News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by elif on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:13AM (#34788786)
As someone who has only worked in "right to work" states, it always strikes me as absurd that people seek "job security" through a 3rd party agency rather than by individual performance and developing personal relationships.

Honestly a big part of why I quit my last job was too many unproductive/unreliable coworkers.

Am I just Stockholm Syndromed?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Vespasian on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:38AM (#34789034)
Working in Europe I have never been a member of a union but enjoy plenty of the achievements fought over in previous decades. Right now my strong market position as someone in a sought after field and with some experience under my belt I am able to negotiate a individual contract that exceeds collective bargain agreements (that's possible in most companies here).

Members of my immediate family don't have that luxury. They are hardworking and diligent people at physically demanding jobs. Yet they get treated way worse than I in my cushy office job.

Individually they don't have much bargaining power but as a group they can get a better outcome and negotiate eye to eye with business owners. It makes sense to carry a few underperformers with you if the benefits outweigh the costs.

In the end market realities still require the company to make a profit or nobody gets paid. But there is no reason why workers/unions shouldn't demand a greater share of that profit.

Look at almost any German International company for a working examples. All Auto manufacturers are heavily unionized and still manage to be innovative and make a very healthy profit. During the Euro crisis in 2008 Unions and business owners worked together to reduce hours and workforce because everyone understood the dire situation.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by hef19898 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:53AM (#34789240)
Considering that some "union" jobs in Germany (there are collectively negotiated terms and conditions per industry which apply to everyone working at a company covered by those conditions whether or not being an actual union member) can go up to as much 120k per year for a 40 hour work week, and increase by a couple of percent every other year so, well, those jobs are a lot more attractive than people think.

Added benefit: working at rather stable companies with more or less solid financials.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by quadrifoliate on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:38AM (#34789043)
I don't think you're Stockholm Syndromed, but I definitely think you're lacking in empathy. Think about it this way -- do you think you have been always productive and reliable, 100% of the time?

If not (let's say, 5% of the time you weren't), then you were the the unproductive or unreliable coworker, possibly due to factors in your life that you could not control. The idea of a union is that it insulates you from being instantly punished for factors you might not be able to control a little better than the market is doing right now (look for news about new parents who were part of the layoffs recently).

Out of "individual performance and developing personal relationships", the "developing personal relationships" part of the equation is slowly fading. When was the last time you got a job purely on the basis of your personal relationships without having to jump through hoops to show your skills?

I am a little hesitant about unions too, but I'm at least willing to give them a chance based on the hack-and-slash behavior from industry leaders seeking to please their investors.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by abduhl on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:41AM (#34789081)
>> The idea of a union is that it insulates you from being instantly punished for factors you might not be able to control a little better than the market is doing right now (look for news about new parents who were part of the layoffs recently).

Since when has this been the idea of the union? Recall that nearly all union rules are set by seniority, not personal factors like having a bad day or having a child.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by quadrifoliate on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:01AM (#34789349)
> Recall that nearly all union rules are set by seniority, not personal factors like having a bad day or having a child.

I'm unable to understand what you're saying here. Of course, union rules are not set by personal factors. I meant that they make it less easy to fire you for personal factors due to the heavier emphasis on due process in unionized workplaces.

In most non-union workplaces in the US, you can get fired because your boss had a bad day, or (practically) if you announce that you're pregnant. The latter case is theoretically protected, but it's very hard for an average person to get an appropriate lawyer, show a pattern and sue the workplace.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by pydry on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:27AM (#34789756)
Pick a better objective metric that correlates well with job performance that can't be twisted by management to promote the ass kissers and snitches.

Unions will be delighted to adopt it.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by trieste92 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:00AM (#34790238)
> The idea of a union is that it insulates you from being instantly punished for factors you might not be able to control a little better than the market is doing right now.

Most people have good days and bad days. Any manager who's crazy enough to punish someone for having one bad day isn't a good manager. If that happens it's likely a manager specific issue

> When was the last time you got a job purely on the basis of your personal relationships without having to jump through hoops to show your skills?

This isn't a bad thing. More merit, less favoritism. People are hired based off of qualifications alone (ideally)

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by quadrifoliate on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:54PM (#34793140)
> Most people have good days and bad days. Any manager who's crazy enough to punish someone for having one bad day isn't a good manager. If that happens it's likely a manager specific issue

How about 2 bad months due to an illness? US companies are pretty much set up so that people in those situations often end up being let go. It's not a "manager specific issue", it's a broader cultural one.

> This isn't a bad thing. More merit, less favoritism.

Sure, but then the OP's point about personal relationships is neutralized, which is why they (if not you) might want to consider unions if they want to protect themselves from the stark meritocracy that you posit.

> People are hired based off of qualifications alone (ideally)

Yep, and kept employed based on the same, and let go immediately if there might be someone cheaper or if market conditions change even slightly and "It's good for the business!". This is raw capitalism. What we have been discovering in the past couple of months of layoffs is that not everyone has the taste for it. Those folks, including OP, might want to consider unionizing.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @05:21PM (#34797027)
> which is why they (if not you) might want to consider unions if they want to protect themselves from the stark meritocracy that you posit.

