News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by quirino on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:59AM (#34038873)
There's a subreddit called r/toprightmessi which is a collection of graphs showing how much Messi excels in so many respects. Crazy how in the biggest sport in the world there can be a player so far above and beyond the rest.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by OscarCunningham on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:11AM (#34039032)
With fat-tailed distributions, increasing the sample size actually makes it more likely that you'll get one element much greater than the others.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by SmooL on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:34AM (#34039326)
Yes, but if you have many fat tailed distributions, increasing the sample size makes it increasingly less likely that it's _the same person at the end each time_
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by OscarCunningham on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:48AM (#34039490)
This would imply that there's a single factor upstream leading to his exceptional ability in several measures downstream.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by cryptonector on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:17PM (#34040632)
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by ByThyGrace on Sunday December 18, 2022 @08:56PM (#34047289)
Recommended. For further context, it's the narration of an article written in Spanish by H. Casciari, translated to English.

It's a lovely but also profound literary article in the subject of Messi never losing sight of the ball, while also a critique on modern day analysis of the game and its influence on player behavior.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by cryptonector on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:15PM (#34048415)
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jonahx on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:21AM (#34039162)
Isn't the surprising part that it's fat-tailed rather than normal?
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by eloff on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:26AM (#34039235)
Why would it be? All careers with leverage seem to follow a Pareto distribution. It would surprise me if any sport, art, or creative endeavor was normally distributed.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jonahx on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:33AM (#34039313)
You're right. I was thinking the "initial talent" might be normal in the way IQ scores are, but the parent was talking about actual performance, where history, training, etc all come into play.

And empirically, you have Gretzky in hockey, Jordan in basketball....

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by eloff on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:39AM (#34039380)
I don’t even think initial talent is normally distributed. Take Usain Bolt, for example, he’d be a far outlier in a Pareto distribution for sprinters just on the basis of his natural heritage.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by OscarCunningham on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:52AM (#34039523)
IQ is normally distributed because it's graded on a curve to make that true by definition. I'm not sure how it's distributed on any sort of 'natural' scale.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by derbOac on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:02PM (#34039633)
No, it's scaled but linearly and not redistributed.

There's still studies of relatively raw distributions and it still looks normal. The biggest deviations from normality are due to an excess mass in the lower range due to disease, and a tendency for scores to spike a tiny bit at certain numbers, probably due to people administering the test fudging a bit sometimes for various reasons.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:53AM (#34039542)
What would such a natural scale look like?
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by derefr on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:42PM (#34040102)
Maybe a cross-species IQ score would be interesting. Chimpanzees and corvids both can solve many IQ-test problems, but also are not experiencing the Flynn effect as far as we know. So we could measure IQ in multiples of a chimp's IQ, just like we measure cars in multiple's of a workhorse's sustainable pulling output. (Which is actually a less objective measure, when you think about it; we were breeding workhorses to increase that very target at the time the concept of "horsepower" was invented!)
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:12PM (#34040552)
That would be a great start. And it would also force us to acknowledge that a lot of the things that we are doing with these animals are utterly un-ethical.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by OscarCunningham on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:55PM (#34040244)
I'm reminded of the paper 'Measuring universal intelligence: Towards an anytime intelligence test' https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000437021....
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:15PM (#34040606)
Thank you for the pointer.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by derefr on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:38PM (#34040058)
I suppose the distribution of aptitude would be a normal distribution in a world where careers were assigned randomly at birth and advancing in your career was on a strict seniority basis. So, for example, you'd see it in career paths that are mostly followed as generational family businesses.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by 082349872349872 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:36AM (#34039342)
keep in mind that even if football ability were (untrainable and) normally distributed, the distribution of ability among international players would be taken from one of the tails of that bell.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jonahx on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#34039820)
Also a good point. Do you know what the exact distribution would be when sampling randomly and rejecting all values below some threshold? You can tell it would at least be Pereto-ish in general shape.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by 082349872349872 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:47PM (#34041166)
I can't do much with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truncated_normal_distribution but maybe you can?
[dead]
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by brewmarche on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:45AM (#34039455)
All norms on finite-dimensional vector spaces are equivalent so the choice of norm shouldn’t matter for tails really.
[dead]
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by brewmarche on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:47PM (#34072300)
Norms are for dealing with magnitude not direction (and were brought up by my parent commenter). If you care about direction specify an angle, quadrant, cone or other subregion that allows you to take the limit to infinity which then doesn’t depend on the norm. Note this is the same in the univariate case where we talk about left and right tail if we need to distinguish.
[dead]
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by brewmarche on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:57PM (#34072430)
This is a standard result which you can look up in most text books, or here on StackExchange: https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/57686/understanding...

