News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:43AM (#35425708)
Also, one of Ma’s last public appearances was at an American conference, maybe TechCrunch but I’m not sure, where he said in an on stage interview something to the effect of, “I’m not afraid of the CCP”, in relation to recent revelations he was a CCP member. Then he got disappeared shortly after. He was really clueless about what kind of org he was dealing with.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by toyg on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:55AM (#35425956)
One doesn't need to be clueless in order to lose a power struggle. He might have been betrayed, he might have overestimated the resources he could fully count on, he might have simply been backing a faction in the party that ended up losing. Xi Jinping went as far as kicking out of the public congress a previous president, which was unprecedented; who knows what else he's capable of.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by re-thc on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:11PM (#35426326)
Correct, he is/was backed by a different faction.

Most startups of that era are.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by esafak on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:55PM (#35429396)
Which faction? I am curious.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#35429620)
From what I’ve both read and experienced on a brief trip to Shanghai, it seems there are two main factions - the Beijing faction and Shanghai faction. The latter is more capitalist and chill, the former more authoritarian. It’s probably more complicated though, with multiple sub factions around different leaders in the CCP. Maybe someone with deeper knowledge can elaborate.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by rfoo on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:33PM (#35429989)
There's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuanpai and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_clique. And of course a third one - Xi organized his own clan.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by viewtransform on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:56PM (#35431168)
This writeup by a former CCP member now living in exile explains the current functioning of the CCP.

The Weakness of Xi Jinping: How Hubris and Paranoia Threaten China’s Future https://archive.is/d9OsU

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Saturday April 08, 2023 @03:15AM (#35491272)
That was excellent, thanks for sharing.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by rvnx on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:03PM (#35429540)
The capitalists ?

Seems like the arch-enemy of communists

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by not2b on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:02PM (#35434455)
You would think, but in China it doesn't seem that way.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by re-thc on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:45AM (#35437207)
There are no capitalists in China. Trace the origins and $$$ all come from some source belonging to a particular faction.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:04PM (#35429556)
But that’s the problem - the risk of losing a power struggle in a democracy with rule of law, separation of powers, an independent court system, and regular elections is vastly different from the risks of losing a power struggle in the CCP, which controls all branches of government, law enforcement, and the military and is accountable to no one.

The former has a limited downside, the latter unlimited. Whatever the Central Committee decides happens to you is law - execution, disappearing and re-education, etc. - and law enforcement and the courts are just there to justify it after the fact.

It’s clueless to publicly mouth off about the CCP if you’re a high-profile influential Chinese billionaire and therefore a potential threat to the current ruling faction, or some future ruling faction when there’s turnover. Discretion is definitely the better part of valor there.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by ethbr0 on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:30PM (#35429947)
I always figured that's why high-level power struggles were so constant and severely fought in totalitarian regimes.

If the downside is unlimited then you do whatever it takes to win, always.

And if there isn't currently a struggle then you prepare for the next one, constantly.

Or in other words, you only spend a small portion of your total ability and time on the job, because you have to constantly expend effort on protecting your back.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:23PM (#35430731)
I have that impression too. Without having directly experienced it myself, it seems like a hellish system. Though it does at least seem like getting “purged” isn’t always final, and that execution is the last choice.

Xi Jinping himself got purged in his youth and spent that time living and working in the countryside and building his ‘man of the common people’ cred, then made it back into the CCP’s favor later. Though Xi was a princeling, his father was one of Mao’s inner circle, so he might have been untouchable and only at risk of exile and not actual execution for that reason, unlike most other CCP members and Chinese people.

And to be fair, US politicians spend most of their time fundraising for their next campaign, so in terms of total ability and time spent on the job it’s probably similar in both systems. But losing a power struggle in the US just means losing your election, and trying again in the next one. In the CCP there’s a wider range of consequences.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by hunvreus on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:53PM (#35433572)
For anybody looking to get some understanding of Xi Jinping's life and ascension to power, I'd recommend listening to "The Prince: Searching for Xi Jinping" from the Economist: https://www.economist.com/theprincepod
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by kdmccormick on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:13PM (#35432693)
As reasonable as your argument is, let's apply Occam's Razor. Which is more likely?

