News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by everdrive on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:24PM (#34130881)
This is very welcome news if it passes. Non-replaceable batteries have NO redeeming qualities in my opinion. Some will say that they're important for waterproofing, but I previously owned an IP68 (ie, certified waterproof) mobile phone which had a user replaceable battery. It's clearly not a requirement. Being able to replace batteries as they go bad will go a long way towards reducing electronic waste, as devices can be used for significantly longer.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by klntsky on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:35PM (#34130965)
> Non-replaceable batteries have NO redeeming qualities in my opinion

Non-replaceable batteries contribute to lowering the price. If the producer can expect to sell more copies of the same product, the price of a single item can be lower.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:37PM (#34130986)
Which is useful to the producer, not to the consumer. The consumer ends up spending more money by having to buy more phones. It's only cheaper if you're looking at a single purchase, not over time.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by klntsky on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:49PM (#34131084)
> It's only cheaper if you're looking at a single purchase, not over time.

It's not entirely true, if you don't buy a new phone and simply live with a battery not holding power for more than a day, you get both cheaper price of the phone and a technically working phone.

Of course someone with higher expectations for battery time will have to buy a new phone sooner, but if you can't afford it, it's valuable to you personally regardless.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by hattar on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:10PM (#34131299)
If the device degrades to the point where it’s effectively useless for my primary use case, I’m not really saving money. Useful timeline needs to be accounted for when considering cost effectiveness.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by klntsky on Monday December 26, 2022 @07:22AM (#34137091)
You are implying that the primary use case is the same for everyone. Consider this counter example: what if I want a phone to use a navigator app in my car (to leave it always on charge)? Battery life would not be important at all.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:30PM (#34132174)
You don’t have to buy a new phone to replace the battery. Just take it to any repair shop.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by don-code on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:13PM (#34132523)
This may work for common phones (aka: Apple and Samsung phones). I had to retire a perfectly workable, but five years old, HTC phone after three such shops refused to fix it, citing unfamiliarity and cost.

I now have an ASUS phone, and fully expect the same to happen in several years.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:27PM (#34133537)
It seems like weird logic to legislate that Apple and Samsung must make their phones less reliable for everyone simply because a 5 year old phone made by a cut price manufacturer is no longer supported.

Why did you buy the ASUS phone if you don’t expect to get support for it?

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by janosdebugs on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:14AM (#34135748)
They can't really say Apple and Samsung have to do this, everybody else doesn't. And they are by far the market leaders, so they sell the most phones ending up in landfills.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by don-code on Monday December 26, 2022 @09:46PM (#34144438)
I bought it used, and with the expectation that I'm going to be on the hook for my own long-term maintenance and support, as is true with more or less everything I buy. (Full-time Linux user here.)

The sad reality is that the experience of running an off-brand phone with an easily-replaceable battery would, long-term, be much worse than running a locked-in flagship that LineageOS builds for.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by dns_snek on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:51PM (#34132862)
> Just take it to any repair shop.

Device manufacturers see that as a bug, not a feature. They are starting to pair genuine parts to a specific device, which will completely lock us out of 3rd party repair options if we accept and normalize this behavior.

See for example:

- "The iPhone 14 Continues Apple’s Digital Repair Lockdown" by iFixit - https://www.ifixit.com/News/66879/iphone-14-parts-pairing-re...

- "iPhone 14 Pro Programmed To Reject Repair" by Hugh Jeffreys - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2WhU77ihw8

- The long list of Louis Rossmann's rants on the topic

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:27PM (#34133533)
Just because people who make money out of repair are making this claim, doesn’t make it true.

See for example: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2022/04/apples-self-service-r...

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by fragmede on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:32PM (#34133570)
Ah yes, that 79-pound iPhone repair kit to fix a 1.1-ounce battery. The review of it was pretty interesting [0]. It's possible, but it's not exactly what I'd call user serviceable. There are a hojillion kits on Amazon which all include all the necessary tools to take the phone apart - triwing screwdriver, pentalobe screwdriver, impossibly small 00 phillipshead screwdriver, etc - so anyone that can follow youtube directions and has a steady hand can do it. It's just way harder than it needs to be so under the proposed law, they'd have to make it easier.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/21/23079058/apple-self-servi...

