News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by UniverseHacker on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:17PM (#35277093)
These things are insane. I tried to cancel a month-to-month gym membership from a small local gym, and they told me "cancellations become effective on the 1st of the following month" and "require two months advance notice" thereby effectively charging me for three additional months after I gave notice. Apparently, this was all in the agreement I signed, although it was written so unclear, that nobody would even suspect this is how they interpret it.

I told them if you don't cancel it effective right now I am posting this dishonest predatory practice on every social media and review site in town, as well as telling all of my friends I met in here what you are doing, and asking them to please quit in protest. I'll also be doing a credit card chargeback, and a small claims court case to recover the time it takes me to deal with all of this. I will also take action to recover my back membership fees, because they repeatedly failed to maintain equipment in a usable condition, so I didn't get what I paid for. They did concede, and canceled it immediately.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bgun on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:22PM (#35277157)
Even though they conceded, you should still follow through on all of the above. You aren't hurting a person, it's a corporation that will only change when forced financially or socially to do so.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by SanderNL on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:39PM (#35277409)
A small local gym is not “a corporation”.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by crazygringo on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:42PM (#35277448)
Legally it usually is, isn't it? It would be unusual for it to be a sole proprietorship.

In any case, predatory/scammy practices are bad no matter what the ownership structure is. Being small and local doesn't excuse you from abusive behavior.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by plagiarist on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:41PM (#35277440)
Even if it is an individual, the predatory behavior deserves to be financially ruinous. If they cannot run their business without scamming people they should never have had a business.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by PM_me_your_math on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:41PM (#35277438)
Yes, all business entities, with the loose exception of a sole-proprietorship, is a corporation under the law.

There are four general types of corporations in the United States: a sole proprietorship, a Limited Liability Company (LLC), an S-Corporation (S-Corp), and a C-Corporation (C-Corp).

People who whine about corporations fail to realize that 99% of the businesses they deal with everyday are incorporated entities under the law. Your pizza shop, tanning salon, dentist, ice cream shop, sandwich truck...

A business entity can be a good or bad actor. Their legal status as a corporation does not mean they are automatically bad, regardless of the size or public/private status. Their actions and policies define them as either good or bad.

Words have meaning and they should be used appropriately.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by mindslight on Thursday March 23, 2023 @11:29PM (#35284737)
My own amateur understanding is that LLCs are distinct from corporations, and that S-corps and C-corps are tax statuses rather than types of legal entities.

Corporations generally have more diffuse ownership than LLCs, which is why people ascribe bad things to that type of entity. If there is a gym doing these tactics, and it's an LLC with a handful of owners ("members"), those owners are just asshole humans that could theoretically be punched in the face. Whereas if it's a corporation with diffuse ownership, then the policies become "just business" and "nobody's fault".

Although corporations certainly can be "closely held" by a few people or a family, just as you can sell shares in an LLC to investors at arms length or have all/part of the LLC owned by a corporation or business trust.

And frankly I'm surprised by the number of small businesses I see doing a sole proprietorship or partnership and doing-business-as rather than spending the money on LLC registration fees. Although as a business gets smaller, the protection afforded by the LLC structure also shrinks, so it's somewhat understandable.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by chitowneats on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:41PM (#35277430)
The "small local gym" sure was pulling some corporate B.S. on their supposed "neighbor".
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by chrisfosterelli on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:43PM (#35277470)
Technically, many small companies are corporations.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by mattgreenrocks on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:16PM (#35277980)
Except legal entities are literally manifest in order to absorb the fallout from situations like these. So don't be shy about using existing processes and tools to issue corrective action.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by pc86 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:40PM (#35278413)
As someone who used to own a couple small local gyms, they absolutely are.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by kjs3 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:34PM (#35284351)
If they've incorporated, they're a corporation. Being a small dick isn't per se different than being a big dick.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by UniverseHacker on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:44PM (#35277494)
Honestly, I was mostly bluffing... I didn't have time to do all of that, which is why I also had to quit the gym. I was planning to temporarily quit/suspend and then rejoin when I was able to, but they lost out on that possibility.

