I guess what I'm trying to say, is that even working with a guillotine above my head feels preferable to having to pick up the slack of people coasting and not meeting their commitments.
Unions have a place for fighting against unfair dismissals of an individual, but they are primarily for when everyone is being treated badly.
American public sector unions are cartoonishly bad. Recent example from San Francisco. Fourth grader hasn’t learned math in six months. Their math teacher had a concussion and can’t work. The substitute doesn’t teach math. (?!?) The original teacher can’t be replaced. (They deserve disability, but students deserve instruction.) Substitutes must be drawn from a list, on which there were two options, and the other person didn’t want to do it.
So students get babysat while their peers learn math. Because every stopgap, including another teacher dropping in, or a parent volunteering, or hiring an off-list sub or even temp, or telling the sub they have hired to knock it off, it’s grade school math, they can probably find a decent YouTube series, is contractually prohibited.
At the larger scale, your choice is to try to convince your co-workers.
The downside of joining a minority union / members only union is not that different in the US as elsewhere, in that you generally have no legal right to be treated as a bargaining agent or in the case of some such unions they explicitly don't even try get recognition.
But even the US has examples of minority unions being voluntarily given some degree of representation:
https://eu.freep.com/story/money/cars/2014/11/12/uaw-volkswa...
Most places have thresholds to be met before an employer can be forced to recognise a given union. It's not unusual for that threshold to be 50% per unit and for people to still opt to stay members in a minority union, which you can in the US too.
The main way the US distinguishes itself in terms of unionisation is by low union membership, and as such the lack of significant minority union locals in the US is more a factor of few people joining a union unless they'd be paying agency fees anyway.
Shortly after starting, he was approached by the local Union bosses, and sternly told to slow down. Not only did he make everone else look bad, if people worked that much, that would lead to layoffs.
Not wanting trouble with the Union, he and his pal switched to only working about 4 hours each night (it was usually night shifts) and then sleep the remaining 4 hours of the shift.
> I massively prefer the work-life balance and workers protections high union participation has created in Norway over the UK
Sure, though it comes at a pretty significant cost in terms of efficiency and of the ability of the more productive part of the workforce to generate income for themselves.
Over time, this kind of setup tends to lead to loss of competitiveness, often resulting in fewer jobs / layoffs, lower salaries or to requiring the rest of society to pay subsidies, trade barriers and/or for consumers to pay more for their products.
Case in point would be Norwegian agricultural unions.
And maybe worst of all, a society dominated by unions may cause some of the most productive citizens to seek better opportunities abroad ;)
While there have at times been overzealous union people and I obviously can't know the conditions specifically at your dads old workplace, closed shops have typically been far more unusual in Norway than e.g. in the US, and the few attempts there have been have increasingly faced legal opposition and are now considered illegal in part based on interpretation of the freedom of association in Council of Europe's social charter from the 1960s. The main exception in the past have been for employees of the unions themselves, and even there closed shops became unusual a long time ago. But of course you won't make many friends at a workplace if you actively place their working conditions and employment at risk.
> Sure, though it comes at a pretty significant cost in terms of efficiency and of the ability of the more productive part of the workforce to generate income for themselves.
Health and safety and the general wellbeing of workers tends to come at a cost, yes, it doesn't come from nothing. The question is not whether or not to do so - not a single country in the world allow employers free reign in deciding workers conditions - but where to draw the line.
So then you have a choice of how much of your own well-being you're willing to sacrifice for the sake of maximising profits for someone else. Of course there is a point beyond which pushing working conditions and salaries up becomes net detrimental. But given Norway tend to rank near the top on almost all quality of life metrics, it does not seem Norway has hit it (and in case you drag up oil: Denmark and Sweden tend to rank equally well)
> Over time, this kind of setup tends to lead to loss of competitiveness, often resulting in fewer jobs / layoffs, lower salaries or to requiring the rest of society to pay subsidies, trade barriers and/or for consumers to pay more for their products.
Come to the UK and experience the life of an average worker here and see how fucked up their situation is compared to the average Norwegian, and see if you consider the trade-off worthwhile. Høyre would be considered far-left extremists by UK standards, with policies in their program more radical than what Corbyn proposed (they support more generous parental leave policies for example, and Solberg stood up for continued government ownership policies that'd see her branded as a communist here). And we live the result. The UK tends to rank well below the Scandinavian countries on most quality of life metrics.
> And maybe worst of all, a society dominated by unions may cause some of the most productive citizens to seek better opportunities abroad ;)
I didn't leave for the salary, and I stayed for family reasons. We need to earn far more here for the same standard of living as in Norway because we need to compensate for a welfare system that is far less generous, despite the fact we on average work far longer hours. Yet the average worker here earns less than in Norway. For me, at a far higher salary than average, it's close to a toss up, but had I been on an average salary I'd be back in Norway in a heartbeat rather than put up with the shitty conditions most people here deal with. For my part, I intend to leave the UK well before I retire, because while money can compensate for the direct impact on me personally, it can't compensate for the negative effect on the society surrounding me.
He. I suppose it's pretty common for expats to keep the mentality they had from their country of origin, and even romanticize it a bit.
I'll not quibble with you a bit, just bring my own anecdote:
About 15 years ago, I was called in to help an Accenture team that was about to fail a software project for Posten. When I arrived, the situation was kind of critical.
The Accenture project was led by an architect/PM from London, and staffed by a couple of devs (one of them lead dev) from Norway, and a larger number of devs in India.
Every afternoon around 15:45, all the devs would be gone, and it was just me and the architect from the UK remaining, trying to sort out all the issues in the code.
As we were working into the evening night after night, we got to know each other a bit. As it turned out, he felt like he was trapped in a hell hole, with a team that was not willing to put in any extra effort even though the project was about to fail. I kind of gave him the story that you gave me above.
But he insisted that live was MUCH better in London. Not only was Oslo dark and freezing cold (this was during the winter) and lacking the kind of cultural attractions of a city like London, for someone like him purchasing power was also much better.
While his peers in Oslo had to leave the office before 4pm every day to fetch the kids from daycare, in London he was able to keep a nanny to both provide more personalized care and also provide more flexibility to the parents. In Oslo, families that can afford that usually make significantly more than a software architect.
My point isn't that one system is better than the other, rather that the patriotism can go in both directions.
And for countries trying to be as agalitarian as Norway without the oil revenue, the downsides are even more pronounced, of course. Norway may be the closest to a social democratic Utopia one can get.
Really? I'd far rather not have a guillotine above my head if the trade-off is a few lazy colleagues. Why should that be my problem?
A union protects your specific job for a specific employer (or set of employers or subset of industry). Networks and reputation protect your ability to get paid for the thing you do in general. The degree to which either approach is successful is going to depend on one's industry and position/skill-set therein.
Edit: This shouldn't need to be said but the above should not be construed as an endorsement of either approach.
I'm not in a union, but I'm also roughly in the 1%. If I was anywhere below the top 5% or so, I'd have joined a union in a heartbeat, and like commenters above I find the US resistance to unions utterly bizarre, not least because US unions were instrumental in laying the groundwork for a lot of modern labour protections, to the point of losing lives as part of those battles.
Even May 1st as an international day for labour demonstrations came after a request from the AFL in part as commemoration of the Chicago Haymarket Massacre, and as a renewal of the multi-decades fight for the 8 hour working day.
I wish unions were not needed too, then I hear about shitty employers exploiting poor people and I accept that unions are needed.
The wave of tech layoffs should've made that clear.
The USA's primal hatred of unions will always blow my mind. There's power in a union my friend.