News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by tjpnz on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:31PM (#36803823)
I don't understand why FedNow and CBDC are such a big issue in the US. FedNow looks quite attractive from a fees perspective, especially when compared to PayPal and alike. Part of me wonders if the middlemen who stand to lose out might be trying to muddy the waters. It wouldn't be the first time.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by lbotos on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:40PM (#36803944)
Because there are many Americans who are small gov and against excessive taxation. A CBDC is "too far" for a lot of people who believe that.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:18PM (#36804477)
Imagine being paid in a ‘programmable’ currency that your employer (or government) decides cannot be spent on alcohol, meat, or fossil fuels.

Meanwhile, wealthier people get paid in ‘unrestricted’ currency.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by candiddevmike on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:24PM (#36804561)
That already exists today, food stamps/SNAP/EBT for low income and dollars for everyone else

I'd just as soon give everyone dollars via UBI

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by imtringued on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#36804753)
Honestly, if governments paid out all social benefits in a demurrage currency which they accept for tax payments, they would save a lot of money because the velocity and therefore fiscal multiplier of a demurrage currency is very high.

Christian Gelleri made this proposal to solve the Greek crisis: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3144910

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by realce on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#36805638)
Your employer doesn't pay you in food stamps, they pay you in money you can use to buy anything you need in the entire world.

The government provides coupons that allow you to buy food which is remediated to the seller in dollars. The authority and funding to provide that service is something that voters can impact or change.

These are very different things, not "that already exists" at all.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by digging on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:02PM (#36807337)
> they pay you in money you can use to buy anything you need in the entire world.

This is an primarily American phenomenon though and it's only really true because of the dominance of the US and US petrodollars over global society. It's probably not easy to spend Turkish lira in Madagascar, for example. Yes there are banks which will exchange approved currencies, but that's one step removed from being paid in a global global currency as you imply.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:14PM (#36808920)
"Petrodollars" are completely unimportant. They just mean Saudi Arabia's financial reserves, and KSA is not a large country so it wouldn't matter if they abandoned the dollar.

If anyone ever mentions petrodollars, CBDC, or crypto to you, they are crazy and I recommend stealing their wallet.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 21, 2023 @08:27AM (#36813010)
The populist right's obsession with currency -- pointing fingers at state banks and currency systems and money lenders and so on -- is a product of their unwillingness to point fingers at real corporate sources of power & control in the world. In large part because they're sympathetic to them (or outright funded by them in some cases.)

At best this kind of stuff is a harmless ideological pressure release valve for a discontented middle class / small business / entrepreneurial layer squeezed from above (esp after COVID). At worst it veers into outright authoritarian & xenophobic politics and often blends in some anti-Semitism. Starts with rants about Bretton-Woods and the next thing you know you're hearing about the Rothschilds.

There was a whole wing of this stuff ascendant in the 1930s (in western Canada we had "Social Credit", for example) whose ideological purpose was to displace left wing populism and anti-capitalist politics with an explicitly pro-capitalist highly social conservative narrative which pinned blame for problems on "international banking" and, ultimately, Jewish people.

The latest flavour is obsessed with talk about "petrodollars" and cryptocurrency, and then you scratch a little and there's the face of Sergei Lavrov or Marie Le Pen hiding under the paint.

The world is f*cked and unjust but not for the reasons that these people go on about.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by digging on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:08AM (#36814714)
Shows where my brain was at yesterday - that was a pretty ill-formed comment. I regret including the term without a fuller understanding of what I was saying, however I reject the notion of being associated with racist populism for making a criticism of the oil-based economy.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:39AM (#36815076)
That's fair, I was more riffing on parent's comment, buzzed on early morning coffee. Not calling you a fascist.

I do agree that the bulk of the foundation of the world's economy is constructed over the petroleum economy. Though I also don't think the nature of power in the world would change significantly if that were to be replaced with something else or if the nationality of the currency it is traded in were to change.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Friday July 21, 2023 @06:45PM (#36820983)
Remember the US is an oil exporter now. Most of this oil analysis stuff is leftover from the 2000s; it's also coming from overly materialist analysis of the Iraq War, where they assumed "this war is for Iraq oil" instead of the real answer which is literally "we invaded Iraq because we felt like it".
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by maerF0x0 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:55PM (#36805879)
afaik food stamps/SNAP/EBT is a charitable thing though, right? ie, the recipients are not trading labor for it, right?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by maerF0x0 on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:31AM (#36814243)
cannot edit, but would like to say

I actually prefer we give out UBI, in a tracked manner, as well.

