News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jarjoura on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:44PM (#36829715)
If the promise of AI means I can do 1/2 the amount of work and maintain my high quality life, then I'm all for it.

However, every advancement that has come in the last 100 years that improved efficiency has only meant we're pushed to work more and do more. So I am now expected to do 2x the work.

If you're really dreaming for AI that can wipe-out entire classes of decent middle-class jobs in one big swing, don't forget that we're going to take down the world economy with it and it's going to be a very long recession where nobody will win.

Meanwhile, those lucky enough to have made it to the top will continue to horde all the profits.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by usednet on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:00PM (#36829882)
The logical conclusion that people don’t like to hear is that there will need to be a fundamental restructuring of the economy. AI will, in the not so distant future, eliminate the vast majority of jobs. The choice will then be between a socialized economy or barbarism.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by bushbaba on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:25PM (#36830115)
Totally disagree. You could have said the same of Industrial Revolution. Yet here we are living better lives from the technological breakthroughs.

AI will just usher the next industrial revolution of the modern era.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by diatone on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#36830181)
Worth pointing out, we live better lives not just from the technological breakthroughs, but also from the social movements that have brought us things like the 40-hour work week and keeping children from labour for a reasonable time. Which were direct responses to the Industrial Revolution.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by tmpz22 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:44PM (#36830282)
And we're starting to see the repeal of Labor laws in the US - newly passed or pending laws allow companies to hire children without work permits and allow children to work longer hours under more dangerous conditions in places like construction sites, meat packing plants, and automobile factories.

[1]: https://www.npr.org/2023/04/27/1172544561/new-state-laws-are...

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by MisterBastahrd on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:40PM (#36830645)
There are states in the US who want to enjoy all the benefits of living in an advanced society but also want the social and political status quo of the 1910s.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by didibus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:20PM (#36830524)
This is an incredibly relevant point.

Take North Korea, they have access the the know how of all the same advancements and yet because of social conditions, it's population is not thriving.

This is true of many countries honestly. The impact of social justice, equality, and all that are huge. And can't be understated.

In fact, we can all easily imagine an Elite ruling the world at the helm of AI powered robots, leaving the rest of us to scrape the bottom.

Social breakthroughs are going to need to keep pace with technological advancements, otherwise those same advancement can also help to bring minority holding power even more stronghold on the rest.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CBarkleyU on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:19PM (#36830918)
>Social breakthroughs are going to need to keep pace with technological advancements, otherwise those same advancement can also help to bring minority holding power even more stronghold on the rest.

Which is why we should push for social breakthroughs instead of hindering technological advancements. Work for the sake of working is just occupational therapy, nothing more.

I'm extremely optimistic regarding all this AI kerfuffle. "In fact, we can all easily imagine an Elite ruling the world at the helm of AI powered robots", yeah, sure, we can. We can also easily imagine us sharpening the good old guillotine.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by mschild on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:38PM (#36830246)
Sure, there's plenty of positives that came out of it, but lets not forget the downsides and the, quite literally, bloody struggles people had to go through to arrive where we are today.

Working conditions were for quite a long time absolutely horrendous. Child labour went from helping your parents on the farm to working in dangerous factories for 12 hour shifts.

Massive amounts of pollution, which we are seeing the effects of today, and that doesn't only include CO2 emissions.

Ideally, AI would help humanity work less or achieve more with less effort, but we both know that's not how corporations function. When there is more profit to be made, or money to be saved, they will.

AI will cost people jobs. Funnily enough, its trade jobs that are probably the safest from all these changes.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:37PM (#36830229)
There is absolutely no guarantee that what worked for the industrial revolution will be repeated for the AI revolution. None. At. All. It might be. But there are a ton of ways in which this could result in some very serious problems for which we currently do not have any solutions. Making the assumption that because something worked the last time it will work this time as well given the same circumstances is simply wrong. Even if - and that is a pretty big if - the circumstances around such revolution would be identical there are many ways in which it could have played out differently. The outcome of this is at this point in time unknowable, so you can't make any claims about what it will be like if and when it happens.

Maybe you're right. But consider the possibility that you are wrong and what the various bad outcomes could be and maybe then you'll at least make some kind of qualification to that statement.

see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retrospective_determinism

Also note that the industrial revolution was a turning point and not necessarily a good one for everybody that was alive back then, and that there are plenty of bad effects from it into today.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ojbyrne on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:40PM (#36830252)
* * *
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by beezlebroxxxxxx on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:38PM (#36830243)
The industrial revolution was also a period of incredible misery for a significant portion of the population. Without legal protection, and a strong social/political system, whole segments of the population were subject to poverty and filth.