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:40PM (#34133621)
Yeah - it’s fairly obvious that linked article is in bad faith.

The 79-pound repair kit is what Apple uses in its stores to avoid damaging phones that remain under warranty.

If people want to buy a bunch of cheap tools and risk damaging a delicate phone, they shouldn’t expect Apple’s help.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by fragmede on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:26AM (#34135240)
That's funny, I got the opposite read from that article and that it's Apple that's operating in bad faith here.

Really though I think what's important is that we should expect help from Apple. It might take EU regulations to force that, but what that really says to me is that as consumer in the US, my bar for what to expect from corporations is set way too low.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by Technetium on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:45PM (#34152864)
I'm going to assume ignorance over bad-faith and provide a video for you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUpnrd-Xuho
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by dns_snek on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:02PM (#34133738)
I don't understand what point you're trying to make. What you're saying only strengthens my original point about Apple monopolizing repair.

My interests as a consumer and those of "people who make money out of repair" are almost completely aligned -- I want them to (be able to) work on my device in the event that I don't have the tools, skills or patience to do the repair myself.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:12PM (#34133805)
> My interests as a consumer and those of "people who make money out of repair" are almost completely aligned

I don’t see how. The less reliable the device is, the more business they get. The more reliable the device is, the less you spend on repairs. Sure seems like opposing interests.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by dns_snek on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:39PM (#34133949)
Repairability is orthogonal to reliability and I've only brought up complaints about the former. This dichotomy you're trying to establish doesn't have any grounding in reality.

All that repair shops can do is provide commentary and inform consumers about whether the OEM is serious about repair or whether they're just greenwashing their image and by all accounts, Apple's self-service repair program is about as anemic as their Apple authorized service provider program.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:56PM (#34134729)
> Repairability is orthogonal to reliability

This is clearly not true when we’re discussing user replaceable batteries or the like. It’s a trade off, like most things in engineering.

There are many extra ways things can go wrong by making components such as batteries easy to replace. Poor contacts, oxidation, mechanical breakage, battery compartment doors popping off, ingress of dust and fluids, looser tolerances for the batteries etc.

Nobody discussing this in good faith can deny that these issues exist.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by krolden on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:07PM (#34134127)
Pay extra for labor on top of parts, and theres a good chance theyll screw something up like the waterproofing seal or leave a loose connection that you won't notice until weeks later. Then you have to take it back and convince them its their fault and wait even longer while they hopefully don't screw the phone up even worse.

Yeah that definitely sounds more convenient than a removable battery.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:57PM (#34134734)
> theres a good chance they’ll screw something up like the waterproofing seal or leave a loose connection that you won't notice until weeks later

You must be strongly opposed to right to repair, since repair shops are incompetent to even replace a battery in your view.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by krolden on Monday December 26, 2022 @12:52AM (#34135013)
Right to repair means being able to replace the battery without risking damage to the device
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by Jorchime on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:39PM (#34130992)
Which probably doesn't reflect the real costs of extracting, processing and discarding resources and their effect on humans, life and nature very well.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by dns_snek on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:42PM (#34131025)
Given that we've largely decided that sustainability is the way forward, an argument in favour of e-waste isn't particularly convincing.

User-replaceable batteries are just the first step. What we should all be pushing towards to reduce waste and emissions is a no-compromise right to repair, with easily accessible parts, tools and schematics.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nradov on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:16PM (#34133458)
I support the right to repair, but it's not the only way to reduce e-waste. Another complementary approach is through refundable deposits, just like with beverage containers. Include a $20+ deposit in the price of each smartphone, then refund it when the consumer returns it to a retailer or manufacturer for proper recycling and safe disposal.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by witheld on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:09PM (#34133780)
Recycling is pretty much a scam, the first step of reduce-reuse-recycle is “reduce”.

One commenter said this legislation doesn’t make sense because they get a new phone every three years.

Even if they do, it would reduce demand if the phone continued to have parts and software for someone else to use.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:43PM (#34131032)
The price of the battery or the price of the final product that uses batteries?

