News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by whatever1 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:55AM (#34427320)
Families will get torn apart, people with health issues will be on their own, immigrants will get booted.

C-suite will get a raise from the stock price bump.

Congrats on our system.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by jarym on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:58AM (#34427361)
The Federal Reserve wants to tame inflation by cooling the economy. I don't believe that historically that has ever been achieved without causing unemployment to rise.

These large companies are ultimately doing what the Fed wants them to do, no point blaming the c-suite for that?

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by whatever1 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:02AM (#34427421)
How did the Fed force the companies to over-hire?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by kyrra on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#34427573)
See the Fed's own theory on this topic: https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/money_12856.htm

> For example, when interest rates go down, it becomes cheaper to borrow, so households are more willing to buy goods and services, and businesses are in a better position to purchase items to expand their businesses, such as property and equipment. Businesses can also hire more workers, influencing employment. And the stronger demand for goods and services may push wages and other costs higher, influencing inflation.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:13AM (#34427594)
By lowering interest rates to the point people chased ever more expansive and risky investments. If all your competition is getting free money you as a business must generally take it too or extinguish to your over-capitalized competition. People also have more loose money which means if you can't up your production your customers will find alternatives and your business will dry up.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mattnewton on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#34427574)
My layman’s understanding is that near zero interest rates make borrowing nearly free and so investments like lots of headcount are rational. The companies don’t have to be doing the borrowing directly (though some do), they can simply benefit from investors willing to tolerate more risk since they have fewer “safe returns” as options, or more income from consumers who are willing to spend at low interest rates.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by malcolmgreaves on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:00AM (#34427396)
They could all take massive pay cuts to preserve jobs. They have agency and they have chosen to enrich their stock price at the expense of people’s lives and well being.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:10AM (#34427531)
Contrary to popular belief, at a company the size of MSFT - the execs could drop all their wages to $0 - and it would not be able to save 5% of the workforce from getting fired.

The execs get paid a lot - but there's not that many of them, and there's 200k people at MSFT making an average salary (with benefits) >$200k. That's >$40B per year. The execs don't take home >$2B per year.

Satya made <$60M last year. There's not 35 execs at MSFT making the same amount of money or higher. There's 18 others, and they make a lot less money on average.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by roflyear on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:05AM (#34428431)
MS c-suite makes a total of roughly ~$135,244,086, the board of directors make a total of about $4m (gates takes no salary at all, btw).

This 10k layoff, at an average salary of 190,302, is about $2b a year. So yeah not quite - but for them to suffer no consequences is still pretty gross.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notfromhere on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:14PM (#34434498)
Worse thing is that MSFT minted $72B in net income last year, so these layoffs are really about them saving...2.7% of net income in exchange for messing with the lives of 10k employees.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by LadyCailin on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:48PM (#34434819)
> gates takes no salary at all, btw

This is in part, due to the fact that he has nothing to do with Microsoft anymore.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by roflyear on Thursday January 19, 2023 @05:13PM (#34446412)
Ah, I thought he was still on the board. One website listing salaries lists gates. Weird.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by culi on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:33AM (#34428905)
If all 10k of these workers get paid an average of $150k, Satya's salary alone would cover 4% of them. I find it hard to believe you couldn't save 5%

Do you have any actual numbers on the number of execs vs workers and their salaries?

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mrandish on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:40PM (#34430010)
I just saw a headline yesterday based on a new study which said the average U.S. CEO's compensation is 399 times the average employee. So there's your number. A CEO taking zero would cover less than 400 employees. Also, keep in mind the vast majority of Satya's compensation is in long-term vesting stock options which can become worthless if the stock is lower in four years than it is this year.

The big numbers you see for CEO compensation for this year are largely stock options that were granted years prior which vested this year.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by culi on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:16PM (#34431496)
> So there's your number. A CEO taking zero would cover less than 400 employees.

That's not our number at all. GP said "executives" which includes a lot more than the CEOs. For all I know 1% of the company could be executives

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:39PM (#34431869)
Well, I told you how many "execs" are at MSFT. It's 19 out of >200k employees - so there's 100x less execs than your guess.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by raydev on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:20PM (#34431568)
> it would not be able to save 5% of the workforce from getting fired

This part of your statement has no relevance given MS's position, even taking into account the current market.