The technological breakthroughs were great and we reap their benefits everyday. But, there was a lot more than simple technological revolution to get to the point where the majority of the population were no longer subject to immiseration at the behest of profit. There were a lot of hard legal and political arguments that had to end up on the side of labour to also give us the life of relative leisure we have now.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by Loquebantur on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:35PM (#36830216)
Any such post-AI jobs are predicated on there being a difference between AI and humans in favor of the latter.

I presume, you imagine large parts of the population will be happy working in the sex industry or similar?

People's irrational assumption, the past could always be linearly extrapolated into the future is remarkably out of place when it comes to the epitome of non-linearity, intelligent consciousness.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by JimtheCoder on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:45PM (#36830291)
"you imagine large parts of the population will be happy working in the sex industry"

About 50% might think it's cool for a while...

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by mouse_ on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#36830178)
Totally disagree. The Industrial Revolution is the catalyst for a major extinction event, and our current trajectory is to certain doom.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CyberDildonics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:35PM (#36830214)
AI will just usher the next industrial revolution of the modern era.

How will it do that? So far the only things being automated are Q&A and image generation.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:06PM (#36830429)
That's a pretty narrow view.

The things that are being automated go much, much further than just those two examples. I'd like to add: classification (including lots of medicine) and diagnosis, lots of low level information processing, process and machine control, vehicle control (for instance: self driving cars) etc.

Whether all of those will succeed for 100% of the cases is up in the air but if I were coming-of-age and slated for some job I'd be very wary of what to pick as a blue collar worker because almost all of those jobs could well be on the chopping block in the next decade.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CyberDildonics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:56PM (#36830762)
Are you calling all automation "AI" now?
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by bugglebeetle on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:33PM (#36830195)
> You could have said the same of Industrial Revolution. Yet here we are living better lives from the technological breakthroughs.

You understand that the course of the Industrial Revolution was a huge increase in barbarism, correct? People forced off their lands, children into factories, labor conditions that were horrendous across the board. Violent labor upheavals, WWI, a communist revolution, the rise of fascism and the Holocaust, WWII and the first use of nuclear weapons. Only in the wake of all of that was there anything like the widespread improvement of people’s lives and in places like the US, this still required a tumultuous and again violent dismantling of segregation.

I certainly don’t hope the AI evolution follows the example of its industrial counterpart, or we’re in for a quite wild ride.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by thatguy0900 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:09PM (#36830442)
It won't, the AI revolution also comes with fully autonomous weapons systems that will keep the rabble in their place this time around. I think the days of labor having the ability to violently threaten the government are also coming to a end.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by asdf6677 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:45PM (#36830289)
The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race. They have greatly increased the life-expectancy of those of us who live in “advanced” countries, but they have destabilized society, have made life unfulfilling, have subjected human beings to indignities, have led to widespread psychological suffering (in the Third World to physical suffering as well) and have inflicted severe damage on the natural world. The continued development of technology will worsen the situation. It will certainly subject human beings to greater indignities and inflict greater damage on the natural world, it will probably lead to greater social disruption and psychological suffering, and it may lead to increased physical suffering even in “advanced” countries.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:03PM (#36830408)
I'm with you in part, but I think it would be good to try to be fair: life as it was before the industrial revolution wasn't exactly paradise either. The industrial revolution solved some problems and replaced them with far larger ones. And for those far larger ones we don't have solutions, even after the thing has run for a couple of hundred years the problems are still increasing. And coupled with runaway economic systems, massive imbalance in the world with respect to where the benefits landed we don't look particularly good when it comes to the historical record of such revolutions.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CyberDildonics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:05PM (#36830419)
Not much is stopping you from living in a log cabin in the woods.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:34PM (#36830614)
Not a chance of that around here. And with any solution you have to ask yourself: does it scale? What if the current population of the earth would want to live in a log cabin in the woods? The woods would no longer be the woods.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CyberDildonics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:55PM (#36830748)
you have to ask yourself: does it scale?

You don't have to ask yourself that because almost no one actually agrees with this person that the 'industrial revolution had disastrous effects on the human race'. They don't even believe it.

What if the current population of the earth would want to live in a log cabin in the woods?

They don't and no one said anything about that.

The woods would no longer be the woods.

That's what we have now because that's what people want.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by asdf6677 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:36PM (#36831049)
The government will reclaim the land unless I pay for it with money I make from the system. It’s not possible to opt out anymore. They stole the land too but my guns are smaller.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/matthew-clarke-youtube-...

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CyberDildonics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:14PM (#36831295)
You could work at a job and then buy land outside a city, thus beating the system. This is something other people have done.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by mahogany on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#36838745)
You still need to pay property tax in perpetuity (in the US at least). Taxes can only be paid with USD aka “system money”, so you’re not really outside of the system in this situation. Plus there is eminent domain.

