News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by p1esk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:33AM (#34090812)
I grew up on a street named after him, but I had no idea who he was until now. Fascinating.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by psychoslave on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:19AM (#34091053)
I’m rather surprised he might not be not better known here.

Kropotkin is a major figure of anarchism that you’ll found revered even in some Russel's books. Surely hackernews readership red all Russel works — both color, didn’t it?

Don’t you search for a Wikipedia biography each time you cross an antonomastic street, creating it if needed?

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by avodonosov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:37AM (#34091144)
In some countries almost every street is named after a person, so it would be too much trouble to research every street name.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by cuteboy19 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:01AM (#34091273)
We had a Minsk Square in Bangalore too. They are sister cities
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by avodonosov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:32AM (#34091531)
Yes, I learned that at some point. You say "had" - I hope it's not renamed / destroyed?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by ngc248 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:09AM (#34092200)
Its still there ...
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by lynx23 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:36AM (#34091135)
Who is Russel? And why should HN readers lean towards leftism terror^W^Wanarchism?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by mad_tortoise on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:27AM (#34091479)
If you consider the ideological philosophy of anarchy as 'leftism terror', then you only serve to out yourself as having no idea of the tenets of anarchism itself.

He is also not saying HN readers should lean that way, but having an intellectual and enlightened view on life, often means having read up on multiple ideologies, theories or philosophies. Which if the HN reader base would generally consider themselves well read, then it is quite possible many would know about one of the most famous political and philosophical minds in history, Petr Kropotkin.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by AnimalMuppet on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:18PM (#34096538)
> one of the most famous political and philosophical minds in history, Petr Kropotkin.

That's rather a stretch. What's your threshold for "most famous"? Top ten? Top one hundred? Top thousand? Top ten thousand? If it's top ten, no way. If it's top ten thousand, yes, he's definitely in. Top thousand? Probably in. Top hundred? Probably out.

But if your definition of "most famous" is "top thousand", I suspect that your threshold is in a different place than most peoples'...

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by mad_tortoise on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:04AM (#34116443)
I would ultimately say he is top one hundred (probably top 20 for me), but that's a personal opinion. If we look at the impact his ideas, beliefs and teachings had on the first half of the 20th century then he was a giant. Anarchism, and specifically how he taught it grabbed hold of much of the disparate political movements that occurred in that part of time. Anarchist movement's and mutual aid, take a grip in many parts of the third world even today.

Perhaps that's because I have taken note of these movements that I see him as one of the most famous, perhaps you see it differently which is fair. I see him as a contemporary to arguably the most famous political mind of all time, Karl Marx, and was regarded along similar lines for his impact.

Sure there are a range of people on the left and right of political ideological thought who could be considered famous, but not many who have produced what he has.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by TaylorAlexander on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:23AM (#34091069)
I’m very familiar with Kropotkin, but not Russel.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by DocTomoe on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:37AM (#34091566)
Oh boy, do you have an opportunity here. I suggest starting with "Understanding History and Other Essays".
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by TaylorAlexander on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:12PM (#34096456)
Ohhhh Bertrand Russell... Yeah he is great. I have just never heard anyone refer to him without including his first name.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by shmerl on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:26AM (#34091092)
Nestor Makhno considered himself a student of Kropotkin.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by culi on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:28AM (#34091491)
If anyone's unaware: famous Ukrainian anti-anti-semitist/anarchist revolutionary who lead a peasant revolt that supported farmer communes in much of Ukraine before getting crushed by both the White and Red Army

pro-russian tankies hate him

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:16AM (#34091834)
fwiw, even Lyube has a song memorialising Makhno, Батька Махно, and I don't know if they're considered tankies, but they're definitely tankie-adjacent (they sang at the pro-"Z" concert at the start of the invasion, ffs).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRMfa6MSAaY

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by shmerl on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:33PM (#34098270)
I suppose they aren't too bright then.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by pessimizer on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:50AM (#34093175)
Pro-Soviet, not "pro-Russian."
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by culi on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:17PM (#34095772)
I was specifically referring to the vein of tankies that are pro-Russia in the ongoing invasion of Ukraine (yes they exist)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:01PM (#34098623)
There may be less distance than we think.

I'm not sure what's going on in https://youtu.be/LffLqUwlY2Y?t=200 , but would not be surprised if it's something to do with rehabilitating Stalin (of the eponymous tanks)?

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Andrew_nenakhov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:36AM (#34090830)
It's really weird seeing letter ё in English language title. I'd rather spell his name as "Pyotr Kropotkin" or even "Peter Kropotkin", following a commong convention to spell Russian tzar Pyotr Romanov's as Peter.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by usrnm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:49AM (#34090898)
I actually like it, it's a great idea. You wouldn't be surprised if you saw words like Köln or Malmö (or even Malmø) in an English text, right, so how is this different?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by pavlov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:41AM (#34091167)
Cyrillic letters mostly don’t map to Latin based on visual similarity.

