So by forcing me to add my phone number some services actually decrease the security of my account.
This really isn't a dumb phone specific issue. Even for smartphones if someone stole it they could pop out the sim and if it isn't password protected (most aren't IME), they'll have full access to your phone number.
Also, even if you want to keep the pin on many people would set it to something convenient like 1111 or 9999. In fact, one of the carriers I used had 1111 s a default pin code for all their SIM cards.
So, while security is there in theory, in practice it's rarely in place.
Can they do this without connecting to a cell tower? Otherwise, the carrier would notice the pairing of your SIM to the new IMEI, and further security steps would be possible.
Making phone numbers required for signing up was only nominally to improve security. Overall, it’s a net negative for privacy and security, and only benefits the service provider by allowing them to track you (they can buy data on that phone number and create a profile on you) + reducing the number of people calling/emailing them because the user is locked out of their account.
Have you tried enabling Wi-Fi calling or switching to a carrier that supports it? At least for my carrier and iOS, you can send/receive SMS messages (yes, the green bubbles) through Wi-Fi.
I do still get them from android phones. Its weird, i have no idea why.
If you have an android phone yourself, maybe it's not actually SMS and it's actually RCS[1]?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services
And, in my experience, Android pushes you heavily to enable RCS; every time you open its messages app, there's a chance that it will randomly ask you to enable it, with a large button to enable and a small link to dismiss the dialog without enabling. I never tried, but I expect that once enabled, it'll never ask again, so it might have been enabled by accident sometime in the past.
It might seem surprising these days, but the parent poster might have network access through means other than a phone.
Most government docs are now PDFs, happily. But forcing people to choose between Android and iPhone (or forgoing service) is pretty nasty - these devices are expensive.
You can even have the authentication app on your laptop so you don’t need to switch devices (1Password at least supports this).
Yeah, I share my 2fa with every device and defy the purpose. I know. But if you have access to any of my devices I sm already compromised.
E.g., ING in Australia.
Not to sidetrack, but could you expound further? I struggle to reach the blanket conclusion of “not useful”.
I don’t really see how it’s a crutch, more than any other assistance tool like Google, StackOverflow, code-completion or actual docs. Hallucination is a separate problem, which is solved by using fine-tuned models.
They won't solve the main cause of hallucination: prompt has zero connection to generated text other than probability.
ChatGPT do not generate answers, it comes up with something that looks like an answer. There is a good chance it is the answer, but you can't guarantee it.
I believe this particular problem won't be solved, unless researchers teach machines how to reason. But then we would have greater concerns than hallucinations.
I don’t need 100% truth, because reading multiple docs myself and piecing things together has tons of potential pitfalls too.
I frankly am baffled by the allure ... of letting opaque computational systems perform intellectual tasks for them. ...when it comes to using language in a sensitive manner and talking about real-life situations where the distinction between truth and falsity and between genuineness and fakeness is absolutely crucial, to me it makes no sense whatsoever to let the artificial voice of a chatbot, chatting randomly away at dazzling speed, replace the far slower but authentic and reflective voice of a thinking, living human being.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/07/godel-esch...
Don't want to pay outrageous fees for Google FI or the like, as literally all I need it for is to get into online banking (who have decided sms 2fa is now compulsory, without offering any other options like an authenticator app). I'm currently locked out of my bank, will have to fork out $50+ just to call them, then hope I can convince them I am who I say I am. Then do the dance again next year when they do it again.
Can we all just do authenticator apps?
Last I checked, they were asking for $20 / month for unlimited calling and texting. Do you consider that outrageous?
As an alternative, Google Voice will host your phone number for free. It works with every WiFi connection and even while traveling internationally. Have you considered that?
It's pretty outrageous if you already have a local sim, so you're basically paying google $20/month to only receive SMS messages.
But yeah re:Google Fi, $240/y to recieve maybe 3 sms is pretty bad imo. And unlimited is only within US.
I kept the number from the last country I lived in solely for 2FA of accounts from that country and after almost a year I've managed to change over most things but not all. A week ago I decided to change that physical sim to an esim as I only need to enable it occasionally. I did the process for this, and at the end I got a link to last country's app store. The only way to install the esim is to use this app and it is only in last country's app store. I haven't logged into that for a while so it needed email confirmation. I haven't logged into the associated gmail address for a while so that needed 2FA confirmation by SMS. So I'm now locked out of an email address, apple id, and phone number.
I live in rural Western Australia with almost zero phone coverage, and this is a huge problem. I'm terrified of all these services wanting my phone number, or bugging me to turn on phone 2FA, because the moment that happens, I lose access to that service.
ChatGPT that everyone is spamming on every discussion? I can't even sign up for it (I'm not really bothered about that; it seems like a dangerous crutch than a useful technology).
The problem is the developers have smartphones, their friends have smartphones, their bosses have smartphones and their clients have smartphones. Everyone they know have smartphones and live in places with reception. So they don't or can't imagine something different.