I would not be surprised if he could have offered the api $420/mo and 100x more apps were willing and/or able to pay.
It was profitable. He caused it to hurtle toward bankruptcy.
https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mje/2022/12/21/twitter-and-its-f...:
> Twitter has been operating at a massive loss for years, failing to book an annual profit since 2019 (Mauer, 2022). For eight out of the last ten years, the company has posted a loss.
https://www.netcials.com/financial-net-profit-year-quarter-u...
Twitter’s underlying business was already profitable.
He almost certainly caused some advertisers to leave, but as a reference snapchat had similar decreases in advertising spend, so its hard to argue this is all Musk and not considerably due to economic conditions and apple's privacy changes
No, that's a misunderstanding. What Fox News cares about is growing and maintaining an audience because that's what profitable. In pursuit of that profit, Fox News will foster its community however it can.
And so, driven by profit seeking, Fox News has embraced total nihilism. Fox News will spin any narrative, tell any lie, invent any fiction if it thinks it is what its audience wants to hear. The more Fox News offers its audience comforting fictions, no matter how untrue, the better for the bottom line.
You don't have to believe me on that. It's what Fox News says of itself:
https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/03/08/tucker-car...
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/02/fox-news-d...
look up the roger ailes papers from when it was founded
Musk is very vocal about his far-right views. He's anti-union, anti-public health, etc.
>how are they amplified considering anybody can post anything?
Anyone can post anything, but Musk can and has systemically prioritized his tweets over organic content.
I'd be interested in any sort of proof.
> Musk is very vocal about his far-right views. He's anti-union, anti-public health, etc.
Please show specific examples of his far-right views, so I can understand what specifically you mean by that term other than things you personally find disagreeable.
Have you been paying attention? https://www.theverge.com/2023/2/14/23600358/elon-musk-tweets... "This story is based on interviews with people familiar with the events involved and supported by documents obtained by Platformer."
You neglected to show any examples of aforementioned far right views.
And from your own link:
> legitimate technical reasons the CEO’s tweets weren’t performing. Twitter’s system has historically promoted tweets from users whose posts perform better to both followers and non-followers in the For You Tab; Musk’s tweets should have fit that model but showed up less only about half the time that some engineers thought they should.
..
> That explains why people opening the app Monday found that Musk dominated the feed, with a dozen or more Musk tweets and replies visible to anyone who followed him and millions more who did not. Over 90 percent of Musk’s followers now see his tweets, according to one internal estimate.
Stands to reason that 90 percent of followers should see tweets for a person they chose to follow..
Where is the conspiracy?
> Musk acknowledged his bombardment of the timeline on Tuesday afternoon, posting a version of the popular “forced to drink milk” meme
> he seemed to suggest that the changes would be walked back, at least in part. “Please stay tuned while we make adjustments to the uh .… “algorithm,” he tweeted.
> Absurd as Musk’s antics are, they do highlight a tension familiar to almost anyone who has ever used a social network: why are some posts more popular than others? Why am I seeing this thing, and not that one?
> Engineers for services like TikTok and Instagram can offer partial, high-level answers to these questions. But ranking algorithms make predictions based on hundreds or thousands of signals, and deliver posts to millions of users, making it almost impossible for anyone to say with any degree of accuracy who sees what.
> For better and for worse, that answer hasn’t been good enough for Musk.
> But Musk’s view counts still fluctuate widely
Yeah, nice try bud. We aren't verge readers here, this is not difficult to understand.
In any case, you sure did a lot of creative reading to avoid reading this sentence:
The algorithm now artificially boosted Musk’s tweets by a factor of 1,000 – a constant score that ensured his tweets rank higher than anyone else’s in the feed.
But that doesn't matter, does it? You're just going to construct something out of precision-selected tidbits anyway as a rebuttal. Really, I think that if you have something to say, you should just say it out loud from the outset instead of leading people around by the nose and wasting everyone's time.If only I would go along with mindless gossip without asking questions.
The artificial boosts applied to his account remain in place, although the factor is now lower than 1,000, we’re told.
Alas.Nevermind breathless verge articles the dude was literally tweeting about all of this as they were tinkering.
> Really, I think that if you have something to say, you should just say it out loud from the outset instead of leading people around by the nose and wasting everyone's time.
It is very obvious to me and most here that some people hate Musk now so much they are willing to do exactly what you accused me of - construct something out of precision-selected tidbits - and throw shade that he is some far-right type. To certain people anybody they don't like is "far right" and <insert bad term here>.
This is very lame behavior. Cancel culture is canceled my friend. The ends do not justify the means.
It's difficult to take this kind of response in good faith. You asked for any proof and the article puts it pretty directly that he pressed for changes to systematically prioritize his own tweets (including to non-followers) and then do a strawman argument against one statement to dismiss the whole thing.
To me the key part of the article is this bit:
> he seemed to suggest that the changes would be walked back, at least in part. “Please stay tuned while we make adjustments to the uh .… “algorithm,” he tweeted.
