As a consequence of this, I think advertising will always persist irrationally unless the system if changed to prevent this irrational behavior. A really high tax on any ad spend would probably work.
It is an interesting question you raise about second order effects-- would there be ways to work around this to get advertising for free?. For example maybe spam would become more common and intrusive and be used by more reputable companies. Note that ideas such as "hashcash" were solutions to effectively put a fee on email spam.
The root of what is troubling about this all is that free speech isn't a sufficient framework in the modern world where attention and time are constrained.
I'm in favor of taxing ads, but it'd need to be comprehensive definition unless you want some unintended consequences.
It does get more complicated about how you define that it’s an advertisement vs not. And there’s lots of “paid placement” stories even in “respectable” newspapers that masquerade as news but would be hard to pierce the veil on as advertisement instead of just “free speech”
I would word the law very generally: an X% sales tax on any transaction made in exchange for publishing, or increasing the visibility of, content supplied by the payer.
this covers Facebook promoted posts, fake editorial articles, search ads, even NPR ad spots and YouTuber sponsors. it wouldn't affect product reviewers taking bribes from companies, unless the companies actually supplied review drafts.
sadly, this probably falls afoul of Citizens United, which was about the legality of ad money.
High tax on ad spend would be a throwback to our Christian moralist days where we decide that some spending is good spending that we like and other is bad spending. Most attempts to ban payment for boosting speech have failed, see citizens united.
These days, sin taxes like those on soda are often not motivated by religious concerns, at least in the US. They're taxes on goods or services that are harmful to individuals or society.
Of course, there are arguments around the externalities of all of these things. I view most of those arguments as society contextual (people don't like others smoking, so it is an externality) as opposed to something like carbon which would have a negative externality regardless of this societal/cultural context.
I agree with you here and find the obsession many people here have with advertising weird. Still, alcohol pretty clearly has a negative externality "regardless of societal/cultural context." The consistently high percentage of vehicular deaths, assaults, rapes, damage to developing babies through FAS, and so on are all largely borne by people besides the drinker themselves.
I've only read peripherally about this and don't have any good sources handy, but it's a historical fact which strikes me as quite interesting.
The market is contracting because when rates are high and capital is expensive, ad spending is one of the first you cut.
Now people (and most importantly regulators) are starting to pay closer attention, so the tide might be turning, up until the point where advertising becomes such a minefield that its costs will make alternative monetization models more profitable.
I can't believe I'm the only one who considers advertising as an active negative signal. That is, if you're pushing ads, you are loudly telegraphing that your offering is not good enough to be discovered organically, and is therefore shit.
Paying for so-called influencers is even worse: if you do that, you are - and there's no kind way of putting this - paying for others to whore their opinions on your behalf.
If you want to make your wares visible in my sphere, find ways to make these appearances interesting, original, inventive and sufficiently unobtrusive. If you can't, tough. Take your toxic waste where it belongs.
I just assume there is some other lower cost competitor that spends less money on advertising and returns the margin to me.
"If you want to make your wares visible in my sphere, find ways to make these appearances interesting, original, inventive and sufficiently unobtrusive"
Yeah, that's also called advertising. Sorry.
On the other hand, I do appreciate the snark here:
So basically all products are shit. Gotcha. Seems like a sound model.
You're not too far off. The rule of thumb I apply to this world is that 90% of everything is crap.[ß] And that rule is recursive. Acceptably decent things are rare exceptions and outliers.
ß: Including me.
The market also doubts the future VR-based ones. If you think there is value in those future VR-based products then I would say take a chance and buy the dip! Institutional investors are not as deeply involved with computing as we are on this forum.
IIUC they are not claiming that basic practice of advertising goods and services you provide is doomed.
As I've recently posted to this thread, Hamilton Holt's 1909 account is an excellent introduction to the beginning of this period:
<https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft>
Google's Ngram Viewer suggest that the terms "advertising agency" and "advertising copywriter" only came into vogue during the 1920s, which would be only just at the century mark:
<https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=advertising+ag...>
I don't have a ready reference for ad spend evolution over the entire 20th century, but based on the 1980--2000 data, it seems likely highly skewed to more recent times:
<https://www.visualcapitalist.com/evolution-global-advertisin...>
There's probably a pretty good historical basis for the series Mad Men to have been set in the years 1960--1970.
