News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by obblekk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:26AM (#34231007)
9mo from the start of the Ukrainian war.

For all the criticism modern governments get (often rightly) it’s incredible how fast Germany built these new terminals.

And it does show we have just as much productive capacity in western societies today as we did 100 years ago. What’s missing is consensus that problems should actually be solved, not used to enrich yet another rentier class.

I hope Germany learns from this and keeps away some of the barriers to growth they regulated into existence.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by albertzeyer on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:34AM (#34231073)
I don't really have any idea, but maybe building such terminals is way easier than building other things like nuclear reactors or whatever?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by toomuchtodo on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:43AM (#34231174)
Floating terminals can be relocated anywhere in the world on short notice. It’s an LNG processor with a ship built around it. They’re also cheap, typically ~$50M-$100M/year to lease.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Archelaos on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:17AM (#34233386)
Of course, but nevertheless it was fast. It should be noted, however, that what has been built so far is only a precursor to a "real" terminal that has yet to be built. And that environmental concerns have not been adequately considered due to the hasty implementation. The special circumstances caused by the failures of previous governments have also prompted the Green Party, under whose ministerial initiative the construction took place, to prioritise speed over thoroughness. However, due to these special circumstances and the previous negligence, this case is not suitable as a general recommendation for the future.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by bamboozled on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:30AM (#34231036)
Would be nice if they did the same thing with Nuclear and Renewables though wouldn't it?

Some how they can "go to war" for gas, but when it comes to climate change it's, "meh"?

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Luc on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:42AM (#34231163)
Fifty years of anti-nuclear movement has left its mark.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tgv on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:50AM (#34231252)
If the best retort the nuclear industry had was a Russian-Ukrainian war, then it's not so odd to see why.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by zmgsabst on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:06AM (#34231420)
Actual retorts:

- we don’t have the mineral supplies for other non-fossil options

- nuclear has a better safety record, all in

- nuclear doesn’t require we do business with cobalt slavers

- nuclear can supply the base load

- nuclear produces rare elements that help with advanced medicine

But you can’t reason people out of a position they didn’t reason themselves into, and many people were raised in a green-washed death cult. Like most religious people, they uncritically repeat that faith and become angered if you point out the inconsistencies.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by flir on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:20AM (#34231609)
> nuclear has a better safety record, all in

Better than... wind turbines? Solar panels? Hydroelectric?

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by jefftk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:34AM (#34231793)
The safety profile of hydro and nukes are dominated by large rare events, which makes prediction tricky. Hydro is much less safe historically because of a single event: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Banqiao_Dam_failure

Wind and solar don't have catastrophic failures, but people installing and repairing them do sometimes fall. Residential rooftop solar is especially bad here, since the deaths are divided over a relatively small amount of generation capacity. Still, overall wind and solar are safer than nukes, and data sources saying otherwise generally are using pre-Fukushima stats.

More: https://ourworldindata.org/nuclear-energy#what-are-the-safes...

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by prottog on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:55AM (#34232100)
> data sources saying otherwise generally are using pre-Fukushima stats.

I thought only one person died as a direct result of the Fukushima meltdown? And the other deaths attributed to it were due to poor handling of the people who evacuated; basically frail people dying in temporary shelters, unrelated to the nuclear aspect.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by jefftk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:12AM (#34232339)
That's right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...

I had thought that counting evacuation deaths was correct, since I'd thought the evacuation was to reduce the risk if far more radiation was released. But reading up on it now, it seems like the evacuation was after the risk of that was over, and was in response to the current levels of radiation? In which case it looks like a large overreaction.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by moloch-hai on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:03AM (#34232222)
It has always been easy to lie with statistics. The "one" figure is such a lie, easy to parrot.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by rhn_mk1 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:26AM (#34233544)
This is a serious accusation. Show the truth.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Arnt on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @03:40PM (#34237691)
The "one" figure ignores deaths caused by evacuation SNAFUs. But if some event causes an evacuation and the evacuation has a normal number of mishaps, then that event causes those mishaps. Evacuations are rare and happen under unusual circumstances, they will suffer from SNAFUs.

You can't cause an evacuation, expect that it'll go perfectly and deny any responsibility when it doesn't.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:02PM (#34234164)
Old stats is the answer, but not because of Nuclear.

The wind and solar industries are ramping exponentially, and the death rates are usually done per TWh generated. The solar deaths are heavily weighted towards the start (mining, installation) while the energy produced lags and accumulates over decades.

The stats used to show that rooftop solar was slightly more dangerous that nuclear per TWh, but the number is dropping faster for solar so it's not been true for years.

The slighlty more important point is how far ahead nuclear solar and wind are, compared with fossil fuels. It's a stark difference.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:33PM (#34239696)
The nuclear stat is missing all the deaths of miners and people living near mines and old tailings dumps.

Similarly solar is missing all the silver (and past Cd/Te/In/etc miners) miners and people dealing with pollution and wind is missing knock on effects from rare earths and PFCs (nuclear may also be, but we don't get any public info on the LCA of UF6 production or what modern centrifuges are made of).

The first is ongoing however, and the second is decreasing exponentially.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @05:03AM (#34243903)
I believe these stats do include mining materials for nuclear and renewables, though I've not double checked recently.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by benj111 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @03:23PM (#34237440)
I think if you die as a result of an evacuation from a nuclear incident, that should count in the death toll of that nuclear incident.

They wouldnt be dead if there weren't a nuclear incident, so....

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by trashtester on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @04:52AM (#34243835)
People forget that the "evacuation" happened after (and because of) a tsunami/earthquake that killed 20000 people. That was the real root cause of all the deaths.

The immediate cause of most off the "evacuation" deaths, was that a large number of very old people were exposed to moderate amounts of stress due to being relocated which caused them to die slighly before what they might otherwise have. (Kind of like when we count terminal cancer patients as dying "from Covid" if they had covid when dying).

For these people, there was no medical reason to relocate them in the large majority of cases. If you're 80+, a few MSv of exposure has no effect on you life expectancy, since you will die from other sources long before any cancer can develop.

In other words, very few years of expected life were lost, and those that WERE lost, was almost entirly due to a huge overraction to whatever increase in radiation there may have been. Which, I would argue, should primarily be blamed on anti-nuclear fear-mongering propaganda.

Imagine a racist couple living in a suburb when a Mexican family moves in to the next-door house, stressing them out. If the racist husband dies from a stress related illness after that, I would argue it was his racism that killed him, not the Mexican family.

Spreading excessive (as in actual misinformation) anti-nuclear propaganda is like spreading such racism or similar forms of prejudice or bigotry. It doesn't matter if it's Greenpeace or Tucker that spreads the propaganda.

The fact is that the Fukushima plants were built at a time when the only alternative was coal. Had they never been built, Japan would have built coal plants with the same capacity at the same time.