"cash" they can spend on anything, but with data collection so we can do society improving retrospectives on how it was spent.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hrdwdmrbl on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#36804803)
A CBDC does not necessarily need to be implemented with that capability.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:09PM (#36805286)
No, but big centralized power tends to crave ever more power, control, and surveillance
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by Spivak on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:45PM (#36804885)
I mean if we're talking that level of societal breakdown they would just use the system we already have for tracking semi-restricted purchases which is scanning and reporting your government ID.

Then you can enforce meat and fossil fuel rations with no way to buy yourself around it.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:55PM (#36805875)
I view this type of thinking as the conspiratorially minded's version of "trying to solve social problems with technical solutions".

If there were political motive and will to implement such a system, it could be done without a CBDC and certainly without modernization of ACH (heh).

Conversely, if there's not political motive and will, then the presence of a CBDC doesn't change that fact.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by treyd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:17PM (#36806125)
Why would they want to do that? How would either your employer or the fed have the grounds to justify doing that?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:26PM (#36806256)
Look at what happened with the Canadian protests and banking restrictions.

Many are concerned that cdbc will allow the gov to create carbon rations that are enforced by disallowing purchases. Cash is fungible while regulated digital currency isn't.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by treyd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:54PM (#36809489)
But how could something like a carbon ration possibly be implemented? They'd have to retrofit every PoS system in the nation to classify sales and tag payments with that information. This would already be possible using the existing settlement infrastructure, nothing unique to how a CBDC would work.

Plus, if the goal is to limit carbon emissioms, it's more of a liberal market-shaping attitude that mainstream economists have to simply tax carbon heavy activities rather than invent new and unpopular technological measures to force it to happen. Same applies to the fears about limiting meat consumption, etc.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by johnny22 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:29PM (#36806289)
it's what they do with foodstamps already, is the point. I don't know whether that'll atually happen, but that's the theory.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:55PM (#36806632)
Something along the lines of ‘We face a climate emergency that is even more serious than the Covid emergency, we have to do this, this is about saving lives’?

(I’m not in any way a climate denier, just a huge pessimist when it comes to attempted solutions)

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by zirgs on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:26PM (#36806969)
Payment processors like VISA can already block payments that they don't like. Even if they are completely legal.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by Mistletoe on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:52PM (#36805004)
You are already starting to pigeonhole people with your stereotype. I'm as liberal as they come and I find the thought of a CBDC to be an unimaginable Orwellian nightmare. A boot stamping on the face of civil liberties and privacy forever.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by kvetching on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:23PM (#36808152)
Maybe if our democracy wasn't broken this wouldn't be an issue. The government is supposed to be ran by us, but it's been taken over by bureaucrat cosmopolitans & multi-national corps who have a distinct will to power.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by dboreham on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:38PM (#36803925)
The same thing happens when a town decides to string fiber on their utility poles and sell transit. All sorts of reasons why that's a terrible thing. Same for importing drugs from other countries. And on and on.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:57PM (#36805897)
The ISP duopoly/monopoly is worse from a consumer perspective and functionally equivalent from a civil rights perspective. To think otherwise is naive.

In fact, the private sector solution is perhaps even worse from a civil rights perspective.

Consider a prosecutor in Jurisdiction A hell-bent on violating the civil rights of a citizen in Jurisdiction B, and suppose Jurisdiction B is sympathetic to this citizen. This isn't even hypothetical in the USA. Abortion, immigration, civil disobedience, etc. In the corporate duopoly setup, Jurisdiction A can compel the ISP to comply -- either by physically entering the property of the ISP and taking data by force, or by threatening market access. In the muni ISP case, Jurisdiction B says "shove it".