If you’re going to use Ë because it looks the same, then logically you’d have also use P instead of R, X instead of Kh, etc.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by culi on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:31AM (#34091514)
english orthography is so fucked up it's kinda fun seeing people desperate try to hold together different conventions loosely mapped to the phonetics they're supposed to represent
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by atoav on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:16AM (#34091030)
AFAIK when going from one language to another you often have known transliterations. Sometimes that can be a mapping from "Ö" to "Ö".

For cyrillic a fixed transliteration is both more needed. "o" and "ö" sound different, but even if you pronounced any "ö" as "o" everybody would understand what you meant. This is different for cyrillic where there are many letters where typical western readers wouldn't even know how to pronounce them. A "Щ" would look like a weird "W", but is romanized as "shch" or "sch".

Even more extreme examples would be the romanization of japanese.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by neontomo on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:15AM (#34091024)
It's different because in English, a diacritic of two dots (diaeresis) is used to show that a vowel is pronounced separately from the vowel that came before it, not as a mix. Naïve is one example, where it is pronounced na-ive, not nive. That said, I also like it, but it means something different here.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by usrnm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:20AM (#34091057)
You probably meant French, because the word is just borrowed from French, including the dots.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by coeneedell on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:56AM (#34092793)
In older texts the notation appears on other words like coöperation. Some Americans use dieresis in their names as well (Zoë and Chloë are increasingly common for example). Furthermore the dieresis (trema in French) in naïf is doing the same job as a dieresis in English, so it can be easy to make the claim that we got all dieresis from French, but in reality it seems to have been borrowed from Ancient Greek as late as the 1600s, and gone directly from Ancient Greek texts to the languages that use the notation today (Galician, English, French, Occitan, Dutch)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:27AM (#34091096)
> in English, a diacritic of two dots (diaeresis) is used to show that a vowel is pronounced separately from the vowel that came before it, not as a mix.

You've correctly defined diaeresis, but it's not actually used in English except in articles that get published in The New Yorker. There is a reason the common English name for the diacritic is "umlaut".

The normal use in English is to show that a word comes from German. There are some old relics like naïve (commonly spelled naive, now) and Laocoön (again, now usually spelled Laocoon). To the best of my knowledge a diaeresis has never been applied to the name "Menelaus" even though it "needs" one just as badly as Laocoon does.

> Naïve is one example, where it is pronounced na-ive, not nive.

The diaeresis there really just shows you that the word is borrowed from French, where it has a diaeresis for internal French reasons. (Because, again, English spelling does not include the concept of diaeresis.) It certainly doesn't tell you not to pronounce the word as "nive" (I assume you're referring to the PRICE vowel) -- the ordinary reading of the written vowel sequence "ai" would use the FACE vowel, as in plain, main, strain, vain, tail, wail, pail, sail, mail, plaice, taint, and waive.

Note that the Russian letter Ё does not have a diacritic - the two dots are an integral part of the letter, and it is not related to the visually similar Russian letter E. As noted upthread, it is the iotified form of the letter O. (Russian has five or six non-reduced vowels, but for historical reasons the Russian alphabet has eleven vowels, including a / e / i / o / u plus ya / ye / y / yo / yu.)

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by usrnm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:04AM (#34091298)
> it is not related to the visually similar Russian letter E

Well, it is very much related to it historically, but it's beyond the point. Just nitpicking, sorry

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by neontomo on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:21AM (#34091410)
Sorry mate, but an umlaut does not represent the same thing as a diaeresis! I don't know what you're arguing for other than that the diaeresis is archaic, which does not conflict with what I said at all. My argument was that the ë used in Russian is different from the ë used in English (and French) because they represent different things, which is exactly what you said too.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:28AM (#34091496)
A diaeresis mark is not used in English. You claimed that it was. That's what I'm saying. There is no ë used in English.

> Sorry mate, but an umlaut does not represent the same thing as a diaeresis!

You're going to need to decide what you're talking about. The diacritic of two dots positioned above a letter is most often called "umlaut" in English. It is not normally called "diaeresis", but sometimes it is.

There is a phonological phenomenon also called "umlaut", which is related to the name for the mark in that the mark was historically used in German to indicate the phenomenon. The relationship is dead now; German ö is just a different letter from German o.

Don't get confused between https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umlaut_(linguistics) and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umlaut_(diacritic) .

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by int_19h on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:54AM (#34091689)
> The normal use in English is to show that a word comes from German.

I can't think of any such examples similar to "naïve". Stuff like "ü" shows up in German names - and that's because the modern English convention is to not transliterate names that are already spelled in some kind of Latin script, even if it means dealing with weird digraphs, diacritics, or letters like ð. This doesn't work for Cyrillic, though.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by coeneedell on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:58AM (#34092806)
It absolutely is used in English, although not commonly, and it was more common in older texts. Nowadays it’s mostly used in proper nouns like Zoë, Chloë, and in some spellings of my own name, Coën.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by JustinVx on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:11AM (#34091002)
Well it’s different as in this case it’s translated from a Cyrillic alphabet. Also, I would be surprised to read Köln in English as an English name exists for the city: Cologne.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by usrnm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:26AM (#34091089)
So? I'm going to transliterate stuff from Russian with ё from now on, it just looks great. A language is whatever we want it to be, after all
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Andrew_nenakhov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:24AM (#34091433)
You'll hardly achieve anything by it, besides really breaking spellchecking software.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by iakov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:42AM (#34092723)
And annoying the language speakers. Pёtr is painful to read. Peter, Pyotr, Peter, Пётр, pick any, but don't mix and match please!
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:09AM (#34092856)
What about the other way? Would it be legit to transliterate the english nickname Pete as Пить?

