News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by intsunny on Monday October 31, 2022 @07:43PM (#33415006)
Today a yuppie can get off an airplane, demand Google maps tell them where the overpriced cocktail bars are, demand Uber take them there, demand the locals speak English, and demand an overpriced pretentious Old Fashioned.

No knowledge of local culture, customs, knowledge, etc needed in any city in the world. The exact same hollow experience over and over again. And yet these people pat themselves on the back for it. They instagram every moment of this manufactured and repetitive experience.

We're losing a lot of culture with globalization. A lot of what makes the different places in the world unique.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by bombcar on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:05PM (#33415182)
We’ve been losing this for decades (Tolkien complained about it) - appification has made it significantly worse.

You can still find real cultures but you have to dig. Everywhere that tourists go have become upscale McDonald’s - identical the world over.

It’s what people want. They don’t actually want all the messy problems associated with actually interacting with a different culture, they just want to tell themselves they have.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by andirk on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:22PM (#33415316)
"We just got back from Mexico. It was great!" Then "We just got back from Thailand. It was amazing!" It can either mean they assimilated into a new culture, or they went to the Marriott in whatever city.

When I travel, I desire to feel like I live there. An AirBnB with nice amenities, the occasional expensive cocktail(s), and some mainstream event, but the rest needs to be as authentic as possible. And that involves accepting some possible discomfort whether it be from language, cuisine, commute, etc. Where comfort isn't, experience is!

Re:The Subway That Sunk by at_a_remove on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:31PM (#33415390)
"You know how Americans are, Kiki. They all love to travel, and then they only want to meet other Americans and talk about how hard it is to get a decent hamburger." -- Naked Lunch
Re:The Subway That Sunk by ok_dad on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:15PM (#33415267)
I live in what feels like the center of the problem you described. Most tourists see one of 3 places, each of which are not even close to local culture. The thing is, if local culture were what tourists wanted, they wouldn't come here. They want the touristy crap they paid for in the tourist areas.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by Eleison23 on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:06PM (#33416070)
I've always lived close to the Mexican border, and I've ventured into Mexico just a few times, in several of the border cities. And the one piece of advice that you really need to adhere to is to stick to the tourist areas. You go outside the tourist areas, and nobody will speak English to you, and you will probably get ripped off (more-so than any tourist would) and you just can't be guaranteed safety as an American in Mexico if you're not in a tourist area of Tijuana, Nogales, Tecate, etc.

I did venture into these off-brand areas a few times, and it is sort of night and day; you know you are out of your element, and you want to go back to the tourist zones ASAP. You really gain nothing by going outside them. It's not "local color" it's "prey on the Gringos" time out there. It is not pretty.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by ok_dad on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:16PM (#33416140)
Well, I can’t speak about Mexico, it was mostly fine to go across the border when I was a kid. Where I live now, the tourists want the resort experience, the actual local experience is not interesting to them. They just want the pools and shopping.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by bombcar on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:26PM (#33416200)
As with many (most?) countries the key is to have a local guide. There are cities in America you’d not want to be caught in the wrong part of at the wrong time - the locals know this stuff.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by fosk on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:07PM (#33416079)
I used to be younger and I used to love being in the middle of the “local mess”. As I got older, I just need a relaxing place with a place that meets my expectations. I traveled across 40+ countries around the world and on every continent before I was 30. I have seen it all.

“Assimilating local culture” is always the same stuff: you meet happy people with nothing, happy people with something, and unhappy people with nothing, and unhappy people with something. Turns out that - besides food and the nuances of local politics - the whole world is the same mesh. There is not much else to see. I had better conversations in Michigan with immigrant Uber drivers in a 15 minutes ride than spending one week in their country.

For a while it was fun to “go with the flow”, ultimately after so many experiences I realized that it is not the place that made the experiences fun, but the mindset. By changing my mindset I had an equal amount of fun experiences in my hometown without having to travel hundreds or thousands of miles away.

Sure..I can say this now after traveling quite a bit, perhaps we can call it experience and wiseness.

The only thing that is truly memorable are the landscapes, and the things you see: temples, pyramids, you name it. But even then, I would say that sightseeing doesn’t really mean that there is any expansive mixing with the local population. It’s a sterile experience, so to speak.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by porknubbins on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:22PM (#33416179)
I can empathize with being older and wanting to just relax and have a quality experience. I used to try to thoroughly immerse myself in daily life of a city but that is exhausting after a while. I am more content to just hit the highlights now.