Regardless, it matters what your pricing power is.

For a luxury finished product - you price on what your consumers will bear (with some maximization curve).

For a commodity battery - then maybe.

Though, I'm not sure I follow your logic why this means more batteries will be sold.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by hn92726819 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:46PM (#34131056)
In the very short term, maybe. But it's only cheaper for the very first phone. In a few years when the battery dies, the cost of the battery would be much lower than the cost of a new phone, which the consumers are required to buy

Same faulty logic for injket printers. They're extremely cheap so sure, you're "saving money" for a period, but the scales tip after one or two refill ink cartridges

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by onli on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:28PM (#34132153)
If non-repairable products were cheaper and those savings passed on to consumers, apple products and the surface series would be the cheapest that exist. They are not...
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:30PM (#34132166)
This is just wrong. Replaceable batteries add cost and fragility to the device, make battery life worse, and most phones die because they stop getting software updates anyway.

Replaceable batteries will increase e-waste because there will be a lot more broken phones.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by kewrkewm53 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:42PM (#34132259)
Thankfully EU is also working on legislation that mandates more years of software support. Hopefully days of only 2-3 years of support will be soon gone for good, it's just plain wrong.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by gaganyaan on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:48PM (#34132317)
Saying "we shouldn't legislate repairablity because <other bad practice that needs to be legislated away>" is not terribly convincing. There should 100% be legislation aimed at keeping old phones able to run newer software.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by tosc on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:41PM (#34133630)
We shouldn’t legislate repairability at the expense of reliability. The only people that benefits are repair shops.

That should be up to the user to choose, as it is now.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by pantalaimon on Monday December 26, 2022 @12:07AM (#34134775)
Yea like those famously unreliable Nokia phones with their replaceable batteries
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by bakugo on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:01PM (#34132431)
> most phones die because they stop getting software updates anyway

Contrary to what most phone manufacturers would like you to think, no, devices do not suddenly stop working if they go a week without an update.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by josephcsible on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:49PM (#34132833)
They do become unsafe to use for most purposes, though.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by mmis1000 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:58PM (#34134738)
Depends on what phone you get. Mid to high end phones usually have communities to maintain 3 party system patches for them after they are not maintained officially. You can still use it safely for a a few years if you even bother about it.

For example, my old sony xz3 is a 2018/08 phone with software update discontinued since 2020(?). But there are actually 3party roms that can update it android 12.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by josephcsible on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:17PM (#34140214)
That covers most of the software, but basically every modern phone has some proprietary drivers that are necessary for it to function and that have security vulnerabilities of their own.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by bakugo on Monday December 26, 2022 @02:48PM (#34141088)
And nobody's going to exploit those device-specific vulnerabilities (that probably require local code execution anyway) unless you're a high-value target.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by crote on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:09PM (#34132490)
Phones don't "die" because they no longer get software updates. They just become obsolete - as planned by the manufacturer. Sounds like the next step is to fix the software update issue!
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by janosdebugs on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:18AM (#34135763)
They practically die. A lot of software, such as work profile, banking apps, etc will stop working (depending on the work settings, bank rules, etc) if you don't update your phone. Also, your apps will no longer update as the app vendor doesn't release their apps for older API versions and will effectively make your app useless if their server side protocol changes.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by rvdginste on Monday December 26, 2022 @11:22AM (#34138983)
> if you don't update your phone

Indeed, but the issue is that the phone manufacturer no longer supports the phone and release OS updates. And on Android, you could install unofficial mods to upgrade to a more recent version of the OS, but then some apps (banking apps for example) refuse to work because of... reasons, again making the phone unusable. And in a majority of cases, this has nothing to do with the hardware no longer being capable.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by ggreer on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:25PM (#34132635)
There are many advantages to integrated batteries:

- Waterproofing. Fewer deals means more resistance to water ingress.

- Compact size. Standard battery sizes rarely fit thin or irregular designs.

- Better battery life. An integrated battery can be designed to fill all available spare space in a device.

- Cost. Integrated batteries involve fewer connectors and parts.

- User satisfaction. Users often blame original manufacturers when the problem is actually poor quality 3rd party batteries. This was extremely common back when most laptops had removable batteries.