And that's before noting that corporations such as modern ISPs are -- like governments -- also large bureaucracies endowed with incredible power that are de facto impossible to opt out of. Except at least in representative government you have some sort of voice, however small, which isn't dependent on amassing vast sums of cash.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by rootusrootus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:50PM (#36807834)
> a town decides to string fiber on their utility poles and sell transit

I dream of the day my municipality does this. The idea of buying service from whoever I want rather than be forced to use Comcast... -swoon-

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by oblio on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:25AM (#36812520)
> The same thing happens when a town decides to string fiber on their utility poles and sell transit. All sorts of reasons why that's a terrible thing.

Why is it horrible?

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by chaostheory on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:40PM (#36803946)
* * *
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by CameronNemo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:07PM (#36804331)
Two points of context:

* the Biden administration is planning to monitor smaller denomination transactions (in an inflationary environment!)

* IRS resources historically and presently target low-income, low-wealth households/individuals for audits

https://www.cnbc.com/select/irs-600-reporting-rule-delayed/

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/irs-audit-eitc-five-times-as-li...

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by jonhohle on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:19PM (#36804483)
What benefit would targeting low wealth individuals have to the IRS? I worked on a state tax system briefly at Accenture and they offered the product for a percentage of reclaimed taxes. They started with high debts with good credit scores. Since they had skin in the game (which it could be argued the IRS doesn’t), they wanted to maximize the unpaid taxes they collected.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by genmud on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:32PM (#36804669)
Because wealthier people have more complicated returns and are much more likely to litigate, resulting in more time commitment.

For high net wealth audits, you could have potentially dozens of people working on it for years so there is a possibility that a judge / jury rules in your favor.

They are going after low effort people, but making it up by volume.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by CameronNemo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:44PM (#36804876)
Tax collectors have traditionally extracted from low wealth individuals to enrich wealthy individuals.

I'll let you figure out why.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by DANmode on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:54PM (#36806610)
> What benefit would targeting low wealth individuals have to the IRS?

I'll shorten the explanation even further: many more easy/no contest wins.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:26PM (#36806972)
> What benefit would targeting low wealth individuals have to the IRS?

Wrong question. The correct question is:

What benefit would the IRS targetting low wealth individuals have to high wealth individuals?

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:16PM (#36808940)
Because it's easy to mess up claiming the EITC and only low income people can claim it.

This also depends if by "audits" you include every kind of correction letter the IRS sends you.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:46AM (#36825138)
I got a letter from the IRS today and thought it was some kind of ironic punishment for commenting this, but it turned out it was just warning me I'd used the website last week(??)
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:25PM (#36806952)
IRS auditing targeting has been at the explicit behest of Republican controlled Congresses. That is, they were told to stop/reduce targetting high net worth individuals, or face even further cuts to their budget.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by digging on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:05PM (#36807379)
> IRS resources historically and presently target low-income, low-wealth households/individuals for audits

If we could actually increase their funding substantially, this would be less true, but it's difficult and expensive to go after wealthy individuals.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hitpointdrew on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:39PM (#36804763)
> I don't understand why ~FedNow and CBDC~ BIG BROTHER are such a big issue in the US.

Fixed this for you.

I don't really want a gigantic federal agency having insight into every financial transaction I make. Hard, fucking, pass.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by chimeracoder on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:43PM (#36804851)
> I don't really want a gigantic federal agency having insight into every financial transaction I make. Hard, fucking, pass.

If that's the case, I have bad news for you about the banking system of literally every developed country.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bboygravity on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:01PM (#36805185)
Ever heard of cash?

I can buy an icecream anywhere in the world without anybody tracking me. Even with the "wrong" political opinion (even if I would be a trucker in Canada during certain protests).

I cannot do that with CBDC.

No. CBDC (aka: the ultimate totalitarian's dream) is not the same as the current banking system, despite the current banking system also being very horrible for privacy.

* All of the above assuming that cash will be banned and CBDC will be mandatory for everybody.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by NamTaf on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:35PM (#36805612)
That's a very load-bearing assumption.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:30PM (#36806312)
Not as load bearing when you look at the legal limits of cash transactions in countries in Europe. Also not so load bearing when you consider the unconstitutional civil asset forfeiture of the current US.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:56PM (#36806643)
> I can buy an icecream anywhere in the world without anybody tracking me.

No you can't. Companies like OpenEye and Deep Sentinel offer facial recognition solutions that are targeted at loss-prevention, and these systems are commonplace in the USA. Facial recognition-based consumer analytics systems are also available.

