News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by cypherpunks01 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:49PM (#36994462)
Why are folks trying to prove that this material is a superconductor in roundabout ways, like levitation, dimagnetism, etc? What is the reason they don't just test to see if electrical current flows without resistance? Surely there is something I am missing here.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by httpz on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:07PM (#36994598)
With the current fabrication process, they're only getting a chunk with LK-99 particles sprinkled in. Since nobody yet knows how to fabricate a pure chunk of LK-99, it'll be hard to measure the true resistance of LK-99.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by appplication on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:53PM (#36995298)
Thank you, this is the best explanation I’ve heard for why it’s so hard of measure.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by hgrbrm on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:23AM (#36996575)
How do you explain the almost three orders of magnitude drop in resistance in Fig. 6d in one of the original articles ( https://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12037.pdf ) with a few LK-99 particles sprinkled here an there? There must be a current path along which more than 99.8% of the material is in the supposed superconducting state. So the particles almost touch but not quite yet?

I think the more likely explanation is that the particles do touch each other but the interface is not superconductive. In other words, it is a polycrystalline material, and most of it is LK-99, but the grain boundaries are not a very good conductor. In conventional superconductors grain boundaries don't disrupt superconductivity because they are 3D superconductors, but in this allegedly 1D superconductor the superconducting channels in most cases don't meet at the grain boundaries, so the current has to overcome the resistance of some material that is almost an insulator.

If that is the case it will be difficult to produce a material that is macroscopically superconducting. But I hope researchers will be able to make single crystals that are large enough for resistance measurements so that finally it can be determined if this material is a superconductor or not. For practical uses the best result that can be achieved with this material may be a metal-LK-99 composite where the LK-99 particles lower the resistivity of the metal by 50-90%.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by adrian_b on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:40AM (#36996726)
I believe that with the synthesis method proposed by the Korean team, i.e. by the chemical reaction between a certain kind of lead sulfate with copper phosphide, the chances of progress are slim.

The Korean team appears to have been stuck for several years by the lack of reproducibility of this synthesis method. While it was a great discovery that has shown that this material must have some very interesting properties, perhaps even superconductivity at ambient temperature and pressure, in order to be able to measure its properties and be able to evaluate the possible practical applications, a much more precise method for enforcing the desired crystal structure is required, than mixing powders and baking them into a ceramic.

Perhaps such a method for producing samples with deterministic properties would be to develop first a method to grow monocrystals of the special kind of lead phosphate that forms the base crystal structure, maybe by drawing the crystals from melt.

Once monocrystals of this kind of lead phosphate are available, they could be doped with copper, e.g. by ion implantation. By controlling and varying the parameters of the process, e.g. the angle of incidence and the velocity of the ions and the thermal profile used for annealing, it is likely that reproducible samples can be produced.

By this method it would be possible to produce only thin layers of LK-99, but that should be enough to enable the characterization of the material.

Moreover, because LK-99 is very fragile, it is unlikely that it could be used to make cables or coils. Practical uses where LK-99 would be deposited as thin films are much more likely.

As an alternative to ion implantation, which might be able to produce thicker layers, perhaps once monocrystals of the base lead phosphate are available it may be possible to develop some method of chemical vapor deposition, to grow epitaxially a layer of LK-99 over the base crystal.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by JRKrause on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:11PM (#37002826)
Drawing from melt to achieve a consistent crystal orientation was my first thought as well.

Looking at the Griffin paper, the Pb(2) site is described as being 1.08eV 'more energetically favorable'. I am having trouble understanding what this means.

Years back I did MOCVD semiconductor fabrication research, I never reached a mastery of it but I am still trying to leverage that understanding here.

During growth, adatoms that incorporate into proper crystal lattice locations enter a lower energy state compared to those in imperfect locations. The energy state is lower in the sense that it requires more energy to remove them from that location. Hence careful control of temperature allows you to selectively favor incorporation into these low energy locations e.g. choose a temperature high enough to remove adatoms from 'imperfect' locations but low enough to not remove them from 'perfect' (low energy) locations.

So when the author says 'energetically favorable' am I to understand this means the Pb(2) location represents a lower energy state (i.e. more difficult to remove Cu from this location) or the opposite? Or something else entirely?