And why do arguments in favor of removable batteries apply to phones and laptops, but not headphones, vehicles, cameras, etc? Just let people buy the devices they want. There’s no need to have the government force people to use things they dislike.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by gumboza on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:33PM (#34132687)
Agree on all points.

The key thing the EU are ruling on here are phones. I replace my phone or laptop battery every 3 years at average! Does it need to be removable for that? Hell no. Sticky tape, glued in I don't care. I will pay apple or whoever to replace it. 30 minutes of labour is fine for this interval!

What pisses me off are the people who are too fucking cheap to pay for a phone battery from the manufacturer but will throw 10x the cost on trivial repairs on a premium car while whining about it.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by rat9988 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:07PM (#34133408)
Why should I pay for a battery from the manufacturer instead of other suppliers?
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by janosdebugs on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:07AM (#34135728)
Because won't somebody think of the... Wait, no, I meant to say: "It's dangerous and a third party battery can set your phone on fire!" Also, "it will allow hackers to steal your data". /s

As far as I can tell, the manufacturers are doing a pretty good job at occassionally setting your phone on fire and exposing your data themselves.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by krolden on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:09PM (#34134142)
Most issues with batreires in laptops and stuff come from vendor firmware that checks if its a genuine OEM part or not. Same with printer cartridges.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by mmis1000 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:49PM (#34134702)
Yep, call pros to replace them every 3 years? Probably okay. Device becomes trash after 3 years because battery is DRM-protected and no longer produced?

EU should really f**k them hard about this behavior. It's 100% planned obsolescence.

Log the producer of parts is okay but intentionally make them non functional is not.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by gumboza on Monday December 26, 2022 @04:17AM (#34136050)
Oh I agree with that one entirely. One reason I buy apple shit is last year I got them to stuff a new battery in my old 6s which I bought in 2015 and they did it there and then in store. Second swap it has had.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by gumboza on Monday December 26, 2022 @04:15AM (#34136041)
No thats not the main issue. Most of the issues come from crap batteries not being anywhere near fit for purpose. I’ve swapped out enough (tens of the things) to see that as the average case.

Most laptops just whine about third party batteries and you can just nuke the vendor battery junk to get rid of it.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by schwartzworld on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:32PM (#34132671)
> but not headphones, vehicles, cameras, etc

Both my car and my DSLR have user replaceable batteries. My headphones don't because they are wired.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by ggreer on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:06PM (#34133396)
I’m talking about EVs, not combustion vehicles. Also there’s no law forcing everyone to use removable batteries in any of those devices.

My point is that users freely choose different types of batteries for different applications. It makes no sense to coerce everyone else into choosing your favorite type of battery.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by schwartzworld on Monday December 26, 2022 @11:14AM (#34138898)
> My point is that users freely choose different types of batteries for different applications.

Where is the choice when all manufacturers arrive at the same conclusion: it's better for profits not to offer replaceable batteries?

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by everdrive on Sunday December 25, 2022 @07:15PM (#34133048)
>And why do arguments in favor of removable batteries apply to phones and laptops, but not headphones, vehicles, cameras, etc?

As far as I can tell this is not accurate. I want user-serviceable batteries in all devices. Phones might get the most attention because they're the most ubiquitous, but I wish that all LiON batteries were standardized and user serviceable.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nradov on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:11PM (#34133431)
That's a nice fantasy, but it would be simply impossible to build a device like my Garmin Descent Mk2 smart watch / dive computer with a user-serviceable battery while still maintaining 100m water resistance. It just can't be done. The extra seals would compromise water resistance and risk a leak when I'm underwater and need it most. And allowing for user-serviceable batteries would inevitably make it physically larger; it's already as large as a wristwatch can reasonably be.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by krolden on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:04PM (#34134115)
Hey I thought capitalism inspired innovation. So why does nearly every phone being made today is basically a brick of glass you can't open?
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nickpp on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:36AM (#34135849)
Because that innovation is market driven and turns out "brick of glass" is what people want, no matter what you or I or the Brussels bureaucrats say.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by growse on Monday December 26, 2022 @04:03AM (#34135983)
> Because that innovation is market driven and turns out "brick of glass" is what people want, no matter what you or I or the Brussels bureaucrats say.

