News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by AltruisticGapHN on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:08AM (#36695674)
I agree with recent TWiT discussion on this : we've had it good for a while - the promise of free internet but all those services cost money to keep running.

I don't have an issue with paying Youtube Premium Lite. Where I have an issue with the subs model is you're pay subs to so many services, YT Netflix Twitch, etc. It adds up pretty quickly, and costs way more than traditional TV used to cost.

Then there's the issue of online magazines. I find most even including Wired, to be too random in terms of content. Itś really easy for me to rationalize the worth of YT : irreplacable. But all those online "news" site that churn out tons of SEO optimized articles and "top ten (insert random hardware)" lists etc? Really difficult for me to warrant a subscription.

Now if someone maintained a really big forum, like there ś a few still running with tons of sub forums where you can spend an hour everyday and get a ton of interaction. Sure, I'd sub to that.

Even Reddit for me it's hard to think why I'd pay for it, even though it is also irreplacable in some way. Perhaps because it is primarily a social site, there is so much abuse, so much idiocy, so much "hive mind" and so much negativity/sarcasm overall - it easily shadows the good side of reddit : the helpful/kind replies, the sharing of useful guides etc.

So huh.. Maybe it is like the TWiT panel agreed, the "free for all" internet is dying, and some sites/ services may well disappear and maybe that's not a bad thing. Maybe there are better ideas to replace them.

If it was just me I´d bring back huge forums. There's gotta be a way to monetize those through Patreon/etc. Theres lots of small perks you can give to forum members. Maybe they still have a life in them, but they were just made seemingly obsolete for a while by "social media" sites like Twitter and Instagram.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by meristohm on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:28AM (#36696004)
WIRED, among many other periodicals, is available online through https://libbyapp.com at my local tax-funded public library (I'm in the USA). I do wonder how things would change if most people started using the library for most of their entertainment and education, as I do.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by WOTERMEON on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:42AM (#36706828)
Libraries would get charged more for a bigger number of magazines that are just a collection of ads. That’s what happens in the UK.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by garciasn on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:16AM (#36695804)
This is EXACTLY what cable companies predicted would happen when we went a la carte. They were using their monopoly power to drive down the overall price of packaged TV and by de-bundling, we end up paying more overall. For once they were correct and I apologize for questioning it 15 years ago.

That said, I am ok with SOME advertisements to keep the web running. There are two big problems with this:

1. Market investors expect their stock to continue to rise, forever. When it doesn't, they push for more revenue, but instead of adding new products or functionality, they push for ad revenue instead.

2. Ad revenue as a model for revenue generation means that we need more ads, as opposed to building better products. This means that the entire web is inundated with advertisements that overwhelm the overall experience and will continue to get worse and worse over time.

This is a product of investment and lack of reinvestment in new products/function and instead more immediate revenue gains as opposed to slow-and-steady rise in value. Investors want to cash in NOW and not over time and thus we have entered a time where 3 ads precede every video alongside in-video sponsorships and more traditional 15-30 second ads within each. It's absurd.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:42AM (#36696269)
> That said, I am ok with SOME advertisements to keep the web running.

Personally, I have no problem with ad-funded stuff. The problem that I have is with the spying that comes along with online ads. I can see no way that could ever be acceptable.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by doctorpangloss on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:32AM (#36696075)
> They were using their monopoly power to drive down the overall price of packaged TV and by de-bundling, we end up paying more overall.

This is complicated. Piracy sold Comcast broadband Internet connections for many. Napster long predates Comcast's acquisition of NBCUniversal, when it became a content maker.

So even in the last two decades, looking at one company, it played some, or all, sides of the producer ecosystem, in complex ways, sometimes 200% changing (sticking a minus sign in front of) how it benefits from consumer trends. If you want to analyze any specific thing about cable TV pricing, you're going to need to write a whole dissertation about it. Meanwhile "whatever the consumer is willing to bear" will get you most of the way there.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by rconti on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:37AM (#36696168)
A significant number of the streaming services people complain about paying for offer services that cable companies never did.

Plus, I can choose which streaming services I want, and how long I want to pay for them. And everything is on-demand. And there are no ads (except on YTTV).

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by alistairSH on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:28AM (#36695996)
we end up paying more overall

A basic Fios TV package is $75/month today.

Most streaming services are around $20-$30/month and allow month-to-month plans.