Given the amount of toxic polution caused by old coal plants over such a time span, I'm sure Nuclear Power in Japan has saved 10s if not 100s of thousands of lives to date, even before counting any damage from global warming.

And Japan is STILL building new coal plants, partly because of the anti-nuclear propaganda, which will continue to cause harm long into the future.

If anything, the vast majority of deaths that will happen as a consequence of the Fukushima incident, will be due to several countries shutting down (or failing to build) nuclear plants while still relying on large amounts of dirty fossil fuels, in many cases still including coal/lignite.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by benj111 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @11:10AM (#34247306)
I'm not sure it's tenable to just evacuate young people from a radiation zone. There still needs to be people to service the old people's needs.

I do take your point, I interpreted the parent to mean that the reason for the evacuation was radiation. In that case I'd still maintain that the deaths should be attributable to the nuclear incident.

Agreed man years lost may be a better measure. I'm not sure what the morality is Vis a vis valuing a young person's life more that an old person, as a society though, we seem to have come the conclusion that an old person's life is more valuable than it should rationally be.

I don't think it's reasonable to resort to whataboutism. Yes nuclear energy has probably saved lives overall, but it still costs lives. If a plane crashed should we accept the people died due to the plane crash or should we discuss how it's much safer than driving?

I suppose half the problem is that humans are bad at evaluating risks. So I'm not averse to contextualising the risk, but the contextualising cart shouldn't be put before the actual quantified risk horse.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:06PM (#34235197)
Construction deaths are added to wind and solar, but people don't add mining and construction deaths to nuclear (that said, they don't add it for hydro either).
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by mrob on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:35AM (#34231803)
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by mensetmanusman on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:28AM (#34231713)
Due to installation deaths, PV has higher deaths per kWhr install: https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw...
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by jefftk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:35AM (#34231809)
Note that your source is specifically "rooftop solar", not solar overall.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by krzyk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:43AM (#34233846)
Wind turbines are a bit loud, and there is a reason why they can't be placed near places where people leave.

Hydroelectric - if it is a damn, then again, there is a possibility of the damn breaking and flooding.

Solar is the real alternative, but not effective enough, yet.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by lostlogin on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:13PM (#34235310)
I think it’s ‘dam’ in this, as opposed to ‘damn’ where something is condemned.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:32AM (#34231760)
"- nuclear can supply the base load"

Looking over the border to France, can it? The forecasted load factor for French nuclear power generation this year is 51.5% and the energy there is probably the most expensive in whole of Europe.

https://mastodon.energy/@Sustainable2050/109625562357246897

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by snehk on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#34232816)
The most recent (complete data) we have shows that electricity prices in France are below EU and Euro zone average: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:06AM (#34233222)
Those are household prices, pretty much irrelevant in this case as they are decided by national regulators and often subsidised. Have a look at wholesale prices. Those were around 1000e/MWh between August and November: https://mobile.twitter.com/Emericdevigan/status/160997302993...
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by rolenthedeep on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:09AM (#34233268)
I'm not sure what point you're trying to make here.

Nuclear is an ideal base load provider because nuclear plants really like to run 100% of the time, only shutting down for refueling or maintenance. Which is exactly what you want to meet a demand that exists 100% of the time.

If you have enough generation, nuclear is an ideal base load provider.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:15AM (#34233365)
That's exactly the counterpoint I'm trying to make: a lot of French reactors were and are down "for maintenance", making it very much not the ideal base, or any, load provider. That's something we never hear from nuclear power proponents, why?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:28AM (#34233579)
My understanding is France's electricity issues are mostly due to shutting down all their gas and coal power plants.

As a result, the confluence of maintenance and safety updates to the nuclear fleet are a greater issue effecting supply than they otherwise would be.

Compare USA in 2021, nuclear provided 19% of electricity while having only 8% of total nameplate capacity.

https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/what-generation-capacity

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by xg15 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:39AM (#34233767)
Many french power plants use nearby rivers as a source of coolant. A big issue last summer was that rivers carried not enough water to reliably provide cooling.

Thanks to climate change, this situation will likely become more common in the future.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by trashtester on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @05:29AM (#34244043)
France's electrical grid has a vastly lower climate footprint than, for instance, Germany's, due to the nuclear plants. If it turns out that water supply remains and issue in future years (and was not just a fluke), I expect they will find ways around that (either by allowing sligtly warmer spill water or by using hydro dams to store more energy for the summer.

Anyway, Germany and France are essentially the same grid, so differences in consumer prices tend to be determined largly by transport costs and the costs of neighboring countries.

German power gets cheap when they can import from Scandinavia, Poland and Central Europe, and expensive when they have to export to those. French power is similarly affected by imports/exports to Spain, Italy and the UK.

If you want to compare nuclear costs to other sources, you have to look at production costs for PLANNABLE energy for a conglomerate of sources, adjusted for risks and externalities (dry spells, reliance on dictatorships or other unstable or adverserial countries, market prices for commodities, pollution and climate change, etc).

If you adjust for all externalities, especially polution and climate change, I'm convinced French electrical production is far, far cheaper per stable GW of output than Germany's.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:47PM (#34234925)
Everything needs maintenance. That doesn't mean it's not the best base load provider.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:51PM (#34236039)
Sure. And as a result, the EU country with most nuclear plants had the most expensive energy production during last year.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:46PM (#34239807)
Burning gas is certainly cheaper. Let's hope it doesn't run out, pollute the earth, or fund a war.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:35AM (#34243384)
That does not change the fact that nuclear plants are currently failing at providing sufficient baseload capacity in the one EU country that has the most of them.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @04:57AM (#34243868)
Yes, that's true. You're misinterpreting that fact. That's the problem. France wants to extend the lifetime of fully depreciated reactors, and hasn't provisioned enough capacity to do all the maintenance required. That could happen with any generation method.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @05:55AM (#34244180)
Yet it has happened with this generation method. In fact the problem has more causes: France has stopped investing in new nuclear plants, in part because they felt safe the old plants will continue to work as usual which they won't as we see, but also because their new EPR design is a complete failure. The Flamanville EPR plant was scheduled to go productive in 2012. It's 2023 and it still isn't. Olkiluoto, another EPR in Finland went briefly productive in 2022 but soon new faults were discovered. And don't even look at the cost overruns for these plants.

So the current situation is EDF will be nationalized to avoid going bankrupt, and who knows when and if the stress corrosion issue with older reactors will be resolved. Let's just hope there will be enough water in the rivers and reservoirs for them to use, because the droughts are worsening. Meanwhile the EPR reactors are still not working and their construction company Areva was taken over by EDF to avoid going bankrupt.

