News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mrguyorama on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:24PM (#36911963)
People always bring up that "90% of US prisons are public so it's not a private prison problem" but those public prisons all contract out things like food and communication and monitoring and anything else that's possible to private companies.

Nobody should profit off of prison, period.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ROTMetro on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:52PM (#36912363)
Don't forget the per minute charge to use kiosk computers to send electronic communication with family, or the pay to use phone app for family members to get those same communications.

Or that you have to buy any medications sold in commissary from there and won't be given them at medical (which costs $5 a visit when you don't make $5 a month) like aspirin at the for profit commissary that buys from jacked up 'prison commissary' distributors and has a way shorter than what you buy in the store expiration date. Keep in mind you are not allowed to share 'medication' and that having expired 'medication' in your locker can be a shot (writeup, potential loss of good time, potential to have your security points increased and shipped to a higher security(i.e. less safe) prison).

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ForOldHack on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:52PM (#36915001)
$5 a visit, when they are making $0.33 and hour...more than two days labor to pay it all for a doctor visit. "One of the biggest differences between the incarceration systems of Norway and the USA is that Norway does not have large, centralized jails. Instead, Norway utilizes a system of small, community-based correctional facilities that focus on rehabilitation and reintegration into society." "Norway's prison system houses approximately three thousand offenders. Norway's prison system is renowned as one of the most effective and humane in the world. Norway does not instate capital punishment or life imprisonment." Seems U.S.A. has cruel and unusual punishment for prison health.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by nickff on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:53PM (#36912370)
>"Nobody should profit off of prison, period. "

What about the guards? Should they be volunteers? Should all services be provided by donation? Where do you draw the line? Should the government farm the food, ship it to the prison, and serve it? What about the clothing, beds, toilets, etc.?

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by gymbeaux on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:56PM (#36912430)
Well you’re definitely missing the spirit of the comment. Employees do not “profit” off of anything, it’s the other way around. I make a cent, BossMan makes a dollar, etc.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by Freedom2 on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:22PM (#36912763)
Agreed, GP is definitely not taking the comment with the most charitable interpretation.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by nickff on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:55PM (#36913896)
I am employing reductio ad absurdum to demonstrate the problem with the comment I replied to.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by misnome on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:58PM (#36914505)
No, you are being an unhelpful dick.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by nickff on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:04PM (#36913970)
Every supplier could say that about every customer.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by Avshalom on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:58PM (#36912468)
Yes, and if there aren't enough donations and volunteers we just close the prison and release the prisoners because obviously people didn't think it was that important.

I'm like 66% serious.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by hkt on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:52PM (#36913145)
That'd shift the cost of the prison system on to billionaires and conservatives..

I like it.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by conscion on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:55PM (#36912403)
Being paid for labor is not usually considered "profit".
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:12PM (#36913400)
If you're not profiting from your work you should find new work. The point of work is to profit. Or has profit been redefined by Marxists with some new "it's not profit when we do it" BS definition?
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:26PM (#36913580)
I'm sure most people who are employed make money from their employment but they're also not running a business which has "costs", "revenue" and, hopefully, "profit". They enter a contract with such a business which will treat the individual's salary as a "cost" which lessens the "profit" from the "revenue".
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by dragonwriter on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:30PM (#36913622)
> has profit been redefined by Marxists with some new "it's not profit when we do it" BS definition?

Profit as the excess retained by or on behalf of capital owners is not a definition created by Marxists, using it for other things which are seen as loosely similar to that central goal of the most important property relation in capitalism is a newer, expansive, metaphorical use.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @08:30PM (#36915380)
> Profit as the excess retained by or on behalf of capital owners

> capital owners

There it is, the "not when we do it" qualification. Just as I suspected, very predictable. Profit is when you're bringing in more money than you're spending. Whether you are labor or a "capital owner", profit is profit. When an animal gets more calories from their food than they spent to get it, even that is profit.

