News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by accelbred on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @01:13AM (#36040120)
You should give modern Gnome a good honest try.

I felt like you before, but ended up using it at work since it was what IT supported. After using it for a month, I switched all my personal machines over. For me, modern Gnome is the most usable, consistent, and smooth desktop experience I've used. And this is from someone who has used KDE, Windows, MacOS, and custom desktop environments with i3 and bspwm.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @01:38AM (#36040283)
Can I rearrange visual elements so my desktop is similar to how it has been in gnome 2, mate and xfce for the last 20 years? Can non-blessed apps get into the systray/notification-area/whatever?

Genuine questions, I've not tried Gnome since the early days of gnome 3 when they broke everything and more or less made out you were a luddite and unwanted loser if you weren't up for a massive change in workflow.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by pmontra on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @01:47AM (#36040353)
There are enough extensions to do whatever you want. My Gnome desktop has no top bar. Activities are totally hidden: I don't have any mouse or keyboard event that shows them. I use 5 virtual desktops and switch between them with hotkeys. I have a bottom bar with status icons, task bar, application menu, a menu of bookmarked directories, a menu of the last notifications, a menu of recent files. Notifications popup from the bottom. I alt tab between windows on the current desktop. Possibly other stuff but that's the most I can remember.

If I remember well I stayed with Gnome Fallback until there were enough of those extensions to rebuild my desktop with Gnome shell. That was about at the time of Ubuntu 20.04.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by grunfelder on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @01:58PM (#36048205)
In my experience, with every update, half the extensions stop working. And then it's unclear if they will ever come back, how supported they actually are, and now and then the whole thing crashes and I don't know if it's because of a rogue extension or something else..
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by pmontra on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:14PM (#36049319)
I had no problems with Ubuntu's updates but I'm staying on LTSes.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by dizhn on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:03AM (#36040877)
KDE Plasma is just what you would think of as KDE. Not a different thing.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by darkwater on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:14AM (#36040959)
> Can I rearrange visual elements so my desktop is similar to how it has been in gnome 2, mate and xfce for the last 20 years?

Gnome 3 has been out for over 10 years (12, to be exact). At this point if they change the UI there would be people like you saying "can I get back how it has been for 10 years?".

I don't really understand how we can have a so strong resistance to UI changes among IT professionals. Personally I started using Gnome 1, then moved to KDE3 when Gnome 2 was released, then moved to Unity with Ubuntu and now Gnome 3/40, Ubuntu flavor as well. I also used XFCE for a year or so at some point. I just need a month or so to get used and configure it a way I feel natural, and that's it.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by jabl on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:47AM (#36041220)
This.

I can obviously only speak for myself, but over the years I've tried a lot of different desktop environments and window managers (http://www.xwinman.org/ was a favorite when I was getting started with Linux back in the mid 90'ies).

Nowadays I use a pretty out of the box gnome (well, with whatever bastardizations Ubuntu has done to vanilla Gnome, with the unity-like sidebar etc.). I just want something that works, not a million papercuts that bleed me dry (e.g. I have a networkmanager applet to configure my VPN, works out of the box, no need to fuzz around with making various scripts or manual editing of config files. Screw that, I have actual work to do as well.), and it seems gnome & ubuntu have been pretty good at delivering. I don't care that my current desktop works differently than my old favorites fvwm or olvwm. I save more time by having my muscle memory get used to current keybindings and my eyes get used to the current look, than desperately trying to make gnome in 2023 look and behave like fvwm in 1995.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:53AM (#36041673)
> I just want something that works, not a million papercuts that bleed me dry

This is precisely why I install Xfce and just get on with my life.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by bebop on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:11AM (#36045437)
I would suggest looking into fedora workstation. I switched from Ubuntu around fedora 35 and have not looked back. Stock gnome, integrates into flathub easily. Dnf and apt are similar enough.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:52AM (#36041667)
I’m not asking anyone to change the Gnome UI. That seems an uncharitable misreading of my question TBH.

I’m asking, honestly and in response to encouragement to give it another try, whether it is now changeable, and can support the way I work relatively simply. If the answer is ‘no’ (or worse “you’re doing it wrong”) then I won’t.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by darkwater on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:02AM (#36042070)
Gnome tries to force their defaults as much as possible but I do have Telegram or Slack sitting in the "tray bar" near the top-right corner of the screen.