You can fairly easily rotate among 4-5 services, using 2-3 at a time, to keep costs lower than with traditional cable. This works pretty well if you have non-specific TV interests. Where they really get you is with sports - that market is super fragmented and getting most of NFL, NBA, NHL, and MLB can cost a fortune.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by garciasn on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:41AM (#36696244)
FIOS is only available in limited areas of 9 states. It's not exactly widely available and should not be used as evidence to the contrary of this. If we're using anecdotal evidence, the only Internet I have available to me at my summer home is $110/month 25/2 DSL, without TV.

That said, you are spot on, because we are no longer tied into long contracts you can absolutely swap in and out. The problem is that they carry primarily self-created content which, IMO, is far less attractive than what the main networks were able to push out previously which further degrades the usefulness of the a la carte model.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by alistairSH on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:51AM (#36696448)
Cox Cable is $56/month. Pick whatever TV provider you want, they're all in the $50-$100 range for a basic package in most parts of the US.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by SoftTalker on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:56AM (#36696522)
If you're paying more you're probably getting more.

Old cable TV had about 5 channels that I ever watched and 50 that I did not care about.

A sports network + Netflix is not more than cable. If you subscribe to much more than that, you're probably getting more than a bundled cable deal used to provide.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by Pet_Ant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:14AM (#36695765)
I mean I don't think the criticism that it costs more than traditional TV is valid. Traditional TV is a linear stream where you are sending out one signal for everyone. On demand is a different beast altogether, so even if it were the exact cost or more, then it'd still be a win. That's not even including the fact that the content that gets made of YouTube or Twitch wouldn't have ever been made on old TV. If you had told me 20 years ago that it would cost the same or even a bit more but you get all this, I'd've signed up in a heartbeat.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by nonameiguess on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:33AM (#36696079)
I can't agree that it costs more. I'm a pretty profligate spender and just subscribe to everything even though I don't actually watch that much television. So right now, my household is subscribed to YouTube Premium, Peacock, Paramount+, Disney+, Max, Apple TV+, Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hulu, and Curiosity Stream. I'm honestly not even sure what it costs, but guessing somewhere in the arena of $10 a month or so on average, since some are more, some are less. That's $100. The last time I was subscribed to premium cable with at least HBO, Showtime, and ESPN, it was $180 a month. In 2011 dollars. That was also linear, not on-demand, so quite a bit worse service. We had to pay extra for a DVR that could record stuff and I don't even remember how much extra that was.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by russh on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:03PM (#36697797)
This is my experience as well. We have at least 6 streaming services and it’s still $100/mo cheaper than my direct tv bill.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by SoftTalker on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:54AM (#36696492)
A problem with many paid services is that they still have ads.

Was watching something with my wife the other day (I think it was on HBO streaming) and there were ads? I'm like "hang on we're paying for this, and still have to watch ads?"

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by lastofthemojito on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:03PM (#36696659)
Infuriatingly, Hulu sometimes shows ads even with their more expensive "No Ads" plans: https://help.hulu.com/s/article/ads-no-commercials
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by joenot443 on Friday July 14, 2023 @07:41AM (#36722440)
>Due to streaming rights, a few shows in the Hulu streaming library will include a short ad break before and after each episode for Hulu (No Ads) subscribers.

Man, that is aggravating. Blaming it on "streaming rights" as well, what a crock!

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by pests on Friday July 14, 2023 @06:30PM (#36730802)
Considering how odd it is and how few shows out of their catalog I'm sure it is an issue with streaming rights with a few shows.

A few shows probably tied payments to the associated ad revenue and they wanted to ensure that didn't go to 0 with ad free streaming.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by dangrossman on Saturday July 15, 2023 @02:47AM (#36734235)
It's one single show out of the 2500+ in their catalog, one they licensed before the "no ads" offering existed (Grey's Anatomy). It's neither aggravating nor a crock.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by IIsi50MHz on Saturday July 15, 2023 @08:41PM (#36742298)
I've never seen this show, yet it seems we are unable to convince Hulu accept enough money to not show ads. Some parts, like the Live TV addon are almost understandable, but still…disappointing. Especially when the not actually watching live (via start-over or 'recording') yet the ads are somehow still unskippable. Other times, a random item on a network where we've not seen ads wild suddenly have ads.