MS as a company is in no danger here. In fact, they are doing quite well.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @05:37PM (#34434122)
> This part of your statement has no relevance given MS's position, even taking into account the current market.

You hire people if you need them, fire them if you don't. It's really that simple.

Your employer doesn't owe you a job.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by cocoland2 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:54PM (#34436182)
Out of curiosity, Did you mean 20k people making more than 200k. The overall strength is 220k at MS isn't it
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by shiftingleft on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:06AM (#34427482)
Microsoft net income 2022: ~$70B. Why force pay cuts or fire workers when you have roughly $300k of net income per employee to work with?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#34427571)
Why make a profit when you can pay your employees >100% of your revenue and just go into debt instead?

It's not how business works.

You hire people if you need people, and you pay them the least you can get away with, so you maximize profits - because long ago, you raised money with the promise to the people you raised the money from that you would do this, and you have a Fiduciary obligation to do so...

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by coldpie on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#34428118)
> you pay them the least you can get away with, so you maximize profits

We agree then that employees should put in the least amount of work that they can get away with, right? Fair's fair.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by ckdarby on Thursday January 19, 2023 @08:00AM (#34439826)
That is what a lot of employees do. That is why these layoffs are probably happening, cutting 5% could have been done by freezing hiring and performance evals.

They're particular individuals who will take a stance like what you're outlining and sit in a limbo state outside of performance firing them. They bring down team moral, high performing employees feel cheated, etc.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by coldpie on Thursday January 19, 2023 @09:19AM (#34440505)
I think it would be more accurate to say it exposes to the high performers that they are being cheated. Those employees are donating their time & effort to the company so that their bosses can drive fancy cars, fund yacht racing teams, take tourist trips to LEO, buy social media companies to use as toys, and pay off politicians to keep those same employees desperate. The owners want employees fighting amongst themselves for scraps because it keeps them distracted from their real enemy.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by roflyear on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:05AM (#34428436)
Lots of companies do take no profit and pay out entirely to their employees, and there are some famous examples of that.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:12AM (#34428549)
Lots of co-ops and private companies...

Please show me one public company that has said - sorry shareholders - we're returning 100%+ of profits to our employees forever.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:52AM (#34429230)
Who cares if a public company hasn’t done it? We know it’s possible. We need to make the world a better place not have the status quo.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:35PM (#34429924)
You can't do it with a public company because you have a fiduciary obligation.

You can't raise money from Shareholder A with the promise to never return the money.

That's a donation. Not gonna be able to raise money like you can from VCs and IPOs.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:42PM (#34430046)
Have people gotten in trouble for breaking the fiduciary obligation by being nicer to workers? Has any one been in a serious chance for getting in trouble for being nicer to workers? I have always assumed this stuff is basically made up. It might be written somewhere, but no one is enforcing it. It appears to be greed and keeping the status quo.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:54PM (#34430235)
> Have people gotten in trouble for breaking the fiduciary obligation by being nicer to workers? Has any one been in a serious chance for getting in trouble for being nicer to workers?

Being nice to workers, and never returning money to shareholders because you're overpaying your workers are two entirely different things.

FAANG has treated their workers quite well for a 10+ years, and shareholders have not cared, because profits and growth have been enormous.

They could've treated their workers much better and paid them 2-3x as much money, though. But they didn't. Because they would've gotten sued by shareholders.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Apocryphon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#34430411)
> They could've treated their workers much better and paid them 2-3x as much money, though. But they didn't. Because they would've gotten sued by shareholders.

Probably not. Google makes $1.6 million in revenue per employee, and $400k in profit per employee. Wages in tech for these money printing companies are more set by arbitrary norms than any real financial basis.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/217489/revenue-per-emplo...

https://csimarket.com/stocks/GOOG-Income-per-Employee.html

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:07PM (#34443465)
The wages workers get aren’t because of lawsuit threats. I don’t follow that logic?

Compared to unions and socialist ideals, FAANG has treated workers okay because of the arbitrarily high income compared to when the working class gets even more exploited in other industries. Being better than bad situations doesn’t mean a good situation.