Why would you prefer a system under which you have to know someone to get a good job instead of a system under which you just have to master a skill?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by nerdponx on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:01AM (#34790249)
It's not just about being unproductive or unreliable. It's about being taken advantage of, even if and when you are fully productive and reliable. Hard work and individual productivity can and do get individually rewarded in many cases, but overall you are still entirely at the whims of your employer in an asymmetric power relationship. The entire purpose of collective bargaining and unions is to balance the power relationship.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by wyldfire on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:26AM (#34788902)
You just described collective bargaining as if it were like an individual hiring a salary negotiator. I suppose we can debate whether some jobs are better off with or without unionization but it doesn't sound like a genuine argument when you describe it that way.

Sadly I think we can honestly say that the unproductive coworkers exist in many different professions and a significant drawback of unions is that they can thrive there.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by GAN_Game on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:34AM (#34788994)
> Honestly a big part of why I quit my last job was too many unproductive/unreliable coworkers.

Unproductive? Then you must really be exercised about the heirs who own the majority of stock, who can and often do siphon off the created wealth of those working and creating wealth, via dividend profit of expropriated surplus labor time.

Oh, I see no such complaint. Just some co-workers who are "unproductive".

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:38AM (#34789048)
Have you seen the margins on businesses old enough to be owned by heirs? They're only "siphoning off" a few percent.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by hef19898 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:57AM (#34789287)
Those heirs are the richest people in Europe, owning everything from VW and Porsche to BMW and a bunch of other household names. And those few percent are coming off from quite huge figures...
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:06AM (#34789407)
Yeah, the lack of new businesses is a big problem in Europe. Regulations and taxation kill them or drive them out of Europe.

But I was speaking from a US perspective (since I'm from the US and this story is about the US), and our biggest, most profitable businesses are mostly under fifty years old, not over.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by hef19898 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:31AM (#34789818)
That is an interesting way to read my comment so.

It is not regulation nor taxes that make it hard for "tech" start ups in Europe. It is harder access to Venture Capital and smaller adressable markets, overall the European Market is huge, but harder to access due to language barriers.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by westpfelia on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:30AM (#34789798)
OH 1000000% I mean can you even name a single business that has started in Berlin in the last 25 years? You cant. Because not a single business has started. Taxes have killed all brand new business ideas in the German tech start up scene.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by malermeister on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:19AM (#34789628)
And most of them are also started by heirs of generational wealth.

Just because the companies change doesn't mean the owners do.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:26AM (#34789735)
Who specifically are you thinking of? Every founder I can think of was born in the middle or upper middle class.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by malermeister on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:39AM (#34789932)
Elon Musk's dad was a South African millionaire.

Bill Gates' mom was on the board of directors of a bank and gave him an intro to IBM execs. [0]

Bezos parents invested 250k to fund Amazon. [1]

Upper middle class is generational wealth already if it passes a generation.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/05/how-bill-gates-mother-influe...

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/02/how-jeff-bezos-got-his-paren...

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:47AM (#34790051)
Yeah those parents are all upper middle class. None of them are at all comparable to the owners of a company like VW, Tesla, or Amazon.

And none of them were "heirs who own the majority of stock" nor support your claim that "just because the companies change doesn't mean the owners do".

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by malermeister on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:31AM (#34790712)
You can call it "upper middle class" all you want, but to the vast majority of the population those folks would simply be "rich".

I'm not as concerned as you with the various strata of richness and the mobility between them.

I'm much more concerned with the social mobility of people living in poverty, which is pretty bad in the US compared to Europe. [0]

Key factor in that? Unions.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Social_Mobility_Index

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by SamReidHughes on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @04:23PM (#34796218)
The thing you're linking doesn't even measure social mobility, it just calls itself a social mobility index.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by GAN_Game on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:53AM (#34790130)
Zuckerberg went to Phillips Exeter, a high school which costs at least $47,000 a year.

Zuckerberg bought Instagram from Kevin Systrom who went to Middlesex high school, which costs at least $55,000 a year.

At this point it becomes a parlor game of who is rich, and who is "upper middle class", which apparently means spending $55,000+ a year on your kid's high school.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:58AM (#34790201)
You're really moving the goalposts. From "the heirs who own the majority of stock" to "spending $55,000+ a year on your kid's high school."

Edit: Zuckerberg's parents were a psychiatrist and a dentist. Well paid jobs but still jobs. I'd hardly call it generational wealth.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by malermeister on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:06AM (#34790319)
If your parents can afford to spend 60k a year on your high school, then that is generational wealth.

Do you think the child of a poor single mother trying to make ends meet is given the same opportunities?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by leereeves on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @05:56PM (#34797419)
It's not as easy, certainly, but I know of several founders who grew up poor.

Steve Jobs father never graduated high school and fixed cars for a living.

Larry Ellison grew up in an apartment in the South Side of Chicago.

Starbucks founder Howard Schultz grew up in a public housing project.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by dexterdog on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:49AM (#34790082)
He's not talking about the founders. He's talking about the funders.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by GAN_Game on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:45AM (#34790019)
If you have thousands working and creating wealth, and then a handful of heirs not working, and siphoning off expropriated surplus labor time of those who do work, then the heirs have a pretty good deal going for themselves. A couple percent of the created wealth of a few thousand workers just for one person? That adds up quick.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by abduhl on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:37AM (#34789032)
Why is it only the heirs? Shouldn’t your issue be with all future stockholders beyond the original founders and venture capitalists? Although I assume you’d feel similar about the venture capitalists?

