News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by jzd131 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:10AM (#33619899)
As the world tunes in to watch the $21B SLS launch today. For the benefit of humanity it is unfortunate that the SLS did not blow up on the launchpad with no injuries of course. If it blew up we then would have hope to direct all future funding to private programs that are 10x more cost efficient. Imagine what SpaceX could have produced for $21b (SpaceX total funding is under 10B). Imagine how much faster humanity can get to space if the funding was spent effectively…

SLS: payload 154k pounds, not reusable, 3B per rocket

SpaceX Starship: payload 220k pounds, 100% reusable, 10m estimate per reuse

Even if you take the argument that Starship has not flown and the prices are not there yet- 3 falcon heavy rockets can lift the same payload today at a fraction of the cost.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:18AM (#33619948)
That's a spicy take, but I fully agree with you, and it's a shame you're getting reflexively downvoted instead argued against. SLS is a hugely expensive pork-barrel project that's basically the same as Atlas in the 1960s, and Artemis is an equally pointless rehash of the Apollo program. Neither will meaningfully advance the state of anything.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by nightski on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:24AM (#33619988)
If I have learned anything from my time in technology, it's that nothing is ever optimal. As much as we fight it, the world is run on big balls of mud. I for one will always celebrate any success from NASA no matter how contrived the path to get there was. Sometimes it just takes compromise to accomplish something.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:30AM (#33620025)
Accomplish something, sure, but what is NASA accomplishing here?
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by andsoitis on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:37AM (#33620084)
From the article: “The primary goal of Artemis I is to thoroughly test the integrated systems before crewed missions by operating the spacecraft in a deep space environment, testing Orion’s heat shield, and recovering the crew module after reentry, descent, and splashdown.”
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:40AM (#33620114)
In other words, Apollo 6, 1968.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_6

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by andsoitis on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @10:05AM (#33624220)
Artemis I is a step in the Artemis Program, which has the stated purpose of building a sustainable human presence on and around the moon. https://www.space.com/artemis-program.html

Elsewhere in this discussion thread there's also cynicism as to why NASA isn't using cheaper / more efficient SpaceX hardware. I won't go into arguing all the criticism that's thrown at the edges, but instead simply point out that NASA has awarded SpaceX a $1.15b contract for second Artemis mission. https://spacenews.com/nasa-awards-spacex-1-15-billion-contra...

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by cormacrelf on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:36AM (#33620071)
They launched a rocket perfectly first time, with no spectacular imagery of failed launches to scare off human passengers.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by unethical_ban on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:43AM (#33620138)
I'm downvoting because they're naive about long-term planning and political momentum, they're stating as fact potential alternate futures that would be far from certain, and they're wishing catastrophic failure to a complex program that would also represent a failure of engineering and safety standards, leading to its own set of negative conclusions.

They pretend that NASA/Congress would just say "whee, full tilt SpaceX" right away if SLS failed, and I don't see the evidence.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by return_to_monke on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:35AM (#33620069)
And SLS is a rocket that is built, and already launched to space. Starship is a fewer dream of Musk, launching in August, no, September, no October, no November or like, soon
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by georgeg23 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:46AM (#33620165)
Fever dream, and yes, since Tom Mueller left their ability to build reliable engines has declined substantially. Elon's inflating ego is going to get him burned. Unfortunately he's not a reliable road to the Moon and Mars.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:46AM (#33620172)
Cut Elon some slack: SLS was supposed to launch in 2016, so it was 6 years behind schedule.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by HWR_14 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:07AM (#33620307)
And Elon is supposed to fly people to the moon in 2023. But keep in mind, Elon has been talking about Starship for longer than the SLS was being planned. Starship (under other names) was officially announced and work on the Raptor engines Starship uses started at the same time as the SLS.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by kiratp on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:38AM (#33620460)
Raptor is a breakthrough engine. If NASA with nation state resources and 23B is 6 years late, let’s cut SpaceX some slack for building a profitable launch business with multiple successful vehicles while also being very close with Starship.