Some big tech companies were colluding to keep wages stagnant by not hiring workers at other companies. Wages were lower until the collision was uncovered and companies like Facebook came around and started paying more. Colluding against workers is not treating them well.

Pay and some stock options aren’t the only ways to treat workers better. Capitalism doesn’t have to control every part of why we are nice to other people.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Apocryphon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:45PM (#34430084)
How many tech companies have never turned a profit? Uber didn’t until 2021. Investors sure didn’t care about fiduciary obligations built on profit when interest rates were low.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:53AM (#34429254)
Long ago capitalism and then neoliberalism infected our brains. There’s no rational reason why any of these promises were made in the first place while still having people without health care or a home.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by w0m on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:24AM (#34427748)
The argument would be sustainability I believe.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:54AM (#34429269)
Microsoft will survive even if they never fire another person for years.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by coldpie on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:32PM (#34429876)
Microsoft spending $70B in cash this year is proof of that, in case anyone reading doubts the above statement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposed_acquisition_of_Activi...
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mikojan on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:16AM (#34427628)
Inflation has been attributed to rising profit margins[0]. Surely, you can take a jab at those who profitted at every step.

[0]: https://www.epi.org/blog/inflation-minimum-wages-and-profits...

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by unity1001 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:01AM (#34427416)
> The Federal Reserve wants to reduce wages by cooling the economy

There. Corrected.

https://mronline.org/2022/05/26/u-s-federal-reserve-says-its...

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by hnfong on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:25AM (#34428781)
Worse, they're actually sort of using unemployment rate as a benchmark on when the economy has cooled down and when to stop raising the rates.

eg. https://www.forbes.com/sites/dereksaul/2022/10/12/does-the-f...

It's politically incorrect to say the Fed is trying to make x% people lose their jobs but that's basically what they're scheming for the past year or so...

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by MSFT_Edging on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:38PM (#34429968)
Its politically incorrect because you're not supposed to say the quiet part out loud.

Our system relies on the fear of the bottom. Capital is in charge, they require the threat of destitution in order to continue to get away with their continued extraction. When wages go up, more power is vested in the worker which isn't okay by the folks at the top.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Ancalagon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @04:04PM (#34433039)
I didn't used to believe this but its actually true.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:01AM (#34427412)
People with health issues should still be able to purchase their existing insurance through COBRA, and, once that expires, through the public exchanges that are guaranteed to cover their existing condition. Thanks ACA.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Arainach on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:25AM (#34427767)
When I left Microsoft I believe the cost I was quoted for COBRA was thousands a month - not quite as much as my salary when I was working there but enough that it would have rapidly depleted my savings if I didn't find another job immediately.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Karunamon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:20AM (#34427692)
Entirely serious question: is COBRA actually of any use to anyone? From where I sit it's always been pretty aspirational since it requires you to also pay the employer side of the insurance which is colossally more expensive than the employee side, and you are expected to do this while being out of work?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by swozey on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:35AM (#34427940)
You can opt out of it (or not opt in) up until, I believe (and correct me if I'm wrong) for up to a year after leaving the job meaning that you can deny coverage UNLESS something major comes up then you pay from that point on. So it's useful for that event, some emergency coming up.

I've never paid for it, the one time I had it come up it was something like $800/mo for me as a single 20s laid off person. Not top priority.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by coredog64 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:42AM (#34428052)
There’s a hack for COBRA if you’re immediately switching jobs: Sign up for COBRA but don’t make the payments. If something really bad happens before coverage at your new employer kicks in, make the payments and the claims.

TL;DR: Treat COBRA as an options contract.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mcast on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:34PM (#34429897)
I thought COBRA benefits were retroactive? I was told you can sign up once you're at the hospital.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by galdosdi on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:44AM (#34428089)
It's useful for 60 days, since for 60 days (or maybe it's 90 or 30, I forget -- look it up yourself if you need it, don't listen to me) you can elect it retroactively. So you can go without insurance, and as long as you haven't hit the 60 days, you can retroactively pay for it if a devastating emergency happens. Actually dealing with this would be a huge logistical hassle, and god help you if you're hospitalized, unconscious, and can't file the paperwork or get someone else to, but at least you probably wouldn't go bankrupt.

