Apart from repairing structural damage such as missing bonds, the cell can even repair missing bases or non-straight breaks without loss. This mechanism is also used for replication: the entire strand is split and each half is completed with its mirror counterpart.
By using base-4, there's enough space to permit lossiness of the coding itself - given the number of amino acids and the 3-NT encoding.
So you really aren't optimizing JUST for nucleotide encoding, but you're also optimizing in concert with 3-nt/AA, and 20AA codes.
So if you have to optimize for information density and fidelity, given X-nucleotides, Y nucleotides/AA, and Z AAs, and sample as much chemical and physical diversity in those AAs life has settled upon: X=4, Y=3, Z=20.
If we went with X=3, you might need Y=4 to get the same kind of fidelity, but that cranks up your energy costs by 30% (from 3 to 4 NT per AA).
Some DNA is used to attract other proteins, or even interact with DNA elsewhere on the strand, or is translated to RNA (one-on-one) which can then have a function based on its sequence or the structure it folds into.
Any 'logic' there is, is built _on top_ of this.
Why did we end up with only 20 proteinogenic amino acids? Why are vertebrate neural architectures inverted (cell bodies on the inside, connections on the outside, even though the other way round way (eg. like a squids brain is organised) is easier and less inhibitive to growth?
2 Reasons:
a) Because nature and evolution cannot engineer. Random mutation, recombination and natural selection are the only mechanisms available. Things get selected if they outcompete existing alternatives, they don't need to be the best solutions.
b) All solutions have to be built by modifying what already exists. Evolution doesn't get to do greenfield projects, because anything that has to start from scratch is so disadvantaged in natural selection compared to already evolved complex life, it will fail.
This leads to systems that, from an engineering point of view, don't always make a lot of sense.
Eg. the architecture of the vertebrate neural system creates a lot of issues (eg. our light sensitive cells point in the wrong direction). The only way this makes any sense if when one looks at how the neural tube (the precursor to the backbone) is formed by the endodermis folding in on itself. This process is so deeply at the root of the Chordata, and so many other things depend on it, that it simply cannot change any more.
Many many biological systems are "legacy systems" in the truest sense of the word: Solutions produced a long time ago that may have many problems, but are simply too deeply enmeshed with everything that came after, that they are now impossible to change.
Mind elaborating on that?
Because there is no biochemical reason why DNA could not have incorporated, say, a third pairing pair, so while base-3 (which I don't specifically mention in my post btw.) wouldn't work, base 6 or 8 would have been possible. "Unnatural Base Pairs" are even known to work in laboratory settings.
There is also no biochemical reason why base2 life wouldn't work. Expand the reading frame of the translation machinery to 5 instead of three, and you have enough coding space for polypeptides.
My answer adresses the question completely, because the only reason behind these "decisions" is an ancient system that simply got "frozen", and now cannot change any more.
are you sure about that? are you sure there's no weird effects that might destabilize very long sequences of 2-nucleotide DNA? or on how wide DNA-binding domains have to be to cope with reduced information density, and how that might sterically hinder smaller arrangements of proteins?
> My answer adresses the question completely, because the only reason behind these "decisions" is an ancient system that simply got "frozen", and now cannot change any more.
your answer is just a hypothesis, not a proof. these things can be studied (by studying abiogenesis in-vitro), and it's not certain these decisions were "flash frozen" like you describe. 2-, 4-, and 6- nucleotide coding systems might have coexisted in the RNA world, and 4- could have won out for some reason.
Yes, I am sure about that, because I used to study Biology before going into IT. And we had a lovely lecture in which we used to discuss theoretical setups for lifeforms at a molecular level.
2 nucleotide DNA isn't necessarily less stable. AT-rich domains have less bindings, but if stablity is the issue, use CG instead (3 bindings)...although that is also a compromise, because then opening DNA for transcription gets more difficult.
> your answer is just a hypothesis, not a proof.
My answer is what we observe in evolutionary biology.
I have given an example outside of the molecular world for a reason. There is no real advantage to the inversion of the neural architecture in Chordata, it just didn't matter when the neural tube formation mechanisms came to be. Now, with mammals having huge brains and complex sensory organs, the warts in that design show.
The proof for that is easy to come by, (also a reason btw. why the neural inversion is my favorite example for this): Look an any Protostomia. Their neural system isn't inverted. Consequently, Squids don't have a visual blind spot.
for instance, I've seen arguments that the codon mapping, and even the particular set of protein- coding amino acids, that we ended up with was arbitrary, but I've also read papers arguing that the amino acids include a sort of spanning set of different structural scaffolds with different polarity that happen to mesh well with DNA, and that the particular choices of codons were influenced by how the RNA t-acyl transferases arose, etc.
so, I'm still unconvinced, but I find this area fascinating to read about.
> your answer is just a hypothesis, not a proof. these things can be studied (by studying abiogenesis in-vitro), and it's not certain these decisions were "flash frozen" like you describe. 2-, 4-, and 6- nucleotide coding systems might have coexisted in the RNA world, and 4- could have won out for some reason.
His hypothesis is, at least in part, “4- won for some reasons for which we have no explanation, and it stayed that way for some reason [that we may or may not know].” I suppose the reason would be that 4- was somehow better suited for the particular use-case at the time.
