I'd pay good money for more personal experiences from companies, especially when it comes to something like this, but it's not easy. The wife and I were looking for a honeymoon package, but neither "beach" nor "romantic European getaway" were on our list. Roughly 90% of travel companies were out of ideas after that. It's literally their JOB to plan trips and they can't deviate from a template. It's pain incarnate.
My dad had one for years who was better than that but I've only sometimes used specialty agencies, e.g. for English walking trips.
*Exotic very much being in the eye of the beholder, but something different from my daily costal urban experience.
It's a book, fully indexed, with searchable and fully reviewed information about the place you are going and the path in between. You use it to make your own plan, or to improvise.
Specifically about improvisation, it has become almost impossible nowadays because there is no reliable information about anything.
but somehow I always end up having to sign up for a bunch of services in a hurry and take crappy pictures of my id only to find out that the hotel doesn't know anything about my reservation when I arrive anyways.
sometimes I even have to upgrade my phone while sitting on a curb to get the app to arrange for the payment etc .etc.
or that lovely looking and affordable Airbnb is next to an open sewer
That killed plenty of guides before our current era of universal dishonesty.
However, it's all nostalgia. There is nothing about them that I would've preferred over a phone or tablet with working internet, had they been a thing back then.
It's almost like a local maximum, if you plot (total happiness-total boredom) against (total screen hours).
Almost no individual activity is more appealing than scrolling (As we can infer from most people's behavior these days), but people will tell you that they want a life that isn't just scrolling and mobile games, and people are happier when they do more than screens.
I probably sound old and nostalgic but there were some things that were just “better” when life was a bit slower and not completely driven by tech—-and I’m someone that works in tech!
Those trips really felt like an adventure whereas now it’s just push some buttons and drive.
Of course, that modern ability lacks the anticipation, excitement and celebration of the annual family trip experience that you talk about, and yes, a personalized physical map that not just aids your navigation to your holiday destination but later becomes a memory artifact when said road trip is fondly remembered and re-imagined.
We invent electronic replacements for things and processes without giving much thought to the positive aspects of the experience that we may wish to retain (or better: re-create) before replacing them. Naturally, the first iterations of the substitute will be lacking. Later refinements will be evaluated relative to previous versions of the electronic replacement, not the original experience, which is soon forgotten. That's why many electronic/automatic replacements are lacking: examples include manual maps versus car navigation systems, human layout creation versus DTP publishing, traditional printing versus print on demand, traditional slide photography and development versus digital photography. The new is not just a replacement of the old, it is different. But the new often renders the old uneconomical and makes it disappear, like it or not, even when they tell us that the new thing is "complementary" to the old. For better or worse, free market economy does not have a place for something _and_ its substitute, only the cheaper one of the two.
Most people don't bother, but I don't think that's the technology's fault. The technology absolutely supports it.
When I told people I went to Alaska, the inevitable answer was, "Oh, did you go on a cruise?" No, I didn't go on a forking cruise. Those are for lazy people.
What I've started doing is booking a short (2-4 days) trip inside the country or state, and being independent before & after that. You still get some guidance and socializing and seeing things you wouldn't otherwise, but your whole vacation isn't locked in. I recommend this.
Even the Rand McNally showed highway rest areas and picnic areas. The Triptik also showed gas stations. Electronic maps often lack this entirely, at least in easy form.
The Triptik shows what you need to know while on a long motor trip. The electronic map emphasizes details I don't need.
At a glance the paper map tells me whether a road is free limited-access, toll limited-access, multi-lane divided, two lanes but major, two lanes and minor, a country lane, or a dirt road. Electronic map only tells me this if I zoom in on a satellite view, and it might even route me over a two-lane road to save five minutes on a two-hour trip when there's a much safer freeway that most drivers would prefer.
Paper map has little dotted lines for scenic routes. Electronic map doesn't.
Mostly I'm surprised the electronic maps don't have these things after all these years. Maybe Apple will get them eventually. Google is busy stuffing ads into its maps.
Yeah, google is always going to be trash for anything that doesn’t align well with advertising. Better to show a Starbucks than a rest area, etc.
Making the call on what is a “scenic route” isn’t something you can just pull directly from highway department data.
Since when did using a map become an "advanced" life skill? Is "Idiocracy" becoming a documentary?
Besides, even before phones, it was somewhat advanced, they were never easy, as shown by how often people got lost, and still get lost with perfectly functional GPS just by making one bad turn because their memory failed since last time they checked the screen.