But I do not live in France, I live in Slovakia and we have another nuclear plant under construction, Mochovce 3. Mochovce 3 construction was restarted in 2008, to be finished in 2014. It's 2023 and any time now it should be finally going productive, after a 15 year construction and about 300% cost overruns. And the energy company may have to be saved by the state as a result.

And these are not exceptions, it's the same for Hinkley Point C in the UK and probably other new plants at least in Europe as well.

So it's very strange when someone writes about stable and cheap nuclear energy production and somehow never mentions current huge issues with it.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @06:58AM (#34244548)
They're definitely expensive and difficult to build. But they are excellent base load providers, which was the point.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @08:49AM (#34245460)
And the point is wrong if you have to wait 15 years and go bankrupt for excellent baseload (and whether the whole baseload thing makes sense at all is also a very good question) that may or may not work depending on water availability.

Especially if you have alternatives, and it looks like we could build a lot of renewables and storage combined with say green hydrogen or ammonia. With lower risk and gradually. And not spend the next 100 years and countless billions decommisioning them.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @10:05AM (#34246302)
What you're saying seems to confuse three things:

- the econonmic situation right now

- a possible future where storage is better

- the general case that's being stated, which is that nuclear is currently the best base load tech, unless you like burning gas.

I'm only talking about the latter.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @11:28AM (#34247621)
But then it looks like it is the best base load tech, until someone actually tries to build it. Then it becomes a huge commitment and a burden for >100 years (20y planning, permissions, building + 60y lifetime + ???y decommissioning and waste management).

What if storage (or hydrogen/ammonia storage and peakers) is already good enough, but we are not building it because we are blinded by the empty promises of nuclear utopia? I guess we will see in a few years as the first efforts of this type go online.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by robertlagrant on Thursday January 05, 2023 @07:50PM (#34269395)
I can't understand the mindset that says nuclear has been some sort of overwhelming force in power generation. It's been the most tentatively adopted generation tech in history; we've ignored the guaranteed radiation of coal mining while we've had endless worry about nuclear power.

We've pumped a huge amount of money and time into talking about and researching and building renewables, with a much smaller promise of return. Which is fine, but it seems very surprising to speculate that popular nuclear has overshadowed poor unpopular renewables.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by tpm on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:33AM (#34309615)
> it seems very surprising to speculate that popular nuclear has overshadowed poor unpopular renewables.

Depends on your social circles or information sources I guess. What I get from mine (including HN) is that nuclear power is the correct technocratic solution to the world's problems. It has no downsides. Meanwhile renewables are ugly and not worth the investment. And I am only exaggerating a little.

> We've pumped a huge amount of money and time into talking about and researching and building renewables, with a much smaller promise of return.

I don't understand this, and also don't agree with it. The yearly new photovoltaic installed capacity is reaching hundreds of GWp. Even with a load factor of 15% it's adding much more capacity than we ever could with current nuclear technologies. And also much cheaper. The typically conservative IEA predicts new 600 GWp/year in 2030, but already in 2022 the world has added 268 GWp (according to BNEF) and will hit over 300 this year. Yes, the storage and smarter grids need attention. But overall renewables are absolutely worth the money and time they get.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Workaccount2 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:49AM (#34232006)
I honestly don't blame people who grew up in the shadow of Chernobyl (some literally) who are critical of nuclear.

They're wrong, but I understand completely where their fear comes from.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by donny2018 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:29AM (#34232617)
That fear could be easily dealt with by stopping unfounded anti-nuclear fearmongering and a tiny bit of education.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ethbr0 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:37AM (#34233724)
When you get things like "Activists have protested the arrival of [tanker LNG] acquired through fracking", during an energy crisis, it seems fair to point out that some people are just unreasonable.

Environmentalism's greatest enemy has been environmentalists.

Teddy Roosevelt et al. were able to get more done because they played realpolitik, and realized that getting 50% of what you want, even if you have to hold your nose at some compromises, is better than getting 100% of what you oppose.

If anti-nuclear protesters were serious about ranking their worries, they'd be supporting the IAEA trying to cordon off the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Station from the war ASAP.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by megaman821 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:54AM (#34234026)
So every nuclear capable nation on Earth is ruled by this fear cabal? What else can this powerful cabal do, end world hunger or colonize the moon?

If nuclear was everything it proponents claimed it to be, there would be at least one country on Earth going all in on them. Nuclear is useful in the power mix but it's value is way overstated. It is not an economical choice, if it was no amount of lobbying would stop them from being built. Coal usage did not decrease due to intense environment lobbying, but only when cheaper alternatives were available.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by sebzim4500 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:30PM (#34234631)
>What else can this powerful cabal do, end world hunger or colonize the moon

The combined money lobbying power of energy companies could almost certainly end world hunger. Probably not colonize the moon but certainly establish a permanent base.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:38PM (#34239748)
Need to keep it to a tiny bit, mind you.

Lest they find out that attempts to keep attention on reactors are a diversion from the real harms.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by microtherion on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#34232031)
> nuclear doesn’t require we do business with cobalt slavers

Uranium does not exactly get pooped out by sparkly unicorns either:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_p...

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Gud on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:55AM (#34233049)
My home country Sweden has plenty of Uranium but it is forbidden to extract it. And this is the problem for the nuclear industry - due to political road blocks, everything is unnecessarily expensive and difficult.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by geysersam on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:08PM (#34234251)
Uranium mining has adverse side effects to the local environment. Few want an uranium mine in their area.

You could also say: uranium mining is incredibly expensive, and we're not willing to pay the cost, so we import it from countries where the cost is paid by someone else.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Gud on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:42PM (#34234842)
It is not banned because it’s expensive, it’s banned because of political reasons. Sweden are great with large scale mining.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by geysersam on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:12PM (#34239498)
It's expensive in terms of the external costs. That's the reason why it's banned.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Gud on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:45PM (#34242125)
The external costs can be mitigated.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by geysersam on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @02:11AM (#34242937)
Perhaps to some extent. But then the extraction becomes more expensive.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Gud on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @06:29AM (#34244380)
Of course. But I’d rather pay more for the Uranium mining than pay outrageous electricity prices
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Pet_Ant on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:09AM (#34233280)
I mean this would be a good thing for Canada and Australia. I wonder with increased demand could they scale up and to be the main, ethical, sources.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:14AM (#34233343)
Besides the obvious malodorous actors, Iran and Russia, what's wrong with that list in your opinion?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by microtherion on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @04:52PM (#34238617)
Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan are hardly beacons of liberty, and might be susceptible to Russian pressure (though they may be more independent than I give them credit for), Namibia and Niger might not have mining standards superior to current Cobalt producers and China is China.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:44PM (#34239790)
The best defense nigerian uranium mining has against slavery allegations is Uranium ore's abysmal energy density.

It would take an artisinal miner years or decades to gather a kg of uranium. They'd produce more electricity on a bicycle generator.

