News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by andrejguran on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @05:58AM (#35067533)
why would they send citizens? NATO has 3.3mil army vs 800k of Russia
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @06:37AM (#35067795)
i think terms like troops, army, etc. have potential to be 'newspeak'. in every case we are talking about citizens. and whats most worrying if things get really hot ... reservists then conscription. just ask russians and ukranians ... or vietnam vets. personally im very worried about the prospect of world war but media seems to be fueling this hero brave pro-war attitude and people seem to be buying it! putin must be punished for his crimes, but do not pretend that us and nato are any better
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by hdjjhhvvhga on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:05AM (#35068009)
> media seems to be fueling this hero brave pro-war attitude

I don't think any serious media is pro-war, it's more like we have two choices: (1) either send weapons, or (2) watch Ukrainians die and become slaves of Putin. This is a tough moral choice because either involves killing, but we don't have the luxury of having more choices. If we don't do anything, Ukrainians will suffer. If we ask Urkainians to surrender, they won't even listen because they know how cruel their fate will be.

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by andrejguran on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:09AM (#35068047)
ofc you can call army troops citizens as well. But then going back to your question if they're prepared for it, well I hope so because that's the army's job to be prepared. But I don't think you original question whether citizens are prepared was aiming only at "army citizens" but regular citizens. And for this I don't see why would regular citizens be conscripted. Currently Ukraine is able to hold russia with limited resources from the west. We have actually the opposite problem if NATO would have a full scale war with russia NATO would win too fast which is problem because it would be an existential crisis for russia and they'd have to use nuclear weapons. So no, regular citizens of NATO countries will very unlikely be conscripted for war with russia as NATO is slowly winning without a single soldier in battle.
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:19AM (#35068630)
so you do think that time will come for professional nato soldiers to come to ukraine to fight russia ?
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by andrejguran on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:46AM (#35068896)
no I don't. And I was trying to explain why I don't think so as it would escalate the conflict possibly to a nuclear one as NATO entering Ukraine would cause russia to lose very quickly
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:54AM (#35068971)
see the problem i have with this is the constant pushing of boundaries. first it was small defensive weapons. then small offensive weapons. then large defensive weapons. then large offensive weapons. now its fighter jets. whats next?

at the same time a narative is being developed in all the major media that the freedom of europe and west depends on ukranian victory. if thats the case, whats the next logical conclusion if ukraine actually begins to lose the war? to me this smells of preparation of the general population for a (much) larger war

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by haspok on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:23AM (#35069262)
Constant pushing of boundaries is exactly what the Russians do: first they annex Crimea (no or very limited response from the West), then they separate Donbas (no response from the West), then they finally attack Ukraine proper. Should the West have watched this with arms folded in your opinion?

We are very far from average Joe being sent to the Russian front. Partly because there is a professional army that will be involved before that, but more likely it will not, in order to avoid nuclear conflict. I think you should worry more about that than the general population being sent to Ukraine.

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by andrejguran on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:49AM (#35070455)
I disagree because russia showed it's very weak militarily. So weak that it caught by surprise everyone. Again we have the opposite problem and that's for Ukraine not winning too fast and that's why NATO is suppling weapons very carefully and slowly. You said that we're pushing boundaries but I see it as pushing boundaries centimeter by centimeter while being miles away from what you call a larger war. So in conclusion there won't be much larger war simply because there is no larger enemy.
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by hdjjhhvvhga on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @12:05PM (#35071602)
We wanted to send help from day one but we were afraid because Putin in its famous speech when announcing the war threatened using nuclear bombs against any country that would help Ukraine. So we had to start small.

The alternative is that we are afraid, we do nothing, and once Putin finishes off with Ukraine, he is ready to invade the ex-Eastern bloc countries, and then go further West. Because if everybody is afraid, who is going to stop him?

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by red-iron-pine on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @12:00PM (#35071525)
Getting some really strong OSINT probe vibes here.

But yes, it's possible that NATO forces could enter the fight. There are already large quantities of NATO troops in Poland, Estonia, etc. Entire US, British, French, etc. brigades on standby.

This isn't new -- we've played these games for damn near 50 years of Cold War. Most of the leaders of NATO, to include Putin and Biden, were Cold Warriors and grew up during that era. They know the game and what's at stake.

But that means lots of staredowns, not necessarily a lot of fighting. Ukraine isn't NATO -- hell, 50 years ago UKR was USSR, and would have been shooting at NATO forces -- and if they need to be sacrificed to collapse the Russian government then so be it. Welcome to Realpolitik.

To that end NATO will prop them up as much as needed to continue grinding down Russian military and economic forces. I believe they will let UKR collapse and be taken over instead of sending troops; only if NATO forces are attacked directly, or maybe if nukes are involved, will NATO do anything more than it is now. Furthermore, it's possible that Ukraine actually wins -- they appear to be absorbing, at high cost mind you, the renewed Russian offensive, and may soon be able to hit back with their own...

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by haspok on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:11AM (#35068058)
You should study pre-WW2 history, what happened when Hitler anschlussed Austria, Czechia, then invaded Poland and then turned west. Meanwhile the allied powers tried to close their eyes and were thinking that if they leave Hitler be there will be peace. It cost the world 6 years and a few million dead people to prove this idea wrong.

And if you think that the western world is not any better than Putin, well, I wish you a very happy life somewhere in Russia...

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @08:16AM (#35068602)
you would send me to russia for having a different opinion? how very putin of you

if you study history of rise of fascism it began all began with supression of differeing opinions. dont forget that nazis received some pretty good encouragement from the US and UK in order to contain the spread of communism. same as sadam. same as taliban

first they came for the jews, but i was not jewish. then they came for the communists, but i was not a communist ... then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me

also read some history about horrors of war before you pump your chest

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by haspok on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:13AM (#35069146)
> you would send me to russia for having a different opinion?

No, you totally misread that. I did not want to send you anywhere.

I just wish people put their money where their mouth is. If you are living in a developed country it's easy to romanticize a communist dictatorship (or not communist anymore - who cares), where writing your opinion in a public forum would actually get you in real trouble (as in prison, or worse), as opposed to another forum user writing a critical response to your message.

> if you study history of rise of fascism it all began with supression of differeing opinions

Am I suppresssing you now? Or to take one step further, are you calling me a nazi, just because I don't agree with you and I dare to reply? Wow.

> first they came for the jews, but i was not jewish. then they came for the communists, but i was not a communist ... then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me

And what does this quote have to do with anything in this thread?

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:23AM (#35069268)
my money is litteraly where my mouth is. where i also pay my taxes. you on the other hand told me my place is in russia. no its not. its in my homeland which i love. and no i dont see a contradiction between pointing out the hypocricy of my government and wanting to live where i live. on the contrary i voice my opinions because i belive that the people who live where i live deserve better. and i do for the reccord believe that the involvement of my government in the wars led by the US for the past three decades were a crime. it is because of these crimes that we have fed the likes of people like putin to become popular
Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by haspok on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:54AM (#35069683)
> you on the other hand told me my place is in russia.

For the last time, I did not. You wrote:

> do not pretend that us and nato are any better

To which my reply was that if you really think so, then you have no idea what you are talking about, and maybe it would help your understanding if you tried the Russian way of things. Figuratively, not literally.

HTH, and have a nice day.

Re:How to Beat Russia [pdf] by medo-bear on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:48AM (#35070436)
you litteraly said

> And if you think that the western world is not any better than Putin, well, I wish you a very happy life somewhere in Russia...

you said that on the basis of me saying that western foreign policy is no better than putins. it is not. neither now and definitely not historically