And sorry if I misinterpreted you.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:25AM (#36042216)
That seems like a genuine improvement from way back when, having a visual indicator for slack messages is definitely one of my major needs. Not that slack was on the radar back then, but at the time I was annoyed that Pidgin (which I also needed for work) wasn't allowed to have a tray icon.

I could live without most of the rest of the things that are sitting in my top right right now. Discord and skype are nice-to-haves but not work related so strictly optional.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by bandrami on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:55AM (#36042478)
> Pidgin (which I also needed for work) wasn't allowed to have a tray icon

Telepathy was but -- I still am annoyed about this more than a decade later -- it wasn't allowed to actually indicate whether you had new messages or not, just that you had some notification from some app somewhere, and you had to drill down through your notifications to see it. It was just annoying, like when Gnome decided it would be hilarious to allow a laptop to not sleep when closed but only for 30 seconds.

I have no idea why the Gnome devs chose to die on this hill.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by ilyt on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:27AM (#36042230)
Why ? If I absolutely love the current Gnome UI they will just change shit in next 5 years for no good reason whatsoever
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:31AM (#36042268)
I'm just interested really - I was burned by the changeover from 2-3 and haven't really looked back since. I'm not looking to change either, my needs are met. But I can change my opinion of the state of the thing if it seems like improvements have been made.

By the sounds of it, that's a resounding 'maybe'.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by ilyt on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:28PM (#36049577)
I was like that in GNOME 1.2/2.0 times, tried probably every DM/WM that was packaged for Debian.

Then realized the thing I do is "switch between a bunch of full screen apps (especially when we have terminal emulators with tabs and tiles builtin)" and "move them from one screen to another screen".

So I sit down, tuned i3 to my liking and never looked back. And now first order of retrievability of most apps is caps lock (rebinded to super) + 1-8/F1-F8, and second order is rofi doing search by window name via alt+tab.

Some rules make sure same app always land on same virtual desktop so I just have my stuff in autostart and it lands in right place every time

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by grt_thr on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @07:01AM (#36042534)
Then issue is that gnome 2 was actually good. Gnome 3 was not.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by darkwater on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:00AM (#36043615)
For me it was the other way round (Gnome 2 made me switch to KDE3) so... who is right?
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by ChrisRR on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @08:07AM (#36043147)
> I don't really understand how we can have a so strong resistance to UI changes among IT professionals

There isn't as much resistance when it's a good change

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by JohnFen on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @11:55AM (#36046172)
> I don't really understand how we can have a so strong resistance to UI changes among IT professionals.

This is easy to explain.

UI changes always bring pain to established users. There is no way around this. Users will accept the change if the benefits of it exceed the pain it brings.

IT professionals spend a great deal more time interacting with the desktop than most users, so they become "established users" more quickly and rely on UI patterns more strongly. So when the UI changes, it hurts that much more. The benefit of the change has to be that much greater to compensate.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by yamtaddle on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @07:38PM (#36052196)
> I don't really understand how we can have a so strong resistance to UI changes among IT professionals.

It's often bad. Poorly-motivated, poorly-conceived, and poorly-executed.

Some of us have watched non-pros suffer through this stuff. It's much, much worse for them. I've come to believe you better have a goddamn great reason to modify UI, these days, and that a complete overhaul or redesign is almost never justifiable.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:08AM (#36041374)
XFCE didn't look like today's XFCE 20years ago. It looked more like CDE which it was trying to replicate back then. So I think your memory is a bit broken.

I would argue that the gnome2 and mate arrangement with top and bottom panels made sense when screens were in 4:3 form factor but is kind of stupid in 16:9 and 16:10 modern screens as it waste a lot of vertical screen estate.

On my Fedora laptop I still have a "Gnome Classic" option at login but I don't know what it does. Last but not least, extensions allows a lot of flexibility. Sometimes they do get broken upon new release and it takes the maintainer months to update (especially if they are debian users) so key is not running a distro that ship the latest Gnome version. For example on Fedora there are always 2 stable versions maintained at the same time, new one and old one, currently 37 and 38. 37 will be retired and out of support when 39 will be released and you can expect at that time that most extensions have been updated to Gnome 44 and you can switch to 38 easily without hiccups.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by Nursie on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:50AM (#36041645)
It’s not my claim that Xfce was around 20 years ago, but that it lets me continue to use my desktop the same sort of way I have for the last 20 years.