Which is not to say that they're paid well or given PPE or that radon levels are monitored, or that the tailings dams are kept to any sort of safety standards.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by p1mrx on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:02PM (#34235136)
Would it really be so bad for Europe to depend on Australia and Canada for fuel? In theory, a single cargo ship delivery could power the entire continent for a year.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:57AM (#34232137)
Only the last is remotely related to reality in 2022, and existing reactors produce plenty.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by brightball on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:12AM (#34233317)
The tail end of your post takes away from otherwise valid points IMO.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by xg15 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:18AM (#34233424)
> nuclear has a better safety record, all in

If you use the pretty tortured metric "human lives lost per KWh energy produced" then yes (as of now). You know what would have an even better safety record according to that metric? Chucking the earth into the sun.

> nuclear doesn’t require we do business with cobalt slavers

Indeed we don't. We just ask the russians for it.

https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/europe-highly-dependent...

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by matthewdgreen on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:52AM (#34233989)
I am 100% in favor of any technology that allows us to stop emitting CO2 in a short time-frame, including nuclear. My reservation about the pro-nuclear (online) argument is that it always seems to be framed more as an excuse to "punch some hippies" than as a serious effort to calculate the cost of deploying nuclear at scale, let alone an effort to marshal political opinion to a state that would allow for any of it to happen.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by asmor on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:23PM (#34234501)
I've resigned myself to hoping France makes new investments so we can just buy it from them on the market. Nuclear isn't happening in Germany. Barely anyone in the anti-nuclear movement is willing to have a discussion beyond "Chernobyl was bad, THTR was a huge failure and waste disposal is a problem I will accept nothing but a perfect solution on".
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by RGamma on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:06PM (#34236343)
What are current feasible, sustainable solutions to long-term nuclear waste storage? Any pointers?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by asmor on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:50PM (#34237000)
All I know is that I'm more comfortable burying some extra waste next to the stuff we already have to bury somewhere (like Onkalo) than burn more fossil fuels. Trading long term for short term isn't the best, but I don't really see anything else getting us off a track to further global ecological devastation you couldn't cause with nuclear waste even if you were trying.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by throw0101c on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @04:57PM (#34238669)
> What are current feasible, sustainable solutions to long-term nuclear waste storage? Any pointers?

Bury it in geologically stable areas.

At some point: it will cool down on its own, or technology will be developed to re-use it in an economically-amiable fashion and we can bring it back up. We know how to re-process it [1] but no body really wants to pay for that.

As it stands: before we start worrying about what happens to nuclear "waste" 500+ years in the future, we have to get through the next 100 years and all the issues that climate change is causing right now.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_Hague_site

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ouid on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:19PM (#34234416)
You are the first person I have ever heard present this sentiment.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:49PM (#34236996)
Yeah I've never heard of it, either. I haven't even really seen hippies in the opposition. They're just normal people who, as soon as they hear the word "nuclear", panic really hard and refuse to receive any new information that would actually address their concerns.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Arnt on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @03:03PM (#34237196)
Try it. Say my concern is that the relevant nuclear operators are organisationally similar to TEPCO. Give me some new information that either explains how they are different, or explains that an organisation like TEPCO is well suited to run a nuclear reactor safely.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @04:17PM (#34238195)
You're kind of proving my point here. Your concern is that an operator can be unsafe, which is valid and will always be true. So no, I won't argue against your contrived framing.

The only true fix would be a reactor and fuel design that can't melt down. A walk-away safe design that, even if you intentionally induced the worst disaster, still wouldn't pose a real threat to the public. Then it wouldn't matter if the operator was a cartoon villain determined to destroy the city.

This is the part that people still don't want to hear. Educating people on how it could work doesn't help because when they run out of unaddressed concerns, they just circle back to old concerns that were already addressed. For nuclear to be accepted, it needs better public messaging, because ultimately people are reacting emotionally rather than thinking critically.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @06:28PM (#34239643)
> For nuclear to be accepted, it needs better public messaging, because ultimately people are reacting emotionally rather than thinking critically.

A great start would be not consistently lying about everything until the lies are indisputably proven and then pretending it never happened every single time about everything for over 70 years.

Demonstrate a walkaway safe pebble bed reactor or similar that doesn't break down constantly or start leaking unsustainable levels of Kr-85. Remediate the hundreds of contaminated mines, spills and processing sites that the buck is being passed on. Stop demanding unlimited indemnity from any accident exceeding a pittance. Actually tell the truth about contamination events and levels entailed in standard practise ahead of time. Allow actually independent third parties rather than industry bodies to confirm claims on site, and estimate costs that are somewhere in the ballpark of reality with no backroom 'service' contracts. Stop pretending you've 'solved' waste by gathering a quarter of the money required and saying "we'll probably bury the SNF somewhere", don't worry about all the low level and intermediate waste. Demonstrate the existence of a viable fuel source or breeding program that isn't walking a tight rope on the edge of prompt criticality. Demonstrate a reprocessing process that doesn't push an entire continent's coastlines to 5% of safe limits whilst producing barely enough fuel to run about 2GW of reactors.

Then it's worth considering as something that isn't just another scam.

Until that point the oligopily of the nuclear industry should be rightly treated as a bunch of craven ghouls who are having a tantrum because they were held to account and didn't get to hoard billions whilst killing millions of people like the coal barons did.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:56PM (#34240941)
I'm not a marketing person. I have no idea how they'll address past bad behavior, dispel common myths, or educate about fundamentally new technologies that eliminate old problems. I'm just saying they'll eventually have to do it.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:03PM (#34241002)
The alternative is we ignore the entire cesspit and acknowledge that accepting 2-5% of energy being provided by fossil fuels in a small minority of countries until storage matures is better than putting everything on hold and hoping that gifting a few trillion dollars to people who have done nothing but scam will work better.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:58PM (#34241418)
You've lost me.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:11PM (#34241931)
There's a much better solution than sitting and pretending nuclear is going to save the day. Let's use that.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @01:13AM (#34242607)
Is this another tactic to reject nuclear, or are you just wandering off-topic?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @02:15AM (#34242959)
You're pretending the option is fossil fuels or nuclear like every other concern troll. Never has been because nuclear is incapable of solving the problem.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @09:45AM (#34246048)
You're illustrating the problem I described originally. When it's time to discus nuclear, people like you can't do it. You deflected by changing the subject to comparing different energy sources.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:52AM (#34256549)
Refusing to acknowledge your attempt to force the conversation into a very narrow framing where the true source of risk and harm is ignored isn't deflecting. And your last point is incredibly disingenuous. Having a nuclear reactor isn't an end, having energy is. Refusing to acknowledge the existence of alternatives and that they beat your proposal on its supposed merits is the inabity to have a discussion.