Hopefully that buys you some more time to find a new job or line up an ACA plan if you're in a state with decent ACA plans, because actually paying for COBRA out of pocket for months at a time is indeed very expensive.

(It also would be totally worth it if you had existing expensive health care needs in your family)

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:54AM (#34428266)
That would explain why COBRA is so insanely expensive.... No one is buying it unless they retroactively needed it and thus the risk pool is sky high
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by sgerenser on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#34429341)
No, that’s not it. The cost is sky high because its the price that your employer, plus you normally pay. At tech companies in particular where the employer usually picks up 90-100% of the cost, it makes COBRA look crazy expensive when you suddenly have to pay 100% instead of 10%.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:03PM (#34429407)
I believe it; but is interesting in the context that I have purchased ACA plans on the open market comparable to my company insurance, and they were far far below the cobra price. For reference a basically identical ACA healthcare.gov plan I bought for ~1k when COBRA charged something around $3k.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notfromhere on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:16PM (#34434527)
ACA is subsidized, COBRA is not. That's where the huge price difference comes from.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:23PM (#34434606)
I was paying the full unsubsidized rate. Not the one for the poors where you earn less than X and you get a deal where taxes pay for part of it.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mynameishere on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:11AM (#34428541)
Just to be clear. Employees ARE paying that full amount while employed. It is part of their benefits. They don't feel the cost, but it is there all the same.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:06AM (#34427471)
> once that expires, through the public exchanges that are guaranteed to cover their existing condition. Thanks ACA.

The ACA just states that insurers can't refuse a customer who wants to purchase a plan just because they have a preexisting condition. It doesn't actually require that the plan cover treatment for said condition.

In many states - including wealthier deep blue states - the marketplace plan options are actually quite terrible.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:14AM (#34427599)
The HHS disagrees with you: https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/about-the-aca/pre-existing-co...

> Health insurers can no longer charge more or deny coverage to you or your child because of a pre-existing health condition like asthma, diabetes, or cancer, as well as pregnancy. They cannot limit benefits for that condition either. Once you have insurance, they can't refuse to cover treatment for your pre-existing condition.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:17AM (#34427652)
Doesn't this create a huge incentive for people to buy rolling "temporary" insurance plans which can consider pre-existing conditions, and then switch to subsidizing off the healthy once they actually get a condition and buy the regular ACA plans?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:22AM (#34427718)
You can only switch plans during the open enrollment window or in cases of specific life events. You can't arbitrarily change plans whenever you want.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:24AM (#34427757)
"Temporary" plans are 1-12 months so you can buy ones that last until the next open enrollment, and if you're healthy you buy another (12 month) temporary plan. If you develop a condition you buy the regular plan.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by vikingerik on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:06AM (#34428445)
Yes, and that's one reason why costs have ballooned so much, the need to subsidize people who didn't pay while they didn't have a condition and now do. The temporary plans aren't even necessary, if you can wait until the next regular enrollment period.

The ACA originally tried to hide that vulnerability by making insurance mandatory, then it appeared when that forcible mandate was repealed.

Edit to reply to the reply: Right, it's not insurance. Insurance is pooling risk. If you wait until the risk event has already happened, it's not insurance, it's just paying your own costs with extra steps.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:12AM (#34428565)
... so we have the worst of both worlds. Insurers are forced to take pre-existing conditions, but you can wait until you have a condition before buying it.

I don't think that's even "insurance" at that point....

America may quite possible have the absolute dumbest system humanly possible.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by willcipriano on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:13PM (#34429574)
The best part? The US spends more per captia than any other OECD nation on socialized medicine. The United Kingdom's NHS costs around half, per capita and delivers universal coverage.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by notch656c on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:15PM (#34429598)
Yeah. As a a pretty hardcore ancap who hates socialized anything, I'll still take NHS over our current system. Anything is better than our current bastardized system.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:24AM (#34427758)
No, you are misreading it. They cannot limit benefits due to your condition, but that doesn't mean that they have to cover treatment for your condition.

If you have a disease or syndrome, the treatments for that condition (whether pharmaceutical, outpatient, or inpatient) may simply not be on the list of benefits provided by the insurance plans offered.