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by snovv_crash on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:02PM (#37004357)
Even thin films would enable highly efficient antenna-on-chip designs.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by httpz on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:37AM (#36997164)
>Most likely, the material LK99 as reported in [1-3] is a heterophase structure, with co-existent non-superconducting constituents. This may yield superconducting droplets surrounded by nonsuperconducting material...

https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01723

>In fact, I find that Cu on this Pb(2) is 1.08 eV more energetically favorable than Cu on the Pb(1) site, suggesting possible difficulties in robustly obtaining Cu substituted on the Pb(1) site.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16892

The paper from Dr. Griffin at LBNL suggests copper atoms have to be placed in a specific (but less likely) position in the molecule to result in the desired flat band characteristic. Also, the original authors and the labs who were able to replicate LK-99 are reporting they had to make multiple batches to even find a tiny piece that shows levitation. This suggests that you just have to be very lucky to produce a sample with high enough concentration of LK-99 to observe levitation.

If we can somehow confirm that LK-99 is truly a room temperature superconductor, billions of dollars of R&D fund will pour in to improve the fabrication process. When the first transistor was invented, people probably weren't imagining that we'll be mass producing them in nanometer scale in the future. Or maybe LK-99 will be stuck in a lab like graphene. Who knows?

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by gitfan86 on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:28AM (#36999036)
The good news is that we should know within a few weeks if rock surgery is effective. If that works they can increase the purity and sample size without needing to find a new creation process
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:59AM (#36999349)
There are a ton of suggestions floating around already on how the efficiency could be improved and some of those are very clever and involve using the superconducting properties of the individual grains to help sort them out from the bulk material.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by DoctorOetker on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:10PM (#37004443)
From a purely scientific angle, so presumably less amenable to mass production, why doesn't anyone use FT-ICR mass spectrometers to assemble say a unit cell?

There is a good classic primer on FT-ICR, mostly focused on analysis (mass spectrometry) but also mentioning activation energies for reactions and measurement of kinetics etc.

https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/chemistry/research/oconnor/oco...

If you dunk a bunch of chemicals (for simplicity think wet chemistry) in a vial, all reactions and side reactions are simultaneously occuring, so one has little control over what happens on an atomic scale.

FT-ICR can be used to observe the state AND to manipulate the state. Its like having a compact particle collider, but instead of the high (TeV) energy in CERN etc. its just chemical energy levels.

It happens in high vacuum, so low densities of species, hence not amenable to mass production.

But the instrument is both eyes and hands: one can identify the frequencies corresponding to each ionized molecule, and selectively energize or de-energize specific species to encourage or prevent main and competing reactions, by pumping or damping specific frequencies.

One may build up a molecule in elementary steps and eject finished molecules. Those steps can occur at the same time in the same vessel. Its like having a miniature digitally controlled chemical plant, without having to redo all the pipework if you decide to use a different pathway here or there.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by WhiteNoiz3 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @11:06AM (#37012738)
Maybe a dumb question, but could you grind them up and separate out the superconducty bits with a magnet or would that destroy the effect?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dontwearitout on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:23PM (#36994706)
My understanding is that synthesis of the exactly right crystal structure is very hard (for every 10 lead atoms, 1 - the exact right one - needs to be substituted with copper), so the samples are small and inhomogeneous. As a result measuring resistivity won't be illuminating until large amounts of perfect material can be produced.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by octacat on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:56PM (#37005768)
kinda like with Graphene, cool material, hard to produce.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by caconym_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:53PM (#36994490)
I have heard people much more knowledgeable than me say that measuring true zero resistance is actually quite difficult and takes some degree of specialized equipment, especially with such small samples. That may be part of it.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:02PM (#36994555)
Just getting the probes to connect reliably is tricky. depending on how large the superconducting features are it may be anywhere from just difficult to next to impossible to do accurately (for instance, if the size of the superconducting features is smaller than the probe size).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by balaji1 on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:22AM (#36995784)
so none of the previous more esoteric superconductors were ever measure for zero resistance?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by whimsicalism on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:54AM (#36995957)
They were, but they had more time to resolve the difficulties
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by scarmig on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:03AM (#36996009)
They were. E.g. see here for a major, good paper announcing a novel class of superconductors:

https://sci-hub.ru/https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007...

The difference now is that we're seeing a premature preprint being replicated in real time.

