I'm like 66% serious.
I like it.
Profit as the excess retained by or on behalf of capital owners is not a definition created by Marxists, using it for other things which are seen as loosely similar to that central goal of the most important property relation in capitalism is a newer, expansive, metaphorical use.
> capital owners
There it is, the "not when we do it" qualification. Just as I suspected, very predictable. Profit is when you're bringing in more money than you're spending. Whether you are labor or a "capital owner", profit is profit. When an animal gets more calories from their food than they spent to get it, even that is profit.
Here's wiktionary's definitions:
> (accounting, economics) Total income or cash flow minus expenditures. The money or other benefit a non-governmental organization or individual receives in exchange for products and services sold at an advertised price.
There's no "capital owners" qualification in this or any other common definition: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/profit https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/profit
If you view profit on a demand basis, profit is the difference between what the the seller values the good at and the value the buyer places on the good. In that regard, labor is never sold at a profit for the laborer: companies only purchase labor that they can use to produce more value than they pay for it.
Framed another way, if the value of labor is the price the market is willing to pay for it, then employment is almost always a negative exchange for the worker. The value of someone's labor is the price that employers are willing to pay for it, and the price employers are willing to pay for the labor is greater than the wage the employee receives (because employing somebody is more expensive than just paying them a wage).
All told, unless your definition of "profit" is indistinguishable from "money changes hands", workers don't profit from their labor.
What about the guards? Should they be volunteers? Should all services be provided by donation? Where do you draw the line? Should the government farm the food, ship it to the prison, and serve it? What about the clothing, beds, toilets, etc.?