News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by CSMastermind on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:11PM (#34842803)
I've posted on Hackernews before mentioning that I grew up in East Palestine and my entire immediate and most of my extended family either live in the town itself or within 20 miles.

It's been surreal to see this event unplay in the media.

Some things I haven't seen talked about:

1. How desperately poor most of the population in that area is.

My fear is that if the crash has long terms effects people will never get justice.

These are people who can't afford to go to a doctor regularly. They can't afford to miss work. They can't afford to sue a railroad and they'll very likely take a small payment to waive all liability because any amount of money right now is better than whatever they might theoretically get in the future.

And for the most part no one there would tell you they're poor or disadvantaged. I don't mean to imply that they are downtrodden or helpless. I certainly didn't think that of myself or anyone else growing up there.

It is only with the perspective of having left and having traveled the world and having risen through the economic ladder that I have the ability to look back and see how disadvantaged they will be against a large corporation.

Barring legislation and government intervention I cannot imagine they will have even a shot in hell at getting a fair evaluation and fair deal.

2. Train wrecks happened in the area somewhat frequently

Growing up I remember at last 3 or 4 train wrecks bad enough that people had to be put up in hotels.

I don't know if that's a lot of a little for an area in a ~10 year span but it feels like a lot.

I also don't know if train wrecks are tracked and reported anywhere other than local paper archives but I would be very interested to see the internal data and memos the railroad has related to derailments.

If anyone is aware of such a resource please let me know.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by Kalium on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:21PM (#34842862)
A quick search (it was the first hit for train derailment tracker) brings up this: https://safetydata.fra.dot.gov/officeofsafety/publicsite/que...

Having poked at it a bit, it does seem happy to spit out a list of train derailments sliced and diced in quite a few different ways.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by eigenhombre on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:23AM (#34847138)
The data on the site is fascinating, and can be downloaded as CSV, XLS, etc. (I live about 100m from a rail corridor, and though I love trains, I do worry occasionally about accidents).
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by version_five on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:55PM (#34843071)
Any insight into why the left is so keen to downplay it? It seems so non-partisan but somehow it's become a darling of the right wing media and the left is trying to emphasize how it's not really anything (see most of the comments here). How did it get so political.

It's also super weird that it has all the components (small town, big company, chemicals, etc) of a typical left-ish cause? Have roles really reversed to this degree?

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by anigbrowl on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:30PM (#34843238)
the left is so keen to downplay it

As one of HN's resident leftists, I drew attention to the story early and it got little traction. While the right has indeed begun screaming loudly about it, calling it an attack on white people and so on (Charlie Kirk@TPUSA, Jesse Watters@Fox, Benny Johnson@Newsmax have all made such claims in the last 48 hours), refuting their claims is not the same as saying the incident is not important.

It is, and I think both the Ohio and federal governments have done a poor job of addressing it, notwithstanding the slow-moving nature of the disaster.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by green_man_lives on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:05PM (#34843113)
The American liberal media is not "left" they are liberal.

That being said, they are probably trying to downplay it because it's directly related to the railroad union strike that Biden shut down a few months back. They wanted more time off-- which would mean more workers and less hours.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by eurticket on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:23AM (#34844175)
Believe they were also striking for safer working conditions.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by TrispusAttucks on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:28PM (#34843224)
The Left that we grew up with no longer exists. The New Left are authoritarian power worshippers.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by nobaddays on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:03PM (#34843097)
Unions :)
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by TaylorAlexander on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:28PM (#34843223)
The unions desperately wanted to fix the problems that lead to stuff like this and Biden forced them not to strike so I can’t see how unions would be the problem here.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by bushbaba on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:04PM (#34843106)
Or that Biden used federal authority to quash the railroad union protests for better wages as safer conditions.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by mikeyouse on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:45PM (#34843330)
I mean, Biden brokered a deal to avert the strike, worked with the house and senate to craft a law guaranteeing the railworkers the benefits they were seeking which was then filibustered by senate republicans, but that's apparently too complicated or politically inconvenient for HN to understand so they pretend like stopping the strike was the end of that story.

https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/3758436-senate-rejects-p...

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by blix on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:21AM (#34844478)
You could easily rephrase your comment as "Biden took away their only option for self-directed action and then passed the buck to an organization known for doing nothing."