It's legally distinct from, but analogous to, a nodiscrimination clause. They can't refuse to cover your mammogram (which they cover for everyone else) just because your initial diagnosis for Vamipiric Brain Syndrome occurred before your plan went into effect. But they can choose to say they they don't cover Nosferatudone for anyone (when Nosferatudone happens to be the only effective treatment for Vamipiric Brain Syndrome).

(There are, separately, certain treatments that all insurance plans must cover by law, although that's separate from the ACA, and it's a very limited set).

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:41AM (#34428020)
Yes, you're always able to buy a bad health insurance plan. But you're also able to buy a good health insurance plan, and your pre-existing condition won't impact the price of the good insurance plan.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:49AM (#34428193)
> Yes, you're always able to buy a bad health insurance plan. But you're also able to buy a good health insurance plan,

If one exists, and as I stated in the original post, in many states, even the best plans available on the marketplace are quite terrible. And that's a problem that's actually gotten worse in recent years, not better, as plans have left the exchange (and providers have dropped marketplace plans from their networks).

> and your pre-existing condition won't impact the price of the good insurance plan.

Your "pre-existing condition" won't impact the price of the insurance plan relative to others who are purchasing that same plan, but you quite likely will be in a situation where the "good" (eg, gold) plans are the only ones which will provide the coverage that you need, and those are the most expensive ones. This satisfies the letter of the law, but in practice it still means that often people with chronic health condition either are are forced to pay more for coverage or are literally unable to get coverage for their conditions at all (because none of the marketplace plans will cover it).

The protections provided by the ACA are much more narrow than you're portraying them as, which is understandable because it's a common misconception about how the ACA operates, but it's unfortunately a very important distinction.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @04:26PM (#34433323)
Do you have any evidence that the plans aren't sufficient? Others in the thread have mentioned they have gotten nearly identical plans to their old employer plans. People I know who buy their own health insurance have totally adequate coverage, and this is in a "blue northeast state" that, according to you, has inadequate options.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @05:09PM (#34433833)
> Others in the thread have mentioned they have gotten nearly identical plans to their old employer plans.

One person said this, without mentioning either their state or any details of their previous plan.

> a "blue northeast state" that, according to you, has inadequate options.

I did not say that every "blue, northeast state" has "inadequate options". I said that many states have terrible options, and that, contrary to the stereotype of ACA issues being limited to poorer red states that refused to expand Medicare, this set includes wealthier blue states.

> Do you have any evidence that the plans aren't sufficient?

You stated that "public exchanges are guaranteed to cover their existing condition", an assertion of universality. This is completely false, for reasons that I have explained. The federal statues guaranteeing coverage for individual conditions are incredibly narrow and exclude both the most expensive conditions for patients, as well as almost all expenses for chronic conditions.

Furthermore, it's very easy to disprove this assertion of universality, because it's incredibly easy to find counterexamples - the ACA has been around for a decade, and there are tons of forum posts all over the past ten years from people struggling to find non-COBRA coverage that continues to match their needs after losing a job. A marketplace plan cannot deny you an insurance plan for a preexisting condition, but that doesn't mean that there exists a marketplace plan that will cover it.

The fact that you happen to know people who are satisfied with their coverage for themselves is neither here nor there, because it does not contradict the main point: the ACA is no guarantee that people losing their jobs will actually have any non-COBRA options to address their health needs (and given that Microsoft has pretty comprehensive insurance and employs people in nearly every state, it's all but certain that the marketplace options will be appreciably worse for many of those people than the status quo).

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @08:30PM (#34435619)
Wow, a lot of words and not a shred of evidence that some blue northeast states have inadequate coverage. Yes, some blue states having adequate coverage does not mean all such states have adequate coverage. However, you have provided absolutely no evidence of inadequate coverage in a blue northeast state. So what do we know? At least some blue northeast states, and maybe all blue northeast states, definitely have adequate coverage.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @08:52PM (#34435783)
Let's be clear: you made a bold claim without evidence. I responded with an explanation of why your claim is incorrect, based on the actual text of the law which defines the terms. I also provided specific examples of the differences, which are in the post you just responded to.