Even in that paper, the authors note: "The way the samples have been prepared seems to be of crucial importance: Michel et al. [21] obtained a single-phase perovskite by mixing the oxides of La and Cu and BaCOa in an appropriate ratio and subsequent annealing at 1,000 ~ in air. We also applied this annealing condition to one of our samples, obtained by the decomposition of the corresponding oxalates, and found no superconductivity." And you can see that in their resistivity/temperature graph of samples prepared using different protocols.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by pyrale on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:37AM (#36997162)
> a premature preprint

Considering how that preprint has sparked interest in other research institutions and multiplied the resources allocated to the problem, I would say this publication was not premature, it's most other research results that are late.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by squeaky-clean on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:28PM (#37004696)
The paper was leaked early. The team wanted more time to get more attempts at producing it and improving their yield. The paper also wasn't generally up to their writing standards. It's essentially an early draft that was leaked.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by gus_massa on Saturday August 05, 2023 @10:33AM (#37012382)
It looks like this worked in this material for years, perhaps the would have taken a few more years.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by caconym_ on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:17PM (#37002918)
I'm not sure how you're getting that from my comment.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by frisco on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:57AM (#36995972)
Right, if our best regular conductors (used in your ohmmeter) are ~10^-8 and superconductivity is (by convention) less than 10^-11, one can see right away the simple regular methods won’t work and some cleverness is needed.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by someplaceguy on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:55AM (#36996361)
> superconductivity is (by convention) less than 10^-11,

Ah, so you're saying that superconductivity is not actual zero resistance, but something close to it, and in fact only a factor of 1000x less resistive than the best conductor?

If that is so, this is something that I had previously thought would make a lot more sense to me.

But in that case it's not intuitive to me how SMES is possible with a 0% discharge rate. Shouldn't a significant fraction of the electrons looping around the coils be lost after many loops? (I know very little about electricity, as you can probably tell, never mind superconductors).

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by mort96 on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:05AM (#36996449)
No, I believe it's literally zero but we don't have a measurement apparatus with infinite precision so we need some cut-off.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by someplaceguy on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:14AM (#36996517)
Thanks, that makes sense.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fooker on Saturday August 05, 2023 @04:30PM (#37016022)
It's only literal zero for superconductors close to 0K temperature.

For high temperature superconductors (50-70+K), it's not literal zero for superconducting mechanisms discovered so far.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by crote on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:51AM (#36996808)
The conductors of your ohmmeter are not that important, though. You can work around that by using four-terminal sensing, and you can of course also calibrate your probes by directly touching them together. Even if your ohmmeter conductors have a resistance of several ohm, you could still get an accurate measurement if your tool has a high enough resolution.

A bigger issue is going to be sample size. A 1mm-diameter 1mm-long rod of silver has a resistance of about 20 μΩ (or 2e-5) at room temperature. That's already getting tricky to measure with lab-grade equipment without pushing insane currents through it, let alone anything even smaller. If you want to measure a 1m-diameter 1m-long silver rod (which would be 0.02μΩ or 2e-8) you could just push a few thousand amps through it and reliably measure that using a household multimeter in the mV range - but do that with a small sample and it'll evaporate.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @09:00AM (#36999359)
> Even if your ohmmeter conductors have a resistance of several ohm, you could still get an accurate measurement if your tool has a high enough resolution.

Not that low in range though, you will end up seeing thermal noise that dwarfs your measurement.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dclowd9901 on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:59AM (#37000940)
How about the wires connected to your probes? Or the internal electronics that are used to gauge resistance? How do you work around those?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:47AM (#37001617)
Calibration. But electric fields across wiring in such sensitive applications is a real problem.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by paulmd on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:09PM (#37001927)
simply build the material into a device that cannot work without superconduction and then see whether it does ;)
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Daneel_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:53PM (#36994495)
It’s difficult to rule out external factors - a badly attached probe could also result in zero resistance for example.

Showing diamagnetism is one of the least error-prone ways to demonstrate the superconductor effect.

That’s my understanding anyway.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:00PM (#36994536)
> a badly attached probe could also result in zero resistance for example

No, a badly attached probe would usually show a larger resistance, not a smaller one. That's actually the easiest error to make, making improper contact with the sample. The resistance is measured indirectly using a reference current. So you'd measure a higher resistance or a break rather than zero if a probe were not attached correctly (unless the two voltage probes are touching but that would normally speaking be spotted).

The diamagnetism is simply easier to verify using an impure or small sample.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Daneel_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:16PM (#36995099)
Glad to be corrected, thank you.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by voidmain on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:19PM (#36995115)
It's apparently hard to measure zero vs extremely low resistance with the two probe setup you are imagining (I guess because the probes and wires aren't superconducting, so most of the resistance in the circuit is not in the sample). The graphs I have seen are all made with a four probe setup [1], where a constant current is run through the outer probe pair and the voltage across the inner pair is measured. If the inner probes have contact issues, the voltage (and inferred resistance) drops, potentially to zero.

