I don't think any serious media is pro-war, it's more like we have two choices: (1) either send weapons, or (2) watch Ukrainians die and become slaves of Putin. This is a tough moral choice because either involves killing, but we don't have the luxury of having more choices. If we don't do anything, Ukrainians will suffer. If we ask Urkainians to surrender, they won't even listen because they know how cruel their fate will be.
at the same time a narative is being developed in all the major media that the freedom of europe and west depends on ukranian victory. if thats the case, whats the next logical conclusion if ukraine actually begins to lose the war? to me this smells of preparation of the general population for a (much) larger war
We are very far from average Joe being sent to the Russian front. Partly because there is a professional army that will be involved before that, but more likely it will not, in order to avoid nuclear conflict. I think you should worry more about that than the general population being sent to Ukraine.
The alternative is that we are afraid, we do nothing, and once Putin finishes off with Ukraine, he is ready to invade the ex-Eastern bloc countries, and then go further West. Because if everybody is afraid, who is going to stop him?
But yes, it's possible that NATO forces could enter the fight. There are already large quantities of NATO troops in Poland, Estonia, etc. Entire US, British, French, etc. brigades on standby.
This isn't new -- we've played these games for damn near 50 years of Cold War. Most of the leaders of NATO, to include Putin and Biden, were Cold Warriors and grew up during that era. They know the game and what's at stake.
But that means lots of staredowns, not necessarily a lot of fighting. Ukraine isn't NATO -- hell, 50 years ago UKR was USSR, and would have been shooting at NATO forces -- and if they need to be sacrificed to collapse the Russian government then so be it. Welcome to Realpolitik.
To that end NATO will prop them up as much as needed to continue grinding down Russian military and economic forces. I believe they will let UKR collapse and be taken over instead of sending troops; only if NATO forces are attacked directly, or maybe if nukes are involved, will NATO do anything more than it is now. Furthermore, it's possible that Ukraine actually wins -- they appear to be absorbing, at high cost mind you, the renewed Russian offensive, and may soon be able to hit back with their own...
And if you think that the western world is not any better than Putin, well, I wish you a very happy life somewhere in Russia...
if you study history of rise of fascism it began all began with supression of differeing opinions. dont forget that nazis received some pretty good encouragement from the US and UK in order to contain the spread of communism. same as sadam. same as taliban
first they came for the jews, but i was not jewish. then they came for the communists, but i was not a communist ... then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me
also read some history about horrors of war before you pump your chest
No, you totally misread that. I did not want to send you anywhere.
I just wish people put their money where their mouth is. If you are living in a developed country it's easy to romanticize a communist dictatorship (or not communist anymore - who cares), where writing your opinion in a public forum would actually get you in real trouble (as in prison, or worse), as opposed to another forum user writing a critical response to your message.
> if you study history of rise of fascism it all began with supression of differeing opinions
Am I suppresssing you now? Or to take one step further, are you calling me a nazi, just because I don't agree with you and I dare to reply? Wow.
> first they came for the jews, but i was not jewish. then they came for the communists, but i was not a communist ... then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me
And what does this quote have to do with anything in this thread?
For the last time, I did not. You wrote:
> do not pretend that us and nato are any better
To which my reply was that if you really think so, then you have no idea what you are talking about, and maybe it would help your understanding if you tried the Russian way of things. Figuratively, not literally.
HTH, and have a nice day.
> And if you think that the western world is not any better than Putin, well, I wish you a very happy life somewhere in Russia...
you said that on the basis of me saying that western foreign policy is no better than putins. it is not. neither now and definitely not historically
There could be a small chance that The Netherlands would activate military service again for anyone up to 45 years old if this war escalates further. I don’t want to fight in this war. I’m 40 years old and I want to care for my family (daughter & girlfriend).
This is not my war and I don’t want to get involved in any way.
Even worse: USA sabotaged the Russian-German pipeline and all Western mass media acts like nothing has happened. Germany has proven to be a lap dog of US interests by staying silent on the matter.
All the Western politicians that are pushing for war will not be on the frontlines themselves and most likely neither will their children.
It’s a shame the Western world and Ukraine deceived Russia with the Minsk accords, as Germany recently admitted [0]. We didn’t have to be in this situation.
———
[0]: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/12/22/ffci-d22.html
Your comment has many factual mistakes, but this is by far the best - you write this as if the NATO attacked Russia, and not the other way around... did you notice that Russia is not only "pushing" the war, but actually attacking another country, not the other way around? That Russians soldiers are in Ukraine, not Ukrainian soldiers in Russia?
> I do feel Russia has had a very valid argument regarding the NATO threat
This is exactly what the Russian propaganda states - they are somehow OK to attack because they feel threatened. I don't remember any occasion after WW2 when Russia was attacked on its home land... especially not by NATO.