In the end it doesn’t whether we go to infinity in one norm or the other.

Note that I am talking about finite dimensions, so I guess you didn’t mean the L^p norms or \ell^p for integrable functions or sequences but the finite-dimensional p-norms.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by TreeRingCounter on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:20PM (#34095810)
This theorem is completely irrelevant - the equivalence relation described by the theorem does not imply an equivalence between ordinal relationships imposed by different choice of norm. Also, "tails" isn't the same as "at infinity".
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:04AM (#34038944)
Alternatively, is it due to the ubiquity of soccer that particularly gifted individuals can be developed into their full potential? Someone that has a one-in-a-billion level of skill in something like frisbee-golf is less likely to be spotted and made into a professional player.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Jenk on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:07AM (#34038980)
This is so true when looking at the distribution of top olympic athletes Vs distribution of countries that invest in developing said athletes in their chosen sport.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by derbOac on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:12PM (#34039746)
Do you know of any sites offhand that discuss this? I can look it up but wasn't sure if there were some you'd recommend. The thing you're mentioning seems really important as an example in these kinds of discussions.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by User23 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:04PM (#34088051)
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by derbOac on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:10PM (#34039731)
This is the weird thing for me about some of these discussions. I'm not going to question Messi's ability or ability in general but I've always wondered how much "extraindividual" factors start to play a role in those upper tails that are incentivized. We talk about Messi like he's just a marble sculpture handed down from God but that's not the case.

Looking at the figure, for example, one thing I noticed was the gap between the two upper points and the rest. It's hard for me to imagine there aren't some missing points there.

In other fields or areas, I think you have to start asking about things like fraud, other vice, or circumstances.

As you suggest, there's probably also some unique things about international football that make it difficult to generalize to other things. Everything is probably a little unique in certain ways really, but the incentives are so extreme and the play is very visible.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Enginerrrd on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:14PM (#34043492)
One thing to note is that the stats in the article don't appear to be normalized to me. It's just a lot of "# of X since 2010". So, it makes sense that the best will be played more often and get more play time to help drive the separation greater.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by browningstreet on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:35PM (#34040955)
As a fan of disc golf I pained and laughed at “frisbee-golf”. The distribution of talent and accomplishment in professional disc golf .. a relatively young sport .. wouldn’t surprise anyone here.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:40PM (#34041056)
Apologies for any discomfort - I clearly should have put "disc golf".
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by tipiirai on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:58PM (#34047829)
It’s called ”frisbee golf” in Finland
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Murfalo on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:56AM (#34053532)
US I've heard "frisbee golf" too, alternatively "frolf"/"frolfing"
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by User23 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:47PM (#34048224)
Sprinting is probably the purest example of no child not having a shot. Kids like to run. In fact, running is probably the most comprehensively sampled sport in the world. It's virtually impossible for anyone with a remotely normal childhood and a gift for sprinting to not know that they have it. Every kid knows who the fastest kid on their playground is. Every kid knows who the fastest kid in their class is, and in their school. And the fastest kids in each school/neighborhood/whatever compete at higher and higher levels until one day the fastest one is eating Chicken McNuggets[1] and signing 30 million dollar endorsement deals.

[1] https://olympics.nbcsports.com/2020/04/21/usain-bolt-beijing...

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by 11235813213455 on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:37AM (#34051342)
> fastest one is eating Chicken McNuggets

Usain Bolt did so on a special occasion, he explained he just didn't know where to eat

It's pretty obvious his average meal is not "fast" food, he would never have reached this level else

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:53AM (#34039531)
If you were to define some new sport from scratch tomorrow morning by the end of the afternoon the Bell curve would start to assert itself in those that chose to play in it and over time that would become more and more evident. Eventually a 'Messi' would turn up.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by dan-robertson on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#34039922)
You say bell curve, which I understand as meaning normally distributed, but the point about Messi is that he is better than what one would expect to find from normally distributed ability.

