News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by dTal on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:32AM (#36825354)
>Why not then, dip into your bank account? By this logic, there are trillion of $$ in bank accounts all around the world. That's a lot of money.

My bank account is dipped into. It's called "tax". I pay it at a considerably higher rate than Apple does. Does that seem fair?

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by landemva on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:44AM (#36825408)
> Does that seem fair?

No, though it is not about fairness. Your slave owner takes part of the fruits of your labor. Why do you allow that?

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by dTal on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:27AM (#36825650)
It is entirely about fairness. We live in a society. Tax is necessary to maintain that society. Everyone needs to pitch in. If you want "rights", that comes with "responsibilities" - they invariably pair.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by landemva on Saturday July 22, 2023 @09:44AM (#36826164)
Responsibilty to maintain road and sewer, for example, are funded by use tax and sales tax. Those who use it are paying to maintain it.

Income tax pays for ... ridiculous things like endless wars and spying on American income tax payers.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by didibus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:16AM (#36826938)
> Income tax pays for ... ridiculous things like endless wars and spying on American income tax payers

12% of federal budget went to national defense.

Most of it went towards Health Insurance, Social Security, and Welfare programs.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by landemva on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:16PM (#36827475)
Federal budget includes deficit spending.

Did trustfundians pay income tax? How does the son of George Soros, who does not need income, pay income tax? The children of ultra rich are not tax slaves. They escaped.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by parineum on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:21PM (#36827989)
How do you think those kids acquire money? I guarantee you it's a in a form the government classifies as income.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by didibus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @02:48PM (#36828704)
Yes, a small percentage went to paying interest on loans, and some of the money spent was borrowed. And the majority of spending from income tax still went to the things I mentioned prior.

I'm not sure I'm following what you're implying.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by nxx788 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:28AM (#36826529)
Are you talking about the idea that taxes are theft, (which I didn't disagree with more) or the idea that wage labor is theft because your employer sells the products for more than they pay you to produce them (which is absolutely theft, imo)?
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by landemva on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:18PM (#36827483)
Sales tax and use tax pay for what we consume. Those and a few others, such as import duties, are reasonable.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by wak90 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:19PM (#36827976)
Normally, I'd just flame you for this.

There's a baseline level of consumption required to survive. Meaning everyone eats, rents, drives to work, buys an entertainment system. Paying for what you consume is a regressive way of generating tax revenue as the tax is raised from the poor masses.

Progressive taxation exists because people with more income have more disposable income. When you tax a poor working single mother of three and she must choose between buying food or paying tax, you will get riots eventually. When you tax a millionaire who's choice is buying a sports car or paying tax, riots don't usually happen.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by atlantic on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:16AM (#36825578)
The cornerstone of a fair tax system is to avoid double taxation. Most countries currently practice triple taxation - they tax personal income, they tax the same income again through taxes on consumption, and a third time through corporate tax. And then there are still countless other small taxes. A fair system would tax people once, on their earnings, and stop there.

So, to answer your question, there should be no corporate tax, and no VAT, if income tax is set at the correct level. It makes no sense for you, as an individual, to compare yourself to a corporation.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by ClumsyPilot on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:38AM (#36825713)
> So, to answer your question, there should be no corporate tax, and no VAT, if income tax is set at the correct level. It makes no sense for you, as an individual, to compare yourself to a corporation.

This is outrageous. Why does, in your world, a corporation have amore rights than a real person?

On the contrary, there should be no personal income tax, only Corporate taxes.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by christophilus on Saturday July 22, 2023 @09:26AM (#36826029)
Or no taxes other than a flat national sales tax, probably with some rebate to assist the poorest X% of families.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by notahacker on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:26AM (#36826516)
Which, like the "only income tax" would enrich the hereditary wealth dynasties at the expense of the sort of people that actually have to spend most of their income.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by landemva on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:19PM (#36827497)
And repeal the income tax. And exempt from sales tax uncooked food at grocery stores.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by pitaj on Saturday July 22, 2023 @09:28AM (#36826044)
Corporate taxes are among the taxes with the highest dead weight loss, and the cost just gets passed on as lower worker compensation or higher prices of goods and services.

The overhead associated with corporate taxes is also much higher for small businesses.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by ameister14 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:34AM (#36826582)
I know that's what a set of economists say theoretically happens, but I'm not sure that's actually borne out in the data.

If you look at periods of wage stagnation and/or inflation, they aren't exactly positively correlated with relative high corporate taxes.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by tanaros on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:31PM (#36827585)
> the cost just gets passed on as lower worker compensation

This applies to payroll taxes, but I don’t think it applies to corporate income taxes. Since corporate income taxes are typically levied against profit, not revenue, wages are paid out of “pre-tax” money. A high corporate income tax rate would actually incentivize paying higher wages and/or hiring more employees.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by dTal on Saturday July 22, 2023 @08:51AM (#36825799)
>The cornerstone of a fair tax system is to avoid double taxation

That's pretty arguable. To me, "fair" simply means that we all obey the same rules. Those rules can be anything we want, if we think they'll make society work better. In our current system, taxes are levied on money movement, which serves important functions. These functions include signalling to the economy which activities we'd like to encourage and discourage, and providing fair and proportionate funding to government services which deal with that specific activity. For instance, road tax is levied only on car users, and goes towards the maintenance of the infrastructure which car users disproportionately benefit from. That is much more "fair" than what you are suggesting. When you use terms like "double taxation", you are presupposing that tax is "attached to a person", and that income tax is the only "valid" form of tax, which is a radical departure from how most of the world thinks about tax - a fact you acknowledge.

>It makes no sense for you, as an individual, to compare yourself to a corporation.

I agree with this, but probably not the way that you mean.

Apple isn't even a person. It deserves no consideration of things like "rights" and "personal sovereignty". It's merely an organization - essentially, a pile of paperwork - that exists entirely subordinate to the parameters that we agree on through the engine of representative democracy, which is our current best effort at creating an avatar of societal cooperation, for the benefit of all. Ethically, we would be entirely within our rights to tax Apple at a rate of 100%, if we felt it would be a net benefit to society as a whole.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by di456 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:04AM (#36826325)
> Apple isn't even a person

Legally, that pile of paperwork gives the Apple corporation some rights of a person. Obviously it is not a living, breathing person in the biological sense. But it is treated as one from a legal perspective.

Should it be? That's a different question. Changing that would probably upend contract law.

IANAL

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood