News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by lbotos on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:40PM (#36803944)
Because there are many Americans who are small gov and against excessive taxation. A CBDC is "too far" for a lot of people who believe that.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:18PM (#36804477)
Imagine being paid in a ‘programmable’ currency that your employer (or government) decides cannot be spent on alcohol, meat, or fossil fuels.

Meanwhile, wealthier people get paid in ‘unrestricted’ currency.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by candiddevmike on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:24PM (#36804561)
That already exists today, food stamps/SNAP/EBT for low income and dollars for everyone else

I'd just as soon give everyone dollars via UBI

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by imtringued on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#36804753)
Honestly, if governments paid out all social benefits in a demurrage currency which they accept for tax payments, they would save a lot of money because the velocity and therefore fiscal multiplier of a demurrage currency is very high.

Christian Gelleri made this proposal to solve the Greek crisis: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3144910

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by realce on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#36805638)
Your employer doesn't pay you in food stamps, they pay you in money you can use to buy anything you need in the entire world.

The government provides coupons that allow you to buy food which is remediated to the seller in dollars. The authority and funding to provide that service is something that voters can impact or change.

These are very different things, not "that already exists" at all.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by digging on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:02PM (#36807337)
> they pay you in money you can use to buy anything you need in the entire world.

This is an primarily American phenomenon though and it's only really true because of the dominance of the US and US petrodollars over global society. It's probably not easy to spend Turkish lira in Madagascar, for example. Yes there are banks which will exchange approved currencies, but that's one step removed from being paid in a global global currency as you imply.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:14PM (#36808920)
"Petrodollars" are completely unimportant. They just mean Saudi Arabia's financial reserves, and KSA is not a large country so it wouldn't matter if they abandoned the dollar.

If anyone ever mentions petrodollars, CBDC, or crypto to you, they are crazy and I recommend stealing their wallet.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 21, 2023 @08:27AM (#36813010)
The populist right's obsession with currency -- pointing fingers at state banks and currency systems and money lenders and so on -- is a product of their unwillingness to point fingers at real corporate sources of power & control in the world. In large part because they're sympathetic to them (or outright funded by them in some cases.)

At best this kind of stuff is a harmless ideological pressure release valve for a discontented middle class / small business / entrepreneurial layer squeezed from above (esp after COVID). At worst it veers into outright authoritarian & xenophobic politics and often blends in some anti-Semitism. Starts with rants about Bretton-Woods and the next thing you know you're hearing about the Rothschilds.

There was a whole wing of this stuff ascendant in the 1930s (in western Canada we had "Social Credit", for example) whose ideological purpose was to displace left wing populism and anti-capitalist politics with an explicitly pro-capitalist highly social conservative narrative which pinned blame for problems on "international banking" and, ultimately, Jewish people.

The latest flavour is obsessed with talk about "petrodollars" and cryptocurrency, and then you scratch a little and there's the face of Sergei Lavrov or Marie Le Pen hiding under the paint.

The world is f*cked and unjust but not for the reasons that these people go on about.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by digging on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:08AM (#36814714)
Shows where my brain was at yesterday - that was a pretty ill-formed comment. I regret including the term without a fuller understanding of what I was saying, however I reject the notion of being associated with racist populism for making a criticism of the oil-based economy.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by cmrdporcupine on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:39AM (#36815076)
That's fair, I was more riffing on parent's comment, buzzed on early morning coffee. Not calling you a fascist.

I do agree that the bulk of the foundation of the world's economy is constructed over the petroleum economy. Though I also don't think the nature of power in the world would change significantly if that were to be replaced with something else or if the nationality of the currency it is traded in were to change.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by astrange on Friday July 21, 2023 @06:45PM (#36820983)
Remember the US is an oil exporter now. Most of this oil analysis stuff is leftover from the 2000s; it's also coming from overly materialist analysis of the Iraq War, where they assumed "this war is for Iraq oil" instead of the real answer which is literally "we invaded Iraq because we felt like it".
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by maerF0x0 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:55PM (#36805879)
afaik food stamps/SNAP/EBT is a charitable thing though, right? ie, the recipients are not trading labor for it, right?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by maerF0x0 on Friday July 21, 2023 @10:31AM (#36814243)
cannot edit, but would like to say

I actually prefer we give out UBI, in a tracked manner, as well.

"cash" they can spend on anything, but with data collection so we can do society improving retrospectives on how it was spent.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hrdwdmrbl on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#36804803)
A CBDC does not necessarily need to be implemented with that capability.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:09PM (#36805286)
No, but big centralized power tends to crave ever more power, control, and surveillance
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by Spivak on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:45PM (#36804885)
I mean if we're talking that level of societal breakdown they would just use the system we already have for tracking semi-restricted purchases which is scanning and reporting your government ID.

Then you can enforce meat and fossil fuel rations with no way to buy yourself around it.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by ke88y on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:55PM (#36805875)
I view this type of thinking as the conspiratorially minded's version of "trying to solve social problems with technical solutions".

If there were political motive and will to implement such a system, it could be done without a CBDC and certainly without modernization of ACH (heh).

Conversely, if there's not political motive and will, then the presence of a CBDC doesn't change that fact.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by treyd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:17PM (#36806125)
Why would they want to do that? How would either your employer or the fed have the grounds to justify doing that?
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by hellojesus on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:26PM (#36806256)
Look at what happened with the Canadian protests and banking restrictions.

Many are concerned that cdbc will allow the gov to create carbon rations that are enforced by disallowing purchases. Cash is fungible while regulated digital currency isn't.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by treyd on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:54PM (#36809489)
But how could something like a carbon ration possibly be implemented? They'd have to retrofit every PoS system in the nation to classify sales and tag payments with that information. This would already be possible using the existing settlement infrastructure, nothing unique to how a CBDC would work.

Plus, if the goal is to limit carbon emissioms, it's more of a liberal market-shaping attitude that mainstream economists have to simply tax carbon heavy activities rather than invent new and unpopular technological measures to force it to happen. Same applies to the fears about limiting meat consumption, etc.

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by johnny22 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:29PM (#36806289)
it's what they do with foodstamps already, is the point. I don't know whether that'll atually happen, but that's the theory.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by bluescrn on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:55PM (#36806632)
Something along the lines of ‘We face a climate emergency that is even more serious than the Covid emergency, we have to do this, this is about saving lives’?

(I’m not in any way a climate denier, just a huge pessimist when it comes to attempted solutions)

Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by zirgs on Thursday July 20, 2023 @05:26PM (#36806969)
Payment processors like VISA can already block payments that they don't like. Even if they are completely legal.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by Mistletoe on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:52PM (#36805004)
You are already starting to pigeonhole people with your stereotype. I'm as liberal as they come and I find the thought of a CBDC to be an unimaginable Orwellian nightmare. A boot stamping on the face of civil liberties and privacy forever.
Re:Fed Opens Service That Dramatically Speeds Up U.S. Payments by kvetching on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:23PM (#36808152)
Maybe if our democracy wasn't broken this wouldn't be an issue. The government is supposed to be ran by us, but it's been taken over by bureaucrat cosmopolitans & multi-national corps who have a distinct will to power.