It's really unfortunate to get "hacked" with such bad timing. You steal customer money and file for bankruptcy but now the bad hackers, probably from the Bahamas as well, take whatever is left and cash out. Oh no! /s
But it's alright, SBF said he's sorry.
It's not OK that we hugely reward taking risks to capital and then largely isolate the "risk"-taker from the consequences of failure when they materialize.
List of countries with extradition treaties with the USA: https://2009-2017.state.gov/documents/organization/71600.pdf
“Reuters is reporting that at least $1 billion in customer funds at the exchange disappeared last weekend, citing two former senior employees briefed on the company's finances.”
https://www.reuters.com/markets/currencies/exclusive-least-1...
There is a reason US regulated exchanged with KYC don't deal in XMR.
this person absolutely knows that they can kick leadership when they're down and that all blame will go to the leadership
it doesn't require being an "apologist" for leadership to see this vulnerability. Council and compliance all resigned, the ceo resigned. Any semblance of checks are gone and any rogue developer can use their keys on anything, rumor now is that an app update went out turning them into malware.
its equally as plausible as just a cringeworthy vendetta of spiraling founders, dumber things have happened in crypto. smart things have too, I’m leaving towards a smart thing
All that said, I’m not surprised at where we are today.
The rules that aren't are so few they may as well be rounding errors lost in noise.
They buy/make a lot of rules, but there's still (currently) a ton more to constrain predation.
(The more money you have, of course, the easier it is to game a more complex system...)
Are you actually buying into SBF’s pathetic ideologies? Or are you more referring to Satoshi’s white paper when you refer to “altruistic motives”.
I can’t understand how anyone would take SBF seriously. He’s a smug charlatan who converted funny money to real money so that he could dump it into politics for his own aims, all while calling his actions “altruism”. Biggest false virtue signaler of all time.
There's little altruistic about an emission that allocates half of all supply (first four years) going to early miners including Satoshi himself, and leaves only crumbs for later generations.
When they could instead minimize the problem (or limit it to the pre-existing fiat inequality) with a pure linear emission, i.e. fixed block subsidy.
The resulting high supply inflation rate (1/n after n years) would have the side benefit of deterring speculation, and keeping prices (and hence environmental impact) low.
Less fine if they won't and someone else will.
That so many people at FTX called themselves "EAers" or "subscribe to the philosophy of EA" screams charlatanism to me. That it became entwined with the Crypto community is no surprise to me.
It reminds me of the many many "churches" in Africa that tell people great fortune will come their way if they are loyal to this particular preacher or whatnot. [2] It is obvious to me those are a scam. Perhaps more akin to Scientology - creation of a VIP club - the less sense it makes the better?
I've tried to read about Effective Altruism and my conclusions are that it is immature gibberish and these proponents are not fully formed emotionally intelligent adults. [3]
> SBF ended up hanging out a lot with his younger brother Gabe, who was living in an EA commune on nearby Stuart Street.
Communes - but it isn't a cult right?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_MacAskill
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/13/world/africans-fill-churc...
[3] https://web.archive.org/web/20221027180943/https://www.sequo...
At its core, EA asks what the most effective way to contribute to humanity is. Some of the thinkers are mature and have produced amazing projects, givewell being an obvious example.
There are definitely some weirdos affiliated with the movement, but I don't think that that discredits its approach or philosophy.
See: all human history.
The essential trust anchor will always be transparency that directly affects a person in society. Anonymous money and anonymous power will be exploited.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_wha...
"The bureaucracy is expanding to meet the needs of the expanding bureaucracy." from (supposedly) Oscar Wilde
+
Survival of the fittest to survive, from Charles Darwin
?
(This is a serious question, I have been pondering it for years now...)
Is that based on some evidence, or is it speculation?
What a dumpster fire. But let's be honest, I think retail investors weren't getting anything back anyways. Probably only impacts creditors
Now the whole point of crypto was the tech behind it which was supposed to replace banks, exchanges and missuse of your OWN money. It's supposed to be an alternative to the trash financial tools we already use. The fact that people are using entities such FTX, Binance makes them deserve to be punished for their betrayal. Regardless if they use FTX or JP Morgan they pretty much deserve to experiment the shortfalls of centralised finance. I think it's part of the hello world example of what DeFi is trying to solve.
One more thing: If FTX was hacked I bet it has almost nothing to do with the crypto technology.
“Nothing to do with the crypto technology” is an empty and meaningless statement.
IF, and that’s a very big if, they got hacked, the fact that $600m could be moved and disappeared so quickly is 100% to do with the “crypto technology”. In the real financial system it is exponentially harder to make money disappear, transfers are logged on three sides of the transaction, you have to hack multiple autonomous and different tech stacks, and you have to wait as the transfers get transmitted, validated and passed in.
A great deal larger than nothing.
Another comment already noted that MF Global was not a (commercial/retail) bank. One part of it was a broker-dealer.
Also, in the United States customers of MF Global brokerage were covered by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) which (to quote Wiki): <<can pay the customer (via its trustee) up to $500,000 for missing equity, including up to $250,000 for missing cash>>. Please read more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Securities_Investor_Protection...
Even with all of the bad behaviour during MF Global's last days (to quote Wiki again): <<In January 2013, a judge approved a settlement that would return 93 percent of customers' investments, with the prospect of additional payouts from the company's general estate.>>
Impressive, considering the extent of fraud at MF Global! Can any collapsed crypto exchange claim the same recovery rate? I doubt it.