I think these kind of predatory cancellation things must be in part a generational thing, and these policies are so old they haven't responded to the times. Older people I know seem to expect it or be okay with it, but millenials and younger will tend to be outraged and refuse to do business with them on principle. America Online, Sirius XM, etc. were able to retain some customers by making it hard to quit, but I think turned away far more without realizing it.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by jiayo on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:07PM (#35281283)
Great example. I like broadcast radio. I don't like picking and choosing podcasts, I like to just listen to "what's on". I really like some of the live music content on SiriusXM (celebrity DJs, etc). I'm their ideal customer. And they'd have captured $300-400 of my value over the past 1.5 years, if they only had self-serve subscription and cancellation like Netflix or Disney+. But since they have decided to go the NYTimes route of "everyone pays a different price, and cancelling is next to impossible", they get nothing from me.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by terinjokes on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:15PM (#35283831)
I cancelled my SiriusXM subscription a fee months ago and it was a painless experience. They even refunded the amount charged a few days prior to my call, without me even asking.

Cancelling my at&t account, on the other hand, took several calls to them and my bank, and in the end, I just had my bank stop payment.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by dreen on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:32PM (#35277310)
Sometimes people you talk to have powers to change the outcome in your favour, sometimes all you need to do is ask.

I had an experience like that last year. I was cancelling my broadband in UK with Virgin, and got a £280 disconnection fee. The person who informed me said I will have to pay it in my final bill. Then over a month later I got a call from someone who's task was to see if I need a new connection where I was going. I said no, I was leaving the country. He asked if there was anything else he could do for me. I said, "you could cancel that huge penalty fee I got.." And he was just like "Sure, no problem, done."

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by manuelabeledo on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:43PM (#35277480)
A "disconnection fee"? This has to be the most absurd charge I have ever heard of.

What does "disconnecting" a customer involve, anyway? I recall having to return equipment or face a penalty to cover costs (high, but still somewhat understandable), but I have never had to pay to get off a broadband contract.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by dcomp on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:56PM (#35277664)
Most likely an early disconnection fee during the minimum term. Nearly everyone has a minimum term with virgin media as they only apply promotional discounts if you have a 12,18 or 24 month minimum term and the price shoots up as soon as you roll over onto the monthly.

[1] https://www.virginmedia.com/legal/fibre-optic-services-terms...

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bombcar on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:30PM (#35278232)
This is it exactly; it's kind of understandable given how they want you subscribe for a long time, and most have an exception that a high-enough ranking person can mark (even if it's just "military exception" misused).
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by dreen on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:15PM (#35277978)
Yep, something like that. I would have had to know if and when Im moving a year in advance, which is ridiculous. I mean it's not like I read the fine print on that, so all the better that they had no problem cancelling the fee.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by ipqk on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:52PM (#35277597)
Often if you sign a yearly contract that includes a discounted monthly rate, if you cancel it before the end of the year, you have to pay the remainder of the contract remaining.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by amalcon on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:38PM (#35280180)
That's just the beginning. My favorite is the concept of the pre-payment penalty: a lender can (in some jurisdictions) charge you a fee if you attempt to pay down the principal on your loan sooner than you are required to.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by pmalynin on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:42PM (#35280256)
Canada has this for mortgages no?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by heffer on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:27PM (#35281538)
Yes, other countries too, like Germany.

It's supposed to compensate banks for lost profit from you not paying interest for the entire term. Equally, a bank can't cancel your mortgage before the term ends for the sole reason that it would be able to charge higher rates for a new mortgage.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by sclarisse on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:56PM (#35281152)
It’s somewhat reasonable. If you make a loan, and it’s paid early, you stop making the expected profit and there is no guarantee you can reinvest the funds at the same rate. Therefore you will either disallow prepayment, charge for it, or price the risk of prepayment into your interest rate. If you can’t do any of those … you will invest elsewhere until the rates go up, for there is lots of competition for capital.

