Raising taxes on wealthy companies to cover pensions seems arbitrary and unfair (by which I don't mean that taxes shouldn't necessarily be raised).
actually this sounds reasonable, and Western countries obviously pay already through various programs.
If they have business interests in Africa, absolutely.
The world's biggest corporations are profiting massively from having access to the French market. But that access is not a given, it is being granted by the French people, and can be taken away at any time for any reason the French people consider valid.
2) Large companies either go bankrupt or leave the country
3) The economy is completely wrecked
4) Venezuela
You think Apple stops operating here because of a 1% headwind? No way.
All of these problems are due to population collapse, due to incredibly low birthrates.
Canada is choosing another method, with current targets of 500k/year, and talk of even higher numbers:
https://globalnews.ca/news/9836414/canada-immigration-aging-...
With 40M people, that's more than a 1% per year. And note, those are immigrants, not refugees, or other classes of new Canadians.
Just the housing and infrastructure needs alone, and initial support, as well as dealing with validation -> full citizenship is mind bogglng.
But beyond that, I believe it is too fast as a culture shift. I want new blood, new ideas, but I also want the ideals of a hoghly democratic nation, its openness to newcomers, its tolerance to not be lost in a voice of newness.
EG, I want newcomer input, but I don't want it to drown out what's here.
But that's how worrisome the population graph is. There are not enough young people to take care of the old, the old who have worked their entire lives, building what is around us, and paying for tgeir elders to retire, a social contract that is vital.
So we know we are doing a risky thing, as all fast change is risky.
But we must, or... what?
France chose another path. I can't say it is right or wrong.
But ... if nothing is done, it won't be good.
The stupid part is, everyone is dealing with this. China, Russia, the entire West, we all knew. We all knew the numbers, all of us, decades ago.
But we waited. For example, Canada could have ramped up immigration a decade ago, thus softening the social impact.
Dude.
> The richest people and biggest corporations own such an unimaginably large amount of wealth that taxing them would fix just about anything.
Still peanuts comparing to the "global" economy or a country needs (in terms of pension or health). Also a significant portion of this wealth is paper money that will take a significant hit at sale.
> In 2017, Apple's cash reserves were $250 billion. That's just a single company, hoarding reserves that could clear the national debt of most countries. Think about that for a second.
Why not then, dip into your bank account? By this logic, there are trillion of $$ in bank accounts all around the world. That's a lot of money.
> There is absolutely no shortage of wealth in the world. There is easily enough to pay all the pensions, including far into the future, even considering demographic change.
> But of course, if governments are OK with allowing corporations to act like sovereign countries, raising the retirement age can seem like a reasonable alternative to moving all that wealth to where it actually belongs.
Sure, let's make every 20-30-40 something work for these 60+ all day instead of having a life. The reality is that the pension system of France was pretty good when it started because there were very few pensioners. Now that the situation is not the same, it means each pensioner will get a little less. And the system is already maxed out to maximum max. Many people are deserting France because of the high taxes and high pension system contributions.
Most of the value produced by workers goes into the pockets of corporate overlords. For their bosses and managers, for the shareholders, and for the landlords of the corporate mafia who take in 30-70% of working people's income. By your own logic, abolish corporate profits and for-profit housing, and let every worker enjoy huge benefits and retirement.
> Now that the situation is not the same, it means each pensioner will get a little less.
This is not wrong. But it's entirely due to Macron reforming the pension system with a "point" system. Without such reform, pensioners would continue to get just as much money, adjusted for inflation.
Corporations are owned by pension funds. Investment funds own 80% of the S&P 500. They would be insolvent if corporations stopped posting profits.
But also, the reason corporations make so much money is regulatory capture. They buy laws that foreclose competition which makes everything cost more. It's the same reason housing is so expensive (the anti-competition laws there are zoning rules). You can't fix this with taxes -- tax them and everything still costs too much. Meanwhile the government is not going to give the money to you, they give it to the politically connected or use it to buy votes from interest groups with inefficient programs.
You have to actually fix the laws that enable this -- as in repeal them, not add some more to the pile.
Government has become captured by wealthy interests and has created a legal system that benefits the rich at the expense of the working class.
If the power of the government can be seized, the wealth of the rich can be taken and used to help the working class.
Problems with this:
A) this essentially is a revolution to seize control of the government to take the wealth from the powerful and wealthy. B) there is a high risk that the attempt to seize control of the government will fail, but the wealth transfer will still occur, just from the middle class to the government/wealthy. C) it's unsustainable.
Some people are now proposing a wealth tax on anyone with more than a billion dollars. That's surprisingly reasonable. It is also completely sustainable, and does not require overthrowing any government ...