As someone with two 32inch 4k screens, having a top and bottom bar with a height of my choosing on one of the screens is barely noticeable. But each to their own, this is my preference and that’s kinda my point, people have preferences!

It sounds like things are still unstable a decade or so on :/

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @05:43AM (#36041977)
> It sounds like things are still unstable a decade or so on :/

They are not. Extensions aren't part of the main DE. The main DE is solid. And most people live happily without extensions.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by ilyt on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:26AM (#36042227)
Other people experiences are really irrelevant here.

People use windows after all

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by liotier on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @02:50AM (#36040783)
> You should give modern Gnome a good honest try

This long time Debian user does not understand why he would choose Gnome over the incredibly satisfying out of the box experience of KDE Plasma combined with its easy customizability. I suspect that I am not Gnome's target segment... What sort of user is Gnome targeting ?

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by qup on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @02:53AM (#36040809)
> KDE Plasma

Is this what Zorin uses? They look very similar.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by AndroidKitKat on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:06AM (#36042095)
Last I checked out Zorin in a distrohop phase, Zorin used a heavily customized version of GNOME 3.38. While they may have updated their GNOME version since, I don't suspect they've changed to KDE.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by teekert on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:10AM (#36040928)
To me Gnome feels more tablet like, but still nice with Mouse and Keyboard. I feel that it makes effective use of my screen, it's just full screen, or super-key left/right for a split. Hit Super, start an app, what's not to like? And then there is the menu with things like bleutooth/wifi etc. It's all very minimal, but to me it feels like they made exactly the right choices. What would you change to a default Gnome desktop?
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by johnny22 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:38AM (#36041151)
the fokls who do not want to customize :). We just want the UI to mostly stay out of the way.

Last I checked, even Linus uses it.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by nablaone on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:29AM (#36041522)
"ease customizability" means no sane defaults. It means more work after the installation.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by zambal on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:37AM (#36041573)
> What sort of user is Gnome targeting ?

I guess that would be me. I mostly work in the terminal and I just don't care that much about the window manager. As long as it's simple, works consistent and looks somewhat nice and clean, I'm fine. Gnome fills that role for me.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by ilyt on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:25AM (#36042220)
I moved to XFCE then to I3 with same profile of usage.

Just a bunch of terminals + full screen browser/IDE/whatever else

Took a bit of customizing... years ago and I haven't needed to change much since

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by George83728 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @07:48AM (#36042970)
Gnome's target demo seems to be people who aren't linux enthusiasts... who are for some reason using linux anyway. So basically, people who are made to use linux on their computer at work, or hapless elder relatives of overzealous linux users who had linux installed on their computer without understanding what it was.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by gymbeaux on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @09:14AM (#36043793)
KDE Plasma is too buggy for my liking. It seems to be mostly scaling-related. I do like that it’s more feature-rich than GNOME, but bugs/UX trump that.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by DiabloD3 on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @07:52PM (#36052282)
That isn't a KDE-related bug, but a Wayland related bug. GNOME using Wayland also has this bug: Wayland apps that do not internally deal with HiDPI scaling don't get scaling.

Both GNOME and KDE's WMs recently supported WM-side scaling now that the protocol for it has been agreed upon.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by gymbeaux on Thursday May 25, 2023 @06:40PM (#36077325)
My understanding was that the KDE distros I was using were still on X11 but I could be mistaken. Fedora 38 with GNOME (on Wayland) has been mostly bug free for me. Certainly better than KDE.
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by DiabloD3 on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:43AM (#36080036)
This also could be true.

To be absolutely fair to both sides, we're in a rough transitory period due to intra-project politics. Some people have a better time on X11, some on Wayland, and its down to which distro they're on and how new (or old) it is.

Today, however, Gnome and KDE both have excellent Wayland support, even mostly okay on Nvidia binary drivers (but still, use the FOSS drivers if they work for you, or just stop buying Nvidia hardware until Nvidia stops trying to throw AMD and Intel's excellent FOSS work under the bus).