But borrowers should know what they’re getting into, and have options.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by maxerickson on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:09PM (#35282794)
In the US that would be part of the particular loan contract.

It means you have to pay attention when borrowing, but loans with that penalty likely carry a slightly lower rate for the borrower (because they are predictable for the lender). It isn't entirely arbitrary.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by smsm42 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:19PM (#35283867)
That's normal. You signed a contract where you take X money and promise to return X+Y money over N years. But instead, now you want to return only X+Z money when Z<Y. In some cases, it's ok, but it doesn't have to be. In fact, there could be loans where you just don't have such an option. E.g. if you buy government bonds, the government can't just give you back the money you spent and take the bond back. The fee is an intermediary option - you can do it, but for a fee. Sometimes, if they really want your money, they could give you the option for free - at least you'd pay Z, it's better than nothing. But it's no law of the universe that they must.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Symbiote on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:59PM (#35281181)
It's common where there's a significant installation fee (perhaps installing a fibre thing on your house) which was waived in return for a 12 or 24 month contract.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by OJFord on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:16PM (#35282101)
I haven't heard of (or it called) a 'disconnection' fee, but 'exit' fees are common. There's no pretence with that that there's work to do in terminating your contract, it's just, oh, you signed up for 24m, you want to leave in month 18, ok no problem but we'll sting you for £X because the alternative is probably you have actually technically committed legally to 24 months so in a way although it doesn't feel like it we're doing you a favour. ... It's pretty shit I think for tenants in particular where the available service periods don't necessarily line up with the time they actually spend in the property.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bob1029 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:33PM (#35277316)
This is why I always prepay for my gym membership up-front and do not enter into any agreement. There are a few places that do this. Last one I went to, I prepaid for 90 days. I confirmed they weren't even storing my payment information because I had to provide it again to renew the next quarter.

The best part of this is that when you decide you are done, you simply do nothing and its all over. Sure, you will get some marketing text spam for a few weeks but that's about it.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by booi on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:37PM (#35277381)
There's also the added benefit of being able to take advantage of "new memeber" offers
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by cloverTiger88 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:39PM (#35277411)
honestly there will be a delay from the government taking action on smaller local gyms too so I feel like there should be a way to submit the businesses for inspection at least to threaten them to improve their policies
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by tshaddox on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:48PM (#35277543)
I’m guessing you probably won’t win a chargeback unless you can show that you sent them a letter telling them to cancel (and because of this, they actually will cancel if you send them a letter).

I think another aspect of this problem is that credit cards don’t just let you mark a transaction as “don’t allow any more of these.” Of course that probably wouldn’t solve the problem. The gyms would probably just continue charging you and eventually send you to debt collection.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by maxsilver on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:55PM (#35277649)
> credit cards don’t just let you mark a transaction as “don’t allow any more of these.”

Ironically, they do almost all support this, you can mark any merchant as non-future-billable and prevent all future charges from a given merchant. Unfortunately, you have to call in and ask a phone rep to do it for you, most cards don't let you set this yourself.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by seer on Friday March 24, 2023 @12:01AM (#35284944)
Modern banks like Revolut have this as literary part of their UI.

They use some simple ML to figure out which are you recurring payments, place them in a separate folder for you to keep tabs on and allow you to unilaterally stop any “future payments like that”.

I mean on top of tech like virtual cards and chargebacks with a few clicks.

