The area around Maui has TONS of whales part of the year… many of them breaching.
I wonder how high these things fly vs how high a humpback can jump out of the water. I think the rule is 1/2 of your wingspan to be in ground effect, but it has been a long time since I’ve studied the exact numbers.
Where I live extending the light rail the last little bit over the river to Washington state is a no brainer, but it's been paralyzed by decades of opposition from suburbanites in Vancouver Wa. My friend's dad is/was one of the key activists. He'd stand in planning meetings and no joke scream about how "criminals" were gonna ride the train up, break into someone's house, steal their tv, then ride the train back. Lots of saying "crime train" over and over again.
We have solid data that building transit lines actually decreases crime. This man is a credentialed civil engineer. He rejected that evidence without consideration every time we put it in front of him.
I have zero respect for these people. If you talk to them for just a few seconds it becomes readily apparent the root is just straight up racism, but they don't wanna own it overtly.
The man wants no transit because "crime train" while the region needs transit. What middle ground do you propose?
Not every criticism and loud individual is worth listening to.
And no, I see zero reason to tolerate what is clearly bad faith behavior.
He might be a racist but based on what you said, it's not clear what may make him so.
What is your expectation of me here, to pull out some sort of video proof to convince you, the skeptical hnews reader?
Sometimes this place is extremely tiresome.
Just go do some googling and you'll realize how common this sentiment is. And it's nothing new. Read about Robert Moses and why he made bridges too low for buses.
On that suggestion, I just went and read the wikipedia article on Robert Moses. It mentions that buses and commercial vehicles do in fact go under those bridges today, and that the accusations of racism are disputed.
Look in the mirror, dude.
I see no such implication.
There is some validity to the idea that preventing mass transit insulates a community from a certain type of change but it comes with major costs.
That is not an exaggeration. One of my coworkers did a historical study and read town hall transcripts from the last couple decades. People were extremely clear why they were voting down mass transit.
(However, everything old is new again; there's widespread annoyance at plans to make the bus system actually work properly now...)
People are weird about this stuff.
It also becomes readily apparent that they also want to be patted on the back and told that they're good and noble people for "protecting the community" from the scourge of undesirables potentially riding public transit near them.
Malls with train access tend to bring a lot of kids strutting around flexing (as kids are expected to do). This has side effects of petty larceny and shootings. All of the mall shootings are groups of these kids that have beef with each other. It's mostly harmless to shoppers but there's always a chance you could get caught in crossfire or become the target of a malicious youth prank.
It's just your typical youth angst but you can avoid it simply by going to a mall without train access.
The question comes down to whether train access brings more benefits than drawbacks. When talking to anti-trainers you have to address this issue. You can't just hand wave it away as they're perfectly fine with the car status quo.
However, I'm sure most people will ignore everything in this comment and just shout "gun control".
As an outsider (from an European country): I don't think train access is the cause here :O
It's like saying "We should seed rain clouds because nice sunny weather correlates with mall shootings as nobody wants to go out in a storm". I mean, yes, the facts check out (sunny weather = more shootings than during a storm. I guess?) but the "solution" (don't provide public transportation / seed rain clouds) is.. ugh..
Trains bring more "these kinds of kids" to the mall vs private cars.
Nice weather brings more "these kinds of kids" to the mall as well (compared to stormy weather).
Now, where we do seem to disagree is the question of where the actual problem is. In my opinion, the problem is _not_ that kids are at the mall. The problem is that, apparently, these kids start to shoot each other while they're at the mall (!?! what the fuck)
Looking at _all_ the other countries that have nicer weather and / or better public transportation, we don't see kids shooting each other at malls. So I'd say that's a good indicator that the _actual problem_ can't be solved by restricting public transportation (or sunshine) but there has to be a different issue that needs to be tackled here..
https://www.euronews.com/2023/01/26/stockholm-bridge-row-exp...
Which is to say, there may be a _reason_ people bring up gun control. As you say "You can't just hand wave it away".
These issues just reveal deep problems we have as a society and the solution we have had so far of trying to avoid it at all costs only making it worse.
Do we? A cursory Google search revealed a couple of papers, one of which showed a slight increase in crime after the addition of a bus line[0] in Cleveland, and another which showed a decrease in homicides but an increase in property crime[1] in São Paolo. I'm not cherry-picking; these were the first two PDFs in the search results. I would love to see the evidence that you presented to your friend's dad.
