Re:Passwords Are Fine
by luma on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @08:25AM
(#36585739)
If you don’t have a smartphone, or your phone cannot connect to a service, why is authentication a problem? If you don’t network access you lose access to the network, this isn’t exactly a surprise.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Passwords Are Fine
by Traubenfuchs on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @08:29AM
(#36585762)
I assume he is talking about SMS. Maybe a virtual SMS inbox is the solution.
> If you don’t have a smartphone, or your phone cannot connect to a service, why is authentication a problem? If you don’t network access you lose access to the network
It might seem surprising these days, but the parent poster might have network access through means other than a phone.
Re:Passwords Are Fine
by MrVandemar on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @09:36AM
(#36586448)
I do :-)
Re:Passwords Are Fine
by denton-scratch on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @10:57AM
(#36587558)
The only reason I have a smartphone is because many services (especially government services, like tax and the NHS) require a mobile phone so you can receive SMS. It's like how the government used to produce documents as MS Office files; they were forcing the public to go along with their choice of software company.
Most government docs are now PDFs, happily. But forcing people to choose between Android and iPhone (or forgoing service) is pretty nasty - these devices are expensive.
Then use that other device for the auth flow? I'm not surprised by that, but am surprised by your implication that it would still involve your phone.
In rural areas you can be in an area where you have a gigabit fiber connection and no cell service at all. Wi-Fi calling being added to the main carriers has been a game changer for rural access.
This really shouldn't have to be said, but wired internet and cellular internet are two different things.