It seems so simple to implement I have no idea how its not a standard feature for banks these days.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Danjoe4 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:50PM (#35277566)
Revoking ACH authorization is an effective tactic. The CFPB dictates that if you give 3 days notice, companies are obligated to honor this. If they charge you afterwards, your bank will be more than happy to reverse the charge. To be clear, this doesn't void the contract you have with them, you're simply revoking their privilege to charge your payment method. If they want your money they'd have to take you to small claims. Here is a sample email which I've used many times to great effect:

May this email serve as your notice to revoke the ACH/Bank Access/Debit Card authorizations of both the below primary bank account and debit card, from [company] effective today, [date]

[Bank Name] Checking Account x** Savings Account x** and Debit Card x**

Additionally, I am revoking withdrawal authorizations from any other accounts associated with my personal information, listed below

name: DOB: phone #: email:

I am also revoking your further access to my banking accounts and have already removed your authorization with the Bank directly.

THIS REVOCATION APPLIES FOR THE NEXT PAYMENT DUE DATE AND ALL FUTURE DUE DATES.

Kindly, I ask that your response to this email shall be confirmation of receipt and you agree it is at least 3 business days prior to any scheduled repayments or membership fee deduction.

Note that in accordance with 12 CFR Part 1005.10(c) (Regulation E) you MUST HALT PAYMENT.

FAIL TO COMPLY and I will submit a report to the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection. Additionally, you will be responsible for any fees, including overdraft fees, incurred as a result of your failure to halt payment

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by KennyBlanken on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:41PM (#35278447)
> If they want your money they'd have to take you to small claims.

No, they'll just send it to collections, and now your credit is dinged for seven years because unless they violated their contract with you, you're still liable for the charges.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by UniverseHacker on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:33PM (#35279272)
I don't think they can do this- generally credit is tracked by social security number (in the USA). If you don't provide them with one, they will not be able to report you to a credit bureau.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by rationalist on Friday March 24, 2023 @08:30AM (#35288146)
Do you have a source, because I'm pretty sure that's false — they can use a combination of other identifying information such as name, birthdate, and address.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:15PM (#35279008)
Ive never heard of gyms doing that. Is it real? They are not a lender and are not lending money to you, so I don’t see how they can affect your credit report. There’s no credit involved.

Anyone actually have a credit report with an unpaid gym membership in the report?

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bluGill on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:37PM (#35279348)
Seems unlikely - collections only want to work with bills large enough that their odds of payment make it worth talking to you. Collectors never gives full price, they pay the person you owe some smaller amount, and when you pay they collect the difference.

There are levels of collections though the first is for things where they expect you will pay, you just need a payment plan (some medical labs don't do billing in house, they always sell it to collections), so collections will buy the bill for the pull price minus $50 (or some minimal amount in that range): since most people are going to pay collections just needs to setup the details for which $50 is a fair price. At the other end there are bills that they know you are not going to pay, collections will buy the a multi-thousand dollar bill for $1, and see if they can get any form of payment at all out of you.

Anyway, the bottom line is for a gym you are never going to owe enough that it is worthwhile for collections to touch it.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by treeman79 on Friday March 24, 2023 @12:05AM (#35284963)
I had a book from college that went missing. Paid 100 at start of semester. Supposed to return it at end.

99 dollar ding on credit. Hundreds of calls from hundreds of numbers about it. Took years to finally block all the numbers.

Beyond abusive.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by TylerE on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:29PM (#35279197)
There is credit involved, because the contracts are worded such that's, say, a 12 month contract paid in monthly installments. The credit is the outstanding balance vs. if you had paid for the full year in cash up front.

Your credit report is answering one question: How good are you about paying for things you've agreed to pay for.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by AdmiralAsshat on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:09PM (#35281313)
Worked on collections software for XX years. I definitely knew of a few clients that collected on behalf of gyms.

You'd be surprised what gets sent to collections. I recall one client that collected on behalf of a fried chicken restaurant.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bob1029 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:22PM (#35280780)
I've let a few things go to collections over the years. Comcast disputes, etc. Never really saw any impact from this. Total charge-offs probably around $1000. Not once have I had an issue getting financing or mortgage.