Sometimes complexity doesn't actually add anything useful :) Focusing on the DC play-by-play is good for convincing yourself the other team is at fault, and not much else.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by mikeyouse on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:14AM (#34844744)
Sure, you could rephrase it to something inaccurate if it was your prerogative to "both sides" something that failed almost entirely along party lines after attracting the support of several very conservative senators. I'm not sure what value that adds though :)
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by blix on Saturday February 18, 2023 @07:43AM (#34846481)
Were the worked who wanted to continue striking allowed to, or not? Was the response of the Republican-dominated Senate predictable or was it a surprise? If I give fine china to a toddler who drops and breaks it, which party is really at fault?
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by mcv on Sunday February 19, 2023 @11:15AM (#34858816)
Wasn't it an amendment that Sanders added to Biden's bill, was blocked by Republicans, and then enough Democrats voted for the bill despite the fact that it didn't include Sanders' amendment that should have been part of it from the start?

Everybody who voted for it bears the blame for taking away the railroad workers' rights.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:40AM (#34844576)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? You've been doing it repeatedly, unfortunately. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

The idea here is: if you have a substantive point, make it thoughtfully; if not, please don't comment until you do.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by AnimalMuppet on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:04PM (#34843102)
The left is downplaying it because it happened on their guy's watch, and he's not doing much about it. In fact, the Biden administration just said that Ohio wouldn't get any disaster money for this. So either the derailment's consequences are nothing, or the left's guy is ineffective at dealing with the real world. The left therefore chooses to say (and even think?) that the problems are nothing.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by krolden on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:42PM (#34843308)
He's far from 'our guy'.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by bombcar on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:05PM (#34843109)
This is exactly it and it’s so sad to watch. Had it happened under trump the sides would have been switched.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by TaylorAlexander on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:30PM (#34843232)
Yeah unfortunately the media in the US just overplays every bad thing that happens under someone they don’t like and underplays the bad when their guy is in office.

But corporate media is just bad so I guess that’s about all we can expect.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by TrispusAttucks on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:00PM (#34843429)
They never speak poorly of their advertisers or benefactors. Don't bite the hand that feeds you.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by doubleg72 on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:53PM (#34843714)
Its one thing to claim certain organizations pick and choose what aspects of a story to focus reporting on, but I can't fathom how someone can come to the conclusion that is as utterly ignorant as yours other than being completely brainwashed.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by Supermancho on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:38PM (#34843949)
I feel like the narrative would be switched, but the events would have played out the same.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by imbnwa on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:46PM (#34843667)
Didn't the Governor of Ohio just refuse Federal assistance?
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by _-david-_ on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:08PM (#34843796)
Nope. FEMA and the EPA are going to be helping.

https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/3864078-ohio-g...

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by infamouscow on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:09PM (#34843806)
I don't think it's about Biden.

I think it's about Pete Buttigieg and his 2024 presidential prospects burning away faster and more effectively than the chemicals in this terrible accident.

If Democrats think this unbelievably stupid approach will work in the election, they might as well be regarded as Trump supporters. The country is watching this incident with bated breath and tremendous skepticism.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by mikeyouse on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:42PM (#34843315)
It's literally front page news on all of the "left" news sources and has been since the accident.. a bunch of weird grifters are proclaiming the left has abandoned the town by not declaring a Federal disaster when it would be illegal to do so since the law only recognizes natural disasters.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by jvolkman on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:51PM (#34843369)
> How did it get so political.

I mean, given events of the last few years I think things becoming unnecessarily political should be expected.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by ihatepython on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:23PM (#34843552)
> Any insight into why the left is so keen to downplay it?

It doesn't serve their agenda so it gets ignored.

They can't blame it on Trump.

They can't blame it on Putin.

They will go out of their way to tell you that gas-stoves are bad for you (and ban them if possible), but somehow igniting toxic chemicals in a mushroom cloud is perfectly fine.

They go on and on about climate change, yet they don't care about the effects of this disaster.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by s1artibartfast on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:51PM (#34843701)
> How did it get so political.

It is political because nobody wants to actually help. By making it political, you take it out of your hands. It is someone else's fault, and you shouldn't have to fix it.

Not once in all of the threads on this topic have I seen someone ask "what can I do to help". Mud slinging and politics is easy because you can do it from a keyboard for free.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by mc32 on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:04PM (#34843781)
What's so odd is the secretary of transportation himself downplayed it by saying "hey, there are a thousand train derailments a year [big whoop]!