The only way to avoid needing system money would be to live on national land for free, but then you cannot have a permanent dwelling like a cabin.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by mahogany on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:56PM (#36839758)
There is not a dichotomy between a post-Industrial Revolution society and living in the woods.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by hwillis on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:49PM (#36830312)
> You could have said the same of Industrial Revolution.

Says who? What jobs did the industrial revolution eliminate? Essentially just spinners and weavers, and that caused a violent social uprising by the Luddites.

Textiles were far outweighed by the industrialization of steam power, ironworking, and machine tools. Those three things did not put people out of jobs, they just created huge numbers of new jobs and totally altered society.

I don't think anybody really believes AI will directly create new jobs, in any way comparable to steam or steel. They think it will be like textiles, but everywhere and without the balancing impact of those massive, unrelated new industries.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:00PM (#36830383)
Not a lot of textile still made in Europe. The Luddites got that one right, they were just a bit off about the timing. But this AI thing, assuming it manages to click the ratchet a few more times has the potential to eliminate a good 50% of all of the remaining blue collar jobs and a sizeable fraction of the rest. That is the sort of economic blow that I highly doubt we are prepared for. The big problem is that I don't see where those jobs will be going to, they are eliminated, not transformed this time around and that is a very serious change in the recipe.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by the_only_law on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:08PM (#36830437)
> they are eliminated, not transformed this time around and that is a very serious change in the recipe.

Don’t worry. Everyone and their mother will just go into the trades. Years from now we’ll be browsing PlumberNews where we’ll get to hear about how the demand for plumbers is infinite and how “plumbing is eating the world” and not to worry about massive increase of labor supply from people who are working on building plumbing robots.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:13PM (#36830470)
If it weren't serious it would be very funny indeed.

Plumbing really is eating the world, by the way ;)

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by itsanaccount on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:04PM (#36830411)
The ruling class wants slaves.

Be it animal, human, or machine. In every case where something made a better slave, capital has switched to using it.

Recognize what class you're in and see it for what it is (lotta people identify with the ruling class on this site), but don't pretend for a second us tech workers are somehow insulated from being workers. No one will care when we're homeless on the street anymore than the current group of i-got-mines care about the current homeless.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ilyt on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:09PM (#36830443)
And it will bring even bigger income inequality because yet again the rich can pay to replace the workers while reaping the benefits and avoiding taxing those benefits
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by coldtea on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:11PM (#36830455)
>Totally disagree. You could have said the same of Industrial Revolution. Yet here we are living better lives from the technological breakthroughs.

We're living more comfortamble lives and with more trinkets. More stressful, more depressed, more isolated, more damaging to the environment, more casually controlled and supervised, even downright less able to reproduce in the more modern of societies (the total gift of death)...

And especially in the first centuries of the industrial revolution peoples lives got a huge turn for the worse, pushed into cities and factories, working up to 16 hour shifts, little kids working just the same in body breaking conditions, discarded as useless when they had an accident, and so on. And it's not some change they welcomed either. They were pushed into it, by the rich classes destroying their previous livelihood, by legal changes making it impossible to survive, and even by raw police and millitary force. And they resisted tooth and nail to keep their previous way of life.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by marcosdumay on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:21PM (#36830532)
> You could have said the same of Industrial Revolution.

Yeah, and that's when people make it clear they don't know history.

There were many points during the Industrial Revolution when if you said the same thing, you would be absolutely correct.

A few of those times, the problem was "solved" by violence and deep restructure of the economy; other times it was "solved" by violence and letting lots and lots of people die. By the 20th century people realized that if you restructure the economy earlier, you can avoid that violence step, but some also realized they can just spread propaganda saying problems never happen, and stop any reorganization.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jfengel on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:28PM (#36830571)
It was also tied to a number of other events that massively depleted the population, including the Black Death. Not violent but very deadly, leaving Europe open to social restructuring.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by seanmcdirmid on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:30PM (#36830590)
There will come a point when technology has advanced to the point to make most human labor obsolete. We are mostly just arguing about when that will happen, not if it will happen. I agree though, at this point, we could just be seeing another productivity boost that still requires human labor.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by cardy31 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:19PM (#36831322)
I think AI will be less like the Industrial Revolution and more like a country finding large oil reserves.

Countries with strong social institutions like Norway do an amazing job of distributing the gains from finding oil.

Countries with poor social institutions (basically all of the developing world) end up enriching a small minority with the oil money. Even Canada doesn’t do a very good job of improving the lives of its citizens with its oil money.