This is an incredibly transparent attempt to frame a conversation in such a way that the only possible avenue of discussion is how long we have to sit on our thumbs and wait for a gen IV nuclear reactor to materialise whilst ignoring the absolute failure of any previous designs to deliver on their promise of cheap, clean, abundant, or safe power.

Your gaslighting is not as subtle as you think it is. Refusing to believe nuclear advocates isn't 'panic' or irrational when the lies have been so consistent for wellover three generations that assuming the opposite of what you say is a much better strategy for coming to correct conclusions than believing you.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @07:13AM (#34258670)
The fact that you're looking for a fight with me is ridiculous. Read my other comments in this thread because I'm not going to repeat myself. It's such a chore to explain to anti-nuclear people that I don't want to force nuclear on them.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:20AM (#34259193)
In your mind, I'm trying to convince you to accept a risk that's unacceptable to you. But I'm not. I don't want to change your risk-tolerance.

It's very laborious to explain that to vehemently anti-nuclear people. Please read my other comment in this thread, because I'm not going to repeat myself.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34248266

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @10:14AM (#34260715)
No. You're trying to shift the focus away from reality and on to an imaginary world where an industry that has consistently lied and done the worst thing they can get away with will do the right thing if we stop holding them to account. And where the very real externalities at mines and fabrication plants and enrichment plants and reprocessing plants that have been accumulating since the 50s are not allowed to be spoken about. And where there will never be an actually bad accident in spite of the yearly near misses and frequent events that 'can never happen'. And where the promises of reactors that exist on paper will come true despite that being the opposite of what happened every single other time.

And you're positioning dealing with this as necessary due to an imagined need that can't be better solved with alternatives.

And instead of acknowledging the industry's unbroken history of gaslighting and lies you are positioning anything other than credulous paying of the scammers to continue doing nothing other than grift as an unfounded panic.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @10:40AM (#34261227)
Either you haven't read the comment like I asked, or you're wilfully ignoring me. Again, I don't want to change your risk-tolerance. Do you understand what that means?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:02PM (#34262831)
I understand perfectly what it means. You're continuing to try to paint any objection as an unfounded fear of an extremely rare event given the assumption that there is no mismanagement or corruption or lying, and to paint any scepticism about non-existent gen IV reactors as unfounded fear of them failing in the exact same ways.

Without specifying which non-existent design you are vaguely gesturing at, the objection cannot be made more concrete. One concern will be 'addressed' with a half lie about one technology, which then isn't allowed to come up when talking about a completely different technology where the half lie doesn't apply.

Gen III+ reactors have many many failure modes that 'can't happen' but require assumptiona and defense in depth princies that are regularly violated. MOX is a complete lie, especially with regard to Pu240 and Pu241 or meaningfully solving fuel shortages. There is nowhere near enough fuel for large scale expansion of them.

Molten salt reactors skate on the edge of prompt criticality and there's no process for cleaning the salt. They also leak constantly.

Sodium cooled Uranium breeders operate on the certainty of emitting more fission products into the ocean (or the Techa river) than fukushima did during reprocessing. Primary coolant leaks are also on fire in addition to being radioactive. They also catch fire constantly and skate on the edge of prompt criticality if used in breeding mode.

Neither has a strategy for dealing with the primary coolant after a plant is done or shuts early other than making the public pay to look after it for 50 years then putting it in a hole. Neither actually helps reduce Pu240 or Pu241 meaningfully. Neither can breed enough fuel to maintin a significant fleet of burner reactors.

HTGRs have yet to manifest and either no-one outside of the boys club will be allowed to make fuel for them or they will produce an order of magnitude more waste. The claims about having '3x' the fuel efficiency are based on 6x as much U235, so they actually run out of fuel twice as fast.

The lies about the rest of the fuel cycle are too numerous to summarize.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#34263176)
Well, the summary you gave in the first paragraph is wrong. I'm running out of ways to say the same thing over and over again. I DON'T WANT TO CONVINCE YOU TO BE OK WITH RARE EVENTS. I don't want to change your risk-tolerance.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:55PM (#34263703)
And this is disingenuous on several fronts. You're packaging several assumptions into your framing and refusing to allow them to be examined, then responding to any attempt to point them out as if it is irrational fear or a subject change.

Firstly that Fukushima was a severity 5 event rather than a severity 2 event. Even chernobyl and mayak had most of the consequences narrowly avoided by acts of heroism and dumb luck.

Secondly that Gen III+ reactors already eliminate severity 5 events or whatever Gen IV reactor you're imagining will do so once it meets reality in spite of that being the exact same story we were given about Gen II and Gen III.

This can only happen if the physical assumptions about the reactor's normal operational state hold, which can only happen if defense in depth is followed and there is no complacency or corruption and there are no black swan events. This assumption is incompatible with a world in which there isn't constant and strenuous objection and externally imposed accountability to the nuclear industry and sufficient attention to cover all malfeasance in depth. It is only barely compatible with the world we have now.

Thirdly that the severity 2 events with likelyhood of 100% are non-existent, when they have been constant, and the ones that happened 70 years ago are only just having their financial and health consequences felt now.

Then on top of that you're bundling in a bunch of assumptions about upsides that don't exist, and framing any objection based on those as the same allegedly unfounded fear of the same type of failure.

You are the one who is claiming any objection is irrational fear and refusal to accept new information. Refusing to accept any objection that is different is entirely circular.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:04PM (#34263855)
Do you realize how insane you sound?

> Fukushima has severity 5 risks

> Firstly that Fukushima was a severity 5 event rather than a severity 2 event.

Explain to me how we're having the same conversation. We both said 5, but you're mad at me because you think I said 2?

Also, the number is for the risk that could happen. Not for the event that did happen. You're not understanding anything I'm saying.

This is the only the only point I want to make. The general public lacks the vocabulary to discuss risk and be mutually understood. It's very difficult to teach that vocabulary because conversations like this one go off the rails because of people like you. This is maybe a two minute conversation with everyone else.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @02:37PM (#34265310)
> Fukushima has severity 5 risks

> Firstly that Fukushima was a severity 5 event rather than a severity 2 event.

What are you angry about this time?

Do you think I called it only a 2? We clearly both said 5.

Or are you trying to say that there are worse things that could have happened? A 5 is any risk we don't want to accept in the future. Unless you're ok with Fukushima and Chernobyl happening again, they're all a 5.

I'm trying to give vocabulary for establishing risk requirements. If you don't want the bad thing to happen, it's a 5. Doesn't matter if it should be a 10. 5 is the threshold of being unacceptable. If it's 5+, then it's just 5.

If the new proposal only changes the likelihood but doesn't reduce the severity, then it doesn't meet the requirement. That's it. It's just a framework to dispassionately discuss risk.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @04:01PM (#34266509)
If you wanted a good faith discussion about potential ways of making nuclear acceptable, then maybe don't open with "as soon as they hear the word "nuclear", panic really hard and refuse to receive any new information that would actually address their concerns". All of your other comments have been fairly well indistinguishable from the standard gaslighting most advocates of mass expanding Gen III+ burner reactors spout.

