News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:46AM (#33830325)
This is evident in America where you'll find some people take a position against free or subsidised healthcare and other social support, because some undeserving person (who is not in their group) might get it.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by tomstokes on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:18AM (#33830662)
> because some undeserving person (who is not in their group) might get it.

Surely someone, somewhere feels like this, but it’s more often a strawman argument used to make opposing arguments more easily dismissible.

From real world anecdotes, the concern about things like student loan forgiveness (as the most recent example of an expensive social program being debated) are more about the extreme cost of the program contributing to an ever increasing list of expenditures. People are nervous about the amount of government spending and how it’s being distributed semi-randomly. This goes back to the rampant COVID loans to businesses, the stimulus programs that far overshot their target, and now proposals to give certain households with up to $250K income a free $10K.

People understand that these things do matter in a society where we’re all bidding for a limited supply of homes and such. It’s nice to imagine someone having a reduced debt load, but people still think about where that money comes from and how the uneven distribution of that money gives some people (excluding those who paid their loans off early) a financial leg up in places like the competitive housing market.

It’s all connected. The money must come from somewhere, and we’re all operating within the same markets. It’s disingenuous to pretend that there are no consequences for these programs, which IMO is where politicians fall far short of structuring them and pitching them to a wider audience.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by zimpenfish on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:30AM (#33830834)
> the concern about things like student loan forgiveness [...] the extreme cost of the program contributing to an ever increasing list of expenditures.

SLF is a one-off cost (of between $400Bi and 1Ti depending on which plan you subscribe to) though. It's not like, say, the DOD which is currently burning $800Bi a year and rising - I would venture that the people happy to shoot down SLF are equally happy to keep that budget going up.

> People are nervous about the amount of government spending

...going to people they deem undeserving. They're perfectly happy with the amount spend on the DOD, DHS, etc.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by abeppu on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:48AM (#33831114)
I think there's also a generational aspect to it. Student loan forgiveness is being painted as a cash transfer to younger generations who are somehow lazy, whereas moving cash from younger generations to older (e.g. social security) is sacrosanct.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by scythe on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:52AM (#33831193)
Student loan forgiveness is not a one-off cost unless it's bundled with a reform that prevents the same debt from being accumulated again. I support the measure, but I wouldn't have supported it if it hadn't included the income-based repayment modifications that should limit the accumulation of unmanageable student debt in the future — I don't believe this goes far enough either, but that's a different topic. My point is that it's not possible for me to countenance supporting a reform that helps some people and "pulls up the ladder" not making it available to others in the future — generally derided as "borrowing against our children's futures".
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by josephcsible on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:39AM (#33832801)
> ...going to people they deem undeserving. They're perfectly happy with the amount spend on the DOD, DHS, etc.

Defense is what the government is supposed to be spending money on. It's a textbook example of a public good.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by zimpenfish on Friday December 02, 2022 @02:46PM (#33835809)
> It's a textbook example of a public good.

https://www.brown.edu/news/2021-09-01/costsofwar would disagree, for example.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by josephcsible on Saturday December 03, 2022 @01:39AM (#33841278)
I don't see anything in that article that disagrees. Note that by "public good", I mean <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good_(economics)>, not the "opposite of bad" good.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by judge2020 on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:24AM (#33830752)
But what are the consequences? People has similar revelation when the national debt was about to surpass GDP, and yet no economy-ending consequences rose from that. In reality nobody really knows how debt works on a global scale, and those that try to understand it seem to do a fair job at keeping the economy afloat when they join FRB or the multinational conglomerates that have a stake in the US remaining economically stable.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by ss108 on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:39AM (#33830965)
We must live in alternate realities; I am old enough to remember polls from 2016-2018 that showed that rural conservative voters liked the Affordable Care Act and its provisions when it was labeled as such, and hated it when it was labeled as Obamacare.

I have also mostly heard "fairness"-based arguments against student debt relief.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by ilyt on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:42AM (#33831009)
They seem to be way less opposed for government to bail out corporations from same tax money tho.