Here's wiktionary's definitions:

> (accounting, economics) Total income or cash flow minus expenditures. The money or other benefit a non-governmental organization or individual receives in exchange for products and services sold at an advertised price.

There's no "capital owners" qualification in this or any other common definition: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/profit https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/profit

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by erik_seaberg on Friday July 28, 2023 @08:33PM (#36915408)
Aren’t wages typically taxed differently than profits?
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @09:33PM (#36915845)
If a worker's wages exceed his expenditures (housing, commute, food, bills, etc), then he's profiting. The tax code doesn't own the word.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by OkayPhysicist on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:53PM (#36913862)
If you view a profit on a supply basis, as "the difference between the sold value of a good and the price to produce it", then somebody living paycheck to paycheck is, by definition, not profiting off of their labor. The cost of living, and thus be able to produce labor, is approximately the same as the amount they're being paid.

If you view profit on a demand basis, profit is the difference between what the the seller values the good at and the value the buyer places on the good. In that regard, labor is never sold at a profit for the laborer: companies only purchase labor that they can use to produce more value than they pay for it.

Framed another way, if the value of labor is the price the market is willing to pay for it, then employment is almost always a negative exchange for the worker. The value of someone's labor is the price that employers are willing to pay for it, and the price employers are willing to pay for the labor is greater than the wage the employee receives (because employing somebody is more expensive than just paying them a wage).

All told, unless your definition of "profit" is indistinguishable from "money changes hands", workers don't profit from their labor.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:53PM (#36914462)
Well yeah if you're treading water living paycheck to paycheck, then you're not making a profit. But anybody in that situation with an opportunity to make more money will jump at it, because the idea is to make more money than you're spending, e.g. to earn a profit.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by flangola7 on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:07PM (#36912581)
Wages are generally not considered profit in business economic contexts.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by Avshalom on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:55PM (#36912415)
I've mentioned it before but Ruth Wilson Gilmore points out that prisons form a system of rural jobs programs. Tying together the 1980s farm crisis and the rise in incarceration

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farm_crisis#1980s_crisis

https://archive.org/details/goldengulagpriso00gilm

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by hgsgm on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:37PM (#36912966)
The Constitution has a word for those kinds of "jobs".
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by Avshalom on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:53PM (#36913160)
I don't mean the prison(er) labor. Prisons employee not just guards but doctors and nurses and groundskeepers and secretaries, plumbers, electricians, HR, food service companies... Just like colleges or military bases, prisons are a source of jobs for the surrounding area and can be the only thing keeping them even vaguely economically viable.

Making the slave labor illegal wouldn't get rid of most of the economic/political incentive for prisons.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by CPLX on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:15PM (#36912680)
It’s even worse than that, at least in New York.

The prisons also counted all the people in them as residents, for apportionment of votes, money, and so on.

You would have a rural county where 6,000 people, including 1,500 prison guards, actually live. And then 6,000 prisoners.

Which would count as 12,000 people in terms of congressional and state representation. But only half of them are actually allowed to vote.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by hgsgm on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:37PM (#36912971)
Ah, the Five-Fifths Compromise.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ForOldHack on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:32PM (#36914825)
The very literal and real truth is that The U.S.A. from the constitution down is a White supremacist country, and it continues to this day. Prison Labor = Slavery, and the Republicans are monopolizing this to their benefit. Until this is fixed... we remain a racist country. We need to continue to progress towards equality, because if we do not, or children will, and will hate us for it. We fought World War I, the War to and all Wars over Fascism, We fought World War II, to end Fascism, and now... we forget. Its shameful, and it will become embarrassing.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by chimeracoder on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:51PM (#36913142)
> It’s even worse than that, at least in New York.

This is known as prison gerrymandering, although in New York it was made illegal in 2010[0].

However, it's still legal in many other states[1].