But it also sounds like you were a little burnt out on travel. I have lived abroad and found most regions of the world are quite different and have something unique and worth experiencing. Different countries are not just different themes on the same OS in my experience. People do live in meaningfully different ways. Out ability to take in new experiences that is finite and needs recharging though.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by margalabargala on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:09PM (#33416096)
Places with "real culture" aren't actually difficult to find, at all. They exist everywhere, in places that are not tourist attractions, especailly in places that have not had huge influxes of money.

My wife and I went to Greenland just pre-covid, where almost no one speaks english, no signs are in english, and there was a very strong culture of which we were very much not a part. We were able to experience a small amount of it thanks to the kindness of our host. There is a program run by the official government tourism agency that allows Greenlandic residents to host tourists in their homes as a Bed & Breakfast. With patience and lots of english-danish translations we were able to communicate well enough to get around.

I would go back in a second and much prefer a place like that over a more generic setting like described in this article.

That said, when our two weeks there were up, it was very nice to meet a Canadian in the airport going home and hold a real conversation with someone besides my wife in my own language for the first time in a half a month.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by Wowfunhappy on Monday October 31, 2022 @09:38PM (#33415904)
This is why I mostly have no desire to travel. I do not enjoy the experience of being a tourist. I already live in New York City--why should I go to Paris?

I'm sure there are trips I could take that would be truly different. I used to have a coworker who would plan trips to the Congo or North Korea or places like that. (She'd go completely on her own, by the way.) I really have no desire to take a trip like that either!

Re:The Subway That Sunk by andirk on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:04PM (#33416056)
NYC pizza is the best. I stash slices of Joe's Pizza from the Lower East Side in my backpack on my way to Paris. Paris baguettes and butter are the best. I stash baguettes and butter in my backpack on way back to USA. Best Mexican food in San Diego. Best coffee in Oregon/Washington. Prettiest beaches, not sure, so many. Most dog walkers ever, Buenos Aires. Nicest people, Bali. Funniest smell with best brass band music everywhere, New Orleans.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by moralestapia on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:15PM (#33416128)
>Best Mexican food in San Diego.

Wait until you try it in, ... well, Mexico?

Re:The Subway That Sunk by bombcar on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:27PM (#33416209)
Mexican food was invented in San Diego. And sadly the Mexicans don’t know how to make it.

(Mostly a joke but actual Mexican food is not what people usually expect or want.)

Re:The Subway That Sunk by orange_joe on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:07PM (#33416081)
If you’re in LES, I’d really suggest Scarr’s over Joe’s.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:34AM (#33421004)
I will admit to being continually perplexed at how no one in all of NYC can make a croissant as good as even an average one in Paris.

I don't like food nearly enough to travel around the world for it, however.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by Markoff on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:13AM (#33417220)
I blame smartphones, not globalization for losing touch with local culture/people.

It's very different travel experience, if you have translator in the phone and navigation and don't need to rely on locals as in older days, I'm glad I experienced traveling prior smartphones went mainstream, I'd have much less stories to tell if I had contemporary smartphone.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday October 31, 2022 @07:48PM (#33415042)
What else is Silicon Valley guilty of today?
Re:The Subway That Sunk by labratmatt on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:30PM (#33415380)
The agent of change is often the punching bag.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by Archelaos on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:15PM (#33415264)
> they have all independently decided to adopt the same faux-artisanal aesthetic. Digital platforms like Foursquare are producing "a harmonization of tastes" across the world

Should we really attribute this to digital platforms in particular, or are digital platforms not rather just today's mass media amplifying trends more or less in the same way as other media have done in the past? I think of the global fashion and music trends of the 20th century: business suites everywhere, blue jeans, rock music ...

Re:The Subway That Sunk by andirk on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:24PM (#33415326)
The article's headline image explains almost the entire article in a wordless gif!
Re:The Subway That Sunk by lotsofpulp on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:51PM (#33415571)
How would someone tell when this article was written?
Re:The Subway That Sunk by iamtedd on Monday October 31, 2022 @09:00PM (#33415652)
Looks like the only place is in the URL.

Something else I don't like is at the bottom where it says "There are 68 comments. Read them." No, I will not read the comments. It comes off as excessively demanding.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by dendrite9 on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:04PM (#33416055)
I guess that's an aesthetic choice. I remembered the article a few lines in but yeah it was hard to find the date to be certain.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by yawnxyz on Monday October 31, 2022 @08:52PM (#33415586)
We're going to see a lot of this "commoditization of creativity" outside of just common spaces in the near future, thanks to LLM and generally-available AI: from writing, to music to anything.