Maybe next time they attack your country we can just let them have it, after all, they might be threatened by you and you don't want to get involved in any way, anyway...
> too many people died on both sides
Yes, let's not forget the massacres in Bucha and the other war crimes Russia has committed. What do you propose we do with that? Just close your eyes, since it was not you or your family that they killed, and you don't want to get involved anyway?
Neither do Ukrainians. But they don't have much of a choice really.
> Already too many people died on both sides.
And who started that?
> This is not my war and I don’t want to get involved in any way.
> I’m 40 years old and I want to care for my family (daughter & girlfriend).
Yeah, as do Ukrainians, but they can't because someone wants to kill them just because they didn't like the idea of no longer being Ukrainians.
> It’s a shame the Western world and Ukraine deceived Russia with the Minsk accords.
Ukrainians wanted to be working more closely with the west. Would you like to be relocated to Russia, or going to prison and your daughter going to orphanage if you didn't want to be Russian [0]?
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/03/01/russia-child...
I’m not sure this question leads anywhere.
I’d like to know, what must be the case for Russia to be able to withdraw from Ukraine?
They may have started, but I’ve heard a claim that for strategic reasons, Russia was compelled to invade; compelled to continue the invasion.
Even if that’s not true, what can the EU do while Ukraine is defending so that Russia is incentivised to switch from war to commerce?
Can anything be done? I don't think we can do much except supplying weapons. Putin can not admit defeat, that's unthinkable for him. So he will send many young and old men to die, until the political situation changes, but I don't believe it can happen anytime soon.
Do I also have a valid reason to barge into your home, rape and slaughter you, your girlfriend and daughter, steal and ruin your furniture if I believe that you pose imaginary threat to me?
> It’s a shame the Western world and Ukraine deceived Russia with the Minsk accords, as Germany recently admitted [0]. We didn’t have to be in this situation.
You mean how Western world and Russia deceived Ukraine with Budapest memorandum? Had they kept nuclear weapons, Russia would stay put or risk having European part of Russia transformed into nuclear wasteland.
> I’m totally from the Netherlands > NATO, US poke the bear > I don’t want to fight *this* war > Think of children > US sabotaging pipeline > Germany is a lapdog > Phony Minsk accords
All in all, weak try, Ivan, here are your 15 rubles.
In case anyone is wondering this is line is very telling.
It's Russian propaganda -- anyone who uses it has been consuming Russian media.
Interestingly, the story is still unfolding on this one, going through:
* "it's obviously the Russian, stupid",
* "wait, no, it's not obviously the Russian, we don't have any proof"
* "thinking about it, it's probably not the Russian, let us investigate"
* "Russian propaganda claims it's the USA, but no-one really believe them anymore, because 'previous year'"
* "previously famous journalist claims it's the USA on his blog, but hardly anyones believe him, because 'anonymous source quoted on a blog'"
* "US intelligence claims it was Ukraine based on undisclosed sources". [1]
For some reason, "the evil western media" does not seem to have too much trouble accusing Ukraine of sabotages - but we're still playing the "whose undisclosed source do we believe ?" game.
Don't insult your intelligence (pun intended) pretending you know better than anyone.
We'll wait and see and humbly acknowledge that this one will probably remain in shadow for a while.
However, I suspect the "It's obviously the CIA, stupid" narrative will go on forever. It's just too catchy. "On ne prête qu'aux riches".
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/07/us/politics/nord-stream-p...
- Condoleeza Rice [2014]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btk_Ldd3NF0
- Biden & Schulz [2022]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OS4O8rGRLf8
- US warns German port of crushing sanctions [2020]: https://www.dw.com/en/nord-stream-2-us-senators-threaten-ger...
Which just makes them _one_ of the many parties that have an intereset in blowing up the pipeline. Again, it's really tempting to jump to this conclusion, not at all unreasonnable or unrealistic, it's just that there _are_ alternatives, and we're still in the mist about that.
It's not rocket science, it's much worse: it's geopolitics. At least in rocket science, you have launches as a "moment of truth" (rocket up / rocket not up.) We love it in HN because it's both very hard to do and very simple to interpret.
Politics ? The exact opposite. Very simple to lie / deceit / build narrative, hardly impossible to get a clear answer on anything - you can always add a "rail in the pool" and build a "credible" alternative narrative.
(My personnal "favorite guess", which is really nothing than that, would be that Ukraine would have done it with some light support (trainging ? intelligence ?) from the USA, while Germany was just "looking the other way". This would provide a "win" for Ukraine, "plausible deniability" for the USA, and "one negoctiation chip less" for Russia to put pressure on Germany - sometimes, constraints are liberating. Pure speculation. No data. I won't feel bad if it ends up being wrong. Would feel better if the war could just stop tomorrow.)