1. Jack Ma knows things you don't, and those things made mouthing off seem worthwhile to him. Still, he miscalculated, but not out of sheer cluelessness.

2. You, HN commenter, understand Chinese politics and power better than Jack Ma, a prominent Chinese billionaire. He is clueless.

Doesn't 2 seem a little arrogant to you?

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:51PM (#35433105)
Haha, you're not wrong.

Though I would argue that the explanation requiring the fewest assumptions is not that Ma was being calculating and strategic, but that he just got cocky and said something dumb in the moment. He let all the global feting of his rise from schoolteacher to China's richest man go to his head, made an all-too-human mistake, and said something inadvisable.

He may even have been trying to defend the CCP in that moment, trying to communicate to US audiences that the CCP doesn't need to be feared because it's not scary, and thus he himself didn't fear it. But Xi and the powers that be interpreted it differently, and disappeared him. Which is always a risk in that system, but not in liberal democracies.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by kdmccormick on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:19PM (#35433329)
Fair enough! There are certainly other recent examples of billionaires getting themselves in trouble by saying too much....
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by SkyMarshal on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:49PM (#35433529)
I know right. A lot of that going around these days. Maybe something in their bottled water.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by factormeta on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @07:24AM (#35437924)
>Which is always a risk in that system, but not in liberal democracies. No, you just get arrested by the authorities, and later committed suicide before the trial.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by HWR_14 on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:55PM (#35433587)
Missing option (3). Jack Ma, prominent billionaire, was surrounded by kiss-asses for the past 5-10 years. In doing so, he developed a distorted sense of his own intelligence/power/allies which caused him to make a calculation about the current state of Chinese politics and power that is obviously false to an outside observer.

See also, Twitter is was not worth $44 billion in 2022.

Missing option (4). If you have billions, sacrificing a lot of wealth and power to do something you want is just another valid option.

See also, sacrificing 20% of your net worth to support "freedom of speech" is a reasonable choice, especially if you are left with an objective fortune.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by not2b on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:00PM (#35434439)
Except that Musk's Twitter in no way supports freedom of speech. For a while he banned any mention of Mastodon, or the ElonJet account, and he's banned a whole slew of antifascist accounts and journalists who report on the far right (he will claim that it's because they violated rules, but in each case it seems it was a new rule: journalism he doesn't like is "doxxing": reporting on who did what). So sure, it looks like he is willing to lose a big chunk of his net worth to change Twitter, but his intent seems to be to promote certain speech and suppress other speech, or as he would say, to kill the "woke mind virus".
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by ehvatum on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @04:30AM (#35436723)
It’s worth noting that Elon unbanned a whole slew of accounts that had been silenced simply for disagreeing with what happen to be your political priorities. Who has Elon banned for their politics? Being banned for tweeting Andy Ngo’s current home address is very different from being banned for saying that COVID-19 likely originated in a laboratory.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by codezero on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:05AM (#35438256)
He suspended ADSBExchange and Elonjet. Accounts sharing open source and public data that he didn’t like. He went so far as to specifically ban the use of the link to his jet on Twitter.

FWIW I know it’s his right to do this as he owns the platform but it is relevant in the context of “but Elon didn’t do X”

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by not2b on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @12:37PM (#35442318)
If this were the reason Ngo managed to get a lot of his critics banned you might have a point. But: https://theintercept.com/2022/11/29/elon-musk-twitter-andy-n...
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by HWR_14 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @07:34PM (#35447280)
It doesn't matter for what we're talking about if Elon's "freedom of speech" is an ironic take on people only being able to listen to him or actual freedom or whatever. The point is, blowing 44 billion USD on a hobby/for a point he cares about is a reasonable cost for him (and Bezos. Maybe a few others)
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by webmaven on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:21AM (#35465324)
> Except that Musk's Twitter in no way supports freedom of speech.

It seems to be supporting Musk's freedom of speech just fine.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by littlestymaar on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:59PM (#35431204)
> One doesn't need to be clueless in order to lose a power struggle.