In fact, I think you'd be hard pressed to find a pint of ice cream that you can buy without having a camera pointed at your face. Even the little stand at the beach in the state park near my old place had a camera, and I didn't even have real LTE coverage there.

Privacy comes only from the force of law; not the other way around.

Anyways, the whole conversation is a red herring. This is a replacement for ACH, which already exists, and there isn't substantively more information sharing between banks and governments than already exists.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by amflare on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:18PM (#36806878)
So because malicious parties can track us via other means, we should just allow them to start doing it (even more) through our financial history?

Anyways, it's not (fully) about information sharing. It's about control. It's the difference between read access and read/write access.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:28PM (#36806996)
FedNow doesn't allow any more or less tracking than what's already possible through the Fed's visibility into ACH. So for the purposes of FedNow the entire conversation is off-topic.

Anyways, you missed the point.

The anti-new-technology and anti-gov-technology response to privacy and control is misguided. Corporations will fuck you, left unchecked, and governments will fuck you through corporations. There is no technical solution to political problems, and physical cash vs FedNow vs digital currency is a suite of technical solutions.

Trying to solve a political problem by eliminating technology is literally the same thing as trying to solve political problems with technology. The fallacy is in focusing on technology where the actual problem is political.

The problem is political and needs to be treated as such. The solution is building and maintaining political consensus in favor of strong privacy and personal property rights, not carrying around a billfold full of physical cash.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by kredd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:22PM (#36806924)
The reality is, supermajority (including me) of people prefer not using cash. Especially up here in the North.

Can’t even recall to ever pulling some out other than some casino entertainment night. I understand all the “freedom” (or whatever one might call it) I’m losing, but the positive sides are much better (never have to care about losing my wallet, much faster transactions, convenience and etc.). Sure, sounds bad on paper, but I haven’t felt any negatives in 10+ years, especially when in practice makes my life easier.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by StanislavPetrov on Friday July 21, 2023 @02:07AM (#36810518)
>The reality is, supermajority (including me) of people prefer not using cash. Especially up here in the North.

Unfortunately, in my experience, I'd have to agree with you on that. But it also brings to mind a relevant Samuel Adams quote:

“If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, go home from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains set lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that ye were our countrymen.”

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by itake on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:45PM (#36804884)
Just wondering, but how is this different from our current system where judges can approve search warrants and companies have to comply?

Are you think they won’t need search warrants?

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:29PM (#36806296)
Cash isn't recordable in the same way. I don't provide my id with the transaction when making cash purchases.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by itake on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:20PM (#36806904)
I don't think this service is replacing cash payments unless I am missing something?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:27PM (#36806980)
You are correct. I was thinking cdbc not fednow.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by phpisthebest on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:24PM (#36807581)
It is a step, a big one, to their "dream" of a "cashless society" that we have been on for decades.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by amflare on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:15PM (#36806840)
This is the difference between the government needing a search warrant and having to come to your house, and them needing a search warrant but a law enforcement officer already living in your house. Sure, they still "need a warrant", but that doesn't make the situation acceptable.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by itake on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:14PM (#36807488)
Do you think private unregulated businesses (CashApp, Venmo, etc.) that this is trying to replace are any better? These companies just sell your transaction data to the highest bidder, no warrant needed.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by amflare on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:24PM (#36815777)
But these companies don't have a legal monopoly on force. It's in my best interest, if I have to deal with both these problems, to keep them separated.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by Analemma_ on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:00PM (#36805161)
Are you under the impression that ACH, the thing FedNow is replacing, is free from government influence?

This is what's bizarre to me about the FedNow hysteria. It's not a government system replacing a private market system. It's a government system replacing an older, worse government system. It's like having a panic attack because the Federal Reserve is updating their PCs to from Windows XP to Windows 10.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by dylanlacom on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:54PM (#36806624)
Because Nacha (and ACH) is explicitly not a government system
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:15PM (#36806838)
ACH involves the Federal Reserve Bank in every transfer. FedNow involves the Federal Reserve Bank in every transfer.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by biesnecker on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:22PM (#36806918)
To be fair only about half of US ACH traffic flows through the Fed (the other half goes through the Clearing House Payments Company), but the Fed is very much involved (and a critical component of) the ACH network, even if the system is not explicitly a government one.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by delfinom on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:50AM (#36814481)
Nacha governs the ACH network and does not operate anything. The actual processing is split between the Fed and a company called Clearing House.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by kelnos on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:32PM (#36807655)
Ignoring the fact that FedNow doesn't change much in this regard...