> As of 2019, only three full-flow staged combustion rocket engines had ever progressed sufficiently to be tested on test stands; the Soviet Energomash RD-270 project in the 1960s, the US government-funded Aerojet Rocketdyne Integrated powerhead demonstration project in the mid-2000s,[6] and SpaceX's flight capable Raptor engine first test-fired in February 2019.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Staged_combustion_cycle

If you want to learn more

https://youtu.be/LbH1ZDImaI8

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by HWR_14 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:41PM (#33629362)
I don't see how the breakthroughness of the Raptor engine is relevant. It's one of the reasons that Starship is cheaper to launch. If you want to say "without that, Starship would be operational" you also have to say "without that, Starship would be more expensive"
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by andsoitis on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:34AM (#33620062)
> SLS: payload 154k pounds, not reusable, 3B per rocket > SpaceX Starship: payload 220k pounds, 100% reusable, 10m estimate per reuse

AFAIK the former is a shipping product while the latter, the Starship, hasn’t shipped yet, right?

> Even if you take the argument that Starship has not flown and the prices are not there yet- 3 falcon heavy rockets can lift the same payload today at a fraction of the cost.

If that’s true, why would SpaceX develop a whole new craft for the intended payload if they could do it with existing hardware (the 3 falcon rockets you cite)?

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tigershark on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:46AM (#33620169)
Starship is fully reusable so it will cost a small fraction of falcon heavy to send a much bigger payload. The cost of sending a payload to orbit will plummet once starship is operative. More importantly Falcon Heavy uses the Merlin engines and runs on RP-1. So, unlike methane, it cannot be produced on Mars.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:14AM (#33620346)
Starship doesn't exist. How reusable or cheap it will be, or what payload it will carry, are all unknown at this time.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by kiratp on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:40AM (#33620470)
Starship is very real and did an 11 engine static fire last week.

I have a hard time understanding the stance of “if it’s not ready exactly when SLS launches then it’s not comparable.” We are talking about decade spanning technologies and investments here

https://youtu.be/7x1-W7k9V-s

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:46AM (#33620497)
That's not Starship, it's the Super Heavy booster. The actual payload part is separate, and I don't think they've been combined in a single test so far.

It's not a flying rocket, and it may yet need significant adjustments before it gets there - especially given that SpaceX has a very iterative development model.

Also remember that the current Starship design requires a completely unproven technology (in-orbit refueling) to be able to reach the moon - it can't do so in a one-shot manner like SLS will hopefully succeed today. That piece of the mission alone may significantly alter the capabilities and costs.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by kiratp on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:54AM (#33620524)
Starship has absolutely undergone extensive testing and continues to do so - https://youtu.be/gA6ppby3JC8

These are decades long investments and technologies. The next Artemis doesn’t launch for something like 2 years. Starship/Superheavy will be flying by then. I don’t see the point of declaring non-compete just because it’s not flying at exactly this moment.

SpaceX’s refueling for approach may need iteration but they have shown incredible ability to iterate. It’s also cheaper by orders of magnitude.

If you were running a business and deciding on a 5 year vendor contract, would you just ignore the vendor who had a 10x better product but required you to wait a bit (and you were not in a rush?)

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @04:07AM (#33620588)
> Starship has absolutely undergone extensive testing and continues to do so

That is the Starship module part. I edited out a portion where I indeed incorrectly claimed that Starhsip module hasn't been tested, and replaced by pointing out that the combination of launch vehicle (super heavy booster) + starship hasn't been tested. When comparing "Starship" with SLS, we actually mean the whole two-stage rocket, not simply the part of it named Starship.

> The next Artemis doesn’t launch for something like 2 years. Starship/Superheavy will be flying by then.

This remains to be seen. It was supposed to be flying this year, or even last year in some older estimates. As we've seen from SLS itself, (6) years of delay for these types of subjects are not surprising.