And I definitely knew many people that oppose to tax break or something for someone that's not in their group all while they enjoy some other tax break without problem and excuse that their one is fine.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by yucky on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:34AM (#33831852)

    > They seem to be way less opposed for government to bail out corporations from same tax money tho.
Not really. We had nationwide Occupy protests about exactly that, from both sides of the aisle. Not only leftists were fed up, but it also spawned the Tea Party movement on the right.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by x86_64Ubuntu on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:03AM (#33832297)
Occupy was largely a Leftist movement. And while the Tea Party was created then by Ron Paul, the political machinery that swept into Federal government seats was only after Obama won in 2008. The Tea Party as an entity is completely different between the pre-Obama and post-Obama eras.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by notacoward on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:52AM (#33831191)
"Hands off my Medicare!" might be the prime example. Or farm subsidies. People who constantly argue that government is too expansive and always incompetent (or evil) literally seem to forget that programs benefiting them are in fact run by that same government.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by meowfly on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:14AM (#33831543)
I usually make the case that 60% of the US federal budget is entitlement programs with the largest portion being Medicare and Social Security.

Medicare is what I usually focus on on because a person will take out $3 for every dollar they put in.

The real welfare queens are grandpa and grandma, yet in the 80s under Reagan many of those same people were blaming the poor.

If you want to see who has power, look at what programs people are willing to touch. Medicaid is constantly under attack by Republicans. While Medicare is a sacred cow to both Dems and Republicans.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by password4321 on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:38AM (#33831904)
Pardon my ignorance, but how is Social Security an entitlement program? I thought it was supposed to be forced retirement savings... how often do people get out more than was taken?
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by notacoward on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:04AM (#33832315)
It's an entitlement program because what you're entitled to it independently of what you put in. There's no isolation. You don't suddenly get cut off when "your" contribution has been exhausted. You keep drawing from the pool, indefinitely, and in fact this is the common case because official estimates of what people need for retirement (both cost per year and longevity) consistently lag behind reality. The pool "just happens" to be replenished mostly from still-working folks' contributions, but it's still a pool and not individual accounts.

Before anyone else "well actually"s me, as a retiree myself I'm well aware that there is some relationship between what you put in and what you get out. That doesn't change the system's essential nature. It's more of an anti-abuse and anti-depletion measure, similar to raising the retirement age or adding means tests. There's still a big common pool in the middle, and people can still keep drawing from that pool even if they live well beyond the point where their net contribution is negative.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by password4321 on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:56AM (#33833079)
Thanks for clarifying that perspective, I've not considered that before.

It would be nice to see some hard numbers re: net negative contributions.

https://en.wikipedia.org//wiki/Social_Security_(United_State...

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by umvi on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:00PM (#33833140)
It's a pyramid scheme. You put in $10 over the course of your career, but you take out $20 during retirement (funded by the next generation(s)). If US had shrinking population like Japan instead of growing population it would quickly collapse on itself because each generation takes more than it gives and relies on population growth to not collapse on itself. Or maybe social security rules would change so you have to be 75 before you get any benefits so that most people die before they qualify.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by fallingfrog on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:21PM (#33833496)
No, the social security taxes levied today go directly to the recipients today, with the plan that when you retire, the next generation will pay for your social security. So it's an entitlement program in the most literal sense.

Saving money in the bank makes sense for an individual, but not a government or a whole country. Because, they can print as much as they need. So why have a big warehouse full of cash when you can just make it later? The limitation to that is that it will cause inflation if you print too much- but if you warehoused the money and then released it later the same thing would happen.

Anyways, the reasons they print money or remove it from the economy are not because they don't have enough, it's because they're trying to moderate the boom/bust business cycle. (Not doing a very good job of it, though.)

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by fallingfrog on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:27PM (#33833602)
By the way, I just want to say that having someone say "pardon my ignorance" gives me hope. I definitely support people who have an open mind! I'm sometimes afraid to ask a question because I'm worried people will downvote or attack me for not knowing the answer. There are tons of things I'm ignorant about.