And there's usually no way to know before trying to watch something if it will be bastardised by ads. We could try revealing the progressbar every time we start a show, to look for the yellow marks that indicate ads…but somehow always just watch until the first frustration appears, and then decide whether to continue. At least some pay-extra addon channels can be relied on to not have ads (unless you count a leader that tells about some other show that channel has).

Hulu and Prime seem very much "FU, pay me.". Especially Prime, with all the attempts to get me to either rent-or-'buy' or watch things with ads, and making it increasingly difficult to identify or find items that are included with the existing subscriptions.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by lastofthemojito on Saturday July 15, 2023 @08:44PM (#36742327)
That list has dwindled, which is good. It definitely used to have more shows on it - when I experienced this issue a few years ago it was not with Grey's Anatomy. Still, it's just jarring for them to have an ad-supported tier and and a "no ads" tier, with the "no ads" tier having a big ol' asterisk and "well, really almost no ads, but you still might see some".
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by dangrossman on Saturday July 15, 2023 @02:46AM (#36734231)
On a single show out of 2500+, Grey's Anatomy, because their license to that show predates the "no ads" offering.

This should not infuriate anyone.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by Aardwolf on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:57AM (#36696537)
People who pay for stuff are more valuable targets for ads
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by coding123 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:33PM (#36697210)
It's almost like Unions of the 1950s was for workers. Its 2023 and now we need Unions for consumers.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:18PM (#36698084)
Interestingly enough, Consumers Union -- the nonprofit that publishes Consumer Reports -- was started by striking workers in the mid 1930s for just this purpose.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by wiml on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:22PM (#36702474)
Ha, that was my reaction to cable TV, too.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by AltruisticGapHN on Thursday July 13, 2023 @06:27AM (#36707104)
Yeah it's pretty ridiculous, that's the reason why I don't sub to anybody on Twitch even though I am super grateful for some streamers I've watched for years : you still get ads on all the other channels... which is ridiculous since by nature the site is supposed to encourage you to browse and discover lots of creators. It would be like you sub to a channel on TV and they remove ads, but as soon as you switch to another channel you gets ads. The F?
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by itsoktocry on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:17PM (#36696913)
>It adds up pretty quickly, and costs way more than traditional TV used to cost.

I have trouble understanding this complaint.

There's way more content than ever before; why wouldn't it be more expensive to get everything? You don't have to subscribe to it all, but the ability to pick and choose providers a la carte, as well as cycle subscriptions on and off seems like a huge win to consumers.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by damnesian on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:03PM (#36700867)
Well, true, except entertainment consumers want a good variety. And ideally, they'd like it priced like a utility, a monthly payment they can budget for.

Before it was taken over by infomercials and reality tv, cable offered unprecedented variety, all for one manageable monthly payment. this is still what people want. This will be what the market gravitates towards, and we see it happening now with cheaper ad-supported tiers and even many 100% free with ads small players. Streaming is, in effect, slowly becoming cable tv all over again. Hell, some of these free channels- like PlutoTV- even look like cable. I predict eventually which aggregator you choose- Roku, Firestick, AppleTV- won't matter, it will be the same galaxy of choices.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by hinkley on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:18AM (#36705988)
Production values for TV shows have quite gotten out of hand. I like it, but that’s a lot of advertising or fees to pay for those.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by dangus on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:28PM (#36697105)
Don’t underestimate how much cable TV costs: I did my budget recently and added up all my services together, having Netflix (highest tier), YT Premium (family, includes music streaming), Discovery+ (ad-free), and Hulu (ad-free), an all comes in at about $62.

That’s about the same price as live cable as a standalone product, and yet cable has advertisements which none of the above services have.

About the only complaint you might have is that I haven’t covered every single television studio (not included: Max, Paramount+, Disney+), but you could always rotate subscriptions in and out and still have a lot of them active at the same time.

Cable really just is that bad. Or, alternative take, cable sucks your dollars away and sends them to live sports and cable news.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by OkayPhysicist on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:20PM (#36699312)
I think that will drive a lot more self-funded communities. People talk about how expensive it is to host websites, but they're talking about sites several orders of magnitude larger than what most communities need. A single Discord server could effectively be hosted on a Raspberry Pi, the market price among cloud hosts for which is "free", or at most ~$10 a month.

That's not "We need to charge for access" level pricing that's "One motivated party funds the entire site" level cost.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by tornato7 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:51PM (#36699847)
To make this happen, we need better open source forum software. A group of us have been searching for a good self-hosted forum to replace /r/BuyItForLife and have trialed quite a few, but they are just... Really bad.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by bsder on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:17PM (#36701040)
Define: really bad.