I think it is interesting to ask why Messi is such an outlier. But maybe you think the fact that someone has to be best makes it all uninteresting.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#34039963)
I think that effect comes from soccer being somewhat multi-dimensional: the ability to run fast, aim well, have stamina and so on.

And yes, I think that the fact that someone will be the best makes it uninteresting, or at least a lot less interesting than if a skill could be universally taught to the point where everybody would be very good at it and it would be productive.

Professional sports is roughly at the same level of interest to me as a circus.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by emmelaich on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:40PM (#34041065)
And yet Mbappé is better paid - most valuable in the world it is thought.

And his WC Final rival and PSG team mate.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by xenospn on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:08PM (#34048357)
His display today was nothing less than spectacular. I can’t wait to follow his career.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by CydeWeys on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:55PM (#34048656)
PSG has that Qatari money. Barca isn't quite as well funded.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by fndex on Monday December 19, 2022 @08:58AM (#34052053)
Messi plays for PSG too.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by MichaelZuo on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:37PM (#34041938)
Is there anyone else in the sporting world that's such a statistical outlier?
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Gunnerhead on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:17PM (#34042605)
Definitely Gretzky!
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by amenghra on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:31PM (#34042880)
Most athletes who are at the top of their sport when they reach age ~40 tend to be crazy outliers. I’m thinking Michael Schumacher (F1), Tom Brady (NFL), Roger Federer (tennis), etc.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by walthamstow on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:05PM (#34044087)
They are outliers because it's a brand new phenomenon. This generation has the first sportsmen to push 40 in a lot of sports, beit Federer, James Anderson, Brady, Ibrahimovic. It will become quite common as time goes on I expect.

p.s. Schumacher drove a car, so I'm not sure he is a fair comparison to physical sportsmen

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Daneel_ on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:41PM (#34044731)
Your postscript is a bit unfair to racing drivers - it's actually an incredibly physically demanding sport.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by walthamstow on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:05AM (#34049666)
I never demeaned racing drivers. I just don't think they are a fair comparison to physical sportsmen who turn and jink and sprint in an open physical space and the effect this has on their bodies.

Going past an opposition player in basketball, football or rugby is very similar. Sprinting to the line to keep a ball in play is something tennis players, footballers and cricketers all do.

Driving is entirely different, and not really comparable.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by alvah on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:31PM (#34045602)
F1 drivers are required to be extremely fit. Braking and cornering at over 4G for almost 2 hours, applying well over 300lb pressure to the brake pedal repeatedly, in cockpit temperatures over 110F, would destroy most athletes from other sports.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by walthamstow on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:09AM (#34049692)
Please see my reply to your sibling.

> would destroy most athletes from other sports

This is pretty hyperbolic, I wonder if you might like to reconsider it.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by pertymcpert on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:20AM (#34050094)
It’s not hyperbolic at all. Subject them to the same forces and you’ll see.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by alvah on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:24AM (#34050113)
It’s not hyperbolic in the slightest. Which other discipline would condition its participants to endure the combination of forces and temperatures over the duration I described above?
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by walthamstow on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:33AM (#34050953)
Doesn't that prove my point that they are completely different things and not comparable?

If you read my other comment you will see my line of reasoning. At no point have I denigrated racing drivers, so there's no need to rush to their defence.

I'm aware of F1 drivers' fitness. I'm also aware of the fitness of astronauts, another group who have immense endurance in tiny spaces. I just wouldn't compare them to Ibrahimovic and Federer.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by alvah on Monday December 19, 2022 @10:41AM (#34053345)
If that’s your point then yes, fair enough, there is no direct comparison. The way your original P.S. was worded gave the opposite impression though, and “racing drivers aren’t athletes” seems to be a POV many people have.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by adamjb on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:26PM (#34046394)
One of the reasons Schumacher was able to dominate was that he was one of the first F1 drivers to train for it as a physical sport.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by alvah on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:30AM (#34050153)
Martin Brundle said if he’d realised earlier in his driving career how vital fitness was, he would have achieved much more.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by shakesbeard on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:13PM (#34043485)
Don Bradman in Cricket.

Apparently, a good batting average for a modern-day batsman is 40+ with those above 50 being exceptional. Bradman's average was 99.94. The second highest average of all time is 60.97.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Bradman

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by nl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:25PM (#34044376)
It's difficult to emphasize what a complete statistical outlier Bradman is.