But one has to be clueless in order to start a power struggle with Xi. He's not like the old school CCP head at all (not even Mao), he's much more of an all-powerful tyrant like Stalin was. Starting a power struggle against such a ruthless despot is clueless.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by alexandre_m on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:27PM (#35432849)
Are you suggesting that Xi is more of a tyrant than Mao?
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by jessaustin on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:43PM (#35433897)
Don't expect rational history on HN. We regularly see e.g. comparisons of Putin to Hitler.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by littlestymaar on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @03:22AM (#35436249)
In the “single person handling all power” sense, I'd say so at least for most of Mao's reign.

Political struggles where commonplace during most of the Mao era, and it wasn't until the end of his reign (in 1969, amidst the cultural revolution) that Mao came to gain complete power over the central committee. (And by that time, he had done most of its harm already)

Two of the most historically important event of the period even happened after Mao lost a power struggle and was trying to get back on his foot: the great march and the cultural revolution.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by hatsunearu on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:53AM (#35425925)
Jack Ma truly is clueless in general. There was a talk involving him and Elon Musk and it somehow was Elon coming out as the eloquent one in that conversation.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by bakuninsbart on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:26PM (#35426670)
I don't think very highly of Jack Ma, but eloquence for non-native speakers should be judged very differently, especially for someone coming from a language very far away linguistically.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by iforgotpassword on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:01PM (#35427363)
Exactly, Ma was kinda struggling to get a train of thought across linguistically and half the time when Musk interrupted him he was rather making fun of some poor choice of words and being like "lol whatever" than trying to actually engage in a conversation.

And I guess now with the Twitter shitshow Musk doesn't exactly look like a genius either.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by kranke155 on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:58PM (#35428458)
Pretty much impossible to defend Elon's Twitter tenure. Can't think of a single thing he did that made that company more valuable.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by gordian-mind on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:22PM (#35432794)
What about laying off 75% of its workforce and open sourcing the twitter algorithm?
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by kranke155 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:38PM (#35446183)
Is the company more valuable ?
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by gordian-mind on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:42PM (#35456920)
Well it increases revenue, so certainly. The open sourcing increases it ethicality; I guess you could say it's not direct value.

In terms of pure market cap, which I'm not sure how relevant it is, it seems that the current valuation (41 billion) is higher than when he offered to buy it (34 billion in April 2022).

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by kranke155 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:31PM (#35458514)
I'd love to see a user count. My impression is a few people left, but I'm not sure.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by andy_ppp on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:21PM (#35426534)
I always do wonder about the reverence shown to billionaires around here, given the quite frankly ludicrous purchase of Twitter ($44bn!!!) and what has happened afterwards I really am not convinced they aren’t just as able as the rest of us.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by midasuni on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#35427018)
Americans tend to equate wealth with ability and set aside luck, everyone is a temporarily embarrassed millionaire.

Musk certainly used to have decent business accuumin - he hit it big several times, that’s not just luck. From all accounts he’s a half decent engineer too, which is rare in many CEO levels.

However his behaviour over the last 3 years has been very surprising. He seems to be less interested in the tech and more in the politics, which is a shame.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by philipov on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:12PM (#35427563)
People thought he had some engineering skills, until he took over Twitter and started talking about all the idiotic engineering decisions he was making.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by robocat on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:46PM (#35431034)
Musk could simultaneously be a numpty at Twitter and a superb engineer at SpaceX.

You imply that skills are context-free black or white - that is a terrible way to think about people or the world IMHO. And you can’t ignore changes over time either.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by WalterSear on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:00PM (#35434001)
Not the kind of engineering numpty he's shown himself to be. All engineering absolutely requires humility for situations outside the realm of your expertise.

But, the fact that he so clearly doesn't know when he is out of his depth in the first place is the real tell.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by philipov on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:38AM (#35438648)
Like management, engineering is a discipline of means divorced from ends. There are certain vital skills that are shared amongst engineers regardless of their particular domain, and those are the skills most important for an engineering manager to have.