I generally find the software is fine.

The problem is login/security and spam control. Those are painful things that I really, really, really don't want to have to deal with. Yet they are the vast majority of the issue with self-hosting your own forums.

Self-hosted forums are not a technical problem--they are a social problem.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by tornato7 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:52PM (#36715056)
You're correct. I do think login/security is mostly solved if you're OK using Google/GitHub/Apple login.

It's the moderation that's a tough part. Many forums end up with over-eager spam filters or captchas that end up driving away regular users.

I do hope that with cost reductions in LLMs we'll be able to have effective AI moderators soon enough.

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by baud147258 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @04:29AM (#36706378)
as an user, xenoforo seemed fine? But then I never had to deal with the admin side of things
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by tornato7 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:49PM (#36715021)
Xenoforo is OK, but it has the same problems of any other forum:

- Time-based comment and post ordering means you're reading a lot of spam like "bump" and "first"

- If there is more than one conversation in a thread, they don't flow as well as they do in a hierarchy format like on HN/Reddit

- Because of user profile pictures, comments take up a lot of space and you can only see 3-4 comments on one screen

- Not very mobile-friendly

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by baud147258 on Friday July 14, 2023 @10:51AM (#36724825)
bump/first style comments are more a problem of moderation/community culture (personaly, on the 3 forum-based communities I've been part of, I've never met this issue)

I agree with the other issues

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by bradlys on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:49PM (#36701454)
When people make the comparison to the cost of cable TV and so forth - I feel like people forget: you were paying for TV and still got shown a ton of advertisements. About a quarter of air time was just advertising. That is usually higher than anything you’ll see on the Internet even for content you aren’t paying for. I’m not even including all the weird product placement aspects and other such things.

Paying for these services to not see ads is still a win compared to most cable tv…

Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by sam0x17 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @04:52PM (#36701500)
As someone who "grew up" on the internet and was very active in internet forums and places in the early 00s as early as age 10, I struggle to see how kids are going to continue to be a huge part of internet discourse and consumption if everything is behind a paywall. That's, like, literally the only problem I have with this line of thought. Other than that, I completely agree. I'd rather pay than have ads be there in the first place in most cases.
Re:The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:15PM (#36701789)
"I agree with recent TWiT discussion on this : we've had it good for a while - the promise of free internet but all those services cost money to keep running."

Most internet users pay for internet access. Many pay dearly. Perhaps those born into a world where internet subscriptions are essential are more prone to ignore this subscription cost. In the US, it is quite substantial. Internet access is definitely not free. That way it is bundled today in the US, it is quite expensive.

The apparent presumption that there would be nothing for free to be found on the internet without advertising was disproven when the www went public in 1993. As a user since that time, I have noticed that it's too irresistable to publish on the internet, whether the publisher is making money from such publication or not, i.e., so-called "monetisation" in today's terminology.^1 As I recall, commercial entities of all types and sizes were publishing for free. Nevermind individual home subscribers. Initially, before ISps, one had to get their internet subscription through their employer or university. I thought the publication of so much free content was astonishing.^2 In the ensuing 30 years the trend has not abated.

There was plenty of free content on the www then, as there continues to be now. IME and IMO, there will always be free content available on the internet. Even more, most internet content today is published by individual home internet users, not corporations.

1. Back then, I do not recall use of the term "monetisation" however there was discussion of "e-commerce". To be clear, I'm not sure the vision of e-commerce was the collection of data about internet users and its use in the sale of advertising services, i.e., today's idea of "monetisation". The term "monetisation" seems to imply that selling widgets over the internet is not a viable business plan. This makes sense if the plan is actually not to build a business that must reconcile profit and loss but instead to obtain mindless venture capital and unreal "unicorn" valuations, not to mention "exits" via absurdly anti-competitive acquisitions.

2. Perhaps this is comparable to the opinions today that suggest there would be no free content if not for "monetisation" via VC money, wanton data collection and sale of online advertising services. As I was not directly paying subscriber fees to an ISP, I believed in 1993 that it made no sense for commercial entities to provide "free" content over the internet, e.g., content that could be sold in meatspace. That belief about "free" was mistaken. It was not long before generally all internet users were paying internet subscriber fees. Nothing was "free".