At no point have you provided any actual evidence, other than an unsourced offhand anecdote (which I addressed), to support your bold initial claim.

I've taken the time to provide much more in the way of both evidence and explication than you have presented. If you'd like more, then perhaps first you can provide some concrete evidence to support the scope of your original, claim, and also address the specific examples that I revealed which refute the premise of your claim.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by rcme on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:17PM (#34435948)
The only who has made a claim here is you: your claim is that the ACA's guarantee of pre-existing condition coverage doesn't matter because there exists places that only have inadequate healthcare options available for purchase. You have provided no evidence for this claim.

Others here have provided first-hand accounts of acquiring adequate coverage on exchanges.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by giaour on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#34428117)
The ACA has "minimum value" requirements and defines what constitute "essential health benefits" that plans must include to satisfy the ACA's coverage requirements and be eligible for sale on healthcare.gov or state-level marketplaces: https://www.healthinsurance.org/obamacare/essential-health-b...
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:54AM (#34428274)
> The ACA has "minimum value" requirements and defines what constitute "essential health benefits" that plans must include to satisfy the ACA's coverage requirements and be eligible for sale on healthcare.gov or state-level marketplaces

Yes, I'm well aware of that, and those requirements are incredibly bare-bones. Nearly any insurance provided by employers far exceeds those requirements, whereas the same cannot be said for insurance provided on the marketplace.

This post is about people who are losing employer-provided insurance, and there's almost no universe in which the non-COBRA options available to most of those people aren't markedly worse than what they're losing, even if we ignore the increased cost of self-purchased insurance.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by foogazi on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#34428122)
> But they can choose to say they they don't cover Nosferatudone for anyone

Does private employer insurance not have the same limitations?

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by chimeracoder on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:52AM (#34428235)
> Does private employer insurance not have the same limitations?

Yes, but insurance sold to private employers is a completely different market, and it is almost universally better than the insurance plans available on the exchanges.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by nblgbg on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @04:59PM (#34433729)
When you enroll in COBRA, you are responsible for paying both the employer's contribution and your own contribution. This can amount to thousands of dollars per month. It may be more cost-effective to consider state insurance options or those available on healthcare.gov. I took COBRA in the past and I know about this.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by listless on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:10AM (#34427528)
I understand the frustration here. But the same system that takes away so much also gives so very very much. There is no system that is only upside.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by monero-xmr on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:02AM (#34427427)
Ah yes, the “let’s force companies to become unprofitable” theory. I think Venezuela and Argentina are good places for you.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by whatever1 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:08AM (#34427499)
Companies have externalities (environmental, societal etc) from their operations, and someone pays for them.

You can close your eyes and cheer about profitability, but the bill is coming anyway.

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by yokoprime on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:24AM (#34427755)
Plenty of profitable companies in Europe. It might be easier to become profitable in the US since you have less of a safety net, but that's a price US voters are willing to pay. Pointing to corrupt developing countries whenever socialized healthcare is brought up is disingenuous.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by mardifoufs on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:13PM (#34429566)
Do you think european corporations don't do mass layoffs? What is this completely false view of europe so many seem to have?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Apocryphon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:37PM (#34429953)
People at the risk of suddenly losing their health insurance start to envy countries where that doesn’t happen
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by leet_thow on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:11AM (#34427550)
Nice, edgy comment bro
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by refurb on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:12AM (#34428564)
I mean you could change the laws so that you get a job for life.

Of course the countries with those laws have never created a company like MS in the first place, so..

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:57AM (#34429320)
American companies/privilege benefit from the US being the hegemonic imperialist power of the world while screwing over the Global South. Domestic America has arguably never created a company like MS either.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by Apocryphon on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:36PM (#34429935)
Even without such laws, doesn’t the corporate culture in Japan foster jobs for life, and they have plenty of megacorps akin to Microsoft?
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:20AM (#34428699)
Whew, are you for lifetime employment? Look what that did to Japan.

>>people with health issues will be on their own

Maybe the US sorts this sheet out, really about time

Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by geodel on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:36PM (#34429932)
Yes, the other system is so much better.
Re:Microsoft Lays Off 10k (5%) Workers by dehrmann on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:37PM (#34429947)
These sound like problems for government to solve.