I suppose the closest thing we have to an "arbitrer of truth" will be the Nordics-based investigation ? Sweden is not in NATO yet, Norway and Denmark do not seem particularly hawkish (but I could be wrong), yet they don't have friendly ties to Russia, it's weird stuff happening "close to home"... who knows ?
Knowing this is not exactly in my circle of control. I'm more interested in how we're going to make EU neither "Russian-gas dependant", nor "US-gas dependant", nor "Middle-East-gas dependant".
> Germany has proven to be a lap dog of US interests by staying silent on the matter.
Yes this is the very pillar of NATO, the other is to keep Russia out and this pillar is shaking.
Because from my understanding, the USA only has granted loans to Ukraine (though EU might have gifted some weapons). If NATO wins the war, it's likely the USA wants payback for the loans. And the most obvious way is to "colonise" this resource-rich [0] country with Western companies to extract the resources for cheap and send to the west.
---
[0]: https://www.britannica.com/place/Ukraine/Resources-and-power
> I don’t want this war to continue.
Nobody wants, but it's Russia who started it. Russia started a genocidal war of conquest against another peaceful and sovereign country. If Russia stops fighting it, then the war will end. If Ukraine will stop fighting it, then Ukraine will cease to exist as an independent nation.
> And I do feel Russia has had a very valid argument regarding the NATO threat and USA has been aware of this for a long time, still they decided to poke the bear.
Why do you disregard the threat from Russia to Poland, Baltics and Finland, and other eastern flank countries? These countries joined NATO for a reason. They were not asked to join, they were not compelled to join. They joined because they are much smaller and live next to a heavily armed and unstable Russian dictatorship. It is incredible how Russian propaganda tries to paint a nuclear-armed and heavily militarized country as a victim.
> USA sabotaged the Russian-German pipeline
Conspiracy theory with no evidence.
> Germany has proven to be a lap dog of US interests
Huh?
> It’s a shame the Western world and Ukraine deceived Russia with the Minsk accords
It is a shame there are a lot apologetics of the Russian fascism. Unfortunately, there were a lot of callers for peace with the "we don't want war" slogans when Nazis were taking over Europe during the World War II. Some even greeted them with flowers, despite all the artocities, including in your country. Well.. history doesn't repeat itself but it certainly rhymes.
There's a good talk from Mike McFaul at Stanford [1] who outlines how Russia under Putin for the longest time was interested in joining NATO. Putin saw NATO as an opportunity, not a threat. NATO is a scapegoat - what Putin really seems to be afraid of is the fall of dictatorships and the rise of democracies around him, and he thinks the US is behind it. So he is anti-US, but the whole anti-NATO thing is a false narrative - Putin is anti-democracy. The talk explains it very well.
> USA sabotaged the Russian-German pipeline and all Western mass media acts like nothing has happened.
Why would the US do that? I don't see the motivation. The current narrative, that it was a faction of the Ukraine, seems the most plausible to me. Russia had no incentive to blow it up either.
> All the Western politicians that are pushing for war will not be on the frontlines themselves and most likely neither will their children.
True. But then again, right now we're in a situation where most politicians are actually rather conservative about the war. Just think about how long it took for heavy artillery and tanks to be shipped to Ukraine. Even now that the US and Germany are sending tanks, very few European nations are following suit - not even some that previously touted loudly that they were ready to send them, and that only Germany was holding them back.
Both Europe and the US are acting rather carefully, for better or worse. The West is definitely not in the business of warmongering.
> It’s a shame the Western world and Ukraine deceived Russia with the Minsk accords, as Germany recently admitted [0]. We didn’t have to be in this situation.
This is the article that your source refers to: https://www.zeit.de/2022/51/angela-merkel-russland-fluechtli...
Unfortunately it's paywalled, but I did sign up (their 1€ trial offer was cheap enough, and I'm German, so easy for me to read). I don't think the WSWS article you linked to cites fairly. While the citation is accurate, it jumps over one main fact:
At the time when the Minsk agreement was made, Russia had illegally de-facto annexed parts of Ukraine. Everyone knew it, even though Russia called it "separatists". Putin didn't have the guts to start an all-out war back then, that took a few more years, but the fact that the majority of these separatists were Russian soldiers was widely reported back then already. Given that Russia had started destabilising Ukraine and annexing parts of it, Merkel's comment of buying the Ukraine time to prepare for more aggressive action from Russia is perfectly reasonable, and in hindsight also the correct political action.