A computer engineer without those skills is merely an amateur physicist. A software engineer without those skills is merely a programmer. Ask a quant with no engineering background to put their ad-hoc scripts into production one day and let's see how that goes.

Musk might know some science, but that doesn't make him an engineer.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by mschuster91 on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:21PM (#35427723)
> However his behaviour over the last 3 years has been very surprising. He seems to be less interested in the tech and more in the politics, which is a shame.

He's a narcissist. People used to worship him - and given just how hard Tesla kicked the butts of the ICE car industry or how SpaceX just completely obliterated Boeing/ULA, rightfully. But let's be honest, both are mainstream now and don't get as much attention as they once did... and then, his wife leaves him for Chelsea Manning and one of his children comes out as trans and sticks the finger to him.

A bad enough combination of events for normal people to handle (getting dumped by a partner is one of the chief causes that sends people into depression and other mental health disaster loops), but for a narcissist with no real support structure to fall back on and already on the edge? No surprise he blames everyone but himself and allies with those that are against those whom he feels "wronged" by: the far-right.

Note, this doesn't excuse any of his actions. He needs to come out of this rabbit hole either by himself or, when he finally hits rock bottom and commits something that he can't just buy himself out of prison, by the government.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by pedrosorio on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:59PM (#35427312)
> business accuumin

I am guessing this couldn't have been just luck either.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by FpUser on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:17PM (#35427652)
>"less interested in the tech and more in the politics"

Once you have x dollars and own companies government is aware of it comes as no surprise

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by flangola7 on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:58PM (#35427298)
I seriously doubt his engineering abilities, but I'll ignore that.

One thing he's demonstrated from the beginning is a stark undersupply of emotional intelligence. There are noises that come out of his mouth that my 15yr old would roll her eyes at for being too self-centered and immature.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by s1artibartfast on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:59PM (#35429472)
There's a fine line between lack of emotional intelligence and simply not caring to placate others.

The two are not the same.

It is like calling someone an idiot because they won't do what you want and ignoring what they want.

You have to admit that it may not be a priority for Elon to maintain his reputation with you in your 15 year old

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by flangola7 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:36AM (#35435896)
There is a fine line, and he is clearly on the side of low emotional intelligence to anyone who does not also have low emotional intelligence
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by s1artibartfast on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @03:54AM (#35436444)
Based on what exactly? Are you sure you aren't confusing EQ with agreeableness, they are orthogonal. Hitler had extremely high EQ, but low agreeability
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by flangola7 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @04:43AM (#35436816)
The fact that you have any doubt about this says a lot about your own intelligence.

I'm not interested in chatting with the Weird Nerd defending Elon Musk from Valid Criticism.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by munificent on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:08PM (#35430503)
> he hit it big several times, that’s not just luck.

The odds of any given entrepreneur getting lucky several times in a row is very small.

Given a large enough entrepreneurs, the odds of one of them getting lucky several times in a row gets very large. We just don't see all the ones who tried and failed, or succeeded once or twice and fizzled out.

I don't doubt that Musk has some skills and appropriate personality traits as well, but luck is likely the dominating factor.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by midasuni on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @04:22AM (#35436650)
I think that’s fair, but PayPal, spacex and Tesla are all successes, and all had a lot of musk in them.

That either seems extreme luck or there’s something else

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by gordian-mind on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @12:40PM (#35442359)
That statement is incredibly disconnected from reality. Are you suggesting that rockets fly through luck?
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by munificent on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:14PM (#35443799)
Musk is not a rocket. There is a company that successfully puts rockets into space that he happens to be CEO of. Whether that company would be successfully putting rockets into space with someone else at the helm is unknown, but I strongly suspect that his own contribution is not as great as would seem.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by gordian-mind on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:21PM (#35446003)
> There is a company that successfully puts rockets into space that he happens to be CEO of.

What an hilarious amount of bad faith! What drives you to resent him that much? Envy? It's okay: he's achieved a lot, but maybe you can too if you work at it.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by munificent on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @07:17PM (#35447141)
I think Musk is a bad person, but I don't carry any particular resentment or anger towards him.