> SpaceX’s refueling for approach may need iteration but they have shown incredible ability to iterate.

Absolutely, but iteration necessarily implies changes in the current design - which is why I'm saying we don't actually know what the final version of Starship will support.

> If you were running a business and deciding on a 5 year vendor contract, would you just ignore the vendor who had a 10x better product but required you to wait a bit (and you were not in a rush?)

It depends on how confident I can be, and in how little of a rush I am. If I think they will deliver the first copy of the 10x better product 5 years from now, I may well award a 5 year contract to the vendor of the 0.1x product today, and have something to work with for the next 5 years.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by andsoitis on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @10:12AM (#33624344)
But NASA has awarded a contract to SpaceX for $1.15b for second Artemis mission. https://spacenews.com/nasa-awards-spacex-1-15-billion-contra...

Unless I missed something, it seems to me that NASA is being highly strategic and practical, in contrast to theoretical debate.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tigershark on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @04:13PM (#33630701)
And let’s not forget the 14 engines static fire earlier that put it just behind SLS power with less than half the engines: https://www.space.com/spacex-starship-super-heavy-14-engine-...
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tigershark on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @04:10PM (#33630652)
"Let's be very honest again," Bolden said in a 2014 interview. "We don't have a commercially available heavy lift vehicle. Falcon 9 Heavy may someday come about. It's on the drawing board right now. SLS is real.

So if I were you I would shut up, just in case, given that SLS flew 7 years later than expected and Bolden was destroyed for his laughable interview.

Falcon heavy is delivering real payloads, Starship will do the same soon, SLS will maybe fly another time of two before retirement.

I can’t wait to see your post next time that SLS will fly.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tsimionescu on Thursday November 17, 2022 @02:46AM (#33636083)
Sure, we'll have to wait and see. I hope you also agree that, if Starship is also delayed 7 years, the decision to go with SLS was not in fact a problem, even if it only flies once or twice a year and is completely replaced by Starship after 7 years.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by bigiain on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:15AM (#33619922)
> Imagine what SpaceX could have produced for $21b

A little under half the cost of destroying Twitter?

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by aaa_aaa on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:19AM (#33619951)
Yet, money was not taken from individuals' pockets.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by fragmede on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:33AM (#33620052)
assuming you're in the US, you pay taxes to the government, the government pays SpaceX to launch things, and SpaceX pays Twitter for advertising. Yay!
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by rob74 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:29AM (#33620022)
Er, doesn't NASA pay SpaceX for it's services? And where does NASA's funding come from again?
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by aaa_aaa on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:35AM (#33620068)
It's not the same thing. They can sell their services to anybody.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by Rebelgecko on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:05AM (#33620289)
Not without a lot of people going to jail for ITAR violations
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by yborg on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:47AM (#33620177)
SpaceX wouldn't exist without US government funding. "...NASA awarded the first Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) contract to SpaceX in December (2008), thus financially saving the company." Give the bureaucrats some credit.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by HWR_14 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:09AM (#33620316)
Also the DoD contracts they got. Don't forget those.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by georgeg23 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:22AM (#33620385)
Also COTS contracts and some shady CIA connections, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin#Career
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by jltsiren on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:43AM (#33620135)
Three things:

1. Efficiency is not an American value. The society almost always chooses decentralization over efficiency. For good and ill, the SLS project looks like America.

2. I don't think SpaceX is lacking talent at this point. Their primary constraint is time, not money. The Starship will fly when it's ready.

3. Three Falcon Heavy rockets can't launch the same payload as a single SLS. Cost per payload mass is only one factor. Maximum payload and the physical dimensions of the fairing are often equally important constraints. And those, rather than the price, are the main reasons why the Starship looks so promising.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by giantrobot on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:50AM (#33620204)
The SLS is not $3b per rocket. Those numbers, just like the numbers everyone trotted out for the Space Shuttle, are NASA's manned spaceflight budget divided by the number of launches per year.