You wouldn’t happen to own any stocks, would you?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by xhkkffbf on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:16AM (#34791538)
Don't forget that many workers end up with stock too, either via options, grants or other mechanisms. Or maybe they just buy the stock because they things going well at the company.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by christophilus on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:32AM (#34788972)
Plenty of us feel the same way. Also, I hate bureaucracy. When you have a union, you have another bureaucracy to deal with. Granted, a good union is probably worth the added effort-- especially when you're in a field where the lack of a union leads to egregious abuses. I've never worked a job where a union felt like it would be a value add to me.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by iso1631 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#34788966)
Your individual performance may be fine when your company is small enough that your boss works for the CTO directly. When you are in a company with thousands of employees it makes no difference.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by elif on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:32AM (#34788980)
Job performance making no difference is my chief complaint. It leads to poor average performance which is a toxic work environment imo.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by rtpg on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:43AM (#34789104)
You think all these tech layoffs are sorting by performance and slicing that way? Ignoring the fact that performance measurements are barely possible at a granular level to allow such an ordering

One could argue about job perf making no difference in union shops (as if people don’t have some pride in their work since they’re spending a third of their life there and the vast majority of people are not trying to work in bad faith) but I think the implicit idea that non-union places have more than the most fat fingered and office politics dependent perf rivals is something to think about. We all know the coasting founder and the absentee manager

I think that during layoffs in a union shop at least management has to think a lot harder about cuts, and how to do them.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by cactusplant7374 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:29AM (#34788934)
Wouldn’t Tesla build quality go up with a union that can make demands? If so, how can we say Tesla’s system is working and management isn’t unproductive and unreliable?
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Robotbeat on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:01AM (#34789350)
I have seen no evidence of build quality being higher in the unionized GM and Ford than the non-unionized Toyota, Hyundai, and Honda plants in the US. The opposite may even be true.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by cactusplant7374 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:40PM (#34792940)
I was referring to panel gaps and other quality issues which are quite egregious with the Tesla brand.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Robotbeat on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @06:14PM (#34797604)
Is there any evidence that Toyota (etc) have worse cosmetic panel gaps than Ford and GM? Overall, Toyota (etc) have excellent quality.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by sidibe on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:29AM (#34788942)
If there's lots of competition over labor in the area, unions aren't necessary but if there isn't much the workers need some kind of leverage that they can't achieve individually. That's when unions are useful IMO, don't know if that's the case here
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by maxehmookau on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:22AM (#34788871)
The idea that "invidivual performance and personal relationships" provides job security is a laughable idea in almost any industry.

The wave of tech layoffs should've made that clear.

The USA's primal hatred of unions will always blow my mind. There's power in a union my friend.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by elif on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:27AM (#34788919)
I'm not trying to say everyone that got let go is a low performer or has poor personal skills. I've seen plenty of good employees fired for bad or no reason.

I guess what I'm trying to say, is that even working with a guillotine above my head feels preferable to having to pick up the slack of people coasting and not meeting their commitments.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by nicoburns on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:35AM (#34789006)
Why do you associate unions with people coasting and not meeting their commitments? For example, two unions striking here in UK recently have teacher and nurse unions. They’re some of the hardest working professions I’ve seen, but they get compensated poorly for it, and in the case of nurses they have to work ridiculously long and busy shifts because they are severely understaffed.

Unions have a place for fighting against unfair dismissals of an individual, but they are primarily for when everyone is being treated badly.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:00AM (#34790233)
> Why do you associate unions with people coasting and not meeting their commitments?

American public sector unions are cartoonishly bad. Recent example from San Francisco. Fourth grader hasn’t learned math in six months. Their math teacher had a concussion and can’t work. The substitute doesn’t teach math. (?!?) The original teacher can’t be replaced. (They deserve disability, but students deserve instruction.) Substitutes must be drawn from a list, on which there were two options, and the other person didn’t want to do it.

So students get babysat while their peers learn math. Because every stopgap, including another teacher dropping in, or a parent volunteering, or hiring an off-list sub or even temp, or telling the sub they have hired to knock it off, it’s grade school math, they can probably find a decent YouTube series, is contractually prohibited.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#34788967)
If a union protects people who are not doing their job from being made to do it, that is an argument for chosing a different union not against unions in general.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Robotbeat on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:02AM (#34789369)
In the US, you don’t really have the luxury of picking a different union. This is one reason unions suck in the US.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:44AM (#34790942)
You do, sort of (though I get what you mean) even as an individual, even though it's less common and affects the benefits you get from being a member, and you may risk still paying dues to the recognised union (if there is one, and your state allows agency fees).

At the larger scale, your choice is to try to convince your co-workers.

The downside of joining a minority union / members only union is not that different in the US as elsewhere, in that you generally have no legal right to be treated as a bargaining agent or in the case of some such unions they explicitly don't even try get recognition.

But even the US has examples of minority unions being voluntarily given some degree of representation:

https://eu.freep.com/story/money/cars/2014/11/12/uaw-volkswa...