Anyways, cheers

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by winReInstall on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:48AM (#33831121)
The printing press, carried by atlas who needs the dollar?
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by kayodelycaon on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:55AM (#33831237)
> Surely someone, somewhere feels like this

That would be my family when I was growing up. A lot of their beliefs are centered people should work for a living. If someone can't work, they are lazy and working people shouldn't have to pay to support them.

My parents have since moderated their stance on this but my dad still believes this is the way things should be. :(

I've moved away from home and very much do not share their view and don't associate with people like this. I still see this belief often enough to believe it's pretty dang common in the midwest among the lower middle class.

Edit:

I should note, everyone I've talked to do make exceptions for a few people they know.

Most of them are otherwise good, kind people. They abhor the idea of anyone else getting something they haven’t earned.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by sokoloff on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:24AM (#33831696)
Is it that they abhor the idea of someone else getting something unearned, or that they are frustrated and fed up with the things that they have worked for and earned being denied to them (and only incidentally that they are given to someone else)?
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by kayodelycaon on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:56AM (#33832200)
Let me pull an example I’ve had to deal with.

I have a disability and some of the accommodations are a regular schedule (no weekends/overtime/on call) and being able to take time off unpaid when I’m sick. This is the bare minimum I need to be able to do knowledge work.

I don’t mention this because some people don’t think I deserve special treatment just because I “claim” to have a disability. If I can take time off for “vacations” whenever I want, they should be able to as well.

If I didn’t have these accommodations, I wouldn’t be able to work. Any explanation of how being bipolar severely impacts every aspect of my life is met with “life is hard for everyone”. (Exact quote from my parents, btw.)

To put it quite simply, no one should be given anything I wasn’t given.

When it comes to taxes, they see it as the government taking what they earned and giving it to people who haven’t earned it.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by stcroixx on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:16AM (#33832495)
This is the default point of view where and when I grew up. Based on the parable 'If you give a man a fish he is hungry again in an hour. If you teach him to catch a fish you do him a good turn.'. The independence and freedom offered by the ability to meet one's own needs rather than be at the whims of others you depend on is seen as a much greater good.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by josephcsible on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:36AM (#33832768)
> can't work

Are you sure you don't mean "can work but won't"?

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by kayodelycaon on Friday December 02, 2022 @03:25PM (#33836402)
Either or. People who can't work are just people who won't work.

For people who can't truly work, it's up to charities to support them. The government shouldn't be taking money from working people for it.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by oifjsidjf on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:41AM (#33830999)
"Free healthcare" lmao.

Who do you think pays for it? TAXPAYERS! It's not free!

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:46AM (#33831077)
I wanna go to a specialist in the United States and it’s still 6 mo waiting time…
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by brodouevencode on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:35AM (#33831859)
I have first hand evidence that this is not the case. Let's not over-generalize here.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:35AM (#33832745)
I’m responding to a generalization with my own specific experiences, so if anything this comment should be going to GP
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by the_only_law on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:40AM (#33832824)
You have first hand evidence that GP does not have to wait 6 months to see a specialist? Was there a HIPAA violation involved?
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by dangerlibrary on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:49AM (#33831145)
Right?

What world are people living in? On anything other than a 30% coinsurance PPO, you aren't getting anything done without insurance pre-approval. And that's an extra month or two wait on top of the three month wait to get in the door for a consult.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by polski-g on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:59PM (#33834108)
I only see specialists in the US and the wait time is usually less than 24 hours.

Are you calling them directly to set up appointments?

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by waboremo on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:49AM (#33831136)
Why did you take such huge offense to the phrase free healthcare when they explicitly mention subsidized a second later?
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by the_gipsy on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:53AM (#33831206)
You know that "free healthcare" does not mean it magically costs nothing, and you know that others wouldn't believe that.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by martin_a on Friday December 02, 2022 @08:57AM (#33830445)
I don't think this is limited to America or healthcare.