Много городов у вас в России))

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by iakov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:35AM (#34093632)
That is how it is done when translating literature, right? Pete becomes Пит - just like you are pronouncing Pete.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by vkazanov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:57AM (#34091250)
This is not transliteration. It would be "pyotr" then. This is just using a German letter in an English text based on a purely visual similarity to a Russian letter.

This is wrong on so many levels...

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by ul5255 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:33AM (#34091538)
I do not know where the inspiration cam from but that e with inverted commas is not a German letter
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by vkazanov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:45AM (#34091622)
I have to admin: no idea as well.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by int_19h on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:42AM (#34091593)
Good transliteration is not arbitrary; it's supposed to make it possible for the reader who doesn't know the original language to reasonably approximate the pronunciation.

In your other examples, all the sounds would be considered "o-like" (rather than "e-like") in most languages with a 5-vowel phonology or similar. A reader might not be able to parse the diaresis, but if they say it with a plain "o", it's a reasonable approximation.

But then "ё" in "Пётр" is really just [ʲo] phonetically, so it should, ideally, be reflected by "o" or some derivative glyph in transliteration for readers to be able to understand and pronounce it with any semblance of accuracy. Something like "Pötr" would probably be best, actually, since in most alphabets that have "ö", it's used for [ø] or similar, which would give a more accurate approximation of [ʲo] than just [o].

OTOH the Latin "ë" (when present in the alphabet, which is much rarer to begin with) tends to stand for [ə], so it would be most logical to use it to distinguish "э" from "е". Note that this can be treated as a consistent pattern: a diaresis over the vowel inverts its "default" frontness (front vowels become back, back vowels become front) to simulate the corresponding presence or absence of [ʲ]. Thus we can then also write "ä" for "я", "ü" for "ю", and "ï" for "ы".

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by dundarious on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:43AM (#34091602)
Diaeresis is used in English as well. The New Yorker writes “coordinate” as “coördinate”. It has the same meaning as in many European writing systems — “pronounce independently”. So it’s like “co ore” not like “core”.

It’s also common to see it in loan words and proper names, even with a different meaning.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by rippercushions on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:14AM (#34092229)
In Russian ë is a completely separate letter pronounced "yo". This is non-intuitive to English speakers, which is why the name in question is almost always anglicized as Pyotr, not "Pëtr".
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by dundarious on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:52AM (#34092779)
> It's really weird seeing letter ё in English language title.

It’s not, for the varied reasons I gave. I know that this is yet another variant. I agree there is a problem with it in that its meaning is not well-known (so you may want to use more well-known alternatives), but not that the diacritic itself is “weird” or foreign to English language users.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by pessimizer on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:52AM (#34093202)
It's weird because it doesn't make sense, not because it's a diacritic.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by aliher1911 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:55AM (#34091691)
Fully agree with the view that ё seems out of place and looks like TETЯIS of atari days. Never the less I think you should be careful when generalizing monarch's name conventions more widely. For example King Charles III is called Karl in Russia according to tradition of using german names for monarchs. I never saw this convention applied to common folk names, and any other Charles would be called Charles e.g. Charles Darwin is never called Karl Darwin.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Andrew_nenakhov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:44AM (#34092026)
When it comes to English kings, Charles becoming Karl is not that bad, comparing to James, which somehow becomes Яков (Iakov?!). It is also a mostly one way effect, as Russian names are usually transliterated into English without some special weirdness, even royal names.

Anyway, it is very common to transliterate Пётр as Peter, though Pyotr seems even more common.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Jorengarenar on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:00AM (#34092128)
>James, which somehow becomes Яков (Iakov?!)

Quoting Wikipedia: "It is a modern descendant, through Old French James, of Vulgar Latin Iacomus, a derivative version of Latin Iacobus, Latin form of the Hebrew name Jacob"

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Andrew_nenakhov on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:22AM (#34092273)
Well thanks, Cap! ;)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by romwell on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:05AM (#34090981)
Incidentally, I've just been unpacking moving boxes, and put the beautifully illuminated [1] print of Mutual Aid on my "to-read" bookshelf.

I wonder how often this particular instance of Baader-Meinhof phenomenon happens on HN, i.e. what's the intersection of regulars here and people familiar with names like Kropotkin, Makhno, etc.

