 billion USD shortfall. Assuming lenders will have to take some haircut the no. is big but not something that will break the economy!! am I missing some nos.?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by OtherShrezzing on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:19AM (#37172714)
The lenders in the Chinese housing market are mostly Chinese citizens. In modern China, rather than buying a house, you buy a promise of a house, then the house builder builds it for you. The house builders though have these huge debts, and they've been using money from new purchases to construct their backlog of homes.

The $90bn outstanding is $90bn in outstanding housing construction, not just abstract debts to banks which could be written off or bailed out. Citizens will need to continue paying their mortgages on houses that don't (and won't) exist, which will cause some civil disquiet. Construction companies are going to have a shortfall of $90bn worth of work in their pipelines, which will mean mass layoffs. Entire large towns will go unbuilt.

Evergrande isn't the only one in this situation, it looks like a handful of large house-builders also have these uncompleted backlogs being paid for with new orders. The collapse of one might prompt the collapse of the others. As house-buyers become less confident that their house will ever exist, they'll stop buying new stock. When they stop buying new stock, the other house-builders collapse under the burden of their backlog of construction projects.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by tremon on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:19AM (#37173140)
That sounds suspiciously like a pyramid scheme: the only thing financing the current construction are payments to new construction. How did they get into this situation? By continuously selling under cost, or perhaps by siphoning off profits?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by NhanH on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:29AM (#37173209)
Land price keeps increasing caused this problem. You can just imagine land price to increase 50% YoY (hypothetical number) and you will understand the situation.

Basically you can not have enough cash on hand to purchase the next piece of land for your development, but you want to always plan for the next step.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by benterix on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:46AM (#37173345)
The first time it happens, you can call it a mistake. But second, third? Is int't it obvious that, seeing this trend, you should calculate the risk and factor in the land cost increase when pricing your offer?
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by NhanH on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:43AM (#37174345)
It's a different issue than what you are imaging. It's not that they sell the property for less than the relevant land cost, it's that the increase is too steep that they can't buy and build the next one without pre-selling the lot, the company just doesn't have enough cash.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jjoonathan on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:19AM (#37175219)
The magnitude of land speculation profits is not dictated by physics. If companies weren't able to pay what they did, the speculators (local governments in this case?) would live with less.

Developers compete with each other, so they will always take as much leverage as allowed, but the rules are adjustable by lenders. Lenders compete too, but they usually wind up backed by a central bank or other political entity, and that's the point at which changes can actually be made. Of course, there is no guarantee these changes won't create problems (Three Red Lines were a decade too late) but they can be made.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jjoonathan on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:16AM (#37175188)
Try doing that and someone who does take the leverage will simply outbid you for the land.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by reisse on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:41AM (#37173802)
The way OP described it, yes, it sounds like a ponzi, but in reality it's more like crowdfunding. First, the developer takes credit from a bank and uses own money to buy a land. Then, in order to start construction, the developer sells what is basically an obligation to build real estate and transfer the rights to buyer. These obligations are obviously cheaper than the expected price of real estate in the future, and also cheaper than already-constructed real estate now. The developer does not sell all the future real estate at once, because as the time goes by, and construction comes closer to a finish, the obligations become more expensive - it sells only the amount necessary to fund the next step of construction. After the construction is finished, developer sells leftover real estate with a markup big enough to finance its next project.

When the housing market is good, this scheme brings real estate costs down, because you can buy cheaper "not-yet-build" flats or houses, and the developer can seek funding without overpaying on the bank loans. But if the housing market tanks, the development freezes, and the first buyers take a loss. I don't know about China, but in some countries such obligations are mandatory insured from the default, so people can get at least some of their money back. In others buyers are left with a piece of land with unfinished building.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bombcar on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:25AM (#37173187)
This sounds ponzi schemic.
Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bobthepanda on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:57PM (#37183782)
That’s because it is.

China lacks a safe financial system that the ordinary person can invest in, the way that an American can park funds in an index fund and expect a reasonable rate of return. (The Shanghai and Hong Kong indices are not as healthy as the general economy.) It also lacks generous pension schemes like those in Europe. So part of the reason this is so bad is because most Chinese citizens put their nest eggs in real estate, and now the bubble has popped.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by hnfong on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:25PM (#37190379)
If you think the S&P500 and NASDAQ in recent years merely gives a "reasonable rate of return" you'll realize that there really aren't any other economies with a "safe financial system". Most markets don't have that level of growth.

The Chinese predisposition to invest in real property is much more cultural (and irrational) than what you suggest. The Chinese stock market is actually much more rational in this regard as for quite a while you could buy Chinese real estate stocks with pennies on the dollar, price to book ratios much less than one. Traders know the real estate bubble is going to burst sooner or later and the stock market priced this in. The real estate market which mostly consists of individual buyers didn't quite get the memo until recently.

Speaking personally, in Chinese circles, the social pressure buy an expensive apartment is honestly overwhelming, and it's not because people knew that the property market was a good investment, it was just something they thought a respectable person should do once they earned some money. Family members without any financial literacy kept thinking I was an idiot for holding FAANG stocks instead of buying an apartment. AFAICT I'm the only person in my social circle (including people who should have known better) that has avoided the recent property slump (in Hong Kong) by steadfastly refusing to enter the property market at its height a couple years ago. It's nice to not have people nagging me about it now.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bobthepanda on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:33PM (#37192873)
I don't disagree with any of that. Most of the other developed countries though have some kind of government or corporate (in the case of Japan) safety net that China lacks. The only example that I'm aware of that lacks either is South Korea, which has extremely high elder poverty rates compared to OECD peers.

I guess the word I was looking for to describe the Chinese financial system is 'immature.' It is unfortunately not uncommon for some Chinese firm to get delisted for accounting fraud or some other type of impropriety, so investing in the indexes is a worse idea than it is in many other countries. And then there's all the marketing of dubious financial products that people inevitably lose their savings on and protest; before people swarming the Evergrande HQ demanding their money it was P2P lending and many other scams.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by bobthepanda on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:01AM (#37172595)
One is that apparently a bunch of suppliers and contractors for their projects have not been paid for a while, so those will default or go bankrupt as well, and cascade further down the economy.

The other thing is that Evergrande sold mostly through presales so now there are all those paid for but unfinished apartment blocks.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by misja111 on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:11AM (#37174567)
> .. and 1.7 trillion Yuan in assets

Note that this is the book value. Probably based on some valuation from years ago and only minimally adjusted, mean while property prices have crashed.

Re:China’s property giant Evergrande files for bankruptcy pr... by jncfhnb on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:45AM (#37174890)
If you have trillions on the balance sheet, then you have trillions in assets, funded by either debt or equity. In this case clearly debt.

It is confusing why you say “use balance this way” because it is a “balance sheet”. You can’t pull the word balance out individually.