Of course there’s a ton of interesting details to discuss to discover, and whether if multiple systems coexisted is one of many fascinating things to discuss, and his response never said otherwise.
That's true, but a) not the point I am making, and b) I am pretty sure it says nowhere in my post that it would.
Can you expand on that? Are you talking about front-facing eyes vs. birds' eyes? Or something else like retinal structure?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina#Inverted_versus_non-inv...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina#/media/File:Retina-diag...
Edit: ninja'd
But that doesn't mean the setup makes sense, and that is exactly my point.
And long term, this has an impact. For example, vertebrate brain size is limited by the simple factor, that we have to put all the connections on the outside. The more neuronal bodies we have, the more connections they require.
N <---> N
In this clumsy diagram, 2 neurons talk with the connections on the inside. However, vertebrate brains have to do this instead: +--------------+
| |
+-> N N <-+
It's easy to see how the second setup becomes prohibitive when more Neurons are added to it. The brains of Protostomia again don't have that problem...they can have the connections on the inside, and the neuron bodies on the outside, aka. the logical setup.Now there are ways around that, eg. Reptile and Bird brains grow in bulbs that theoretically allow sustained growth without the connective layer getting in the way. But similar to the reflective layer in our eyes, this is not a setup that's there because it makes a lot of sense...it's a hack, a workaround for some "legacy system", that is now so enmeshed, it's impossible to change.
Lefthand is a vertebrate eye, righthand is a squids eye.
In Vertebrates (really in all Chordata), the light sensitive "tips" of the sensory cells point inwards, aka. the exact wrong direction. At the base of the cells are the axons (nerve connections) which transmit the information into the brain.
Due to the aforementioned orientation, these axons run along the outer layer of our light sensitive cells, and at some point have to travel "invards" towards the brain. At that point there can be no cell bodies, and that's the "visual blind spot" of our eyes.
A squids eye doesn't have that problem; all the light sensitive cells point outwards, the axons are at the innermost layer, and connectivity can be achieved without a blind spot (also, they don't need a reflective layer).
Hubris and attempts to alter inherent nature are often tied up ironically. But we can benefit a lot more from biological humility, realizing there are many unknown unknowns.
One, is that base 4 makes a lot of sense for the stability of DNA structures. You have two purines, two pyrimadines.
Another is that partly because codons are degenerate, the distribution is way off a uniform distribution. For chemistry and mol bio reasons, the distribution of AGTC is very skewed.
When i fully wake up, this might be a fun blog post to draft.
Which is a problem given DNA is a lossy format.
This ratio is what leads to base e being the theoretical maximum.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repeated_sequence_(DNA)
Many real wire protocols have mechanisms to prevent repeated sequences entirely
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8b/10b_encoding
DNA coding for real proteins is unlikely to be too terribly repetitive but I image a long α helix could have a repetitive amino acid sequence. Many amino acids can be coded with variant codons, I guess if repetition were a problem in a particular gene natural selection could step in.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinucleotide_repeat_expansi...
TLDR: DNA triplet repeat expansions cause diseases like Huntington's disease.
Binary for electronics is obvious because there are 2 states in electric components: on or off. There is no 3rd option.
DNA base set, Amino acid set, Translation layer between DNA/Proteins.
Currently, we've got: 4 DNA bases, 3 bases/AA, 20 AAs; 4^3 => 20
If you change one of those numbers, you'll need to rejigger the rest, and you'd need to reoptimize. And there are competing goals which at least include: - maximize access to biophysical/chemical diversity - minimize energy expenditure to produce each component, chemically - minimize energy expenditure to both copy instructions & produce products - maximize information fidelity - minimize or at least degrade gracefully in the context of errors
In the context of a 3-base system, you very well could throw off those optimizations given the consequences for the other 2 parameters (#AA & nt/AA). 3^3 = 27, which is very close to the maximum of 20 amino acids. Which means you'd probably need a 4nt->AA translation layer to keep the same number of AAs, and that alone would add 30% more energy expenditure. If you kept the 3nt->AA system you'd BOTH need to reduce the number of accessible amino acids AND you'd lose some of the error correction mechanisms of having degenerate codons code for the same amino acid.
We are all a bunch of biological goop resulting from random processes. Don't expect optimal solutions from evolution. There is no "why".
Ironic to say it’s not optimal, really we don’t have the full knowledge. Often when we learn more we learn how little we really know about biology.
Why would pairs of two be favorable?
> So for example, ternary logic is (much) more efficient than binary logic. Having that 3rd state just makes problem solving much more elegant.
What do you have in mind here?
> Like, are there all sorts of exotic logic gates that come from a 4 state system?
I don't know but you may be interested in this [1].
Obviously if you have a special use case, then that may dominate your radix economy (like hex, b64, etc...), but for general purpose information purposes, the order base 3, base 4, then base 2.
This present a lot of interesting questions to me. Like, why didn't DNA end up as base 3? (probably because 4 naturally lends itself to pairs of 2).
Also, this idea of radix economy goes beyond just the encoding of information and is represented in logical economy as well. So for example, ternary logic is (much) more efficient than binary logic. Having that 3rd state just makes problem solving much more elegant.
To that end, I have always wondered how nature has exploited this 4-state number system logically. Like, are there all sorts of exotic logic gates that come from a 4 state system?