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by iforgotpassword on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @02:59AM (#36040845)
Modern gnome is a joke. For two years now, scrolling doesn't work in folders with many files. I can't find the issue in their bug tracker right now, but they're just like "well yeah it's not easy to fix". Like, how can you break something that fundamental in a way that makes it too hard to fix? And this isn't just some minor cosmetic issue, it literally is a showstopper if you frequently navigate large directories. Holy crap, but at least it looks pretty!

(found at least a Reddit post from three months ago that seems to be the same bug: https://old.reddit.com/r/gnome/comments/1129jro/nautilus_scr...)

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @03:57AM (#36041299)
How is a reddit link relevant?

FWIW I may not have large enough directories but on the ones I just tested I didn't had this bug. I am not negating such a bug may have existed but a link to the actual gnome bug tracker would be more relevant, it may have already been fixed for all I know.

Also, are you implying that KDE or any other DE do not suffer any bug?

Last but not least, you are not forced to use Nautilus in Gnome. If Nautilus is not your preferred file manager you can perfectly live with a Gnome desktop while using Thunar (from XFCE), Nemo (from Cinnamon), PCManFM or even Dolphin if you don't mind the toolkit difference. I am personnaly using Gnome for most of my laptops but use Kitty as default terminal emulator instead of Gnome Terminal.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by robertlagrant on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:12AM (#36041404)
> And this isn't just some minor cosmetic issue, it literally is a showstopper if you frequently navigate large directories.

> are you implying that KDE or any other DE do not suffer any bug?

...

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @04:28AM (#36041517)
Looks like you are implying that if your file manager has a bug your brain just crash and you end up in a vegetative state, unable to use a different file manager.

Looks like it just happened to you. I think the main problem lies in the chair to keyboard interface, regardless of the DE respective qualities.

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by grt_thr on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:00AM (#36042058)
Is this a joke or are you trolling to make the gnome devs look even more unreasonable?
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @06:45AM (#36042375)
Where did I say I was a gnome dev?
Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by fps_doug on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @05:03AM (#36041729)
> How is a reddit link relevant?

It appears the video in that post shows the bug, so, rather relevant?

The according issue seems to be[1], which has indeed been fixed two months ago, but as OP said was opened two years ago.

[1] https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gtk/-/issues/2971

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by prmoustache on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @05:44AM (#36041984)
So that was relevant until two months ago and is not right now.

Software have bugs, some are fixed quickly, other not. Dolphin (KDE file manager) also have bugs, it seems to crash for a number of reasons, also has scrolling issues, or bugs triggered by scrolling.

Do I say KDE is unusable because Dolphin can crash or has sometimes issues with scrolling. Nope that would be stupid. If I run into a bug with one among n components on a DE, I either report, fix it by patching it and supply a patch upstream, find a workaround or use temporarily an alternative component of that DE.

https://bugs.kde.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=__open__&content...

https://bugs.kde.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=__open__&content...

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by d_tr on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @02:13PM (#36061980)
I had to switch from Arch + i3 to Ubuntu 23.04 and gave Gnome a try with the intention to keep using it. I like the look and feel, and the appindicator and tiling assistant extensions are all I would need.

The first thing I did (on X11) was to set fractional scaling to 125%. Changing this setting reliably renders the settings app unresponsive and it needs to be killed.

The second thing I did was to tile the settings app to the left (without having installed the tiling extension, I am talking about Gnome's tiling feature). The window gets graphically corrupted and after a few seconds I get a notification that "Ubuntu has experienced an internal error".

"Screw it", I said, "time to go Wayland, it's the future anyway". I did a couple totally benign random things and I somehow managed to cause a crash there too...

I just fetched my dotfiles and rebuilt my i3 on Ubuntu Server...

Re:Vanilla OS 2.0 Orchid base is changing from Ubuntu to Debian by pjmlp on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @07:05AM (#36042566)
Back in my daily GNU/Linux days, I even wrote magazine articles about Gtkmm.

Nowadays, I rather not use a desktop that requires extensions for basic stuff (written in JavaScript!), no longer supports window shading, and hates files on the desktop.