If you are intending to pay cash for everything, you don't even need a credit score. No one cares about who you are or what you did when you walk in the door with a bag of cash in each hand.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by tadfisher on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:18PM (#35278019)
Unfortunately, "ACH authorization" is a collective delusion, as there is no technical mechanism in the protocol to prevent ACH pulls.

Better to use something like a Privacy card in the first place so you can revoke it on your own terms.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by tyingq on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:21PM (#35278085)
>there is no technical mechanism in the protocol to prevent ACH pull

Nothing in the protocol, but many individual banks have their own in-house ways of failing the pull.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by yuliyp on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:22PM (#35278104)
It's not a delusion. From a legal perspective, the bank treats actions which are authorized by you and actions which are not differently. If you enter into an agreement that says you're authorizing entity X to charge you based on a contract and they charge you, the bank is likely to side with them, and tell you to go sue them if you want your money bank. If the bank knows that you did not authorize the ACH transfer, they're supposed to reverse the transaction.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by benced on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:32PM (#35279260)
Bits have color, no matter what us software engineers think: https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Akronymus on Friday March 24, 2023 @04:28AM (#35286466)
Am I missing some context here? This seems to not be related to the grandparent comment at all, to me.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by foobarian on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:30PM (#35278228)
Are there privacy cards that work? I find that once a recurring charge is established and tied to an account it's very hard to cancel, surviving expired cards or even canceled card numbers.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by fouc on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:35PM (#35278327)
I think they're referring to privacy.com specifically, which should give fully cancellable virtual cards. Or so I heard.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:13PM (#35278978)
citi, capital one, and others call it “virtual cards”. They allow you to set charge limits and exp date. I always choose the current month + 1 for expiration and for charge limit, $1 more than the anticipated charge
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by flutas on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:13PM (#35281367)
Or just get you dinged for $200+ of fraud and they will refuse to do anything about it.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bsg75 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:53PM (#35283667)
Does this refer to privacy.com, or something else?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by pc86 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:35PM (#35278325)
Privacy generates a valid CC # with protections you set up (one-time use, monthly maxes, per-charge maxes, etc).
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by astura on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:01PM (#35278777)
You can revoke a subscription in PayPal.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by kube-system on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:32PM (#35278271)
It is common for gyms to only accept ACH
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by HWR_14 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:10PM (#35279811)
There doesn't have to be a technical mechanism. There is a legal one.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by patmorgan23 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:44PM (#35281010)
The mechanism is when the bank authorizes or denys the ACH pull.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by preommr on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:16PM (#35277985)
And people actually reply to that?

What do you do if they tell you no one got this email?

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by pc86 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:37PM (#35278361)
You mean what do you do if someone knowingly lies in order to continue fraudulently charging you for something? Sounds like a crime to me.

But more realistically, at that point you've already filed a claim with the CFPB so who cares what they say? It will get settled one way or the other.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by billpg on Friday March 24, 2023 @05:00AM (#35286674)
We live in a world of spam filters. Email is not a reliable delivery system. "I didn't see it" is always plausible when dealing with emails.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by nijave on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:26PM (#35282248)
Some companies report this type of thing to consumer trust worthiness services (similar to credit bureaus). Other companies use these services to gage customer risk before initiating new service so you can effectively get yourself blacklisted.

Not saying this answer isn't the way to do it, but it's not without additional collateral damage in some cases.

Even if it doesn't impact other companies, the company in question may refuse to do business with you in the future (which may or may not be of concern).

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by camhart on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:59PM (#35283248)
If you're dealing with a (normally small) company that generally takes care of their customers, an email like this as a conversation starter is just going to make the customer support reps lives miserable and make them not want to lift a finger for you. Save this for the companies that really deserve it.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by junon on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:16PM (#35283382)
Feelings do not trump laws. If those reps are miserable working at a company knowingly employing deceptive or predatory tactics, they should find employment elsewhere.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by camhart on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:28PM (#35284320)
I literally said save it for the companies that deserve it... Did you fail to read my entire comment?