As far as I can tell, the top 1% of earners pay 42.3% of income taxes and earn 22.2% of income. The average 1%-er makes 1.76 million dollars a year. They pay as a group approximately 722 billion dollars annually in income taxes [1]. Then factor in estate taxes and corporate taxes which are disproportionately ultimately borne by the very rich. Then factor in payroll taxes, which are 50% paid by companies. The top 1% bears an incredibly large portion of the national tax burden, as I see it. One could argue it should be more, but I don’t see the argument that the middle class pays “pretty much all the taxes”.
As for a wealth tax, a lot of wealth isn’t in a liquid form. Would you see it forcibly liquidated or would you like the government to have substantial holdings in US companies?
Personally I think there are much more fruitful ways to go about addressing inequality than the progressive “eat the rich” agenda.
[1]: https://taxfoundation.org/publications/latest-federal-income...
My landlord is in a tax heaven. It's a corporation and there is no way for me to know who own it! What if I am paying rent to a war criminal? How do they account for this?
But let's look at a simpler situation - say you own a company, company let's out apartments, the rent is used to buy new apartments -> if you time purchases of new property well, there is never a profit to tax, corporation tax is zero. If I never take money out, but just grow my net worth, then my personal tax is zero too. So my net worth can keep growing forever, without ever paying tax.
You only ever pay tax on the small amount of money you take out of the company for living expenses, like food.
https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/bezos-musk-and-other...
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/21/us/politics/trump-taxes-i...
https://ktla.com/news/how-does-tesla-get-away-with-paying-0-...
The list goes on and on. Once you have enough money you use staff lawyers at your company to pay nothing taxes either for your company or for yourself.
Not in France, where retirement fund is a nation-wide socialized entity, which was the core of this debate. Private pension funds are close to non-existent here ; i personally cannot name a single person doing that because the public model worked so well for decades.
> It's the same reason housing is so expensive (the anti-competition laws there are zoning rules).
I don't entirely disagree because France has the more draconian housing regulations you can imagine: it's to my knowledge the only country in the world where it's illegal to build your own house (or lightweight housing) and produce your own electricity off-grid on land you actually own.
However, the argument doesn't stand scrutiny. According to public studies there's hundreds of thousands of empty dwellings in France... not even counting secondary/vacation housing or AirBnBs. There's two faces to the housing crisis here in France.
The first is the landlord mafia keeping apartments empty on purpose for speculation. Because if the entire supply was put on market, the prices would collapse, and people could actually afford housing. We could design a law to tax empty housing proportionally to the owner's wealth, and see how fast we get housing for everyone.
The second is the government backed off on public housing. Low-cost housing (HLM) programs started after WWII have been mostly cut, and whatever funding is left has been diverted to "ownership accession" and higher-standing "low-cost" housing which are luxury housing below market rates but very inaccessible to minimum-wage workers. To give you an idea, a two-bedroom apartment in standard HLM usually costs 200-500€/month in Paris. The newer ones being produced from public funds are rented for ~800-1500€/month, while the minimum wage is around 1300€ after taxes.
I have a hard time calling this a "crisis" when it's a massive defrauding operation orchestrated by the State and the housing mafia.
It's not that extreme. There are a lot of "assurances-vie" which are quite literally meant to be private pension funds (with lots of tax incentives...). That being said no-one actually relies on it, and the core of pensions are definitely the nation-wide entities. (Yes plural, we wouldn't be french if there weren't dozens of competing institutions doing the same thing, with of course people getting sucked dry but that administrative complexity)
> The first is the landlord mafia keeping apartments empty on purpose for speculation. Because if the entire supply was put on market, the prices would collapse, and people could actually afford housing. We could design a law to tax empty housing proportionally to the owner's wealth, and see how fast we get housing for everyone.
I don't agree on the "proportionally to the owner's wealth", simply on the empty apartments' value. But yes, we need to tax empty housing. And we're getting there. There has been a lot of changes with regards to housing taxes that are largely going towards taxing (relatively) more empty housing, with this year being the first year you need to properly declare for every housing you own what its use. And I feel like it's just the start, and we're going to keep those taxes evolving towards taxing empty apartments while taxing less family housing.
The biggest problem in this day and age is cost of living, not wages. Housing is way too expensive. But that's not because it's provided by the market for profit, it's because government hasn't allowed it to be build in large enough volume to satisfy the demand of people moving into cities.
Why?
I mean you don't provide a justification that's more defended than me saying the opposite is true.
Because wealth is immensely concentrated. There isn't nearly as much money in everyday individual bank accounts as in those of ultrawealthy individuals and corporates; and the trend since the 80s is for this to accelerate.
