News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:53AM (#34039531)
If you were to define some new sport from scratch tomorrow morning by the end of the afternoon the Bell curve would start to assert itself in those that chose to play in it and over time that would become more and more evident. Eventually a 'Messi' would turn up.
Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by dan-robertson on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:27PM (#34039922)
You say bell curve, which I understand as meaning normally distributed, but the point about Messi is that he is better than what one would expect to find from normally distributed ability.

I think it is interesting to ask why Messi is such an outlier. But maybe you think the fact that someone has to be best makes it all uninteresting.

Re:Lionel Messi Is Impossible (2014) by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#34039963)
I think that effect comes from soccer being somewhat multi-dimensional: the ability to run fast, aim well, have stamina and so on.

And yes, I think that the fact that someone will be the best makes it uninteresting, or at least a lot less interesting than if a skill could be universally taught to the point where everybody would be very good at it and it would be productive.

Professional sports is roughly at the same level of interest to me as a circus.