[1] PM press edition: https://www.pmpress.org/index.php?l=product_detail&p=1272

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:31AM (#34093600)
It's not difficult to find Kropotkin's name popping up in many places online.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by romwell on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:02PM (#34097883)
Of course it's not. I just wonder how common it is with people who frequent HN, which is a very unrepresentative sample of the population.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:48AM (#34091196)
Interesting. While reading this, I wondered idly if solidarity might be more acceptable phrasing than mutual aid in the US?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by FireInsight on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:52AM (#34091672)
I'd say that it could be confusing, since people often "Stand in solidarity" without any actions, but "Giving mutual aid" is something active, like protesting, monetary aid, a large scope if things.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by civopsec on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:06PM (#34100139)
Solidarity is all about mutuality… doesn’t matter what pretenders and virtue signallers in the digital age try to lead you to believe.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by dluan on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:59AM (#34091716)
Solidarity usually means a specific action - e.g. joining a strike action, critical support, organizing, etc. Mutual aid usually means intra class action.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by psychoslave on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:14AM (#34091827)
In French you would translate solidarité and entre-aide respectively each term, so they worth having each a dedicated word.

Actually I was surprised when I wanted to find a straight forward equivalent to "entre aide". It seems that "interhelp" is sufficiently obvious for having an organization taking this name, but this apparently not an idiomatic word per se.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:51AM (#34092068)
After 5 minutes L1 reflection, my most idiomatic translation for « entre-aide » would be not a word but the phrase "one hand washes the other".
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by richiebful1 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:12AM (#34093405)
Mutual aid is a fairly common term in my region:

https://www.lpm.org/news/2022-11-27/eastern-ky-mutual-aid-gr...

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by n8cpdx on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:46AM (#34093757)
Anarchists seem to think they have a monopoly on mutual aid, but it turns out that police agencies are all about it as well. At least where I’m at, people think that mutual aid is the secret sauce they have to defeat the efforts of the state, not realizing that just in Portland they have the city, multiple counties, Metro, and several neighboring suburbs strategically sharing resources and cooperating, even across state lines.

I observe that mutual aid between well-structured and stable organizations of well-trained people is even more effective than mutual aid between lone actors and temporary self-organizing cliques.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:07AM (#34094813)
that seems to be a crux: how to get (and utilise) well-trained people while avoiding long-lived organisations.

(to some degree, one might argue that back in the day, Silicon Valley was an example of successfully recombining groups of well-trained people, each of whose career-length might involve participation in over a dozen different hierarchal entities; in the 1970s this promiscuity was considered radical.)

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by OkayPhysicist on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:57PM (#34096260)
Mutual aid is right now innocuous enough to act as a pretty good left-wing shibboleth. Depending on whether a group refers to their activities as "charity", "service", or "mutual aid", you can get a pretty good idea of how left-wing the general consensus of the group is.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by acabal on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:53AM (#34091227)
I produced a free ebook edition of Mutual Aid for Standard Ebooks last year: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/peter-kropotkin/mutual-aid

It's very readable and quite interesting. It aimed to have a veneer of science, when the science of animals and nature was still fairly undeveloped; and it succeeded in a sense, because its observations are still held in regard, but I think it succeeded much better as a work of philosophy.

In any case, it suffers a little for what I think is the naive thesis of "if only mankind could cooperate like the animals do, we would live in a utopia." Of course, mankind has demonstrated through thousands of years of history that tribes of men can't really cooperate in any grand sense, so the point seems rather moot.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by culi on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:22AM (#34091420)
In what ways has mankind demonstrated that "tribes of men" can't cooperate? Humans have been able to live in large decentralized polities for millennia and modern archeology strongly backs this up. Göbekli Tepe (~11kya), the still-standing mammoth houses of North Eastern Europe (~15kya), or perhaps best exemplified by "the new archaic" or "monuments without kings"[^0] which is a term used by archeologists to describe the study of certain North American monument sites like Poverty Point where massive complex monuments were built by mobile groups of foragers without the need for permanent habitation. These massive geo-engineering projects were taken on by many different independent but connected tribes of peoples.

Wherever you look we see constant evidence of humanity's ability to cooperate to achieve grand accomplishments. I mean we're on the internet ffs. Ever heard of Wikipedia? Or how most modern tech companies are only possible because of the massive efforts of the open source communities? These aren't really new behaviors for humanity. In fact, I'd argue that if you take a look at the way language evolved you'd find a lot of support for the idea that it's actually a defining characteristic of humanity

[^0]: https://documents.saa.org/container/docs/default-source/doc-...

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:37AM (#34091974)
Mutual Aid Among Animals mentions the existence of Defectors. I would argue both that the existence of the internet in particular and civilisation in general is a sign that great numbers of people can cooperate effectively, and that the woeful Covid response is a sign that small numbers of people defecting can be ruinous.

The best laid plans of mice and men, therefore, would seem to be those that (a) allow Cooperators to combine with at least linear effect, and (b) are resistant to sizeable Defecting populations.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by robertlagrant on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:30AM (#34092656)
Defectors implies authoritarianism, and my way or the highway thinking. which have generally been the enemy of overall cooperation. Wikipedia and the internet work because they mostly aren't like that, and are at their worst when they are.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Gravityloss on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:40AM (#34092718)
Hmm, if someone "defects" wikipedia and doesn't edit it, no big deal.