> Absurd as Musk’s antics are, they do highlight a tension familiar to almost anyone who has ever used a social network: why are some posts more popular than others? Why am I seeing this thing, and not that one?
I actually saw this unfold in real time as he was tweeting about all of this in the open as it was happening (not just the milk meme) -- a lot of people tweeted at him that the algorithm was b0rked and he was replying and saying they were tinkering until they arrived at a place where, according to the very article, 90 percent of his and other peoples followers actually started seeing tweets from people they followed. This simply makes sense, no?
I don't see a smoking gun where he over prioritized his own tweets maliciously. They even deboosted his magic number as part of the cowboy debugging session.
Recall the original claim I was replying to is:
> It is a megaphone to amplify his own voice and the voices that support his viewpoints.
I just don't buy this narrative, forgive my skepticism. You can go look at his reply timeline and see for yourself and draw your own conclusions no need for the verge editorializing.
I understand some people view him as a malicious actor but going out of your way to ascribe the least charitable interpretation to everything is just not convincing to people who aren't invested in the politics. You're even directing this attitude towards me for not automatically agreeing with this viewpoint.
> Anyone can post anything, but Musk can and has systemically prioritized his tweets over organic content.
>If we keep throwing that around when we mean right leaning or politically right views then anyone on the right is going to be "far-right
The GOP is a far-right political party. They are fundamentally anti-democracy.
>and we're never going to work together.
We aren't going to work together regardless because the far-right GOP doesn't want the same things as most Americans. They are a political minority that can wreak havoc on the country due to poorly thought electoral systems.
>I think that the other comments to you are to point out where Elon has fascist or Nazism beliefs.
There is more to the far-right than having Nazism beliefs. American far-right is Christian Fascist. Elon Musk is a fascist a la Henry Ford.
He provides vocal and material support to fascist and far-right causes such as vaccine conspiracies and transphobia. He's anti-labor, anti-safety regulations.
I'm guessing you're one of those folks who want to pretend he's not far-right until he openly wears a swastika.
My pronouns are Prosecute/Fauci
> In five words, Musk manages to mock transgender and nonbinary people, signal his disdain for public-health officials, and send up a flare to far-right shitposters and trolls.Heh. I have a disdain for throwing shade and hyperbole, am I also far right cmh89? :)
I don't know. How often do you pal around with far-right people and help spread their rhetoric? That would be a good indicator. If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and walks like a duck, its probably a duck.
Likewise, Musk has adopted far-right talking points, wants far-right approval, and supports far-right causes. He's probably a duck huh
When any amount of right wing is far right, it just show how far left your perspective is. And if you think far right is in any way worse than far left, that's just more evidence of the same. They're the same people, just with opposite causes.
It's more complicated than just the ability to post. Never discount the power of the algorithm. And that can be tinkered with:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-15/musk-forc...
That would be a change of subject, wouldn't it? I suspect you aren't interested in any evidence anyone will present on what Elon has done, given your tu quoque reply.
The twitter files are not a change of subject as they are precisely about the power of the algorithm, censorship, and how it was tinkered with prior to Musk taking over. It is literally your concerns but backed up with actual proof.
Understand something: I think such things are very bad regardless of the direction in which it applies. I am a-political. I would actually be very interested in any actual evidence.
It is a bummer that you think I will just be willing to put my head in the sand if it was Musk doing it, clearly you think I am somehow aligned politically with his views (whatever the hell they are supposed to be) and would be willing to look the other way. Nope, not the case. People do be like that and this is a problem.
Again, regardless of affiliation, it is a problem.
You didn't ask about the pre-Elon days. You asked about Elon, so multiple people have responded accordingly. Being unable to rebut them, you've chosen to try to divert the topic to something else.
>clearly you think I am somehow aligned politically with his views
I do. But I'll disengage at this point, given your insincerity.
> I do. But I'll disengage at this point, given your insincerity.
Aw :(
Yeah that just about sums you up. Have a nice day.
If you have been paying attention to his tweets they are mainly really stupid far right takes on things.
For a supposedly smart man he says some INCREDIBLY stupid things.
https://www.axios.com/2022/10/30/elon-musk-paul-pelosi-tweet...
Oh, it's better because you want to agree with them.
Right wing tends to be very egalitarian compared to the right's support of a social hierarchy and wealth concentration.
I don't remember being a highly profitable venture before, so what was the previous owners intentions with owning the business but not caring if it generated a reasonable return?
What propaganda were they spewing?
It was profitable on an ongoing basis (the most recent reported period had a one-time charge that made it unprofitable, IIRC) though not “highly profitable”. Since the Musk takeover was announced – leading to forward advertising sales drying up even before it was consummated – its been (by Musk’s own description, including as to the timing, though he places the blame elsewhere) hurtling toward bankruptcy.
- Jim Morrison
Doesn't make economic sense at all if you buy it for $44 billion when it was already on shakey financial grounds.
The genius of Fox News was "why spend money on buying political attack ads when you can just buy the network and run them all day long." Twitter is just becoming that too.