[0] https://www.prisonersofthecensus.org/NYS_A9710-D.html

[1] https://www.prisonersofthecensus.org/models/chart.html

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ImPostingOnHN on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:53PM (#36913164)
The counting makes sense: prisoners, too, require the resources of the locality in which they reside, even if they can't vote at the moment

They should be able to vote though

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by jstarfish on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:35PM (#36913681)
The lifelong ban does seem arbitrarily harsh and engineered for abuse (anybody subject to taxation should retain voting rights); who benefits from this and how? (It's been 20+ years since my last civics class.)

Racism was the historic angle-- but even if you target a black community and make felons of all the men, they would only comprise a minority of voters in a white district, and it just reduces the number of all eligible voters in an all-black district. Is this a local politics thing (school funding, etc.)?

Or is it just a way to suppress voting by as much of the Left as possible?

The Right are the ones who define all these laws. The Left are the ones who seem positioned to run afoul of them (pro-drugs, pro-abortion, pro-prostitution, etc.), then lose their ability to influence change.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by dragonwriter on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:45PM (#36913780)
> Racism was the historic angle-- but even if you target a black community and make felons of all the men, they would only comprise a minority of voters in a white district, and it just reduces the number of all eligible voters in an all-black district.

Reducing the number of voters by eliminating a disfavored class from representation while retaining the political power of apportionment that counts the disebfranchised citizens was the whole point of the 3/5 compromise, and mass criminalization plus felon disenfranchisement is its direct replacement.

Also, you maybe want to consider the effect on a mixed-race district where, say, a sufficient minority of whites are sympathetic to black interests that together they would, before selective disenfrnachisement, constitute a majority.

> Is this a local politics thing (school funding, etc.)?

That, too, but its largely a federal politics thing.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by jstarfish on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:13PM (#36914060)
> Reducing the number of voters by eliminating a disfavored class from representation while retaining the political power of apportionment that counts the disebfranchised citizens was the whole point of the 3/5 compromise

Thanks-- I [think I] see where you're going but still don't get where this ends. You have a district with a minority of people who can't vote. Yet they are counted among the population.

This directly suppresses presidential votes, but what besides the House benefits from an inflated population of non-voters?

> you maybe want to consider the effect on a mixed-race district where, say, a sufficient minority of whites are sympathetic to black interests that together they would, before selective disenfrnachisement, constitute a majority.

The thought crossed my mind, but the only example I'm familiar with is Atlanta-- a few blue droplets on a red ocean, yet the state is currently represented by two Democratic senators, and the House is split. There's something weird about this but I'm not a political strategist enough to understand what's going on here. Is this where population matters-- density of the metro area outweighing the rest of the state?

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by dragonwriter on Friday July 28, 2023 @09:02PM (#36915623)
> This directly suppresses presidential votes, but what besides the House benefits from an inflated population of non-voters?

Presidential voting power (for the same reason as the House; well, really, as a direct consequence of apportionment of the House).

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by lostdog on Saturday July 29, 2023 @12:14AM (#36916834)
In the 2020 election in Georgia, 49.24% voted for one party and 49.49% voted for the other. The "blue droplets in a red ocean" is very obvious: the ocean has very few people.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by dragonwriter on Saturday July 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#36921211)
> The thought crossed my mind, but the only example I'm familiar with is Atlanta-- a few blue droplets on a red ocean, yet the state is currently represented by two Democratic senators, and the House is split. There's something weird about this but I'm not a political strategist enough to understand what's going on here. Is this where population matters-- density of the metro area outweighing the rest of the state?

Yes, Atlanta metro is about 60% of the population of the state of Georgia.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by jrussino on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:16PM (#36914091)
> 12,000 people in terms of congressional and state representation. But only half of them are actually allowed to vote

This is egregious.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ForOldHack on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:26PM (#36914780)
The Republicans did this for decades, until they could start building prisons in their districts, then they went into hyper-drive, moving as many prisons into Republican districts as they could, and its well documented, and it is completely egregious.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by bhickey on Friday July 28, 2023 @08:04PM (#36915111)
It gets even worse. For purposes of apportionment prisoners are counted in their place of incarceration rather than their domicile. New York lost a congressional seat by 89 people. How many New Yorkers are incarcerated at Fort Dix?
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by cltby on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:41PM (#36914352)
If illegal aliens count for apportionment, why shouldn't prisoners?
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by tehwebguy on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:51PM (#36916695)
Absolutely unconscionable to ever deny someone their right to vote, even during a prison term. There are no exceptions!
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by eastbound on Saturday July 29, 2023 @03:02AM (#36917657)
If you let criminals vote, you’ll end up with (place your most hated political figure) elected.
Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by lexlash on Saturday July 29, 2023 @06:17AM (#36918688)
So a politician will be elected then?