History has countless examples of how the market is very bad at accounting for externalities.

People may very well want just a "brick of glass", but regulation comes in and drives innovation when it turns out that selling people what they want in the short term actually needlessly harms society in the long run.

"What the people want" actually has a lot of nuance and variability over different timeframes.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nickpp on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:34AM (#34138383)
History has even more examples of how planners and regulators are bad at accounting for… reality, really. Or the unexpected creativity of people bent on getting what they want in spite of "well meaning" regulators.

"What harms society" actually has a lot of nuance and variability over different timeframes. I don’t think anybody can define it, actually.

Regulators making nuclear power hugely expensive and activists making it wildly unpopular thus condemning us to burn coal in 2022 quickly come to mind. Or the idiocy of banning plastic straws in the west while the ocean drowns in fishing nets from Asia.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by alexvoda on Monday December 26, 2022 @09:02AM (#34137676)
Quite wrong. The market is efficient at solving simple issues.

On the other hand a smartphone has pages long list if specs. And users have divergent preferences for those specs.

The market is only able to find a common denominator that makes everyone equally unhappy. In doing so it transfers power to the few manufacturers who now make choices for the users. Even worse, manufacturers copy each other and follow fashion trends.

It is almost impossible to find a phone that has a replaceable battery. It is very hard to find small phones. It is very hard to find phones with headphone jacks. It is very hard to find phones without a punchhole or notch for the camera.

These are all things people desire, but either not strong enough or not enough people or both.

I like the iPhone mini but not enough to sacrifice the flexibility of Android.

I like displays without cutouts, but not enough to sacrifice the 4 years of updates Samsung offers.

Etc. Etc. Etc.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nickpp on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:46AM (#34138548)
> things people desire, but either not strong enough or not enough people or both

> I like […] but not enough

> I like […] but not enough

Sounds like the market has managed to understand perfectly the things people actually want in a phone versus the ones they are just paying lip service to.

Taking such a long list of specs with wildly contradictory requirements and create compromise products that satisfiy the most is an extremely complex issue and something the market is uniquely suited to do - I am not aware of another mechanism that can do that, maybe a future AI.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by felurx on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:58PM (#34140614)
Getting updates and not having a notch are in no way contradictory requirements.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nickpp on Monday December 26, 2022 @02:20PM (#34140812)
Maybe, but I would bet they both impact the device cost while their rank on most people's desired characteristics list is not very high.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by alexvoda on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @09:01AM (#34161001)
Non-notched screen is cheaper.

Headphone jack is a minuscule cost (you still need the DAC for the speakers).

There are now magnetically attached Bluetooth devices that provide a headphone jack to an iPhone and make twice as thick.

This showcases perfectly that there is a market for an iPhone with a jack, but Apple has the power to decide for everyone.

A user has the options:

- use an old phone(for how long?)

- sacrifice the jack and stay on iOS (give up)

- sacrifice iOS, repurchase all apps (are they available? alternatives?) and other purchases, and find some phone that still has it (gradually all flagships other than Sony dropped it)

This is not a free market, it is a market with plenty of obstacles to entry (some natural some imposed).

And the following of fashion trends (mostly follow Apple) make the situation doubly toxic.

In a captive market it is sufficient for one player to demonstrate the market will accept a worse offer and other players will follow through.

This may sound like blasphemy, but capitalism is actually not compatible with the free market.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by lwhi on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @06:57AM (#34160128)
You're incorrect.

The simple fact is, unrestrained capitalism is ugly.

A company that has become wildly successful will equally hold a lot of financial power. The same company is often likely to engage in lobbying .. exchanging that fiscal power for actual political power.

Without regulations we end up living in world driven by the singular need to make more and more money.

These corporations are not able to factor the good of human kind into their plan because that's got nothing to do with their very reason for existence.

Regulation is the only way we can address this.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nickpp on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @03:38PM (#34165627)
> A company that has become wildly successful will equally hold a lot of financial power.

The most successful and influential companies of today did not even exist 50 years ago.