> Still peanuts comparing to the "global" economy or a country needs (in terms of pension or health). Also a significant portion of this wealth is paper money that will take a significant hit at sale.
> In 2017, Apple's cash reserves were $250 billion. That's just a single company, hoarding reserves that could clear the national debt of most countries. Think about that for a second.
> Why not then, dip into your bank account? By this logic, there are trillion of $$ in bank accounts all around the world. That's a lot of money.
Well they mentioned Apple's cash reserves that's traditionally easily accessible funds that do not take a significant hit at sale (although the number I read is $55 Billion), but if we talking about Apple's cash and cash equivalents, that was $20,535. That money would fix quite a few economies (and pension funds).
I'm not sure why you bring up peoples bank accounts. They were specifically talking about the worlds richest people and companies, you're average Joe doesn't count. The whole argument is that many economies are in this mess because the super-rich companies and individuals have not been paying their fair share of taxes (as sufficiently document by e.g. the Panama papers etc.).
My bank account is dipped into. It's called "tax". I pay it at a considerably higher rate than Apple does. Does that seem fair?
No, though it is not about fairness. Your slave owner takes part of the fruits of your labor. Why do you allow that?
Income tax pays for ... ridiculous things like endless wars and spying on American income tax payers.
12% of federal budget went to national defense.
Most of it went towards Health Insurance, Social Security, and Welfare programs.
Did trustfundians pay income tax? How does the son of George Soros, who does not need income, pay income tax? The children of ultra rich are not tax slaves. They escaped.
I'm not sure I'm following what you're implying.
There's a baseline level of consumption required to survive. Meaning everyone eats, rents, drives to work, buys an entertainment system. Paying for what you consume is a regressive way of generating tax revenue as the tax is raised from the poor masses.
Progressive taxation exists because people with more income have more disposable income. When you tax a poor working single mother of three and she must choose between buying food or paying tax, you will get riots eventually. When you tax a millionaire who's choice is buying a sports car or paying tax, riots don't usually happen.
So, to answer your question, there should be no corporate tax, and no VAT, if income tax is set at the correct level. It makes no sense for you, as an individual, to compare yourself to a corporation.
This is outrageous. Why does, in your world, a corporation have amore rights than a real person?
On the contrary, there should be no personal income tax, only Corporate taxes.
The overhead associated with corporate taxes is also much higher for small businesses.
If you look at periods of wage stagnation and/or inflation, they aren't exactly positively correlated with relative high corporate taxes.
This applies to payroll taxes, but I don’t think it applies to corporate income taxes. Since corporate income taxes are typically levied against profit, not revenue, wages are paid out of “pre-tax” money. A high corporate income tax rate would actually incentivize paying higher wages and/or hiring more employees.
That's pretty arguable. To me, "fair" simply means that we all obey the same rules. Those rules can be anything we want, if we think they'll make society work better. In our current system, taxes are levied on money movement, which serves important functions. These functions include signalling to the economy which activities we'd like to encourage and discourage, and providing fair and proportionate funding to government services which deal with that specific activity. For instance, road tax is levied only on car users, and goes towards the maintenance of the infrastructure which car users disproportionately benefit from. That is much more "fair" than what you are suggesting. When you use terms like "double taxation", you are presupposing that tax is "attached to a person", and that income tax is the only "valid" form of tax, which is a radical departure from how most of the world thinks about tax - a fact you acknowledge.
>It makes no sense for you, as an individual, to compare yourself to a corporation.
I agree with this, but probably not the way that you mean.
Apple isn't even a person. It deserves no consideration of things like "rights" and "personal sovereignty". It's merely an organization - essentially, a pile of paperwork - that exists entirely subordinate to the parameters that we agree on through the engine of representative democracy, which is our current best effort at creating an avatar of societal cooperation, for the benefit of all. Ethically, we would be entirely within our rights to tax Apple at a rate of 100%, if we felt it would be a net benefit to society as a whole.
Legally, that pile of paperwork gives the Apple corporation some rights of a person. Obviously it is not a living, breathing person in the biological sense. But it is treated as one from a legal perspective.
Should it be? That's a different question. Changing that would probably upend contract law.
IANAL
The government does it every time when it prints money. Note that with cryptocurrency or golden money that would become impossible. Maybe that is why government set up obstacles for buying gold or cryptocurrency.
They don't have wealth though, they have capital or money but not wealth. Wealth is actual goods and services, money is an abstract representation of the ability to obtain these things. As the pandemic proved it doesn't matter how much money you have, if there just isn't stuff to spend it on.
To quote Douglas Adams "Many solutions were suggested for this problem, but most of these were largely concerned with the movement of small green pieces of paper, which was odd because on the whole it wasn't the small green pieces of paper that were unhappy."
