Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:18AM
(#33619948)
That's a spicy take, but I fully agree with you, and it's a shame you're getting reflexively downvoted instead argued against. SLS is a hugely expensive pork-barrel project that's basically the same as Atlas in the 1960s, and Artemis is an equally pointless rehash of the Apollo program. Neither will meaningfully advance the state of anything.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If I have learned anything from my time in technology, it's that nothing is ever optimal. As much as we fight it, the world is run on big balls of mud. I for one will always celebrate any success from NASA no matter how contrived the path to get there was. Sometimes it just takes compromise to accomplish something.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:30AM
(#33620025)
Accomplish something, sure, but what is NASA accomplishing here?
From the article: “The primary goal of Artemis I is to thoroughly test the integrated systems before crewed missions by operating the spacecraft in a deep space environment, testing Orion’s heat shield, and recovering the crew module after reentry, descent, and splashdown.”
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
by rippercushions on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:40AM
(#33620114)
In other words, Apollo 6, 1968.
Artemis I is a step in the Artemis Program, which has the stated purpose of building a sustainable human presence on and around the moon. https://www.space.com/artemis-program.html
Elsewhere in this discussion thread there's also cynicism as to why NASA isn't using cheaper / more efficient SpaceX hardware. I won't go into arguing all the criticism that's thrown at the edges, but instead simply point out that NASA has awarded SpaceX a $1.15b contract for second Artemis mission. https://spacenews.com/nasa-awards-spacex-1-15-billion-contra...
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
by cormacrelf on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:36AM
(#33620071)
They launched a rocket perfectly first time, with no spectacular imagery of failed launches to scare off human passengers.
Re:NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
by unethical_ban on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @02:43AM
(#33620138)
I'm downvoting because they're naive about long-term planning and political momentum, they're stating as fact potential alternate futures that would be far from certain, and they're wishing catastrophic failure to a complex program that would also represent a failure of engineering and safety standards, leading to its own set of negative conclusions.
They pretend that NASA/Congress would just say "whee, full tilt SpaceX" right away if SLS failed, and I don't see the evidence.