News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by monsecchris on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:56PM (#34129962)
The people trying to minimise every intelligence agency working with every tech company on behalf of the Democratic Party are the same people calling this a dangerous far right conspiracy theory not long ago.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by phphphphp on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:15PM (#34130183)
If any party was responsible for this FBI behaviour, surely it would be the party that was in power at the time? The Republican party were in control in 2020.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Fellshard on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:34PM (#34130388)
FBI has disjointed itself from the administrative branch entirely, having become more of a party apparatus by all available evidence. It will require reform from the inside by those operatives whose conscience remains intact.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by akiselev on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:50PM (#34130555)
The FBI? The party that tried to blackmail MLK into killing himself? That FBI?
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Fellshard on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:59PM (#34130654)
Institutions drift in loyalty and direction, but corruption and lack of accountability fester regardless. Is it difficult to believe that it continues to abuse its power, and will ally itself with whichever party endorses that abuse?
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by slenocchio on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:21PM (#34130247)
Not necessarily. The FBI doesn't change much from administration to administration, no?
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by phphphphp on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:25PM (#34130292)
Donald Trump famously had huge influence over the FBI (and more broadly, the justice department). He fired James Comey because he did not achieve Trump's desired political aims: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dismissal_of_James_Comey
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by hermitdev on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:27PM (#34130912)
The president merely has control of the heads of departments. They don't have control over the rank and file. It is notoriously hard to get rid of non-elected government officials...
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:23PM (#34130271)
Trump dismissed the FBI Director and picked the new one in 2017. That's a fairly significant change.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by retinaros on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:30PM (#34130341)
so? the history of mankind is built on people picking other people thinking they will do X while they will use all their force to do Y.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by bell-cot on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:47PM (#34130529)
Which is why the admirals of the Imperial Japanese Navy refused to attack Pearl Harbor when ordered to do so...right?

The ones who do Y instead of X are often pretty interesting. But that's partly because they're pretty rare.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by retinaros on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:14PM (#34130781)
putin was picked because they thought they could easily control this little spy…

as for pearl harbor. I know americans love to say they attacked for no reason… but that is just not true. what triggered it was the US embargo on oil. it seems history repeats itself btw…

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by hermitdev on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:29PM (#34130931)
The oil embargo was in response to Japanese Imperialism in the Pacific, having already conquered a fair amount of territory. It wasn't just out of the blue with Japan sitting there behaving themselves.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by hotpotamus on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:25PM (#34130294)
Not to mention the only party from which FBI directors have ever been appointed. It is not a culturally liberal/progressive federal agency in the slightest.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by machina_ex_deus on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:21PM (#34130242)
Schrodinger's conspiracy: in superposition of being a dangerous conspiracy theory and well known fact everyone knew and nothing interesting.

Of course, the status of a Schrodinger's conspiracy is only known when the truth is revealed and the conspiracy is measured.

When the truth becomes known, it is retconned to have always been known.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by doublepg23 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:51PM (#34131098)
“This isn’t happening.” => “It’s happening and it’s actually good.” Also seems popular lately.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by themagician on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:05PM (#34130042)
Not really. What are the intelligence agencies supposed to do if not exactly what is being “revealed”? Are they not allowed to talk to private companies or citizens?

If it was being revealed that they were making demands and forcing companies to do things that would be a serious issue. Instead they are asking, nicely, and even paying them for their time and work.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by asynchronous on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:08PM (#34130102)
They literally sent a list of accounts to Twitter and *demanded* “these are Russian disinfo, eradicate them” without any shred of evidence, so much so the analysts assigned to the ticket couldn’t find any links.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:16PM (#34130193)
Can you cite a source? Be specific.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:12PM (#34130141)
> "these are Russian disinfo, eradicate them"

The actual wording, of course, was this sort of thing:

"FBI San Francisco is notifying you of the below accounts which may potentially constitute violations of Twitter's Terms of Service for any action or inaction deemed appropriate within Twitter policy..." (https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fbi-employees-notified-twit...)