It's not an accurate cost for the SLS, you don't come up with the cost of a SpaceX launch by taking into consideration their whole operating budget. Even your Starship cost is inaccurate by half, a single Starship launch can only get it to low Earth orbit with just enough fuel to land. To get anywhere interesting a Starship needs to refuel in-orbit, a capability SpaceX has yet to demonstrate even at the small scale. So every Starship launch needs a second buddy launch to refuel in orbit.

The SLS is not a perfect launch system but it's actually flying right now. Starship is still years out and requires unproven and as-yet undeveloped technology. It'll be interesting when it flies but it's a lot of undelivered promises at the moment.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by kunai on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:58AM (#33620246)
> or the benefit of humanity it is unfortunate that the SLS did not blow up on the launchpad

This is genuinely one of the most vile and disgusting things I've read on this thread so far. Cheering on the hypothetical destruction of people's hard work to create a significant engineering and technological milestone is so fundamentally antithetical to the hacker ethos that I can't believe you found it acceptable to put that into writing in such a crass manner.

> Imagine what SpaceX could have produced for $21b

Considering the vast majority of SpaceX's technical achievements are built on the back of the American taxpayer (through use of public-domain NASA documentation and blueprints as well as government contracts), likely not much. As I've said elsewhere in this thread, SpaceX's strengths lie in their crack team of software engineers for which you can credit their advances in reusability, not necessarily their hardware.

It's extremely tiresome to see individuals so cynical that their bias against government-funded research and technology manifests in such an ugly way, especially against the backdrop of such a magnificent success story despite overwhelming odds. Good night.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by kiratp on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:45AM (#33620496)
You keep stating that spaceX only really does software, not hardware.

Re-linking my earlier response about Raptor engines: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33620423

They are the only current player building with stainless steel.

Software alone doesn’t let you catch a rocket out of the air when it lands.

We literally just pulled out old shuttle engines from storage for today’s launch. And new ones will cost 146M a pop. And they aren’t as sophisticated as the SpaceX Raptor.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by vonzepp on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:59AM (#33620251)
Government's role is more than just launching rockets at the lowest price point. People deride pork barrel politics and contracts going all over America, but supporting communities is part of the mandate of a government. NASA funding is also partially possible, as politicians can say it is supporting jobs. If they couldn't justify it like that, NASA funding would be a lot less.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @03:18AM (#33620370)
SLS: payload 154k pounds, not reusable, 3B per rocket, currently on its way to the moon

SpaceX Starship: payload ??? pounds, ???% reusable, ??? estimate per reuse, hasn't flown once

Taking Elon numbers for what Starship might one day be and comparing it to the SLS which is actually working right now is entirely misplaced.

If and when the numbers turn out to be true, then I will join in congratulating an extraordinary accomplishment from SpaceX. We are nowhere close to that though at the moment, so let's reserve judgement of how Starship may or may not compare to SLS.

Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff by jve on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @04:03AM (#33620563)
Well, imagine you were an engineer working a decade on this rocket. You wouldn't want the outcome you described.

SLS Development started in 2011, I suspect decision to build was way before (budget had to be allocated after all). SpaceX first F9 launch was June 2010 and landing was Dec 2015. On 2011 they were awarded contract to develop launch escape system for Dragon for preparation of crew launch.

I mean at the time SLS was planned everyone was laughing Elon off at the idea of landing a rocket. SpaceX was new kid on the block and not yet as trusted and reliable as we view them today. I think it wouldn't have been a wise decision to: "No, let's not develop a rocket for us to go to moon, let's wait maybe some commercial launcher will have so much success and resources that we will do it so much cheaper after 10-15 years."

So, what I want to say - SLS looks like an old-time-space participant, and if capabilities will be here (I sure think so), it will be much cheaper to achieve moon landings.