We're seeing these effects in corporate life, too: A charging station for EVs has been put up for the company and client EVs. I'm the first employee to have received "free access" to the charger as a benefit instead of more money. (to be fair: I'm the only one with a pure EV until now, too).

Now people are voting against putting up more chargers and enabling employees to charge for a smaller fee than normal, because "there's no normal gas pump being installed".

Nobody will lose anything with two more charging stations. But before somebody with another car gets "something nice", people prefer getting nothing at all now.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:03AM (#33830507)
But this isn't so much a foot shoot. The gas-guzzling employees are voting (why is there voting anyway?) for "I get nothing, you get nothing" over "I get nothing, you get something" - perhaps arguing that the cost of the something has to come from somewhere.

The described action would be more like "remove all parking lots instead of letting martin_a charge his car in a space" - which would harm the guzzlers to own the EVs.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by tomstokes on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:10AM (#33830569)
> perhaps arguing that the cost of the something has to come from somewhere.

This is exactly what’s going on. People know that these expenditures ultimately come out of the company’s operating budget, which diminishes the funds available for other things. Installing EV chargers is a great environmental move in my personal opinion, but we can’t pretend it’s unrelated to discussions come raise/bonus time when people are told that their raises are smaller than expected because budgets are stretched this year.

The EV chargers may be a tiny contributor, but they’re still an unbalanced distribution of the company’s funds based on something completely unrelated to performance. People are keenly aware of these things.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by martin_a on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:17AM (#33830645)
You've brought up good points here. Our "corporate climate" often isn't the best, that's probably why this leads to lots of upset people.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:21AM (#33830707)
Amusingly if it were proposed to put the EV charging stations in the worst part of the parking lot, people would probably be happier; as it is they're often right next to the handicap stalls and so you have the double whammy of someone getting the best parking space AND free "gas".
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by martin_a on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:30AM (#33830829)
> (why is there voting anyway?)

Meh, it's not the best word, I'm no native speaker. There are some very vocal people pushing against this initiative which are "inciting" (DeepL) others to stand up against this.

> But this isn't so much a foot shoot.

Not sure about it.

We've got some money left from a good business year, so the CEOs wanted to make some "small projects" for the production site, with some kind of "longer impact" than one-time payments. With payments, taxes will eat most it and the holding corporation would probably step in and mess it up, as other companies from the group are struggling a little bit.

So they've built a barbecue area for example. A handful of people wanted that (it hasn't been used more than two times up till now) and some people have said that they'd like their next car to be an EV/hybrid and that it would be great if there were more charging stations. So they thought it would be a good idea to invest some of the money in chargers.

As there's this "inciting" now, it seems like that plan will be cancelled and the money will find its way into the holding group and be lost to the employees right here.

Not sure if that isn't a foot shoot in the end after all.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:53AM (#33831212)
Yeah, that's an inter-family squabble about what to do with a "windfall" - the leaders should have collected various ideas and "combined" them in some way, a barbecue area that includes EV parking and (I have no idea what office workers see as perks, tbh).
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by martin_a on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:11AM (#33832413)
> the leaders should have collected various ideas

Oh, that happened, but only a quarter of people took part in it because of "meh"... Now they are complaining...

We also got bicycle leasing now and some other stuff, not all is bad...

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by FpUser on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:11AM (#33830575)
>"The gas-guzzling employees"

Contrary to EV driving nature saving unicorns? Ever heard that many simply can not afford EV. Or healthy food. Or many other things.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by thesuitonym on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:09AM (#33830552)
It's not limited to the US or healthcare, but it is extremely evident there. Look at how many politicians get elected solely on the platform of "We won't help a certain group," regardless of who that hurts.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by jcampbell1 on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:16AM (#33831584)
When you account for opportunity costs, i.e. no such thing as a free lunch, then your opponents' position is rational. People see installing chargers as depleting the pool of funds for employee benefits for which they receive no benefit.