I'm torn on this. Visa, MasterCard, Venmo (aka PayPal), etc. all know about large subsets of my transactions, and they go and sell my personal data to other companies in sleazy ways to cover their costs.

Is that better or worse than the government knowing all this stuff? Sure, the government can also legally use force against me and deprive me of my freedom and possessions, and might pervert my transaction history into justifying doing bad things to me. But that's a risk, not a certainty. Private companies selling my data and using it in nefarious ways is a certainty.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by just-ok on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:54PM (#36808388)
Can’t the government just buy this data from them, anyway?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by delfinom on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:53AM (#36814529)
They can and do. The government doesn't need a warrant to buy data from a databroker selling your information wholesale.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by pas on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:04PM (#36808454)
don't forget SARs to FinCEN and other AML requirements

the government already knows.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by JakeAl on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:29AM (#36814940)
It's not about KNOWING, it's about CONTROLLING. The concern is they can shut off your ability to make transactions if you don't cooperate with whatever their agenda is at any given moment, like what the truckers in Canada protesting vax mandates experienced.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by pas on Sunday July 23, 2023 @01:16AM (#36832740)
in effect the requirement to file these activity reports leads to banks simply requesting a lot of data from clients (contracts, trading data, invoices), and if you can't convince them, they'll eventually close your account. so you go to a different bank. their compliance department eventually also starts asking questions, and so on.

the freezing of accounts related to the "Freedom Convoy" is quite different, as it was an exercise of emergency powers. the Trudeau admin could have ordered gas stations to not sell fuel to them, or Visa/MasterCard to not process certain cards, or anything similarly extraordinary.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by flagrant_taco on Friday July 21, 2023 @08:38AM (#36813082)
We can stop private companies from selling that data if we wanted to. Once the federal government has direct control of our financial transactions, how do we limit what they can do with that power?

The point of keeping the government out of the banking business would be to keep the door cracked for the chance to improve it later. That door slams shut once the federal government has the insights into every transaction, and more importantly the ability to deny ones they don't want us to do. We also Wil have much less control over the creation of a social credit score, theoretically the government would have everything it needs to make that happen with control over our transactions.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by patmorgan23 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:42PM (#36808300)
You know they already do right? If you pay or get paid by direct deposit or check those all run through the fed.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by sMarsIntruder on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:25AM (#36810302)
Seems to me people is failing to understand what CBDCs will bring, especially even more “bad money” and economic slavery caused by “incentives” to spend.

But the list goes on..

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by callalex on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:30AM (#36810316)
Please explain to me what FedNow changes compared to the current ACH system in regards to government recording of transactions? Please explain to me how FedNow prevents cash transactions from occurring, or otherwise justify your statement “every financial transaction I make”?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by danielmarkbruce on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:52PM (#36805846)
FedNow isn't a big issue.

CBDC really isn't a big issue either, because it almost certainly won't happen. Americans are very unlikely to want a system like that.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by atentaten on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:12PM (#36806816)
Americans didn't want a central bank, but look at where we are.

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli...

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by danielmarkbruce on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:34PM (#36807060)
The "central bank" americans fought hard against in the first place didn't have the same function as the modern central bank started last century.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by flagrant_taco on Friday July 21, 2023 @08:34AM (#36813056)
Many of the arguments revolve around concerns that the government will gain too much control, power, and personal information. It the government directly controls financial transactions they know every transaction we make, and more importantly can deny transactions they don't like.

Arguably the US government effectively has these powers today, but beingtthat they don't directly own our banks there is a level of red tape they have to go through. As long as they are technically separate there is also the opportunity for us to change the laws and strip them of that access, once combined we give up that possibility.

The US was originally design with a very strong distrust of our own federal government. For the last 80 years we've completely flipped the script and given more and more power to a massive federal government, but the undertone of distrust is still around for quite a few Americans.