If I take this definition of a 5, then reactor design (in the context of current fission concepts) is barely relevant, because the 5s start at the mine site (or in the case of breeders, in the reprocessing facility). Examples are Sellafield, La Hague, Kadapa, Serpent River, Rossing, Kakadu, Mayak and many others. One Fukushima is better than one La Hague. One chernobyl is preferable to a terawatt worth of La Hagues, Kadapas, and Sellafields.

At the other end there are unsustainable Kr-85 and other gaseous emissions during fuel handling for which there is no attempt at containment, fission product laden reprocessing effluent that is barely below safe thresholds for an entire continent's coast whilst only generating a few GW worth of fuel, long lived twice-cycled Pu240 and Pu241 for which there is no attempt at a clean reprocessing process, lost weapons grade plutonium, and (in the context of wantonly using as much energy as we please) waste heat cooking the planet directly.

Other 5s include at one end all small countries being locked into a small handful of fuel suppliers because plutonium separation and enrichment facilities are gatekept, or at the other end unlimited weapons proliferation.

Worth noting is in this context the current renewable industry has plenty of 5s but there are easier to see pathways to eliminating them (and many of them are eliminating themselves simply because highly polluting mines and slaves have a minimum cost marginally higher than abundant materials and full automation).

Some variation on a TRISO-style pellet based pebble bed reactor that somehow used natural uranium at high enough burnup that mining could be kept under control would be the vague shape of addressing as many of the 5s as possible. In this context there is still a near certainty of someone doing a Chevron and quietly dumping a few hundred tonnes of spent fuel somewhere it would begin leaking and be impossible to clean up in a few decades, as well as cumulative low level medium lived radioactive emissions with a similar risk profile (although different mechanisms and harms) to CO2 or methane emissions (ie. Harmless at low levels but terrible in aggregate).

It's difficult to imagine a scenario where the number of 5s in a fission reactor is preferable to the alternatives. You'd need a breeder that could take U238/Th232 and breed/burn all of the Am,Cm,Np,Pu until only fission products were left as well as some way of vitrifying all of the fission products including tritium and noble gases on site with no effluent whilst never having a weapons grade fissile/fertile ratio in any of the weaponisable elements. Even then there would probably be one or two quite nasty long alpha decay chains with at least one medium lived step due to the number of opportunities for transmutation.

Even if that last were solved, it's still inferior to solar for building a civilisation on due to waste heat.

Such a device is also far more scifi than an anuetronic direct conversion He3 fusion reactor which also solves that last to about the same extent solar can (but has a more difficult pathway to being built from abundant materials).

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @04:38PM (#34267082)
Well, you did prove my point. I said nuclear the wrong way, and you had a meltdown. Again, I didn't make any arguments against you. You put those words in my mouth yourself.

I mostly agree with facts you wrote. I don't necessarily agree with where you drew the line for what counts as a 5. But again, I don't want to convince you to move where you drew that line. It's your line. I don't want to change your risk-tolerance.

Many people can't have this type of conversation. They don't know all the facts you know to support their opinion. Having a risk vocabulary like severity vs likelihood is really useful for communicating your requirements, evaluating new information, and explaining why it does or doesn't meet your requirements.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @05:36PM (#34267899)
Jesus fucking christ, way to punish a good deed. You receive one iota of charity as to your motivations and rather than engage in good faith you go back to 'see it's because you're irrational that you don't trust the constant gaslighting and you took my words at face value rather than assuming the most favourable possible turn of any ambiguity'.

There was no meltdown. I was outlining the history of why your cry bullying wasn't the enlightened rationality you were pretending it was.

You've not even attempted to dispense any new information other than asserting anyone who disagrees with you for any reason is doing it for irrational reasons.

At least the usual trolls have the decency to posit a semi-coherent position.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @06:15PM (#34268370)
Quote me gaslighting you.

You accused me of it twice without evidence.

First time, you thought I wanted you to believe people, and that since you didn't, you were panicked. I never said that. You did. The comment I linked explained to another commenter why I don't want them to trust anyone. I replied to you that I don't want you to accept anything that's unacceptable to you. And the panic refers to inability to engage in the conversation.

Second time, you accused me of not acknowledging past lies. But I had already said that the nuclear industry would have to address past bad behavior. And like I said, you shouldn't be trusting people anyway.

I told you that you were wilfully misunderstanding me. You disagreed. That's on you. You gaslit yourself.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @07:10PM (#34268961)
The gaslighting was referring to the industry's messaging as a whole and you knew this, but if you insist.

> The only true fix would be a reactor and fuel design that can't melt down. A walk-away safe design that, even if you intentionally induced the worst disaster, still wouldn't pose a real threat to the public. Then it wouldn't matter if the operator was a cartoon villain determined to destroy the city.

> This is the part that people still don't want to hear. They can't accept that their pet concern can be eliminated by approaching the problem differently and breaking their assumptions. They look for new concerns, but educating them doesn't help because when they run out of unaddressed concerns, they just circle back to old concerns that were already addressed. Their concern was never more than an excuse. They just want the answer to fit their preconceived notions.

You've claimed 1) that the only possible objection is risk of plant meltdown 2) that there are credibly deployable technologies where this is categorically impossible and not just an extension of defense in depth 3) that the claimed existence of 2 satisfies any objections to existing reactors and not just potential future ones and 4) that any objection that doesn't fit this framework is the fault of the objector's reasoning faculties.

1 2 and 3 are untrue, and 4 places the blame for reality not agreeing with this on anyone objecting and silences any further discussion. This is textbook gaslighting. You also left just enough ambiguity that you can have a little cry if someone calls you out on it and call them emotional for reading what you meant rather than what you might possibly have meant if we really stretch the principleof charity to breaking point.

> I literally told you that you were wilfully misunderstanding me. You disagreed. That's on you. You gaslit yourself.

I briefly entertained the notion that you had made a good faith misunderstanding and were just an incredibly poor communicator and attempted to engage, but you disproved that resoundingly by refusing to engage in good faith. Now you are attempting yet again to claim any disagreement is a purely irrational response. This is a second attempt.

You've also abandoned the clearly stated claim that walk away safety satisfies all objections and claimed that you agreed all along Gen 4 reactors and their fuel cycles posed unnaceptable risks.

This is a third attempt at gaslighting.

You also keep talking about how you address concerns and educate people, but you've done nothing but insult.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @07:54PM (#34269441)
> Your gaslighting is not as subtle as you think it is.

> The gaslighting was referring to the industry's messaging as a whole and you knew this

I guess "your" means "the industry"? I'll go add that to the dictionary right away.