> Nobody will lose anything with two more charging stations

Money doesn't grow on trees.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by brodouevencode on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:10AM (#33830560)
Or we see the problems in other countries that have such systems and think we can provide better solutions. That's not to say the current system is the best, but that's not what many want either.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by Sharlin on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:17AM (#33830656)
I'm pretty sure most Americans don't "see" anything outside the US. Even on Hacker News you see the phenomenon where people tend to dismiss solutions popular and proven to work everywhere else as somehow hypothetical and untested, or at least immediately confabulate some random knee-jerk reason why "it could never work in the US". American exceptionalism is truly a force to be reckoned with.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by tomrod on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:32AM (#33830858)
Nah, in my experience many Americans do, especially those that have the privilege to leave home (study abroad, move to a new place far away, etc.).
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by Sharlin on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:55AM (#33831234)
But those aren't most.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by tomrod on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:01AM (#33831350)
Not sure about that. A _lot_ of city folks didn't start there.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by ss108 on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:43AM (#33831023)
I would say that those of us in the US who are more or less "coastal elite" types are probably just kind of sophomoric about how things work in Europe. I think a lot of us have a simplified and rosy picture of how European systems work, but if we were pressed on the details, would have to concede our ignorance lol
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by hotpotamus on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:45AM (#33831066)
I can't find the quote, but I believe it was one of the physicists involved in the Manhattan Project who said that the greatest secret of nuclear weapons is that they were feasible to engineer at all. Just by dropping them, the US let that secret out and ensured that other countries began engineering them.

I feel like American Exceptionalism has just turned into collective denial.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by krapp on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:52AM (#33831183)
Although we now know Russia had spies infiltrating the Manhattan project, so the cat was out of the bag either way.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by scythe on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:54AM (#33831228)
The Allies also had spies sabotaging the Nazis' nuclear program, which may certainly have prevented WWII from being a lot worse.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by Sharlin on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:59AM (#33831296)
There were many reasons, including the fact that the Nazis weren't nearly Manhattan Project level serious enough about pursuing nuclear weapons, and simply lacked the brainpower that had emigrated en masse before the war.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by tchalla on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:47AM (#33831100)
You will see this phenomena on discussion forums like r/science

Study participants based out of USA : Most discussion focussed on the study

Study participants based outside of USA : The study is not conclusive because the study is done somewhere else and not generalisable.

They don't say "it doesn't apply to US"; but rather they are "not generalisable".

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by machina_ex_deus on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:17AM (#33830641)
You can have good socialistic healthcare, and welfare country. You can also have open borders. You can't have both.

It's basic stability condition. People will flow to the socialistic welfare or against it, and it's not going to stop until forces equalize, a.k.a it's just as good staying in the worst country as it is moving to the better welfare one. Since people moving tends to harm the other country the immigration is from, it should bring both down.

Only one side has a stable condition. It's a matter of common sense at this point. If one side advocated for closed borders with subsidized healthcare, that's fair enough and maybe even better choice.

P.S. socialized healthcare works well in Israel for example.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by jameshart on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:34AM (#33830901)
This is what’s called a ‘false dichotomy’

‘Open borders’ is a strawman, anyway. You can have policies which promote immigration, provide legal pathways for immigrants to provide labor to the economy (including unpaid labor like raising kids and domestic elder care), and can structure social benefits in such a way that you provide a social safety net, without having to just throw the border open to all or pay out unemployment benefits to anyone who shows up out of work.

Illegal immigration is a market response to a failure of the government to provide a legal framework for sufficient legal migration. People are willing to come to (for example) the US and work illegally without legal access to any social safety net. But allowing people to live under those conditions is both a moral failing (we should not be comfortable relying on the labor of people who face destitution if they lose their job) and a societal risk (people with no safety net are more likely to end up engaged in criminal activity that harms society).

So why not create a more structured arrangement? Create paths to legal immigration, with access to defined, limited, temporary benefits, and with a pathway that over time - as an immigrant’s stake in the country increases - converges towards the full security afforded to citizens.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by 988747 on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:22AM (#33831658)
>> Illegal immigration is a market response to a failure of the government to provide a legal framework for sufficient legal migration.