As the parent poster points out, the next highest average is in the low 60s (actually 61.87 now[1]). Looking at the stats though, we see averages are roughly a normal curve, centered on 40 with a standard deviation of a little over 9[2]. This puts Bradman over 6 standard deviations above average!

[1] https://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/content/records/282910.htm...

[2] https://www.significancemagazine.com/sports/24-did-don-bradm...

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by gravelc on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:33PM (#34048102)
I'd be surprised if anyone in any large scale sport ever dominated like Bradman or will be as dominant in the future. He missed part of the prime of his career due to WW2, so who knows what could have happened if he'd avoided the interruption.

He's probably not as well known as someone like Gretzky in North America, so his name wouldn't immediately spring to mind on forums like this. In cricket, there just isn't any debate about the greatest - the only area of interest is about who comes next (Viv Richards or Brian Lara in my opinion)

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by nl on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:47PM (#34058888)
> He's probably not as well known as someone like Gretzky in North America, so his name wouldn't immediately spring to mind on forums like this.

I think you might find there are a fairly large number of Indian, Australian and English people on this forum who will find his name does spring to mind immediately. It's more about the timezone than numbers.

> who comes next (Viv Richards or Brian Lara in my opinion)

Tendulkar.

Viv Richards was amazing at his best but declined badly. Lara's best innings were better than anyone (maybe even Bradman) but he wasn't as consistent and unfortunately he was playing in a declining team.

But I'm old enough to remember his 1993 innings of 277 at the SCG. In some ways that was enough to hold off Australia being undisputably the best team in the world for another couple of years.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by Enginerrrd on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:16PM (#34043533)
Wayne Gretzky!
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by lordnacho on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:35PM (#34043757)
Gretzky is even more insane. Fun facts:

If you don't count his goals, he still has more points than the next guy. Points are goals plus assists.

Something like 15 of the best 20 seasons in history by points are him.

Player of the year every year for a decade.

The only thing that makes it look less spectacular is that ice hockey is not the world's favourite sport.

Messi is the goat of a game that is massively popular on every continent, that you can find people playing in a park in almost every city.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by kaesar14 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:42PM (#34047687)
Not that Gretzky wasn’t great. He indisputably was and his title as the GOAT of hockey is totally fair.

However, these records are incredibly influenced by the era he played in. Look at a list of the highest scoring seasons for teams ever and it’s either far pre expansion or the late 70s and 80s - Gretzky’s era.

Messi’s records are astounding for the reason that soccer scoring trends have remained far more stable (imo)

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by lordnacho on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:13AM (#34049380)
Referees are nicer to attackers nowadays, plus there's several rule tweaks done in recent decades to make attacking more worthwhile. Goals scored at WC bottomed in 1990 iirc.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by kaesar14 on Monday December 19, 2022 @01:31PM (#34055692)
Goals scored isn't a great metric though since there's more teams than ever. Highest goal to game ratio was during the 50s.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by lordnacho on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:53PM (#34057529)
Yeah I meant goals/game bottomed. It came down from the 50s towards Italia 90 and the authorities decided to make some changes.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by 11235813213455 on Monday December 19, 2022 @08:01AM (#34051531)
- Mondo Duplantis - Sydney Mac Laughlin - Usain Bolt - Jan Železný
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by WiSaGaN on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:26PM (#34057944)
Curry’s three pointer shooting
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by WiSaGaN on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:27PM (#34059880)
fivethirtyeight also had a feature article about it in 2015: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/stephen-curry-is-the-re...

And he just got his finals MVP in 2022, kind of the only thing people lamented about for their careers.

They have pretty interesting similarities: * their teams in their primes, GSW and Barcelona are both dynasty teams with highest level teamplay. GSW rountinely have the highest number assists in the league, Barcelona have more successive passes than almost any other teams. * they are both considered more technical and humble comparing to peers like L. James, and C. Ronaldo, which pocess more physical talents and show dominant personalities

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by macrael on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:10PM (#34047439)
I highly recommend this old DFW essay about the 79th best tennis player on earth in '95. Big discontinuous jumps in ability exist in many sports. https://www.esquire.com/sports/a5151/the-string-theory-david...
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by JHer on Monday December 19, 2022 @09:03AM (#34052112)
DFW = David Foster Wallace