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Robotbeat on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:18PM (#34792590)
So in other words… we have effective union monopolization in the US.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @01:09PM (#34793400)
Not all that much more so than in a substantial proportion of other countries with far more powerful unions, and which often have multiple unions represented in the same companies.

Most places have thresholds to be met before an employer can be forced to recognise a given union. It's not unusual for that threshold to be 50% per unit and for people to still opt to stay members in a minority union, which you can in the US too.

The main way the US distinguishes itself in terms of unionisation is by low union membership, and as such the lack of significant minority union locals in the US is more a factor of few people joining a union unless they'd be paying agency fees anyway.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by trashtester on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:34AM (#34802487)
A lot of years ago, before entering college, my father was working in an aluminium melting plant in western Norway for a year. Being young and fit, he was able to work quite fast.

Shortly after starting, he was approached by the local Union bosses, and sternly told to slow down. Not only did he make everone else look bad, if people worked that much, that would lead to layoffs.

Not wanting trouble with the Union, he and his pal switched to only working about 4 hours each night (it was usually night shifts) and then sleep the remaining 4 hours of the shift.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:53AM (#34803152)
It's not clear to me whether you see this as an argument for being part of that union or for picking another one. Protecting the workforce against expectations that might be unreasonable for many workers is an essential part of the functions unions serve. Your dad might have been happy to have worked faster and longer when he was young, but if he'd remained in that job he'd soon be happy the performance expectations were not set so high that he'd start struggling to meet them. Having grown up in Norway and now living in the UK, I massively prefer the work-life balance and workers protections high union participation has created in Norway over the UK (and the US is far worse than the UK in this respect).
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by trashtester on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:21AM (#34804114)
Pretty sure Jern og Metall (Metallurgy union) would not have accepted competition at that workplace at that time. :)

> I massively prefer the work-life balance and workers protections high union participation has created in Norway over the UK

Sure, though it comes at a pretty significant cost in terms of efficiency and of the ability of the more productive part of the workforce to generate income for themselves.

Over time, this kind of setup tends to lead to loss of competitiveness, often resulting in fewer jobs / layoffs, lower salaries or to requiring the rest of society to pay subsidies, trade barriers and/or for consumers to pay more for their products.

Case in point would be Norwegian agricultural unions.

And maybe worst of all, a society dominated by unions may cause some of the most productive citizens to seek better opportunities abroad ;)

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:59AM (#34805568)
> Pretty sure Jern og Metall (Metallurgy union) would not have accepted competition at that workplace at that time. :)

While there have at times been overzealous union people and I obviously can't know the conditions specifically at your dads old workplace, closed shops have typically been far more unusual in Norway than e.g. in the US, and the few attempts there have been have increasingly faced legal opposition and are now considered illegal in part based on interpretation of the freedom of association in Council of Europe's social charter from the 1960s. The main exception in the past have been for employees of the unions themselves, and even there closed shops became unusual a long time ago. But of course you won't make many friends at a workplace if you actively place their working conditions and employment at risk.

> Sure, though it comes at a pretty significant cost in terms of efficiency and of the ability of the more productive part of the workforce to generate income for themselves.

Health and safety and the general wellbeing of workers tends to come at a cost, yes, it doesn't come from nothing. The question is not whether or not to do so - not a single country in the world allow employers free reign in deciding workers conditions - but where to draw the line.

So then you have a choice of how much of your own well-being you're willing to sacrifice for the sake of maximising profits for someone else. Of course there is a point beyond which pushing working conditions and salaries up becomes net detrimental. But given Norway tend to rank near the top on almost all quality of life metrics, it does not seem Norway has hit it (and in case you drag up oil: Denmark and Sweden tend to rank equally well)

> Over time, this kind of setup tends to lead to loss of competitiveness, often resulting in fewer jobs / layoffs, lower salaries or to requiring the rest of society to pay subsidies, trade barriers and/or for consumers to pay more for their products.

Come to the UK and experience the life of an average worker here and see how fucked up their situation is compared to the average Norwegian, and see if you consider the trade-off worthwhile. Høyre would be considered far-left extremists by UK standards, with policies in their program more radical than what Corbyn proposed (they support more generous parental leave policies for example, and Solberg stood up for continued government ownership policies that'd see her branded as a communist here). And we live the result. The UK tends to rank well below the Scandinavian countries on most quality of life metrics.

> And maybe worst of all, a society dominated by unions may cause some of the most productive citizens to seek better opportunities abroad ;)

I didn't leave for the salary, and I stayed for family reasons. We need to earn far more here for the same standard of living as in Norway because we need to compensate for a welfare system that is far less generous, despite the fact we on average work far longer hours. Yet the average worker here earns less than in Norway. For me, at a far higher salary than average, it's close to a toss up, but had I been on an average salary I'd be back in Norway in a heartbeat rather than put up with the shitty conditions most people here deal with. For my part, I intend to leave the UK well before I retire, because while money can compensate for the direct impact on me personally, it can't compensate for the negative effect on the society surrounding me.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by trashtester on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:25AM (#34816343)
> I didn't leave for the salary, and I stayed for family reasons.

He. I suppose it's pretty common for expats to keep the mentality they had from their country of origin, and even romanticize it a bit.