Really so the implication is there are ~2.75 of East Palestine derailments per day and therefore no biggie? Or, the others are mostly very minor but I want to downplay this so I'll say this happens almost three times a day, big whoop, deal!

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:40AM (#34844580)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34842803.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by moremetadata on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:44PM (#34843325)
>My fear is that if the crash has long terms effects people will never get justice.

I think we all know corporates nearly always win if history is anything to go by! Even judges get lent on so cant be considered independent and free of influence.

If I was in your family and friends shoes over there, if I couldnt take a 4-6 week out of town vacation, I'd be increasing my Omega-3's intake to may be as much as 1g a day to increase my neutrophil size, keeping to a minimum Omega-6's as it already causes enough trouble in the western diet, cutting out all sugar from the diet except starch, to increase my neutrophil phagocytic capacity, and be taking some B12 to help my neutrophils remain normal with todays polluted world in general.

In other words, plenty of fish and potato from out of town.

Thats not a nice situation over there, but you are lucky it even got on the news, some things dont even make it onto the news in some countries.

Good luck!

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by s1artibartfast on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:52PM (#34843710)
Since you have family in the area maybe you can answer this question:

What do people need and is there anything that can be done to help them?

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by CSMastermind on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:33AM (#34844229)
This will be an unsatisfying answer.

Thanks to my job as a software engineer I felt like I was in the position to help people financially but the dozens of people I've asked at this point have all told me the same thing:

1. Their immediate needs are taken care of.

The ones who got evacuated were put up in hotels at first and have tons of support from local organizations. The ones who were more than 1 mile away generally are staying with friends until they feel like it's okay to return home.

2. They want life to return to normal.

This has been a major disruption in their daily routines. They want it resolved so they can get back to living their lives.

3. They're anxious and terrified about the health implications.

Ignoring the actual smoke cloud when they did the burn: the smell of the burn went for miles. It's hard to believe someone telling everything is safe when you home still reeks of chemical smell.

When the burn happens lots of people experienced runny noses, sore throats, and other minor symptoms. Was it a result of the chemicals? Was it stress? Was it all in their head? We just don't know.

There's a ton of dubious information flowing around social media scaring them. They don't know what to believe.

---

The main thing that will help people is to feel like their situation is being taken seriously.

Things like a congressional hearing to establish answers to what happened and how it can be rectified. The federal government stepping in and committing to long term testing of the area. The railroad being forced to provide medical screening for at least the next several years.

Someone in a position of authority stepping up and saying they're committed to making things right instead of trying to minimize the situation or use it as a talking point.

Those are things no individual can do by themselves but if I had a suggestion I guess it would just be to reach out to your congressperson and tell them that you care about this getting fixed and never happening again.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by icelancer on Saturday February 18, 2023 @03:50AM (#34845225)
I grew up in a below-average income household in Ohio and everything you said rings so true about where I'm from as well.

Just take us seriously and let us go back to normal. Money is the last thing people want.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by andsoitis on Saturday February 18, 2023 @04:54AM (#34845578)
> experienced runny noses, sore throats, and other minor symptoms. Was it a result of the chemicals? Was it stress? Was it all in their head? We just don't know.

chemicals.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by s1artibartfast on Saturday February 18, 2023 @08:28AM (#34846785)
Thanks for the insight. Actually found it rather satisfying and a refreshing take.

Trying to think constructively here, maybe third party Chemical Testing for residuals would provide these people with some peace of mind.

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by DarknessFalls on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:24PM (#34843884)
An idea I've had for a while now is to put together a site like GoFundMe, specifically to crowdsource funding for people who couldn't otherwise afford legal representation. This is absolutely a good use case for such a project.
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by culi on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:32AM (#34844833)
People really underestimate how much 2 or 3 community members who don't have to worry about working or making rent and focus solely on this issue can get done

If we could have something like a community strike fund that could be payed back into when/if their case is won, I'd happily donate while I have a stable job.

Who knows, maybe some day I'll be in some affected community that could make use of such a fund

Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by prox on Saturday February 18, 2023 @07:42AM (#34846479)
I would chip in. That’s a great idea!
Re:Clinic to open near Ohio derailment as health worries linger by eternalban on Saturday February 18, 2023 @06:24AM (#34846031)
There was an opinion piece in nytimes yesterday with some overall numbers:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/17/opinion/ohio-train-derail...