Russia wasn't deceived with the Minsk accords. Russia was already the aggressor back then. We wouldn't have this war if Russia wasn't invading its neighbour.
---
You are honestly making this statement without deceipt?
The West is in the warmongering business.
https://responsiblestatecraft.org/2023/02/24/war-is-great-fo...
This is outweighed by far by the effects on everyone else. Or as the article you cite puts it:
"In other words, a humanitarian, geopolitical, and economic disaster for the world..."
But why would a Ukrainian faction not publicly claim the biggest successful sabotage act against Russian infrastructure? Ukrainian side had no qualms about claiming the Crimea bridge sabotage, or drone strikes deep in Russian territory.
NATO has large stocks of 155mm shells. But they can also buy them because it's become a standard outside of the non Russian influence world. South Korea has a huge production and stock that is under negotiation.
Numbers around mobilization are really iffy. I watched an opposition Russian politician yesterday saying no more than 200,000 had been drafted, so your number is the opposite direction to his. I bet even the Kremlin doesn't know the true number due to the way the regions were instructed to draft.
Even if they had all that, they are outranged by NATO missiles, so all ammo dumps have to be very far away from the front (90+ km). Munitions and supplies must be moved in small and uneven batches on poor roads and with overworked crews and equipment over multiple days.
UA forces share some of these issues, but not as badly.
Do you have a source for that. The last part (especially) is pretty unbelievable. I would assume that the techniques for pouring flat concrete isn't new, and even if they didn't have it, they could just make forklifts with bigger wheels or something. For instance, here's a US military forklift driving on gravel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forklift#Counterbalanced_forkl....
I do understand the Russians are much more focused on rail for military transport compared to the US, which then let them make design choices that have made it hard to switch to truck transport.
1. You can point to a source with some authority talking about the lack of a thing. Which shouldn't be too hard, since, unless you're ex-Russian Army logistics, you must have learned those claims from somewhere.
2. You can point to a source talking talking about Russian Army logistics, that shows them "moving things by hand" when forklifts would be more appropriate.
3. You can point to a source talking about how all forklifts require really flat concrete, and not all countries can make it because [reasons].
Most of my evidence here is fueled by what I've been seeing and hearing via the internet, so take it with a grain of salt. I'm, thankfully, not in theater. That said, these sources do seem to be 'experts' of some sort or another behind their own fog of war:
War on the Rocks, podcast and online
Foreign Policy Magazine, online edition
Washington Post, print and online
New York Times, print and online
Philips P O'Brien, publications and twitter
Trent Telenko, interviews and podcasts and twitter
ChrisO_wiki, twitter
Go ahead and look in the older work if you're curious to find more out about the logistical mountain that RF is facing. The concrete thing, though a bit curious, does seem to bear out in photos of their ammo dumps and RF's inability to cure a pad before rebar is stolen (WaPo, NYT, and ChrisO_wiki are good on this issue). Gravel isn't going to work for such repeated use in wet conditions. To move those loads you'd need very large tires to distribute the weight, something like a JCB. Something that RF also seems to be without. Like, they really do seem to be that corrupt and incompetent.
> The concrete thing, though a bit curious, does seem to bear out in photos of their ammo dumps and RF's inability to cure a pad before rebar is stolen (WaPo, NYT, and ChrisO_wiki are good on this issue).
However, the reasoning you give here makes the claim more credible, since it makes clear the problem is corruption not technology.
That's not true: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/05/us/politics/cruise-missil...:
"Weapons investigators in Kyiv found that at least one Russian Kh-101 cruise missile used in widespread attacks there on Nov. 23 had been made no earlier than October."
> ...whereas those are available to NATO, and we've seen those be a lot more effective than the dumb artillery.
They are, but I'm under the impression that NATO/the US would also quickly use up their cruise missile stockpiles in the event of a hot war.
> NATO has large stocks of 155mm shells. But they can also buy them because it's become a standard outside of the non Russian influence world. South Korea has a huge production and stock that is under negotiation.
South Korea isn't allowing any of their equipment or ammunition to be exported to Ukraine. The best that enables is for Western countries to play musical chairs and give Ukraine a greater share of their stockpiles/production from other sources.
Musical chairs indeed but pretty direct ones:
https://edition.cnn.com/2022/11/11/politics/us-artillery-sou...
I mean that's pretty much just throwing the chair at someone.
Looks like Russia mobilized over half a million soldiers so far (while officially stating 300K). Their military factories are working on 3 shifts 24/7. When they produce enough equipment and weapons no doubt they'll do a new wave of mobilization. Long term Russia can mobilize more soldiers than Ukraine, so NATO has to compensate by supplying Ukraine with big amount of artillery, tanks, fuel, equipment and most importantly ammo.