I'll not quibble with you a bit, just bring my own anecdote:

About 15 years ago, I was called in to help an Accenture team that was about to fail a software project for Posten. When I arrived, the situation was kind of critical.

The Accenture project was led by an architect/PM from London, and staffed by a couple of devs (one of them lead dev) from Norway, and a larger number of devs in India.

Every afternoon around 15:45, all the devs would be gone, and it was just me and the architect from the UK remaining, trying to sort out all the issues in the code.

As we were working into the evening night after night, we got to know each other a bit. As it turned out, he felt like he was trapped in a hell hole, with a team that was not willing to put in any extra effort even though the project was about to fail. I kind of gave him the story that you gave me above.

But he insisted that live was MUCH better in London. Not only was Oslo dark and freezing cold (this was during the winter) and lacking the kind of cultural attractions of a city like London, for someone like him purchasing power was also much better.

While his peers in Oslo had to leave the office before 4pm every day to fetch the kids from daycare, in London he was able to keep a nanny to both provide more personalized care and also provide more flexibility to the parents. In Oslo, families that can afford that usually make significantly more than a software architect.

My point isn't that one system is better than the other, rather that the patriotism can go in both directions.

And for countries trying to be as agalitarian as Norway without the oil revenue, the downsides are even more pronounced, of course. Norway may be the closest to a social democratic Utopia one can get.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by fzeroracer on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:33AM (#34788984)
I mean, the current situation is that you get to work with a guillotine above your head and pick up the slack of people coasting because they can suck up to upper management and puff up their work better than you. Or worse, they lay off the people that did the work, promote the slackers and then you're doing 3x the work for 1x the pay.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by soco on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:13AM (#34789526)
Which means that the slackers are better at networking and whatnot, exactly what the OP was recommending as alternative to unionizing. Isn't it ironic, slackers winning either way. Or maybe the slackers-based argument isn't that sound?
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by maxehmookau on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#34788970)
> I guess what I'm trying to say, is that even working with a guillotine above my head feels preferable to having to pick up the slack of people coasting and not meeting their commitments.

Really? I'd far rather not have a guillotine above my head if the trade-off is a few lazy colleagues. Why should that be my problem?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:24AM (#34788888)
You're talking about specific job security. He's talking about general job security (or at least seems to be based on wording).

A union protects your specific job for a specific employer (or set of employers or subset of industry). Networks and reputation protect your ability to get paid for the thing you do in general. The degree to which either approach is successful is going to depend on one's industry and position/skill-set therein.

Edit: This shouldn't need to be said but the above should not be construed as an endorsement of either approach.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by vidarh on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:30AM (#34788953)
The latter is mostly relevant for specialist, high paid labour.

I'm not in a union, but I'm also roughly in the 1%. If I was anywhere below the top 5% or so, I'd have joined a union in a heartbeat, and like commenters above I find the US resistance to unions utterly bizarre, not least because US unions were instrumental in laying the groundwork for a lot of modern labour protections, to the point of losing lives as part of those battles.

Even May 1st as an international day for labour demonstrations came after a request from the AFL in part as commemoration of the Chicago Haymarket Massacre, and as a renewal of the multi-decades fight for the 8 hour working day.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by jimnotgym on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#34788961)
If ones job at Tesla is to screw on wing mirrors, how should one go about building a network and developing their reputation? A github page? Speak at conferences maybe?

I wish unions were not needed too, then I hear about shitty employers exploiting poor people and I accept that unions are needed.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by hotpotamus on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:21AM (#34788854)
As someone who has never needed "the police" to provide physical security, it always strikes me as absurd that people seek to form governments to "provide security" rather than through individual enforcement of the law through firearm ownership.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by soco on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:10AM (#34789466)
Please please think of the Poe's law when writing such comments... we might be HN but we're humans too.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by SiempreViernes on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:10AM (#34789470)
I suspect this comment would benefit from adding a clarifying "/s" at the end.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by mattkevan on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:14AM (#34789553)
As someone who has never needed "the fire brigade" to extinguish a fire in my house, it always strikes me as absurd that people seek to form governments to "provide fire services" rather than through individual application of water through bucket ownership.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by aliqot on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:19AM (#34788836)
imo very few industries need unions, and most devolve post union integration. it seems like there's no one size fits all union model and about a million ways to turn it into a kludgy fiefdom.

edit: downvote with your words you nerds

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by mc32 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:46AM (#34789133)
The relationship between unions and company are as tenuous and they fulfil a dual role of parasite and symbiosis where from time to time they are symbiotic to the worker while being parasitic to the company and worker at different times. In ideal conditions they would not be necessary; however, companies at times become too powerful and forget or diminish the value of their workers giving unions an in.

In the end, in the US at least Unions induce inefficiencies and add drag to a company. Yes, on the one hand companies don't voluntarily want to provide more benefits than the bare minimum but on the other hand they want to avoid the straightjacket that Unions tend to bring.

I'm not saying we don't need unions but I am saying they are a very uneasy relationship for all parties but the union bosses.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by beanjuiceII on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:49AM (#34789185)
I've been working along side(not in) an IT union for 15 years, what an interesting ride.. If you ever want to see how unproductive and lazy people can be this is the place!
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:10AM (#34789474)
I've only ever had one union job, and ever non-union job I've been in has had about the same number of unproductive lazy people.