> the good of human kind

Please define “the good of human kind”. Be specific.

Soviets did most of their crimes “for the betterment of all mankind”. It’s a wonderful cover.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by lwhi on Thursday December 29, 2022 @05:45AM (#34171363)
Your first statement makes no difference to what I'm saying.

I've been clear enough in my initial comment. The fact you're asking this second question makes me feel you understand I have a point.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by krolden on Thursday December 29, 2022 @04:36PM (#34178340)
So since there's basically zero phones with physical keyboards that means no one actually wants them? I guess me and everyone else that have been angry about touchscreen only input for nearly the last decade just "dont want it enough"
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by lightedman on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:47PM (#34134353)
"but it would be simply impossible to build a device like my Garmin Descent Mk2 smart watch / dive computer with a user-serviceable battery while still maintaining 100m water resistance. It just can't be done."

That's been a solved problem for a very, very long time. Even older battery-operated dive watches have user-serviceable batteries. My Tekmagic is user-replaceable. The gaskets and tolerance ranges are well-understood for this sort of thing.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by mvid on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:19PM (#34134536)
Replacing a battery once a year in a laborious process isn't an acceptable comparison for a device who's battery lasts a week at best.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by Nullabillity on Monday December 26, 2022 @06:36AM (#34136826)
Nobody's saying that they have to be single-use batteries? Just that the rechargeable ones should be replaceable once they reach the end of their lifetime.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nradov on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:57PM (#34134733)
No that's completely incorrect. It is not a solved problem. Those Tekmagic devices have very limited functionality and are not real smart watches or fitness trackers like the Garmin Descent series. A smart watch draws more power than a replaceable CR2025 coin cell battery can sustain. (I had a similar old Suunto wristwatch style dive computer with a replaceable battery so I am very familiar with the differences.)
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by potamic on Monday December 26, 2022 @04:36AM (#34136135)
I think the point was not so much to use replaceable coin cells, but introduce a rechargeable lithium battery with a standard interface and form factors that can be adopted by all devices. It doesn't seem impossible on the outset, but no manufacturer has incentive to do so.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nradov on Monday December 26, 2022 @05:25AM (#34136408)
That is impossible. A rechargeable lithium battery the size of a CR2025 would be useless for a device which draws so much power. Make the battery any bigger and then you'd have to increase the size of the device, which is already at the limit.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by potamic on Monday December 26, 2022 @05:34AM (#34136459)
Smart watches already use rechargeable lithium batteries of a few hundred mAh which are tiny enough to fit in the watch. You just need to standardize the interface and form factors across the industry. Again, not suggesting to use CR2025 form factor, you can always define a new one. Most watches in the market already use very similar battery packs, it just isn't standardized.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by lightedman on Monday December 26, 2022 @02:04PM (#34140663)
"No that's completely incorrect. It is not a solved problem."

We have IP6X-rated USB connectors. Charge port is a solved problem.

Gaskets and seal plates are gaskets and seal plates, nothing really special about them. Solved problem.

The battery probably won't need to be replaced for a few years, we aren't talking a coin cell, we're talking a mini-pouch like what already exists in these watches.

I do work in this industry. It's a solved problem, has been for several decades.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by PontifexMinimus on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:28PM (#34133542)
> Just let people buy the devices they want

But that's not what will happen. Instead people will have to buy the devices manufacturers force on them.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by ggreer on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:14AM (#34135152)
How are manufacturers forcing anything? They are all competing with each other for customers.

The problem is that making a modern phone is ridiculously expensive, and not enough customers want removable batteries to make the investment worthwhile. Samsung made phones with removable batteries. Not enough people bought them, so the product line was discontinued.

Apple can’t force you to buy any of their products. Tim Cook can’t send men with guns to your home and put you in a cage. The government can. Anyone who uses that power to force people to make phones with removable batteries is absurdly authoritarian.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by gambiting on Monday December 26, 2022 @02:38AM (#34135590)
I only sorta agree with this argument. It's like saying that headphone jack was removed because not enough people bought phones with them - and that's obviously nonsense, pretty much every manufacturer dropped them within a very short timespan, so there really wasn't any choice in that matter as a consumer. Especially for consumers invested into an ecosystem(apple), manufacturer took away that choice - and the cost of switching away to android to keep the headphone jack was greater than dealing with the inconvenience, so most people didn't do that - but that doesn't mean they wouldn't prefer to keep the port.