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Fellshard on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:19PM (#34130230)
If the FBI sends such an email, there is a tacit threat of criminal liability.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:21PM (#34130244)
That's really not how criminal liability works.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Fellshard on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:53PM (#34130586)
De facto more than de jour, given how the FBI has been operating.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by andsoitis on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:14PM (#34130178)
> these are Russian disinfo

And is that the case of those accounts? Do we have access to what 5ose accounts have propagated?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by elurg on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:12PM (#34130152)
The distinction between the government "asking nicely" and "making demands" is not strong enough. In theory could Twitter could have resisted but the costs would have been quite high.

The government should be prohibited from making such requests.

It's also apparent that regarding the Hunter Biden story the FBI outright lied in order to make web platforms censor the story.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by marcosdumay on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:25PM (#34130296)
> The distinction between the government "asking nicely" and "making demands" is not strong enough.

A democratic government is usually forbiden fron "asking nicely". So the difference is that one of those exists, the other doesn't.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:19PM (#34130227)
> The distinction between the government "asking nicely" and "making demands" is not strong enough. In theory could Twitter could have resisted but the costs would have been quite high.

Really? Companies do this all of the time. For example, how many billions did Apple lose for resisting the FBI’s requests with the San Bernardino shooter?

> It's also apparent that regarding the Hunter Biden story the FBI outright lied in order to make web platforms censor the story.

Can you be specific about this? The “Twitter Files” and all extent accounts say the opposite – and that was the best the right-wing media could find – and if you’re thinking about Zuckerberg’s interview, he specifically said the FBI did not make a request in this case.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by elurg on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:29PM (#34130333)
As far as I understand the FBI knew that the Hunter Biden story was real but encouraged everybody else to believe that it was a Russian hoax. Doesn't this count as lying? It's not just lying, it's explicit disinformation with an electoral goal.

This went so far that major web platforms blocked all forms of disagreement and the public dismissed it as a conspiracy theory. It was highly effective.

I hate Trump's guts but it's important to acknowledge the enormous amount of effort that went into covering up the behavior of Biden's son.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:44PM (#34130485)
Can you cite any of those claims? What’s been established in public and e.g. Zuckerberg’s interview was that they warned companies to be wary about another repeat of election interference, but nobody is saying that the FBI told them to kill this story.

> This went so far that major web platforms blocked all forms of disagreement and the public dismissed it as a conspiracy theory. It was highly effective

This is imaginary: I’m not even sure why you’re lying about something we all remember, especially since nothing in the laptop data was even substantial even if was all true.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by fragmede on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:53PM (#34130582)
Can we ever really be sure there weren't emails from Hillary Clinton that were deleted.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:28PM (#34130919)
This is really off-topic, but while we can’t prove that she never sent an email we can look at the lack of evidence of this happening and conclude it’s unlikely. For example, the Republicans had years to find evidence of someone receiving or mentioning an email which wasn’t turned over but found nothing. That tells us that anyone confidently claiming that it happened is lying because there’s a 0% chance that they’d have suppressed that evidence for the entire Trump administration.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by elurg on Monday December 26, 2022 @05:31AM (#34136443)
The FBI seized the laptop in December 2021, nearly an year before it was revealed. They knew it was real but they strongly encouraged media companies to "expect a leak". As a consequence of this the story was strongly suppressed and the general public came to believe the opposite of the truth.

It's true that the FBI didn't force companies to kill the story but the story was still killed as a result of FBI actions. Are you OK with the FBI misleading the public? Or are you going to argue that they are incompetent and genuinely believed that it was a Russian operation?

There is no proof that Joe Biden himself acted improperly but Hunter Biden did receive large consulting fees for performing no work - he spent his time on cocaine and hookers instead. This strongly indicates that he was hired for political connections.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Monday December 26, 2022 @07:29AM (#34137133)
The story wasn’t killed, it was front page news. The reasons it dropped off were accurate: Giuliani’s sloppy handling tainted the evidence and there wasn’t much there relevant to Joe Biden. Everyone already knew Hunter Biden had a drug problem but he wasn’t the candidate and there was no reason to think his father was going to pull a Trump and install him in the government.

Two years later, that’s held up well - despite a lot of attention, there hasn’t been anything of interest to come out of the dump, which is why Republicans have shifted to claiming the problem was some kind of coverup despite it not being covered up.

> Are you OK with the FBI misleading the public? Or are you going to argue that they are incompetent and genuinely believed that it was a Russian operation?