The unproductive lazy people at the union job didn't have to kiss ass and bullshit quite as much. That's it.

P.S. Oh, and we had significantly better health care benefits at the union job.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by jackmott42 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:50AM (#34789192)
The viability of your approach varies a lot depending on the type of job. For creative or technical jobs, sure. For people just on an assembly line doing boring repetitive work, you don't have those levers. Not everyone is a warrior poet who is going to network, and if we all could do that, then it wouldn't work anymore.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by dhfbshfbu4u3 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:51AM (#34789209)
Aren’t you the same person who was worried your “voluntary” retirement might be held against you when/if you look for a job?
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by wnkrshm on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:59AM (#34789316)
You are in the privileged position that your employer actually needs you specifically because you aren't easily replaced. That can change over time.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by nimbius on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:08AM (#34789443)
hi, im an IAM union diesel engine mechanic and have been for over a decade. Maybe I can help explain a bit.

in a 'blue collar' job like manufacturing or shipping or any of the trades like plumbing or mechanical maintenance, the only part of the business that doesnt see meaningful pushback is the labor. My job performance as a TIG welder in Texas as part of an oil and gas company was stellar, but not stellar enough to keep me from things like "mandatory overtime" and having to show up at a frigid gas field at 4 am to fix a line in chronic disrepair. part of the reason for this is a rosy picture of the rugged life of a tradesman, a misunderstanding of just how hard this work is, and a disconnected culture of leadership that see us as expendables/undesireables/expenses. Personal relationships only go so far when your op supervisor only shows up to berate you about tardiness or demand you work a weekend.

The union isnt a third party agency, its you. you decide what needs fixing, what doesnt work, and what you want changed to make your job more effective and a lot of times that includes your pay. when our shop unionized we did things like reduce shop floor noise, change how overtime gets assigned and made it voluntary, and even added paternity leave (we also get a say in our healthcare and opt in or out.) We even amended the companies equal opportunity employment statement to include LGBTQ+, something leadership resisted for a long time.

unions dont guarantee everyone works hard (thats culture), but they help to make sure everyone whos hired to work is treated fairly and with respect, and they fight to prevent common excesses in trade like wage theft, mandatory overtime, unfair scheduling, retaliation, and dangerous work conditions. They can push back on myopic or bad management decisions that harm customers or degrade quality.

The relationship isnt perfect. strikes can and do happen but when they do its mostly for good reasons like demanding sick leave (go get em CSX railworkers!!) and health insurance we were told the free market would provide us (looking at you Starbucks.) Federal law requires good faith collective bargaining, regardless of how many hit pieces on the evening news try to spin it any other way.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by nerdponx on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:18AM (#34791568)
> Those CSX rail workers just didn't work hard enough, and poor struggling management can't afford to give them paid sick leave because they're just so lazy and they work too slowly to be able to take the time off.

The above should be obvious as cruel sarcasm, but based on how people talk (and vote), it seems that some people genuinely believe such things.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by beepbooptheory on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:09AM (#34789454)
Maybe a little bit, but just in kinda applying that kind of high level business logic of a manager onto yourself as a person. It is really best to not worry so much on being "more productive" for your boss. You have a specific contract, which delineates how you trade your labor for money, that's it. They will make you think that your personal productivity is more than that, and yes, that your fellow workers who are less productive are somehow an obstacle to you. But you gotta realize at least deep down the bad faith in this way of thinking, even of you understandably need to act the part day to day.

Even if worker solidarity isn't you're thing, just for your mental health down the line you should adjust your thinking a little bit.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by RivieraKid on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:15AM (#34789560)
The theoretical reasoning behind unions is that they counteract the market power of companies over employees.

If this market power assymetry doesn't exist (for example software engineers in San Francisco), unions are not beneficial to the society but at least slightly beneficial to the average union member assuming the union is making good decisions. Because more market power is always better than less market power. It's always advantageous to be a monopoly.

If you're a highly productive employee, the company doesn't have market over you, you can easily find another job. But this may be different for an average employee.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by dls2016 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:31AM (#34789810)
> for example software engineers in San Francisco

Uhm... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by RivieraKid on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:19AM (#34815695)
Not sure what's your point.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by realslimjd on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:18AM (#34789599)
Unions can and do exist in right to work states.

The point of a union is not job security. It's about giving workers collective power they may not otherwise have. Historically unions have been painted as extremely antagonistic towards companies in the United States, but there's no reason that has to be true.

A well-run union recognizes that their survival is tied to the company's survival, and as long as both sides engage in good faith, they should reach an agreement that's mutually beneficial. To your point about job security, no one I know in unions wants to keep all employees no matter what. What people want is protection from being fired for no reason. Usually that means something like getting a PIP and six weeks to improve performance. Is that such an unreasonable ask? That way the employee has a chance to keep their job, and the company can potentially avoid the expense of hiring and training a new employee.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by kingstoned on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:42AM (#34789980)

  The point of a union is not job security. It's about giving workers collective power they may not otherwise have.
What would people do with this theoretical collective power? Probably job security combined with restrictions on work. Do as little as you can while being guaranteed a paycheck.