If you can darn socks you can probably fix holes in your pants, and if you have a car charger, getting lost happens a lot less than clothes repair, at least in the city.
- What road am I on? What town am I in?
- and other flavors of "where the hell am I, anyway?"
- This is especially annoying when on the phone and the person is asking where you are, and the best you can answer is "Google says I'm X minutes away"
- What road is this coming up next? - instead it puts the name halfway along the road, which is out of view...
- Some of the true nav systems (Garmin, etc) do this better.Dear Google:
If I have my directions preference set to walking, cycling, or public transit, there is no reason to EVER show me the route number of a street that has a name. I don't care about it, and it actively gets in the way of using the map since it displaces the name, you know, the thing that is actually on the signs that I am looking at with my eyes.
It would be one thing if it showed both the name and the number, but usually you have to pinch and pan so far from where you are before you luck into seeing the name that you've totally lost your orientation on the map.
It frustrates me to no end how hard it can be to see the names of streets in Maps, it's one of the most important things!
Not for streets that go through a town or city and have maximum speeds of 30 mph (48 Kmh). And those are the streets that Maps displays route numbers. I don’t know of truckers using those streets.
In my area (Connecticut), it depends. Some streets are known by their route numbers, vs some streets have route numbers and most people aren't aware of them at all. It's more common to refer by route number if it's a busy main road that changes name from town to town that it passes through.
Then there's upstate New York, with plenty of streets that are only route numbers, despite being otherwise residential normal roads.
The interesting thing is that Apple now offers "explore" vs "driving" maps, I hope they also add "walking" or "Cycling" maps. And because they aren't driven by advertising sales, the maps can be more useful without compromising sales revenue.
If Apple decided to invest in a crawler/indexer with a search front end to give Siri the data sources for better response, and to allow for "pure" informational search (rather than search-ad/revenue prioritized search), once it got good enough for that it would put Google into a very tight spot. (Well tighter than the one it currently finds itself in).
While it's nice that their users can have an alternate first-party experience, that experience is not a publically available map. For example if you go to maps.apple.com you are told "Open this on your Apple Hardware".
(i.e. If 100% of Apple users used Apple Maps, Apple's best case scenario is still #2 in mapping)
1) People start buying Apple hardware because it has a better map experience.
2) Apple can produce the iMap device, likely in cooperation with their maps partner TomTom, that people can use to get the Apple Maps experience without changing their phone provider.
[1] https://www.oberlo.com/statistics/us-smartphone-market-share
I am also a firm believer that everyone should "vote with their wallet" for the products they want, so no judgement, on my part, on folks who buy one product or the other.
In my experience I find that for every product I buy, the various choices all come with pluses and minuses. I go through that list and apply my own importance rating on each one and come up with my final choice.
My original comment was that Apple Maps are getting better, they were at one time a complete joke. I use maps on my phone all the time, it is probably the largest use of mine after "looking things up on the web" or "communicating" via text or voice. As a result of this improvement in maps, it made this particular choice (for me) a better choice on the iPhone than on an android phone.
I can tell that some people heard my comment above "if you don't own an iPhone you are stupid" or something like that. It certainly wasn't my intent. Never easy to know how something you say will be heard.
My other experience is that products that get "better" overall, supplant, then replace what existed before them. Whether it is TVs, cars, computers, or phones. I still have a Garmin Navigator in my car's glove box but I don't think I have used it in nearly a decade. And yet there was a time when devices of that form were 90+% of the market for "in vehicle navigation."
The reference article was discussing a resurgence in "paper" maps, which have three advantages over "electronic" maps that I am aware of; they work when you are "offline", they have specific details of interest, and they "look good."
My observation was that Apple appears to be investing in a better "map" experience on their phones. This resurgence might influence that investment.
Dismissing that observation based on market share is probably unwise. Why? Because market share is a function of serving customer requirements better than the competition. Market share is a reflection of meeting requirements, and in the absence of external forces will result in the brands with doing the best job of meeting requirements ahead of their competitors.
For the record, the best data available suggests that only ~50% of iOS users choose the pre-installed built-in Maps versus explicitly downloading the Google Maps app.
One wonders what that number would look like without anti-competitive monopolistic bundling, too. From that perspective, it seems that the "majority of iOS users" would choose Google over Apple Maps, but Apple's anti-competitive behavior has kept it at around 50/50 on their own platform.