However, I think it's an unhelpful mindset for others to believe that Musk is some sort of model for entrepreneurial success.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by gordian-mind on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:33PM (#35456789)
> I think Musk is a bad person, but I don't carry any particular resentment or anger towards him.

Then maybe you should scrutinize who you get your information from: intelligent people who have worked with Musk, or random journalists and forumers that repeat talking points such as "this immense success over several decades of active executive role is just pure luck".

> However, I think it's an unhelpful mindset for others to believe that Musk is some sort of model for entrepreneurial success.

What an interesting thing to think! The person with arguably the greatest track record of entrepeneurial success alive should, under no occasion, be taken as some sort of model for entrepreneurial success. If you have contenders for this position, I'm interested.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by smackeyacky on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:50PM (#35434366)
As an external observer, I don't square the two different conclusions in your first statement: "equate wealth with ability", "everybody is a temporarily embarrassed millionaire".

There is a far stronger underpinning to the American attitude to wealth: It's not "equate wealth with ability", it's more "equate wealth with virtue and morality" - that the owners of wealth "did something right" generally has nothing to do with ability. Even the founders of Hewlett-Packard aren't remembered for their technological advances but for the "HP Way", a marker of virtue rather than business acumen.

The absolute veneration of "hard work" as a marker of success over connections/which hoo-ha you accidentally fell out of is rarely raised, despite their being overwhelming evidence that to be successfull in the US, you have to be born on 3rd base.

When it comes down to it, it should be absolutely no surprise that these billionaires with feet of clay rarely live up to the image that is built for them by the fanboys. Musk's family had a history of bizarre, he has simply not fallen far from the tree.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by FormerBandmate on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:45PM (#35427030)
The Twitter purchase really just shows how rich and apathetic Elon Musk is. A Ferrari is a difficult to impossible purchase for almost all of us, but rappers buy them for no reason and then trash them all the time. Twitter is that on a much larger scale, and Musk is treating it the same way because he doesn’t care.

You don’t build the first successful auto startup in 70 years and revitalize the space industry by being a moron. Everything Elon Musk has ever done with Twitter (including the 2018 SEC debacle) has been the dumbest shit possible, however

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by andy_ppp on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:01PM (#35427358)
Both SpaceX and Tesla nearly went bankrupt multiple times, we could just as easily be talking about an Elon Musk who had every advantage (government contracts, huge tax breaks and a fantastically wealthy family) and still failed. Maybe this is a case of fortune favoring the bold and I admire his perseverance/grit/marketing ability a lot. I've never heard him explain anything technical in any interview he's ever given and instead just starts behaving autistic if he's asked any detail about things. When he does stray into technical subjects like Twitter code he seems to talk nonsense that any engineer who has worked at a Twitter scale company would laugh at.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by cmh89 on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:47PM (#35430194)
He's really good at selling an image, which is what pushed Tesla ahead of other car makers. His whole 'Tony Stark' image is basically cat nip to tech bros and made Tesla cool and desirable.

I think you are spot on. There are dozens of 'Elon Musks' out there we don't notice or talk about because they didn't win. Someone was going to win in the space, the government was heavily incentivizing electric car purchases. Musk was the best salesmen and here we are. That doesn't make him a tactical genius.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by djmips on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:05PM (#35434465)
I don't believe that Musk's family was fantastically wealthy.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by lupire on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:56PM (#35434413)
Don't know why you went to rappers. When Musk first got rich, he bought a $million car and immediately destroyed it, uninsured, nearly killing himself and Peter Thiel. Imagine if he succeeded.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by RobotToaster on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:20PM (#35427710)
Given China's, (and to some extent, Asia's), obsession with face, his actions do all seem pretty clueless. I wonder, could it all be part of some performance?