Snark aside, this is how you systematically disenfranchise minorities. See Florida.

Democracy doesn’t mean only the “deserving” get a vote. In theory.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:10PM (#36913363)
If nobody sells food to prisons, then what will the prisoners eat? Do you propose that prisons be run as farms where prisoners are made to produce their own food? I've heard that prisons in South Korea work that way, but I've also heard that prisons in South Korea are brutal by even American standards, such that the US Military has an agreement with the South Korean government that any US servicemen put into Korean prisons will be fed more than a starvation diet. Apparently conditions in Korean prisons are such that an agreement like that is necessary.

Maybe, prisons buying food isn't the problem with American prisons.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by jstarfish on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:49PM (#36913820)
> Apparently conditions in Korean prisons are such that an agreement like that is necessary.

I don't know the current state of them, but you can tour Seodaemun prison (operational 1908-1987; it's now a museum/memorial). They make no attempt to hide the fact that the conditions were historically even worse than you're describing-- basically concentration camps sans gas chambers. Food was watery gruel, toilets were rat-infested holes in the ground, etc.

Visit in the winter when it's 30F out for the full experience; the prisoners weren't given adequate clothing for the cold themselves so even bundled up to the teeth you can appreciate their misery.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by FirmwareBurner on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:11PM (#36914048)
>US servicemen put into Korean prisons

Out of curiosity, how many servicemen did the US allow to get into foreign prisons?

I know at least two highly mediatized cases of US servicemen committing murder in Europe[1][2] but were instantly airlifted to the US before they could be arrested by the local police, so they couldn't be trialed and jailed in the EU and instead got to walk free back home.

If the US stepped in for them in Europe, I doubt they won't do the same in Korea.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1998_Cavalese_cable_car_crash

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teo_Peter#Death

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:50PM (#36914436)
The American soldier who recently defected to North Korea had previously been in a South Korean prison for two months for assault: https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/07/18/us-soldier-who-fled-...

Here is a 2007 article in Stars and Stripes (USDoD newspaper) about the special treatment American service-members receive in South Korean prisons: https://www.stripes.com/news/u-s-servicemembers-treated-diff...

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by FirmwareBurner on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:09PM (#36914613)
>The American soldier who recently defected to North Korea

Wait, what?!

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by mcpackieh on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:44PM (#36914931)
Just last week, the first such defection in 40 years I believe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travis_King

He was meant to board a plane back to America where he would be thrown out of the military, but he evidently decided to jump out of the frying pan and into the fire.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by FirmwareBurner on Saturday July 29, 2023 @04:33AM (#36918174)
Reading through his list of "achievements" of always getting into trouble, that looks like a person suffering from mental illnesses.

I suspect the north will keep him as a bargaining chip to exchange for something later on.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by arp242 on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:22PM (#36913528)
But the prison still gets to set the policy, no? Like how many minutes people can call, and what they can charge?

"Nobody should profit off of prison, period" is very simplistic: the electricity company makes a profit; the store selling bread, sausages, milk, potatoes, and whatnot makes a profit; the supplier selling books makes a profit; AT&T will make a profit from the phone lines regardless, just as they make a profit off phone lines to offices, etc. etc.

The problem isn't private companies: it's the prison officials. How much of that revenue goes back to the prison? A substantial amount I bet. That's why they do it; that a private company is involved isn't all that important. Yes, it's exploitive and counter-productive, but few seem to care as prisons are for evil people who deserve to be assraped on a daily basis anyway, and anything more than bread & water is a luxury.