But there absolutely are edit wars and battles of authority and admin bans etc.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by robertlagrant on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:30AM (#34093001)
Indeed. Hence my final phrase :)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:08AM (#34093361)
OK, so what model of overall cooperation would avoid Wikipedia drama?

(having seen humanity's response to Covid, I'm not willing to admit "the spirit of full cooperation will bloom as defecting behaviour withers away" as axiomatic. But I am curious as to what you have in mind?)

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by robertlagrant on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:46AM (#34093751)
I don't have an alternative for Wikipedia. I'm saying we shouldn't lean into any (always seductive) way of thinking that demonises people who disagrees with our one true way of doing things. People should be herded cats; neither wild cats nor herded sheep.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:53AM (#34093843)
Agreed. What terms might be better than the game-theoretic Cooperator and Defector, then?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:58AM (#34092804)
Defect and Cooperate are terms of art: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner's_dilemma#Generalized...

In a "one hand washes the other" model of cooperation, the right hand would be defecting if it was frequently washed by the left, while never (or infrequently) washing in return.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:22AM (#34093510)
I think the woeful Covid response shows how powerful culture is in shaping human behavior.

This is simultaneously terrifying and a source of optimism.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by jrochkind1 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:41AM (#34093091)
I think Kropotkin would agree with you rather than GP. Check out his books for yourself if interested.

But I read his work in part as a response to the influence of "darwinism" at the time, which had people thinking evolution meant that we were evolved to compete with each other viciously. Kropotkin argued that this is a misreading of natural history and the effects of evolution, that in fact cooperation was just as much a factor in natural selection, in surivivability, that all creatures were in fact "evolved" to cooperate -- including humans, and for sure there are many many places where intensive cooperation is visible in human history. If humans have of late often chosen on a mass scale to mistreat and kill each other, that's a result of humans apparently unusual level of ability to choose their "culture", and not a predestined result of evolution.

Is what I get as a summary of one of Kropotkin's theses. I think he would fully agree that cooperation is one of the defining characteristics of humanity, would fully agree that humans are "built for cooperation".

He was thinking and writing in the Victorian era, and his approach to "science" is characteristic.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by cuteboy19 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:07AM (#34093994)
There would be no point in competing with someone who has the same genes as you since it is the genes that drive evolution. Going further, the more different the genes the more you would want to compete.

So this means that you would cooperate most with your parents then your siblings, then your family, tribe, race and species.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by jrochkind1 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:24AM (#34094218)
That is not Kropotkin's analysis; it is a very commonplace current "evolutionary biology" analysis.

I don't really want to get into the whole argument here -- it's one of those that we will go on forever with.

But the Kropotkin point of view would probably point out that humans as a species (and any species, in fact) have improved survivability and natural selection when we cooperate with those in our communities/populations without regard for family relations.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by cuteboy19 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:29PM (#34095936)
That may be true but we do not observe it in nature. Most mammals would prioritize their own offspring over others. "Without regard" is very rare to see
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by jrochkind1 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:36PM (#34096011)
I think what "we observe in nature" is debatable. Kropotkin was taking part in that debate, although it was over 100 years ago.

But apparently in 1998, respected evolutionary biologist Stephen Jay Gould found Kropotkin to be "no crackpot" too. (Article found from wikipedia reference).

https://www.marxists.org/subject/science/essays/kropotkin.ht...

There's plenty of cooperation between population members not directly related observed in nature, that's literally what Kropotkin's whole book is about.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by annadiru on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:46PM (#34096861)
Nature ecologies are so full of examples of mutual aid across all types of life that we are still discovering new relationships everyday. I'd like to see an updated collation of all these findings since kropotkin's writigs. Any suggestions?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by culi on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:55AM (#34102992)
I think the main thing missing from this simplistic analysis (which I would tie back to Dawkins' "The Selfish Gene" and the gene-centric view of evolution it proposed) is that organisms don't need to just replicate themselves, but also their environments. I mean look at lichen. A small colony of organisms from completely different domains of life and they would die without each other yet that algae would obviously prefer to replicate the fungi it partners with over some other species of algae. Bison need to keep grasslands healthy, worms need to keep the soil organisms alive, mycorrhizal fungi need to keep plants alive, plant roots have a large toolbelt of chemical dances it does JUST to cultivate the specific soil bacteria they like, our gut bacteria have it in their interest to keep us humans thriving and interacting socially, myrmecophyte trees attract and support ant life, capitalism needs to replicate artificial scarcity, parasitic plants like dodders actually provide a whole host of benefits to its hosts like acting as an above-ground communication network, beavers practice "niche construction", most "weeds" occupy a specific niche where they grow in disturbed soils only to "work themselves out of a job" by conditioning the soil to better health allowing for ecological succession to take place (e.g. dandelions decompacting soil), and your dog would very likely kill another dog (extremely genetically similar as they are) in order to save your life.