A decent person cares about being decent towards other human beings.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by nkrisc on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:28PM (#35283910)
This isn't about service reps, it's about you. Sometimes you have to look out for yourself. This is hardly being abusive to service reps so they can suck it up and deal with it.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by camhart on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:32PM (#35284338)
You should care about how you treat others. When a simple "hey, can you help me cancel my subscription?" would suffice, there's no reason to turn into a jerk.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by FireBeyond on Thursday March 23, 2023 @08:08PM (#35283323)
> To be clear, this doesn't void the contract you have with them, you're simply revoking their privilege to charge your payment method.

It's gotten better, but on more than one occasion I've had to argue with my bank to honor my request to block the charges. I've had tellers say "Well, if you have a subscription with them, this needs to be allowed". No. As you say - my bank's obligation is to honor my account wishes, not be an arbiter of my agreements with third parties.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by whythre on Friday March 24, 2023 @04:26AM (#35286456)
That is fucking bizarre that bank personnel would even try to argue with you. Why would a bank want their customers to be ripped off by shitty subscriptions?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by gigatexal on Friday March 24, 2023 @12:18AM (#35285032)
This would be a super duper feature add to a company or service that learns all your subscriptions and helps you cancel them.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by jrib on Friday March 24, 2023 @06:14AM (#35287137)
> and have already removed your authorization with the Bank directly

Can you expand on what you mean by this?

My banks don't offer me some way to revoke authorization from the bank's website. Does this mean calling customer service and giving them a business name to disallow future ach debits from?

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by phil21 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:52PM (#35277599)
> I'll also be doing a credit card chargeback

Maybe you would since it's a local gym, but if it's a national chain credit card companies won't even let you initiate the chargeback whatsoever.

I had to go so far as to completely cancel my Amex account to get Lifestyle Fitness to stop billing me. American Express utterly refused to either chargeback, or deny future billings. To the point a new card number issued didn't even fix it. I was quite happy to sign a waiver that I'd take all liability.

This was after moving states, calling to cancel, and them saying I needed to fly in to cancel in person. Outright scam that the banks help enable.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by dangwhy on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:55PM (#35277639)
> Outright scam that the banks help enable.

I think first logical step is to legislate banks from enabling this. That should cover most of the problem without a wide ranging laws.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by denimnerd42 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:56PM (#35277667)
my amex processed my chargeback for gold's gym just fine. They said it was a no obligation free trial I could cancel at any time and then when I called to cancel before the first bill they said no, you have to come once a week for that to be true..?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bombcar on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:33PM (#35278287)
A chargeback is distinct from a "never let this company charge me again" - the latter some places can't do.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by markus_zhang on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:58PM (#35277702)
We should have a github repo for these scamming activities.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by tibbon on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:21PM (#35281448)
I wonder why Amex plays ball with them? They are normally really firm about their chargebacks
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by jamincan on Friday March 24, 2023 @07:33AM (#35287686)
Isn't that part of the value proposition of Amex in the first place?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by markus_zhang on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:56PM (#35277668)
I'm thinking as an added protection measure we should always use a secondary phone line plus a secondary email and fake address for these types of subscriptions. You don't know what they are going to do.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bombcar on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:48PM (#35278562)
When you have to utilize dark web techniques to get a gym membership, maybe it's time to do something else.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Waterluvian on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:08PM (#35277850)
They prey on people who don't want to rock the boat, don't know that they can try to rock the boat, or are just too busy for this absolute nonsense.

The leadership of any company that does anything like this should be very consciously aware that they're mediocre leftovers of the professional world. Real leaders of real companies don't have to be predatory. It is a screaming confession of incompetence.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by mattgreenrocks on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:13PM (#35277938)
> Real leaders of real companies don't have to be predatory. It is a screaming confession of incompetence.