> If you talk to them for just a few seconds it becomes readily apparent the root is just straight up racism, but they don't wanna own it overtly.
This may very well be the case as you exhort downthread, but I just want to point out that besides the obvious (that we are all internet randos who don't know your friend's dad), racism means different things to different people. I know people who think that if a white author writes nonwhite characters, it's racism. I also know people who were disowned for marrying "outside the race". My personal definition of racism is a lot closer to the latter.
Sometimes a concern for crime is just that; other times it can be a code for a race-related pretext. Here's a thought: if you're concerned about female genital mutilation, which is virtually only practiced in sub-Saharan Africa, the Middle East, and the Muslim countries of South Asia, are you concerned about the women being mutilated, or are you just a racist?
[0]: https://collected.jcu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1003&c...
[1]: https://sistemas.colmex.mx/Reportes/LACEALAMES/LACEA-LAMES20...
NIMBYs ruin everything, I doubt they were really concerned about the whales.
You see the same BS with bike paths through residential neighborhoods. Despite studies showing that bike paths increase property values, residents bitch and moan about safety/crime. They basically figure that poor/non-white people will bike into their neighborhood and rape/pillage/burn everything.
So you get a bunch of environmental concern-trolls funded by wealthy people who don't want to admit that, really, it's about race/class.
Except that these studies are rather suspect and/or very narrow.
The situation for actual residential neighborhoods is at most unclear.
Yep, there too not.
Evidence for bike lanes in the US comes from very methodologically suspicious studies (e.g. the Portland State one) that were heavily influenced by hyper-local effects and neglect to look at nearby businesses.
Some of the more honest studies found the opposite effect. E.g. the LA study has shown that the non-sabotaged section had more revenue growth than the road-sabotaged section.
There are also clear cases of bike lanes destroying businesses: https://www.sandiegoreader.com/news/2022/dec/26/stringers-46...
I'm an anti-bike activist. Bike lanes work only in _very_ narrow cases:
1. In densified hellscape cities, like Manhattan, where normal traffic is simply impossible.
2. In small tourist destination towns.
3. On university campuses and around them.
And that's pretty much it.
Which, as the comment stated is not at all what bike lanes actually deliver (higher property values, white folks in silly clothes).
This would be the first time im hearing about something like this. It sounds like the bike path was very successful.
Do you have more information?
I'll trade you streets and you can deal with the 3 dead kids from traffic incidents over the last 5 years
You are supposed to yield to traffic when opening your car door into a lane. The "sanctimonious" cyclist is justifiably mad because you violated his right of way and placed him at risk of severe injury.
https://southpark.fandom.com/wiki/Some_Puerto_Rican_Guy
The only criminals on a bike that I'm aware of are bicycle thieves.
And, to be fair, it's only easy to identify them after it's too late.
Citation needed. This is an extraordinary claim; you are going to need more than one single study done on a tiny sample with no control variables.
I would definitely be more interested in a property with bike infrastructure, although that is just one tiny sample with no control variables:)
Well, yes, when you're talking about residential areas. Home owners don't want a wall of strangers around their home all the time - it makes it difficult to spot the ones with ill-intent.
I mean, if that wasn't true, homes in gated communities wouldn't be more expensive than standalone houses.
> I would definitely be more interested in a property with bike infrastructure, although that is just one tiny sample with no control variables:)
You'd think that (I certainly did), but the price for homes in gated communities are far far higher than the equivalent in non-gated.
Which is why I want to see this hypothetical study that shows that residential areas closed to non-residents are cheaper than residential areas open to the public.
Because, a simple look at home prices shows this to be wildly untrue.
The majority of people do not live in gated communities and even gated communities have access routes outside the gates.
That wasn't the claim the poster made. The specific claim was that bike traffic through residential areas by non-residents increase the value of properties in that residential area.
>> Read on - what they were really afraid of was the dirty/smelly poors coming onto their precious island.
>> You see the same BS with bike paths through residential neighborhoods.
GP could not have been clearer in his implication that having public traffic pass through the residential area increases the value of that property in that area.
Which is complete nonsense when you look at residential property prices in area which has a through-flow for non-residents/the public and compare to areas which are effectively gated off for residents only.