[1] https://www.ni.com/docs/en-US/bundle/ni-daqmx/page/measfunds...

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by applied_heat on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:13AM (#36995406)
That’s what he said. You inject a known current and measure the voltage drop across the item you want to measure the resistance of, and then use ohms law
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by SV_BubbleTime on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:35AM (#36995528)
And what he saying, and you weren’t listening to is it all your testing equipment is introducing resistance.

You can mesaure current by electrical fields, but have the same issues as before. Your testing equipment and your very tiny sample sizes.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fnordpiglet on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:22AM (#36996115)
I sort of don’t get this either. If your testing equipment is introducing resistance can you not “tare” or calibrate your measurements by measuring the equipments current flow in a direct circuit between probes to determine its base resistance then introduce your sample and measure the difference? The resistance in a serial circuit is additive, no?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by proto_lambda on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:02AM (#36996423)
The parasitic resistance will be orders of magnitude larger than your sample resistance, any detector capable of detecting the sample resistance would be completely swamped out by it.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:29AM (#37001370)
They are measuring voltage, not resistance (the resistance is computed). It's impossible to measure resistance without current and some voltage across the resistance, and while the parasitic effects are small the resistance we're talking about (and hence the voltage across that resistance) is so small that second order effects introduced by the probe wires can have a real effect, for instance if the probe wires have a higher resistance that makes them more susceptible to electric fields, which in turn would show up as a voltage. So this is anything but trivial.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:41AM (#36997636)
If you pick your reference current properly this effect should be extremely small. It will have a little bit of effect but nothing that you should normally have to worry about.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:40AM (#36997629)
In a four probe setup you are measuring voltage, not resistance. But you are right that the measurement can still influence the results when the voltages measured are tiny.

The way to think of this is simple: you can't measure anything without subtle joining the circuitry that you are measuring and that has an effect on the properties of the circuit as a whole for which you have to compensate. In this case: the voltage measurement is going to consume a tiny bit of power and that is due to the resistance of the measurement apparatus even if it isn't in the main current path but a secondary one. But the people that do these kinds of measurements tend to be well aware of this and will pick their measurement gear and reference current to minimize the chances of that happening.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:37AM (#36997605)
I am not imagining a 'two probe' setup (see other comment in this thread).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fsckboy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:27PM (#36995151)
>No, a badly attached probe would usually show a larger resistance, not a smaller one.

if the area is small, couldn't it be "badly attached" directly to the other probe?

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:42AM (#36997639)
That could happen, but you'd have such a perfect zero across the whole temp range that I think any researcher worth their pay would spot the error.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by qnleigh on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:21AM (#36995773)
That's right. The standard way to measure resistance without being sensitive to contact resistance is called the four-terminal method, see (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-terminal_sensing). You drive a current using two outer wires, but then detect the voltage across the sample using a different pair of wires. You'll measure zero voltage if it's superconducting, since V=IR. Or if one of the probe wires became detached.

The first LK-99 paper used this method to claim zero resistivity, but people complained that if the inner probes lost contact, that would also be consistent with their data. This criticism doesn't totally make sense to me, since the apparent superconductivity came and went in the expected way as they changed an external magnetic field. I don't understand how a loose terminal could mimic that figure (I think it was in figure 1).

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fnordpiglet on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:29AM (#36996171)
It also doesn’t make sense to me because you would expect they didn’t just say “omg super conductivity!” on their first measurement and presumably measured more than once, verified connections, and generally assumed scrutiny would be high on any claim and (from what I’ve read of the history so far) the reason it’s from 1999 and published now is they didn’t believe it was real to begin with but believed it was a measurement mistake. This doesn’t mean others should be credulous and replication is crucial. But it seems to beggar reality to assume they made such an amateur mistake. I would assume outright fraud first.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by EvgeniyZh on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:28AM (#36997099)
One case in which you can see something similar to SC transition is percolation, where the sample is mix of regular metal and insulator, and you (accidentally) connect current contacts to metal but voltage probes to insulator [1]