In the 1990s a cholera outbreak in South America created an interesting natural experiment. In some countries it was a deadly disease that spread through waterways. But in places with better hygiene, it couldn't spread through those typical pathways. So it eventually evolved into a much milder form in order to allow people to go out and socialize so it can continue to spread

This is why every single deadly pandemic has been zoonotic in origin. The black plague, covid, hiv, etc all came from other animals. It's a matter of maladaption. All the diseases that have been closely associated with humans for thousands of years have instead evolved to... not kill us. Some of them even became an essential part of our microbiome. Even herpes, a rather ancient human "parasite", actually plays some beneficial roles in our immune system. The microbial universe is a prime example of how organisms need not only replicate themselves but also the environments in which they thrive

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by rowanajmarshall on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:35AM (#34091959)
> mankind has demonstrated through thousands of years of history that tribes of men can't really cooperate in any grand sense

I'd argue the fact that humans can live in reasonably stable polities of more than a billion people proves, and in an economic space of practically the entire planet (globalisation!) proves we absolutely can cooperate at grand, epic scales.Whether or not that means Kropotkin is right is another thing, but we're built for cooperation.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by PeterisP on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:31AM (#34092324)
I'd argue that the fact that humans can live in reasonably stable polities of more than a billion people only proves that there exist social systems and structures which can achieve reasonable outcomes even without cooperation by incentives which ensure that agents who do not intend to cooperate but act competitively and even maliciously still act reasonably out of pure self-interest and fear of retaliation for defecting.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by PartiallyTyped on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:32AM (#34092327)
We are not cooperating at grand scales, not in what matters to the average person, but we certainly cooperate on helping the rich get richer.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:25AM (#34093530)
Are you ignoring the billion and a half people that have been lifted out of poverty since the 50s or 60s? We can definitely cooperate to benefit the masses of humankind and we do.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by PartiallyTyped on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:58AM (#34094691)
Are you ignoring that despite knowing the consequences of climate change for a hundred or so years, "we" chose to ignore them for corporate profits?

What's the point of lifting anyone out of poverty if we are actively ruining our environment through obviously unsustainable behaviour?

How many more billions of people could we have brought out of poverty if the goal wasn't to improve bottom lines? What about all the displaced people due to wars for oil?

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:52PM (#34096943)
No, I'm not. Some of that wealth was created by externalizing costs in the form of pollution. Because that is how our society was designed and we did not have good alternatives until around the turn of the century. But most of it was not. Most was genuine wealth that improved many people's lives.

The point of lifting people out of poverty - which doesn't mean they have now have money; it more means they have more access to education, healthcare, and capital - is that those people are now in a better position to help us deal with the future challenges, climate change being one of them. In addition to their quality of life being much better. There is a significant bootstrapping effect.

>How many more billions of people could we have brought out of poverty if the goal wasn't to improve bottom lines?

We don't know. It is difficult to say what would happen in a different timeline. But if Mao-era China and the Soviet Union are any indication, what we decided upon was a much better outcome than that. If you can design a system where wealth is allocated in a way that creates more wealth than it does currently, plenty of folks are all ears. Lots of people in positions of influence like creating more wealth.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by PartiallyTyped on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:38PM (#34097537)
There is a mountain of difference between:

We did not have good alternatives, until we did; and

We suppressed progress, had people killed, and squashed all attempts at public ownership of the goods, launched defamation campaigns, buried people in lawsuits, had them locked in their homes or jail for no reason other than being a block at corporate earnings.

If you have to slave away your life to pay for access to education, you clearly don’t have access to it, you are paying with your life for it.

What wall street and the rich are asking for is absurd. Gains on top of gains, chasing growth on rate of growth.

People in places of influence care about creating more wealth for themselves. They clearly don’t care about the average person because they are not the average person.

lets assume for a moment that we don’t have access to space, we are confined on earth, and have finite resources to work with. Certain people by virtue of chance end up consuming orders of magnitude more resources by virtue of their lineage and the place they were born it.

By said virtue, they impose onto the rest of us their will, and make it so they don’t face any repercussions for their wastefulness.

Can you argue, in good conscience, that all the resources spent on and by somebody like Musk, are better spent on Musk than feeding families in Africa, building infrastructure and providing top notch education to have more doctors and researchers do stuff like, idk find cures to all the different forms of cancer that we have?

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:56PM (#34100626)
I think you're on the wrong forum.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:01AM (#34092815)
Domesticated animals are often more cooperative than their wildtype kin.

I suspect humans, over tens of thousands of years, have successfully domesticated not only b taurus and c familiaris, but also h sapiens.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by raybb on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:01AM (#34092139)
What was your experience like producing the book? Have you done it before? Did you previously read the book before producing?

If you already have a blog post or something I'd love to read it :)

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by specialist on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:11AM (#34093396)
> men can't really cooperate in any grand sense

Dawn of Everything shares the latest anthropology about prior societies. Spoiler: Science indicates a whole lot more cooperation than was previously assumed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dawn_of_Everything

I'm quite bullish on the future of cooperatives. Perhaps like the worker directed social enterprises advocated by Richard Wolfe.

One missing "technology" is better, more durable governance. Cooperatives have been vulnerable to corporate capture (or transmutation). Like the farmer's cooperatives of yore. And they need better protection against coups, usurpers.