"My" 4 claims are your 4 claims.

For 1, context was Fukushima, which was a partial meltdown. So I gave a matching example about a concern about a meltdown. You extrapolated that yourself to mean that the only risk that exists is meltdown. I don't think that. Should have been easy to clear up early on.

For 2, I guess we should just trust you that there will never be a solution and never talk about it again? Ironic, coming from you. But also, I want to point out how I agree with you here. Most proposals are just defense in depth. People talk in circles when they can't categorize a proposal as defense in depth vs elimination by design.

For 3, I can't see anything I wrote to suggest this. It looks to me like the only evidence you had that I might think that was your misunderstanding of 1 and 2. Either way, I don't think that.

For 4, I don't even know how you got there. But again, I don't think that.

You're still adamantly telling me what I'm thinking. I'm still telling you that I don't think those things. How can I be a poor communicator if you're the one who's deciding what I'm saying?

Look at this from my perspective. You tell me what I said, and then rant about it and accuse me of being a bad person. Every time I try to tell you what I actually think, you say "no, this is what you think, and now I'm going to rant some more and tell you how you're even worse now". The only person who has the power to stop this cycle is you. You have to stop fabricating what I'm thinking.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:03PM (#34269525)
You've still not done anything other than play word games and insult.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:11PM (#34269616)
You fabricated 99% of what you accused me of saying and then called me a gas lighter, cry bullier, a poor communicator, and a word game player. You're a psycho.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:16PM (#34269646)
And yet you continue to double down on all of them every comment.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:23PM (#34269701)
The only words I have are the ones you put in my mouth. If you don't like them, stop putting them there.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:38PM (#34269816)
Narcissistic mind games are supposed to be subtle and have a plausible enough connection to reality that people believe them. You're not really doing it very well.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @09:07PM (#34270030)
Quote yourself responding to any of the numerous times I said you misunderstood me, where you demonstrated an attempt to understand why I was saying that. You're sick in the head.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Thursday January 05, 2023 @10:20PM (#34270537)
I posited that you might have somehow been acting in good faith by opening with an insult and then following up with insults at every turn, but you soundly disproved that.

Again, you're missing the subtle bit in addition to having nothing other than insults to offer.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Thursday January 05, 2023 @11:27PM (#34270966)
My understanding is that you think I've offered you a rebuttal to any fact or opinion you might challenge me with. I haven't. I originally offered a meta-comment about the way that people discuss the topic, in response to another meta-comment about the same.

You understood what I said in a very different way than I meant it. I recognized that early on and told you so repeatedly. You willfully ignored me, and apparently continue to do so.

What can I do to clarify myself? You haven't asked me for clarification. You misconstrue everything I offer up because you view it through the lense of the initial misunderstanding. You ignore me when I explicitly tell you we need clarification. I'm out of ideas. What am I supposed to do?

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Schroedingersat on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:21AM (#34271292)
You've only repeated the assertion that anyone who has any objection to nuclear is irrational and refused to substantiate it. And this in response to my comment specifically outlining why even technically uneducated objections to the industry are actually wholly rational and evidence based, just not on evidence you like. You then followed your initial insult with further insults, and repeatedly attempted to deflect from my main point which was a rebuttal to yours by claiming I didn't understand it.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:44AM (#34271438)
> You've only repeated the assertion that anyone who has any objection to nuclear is irrational

I already explained I never said that, much less repeated it.

Clearly I'm not really a participant in this conversation. If you want to continue this conversation with yourself, go ask ChatGPT to debate you or something.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Arnt on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @04:10AM (#34243571)
You're not giving new information about my concern, you're trying to stay on another topic. You're answering the question you think I should have instead of the one I have.

Some of the relevant German organisations discarded dangerous waste at a construction site and then shredded the paperwork. That happened due to organisational traits, nothing to do with nuclear physics, but if my concern is that organisations with those organisational traits shouldn't be doing things with potential catastrophic effects, then you can't just answer with physics. Shredding paperwork is real, and my concern about is a concern to answer, not to ignore. If you ignore it, blame yourself for ignorance, not me for refusing to listen to "new information that addresses my concern".

This is similar to the Challenger space shuttle. NASA had organisational traits that led to powerpoint slides with seven different font sizes, and "the shuttle might burn" was in the smallest font size. The shuttle eventually did, and partly because organisation's culture was one to suppress risks using the smallest of seven font sizes.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by marmetio on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @12:08PM (#34248266)
Risk has two components: severity and likelihood. Typically on a scale of 1-5.

Fukushima has severity 5 risks, and some people are willing to accept them as long as they think the likelihood is 1. But not you. And that's fine.

This is the problem that new technology is trying to address. Eliminate the severity 5 risks.

But a lot of people are resistant to taking stock of what's been eliminated so far and what hasn't. That's the problem with the public discourse. That's the new information that people reject.

Going back to your concern. TEPCO is an operator. They can only affect the likelihood, not the severity. That's why I don't want to debate you about them. I don't want to convince you to accept a severity 5. I want to ask you where you think we are in eliminating the severity 5s.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Archelaos on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:05AM (#34233207)
It is the same spirit of pocketing profits and deferring problems to later generations that is behind nuclear power as it is behind fossil fuels. Both are evil. By acknowledging this, Germany is ethically ahead of most other societies on this planet.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by rhn_mk1 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:20AM (#34233451)
Considering the nuclear power shutdowns, it's not so clear that any acknowledgement was made. To me, it seems to confirm business as usual, especially the continued expansion of lignite mines.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by froh on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:59AM (#34234115)
yes! wind, solar and decentralized buffer storage can make us independent from both mined fuels, uranium and fossils, real fast once there is a political willpower to do so.

Merkel as a quantum physicist, a PhD at that, knew how to read statistics and forecasts. her exit from nuclear was an incredibly wise and far sighted political measure. I hope we'll be wise enough to stick with it.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by nforgerit on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:52PM (#34234998)
had to lol at praising Merkel. Well what _actually_ happened was that due to nuclear lobbying her cabinet decided in 2010 to stall the already decided exit by the former government under chancellor schröder (in 2004 ircc). Then 9 months later Fukushima happened and due to german angst in public polls she announced 3 days afterwards to make the nuclear exit even shorter than in the beginning which happened to be end of 2022. This all led to hefty fines (ircc couple billions) paid by tax payers.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by froh on Thursday January 05, 2023 @11:05AM (#34261786)
I'd never thought I'd praise Merkel for anything. still her change of direction to a shorter exit was remarkable.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by nforgerit on Thursday January 05, 2023 @05:18PM (#34267675)
Well I think she deserves praise for her actions around the refugee crisis around 2015 which took some guts on her side.