There's a certain toxic element of business culture that preaches dominance as a virtuous thing, ether overtly, or through dubious terminology/beliefs in ideas like "alpha males." It argues that if you aren't dominating someone, then they necessarily must be dominating you in this interaction.

It is an extremely reductionistic view that has trickled down into certain parts of Weird Internet, too.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:18PM (#35278021)
> Real leaders of real companies don't have to be predatory

I dont think it works as your described. Amazon is plenty predatory.

What happens is a company tries to see what it can get away with. If they don't get in legal trouble, and customers don't abandon them in droves, then other companies start doing the same. It becomes industry standard.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Waterluvian on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:29PM (#35278218)
You might be right. Though I think this is a cousin of "I'm just following orders." Too many people don't speak up. Is there nobody who feels embarrassed that this is what they're a part of?

"Hey dad, what did you do at work today?"

"I worked with some lawyers to make an indecipherable contract so that we can extract extra money for a service someone doesn't want."

I guess the answer is some mix of "make the org structure so complex that everyone can feel innocent because no one person is pulling the trigger" (I don't buy it, that just means incompetent managers) plus a heaping scoop of cognitive dissonance.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by daemedeor on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:22PM (#35280781)
There’s two layers to it.

With a sufficiently large enough org, you can build it in discrete enough parts (assuming it’s a building something based) that only the one who creates the final part is the one who knows what the ultimate goal is or the one who pulls the trigger. These people are also high enough to be inured to any effects of their decision. The second layer is even if you can see where it’s going and you do care, is it worth it to speak up and get fired? I know whistleblowers are meant to be protected (speaking only for the US) but with at-will employment and certain conditions that favor employers, how do you know they won’t cycle in someone who will do it anyway?

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by myaccountonhn on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:03PM (#35281915)
My experience is that they somehow delusion themselves into thinking they are doing a good thing and providing a good service.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by Jochim on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:05AM (#35289993)
I think the root cause is the lack of social consequences for this kind of antisocial behaviour. Charles Boycott[0] engaged in a similar kind of behaviour and in response the local community refused to engage with him.

That particular kind of community has largely disappeared. Furthermore, the consequences of someone's actions are often so far removed from the people they interact with that the behaviour becomes easily excused.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Boycott

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by prawn on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:49PM (#35282559)
I imagine there are consultants that go around to gyms (especially chains) and say "We've got x things that are trivial to implement and will guarantee you make $123 more per customer on average. Cost for our analysis and recommendations is $12,345 with an assurance that you will make this back in the first 6 months." And one of the things is adding a paragraph to the sign up terms.

It's a bit like the toothpaste consultant story.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by maxerickson on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:11PM (#35282810)
It's like how bike stores and hair salons want you to set up an account.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by prawn on Thursday March 23, 2023 @07:37PM (#35283065)
Everyone wants you to set up an account. It's tiring just visiting a physical store!
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by JohnTHaller on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:14PM (#35277959)
Careful, many gyms will send you to collections for failing to pay to the terms of the contract.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bluGill on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:41PM (#35279396)
Depending on the law though, you may be able to ignore collections, and you can dispute it if they put anything on your credit report. Just because something is in a contract that doesn't mean it is legal an enforceable. See a lawyer for details as this is different in every state and country.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by bob1029 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:08PM (#35281296)
Collections is mostly meaningless if you are otherwise financially responsible.

The entire system is quite abusive. You may try experimenting with "I don't give a shit", assuming your other ducks are in order. I have found it to be therapeutic.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by kjs3 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:39PM (#35284390)
You can contest being sent to collection tho (in the US: Fair Debt Collection Practices Act). It takes time and research to understand what you have to do, but being sent to collections isn't always a credit death sentence.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by temporallobe on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:29PM (#35278201)
I had a similar situation. During covid, a gym I was attending shut down some of their locations because of covid, forcing all those members to crowd into fewer locations. Those gyms became unusable to me because of equipment hogging and overcrowding (I typically counted on one hour to complete a full workout and was extremely pressed for time, now it would take me at least twice that). I tried to cancel, citing my reasons, but I got a similar runaround to you. I also had to submit my cancellation in writing and mail it into their corporate office. I refused to do any of this, so I called my credit card company and complained that they were fraudulently charging me and requested that they block further charges. Sure enough, a few months later I got letters and emails threatening to cancel my membership because there was an issue with my payment method. Since the membership was month-to-month, they couldn’t hold me responsible for anything beyond the month for which I had already paid.