The fact that they let Ali "voluntarily" restructure, and save face from having it be enforced, is interesting on it's own. I'm not really sure what to make of it.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by carschno on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:45PM (#35428166)
Genuine question: is there any evidence that "Asia's obsession with face" has actual impact on daily business, or is it really just a cliché?
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by KerryJones on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:57PM (#35429442)
Jack Ma is part of the evidence -- there are others who have said the same thing. There are many examples of less notoriety of people saying bad things about CCP and then "disappearing" (many government officials).
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by throwawaymaths on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:20PM (#35430699)
It's only a cliche, because westerners are often just as obsessed with face, though having a foot in two cultures there are a few big places where the difference is noticable:

US (and by extension NATO, doctrinally) military is very unconcerned with face in the small. For (real example) anyone on the bridge of a US ship can report to the captain of a ship that the ship is out of position (for an exercise). A buddy almost got walloped on the bridge of a ROK ship for doing that. They didn't because he was American and that's what exchanges are for.

some cultures in the west tend to value bluntness over face in the small.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by chrischen on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:37PM (#35434732)
Yea I remember an HN post from a US pilot trainer explaining the same culture problem in Korea in the aftermath of the Asiana airlines crash at SFO. But I see that as more of a hierarchy problem rather than saving face.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by twblalock on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:41PM (#35430963)
We don't need to resort to cultural tropes like "face" to explain this.

This is about power and control. The Communist party does not want any other centers of power or control to emerge which might challenge the party. Jack Ma, and the tech industry in general, was emerging as such a power. Now that problem has been taken care of.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by alimov on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:24PM (#35427770)
Reuters reported on Jack Ma’s return to China 7 days ago. The title is: Jack Ma returns to China as government tries to allay private sector fears
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by s1artibartfast on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:47PM (#35429255)
I think characterizing it as Clueless make some overly broad assumptions on Ma's motivations.

It could be as simple as he disagrees with the CCP policy.

For example, we don't typically look at human rights or anti-war protesters and call them Clueless, even when governments Crackdown on them

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by insane_dreamer on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:07PM (#35431300)
Clueless in understanding the consequences of disagreeing with CCP policy. He should have known what would happen.
Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by s1artibartfast on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:17PM (#35432728)
That is my exact point. I don't think it is reasonable to assume he wasn't aware that it was a risk.

It takes a special kind of arrogance to conclude that people are idiots simply because you don't understand their actions after a moment of thought and with no information.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by insane_dreamer on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @06:25PM (#35446669)
Ma is no idiot, and he knows how the system works or Alibaba would never have become a titan, but I think when you get to a certain level of power / money I it warps your perception of what's risky and you overestimate how much you can get away with because of your own sense of invincibility. Musk is a pretty good example of this.

So yeah, I would retract what I said about him being clueless, more like careless and overconfident.

I can tell you that no one in China was surprised when Ma got smacked down; we've seen this same thing play out over the past decade.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by s1artibartfast on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:45PM (#35460138)
When it comes to Ma or Musk, I think it easy to backseat, and project how we would have acted to get the outcome we would want. This ignores the reality that we don't actually know what their motivations and priorities are.

The relevant question is if Ma was actually surprised with the smackdown, or realized it was a possible/likely outcome, and chose to proceed anyways. You seem to think Ma made a mistake, maybe so, but maybe he would make the same choice again given the same chances.

Both Ma and Musk have FU money. They have both made choices that cost them money, but we can only guess at if they actually see their choices as mistakes. They are both still multi-billionaires, so their mistakes haven't been bad enough to cost them their lives or fortunes.

If you had 20 or 200B in the bank, would you let financial risks govern every decision you make? What price tag would you put on speaking your mind or living the life you want to live? How many billion would you gamble on a long shot? Being insanely wealthy probably makes people overconfident, but it absolutely makes some people more willing to take financial risks.

Im not saying Musk or Ma are right all the time, but I don't think it is right to judge everything through a financial lens, with hindsight, and no insider information on motivation. I think that anyone who pretends to know what Ma was thinking is overestimating their knowledge and ability.

Re:Alibaba breaks itself up in six by viewtransform on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:31PM (#35430860)
This article helped me understand the CPP. The author was expelled from CCP and lives in exile in the US.

The Weakness of Xi Jinping: How Hubris and Paranoia Threaten China’s Future https://archive.is/d9OsU