But along with her erratic nuclear policies she left highly crusted public authorities, a failed energiewende towards renewables, a strategic disaster in terms of russian gas and a dysfunctional army among many other things. She always presented opportunism as a legit style of doing politics ("Politik der kleinen Schritte") oftentimes leading to absurd compromises and systematic short-sightedness.

Her conservative party started copying US Republican tactics which harms the German system even more because it is much relying on compromises between political camps.

For me the only remarkable attribute about her is her willingness to do anything to stay in power. I'd bet she didn't even know what for.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ajross on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:34AM (#34233684)
Renewable generation in Germany has quadrupled in the last decade (c.f. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Germany). You're framing it differently, but your argument is mostly just about "nuclear" and will devolve into the same tired arguments. So I'll give my standard statement, I guess:

Nuclear is failing not because of resistance from hippies or whatever. It's failing because it's far, far, far too expensive, by more than an order of magnitude vs. other renewable choices. There's zero value in spending Euros on a reactor when we could build a bazillion wind turbines and hydro pumps and battery farms for that cash. Nuclear might have a home at the very end of the process when we're trying to wind down the last of the gas peaker plants. But no, nuclear will never represent a significant fraction of renewable power generation. Never. No one wants to write that check.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ljlolel on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:36AM (#34233708)
it's too expensive because of resistance from hippies who constantly interfere with more regulations and changing regulations and requirements. They can be built safely and cheaply and mined with local swedish uranium if not for all of the ever shifting regulations from the political resistance tactics.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by xg15 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:41AM (#34233815)
And yet the pro-nuclear argument is that nuclear power is safe thanks to regulations. That's circular reasoning.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by ajross on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:42AM (#34233841)
If that were true then there would be a reactor somewhere in the world beating wind power on cost, and there isn't. Even Chinese reactors, constructed under a regime that criminalizes hippies and regulates only for the benefit of the party leaders, are reliably late and over budget. Ex: Fangchenggang-3 is a new unit of an existing design on an already-operating site. It began construction 8 years ago, was supposed to be operational two years ago, and hasn't reached criticality yet.

It just doesn't work. You can blame your political enemies if you want, but that's not going to make a reactor appear.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by bamboozled on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @05:58PM (#34253198)
I'm making a different point.

We're already in serious trouble due to climate change, and our future looks increasingly bleak due to it becoming worse.

It's a big enough issue that the whole world should really be at war with burning fossil fuels right now, our best minds should be focused on solving this issue, yesterday.

What this article proves proves is that we're capable of solving really hard problems in very short amounts of time, "if the inventive is there". Clearly it was, I can't help but feel it has a little bit to do with profits and political motivations, which is why moving to renewables is happening (because it makes economic sense), but is the political drive and will to do more there? I don't think so.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Denvercoder9 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:45AM (#34231191)
They didn't exactly build a terminal, they upgraded an existing jetty to allow a floating terminal to dock and connect to the gas network on the main land. Engineering-wise it was a fairly straightforward job.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by selectodude on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:56AM (#34231304)
Nothing is straightforward when you're dealing with an explosive gas under extremely high pressure.

This was a large project and completing it on time in 9 months is laudable.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by moloch-hai on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:09AM (#34232305)
LNG is not a gas, it is a cryogenic liquid. Cryogenic liquids are not easy, but are anyway not "under extremely high pressure", nor is LNG especially explosive: there is rarely enough oxygen immediately at hand for a good explosion, as opposed to a big fire. (Rockets would have a big tank of LOX right there.)

A big fire can be bad, but is nothing like a detonation.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by b3orn on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:36AM (#34232746)
The LNG is regasified before entering the gas network.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by moloch-hai on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:50AM (#34232962)
But not at the terminal.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by cormacrelf on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:58AM (#34233089)
Uh, yes at the terminal. The floating LNG terminal is a ship, and the liquid is gas by the time it gets to the jetty. https://www.rwe.com/en/research-and-development/project-plan...
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by moloch-hai on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:17AM (#34233392)
That's fixable.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by bob29 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:54PM (#34236076)
Love the confidence, keep it up
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by Denvercoder9 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:55AM (#34234049)
If you zoom out far enough, nothing is straightforward. I bet most people on this site would consider building a small-scale CRUD app straightforward, but if you ask them to start from pure silicon and a bit of metal nobody could pull it off.

Germany already operates about 40,000 km of natural gas pipeline. This was a 26km extension in a flat and rural/industrial area. There was no engineering challenge here that they hadn't already pulled off hundreds of times before.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by selectodude on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:09PM (#34234262)
https://www.wsj.com/articles/natural-gas-terminal-engineerin...

Doing anything like that in nine months is impressive. I haven't the faintest idea why anybody would say otherwise.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by seper8 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:45AM (#34231202)
>modern governments

Did a "modern government" create this terminal or did a public company "simply" respond to market demand or other incentives like subsidies?

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by flohofwoe on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @08:59AM (#34231346)
The government introduced a 'red tape cutting law' to speed up the process (also, it's remarkable because it's the first 'high profile project' in Germany I can remember that was finished in time).

https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/themen/klimaschutz/se...

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by seper8 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:32AM (#34231759)
Oh so the government removed some of the red tape (which it made itself) and suddenly the project was able to be finished on time?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by flohofwoe on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @09:36AM (#34231821)
Well, the 'red tape' exists so that the public also has a say in the planning process of infrastructure projects (it is their money after all that pays for those projects, but also often unfortunately results in pointless NIMBY-ism of small interest groups).

So cutting the red tape actually means taking away freedom from the people, which is a serious matter and shouldn't be taken lightly (I agree though that the two sides of the problem need to be better balanced in Germany).

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by moloch-hai on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:38AM (#34232780)
Red tape provides space for graft, which wants projects never completed. Grafty projects are finally completed when it looks like the money would dry up regardless.

Nukes are among the graftiest projects (alongside urban tunnels, some places). NB, even without the graft and even discounting public subsidy, they would be among the most expensive power sources, so there is never a good reason to build one.

Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by welterde on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @10:49AM (#34232950)
Not sure if it qualifies as "high profile", but the Emscher renaturization project (5 billion euro budget from 1992 to now), which included digging a 51 km underground canal was on-time and on-budget as far as I can tell.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by pjmorris on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @11:04AM (#34233181)
Isn't every 'public company' an entity created by 'modern government' regulation?
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by lostlogin on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:18PM (#34235398)
And the subsidies too.
Re:First LNG tanker arrives at Germany's new floating terminal by kakwa_ on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @07:36AM (#34244810)
> it’s incredible how fast Germany built these new terminals.

Except they weren't really "built" in 9 months. Höegh Esperanza (the floating terminal), was commissioned in 2018.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%B6egh_Esperanza

In reality, oversimplifying wildly, it took 9 months to negotiate the contract and "plug" this preexisting terminal into the German gas network.

However, it's still impressive that our societies have tools like that available to handle unforeseen situations and crisis.