I joined a small private gym that works on a monthly prepaid membership. Just pay for the month in advance, and you have access. Don’t pay? No access, no pressure, no worries. Leave for months at a time and come come back with no hassle.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:33PM (#35278298)
I personally had to get cc dispute started, because, $my_local_gym_that_is_not_a_chain also uses the same scummy tactics including, but limited to starting to add more charges. They also said, I need to fax my hand written cancellation to their HQ. I did, but as you can guess there is a reason I opened a dispute with CC.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by kemitche on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:19PM (#35279067)
I had a gym membership that I wanted to cancel because I had moved, and their closest location was no longer convenient.

First, they tried to tell me I had to go back to the location I had originally signed up at in order to cancel. No phone cancellation options or anything. I guess if I had moved more than a few miles away, I'd be out of luck.

After some fighting, the closer location let me fill out a paper cancellation form. The cancellation form had a very clear section that showed "paid in full" and "$0 remaining due." Despite this, I got a bill a month later for my "final month." I refused to pay it, obviously. They harassed me, calling me daily. Only once I posted a poor review online did someone finally decide the $50 (or whatever it was) wasn't worth it.

They gym itself was a fine gym, but these billing practices are scummy scummy scummy. I refuse to sign up for any other gym (except maybe a local rec center) until there's more legislation to protect my consumer rights. The cancellation nonsense isn't worth my time.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by louison11 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:16PM (#35279905)
The opposite happened to my partner here in Portugal. She signed up to a gym ($100/month), and they literally forgot to start charging the account until 5 months later. Everything tends to be so inefficient here. I guess at least in this case the inefficiency worked in our favor. Now let's hope they won't take 5 months to stop charging when we cancel ;-)
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by grammers on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:21PM (#35280765)
My daughter had dancing lessons in the past (never again!), we quit because she did not want to go anymore. They told us we can only quit by the end of the quarter with a month's notice - it was beginning of March, so too late to quit for end of June.

Then Covid hit, classes got cancelled; we still had to pay until end of September. This fine print is totally insane.

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by josephcsible on Thursday March 23, 2023 @10:05PM (#35284148)
> classes got cancelled; we still had to pay until end of September. This fine print is totally insane.

Isn't charging people for things you don't give them supposed to be one of those things that are illegal no matter what any contracts say?

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by knodi123 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:19PM (#35281434)
such a depressingly common trope.

them: "Sorry, there's nothing I can do, I simply can't help you!"

customer: "I'll be really annoying."

them: "I figured out how to help you!"

Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by themitigating on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:49PM (#35281758)
This is exactly how most people operate. Reactive instead of proactive.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by OJFord on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:11PM (#35282038)
Just cancel the payment, I wouldn't even bother to talk to them if it's clear it'll be difficult. They'll send you a letter or something saying if you don't update the payment method your access will be cancelled. Ok?
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by EastSmith on Thursday March 23, 2023 @06:54PM (#35282607)
I think you should do what you told them you would do anyway - posting on each and every social network.
Re:The FTC wants to ban those tough-to-cancel gym and cable ... by treeman79 on Friday March 24, 2023 @12:01AM (#35284946)
Similar. I got badly injured. Gym said I could only cancel in person. Was not possible. Played me off between gym and corporate for several days. Went ballistic on all social media, review sites etc. wrote some emails shaming them. Charged back from bank.

They finally agreed to cancel remotely.