I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing though — we just have a higher bar of defaults. The Airbnb-homogeneity is just setting a higher default bar of quality; anyone is welcome to do more work and break out of it. It's just hard. It's like Airbnb (and similar) is setting a Strunk & White's "Elements of Style" to interior design.

A similar kind of thing probably happened when newspapers and magazines started making certain looks trending, and everyone started doing that thing. We're just seeing that at a global scale now.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by noduerme on Monday October 31, 2022 @09:56PM (#33416002)
Growing up in LA in the 90s, there was an astonishing variety of independent coffee houses, each themed their own way. The owners weren't making much money, they just liked having their hangout spaces. Van Gogh's Ear was art themed; Anastasia's Asylum rag rolled red with live singer songwriters; Cacao was tiki-meets-UFO: Stir Crazy was themed like a woodsy cabin; a place I don't remember the name of was like walking into an underground moonbase. There were dozens more. All gone. Dead as the late night politically engaged, literate, poetic, artistic and musical youth culture that supported them. They were places teenagers could go. Having worked the all-night shift at one after high school and served the employees of the new Starbucks across the street when it opened, I made a few observations about the death of all that.

It wasn't laptops. People had those. Kids came and did their homework and hung out. A bigger deal was the smoking ban. That kneecapped them because all the underage kids went to these places to smoke cigarettes and feel like grown-ups. The rents all went up to the point where they couldn't survive. But the real ending was when socialization moved online. Sitting around a coffee place meeting new people just isn't done in America anymore. Coffee houses are purely workspaces now, and it doesn't matter for that purpose if they're all the same.

What socializing there is moved to bars, where alcohol makes it easier. But the first question now is always "what do you do?" It's a shame. People are thinking like tinder robots instead of actually getting into conversations about stuff.

The reason they died is that American-style global culture has no room for, and actively discourages unmediated and spontaneous social interaction. You can't monetize it on any kind of large scale, and it may be politically dangerous. This is actually why I live in Portland and love it... it's one of the last hold-outs.

Re:The Subway That Sunk by orange_joe on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:13PM (#33416120)
Yes globalism leads to greater homogenization, but the style complaints this article levels aren’t the consequence of foursquare, but the nature of trends at the time. In 2016, Faux industrial was on its way out, but in the 70s it was the shag carpet. Apps aren’t forcing new buildings to have fake reclaimed industrial aesthetics and the tv didn’t force us to wear Jean jackets forever. Styles change, and as we become more connected the magnates of those styles change, but places retain their individuality to a very significant extent despite globalization. Seoul’s street wear looks quite different than that in NYC Chinatown. This article is just another intention of complaining about the youth framed as techno criticism.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by etrautmann on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:23PM (#33416181)
I think it a bit different actually - while you’re correct that there’s always been an aesthetic churn, the author is arguing that rather than having lots of pockets around the world churning with their own tastes, now social media (or 2016) created a single global taste. Whatever that may be at the time, I think it’s reasonable to lament the lack of lots of people experimenting with ideas more independently. Of course, that ship has sailed, and perhaps the pushback on airspace or whatever is hot now will drive addition search for orthogonal differentiation.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by ehnto on Monday October 31, 2022 @11:38PM (#33416616)
Although I agree, I think even then it is more homogenous in history than we are suggesting here. Take the automotive industry as an example. The major manufacturing centres have been in design lockstep for decades, and automotive design tends to influence architecture and product design through history as well.
Re:The Subway That Sunk by noduerme on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:05AM (#33417168)
In terms of pushback, you can definitely see an almost desperate public surge toward any "odd" or "quirky" restaurant / bar / hotel space that opens in a major market now. The twofold problem is that, like small eastern european nations after WWI, these can't survive and retain autonomy between great powers. They either need to be designed from the ground up as a franchise model geared for expansion, with all the marketing, paraphernalia and impersonal management strategy that implies, or else if they're locally popular they'll be quickly assimilated and watered down by the larger many-faced corporate hospitality industry. Vanishingly few local or regional restaurants, bars, coffeehouses, etc. flourish for any length of time before they're co-opted.

To me, the biggest single change wrought by the rapid spread of trends globally is that the cycle of co-opting has gotten shorter. Circular references to culture have become bounded by smaller and smaller time frames, and present an increasingly impoverished and banal version of wink-and-nod. What was once stepping into the past became ironic, and what was ironic is now unacknowledged and treated with a straight face. As a result of superficializing everything about the past, original ideas have dried up for lack of historical knowledge to fuel them, as nostalgia-mining tapped out the entire 20th Century.

Look no further than the food-truck to brick-and-mortar to Whole Foods pipeline, or the same that's happened in the music industry from YouTube to Top 40.