  What people want is protection from being fired for no reason.
How can people be fired for no reason? There is always a reason, whether it's related to company's performance, worker productivity or overall economic conditions.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by PavleMiha on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:57AM (#34790195)
On the other hand, why would people use their collective power to sink the company they work for? No company, no jobs. In reality the power has to be balanced between the two, and both parties need to act carefully and rationally.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by uxp100 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:23PM (#34792686)
And in fact, sometimes I feel the power goes the other way a little bit. Unions are big boosters for industry in a way that can be negative for the public. So you’ve got “pro-business” politicians supporting some project (let’s say highway expansion) alongside “pro-labor” politicians. The glowing blue orb manufacturers agree with their unions that people need more glowing blue orbs.

That’s in the case of a traditional trade union anyway, there are other models, and if there’s one big union that represents horseshoe workers (blacksmiths? Puddlers? Idk how a horseshoe is made I guess) and rubber tire manufacturers well, uh, they’ve got some things to discuss.

Anyway, much ink has been used discussing this by people better informed than me, but yeah, I agree, it is nuanced.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by realslimjd on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:54AM (#34790154)
I feel like you missed my point that it is not in a union's interest to protect low-performing workers. A union cannot survive without jobs, and union members are just as frustrated as anyone else when someone is not pulling their weight.

To your point about labor restrictions, unions gave us two day weekends and forty hour weeks. Modern labor practices are almost entirely defined by things unions fought for and standardized. The restrictions we have on work now didn't nebulously appear from the goodwill of employers.

People are absolutely fired for no reason all the time. Sometimes their boss is having a bad day. Maybe their manager is prejudiced against people wearing green shirts. Sometimes people are (illegally) fired for joining a union. People are not always rational, and that doesn't change between their work and personal lives.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by kingstoned on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:42AM (#34790904)
So according to you unions are rational, omnisciencet and benevolent agents, while entrepreneurs are dumb irrational idiots who will randomly fire people all the time for wearing a green shirt.

  To your point about labor restrictions, unions gave us two day weekends and forty hour weeks. Modern labor practices are almost entirely defined by things unions fought for and standardized. The restrictions we have on work now didn't nebulously appear from the goodwill of employers.
What enabled more leisure and higher living standards for workers was harnessing efficient sources of energy, especially in the 19th century and creating machines to do a lot of hard work. Without efficient energy and machines, everything has to be done by humans, so reducing work hours means worse living standards. The fact that living standards were rising while cutting back on hours tells you there was something else doing the hard work and that was machines powered by efficient energy sources. That was the real enabler of leasure, cozy office work and high living standards.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Eisenstein on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:55AM (#34792183)
> So according to you unions are rational, omnisciencet and benevolent agents, while entrepreneurs are dumb irrational idiots who will randomly fire people all the time for wearing a green shirt.

Why so antagonistic? By the way getting antagonistic doesn't make your argument better, it just makes you look frustrated and sour. Using logical fallacies like false binaries also isn't helpful.

The point isn't that one set is 'rational and good' and the other is 'frivolous and bad', the point is that in order for markets to work (labor is a market) there must be a even playing field so that parties can leverage their value for others without getting exploited.

When you have a society setup like the USA, without a real safety net and where periods of unemployment lead to instability financially, personally, and healthcare-wise, then employees are not able to properly leverage their value.

The proposal of 'work for me or your life falls apart' is pretty devastating to labor markets because it makes people settle for bad deals.

Unions are one method of trying to level this, by saying 'if you try to make me work on a ledge and don't give me a harness, then we are all going to shut down your business and not let you hire someone more desperate to do it' then one person is able to leverage the actual value of labor to bargain with the employer.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by Mountain_Skies on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @10:25AM (#34790610)
All of this is true but there are companies that were driven out of business due to unrealistic demands from their union. As you pointed out, humans are quite often irrational and there's no reason to think that unions will always act in a rational manner that protects workers from losing their job through employer bankruptcies. Certainly, it is the goal to prevent that from happening, but humans being humans, often don't see how a particular short-term goal can end up harming their long-term goals. Of course, most companies, no matter how profitable, will cry poverty to each union request that's going to have costs to the company, so an adversarial relationship builds, with both sides insisting the other is acting in bad faith. Plenty of times, it's true for both sides.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by trieste92 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:48AM (#34790064)
> Usually that means something like getting a PIP and six weeks to improve performance. Is that such an unreasonable ask?

Isn't this what parent took issue with? If you can't fire the underperformers, where's the incentive to get shit done?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by realslimjd on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:55AM (#34790168)
You can fire them after six weeks, which in the grand scheme of things is not that long. I've been places where it takes longer to get requirements back from clients.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by krainboltgreene on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @04:34PM (#34796372)
> If you can't fire the underperformers, where's the incentive to get shit done?

The assumption with you guys is always three parts:

  1. That the company actors know what good performance is, therefor they can determine underperformance
  2. That underperformance is meaningful in the context (taking care of a sick kid for a month is underperformance, but not meaningful when the kid is no longer sick)
  3. That the company actors are being truthful about the reason
When in reality I know that company actors rarely understand good performance or thus underperformance, they rarely consider meaningfulness, and rarely are they actually telling the truth about the reason.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by surement on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @05:11PM (#34796910)
> The point of a union is not job security. It's about giving workers collective power they may not otherwise have.