But surely that's solvable. We have 1,000s of successful examples to learn from.

Imagine a world where participating in a home owner association, local government council, or a volunteer org's executive board wasn't considered cruel and unusual punishment.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:52AM (#34093827)
Whenever I see someone talk about The Dawn of Everything I like to link this series of video critiques.

https://youtu.be/oJIHWk_M398

The person critiquing generally agrees that humans are cooperative but he takes issue with the author’s general position that people kinda just decide to organize culture in a certain way. Instead the video creator offers a materialist perspective that I find a lot more compelling.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by andrepd on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:20AM (#34093481)
> Of course, mankind has demonstrated through thousands of years of history that tribes of men can't really cooperate in any grand sense

I'm assuming this is satire, but it's hard to tell via text.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by civopsec on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:22PM (#34100326)
> In any case, it suffers a little for what I think is the naive thesis of "if only mankind could cooperate like the animals do, we would live in a utopia." Of course, mankind has demonstrated through thousands of years of history that tribes of men can't really cooperate in any grand sense, so the point seems rather moot.

In one paragraph you say that his biological observations are still held in high regard. (Nothwithstanding that the science of such things was farily “underdeveloped”, he protested… you know, like how people massively protest against Darwin’s theories, from about the same era?) Then you take a dump on those same observations in the next paragraph because people who have lived in class societies, under strict hierachies (that’s all of recorded history, yes) weren’t nice to each other? Well… why do you think anarchists proposed an alternative to that?

You know what is utopian? To build a society on such a flawed human nature as what we have, centred around our selfish shortcomings—basing socity on on subjugation, oppression, and exploitation, so that (predictably) the ones who are vile and strong will take as much for themselves as they can and exploit the rest—see history—and for us collectively to doom ourselves by ruining the planet by pillaging it of its resources and all kinds of ecological balance. That’s utopian!

But congrats on your ebook project. Your pathetic little gloss demonstrates how classic literature is often wasted like pearls before swine.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by phillc73 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:00AM (#34091264)
The article links to a few book pages scanned as PDFs and an HTML version of Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution. Also worth mentioning is that there is a very large collection of Kropotkin's writing at the Anarchist Library[1], including an epub version of Mutual Aid[2] and his autobiography, Memoirs of a Revolutionist[3], which was also mentioned in the article.

[1] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/category/author/petr-kropotk...

[2] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petr-kropotkin-mutua...

[3] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petr-kropotkin-memoi...

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by derelicta on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:08AM (#34092536)
Kropotkin would weep to what has become Jura's anarchist dream. We may have reached independance from Bern but at the cost of a parlement filled with liberals and conservatives.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:12AM (#34092886)
any good reading for Jura's anarchist dream? (le français, ça joue)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by pimbrah on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:38AM (#34093064)
A movie "Unrueh" (Unrest) has just been released in the theaters about Kropotkin's Swiss period. Haven't seen it yet but it is on my list
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by 082349872349872 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:31AM (#34093604)
Tiptop (one wonders if an anarchist Jura would or would not have reacted in a more timely fashion to the invention of the quartz watch?)
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:45AM (#34093741)
Anarchism is an interesting topic, and learning about it has lead me down some interesting paths of learning and thought.

At its core, it’s the position of being against hierarchies of power where humans dominate those with less power. In simple terms, it’s being against humans dominating each other.

The big question is can we have a functioning society with less human domination and how far can we reduce it? That’s a deep question that involves everything from economics to the study of human nature.

In terms of human nature, I think people are far too quick to ascribe certain behaviors to human nature.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by greenie_beans on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:36AM (#34094373)
agreed. the human nature argument is a lazy one against something like anarchism or any other alternative system. if we can be socialized to seek money (it starts with the piggy bank when we're like 4 years old), we can be socialized to not seek those things and instead seek something else. replace "money" or "greed" with any negative way that humans behave, like power or domination.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:55AM (#34094638)
Yes, the environment we grow up in plays a huge part in our development. Everything from nutrition during development to culture, values, etc. All shape how we think.

I was learning recently about Christopher Columbus and his encounters with native peoples and it’s fascinating how differently these people thought. The natives had a hard time understanding the colonizers and their endless need for gold and things.

Eventually some of them theorized that the European’s god is actually gold lol.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by ausbah on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:02PM (#34095575)
where does the ability to mold humans to fit a certain set of standards end? incentives, culture, norms, etc. I think can shape someone's default mode of thinking and actions on the margin, but eventually you reach some point like the "New Soviet Man" where you're asking someone not to be human?
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by greenie_beans on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:43PM (#34096090)
i'm talking more about incentive structures as a way to encourage people to act towards the greater good within society, rather than having an individual fit a certain type. anarchism is all about individual self-determination, i.e. not trying to make everybody fit a certain set of standards.

but to your point of the new soviet man, how is that any different than the certain set of standards that we mold humans into today? we're raised to fit the status quo and be operatives for capital. we're compelled to look and dress a certain way, etc.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:51PM (#34096170)
I think that’s a pretty negative take. There are lots of positive ways that we can reduce dysfunction in humans.