Given the way the Western world has been going in terms of wealth consolidation, I am not optimistic about broad segments of the population seeing the benefits of AI.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by labster on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:40PM (#36830255)
I’ll bet one hundred dollars on barbarism. Seems like a sure thing.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jarjoura on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:21PM (#36830084)
Sure, but I'm not really a believer that any government will have the political power to restructure the economy. At least nothing would actually change unless states utterly collapsed and there's loss of life.

I don't think AI is going to replace everything either. It will be a cheap knockoff replacement for a lot of decent low paying middle class jobs, enough to do real damage, but not catastrophic. We will be forced to adapt like we always do and the wealth disparity continues to widens like it has been.

I guess if anything, we'll make life so efficient that people will start to question if we need our life to be so efficient. There comes a point when you start having diminishing returns on all that efficiency. We'll still have the same problems we always do, with bad relationship breakups, or addiction, or whatever. AI will never fix those things.

So in my mind, the logical conclusion is just a march toward mediocrity and feeling handcuffed to whatever situation you were born into.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by solardev on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:39PM (#36830248)
Barbarism usually wins. It always has so far.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jstx1 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:14PM (#36830024)
I don't think it will eliminate the vast majority of jobs, more likely that it will significantly reduce the demand for certain jobs in an uneven way. I guess some of this depends on the time horizon you're looking at too.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by Joeri on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:23PM (#36830095)
Just because we can’t imagine the jobs that would exist in an AI future doesn’t mean they won’t be there. And there are many ways this thing plays out where we don’t get a world of cheap AI abundance where the AI provides without limit. If nothing else the copyright maffia will do its best to prevent that future from occurring.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by philipkglass on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:39PM (#36830249)
The intellectual property lobby doesn't have much sway outside the rather small set of countries with significant cultural exports, software businesses, and/or patent-protected manufacturing. That's basically the Anglosphere, richer parts of Europe, South Korea, and Japan. If countries outside this group can reach prosperity faster by pirating intellectual property than by continuing to play by WTO rules, they will.

If the only thing standing between poor countries and a world of cheap AI abundance is law, respect for those laws won't last. Why should e.g. India play by the normal rules of trade if foreign companies have developed do-everything robots that they want to license on a restrictive basis? Obtain a few do-everything robots by means of normal trade, jailbreak or reverse engineer them, then duplicate do-everything robots domestically while ignoring the impotent griping of the original company and its government. There's no big IP lobby inside of India itself and it's really hard to see what "carrot" other countries could offer for compliance that tops the prize of having unlimited do-everything robots.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#36830175)
There are many pathways to such a restructuring and not all of them are wide enough to accommodate 8 billion people.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by monero-xmr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:12PM (#36830008)
It’s just hard for the reality of human behavior to square with “a socialized economy” given that every attempt to create one, past and present, has resulted in barbarism and some of the worst examples of genocidal horror that ever existed.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by chc on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:36PM (#36830224)
Why do you think that? To the extent that a correlation exists between the level of social benefits offered by a country and the amount of horrors committed by its government, I would expect it to go the opposite direction (i.e. brutal dictators are more likely to hoard resources than share them freely). I have heard some attempts to substantively make the argument that socialized economies lead to brutality before, but every one I have seen has relied on a pretty blatant sleight of hand where laissez-faire economics is conflated with democracy. If you're aware of an analysis that does an apples to apples comparison and comes to that conclusion, that would be very interesting.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by wahnfrieden on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:21PM (#36830081)
Those have all been authoritarian. There are anarchist visions of "socialized economy"
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by philistine on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:24PM (#36830101)
A socialized economy does not need to come with the death of democracy. The idea that communism can only be achieved if power rests on workers through something else than legislative elections is poison.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by antris on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:28PM (#36830143)
Same goes for capitalism currently. If the bar for the economic system is no more genocide, barbarism, hunger, exploitation of the workers or wars then you're aiming for something utopian immediately. Capitalism definitely has not solved these issues. In fact it's currently destroying the whole ecosystem.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by renewedrebecca on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:10PM (#36830449)
strawman. socialism != communism.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by MisterBastahrd on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:43PM (#36830671)
It's hard to take a comment like this seriously given all the bloodshed that has come about because of capitalism.

Now, it could just be that people who accumulate power also accumulate the means to defend that power, and that to accumulate it in the first place you've almost got to be a sociopath, but that's actually being thoughtful instead of bringing up context-barren boogeymen.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by polote on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:02PM (#36830401)
The vast majority of jobs could be eliminated today without AI and still they are not, so we are very safe. Even with AI getting better and better we will be
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by coldtea on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:03PM (#36830409)
>is that there will need to be a fundamental restructuring of the economy

Yes, and basically a fundamental restructuring of the power relations in the economy.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by 0xDEF on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:21PM (#36830530)
>socialized economy

Here in Denmark a significant fraction of the population (students, elderly, long-term unemployed) are already on some kind of pseudo basic income.