No, it's about giving workers currently employed by the company collective power. This means keeping potential employees out by setting a threshold for financial compensation or number of hours available to work. The victims here (unemployed and underemployed people) have no collective power and don't appear in data so they are ignored.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by zzzeek on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:28AM (#34789766)
this take is kind of breathtaking? There's an entire history of workers unions in the US and around the world, famous spurring events like the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory disaster, surely you aren't just waving the entire subject off as "absurd", thinking that whole factories of garment workers for example would have success via "individual performance" ? like they'd have fire exits just for the better performing workers? I can't even get my head around this take.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by wil421 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:52AM (#34790125)
They are comparing an office job to a back breaking trade (plumbing, metal working, electrician) or manufacturing job. Factory jobs have lots of people doing the same reparative job, individual performance only goes so far.

Would the bosses really care if you are the fastest chicken skinner or bolt screwer?

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by nerdponx on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:16AM (#34791543)
It exemplifies the "individual exceptionalism" attitude of many Americans, wherein they attribute all their successes to themselves and all their failures to external forces beyond their control.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by zzzeek on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @06:17PM (#34797634)
yeah that's the baseline attitude of Hacker Newsers, that post went way above and beyond all that in its ignorance :)
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by PeterisP on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:30AM (#34789794)
A decent union is mostly about job conditions, not job security - collective bargaining prevents a "race to the bottom" where abusive conditions creep in due to there always being some people who'll do the job anyway. A good example is the Screen Actors Guild which imposes all kinds of minimum conditions, for example, due to which all kinds of safety issues in filming are handled quite decently (even if stuff does still happen), despite the fact that many desperate wannabe actors would easily sign a contract where they agree to whatever conditions the company imposes.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by surement on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @05:13PM (#34796939)
> conditions creep in due to there always being some people who'll do the job anyway

don't worry, minimum wage laws keep those pesky people unemployed

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by mrzimmerman on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:21PM (#34799219)
I can’t tell if you’re against minimum wage laws or not but I’ll say regardless that minimum wage laws show a boat in worker income and small employment effects:

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by surement on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:36PM (#34799321)
The 5% of economists who suck up to politicians are always able to find data that shows that if you set a floor on the price of labor it somehow doesn't affect demand. The other 95%–the ones who aren't grifters–know that the only effect of minimum wage laws is unemployment for those who would otherwise make less than the price floor. This has devastating effects on teenage and young adult unemployment, and prevents those people from gaining experience, which is highly correlated with income.

Everyone can already set their own price floor under which they will not work. There's zero good reason to make it illegal for people to choose their own minimum. This is third parties making the decision because they feel icky about it. No one who's ever had a low wage would've preferred to not work at all. Ask all the people e.g. who worked for $10/h before California raised the minimum wage to $15/h.

When less experienced workers agree to receive less in compensation it's because they understand that they are not just being compensated financially, they are also gaining experience.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by akerl_ on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:37AM (#34789897)
As individuals negotiating with a business, you’re always going to be at a massive disadvantage due to the balance of resources. The company is bigger than the people you’re building relationships with.

Unions, done well, perform a lot of similar functions to insurance providers: they allow many people to collectively bargain in a way that can level the playing field in negotiations.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by jacquesm on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:41AM (#34789957)
Do you enjoy free Saturdays? Paternity leave? Maternity leave? A pension? Health insurance? Holidays? A 40 hour work week? A safe working environment? Workplace training programs?

And so on. All of these and more are the result of unions. You by your lonesome wouldn't stand a chance negotiating all of the above with the captains of industry, no matter how rare your talents.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by dfxm12 on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:42AM (#34789965)
Probably. I think you should start by understanding the workers' conditions and demands better. Your post mentions job security and puts in quotes, and yeah, that is one thing the workers mentioned, but they've talked about more, too.

If you've been treated with dignity and fairly compensated for your effort at your previous jobs, that's great! Not every employer is like that, though, and no amount of personal relationships can change them. In that situation, you gotta demand it together with your fellow worker.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by eunos on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:58AM (#34790204)
Reflecting on the latest big tech lay offs. Decisions about whom were targeted were made by folks 3-4 levels above you who doesnt know you personally and even your performance might not matter to them.
Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by jitix on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @04:58PM (#34796749)
When talking about unions the focus is generally on hourly wage jobs where the skills are quite transferable and thus workers’ leverage is less.

A factory worker installing bolts on a panel in some car isn’t gonna get opportunities to show “individual performance” or get to develop “personal relationships” with their supervisor who’s probably managing dozens of people

In context of white collar salaries jobs, esp software engineering I agree with you 100%.

Re:Tesla Workers Launch Union Campaign in New York by mrzimmerman on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:31PM (#34799288)
I also live in a “right to fire for whatever” state, often referred to as “right to work” which really means the right of employers to ignore union agreements and compensate individuals less if the individual agrees to it. It’s already illegal at the federal level to force someone to be part of a union and states like ours just work harder to make sure we don’t end up collectively bargaining for better conditions by controlling the supply of our labor of which our employers are the consumers (literally basic market economics and nothing more).

Your statement brings to mind this quote from Martin Niemöller, who was sympathetic to the Nazis until he witnessed the escalation and reach of their beliefs:

> First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist. > Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist. > Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. > Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me. > —Martin Niemöller