This is key to your misunderstanding: the FBI was on watch for a repeat of the election interference we saw in 2016. They didn’t mislead the public, so it’s not a question of anyone being okay with it because that never happened.

> This strongly indicates that he was hired for political connections.

Yes, and lots of rich kids fail up. The question is whether his father actually did something improper to help him. For example, did Joe Biden actually pull strings for Hunter’s clients or did he refuse to violate the ethical rules? If you want this to be a scandal that’s the kind of thing you need to show.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by joshuamorton on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:46PM (#34130508)
Just to clarify, what part of the hunter Biden story was "real"? The hunter Biden story can mean everything from "a laptop was found with hunters nudes, and it's discovery was probably influenced by Russian state assets" to "hunters laptop contains proof of misdealings my the president".

As far as I can tell, the first is more or less true and the second isn't.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by nkurz on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:13PM (#34132006)
I agree that the way the laptop was claimed to be found sounds incredibly suspicious, but I don't know of any current evidence that the laptop's "discovery was probably influenced by Russian state assets". When you say "the first is more or less true", are you including this part? If so, can you point to evidence linking the find to Russia?

For the second part, I'd also agree that the laptop does not contain clear evidence of wrongdoing by the president. It contains a lot more than just nude photos of Hunter, though. It's real in the sense that everything on the laptop is believed to be authentic. It offers insight of Hunter's business dealings, and I think hints that contrary to the president's claims, he was at least aware of some of the details of those dealings. As such, I think it's reasonable for people to want to inspect the contents and reach their own conclusion as to what it implies, rather than being prevented from doing so.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:29PM (#34132655)
> As such, I think it's reasonable for people to want to inspect the contents and reach their own conclusion as to what it implies, rather than being prevented from doing so.

I don’t disagree with the desire but that doesn’t make it legal, and in this case it really runs headlong into Giuliani’s incompetent effort to turn it into an October surprise. Much of the data can’t be authenticated and the signs of tampering mean it’s hard to trust. There are some things which have been verifiable (e.g. emails whose recipients confirmed them or with valid DKIM signatures) but the way they restricted access to Republican operatives for over a year suggests that they had no interest in letting people make up their own minds instead of the carefully constructed narrative being shopped around to loyalist websites.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by NaturalPhallacy on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:36PM (#34130977)
>The government should be prohibited from making such requests.

They are. The first amendment forbids the government from interfering with the press. They're ignoring it and hoping people don't know this fact. The fact that other media outlets aren't pointing this out, means they're all part of the same fascist tribe as the FBI.

Remember, fascism is the union of state and corporate power according to Mussolini's ghost writer. And it's what we're seeing here. The FBI and big tech being on the same side.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by nathias on Monday December 26, 2022 @01:21PM (#34140260)
yea, exactly, I really don't see how they got all of the people to cheer at this
[dead]
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by quacked on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:16PM (#34130201)
The middle step is "it's not a big deal/it doesn't affect you"
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by HideousKojima on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:42PM (#34130452)
The final stage is always "Yes, $GovernmentAgency did actually do $BadThing, and that's a good thing (TM)"
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by jimbob45 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:01PM (#34130672)
I thought Musk and co did a decent job showing that both the Democrats and the Republicans both had access to the tools of censorship and used them at regular intervals. This should have been a nice time for everyone to come together against tool misuse - if everyone is guilty, then there is no need to pass judgement. Instead both sides are blaming one another (justifiably) while ignoring their own misuse (unjustifiably).
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by hermitdev on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:33PM (#34130947)
It really doesn't matter that it was either Democrats, Republicans or both. It's that it was happening at all. The government should not be inserting itself into censoring speech of any kind, especially the sort they don't agree with. We have constitutional protections against this. It's bad, no matter which political party directed it.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Avshalom on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:15PM (#34130783)
Everything the FBI did here was under republican leadership. It's the fucking FBI, it's a fundamentally right wing organization that has always and will always be so.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by OrvalWintermute on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:33PM (#34132189)
> In District of Columbia County, DC 92.1% of the people voted Democrat

Washington DC is overwhelmingly a Democrat bastion, so, regardless of the political appointee SESers, the rank and file that live around DC are likely to have a specific political leaning.

Feel free to fact check this.

https://bestneighborhood.org/conservative-vs-liberal-map-was...