>>Anyone who uses that power to force people to make phones with removable batteries is absurdly authoritarian.

Do you think any and all regulations are authoritarian? Governments everywhere, not just in EU, try to legislate based on what's best for the society. As the simplest example, they force manufacturers to limit transmission power to protect users from too much RF exposure - is that authoritarian? Or just a good idea that protects people? What if customers would prefer phones that have a stronger signal, at the potential expense of health consequences?

Similarly, we can decide that it's better for the society if phones have removable batteries, because in theory it will lead to less electronic waste(which affects us all). I don't personally think that's true, I think even with removable batteries people will just buy new phones every 2 years anyway, but I wouldn't describe this move as authoritarian - just misguided.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by yakireev on Monday December 26, 2022 @07:11AM (#34137030)
> How are manufacturers forcing anything?

Could you point me to AAA-battery powered noise cancelling headphones? No bluetooth necessary.

I have a pair from 2014, and I love that as long as I have some spare batteries, I'm never stuck with headphones which I can't use because of low charge, and that I don't have to charge yet another device. That pair has no bluetooth, so power usage is low: one AAA battery for 30-40 hours of use.

When these are dead, I won't find a replacement, because manufacturer does not want me to use the same device for eight years. They want me to have the integrated battery dead in a couple of years and buy a new pair.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by ggreer on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:35PM (#34153438)
And I miss the form factor of the iPhone 5. Does that mean Apple should be forced to make devices of that size indefinitely? I don’t think so.

You’re demanding that the government force people to make things that they no longer want to make, usually because the product is no longer profitable. Someone has to pay for the workers and factories needed to produce these products. Better it be you than the >99% of taxpayers who don’t want battery-powered wired headphones.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by hinkley on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:58AM (#34135409)
The problem with phones, even up through the Symbian ones that presaged the iPhone, was that if you didn't have the most popular phone model around you could not find a decent replacement battery after the product end-of-lifed. For a while Fry's was the only place. So with respect to 'the largest battery' it's a matter of whether it's really fruitful for your new model to have a battery that's 2mm wider than the old one because you shrunk some component and want the extra 10% battery life you get by doing so.

If you're laying up your own prismatic cells from a reel of battery film, why not? If you need a whole separate distribution chain, fuck it, we use the same battery as last year.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by rasz on Monday December 26, 2022 @09:04AM (#34137685)
My very first cellphone was Ericsson t10s, removable battery was part of the case. Solves all of the problems you mention.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by TheCleric on Sunday December 25, 2022 @07:29PM (#34133152)
I also had a user replaceable battery on an IP68 phone. And it had multiple warnings on the phone and the manual about how to get a good seal and a strong implication that if it goes wrong that's your fault.

So while I am 100% in favor of right of repair, I wonder if the law of unintended consequences will lead to more difficult warranty claims.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by SillyUsername on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:34AM (#34135292)
Sounds more like poor design.

Plenty of other devices such as outdoor cameras have replaceable batteries with no warnings.

Shavers have a water proofed interior shelled battery that although usually not replaceable, technically can be since all but 2 flat contacts are sealed.

Designing batteries for said water protection incurs extra cost, and is cheaper to just seal in, ensuring the financial burden of the design failure is on the consumer, this law helps end that practice.

Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by nikau on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:06AM (#34135723)
Its likely he is referring to the galaxy s5 - the cameras and shavers you mentioned aren't trying to keep to the same size and weight limitations as mobile phones.
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by TheCleric on Monday December 26, 2022 @07:15PM (#34143389)
I couldn't remember at the time which phone this was since it was almost a decade ago, but yes I now recall it was an S5!
Re:Non-Replaceable Battery? Not If This Proposed EU Law Passes by megablast on Monday December 26, 2022 @12:33AM (#34134888)
> Non-replaceable batteries have NO redeeming qualities in my opinion

This is some insane ramblings.