Why not just do basic income in this future "total AI automation" scenario? Why do so many people on the Internet think only radical socialist revolutions can solve all our problems?

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by Shekelphile on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:49PM (#36830710)
Basic income is a horrible idea. It resigns 80%+ of the population to being unproductive for life and living in abject poverty.

If AI is going to automate away all 'meaningless' low and middle class jobs then the government should be stepping in to tax the productivity gains and use the money to educate and employ those people in roles that AI can't (maybe ever) fill. Having the government pay tens of millions of people to further scientific research and innovation would be a massive boon for our society rather than the current ratcheting incrementalism and lack of innovation the pervades in our current system where innovation is always shunned unless it can provide immediate short-term gains.

Unfortunately it's moot to even think about. Nothing will change and the elites will simply let the majority of the population starve to death.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by sangnoir on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:50PM (#36830721)
> Why not just do basic income in this future "total AI automation" scenario?

The oligarchy doesn't want to fund this future, and the federal, state and local governments in the US don't have the wherewithal.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by cscurmudgeon on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:39PM (#36855735)
In practice so far, socialized economy is barbarism.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by yreg on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:48PM (#36829765)
The mean quality of life is sky high compared to 100 years ago and it is such thanks to the advancement made.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by almost_usual on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:51PM (#36829796)
And as the Earth burns away and we choke on the smoke we rejoice as we have our AI entertainment and we can go quietly into the night.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by starik36 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:00PM (#36829889)
I think the air quality is far better today than it was in the 30-40 years ago. I moved to Los Angeles in the late 80s and in the first six months didn't even realize that there were mountains all around us. I just couldn't see them because of the smog. I can see the mountains clearly today.

That's my anecdotal evidence.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jachee on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:29PM (#36830148)
Now do Beijing.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CamperBob2 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:53PM (#36830738)
Damn, the wheels on those goalposts must be diesel-powered.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jachee on Monday July 24, 2023 @04:46AM (#36844722)
“It’s less smoggy in LA.” Is the “it works on my machine” of climate change denial.

It’s a global problem, and acknowledging that isn’t moving the goal posts. It’s reminding you that a first down is not a touchdown.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by yreg on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:05PM (#36829932)
Yes, but that's an entirely different problem I would say.

The parent complained about having to work more when the tools get more efficient, insinuating that the fruits of advancement go only to the business owner. I commented only on that.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by darawk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:56PM (#36829848)
Lol. Nobody is choking on smoke. The earth is fine. Humans may make life slightly more difficult for themselves in the next century or two due to global warming, but those difficulties will be more than offset by advances in technology, even under pessimistic assumptions.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by coryrc on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:01PM (#36829900)
No one except most Canadians, the West Coast, Midwest, and Northeast of the US.

And Texas too apparently: https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/environm...

Is there anywhere in the continental US not affected by wildfire smoke? Hawaii is probably doing alright.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by justinhj on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:21PM (#36830077)
Wildfires are periodic and affected by forest management not just heat
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by WirelessGigabit on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:35PM (#36830219)
Doing pretty well in Phoenix. For as long as the AC keeps up!
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ChumpGPT on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:06PM (#36829946)
They are getting choked by Chinese pollution.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jeezfrk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:02PM (#36829909)
Erm. We are choking on smoke.

Its also the case that HappyMemes are very much as profitable (if not more) as home air filters.

Liars may not know they are part of the zombie horde .... but they do their master's will anyway.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ChumpGPT on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:05PM (#36829938)
I wish I shared your optimism, but I feel like we're running out of road while accelerating.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ThrowawayTestr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:00PM (#36829886)
A good portion of NA is literally choked in forest fire smoke.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vic-traill on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:25PM (#36830560)
This link is the parents speaking, nonetheless another data point [0}

I'm respiratorily at risk to particulate matter in the air (partially my own fault for cigarette smoking for many years, partially happenstance via a house fire/smoke inhalation), and the air quality has been a bastard in ON Canada this summer. It certainly has affected my outdoor activities.

[0] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/nine-year-ol...

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by 0xDEF on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:32PM (#36830604)
Localized toxic pollutants in air (smoke etc.) and water have been significantly reduced compared to 100 years ago.

However we have been too slow to reduce the CO2 emissions that are causing climate change exactly because it doesn't have an immediate local toxic effect.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by digdugdirk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:50PM (#36829779)
The mean quality of life is irrelevant if the mode quality of life is only a tenth of that.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by yreg on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:01PM (#36829898)
The mode quality of life is also sky high compared to 100 years ago. So is the median quality of life.

Mode and median were raised even faster than the average. Humanity managed to uplift a huge fraction of people out of extreme poverty.