I would agree 100% that for the last 10 years, Google Maps has been "the best choice" for an online map. I think it would be ill advised if they relied on their historical advantage and simply "assumed" it would always be "the best choice." Their competitors are evolving their maps offerings and if Google doesn't pay attention they will find themselves suddenly playing catch up.
My observation is that Google is very distracted at the moment but I don't know how that affects the maps team (were any of them laid off?). Apple seems to be investing here and the improvements in their product reflect that investment.
Apple isn't a serious contender because they don't sell anything in the low-end segment. Ferrari make great cars but you can't expect everyone to drive a Ferrari.
> You can also get an iOS device (partly) included with a post-paid mobile plan, can't you?
That acts as a payment plan, but you're still paying the full cost (usually plus interest) one way or another.
Given that Apple just issued another security update for the decade old iPhone 5s, your ability to hand down an iPhone is greatly extended, especially compared to the support policy you get with a bottom of the barrel Android device.
I think this is a fair point in favour of Apple, but I would be surprised if many people who are weighing up hand-me-downs vs cheapest models are concerned with security updates
> based on handsets with an initial buyback price of $700 or higher, Android phones lose value twice as fast as iOS models over the first two years of ownership.
https://www.phonearena.com/news/android-phones-lose-more-val...
Also, the cheaper the Android device, the quicker it depreciates.
Are we pretending that T-Mobile won't cut you a deal on an iPhone SE?
I'll be looking for a new phone soon. 350 and under is what I'm aiming for. 400 is extreme stretch and the 400 dollar phone would have to blow me away to get me to consider it.
Apple Maps isn't a serious contender because 1) it's not public 2) it's not web 3) iOS represents a minority of the world userbase.
Worldwide it's 70% Android and 20% Apple.
Do you really think 100% of 20% will beat any decent percent of 70%?
No affiliation, just a happy user.
With paper maps, you can just look at them -- a single page, no pinch zooming or scrolling! -- to see what exit is appropriate for your destination. Not possible with Google Maps -- you either have to zoom in until the exit ramp fills the screen, or make up a fake address near where you're going to get directions which you then have to read through to find the relevant exit. It's a needless frustration when I'm in a hurry and just what to know what exit serves town X.
I now generally turn the audio part off except for alerts. I like that better, not only is it more soothing, but it forces me to engage my brain a little more.
https://www.amazon.com/Collins-Nicholson-Waterways-Guides-Ox...
It includes important details, like the location of the nearest Pub, waterpoints, Tesco.
There are a few apps: "Open Canal Map" and "WaterNav".
Life becomes a series of more, but lower value experiences.
Which seems to be very culture specific, it's important to some but not others.
I don't have much doubt that people get lost less with phones now. It's reliable and available on demand at any moment. Basic utilitarian trips might even use less gas because if dynamic traffic data.
The main thing we lost is the sense that things are real and solid, rather than unearned power ups in a global scale video game, but by technical engineering measures, it seems like almost every single product outside of the arts has improved, year after year.
Old analog stuff is cool, but if I only had room in my bag for one, I'm probably going to take the latest new version, every time.
In the US, younger students are performing worse in mathematics than previous cohorts; calculators aren't a singular cause but their ubiquity does encourage a mentality both from children and adults that basic arithmetic and even algebra or geometry aren't important, which then becomes worse performance by older students who lack the fundamentals.
I'd be interested to see a study on how often folks are "lost" and how that was defined: if someone's phone lost power or crashed mid-journey, then the person would qualify as lost because they don't know where they are or how to get out of where they are, but even with the phone _telling_ them where to go, do they really know where they are or how to get out of where they are? Or are they just a simple child being given and following directions from a parent, without any concept of what those directions mean?
Algebra is not useful to an average person directly, and the path to actually getting a job that needs math is long enough that nobody in school is going to think through their future like that, we don't really have a culture of kids thinking a decade ahead. I sure didn't.
Plus, the main thing educators seem to talk about is this mysterious "New way of thinking" you get from math. But nobody just trusts their teachers on that, since it's not something that can be explained easily.
It probably doesn't help that they still like to pretend you're going to actually directly do long division IRL. Even if there's a reason to learn it, I don't see why we need to tell people they'll actually use it directly, when it seems pretty clear most people don't.
But that seems like a matter for educators to solve rather than tech or tech culture.
Is there a different optimal curriculum that takes into account the existence of calculators and the fact we learn math for different reasons now? Or is the best way to teach it unchanged?