Almost everyone who has lost their shirt in financial derivatives in the past 50 years could have learned about the risks they were taking from some text in a prospectus somewhere, but chose not to.
For example, people who lost a lot of money holding XIV (a leveraged inverse-VIX ETN) had the warning about not holding the thing overnight in bold red text in the prospectus. People holding leveraged CDOs and every kind of CDS had all kinds of warnings in big bold text in their prospectus. The good old "liar's loans" of the early 2000's had big bold text saying "it will be bad for you if you lie about your income."
Pretty much the only financial products that don't come with big bold text saying "you are an idiot for buying this" are single stocks and the most boring of ETFs/mutual funds (eg SPY).
Contrast that with the warning signs from crypto projects, which are a lot more oblique than big bold text in a document that they tell you to read. Wall Street screws you, but they generally do it slowly and they tell you how. Crypto projects just straight up steal your money one day out of the blue and run to Dubai.
The rating agencies did not understand the products they were rating. However, the warnings were almost certainly on the label.
That's why the rating agencies were sued over this, and not the banks.
They did sue the banks. For many things including inflated appraisals of the loans.
I'm sure they have some kind of warning for everything that isn't FDIC insured. But misrepresenting high risk as low risk instead of zero risk is just a quantitative difference. There are plenty of scams that do this. for example just lying about a company's earnings. I suppose the precise crimes they charge them for may differ a bit.
Does anyone actually remember MtGox? It wasn't actually that long ago!
If - hypothetically - someone else wanted to take a similar path, the odds of jail time are actually pretty low.
I think there are two ways to think about this:
1. If you’re a company and you have N classes of debt then probably ‘ordinary people’ will all be in the same class (this can vary, eg if you’re a big retail store then wages owed will likely be a different more senior class of debt than anything you owe customers). So the more senior claims are more likely to be big companies as are the more junior claims, and it is unlikely that the ‘ordinary people’ class of debt will be the most senior. For FTX I expect the hedge funds and retail customers to have the same seniority.
2. Hedge funds, etc, will be able to retain lawyers and seek representation in the bankruptcy process in a way that is unaffordable to ordinary people. So they might end up with favourable timelines/restructurings or better accounting of what they’re owed but those arrangements can’t be that the big members of the class get a higher proportion of their money back than the smaller members.
And a lot of bankrupt companies owe the government a lot of money in due taxes...
How do you know that? It says explicitly: "52 contributions in private repositories" between November 1 and November 11.
What's interesting is that a lot of the FTX people on the about page (https://about.ftx.com/), including Gary Wang and Dan Friedberg have deleted their LinkedIn accounts, whereas they were available earlier. If they're deleting something so harmless, then who knows what else they are deleting and covering up.
Is there any reason to believe that attorneys are less likely to abscond to Dubai with pilfered millions? Are they more likely to worry about getting disbarred or losing professional reputation?
Keep in mind these are the attorneys who choose to work for a funny-money bucket shop.
S*t happens in any industry. Check bank runs in the past or banking crunch from 2008 etc.
Any fast growing situation or industry takes pain.
Question, what will happen in 20 years from now? Puting hate on public forum is weak
Yes, these things happen elsewhere but crypto is perfectly designed to facilitate these bad behaviours.
Every where you look, it turns out that someone is doing a 'rug pull', using customer funds in ways that don't line up with what they said publicly, or using misleading and deceptive behaviours to con others into giving them money.
We do not want that future. We don't even want the bitcoin present. We think it's bad and will cheer as it implodes.
There was a time I thought something like bitcoin had a useful role to play in the world, never as a consumer/retail thing, but more a zero trust alternative to existing clearing houses used by businesses. The mania around getting rich quick on crypto coins has utterly destroyed that possibility.
You can call it hate if you like. I don't particularly care. I do think spreading this criticism to counter the hype and straight up fraud pitches is justified, including being rather emphatic about it.
My grandfather hears “blockchain” and he assumes he is looking at a crypto scam.
As a first approximation he sounds like a wise man.
> They’re not just for cryptocurrencies.
Please tell me about the other use cases.
That is useful, but not as generally useful as cryptocurrency advocates want you to believe.
people were misusing it, does it mean that it is bad?
LLC are a main factorfor growth in last 100 years because of incentives aligment. same with crypto.
any tool can be exploited by bad actors
does it mean it should not exsist or be hated?
2. Because there are so many scams in the field.
3. Because crypto people have this unattractive combination of acting superior to others while literally never having read about or even thought deeply about economics.
4. Because after 13 years, not one Web3 project has emerged that has any value outside cryptocurrencies.
5. Because blockchains are wildly consumptive of the world's resources, right when we see the devastation of our biosphere roaring down on us.
people wont fall twice into same scam
people can learn faster thanks to it
in other indystries there are also bad actors
only different, crypto is faster which is good thing in good use cases
From FTX's general counsel[1], retweeted by FTX_Official. So that indicates it's not being sold off legitimately under some sort of liquidation proceedings. It could be insiders or it could be hackers.
[1] https://twitter.com/_Ryne_Miller/status/1591281729125613570
Rumors on Twitter[2] are there was also an update just pushed to the FTX app. Concerns are the update may contain malware. It makes sense to uninstall the FTX app if you have it.
[2] https://twitter.com/zachxbt/status/1591295039946493952