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.05871

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by stolsvik on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:24AM (#36997495)
Don’t you also measure the current of the “inner probes” (the ones “driving a current”), to verify that you do have contact?!
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by VygmraMGVl on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:27PM (#37004689)
You drive current through the outer probes. The inner probes measure voltage and are not driven. When measuring non-zero resistance, you can vary the driving current to confirm the voltage you measure also varies linearly (ex thermal effects, capacitance of the material etc.). When measuring zero resistance, you can't distinguish vs a voltage probe error.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by 9991 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @10:36AM (#37012406)
Magnetic fields can move the probes.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:51PM (#36994477)
They do both. But measuring the resistance of something that is that small is super hard because it will be close to zero anyway even if it isn't superconducting. So a larger sample would give much more conclusive results.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by bhaney on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:53PM (#36994496)
It's difficult to produce a sample large enough and pure enough to have its resistance measured.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:02PM (#36994550)
Not an expert, but I would guess a direct measurement couldn't distinguish between a true superconductor and something with very very low resistance.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Zardoz84 on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:48AM (#36996306)
No. Any device to measuring resistence ALWAYS have a minimal value that can measure. They can never measure exactly zero ohms.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by ProjectArcturis on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:48AM (#37001642)
Isn't that exactly what I said?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by rendang on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:54PM (#36994499)
Purely speculating, but might it be easy to doubt resistance measurements by claiming that equipment was faulty or used incorrectly?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by postalrat on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:44PM (#36994871)
How would you prove there isn't any water in a cup?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by bagels on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:57PM (#36994974)
I didn't see any references to cups or water in these papers.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by postalrat on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:10PM (#36995065)
If you can't answer the question then you won't ever understand how to measure zero resistance.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by svnt on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:31PM (#36995174)
It's a limitation of the most basic approach to the problem (measuring resistance), but not a limitation of every approach (such as measuring current).

You can inject a current into a superconducting coil and take measurements of the resultant magnetic field as the current circles for an indefinite period of time. I'm not able to see how this approach analogizes to water in a cup.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by davrosthedalek on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:00PM (#37002668)
I don't think that works as advertised: Any measurement of the current will likely produce a magnetic field itself -- for example from the current in a Hall probe. This current will induct a small, opposite current into the superconducting coil. So the current will go down.

And even if not, what you would need is to measure the change of the field over time. This has finite resolution, so you can't distinguish no resistance from very very small resistance.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by svnt on Saturday August 05, 2023 @12:50PM (#37013924)
There are several tests that have been ongoing over decades doing exactly this. The small loss of current during measurement occurs, but you only engage with the field intermittently, and you can calculate approximately what the loss should be.

Yes it could be some tiny resistance, but the same issue occurs with the resolution/accuracy of the voltage or current measurement you would make.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by davrosthedalek on Saturday August 05, 2023 @11:29PM (#37018724)
Exactly my point. You cannot measure that the resistance is exactly zero, you can "only" give an upper bound. The upper bound depends on your approach, but no approach can give you a zero upper bound.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by svnt on Monday August 07, 2023 @12:11PM (#37036384)
This is always true, though, for any value.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by appplication on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:17AM (#36995427)
Would one method (assuming a pure sample) be to pass a high current through it and measure if it heats up? I know nothing about this, but that would be my first guess.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by moqmar on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:37AM (#36995870)
It will heat up, as the contact points & probes will have resistance, not sure if there are good ways to correct for that.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jonny_eh on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:56AM (#36996369)
If the material were an unshielded wire, spool it, and send a current through it and measure if the V/I/W drops off as you unspool it?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jadamson on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:29AM (#36996628)
But I did eat breakfast this morning?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fooker on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:04AM (#36996444)
That's a really good way to reason about the difficulties.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Zardoz84 on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:47AM (#36996300)
Because (like someone explained very well in another HW notice) you can't measure zero ohms. Any device to measure resistance ALWAYS would have a minimal value that can measure. It's far more easy to detect superconductivity using the weird things that does all superconductors in presence of magnetic fields (ie, levitation).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by hgomersall on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:14AM (#36996515)
Without being intentionally snarky, the same logic applies to measuring current and voltage. What is observed is an effect of zero resistance, not zero resistance itself (whatever that would mean).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by m3kw9 on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:26PM (#37005413)
The korean guy say this is a 1d superconductor (as opposed to 2d sheet or 3d, which means you would need a single line of superconducting molecules from end to end. Its likely why it doesn't float all the way as only parts of it has these and scattered all over the chunk of solid.

However, if they perfect 1d production, they can layer in a bunch of them to create a quasi 2d or 3d superconductor.