This fully fits with the general attitude that exists in the US towards criminals. This is a country that puts 9-year olds in full leg and arm shackles for stealing bubble gum[1] (putting a kid like that in court is already dubious), and there are plenty of examples ranging from the existence of the "innocence project" to all the drug tests for employment, etc. etc. What is wrong with you people?

[1]: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/02/courts-shackle-...

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by ForOldHack on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:34PM (#36914839)
No, the Prisons do not, its the sheriffs. Follow the money.

https://www.prisonpolicy.org/phones/

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by P_I_Staker on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:27PM (#36913593)
Right, the criminal industrial complex is a problem, just not private prisons... they are, I just mean insofar as being a significant factor today.

We're happy to send people to public prisons, and they're not that many private ones.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by nonameiguess on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:13PM (#36914061)
I'm sure it's a multifactorial problem, but I have a hard time seeing direct profit as being the original cause of this issue, as opposed to a parasitic growth that developed on top of it. The core issue has to be the basic voter fear and attitude that so harshly punished any politician of the 80s and 90s who was seen to be "soft on crime." Misdemeanors converted to felonies. Mandatory minimum sentences were introduced. Police got free military surplus gear and became more of a hostile occupying force than part of the community.

There's discord between the discussion in this thread and discussion any time the subject of San Francisco policing comes up. They're too soft and let crime happen. They ignore shoplifters. People are just shitting in the streets. Okay, well what do you want the police to do? It seems the options are you either kill petty shoplifters and homeless people or you send them to prison. But then the same people will complain about exploding prison populations.

Am I lacking in creativity? Because there are three options I can see:

- Create a society where even unskilled, somewhat antisocial people who went through great trauma as children do well enough that they don't turn to crime, and actually treat those who are so mentally ill that they'll be long-term homeless virtually no matter what.

- Allow some amount of non-lethal crime to happen and live with it.

- Put massive amounts of people in prison.

It seems like voters have converged on the third as their preference, not because they're being brainwashed by private prisons and corrupt corrections officer unions, but because the first option is too expensive and the second option would mean they need to see human shit and broken windows when they're walking around the city. At least prisons tend to be in the middle of the desert or swamp where it's out of sight, someone else's problem.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by jstarfish on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:29PM (#36914240)
We used to let people do military service as an alternative sentence for minor infractions, but that led to a lot of antisocial behavior in an institution that requires order to function (it stopped after Vietnam). There's a reason why when Russia did the same thing recently, the prisoners were used as first-wave cannon fodder and left the actual fighting to Wagner...criminals tend to lack discipline.

There's room for a middle option between passivity and slavery/prison. Some people need to be wards of somebody, so set up an institution like the military (endless boot camp, or the mining-town setups of old) and use that for alternate sentencing. Last chance: you get training, a mandatory job, shitty housing, and limited freedom (shore leave/weekend passes). It's not ideal, so work the program as long as you need to and GTFO. Fuck it up and next time you will go to prison.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by fnimick on Saturday July 29, 2023 @04:04AM (#36917996)
The first option is not actually more expensive than the cost of how we handle it now. E.g. we could just give homeless people housing for less than the cost we already spend on homeless services.

The problem is the "they don't deserve things for free" mindset. It's even here in this thread too, I had to pay for education, why should prisoners get it? This vindictive thinking is all over HN, just a couple days ago a top comment was wondering why we allow them to "infest" cities like they're some sort of disease rather than other people. If you ran on a dog whistled "kill the homeless" platform, you'd get a lot of voter support.

Re:Free prison phone calls boost family ties, rehabilitation by grecy on Friday July 28, 2023 @10:42PM (#36916281)
> Nobody should profit off of prison, period.

Of course they shouldn't, and they shouldn't profit off of healthcare, or higher education or a bunch of other things either.

Which one is actually going to get fixed?

None of them, because the goal is making money, and it's working really well.