In 1820s around 70-80% people lived in extreme poverty

In 1920s it was around 60-70%

In 2020s it's around 10%

source: e.g. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/e20f2f1a-en/index.html?i...

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vikinghckr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:05PM (#36829940)
That this even needed to be said on a forum like HN baffles me. I suspect it's a result of decades of mainstream political/cultural doom-and-gloom propaganda.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:15PM (#36830032)
This quality of life metric is purely economic, but it is easy to read it as general life quality- personally, I'd swap now for 1820s homesteading out west in a heartbeat even though that would register as 'extreme poverty' on the economic scale.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by gus_massa on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:38PM (#36830241)
Refrigerators. Just imagine your life without a refrigerator. If you go to 1820 you will have no refrigerator. From https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/worldwide-ave... , now the 80% of the homes in the world have a refrigerator.

[And 50% have a washing machine. Mine broke a few months and it was a big mess until we got a new one.]

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vikinghckr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:24PM (#36830103)
Well, for a start, it's safe to assume you're not a woman or a minority. And even if you're a young healthy white male, your quality of life would be significantly worse in the 1820s. Not only would you lose access to a lot of the everyday conveniences of life today, you're also far more likely to die a young and painful death from any number of disease.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#36830182)
Conveniences don't make life worth living, and a long life doesn't mean a good life. Do you really think people, on average, enjoyed their lives less back then? I don't
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vikinghckr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:38PM (#36830240)
Well, enjoyment or happiness is tricky to measure because happiness = reality - expectation. So people in the 1820s might've been "happy" enough because they simply didn't know a better life like today's was a possibility. There's no reason to think they were happier than today's population though. And certainly, you as someone who experienced today's conveniences will not be happy long term if all those were taken away suddenly.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:42PM (#36830269)
I've spent the best years of my life living in the woods and in wall-less huts w/ no water, plumbing or electricity. Imho our modern conveniences don't make life any richer, and in many cases take away the pleasure of things we take for granted. If I had medical problems I would probably feel differently.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ZephyrBlu on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:20PM (#36830931)
I feel like you are probably taking a lot of things for granted. Clothes, food, equipment, vehicles, etc. Heck, even just the ability to choose to live in a hut in the woods.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vunderba on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:36PM (#36831058)
Uh huh. What were you wearing? Did you sew your own clothes and grow your own cotton for those clothes? There's a surprising amount of "on the grid" work that afforded you the ability to live "off the grid".

There's also a big difference between living in a part of the world where the woods provide a relatively temperate climate. Try living out in the forest to Papua New Guinea with 100% humidity.

By the way, try to make sure you don't accidentally get bitten by a rabid animal because the cure for rabies wasn't invented until the 1880s.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by yreg on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:25PM (#36830113)
If you are jumping in a time machine to move your consciousness to a body in 1820 USA you are rolling dangerous dice because you have a significant chance of living the horrible life of a slave.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by awwaiid on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:31PM (#36830169)
You can do this right now! It's called "Alaska".
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:50PM (#36830316)
I do hope to end up there eventually, but I think the government ended homesteading back in the 80s sadly.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by antisthenes on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:55PM (#36830752)
Homesteading is a lifestyle.

Government can't "end" it any more than it can end partying.

If you're talking about the ability to live off the land you don't own and owning land without paying taxes, that's a different story.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:34AM (#36833804)
The US government passed Homestead Acts back in the 1800s where they gave away plots of land, called homesteads, (like 10% of the country) for free. It's a lifestyle, for sure, but living off land you don't own isn't what I was referring to. I think the last homesteads (free land) were given away in the 1980s.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by didibus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:21PM (#36830078)
But that linked paper does mention near the end:

> At the same time, the drop in global poverty after 1995 is the largest observed, despite the low correlation with GDP per capita. This implies a “lost opportunity”, for even faster poverty reduction could have been achieved if measures had been taken to contain increasing within-country income inequality

Which I feel this is the topic at hand.

Income inequality clearly impacts both local and global poverty.

Production efficiency also has a positive impact, you can produce and serve more people for cheaper. Yes, but that implies the efficacy of production benefits people equally, otherwise there are "lost opportunity" in poverty reduction.

This is what the "outrage" is here. It doesn't seem like AI support benefits the merchants or the workers, but exclusively the executives and shareholders.

And this is the challenge that face AI. At face value, it's great technology, that could help everyone, but will it benefit everyone equally, or will there be losers here?

If we want AI to be more positively received, that question needs to be addressed seriously.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by usednet on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:29PM (#36830151)
As somebody with a degree in economics who did research in this area, I strongly disagree. I cannot stress how important is to not equate poverty data with quality of life. Let me give you an example of how economic statistics can be misleading. In colonial India, economic production and GDP skyrocketed. Forests were razed, waterways were privatized, communal granaries were destroyed, etc. Agricultural production increased massively, yet hundreds of millions of Indian people starved and died.