For example we know that reducing poverty, increasing access to education, and increasing access to nutritious food increase IQ, and reduce crime.

In terms of culture, there is no such thing as a society without culture so why not build a culture based on kindness and mutual aid?

Our capitalist society makes us think the only answer is greed but it isn’t.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by annadiru on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:42PM (#34096807)
Collectively held norms and expectations are commonplace across cultures, otherwise how would we effectively cooperate? They are kinda like protocols. There are many ways to raise people to uphold those sets of customs without falling into the domination and homogenization traps.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by teachrdan on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:20PM (#34099640)
> like the "New Soviet Man" where you're asking someone not to be human?

I wonder if late American capitalism is doing the same with entrepreneur worship. Mainstream culture celebrates people who are self starters, constantly grinding, always on the lookout for unfulfilled human desires and new markets, sensitive to customers' feelings and individuality while somehow also completely indifferent to urgent systemic catastrophes like environmental destruction or the end of democracy (which require collective effort)...

This is not an ideology like Soviet dogma. But in capitalism's funny way, it's an omnipresent and coherent archetype nevertheless.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by throwayyy479087 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:59AM (#34094715)
>The big question is can we have a functioning society with less human domination and how far can we reduce it?

No, not with any scale. This has been tried and tried and tried. It's a nice idea, but like most of leftism, only works on paper.

I wish the people that argue for things like the destruction of the family would instead push for universal healthcare. That's at least doable.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by lghh on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:11AM (#34094860)
Big jump from "less human domination" to "destruction of the family" that you're making.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by throwayyy479087 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:17AM (#34094940)
I'm talking about stuff like this, rhetoric that's common in anarchist communities: https://www.instagram.com/p/CmUY0cjKsIE/

Humans are hierarchical creatures. It's emergent behavior, not forced upon us.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by yellowapple on Friday December 23, 2022 @03:15PM (#34110127)
I'm pretty active in anarchist (of the left-leaning variety) spaces and this is literally the first I've heard of family-abolitionism. That doesn't necessarily mean it ain't common, to be clear, but it does mean that this assertion that it is "common in anarchist communities" should probably be taken with a neighborhood-clearing and hydrostatically-equilibrious grain of salt.

At most, I've encountered calls to abolish the dependence on traditional family structures, in particular the assumption of a "nuclear family" baked into a lot of societal interactions. That doesn't mean abolishing families (nuclear or otherwise) themselves, but rather making it so that people who lack familial support systems (nuclear or otherwise) are not disadvantaged as a result of that lack.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by whitexn--g28h on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:17AM (#34094949)
Thinking your own family members are more important than others in the community leads to hierarchy.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by schizo89 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:38AM (#34095245)
As most things in life, it's just the surface meaning. The actual idea is denying that history have power over an individual
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by ausbah on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:08PM (#34095653)
I think that anarcho-capitalism, and to a lesser degree even libertarianism, is a fundamentally flawed philosophy because of it being against hierarchies that "suppress" their followers and in support of hierarchies that bolster them. In other words capital owners down playing the state and propping up "free market economics".
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by schizo89 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:17PM (#34096533)
There's much changed since the inception but the core idea of anarchism is abolishing central powers (and single truth) in favor of their own homemade belief system where government has no power over them and can't enforce their laws, because, hey, they're (anarchists) moved away from main stream.
Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:33PM (#34097484)
Communities with rules are not necessarily against the ideas of anarchism as long as participation in that community is voluntary.

Anarchism != chaos

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by serverholic on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:33PM (#34095979)
That seems like an odd definition of anarchism that leads to confusion.

And anarcho-capitalism has nothing to do with anarchism since capitalism is a system of domination. It’s just rebranded laissez-faire capitalism.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by OkayPhysicist on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:53PM (#34096205)
"Anarcho"-Capitalism has nothing at all to do with the Anarchism of Pyotr Kropotkin, in the same way the "National Socialists" aren't actually Socialists.

Just a right wing group co-opting left wing terminology to try and give their abhorrent beliefs credence.

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by Deprogrammer9 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:36AM (#34095212)
Why hello my hacker anarchist sisters & brothers. If anyone would like to listen to Mutual Aid and many, many other FREE anarchist audio-books as you drive or workout, have got the plug for you!

https://librivox.org/conquest-bread-2-by-peter-kropotkin/

https://librivox.org/anarchy-by-errico-malatesta/

https://librivox.org/god-and-the-state-by-mikhail-bakunin/

Re:Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid by hyperpape on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:07PM (#34095640)
Not on the subject of mutual aid per se, but the relation between Anarchism and Communism, late in his life, Kropotkin returned to Russia, and met Lenin. That meeting was documented: https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/kropotkin-peter/1....

A friend of mine described this as "essentially the same as every conversation between anarchists and communists today", which seems largely accurate. In particular, I enjoyed one comment:

> “No, no,” Kropotkin replied, “if you and your comrades think in this way, if the power is not going to their heads, and if they feel that they will not be going in the direction of oppression by the state, then they will achieve a lot. Then the revolution is truly in good hands.”

Draw your own conclusions.