Philosophically I suppose phone-dependent people are perpetually lost, but I think a practical definition would be "Unable to navigate to their destination with available equipment".
Someone who's phone dies isn't really experiencing what most know as lost unless they have no power bank or car charger, only then are they going to really be experiencing some panic.
Google Maps is constantly making weasel changes to try to get people to sign in and inserting ads for businesses. OpenStreetMaps is great offline, no sign-in required, but it's still too janky.
IMO, it doesn't really matter how well Google/Apple Maps works because something very important is lost when using it. Namely, the privacy of one's interests and movements.
Imagine if AAA, after they provide you with highlighted maps and useful information for your travel, proceeded to track you through every step of your journey and there was no way you could say, "No, thank you."
Google does not need to file a complaint that survives a motion to dismiss, reach the discovery phase of litigation and then subpoena AAA in order to obtain a driving plan for one specific driver. It continuously collects driving plans passively and indiscriminantly.
In litigation, testimony might be sealed. The data Google collects via Google Maps has no such protections available.
Let's be "realistic". Most people getting maps highlighted at AAA offices were not parties in lawsuits, the AAA employees that provided maps to them were not deposed by lawyers, and their driving plans were not used to prop up on online ad services racket. Yet every person that uses Google Maps is being surveilled for commercial purposes.
Flooding the web with more programmatic advertising.
My other claim to fame was that I was the only one in the family - maybe in the entire neighborhood - who could fold a paper map so everything fell into place and it looked like new.
All the adults would just force the map to fold along whichever creases they felt like folding. I let the map "fold itself" with the map deciding where it wanted to be folded, and me just executing the map's wishes.
Specifically, first I would find the one crease that ran all the way across the map in the same direction - it was a "valley" or a "tent" all the way across, depending on which side you were looking at.
Then I'd find the next crease that was the same across the now-folded map. And the next one, and so on.
Adults didn't know this trick. They would fold along the creases, but they didn't take the time to let the map teach them which crease to fold first.
This is kind of like something I learned recently when I rescued a stray kitten from the street: You don't find a cat, the cat finds you.
Back to TripTiks, I bought one on eBay a few months ago, and it turned out to be an awesome road trip a southern California family took in the late 1960s.
First is the "front matter", with pages on:
Using your TripTik
Strip Map Legend
About Accommodations
In Case Of Accident
Western Radio Stations
The SPEED that's set is your best bet
Trip Planning
Expenses
Entering Canada and Returning to the United States
A Summary of Safety Responsibility Laws in Canada
Now we start the trip from Temple City, near Pasadena. Many of the pages were 2-3 page foldouts. I will use the original state abbreviations instead of our modern two-letter ones. Temple City to I-10 East
I-10 to I-15 through San Bernardino
San Bernardino to Las Vegas
Local map of Las Vegas
Las Vegas to Beaver, Utah
Beaver to Salt Lake City
Local map of Salt Lake City
Salt Lake City to Logan, turning onto US 89 East
Logan to Alpine, Wyo.
Alpine to Yellowstone National Park
Local map of Yellowstone
Yellowstone to Gillette, Wyo.
Gillette to Deadwood, S. Dak.
An optional loop all around the Black Hills Region
A TripTik Supplement for US 85/14/94 where they didn't have the map
Belfield, N. Dak. to Bismarck, N. Dak.
Bismarck to Fargo and on to US 81
Fargo to Winnipeg, Man.
Winnipeg to Kenora, Ont.
Kenora to Port Arthur on the Thunder Bay
Port Arthur to Nipigon, Ont.
Nipigon to Sault Ste. Marie, Ont.
Sault Ste. Marie to North Bay, Ont.
Another missing-map supplement for North Bay to Ottawa, Ont.
And finally a local map of Ottawa, their destination
Every one of these TripTik pages has a description of the towns and cities along the way, with hotel, motel, restaurant, and service station listings.Thanks for mentioning TripTiks. It was fun for me to go through this road trip in my mind and on paper just now.
Maybe it was because I grew up in a rural area but I much prefer NSEW directions and looking at a physical map.
They were awesome. When we were growing up most big family trips were in the car because gas and hotels were just so much more affordable than flying an entire family anywhere. I got to be the "navigator" on so many trips by helping family members read the Triptiks.
Apparently AAA still offers these, but they're generated digitally now via their app, and you can print them off if you want. But something about those human-built Triptiks were really really special.