No, it really is not. There's really no upper limit on how many people might WANT to immigrate to your country (other than the obvious 8B world population size), but there's an upper limit on how many immigrants your country can accommodate in the given time frame. Increasing limits for legal immigration won't stop illegal one, it might even encourage it (e.g. when one person gets an immigrant visa and some of their relatives don't but they still decide do go, illegally)

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by jameshart on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:39AM (#33831915)
If you make it possible for a large enough population of immigrants to be legally permitted to work, you create a situation where employers can remain within the law and only employ people who have legal right to work, meaning you can afford to actually enforce the law preventing employers from employing illegal workers (without as a side effect completely shutting down agriculture, construction and cleaning services across several states).

THAT reduces the incentive to enter the country outside the legal framework, since all the jobs are going to people who have the paperwork.

People do not want to go to live in places where they have no economic prospects.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by machina_ex_deus on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:53AM (#33832147)
Illegal immigration is the market response to different economic potential across countries. Just like in physics, if you have chemical potential differences across a boundary and particles can pass, you'll only reach equilibrium when the chemical potential equalizes.

Even if an immigrant enters a country and is still productive and doesn't even use any social benefits, he diluted the job pool. Those getting out of the job pool get the socialistic benefits. So the average productivity could still go down. Those immigrants compete with locals equally in the job market, so dividing them into one group having benefits and another without doesn't change the stability condition. So instead of an immigrant coming and taking benefits directly, he comes, replaces a working local which just takes benefits.

Open or closed borders are a real dichotomy from higher up viewpoint which analyzes dynamics and stability condition, not a 'false dichotomy'. They represent a constraint in the equilibrium condition, which either exists or doesn't. The most you can do is filter the demographics which can enter or leave. But you'll still reach an equilibrium for each demographic with an open border. Like diffusion through filtering membrane. Or you can restrict the flow, but it only delays reaching the equilibrium, doesn't change where that equilibrium will be.

These stability conditions and dynamics are forces beyond the power of governments. You can play around them and find a reasonable trade-off, or you can try fighting them and get disappointed.

It doesn't matter whether the immigrants don't get the benefits themselves, they compete for wages with people that do. It's funny you're even suggesting to solve this problem with inequality.

By the way, in Israel for example, the construction industry is completely dominated by Palestinians. They don't get any benefits. Israelis just don't work in construction anymore. Even when people are jobless they don't even consider working in construction because the state of employment just isn't worth it.

You can't solve this by creating inequality between immigrants and locals. It's even worse.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by jameshart on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:30PM (#33834628)
All immigration is the market response to different economic potential across countries. It will be illegal if no legal pathway for it is provided.

And: Did you just commit the lump of labor fallacy?

Why, in this model, are people ‘getting out of the job pool’ for these ‘socialistic’ benefits?

Benefits like.. healthcare that restores them to a state where they can return to work after an injury? Education that lets them develop skills to increase their productivity? Income support to allow them to care for a child, raising another generation of productive citizens?

I don’t understand why a society offering those benefits is automatically unable to also offer a structured immigration program.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by swfsql on Friday December 02, 2022 @09:48AM (#33831116)
The same can be said from the opposite side of the argument.

People will be on the side of free or subsidised healthcare and other social support regardless of their unpayable public debt rising even further and that it eventually may crush individuals from society that are perhaps not even born yet.

The "opponent" in this case is the wrong person who has a different political view.

Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by x86_64Ubuntu on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:04AM (#33831383)
Reagan's Welfare Queen is a prime example of how government support systems were not only dismantled, but met with disdain because of the feeling that they were helping undeserving people.
Re:Individuals prefer to harm their own group rather than he... by josephcsible on Friday December 02, 2022 @11:35AM (#33832744)
This is a straw man. The actual viewpoint is "I don't want more of my hard-earned money to be taken from me via higher taxes and then wasted".