Buying a house in an area that is limited to residents traffic only is damned expensive.
I'm not sure that your own implication that property prices are inversely proportional to the ease of commute to where all the people and jobs are is well evidenced by representative studies either. Even if the GP was talking about gated communities, which he wasn't, they're still usually nowhere near as expensive as being cycling distance from central San Francisco or London.
I'd invite you to take a look at the Springwater Corridor in Portland. It is plausible that ubiquitous bike paths would not have the same problem, but it is difficult to fault someone for taking one look at that disaster and wanting it to come to their own quiet neighborhood.
We're taking a different approach that focuses on community and environmental considerations first. Look for more exciting news in Hawaii soon!
Hawaii is notoriously difficult to do business in, Hawaiian Airlines has become entrenched in protecting these routes, Southwest has been moderately effective but it's at a significant cost, and mokulele has had some serious negative press over the safety of their aircraft.
Part of the super ferry demise wasn't just NIMBYs' but entrenched politics and money.. glad you folks are brining some innovation and wish you luck on some much needed disruption.
An electric wing-in-ground-effect aircraft still looks like an airplane and might still fall under the same regulations as any other airplane.
In any case TSA objectively does not add much security[1] and does cause issues e.g. for people who have names with similar spellings to those on a no-fly-list [2].
But that aside, the technology is great for short distance travel. Climbing to 2-5 thousand foot to travel some 50 miles is clearly insane.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_Security_Admini...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Fly_List#False_positives
Same if you have Pre and Clear. I usually get to the airport 30-40m early.
That said I'm usually at the train station 10m before departure with bags.
TSA Pre actually does reduce security requirements (e.g. you can keep your shoes on...) in exchange for, I've always assumed, a mini-background check when you apply for the program.
You'll get fingerprinted, etc., and while it's nothing like a serious security clearance, they do look you up rather thoroughly.
Note: my only direct knowledge comes from applying to Global Entry, which is a pickier program, but Precheck does collect biometrics (at least facial and fingerprints). Global Entry was around 15 minutes for the interview process (both formal and informal; I knew the two guys outside the interview and fingerprint room didn't really just want to talk to me to pass the time), but that was a decade ago.
One interesting anecdote from my interview is that I was told that the #1 reason Global Entry applications failed at the time was that one of the questions was whether or not you had ever been arrested - not convicted - and people would say no. Not an auto-disqualifier to have been arrested, but lying about it was.
I live outside the US and this is laughably wrong.
How can you collapse the entire world down to "outside the US".
Israeli airports are exactly the same as Zimbabwean airports in your worldview?
I live in SE Asia and no country around here has air travel "like rail". I cannot get through xray and security in minutes. I cannot just show a ticket on my phone.
(For the curious, there is a titanium plate in my body due to an accident)
The TSA explicitly allows hand tools up to 17cm (7 in.)
I think that at this point the TSA is more interested in explosives since hardened cockpit doors, and passenger willingness to intervene have pretty much killed takeover style hijackings.
But the TSA has absolutely no bearing on whether or not a plane gets hijacked. It is far too easy to circumvent.
I live in the EU. There is nothing similar. Two hours at the airport being put in several different queues, often in a high stress atmosphere.
Train travel: Five-ten minutes at the station, all done.
Yes, I’m partial to trains.
Why jets? In the Caribbean, where distances are longer, turboprop aircraft are standard for island hopping and I thought these made more economic sense for short distances.
From the description of the ship they tried to use environmentally-friendly tech (despite it being a bit of a behemoth), but I know nothing about the local ecosystem. I imagined the area would already have heavy boat traffic from cruises and the military.
It's insane to me that the vast majority of inter-island travel in Hawaii (an archipelago where generally each island is visible from the next) is via jet aircraft. You have to spend hours (especially if you're checking bags) getting to the airport early, going through security, waiting at the gate, taxiing, etc ... for a 20 minute flight.
There used to be a ferry between Oahu and Maui but it got killed due to real and perceived environmental impact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawaii_Superferry
A light electric ferry service like this, directly between say, Ala Wai and Lahaina harbors, skipping airport/TSA nonsense, could be a very successful premium product. I just hope from there it could be scaled up so that it wouldn't remain just a niche offering for the rich.