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:51PM (#34132864)
Now do the Virginia suburbs where a large fraction of them actually live — or, since the DC field office is about 5% of their total staff, the other 55 field offices.

DC’s residents skew Democratic for a reason: having such a large black population means that they don’t trust the party which has such a questionable racial history, and that’s important to understand because the FBI’s history means the same people who don’t vote for Republicans are not jumping to join an organization with its history.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by willcipriano on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:00PM (#34133724)
> DC’s residents skew Democratic for a reason: having such a large black population means that they don’t trust the party which has such a questionable racial history

Hmmm.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:07PM (#34133770)
Continue that thought?

I have a hunch that you’re about to repeat the usual conservative “the Democrats were the party of slavery” claim which assumes the reader is unaware of the Southern Strategy half a century ago[1], but I’d love to be wrong in that pessimism.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by willcipriano on Monday December 26, 2022 @08:08AM (#34137337)
Ahh yes, the southern strategy also know as "to win elections in the south we should do what the Democrats are doing"

Go ahead and tell me when the parties "switched": https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_senato...

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Monday December 26, 2022 @08:24AM (#34137425)
I would suggest reading the link I gave you previously, which covers the evolution in detail.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by willcipriano on Monday December 26, 2022 @08:40AM (#34137536)
No it doesn't.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by dragonwriter on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:13PM (#34133816)
> DC’s residents skew Democratic for a reason: having such a large black population means that they don’t trust the party which has such a questionable racial history

This seems odd if you think about it in terms of long term party history, because from the founding through the New Deal the Democrats were first and foremost the party of the white Southerners bent on the most extreme de jure racial discrimination (slavery, and then Jim Crow, etc.), and from the New Deal through the Civil Rights Act of 1964 things were more complicated, but they still had that same base as a key constituency; that didn’t really change until Johnson embraced the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Republicans followed up the way that had not done with previous times Democratic leadership had alienated that part of the base by actively courting them, especially starting in the 1968 Presidential election.

But you have to realize when discussing D.C. political parties, the District didn’t get to vote for President at all until 1964, didn’t get to vote for a (nonvoting) delegate to Congress (after 1874) until 1970, and didn’t get to vote for its local government until 1974. The history of electoral politics for D.C. residents is much shorter than for most of the rest of the country, and consists almost entirely of the period since the Republicans started actively courting racists as a key constituency.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by acdha on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:28PM (#34133895)
Yes - and these were self-reinforcing since you had huge shifts following the 1968 riots which caused a lot of people to move to the suburbs, removing them from the DC electorate. Combined with the way the District tends to get more pointless meddling & fiscal sabotage when Republicans control the House and that spread isn’t likely to change anytime soon.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by lovich on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:41PM (#34131010)
>… on behalf of the Democratic Party…

This persecution complex the Republicans have promulgated is amazing with how widely believed it is. The republicans have controlled the reigns of power repeatedly over the past few decades and for a greater number of elections than you’d anticipate looking at the popular vote. The timeline the Twitter files is talking about was explicitly during Republican control and not something like a month after the elections where bureaucratic momentum might have still been in play but years after they had taken the executive and legislature. The FBI head was 2-3 years into his job after being placed by a Republican president at this point.

How are they possibly working as an arm of the Democratic Party?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by OrvalWintermute on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:22PM (#34132100)
I'd describe this more as the weaponization of the Establishment Uniparty against any rivals, whether they be populists, anti-war Left, or even the more communist Left.

Pretty much everyone that does not support the establishment line is a target.

This is why Biden is inch an Establishment soldier as George H.W. Bush was, despite their relatively minor policy differences.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by lovich on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:00PM (#34132420)
What does anything you just posted have to do with the parent comment talking about intelligence agencies working with every tech company on behalf of the Democrats.

Singling out Democrats doesn’t imply “Uniparty”. And this was the “outsider’s”(Trump’s) FBI attempting to get Twitter to censor things. How is that the “uniparty” working against populists like Trump?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by mynameishere on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:45PM (#34131702)
People have a curious inability to imagine "What if the other side was doing this?" If the FBI was regulating content on Twitter (and god knows where else) in order to swing the election towards Trump, it would be 24/7/365 outrage from liberals for years.