It is absolutely not clear-cut that poverty has actually decreased on a long term scale. The real wage evidence shows less poverty and higher incomes during precolonial times in several countries. The datasets are woefully incomplete and flawed prior to 1900. Furthermore, the global poverty line is still set at $1.90 (!), and reexaming the decrease in poverty using more realistic costs of living results in very little change. Compounding on that, the vast majority of poverty reduction in the last century has been in China, a non-capitalist country. Removing them from the dataset results in almost no change in global poverty in the last 50 years. I can go on.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CapricornNoble on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:47PM (#36830688)
> the vast majority of poverty reduction in the last century has been in China, a non-capitalist country

Can't it also be said that the vast majority of poverty reduction has been in China...once they began to adopt capitalist economic principles in the last 40 years ?

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by medion on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:23PM (#36830548)
While quality of life has improved percentage wise for a small percentage of the earth's inhabitants, it is also a completely unsustainable way of living - it's a quality of life built on fossil fuels and debt. It's all a complete facade - if fossil fuels and access to effectively free money were wiped out tomorrow, quality of life would revert almost overnight... The fragility of it all is just extraordinary.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vikinghckr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:58PM (#36829866)
The median quality of life is MUCH higher today than 100 years ago. And bottom 1%-tile quality of life might be 1000 times better. All thanks to advance in technology and increased productivity.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by didibus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:57PM (#36829855)
And honestly the range matters a lot here as well. The mean just isn't a useful metric for human emancipation.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jacquesm on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:41PM (#36830256)
> The mean just isn't a useful metric for human emancipation.

For those at the top of the foodchain it is a very useful metric: it allows them to sleep at night.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vbezhenar on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:31PM (#36830163)
What about quality of life compared to 50 years ago? I guess it depends on country but I feel like my parents generation lived better life compared to mine.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vikinghckr on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:43PM (#36830275)
What did they have you don't?
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by thatguy0900 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:15PM (#36830493)
My parents bought a house and went on multiple family vacations every year and never really were too concerned about money, saving up a decent amount for retirement. My mom was a teacher in a poor inner city school and my dad was a low level insurance salesman. My mom never had to worry about student loans, they were easily paid off. I think trading fiscal peace and security for an iPhone is a bad trade.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by rolandog on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:00PM (#36829881)
The mean quality of life can be skewed by outliers. I wonder if there are median quality of life indicators with the box-diagram of Upper and Lower Fence values based on the Inter Quartile Range
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by jarjoura on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:05PM (#36829935)
Actually, economists are now saying that the 20th century was an anomaly in terms of QoL and we're reverting back to U shaped distribution of wealth.

It will be very interesting times when all that 20th century earned Baby Boomer wealth moves to the next generation and accelerates the shift even faster.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by nverno on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:08PM (#36829961)
Do you mean U-shaped on a wealth vs. age graph, or something else? I would imagine wealth distribution to look more like an exponential distribution.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by diatone on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:38PM (#36830245)
Frequency distribution I think - normal, not uniform.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by metadat on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:58PM (#36831202)
What does "U-shaped" mean or imply? I searched, but am still unclear.

Will the distribution be more even or more uneven?

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by tomrod on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:29PM (#36830586)
Not sure, sounds like that is a baked measurement intended to superficially mollify people. Medicine and health costs more than ever. Inequality higher than ever. Sure, we can buy cheapish bread and occasional circuses, but is that a valid measure of life?
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by theonlybutlet on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:31PM (#36830167)
Not every innovation, for a long while it was linked to benefits but then I think the 1970's they started stripping away unions, worker rights and pay, hours etc. started becoming detached from productivity.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by BaseballPhysics on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:15PM (#36830034)
> If the promise of AI means I can do 1/2 the amount of work and maintain my high quality life, then I'm all for it.

The only way that'll happen is worker co-ops. The benefits of increased productivity always accrue to the owners, not the employees.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by wahnfrieden on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:18PM (#36830061)
And somehow most people consider this wrong
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by whateveracct on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:12PM (#36830007)
It's not about efficiency it's about devaluing workers so you have more leverage over them.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by PheonixPharts on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:07PM (#36830431)
Personally I find the fact that Keynes's 15-hour work week never materialized despite massive improvements in automation to be fairly strong evidence in favor of Marx's Labor Theory of Value.

One of the ways that Marx posited capitalist extract surplus value is to have the increase in quality of life always lagging the increase in efficiency. Our quality of life does increase, but only if capitalists are able to increase greater surplus value from our labor than that quality of life increase accounts for.