Any real solution needs to focus on wealth creation, and not on moving around small green pieces of paper. As long as people's standard of living is increasing they really care a lot less about money and income inequality, people only start caring about that when they realize things are getting worse.
Now you take the most wealthy and successful corporation in the history of mankind, Apple, take its cash reserves (250 billion), subtract its debt (100 billion), and tax it (e.g. 10%) and you're left with 15 billion, which gives you the fraction 0.00005 of the 300 trillion you'll want to raise for US retirement of everyone alive in the US today. So in actuality you'd need to have another 20 thousand Apples, and you'd get to your number, just for the US population.
Ignore of course the rest of the 97% of the world population, despite Apple having earned its cash reserves from its global business, they'll need to find their own first-in-class corporate behemoth to tax for their retirement.
----
I think more importantly, you have to acknowledge that money is just a tool for expressing value, but fundamentally has no value. What does have value is actual production. Everything that the people of the Earth can produce in a given year, and consume in a given year, constitutes their wealth. The more people work & produce, the richer we are, in total. Apple could have 1 quadrillion in cash, if nobody on the planet is working, Apple and everyone else is extremely poor. Retiring simply means: you do not produce, but you do consume what others produce. And that's fine if it's sufficiently balanced, where the working produce sufficiently for their and the non-working's consumption. And in France it was extremely clear from all studies that this condition wasn't going to be met the coming decades. Raising money through taxes doesn't change that fundamental truth, that this system is only sustainable if it is balanced, and it wasn't.
To simplify it, if every working person produces 2 loafs of bread, and every person eats 1 loaf of bread per day, in a population of 10 people you need 5 to be working, and 5 can retire. 10 loafs are produced, and 10 loafs are consumed.
If the retirement age is low enough that 3 people work and 7 retire, you'd produce 6 loafs, but the population still needs 10 loafs to consume.
Taxing companies in this population to finance this earlier retirement age, just puts money in the hands of the 7. It doesn't change the fundamental issue, which is that there's 6 loafs of production and 10 are necessary. So you'll see rapid inflation, bread becoming very expensive, some working and some retirees having no bread, in other words, poverty, versus the situation where the retirement age was a bit higher and all demand was being met by supply.
Of course actual economic models are way more complex, but this example illustrates: it's not money, or taxes, that constitutes or generates wealth, it's just a unit of account. What makes us wealthy is that which we produce. And human activity (= work) is the engine of that production. Reducing the retirement age = less human activity = less work = less production = less wealth. You can put taxes at any level, but that remains true. And France chose heed this rule, because all actuarial & demographic tables showed it can't sustain the wealth with the growing number of retirees, lower number of working age population, and growing life expectancy, at the old retirement age.
To put it in context, in British, _annual_ health spending is 280 billions.
Those reserve can't last for a year in a smaller country.
Government will never be incentivized to function properly until their revenue, like any and all successful institutions, is dependent upon their own competence. Endless skies the limit money with no consideration for how wisely or efficiently that money is used is an obvious recipe for national failure.
many do, even ones with big pensions programs and social safety nets
even many currently indebted ones have before
government revenues via passive rent seeking behaviors of other people’s production are not the only ways governments have raised revenues before
Just because cash exists somewhere as numbers in a system, it doesn't mean those numbers can jump out of the system and suddenly manifest as young, capable humans who can help retires. Plus, as others have pointed out, 250 billion it isn't even a drop in the bucket.
If there is 2 trillion dollars of profit held as cash by companies, that doesn't mean they are holding back 2 trillion dollars worth of production. It means they're holding a claim on the purchasing power of 2 trillion dollars VS the total of all worldwide cash value, say 2% as an example.
If the 2 trillion is taken out of the bank and spent, say on social services, it just dilutes the current purchasing power of the remaining cash value. It does not create 2 trillion dollars worth of value from nowhere. I return to my opening claim, that money itself doesn't have value.
If anything, money could be described as, "A claim on a certain percentage of the worlds output at any given moment, limited by locale." That percentage claim is wildly unstable and changes as money is created/destroyed.
The richest people and biggest corporations own such an unimaginably large amount of wealth that taxing them would fix just about anything.
In 2017, Apple's cash reserves were $250 billion. That's just a single company, hoarding reserves that could clear the national debt of most countries. Think about that for a second.
There is absolutely no shortage of wealth in the world. There is easily enough to pay all the pensions, including far into the future, even considering demographic change.
But of course, if governments are OK with allowing corporations to act like sovereign countries, raising the retirement age can seem like a reasonable alternative to moving all that wealth to where it actually belongs.