> don't forget that we're going to take down the world economy with it

Interestingly enough this is one of the major focuses of Capital vol III: the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.

Marx argued that eventually the Capitalist pressure to increase efficiency through automation means that while production continues to be more efficient, precisely because of this the ratio of profit to capital expended decreases. For Marx this was the ultimate threat to Capitalism itself.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by vba616 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:53PM (#36830735)
>Personally I find the fact that Keynes's 15-hour work week never materialized despite massive improvements in automation to be fairly strong evidence in favor of Marx's Labor Theory of Value.

I don't understand the train of thought that lead to the sentence above. "Marx's Labor Theory of Value" is a well-known phrase, but its meaning is probably more precise for you than me.

Do you not think, broadly speaking, there is some economy of scale with longer hours (compared to 15/week), that gaining experience more quickly has some value, that overhead like shift handoffs or putting work aside for the next day becomes more significant the shorter the day/week is?

I'd also suggest it's plausible that automation changes the nature of work to increase the efficiency of long hours. The more education and thought a job requires, the longer it takes to "get up to speed" and to hand off work to other people.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by dheera on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:09PM (#36830447)
> If the promise of AI means I can do 1/2 the amount of work and maintain my high quality life, then I'm all for it.

What I'd personally really hope for is a future in which AI and robotics allow high quality food, housing, transportation, clothing, state-of-the-art medical care, and basic necessities to be available for free to everyone. Basically, a modest, comfortable, safe middle-class-quality life should be free and provided for by robots to everyone in the world.

Anything above that, one would have to work for. It would also likely be a world in which any work humans voluntarily do is interesting work. There might also be some kind of analog art renaissance.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:16PM (#36830498)
One tractor can do the work of tens of people easily, and in the last ~150-200 years, we've gone from a vast majority of people producing food to a tiny minority, while the rest can be social media managers and feng-shui specialist. One excell spreadsheet can do the work of a 100+ paper-based accountants, and that's even before a database and automation.

We could've stopped at tractors, lived the same lifestyle as before, but with 1-2 hours work per day (or even less), but we decided we wanted and needed more, and more is what we got.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by CharlieDigital on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:25PM (#36830555)
Key difference: productivity gains in agriculture made food not only more plentiful, but also cheaper.

We can say the same for the steam engine and transportation. It made it cheaper to move goods and people.

Question is whether advancements in AI translate to making some fundamental goods or services cheaper and more accessible.

Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ricardonunez on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:32PM (#36830605)
It is going to make profits more accessible to those at the top; that’s that.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by Gehinnn on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:32PM (#36830601)
Doesn't the free market regulate this?
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by ajsnigrutin on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:37PM (#36831066)
And gains in computing made computers cheaper. An esp32 which is way way more powerful than desktop machines ~30-40 years ago costs $4, you can buy a full laptop for ~150eur, or a smartphone for even less. Yes, of course AI will make stuff cheaper and more accessible, but you'll want more and more of that stuff. Just count the number of "computers" in your home now, and think what else will become "smart" in the future.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by _a_a_a_ on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:34PM (#36830618)
Hot water, sewers, decent food, television and films, warm & damp-resistant housing, electric lights and much more and I'm glad of it. I remember living in places where hot water had to come from a kettle and it was cold and in winter the damp rose nearly to the ceiling from the floor. And the food back then was expensive and pretty bad.
Re:Shopify Quietly Replacing Laid Off Workers with AI by whack on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:41PM (#36830659)
> If the promise of AI means I can do 1/2 the amount of work and maintain my high quality life, then I'm all for it. However, every advancement that has come in the last 100 years that improved efficiency has only meant we're pushed to work more and do more. So I am now expected to do 2x the work.

If you're content to live at the same quality-of-life that people had in 1923, you can certainly achieve that by doing half the amount of work. The cost of living that quality of life is dirt-cheap - median household real-income back then in today's dollars is less than $30k. The average person back then had a life expectancy of ~60, barely traveled long distances, had minimal electronic gadgets, and lived in houses that have none of today's modern amenities.

If you're content with that kind of lifestyle, you can easily achieve that by either working as a freelancer for 20 hours per week. Or by working a high-paying job, saving most of your money, and retiring in your 30s/40s.

Most people don't do this because ... they don't want to live like someone in 1923. Our own life expectations today are far higher, and hence, we push ourselves to work 40+ hours/week to meet them.

The risk of hyper-income-inequality is real. Fortunately we also live in a democracy. Billionaires like Murdoch will be able to exploit wedge issues like guns and LGBT for only so long. Sooner or later a critical mass of people will demand sharply more progressive tax rates, and even things like UBI, if too much wealth is concentrated in too few hands.