WPP is seeing increased ad spend as well.
Conclusion? Probably that apple has fucked facebook to such an extent that it's threatening their entire business. This isn't much to do with advertising in general.
What you say is probably one reason, though. But the actual crash is more likely because Meta didn't innovate and move away from-, or diversify their advertising-model over time. So rather than a steady change through continued innovation, A&M etc, they are now forced to bet on a giant pivot. For one, this makes investors nervous.
Meta has performed several M&As though, some of which proven extremely profitable and successful. But while e.g. Instagrams' userbase is different from FB, their income is based on almost the exact same model of targeted advertising. FB failed to move into ecommerce, video, streaming, etc. and diversify their income significant. Something that Amazon or Google do much better.
They've invested so much reputation wise (changing their name even) that it's very hard for them to back down, maybe impossible considering who makes that call.
I'm not following META closely. But isn't this another pivot to diversify their userbase, rather than diversify their revenue-stream?
Or is there some plan to monetize this "discovery" outside of their common "targeted advertising"?
The advertising market is definitely slowing with the high rates.
But Advertising certainly is an important income stream. It gets its own chapter in the earning calls. ~$9 billion in 2021, which is more than subscriptions (Prime etc), at ~$8 billion[1]
[1] https://www.insiderintelligence.com/insights/amazon-revenue/ , https://s2.q4cdn.com/299287126/files/doc_financials/2022/q2/...
Facebook loses users of genuine content consumption to tiktok. Amazon has smaller baskets checking out. Google threatened on its buying into default search on mobile safari.
Ad revenue has padded earnings and shielded these companies from investor critique and urgency in “what’s next?”
So the audience is getting older, and there is no way of now getting new eyeballs. So they have to try something else to get them, hence Metaverse.
Let me introduce you to: Instagram.
Snapchat is where the teens spend their time keeping in touch with their friends, Meta has lost them, they aren’t going to get them back to Facebook or WhatsApp. The teens have moved on because their parents are there.
But IG has a lot more going on than you are imagining - stories & DMs have rescued it, hardly anyone ever actually posts though.
Yes. Just to put numbers on that: Google's share price has dropped 25% since one year ago. Now everyone's in a bit of funk right now (except energy companies), but for comparison Apple has only dropped around 5% in the same time period.
> Amazon doesn't rely on advertising.
Yep, for revenues Amazon relies on retail, then AWS, then advertising and other miscellaneous. (And for profit largely on AWS, IIRC).
FB is down 70% though. It's different.
The same isn't true for Facebook. I've stopped using this 7 years ago and I didn't even miss it for one day. One day my wife was scrolling through FB feed and all I can see is ads after ads after promoted pages. She scrolled for like 5 minutes, encountered may be 2 posts from her acquaintance circle and then she closed the app. The boredom while browsing FB feed was visible in her eyes.
FB simply doesn't offer any value these days. Almost everyone I know has gradually stopped using FB. This is an app with very low signal to noise ratio.
My FB feed would not show me posts from friends, whom I knew posted something (by checking their profile manually). I think their internal kpi metrics meant staff sacrificed their user base by tuning for engagement in the short term.
Once users realized they weren't seeing posts from their own social network they left. As each person left, FB had no choice but to fill a diminishing feed with crap. To the point where they forgot to feature genuine posts their users made over curated 'attention' content.
This is similar; everyone dependent on advertising is struggling to an extent, but most of them aren't currently setting fire to vast piles of cash in service of an idiosyncratic project which most people don't have much hope for.
If you look into FB financials, revenue per user has more room to grow, outside US if nothing else, but I think US as well.
So "advertising model broken" isn't really true. It is irritable and despicable/deplorable in some ways for sure. But it works.
Sort of, but not quite. We had already kind of reached peak advertising, this isn't recent. More specifically the following trends:
- Advertising has been and is expected to continue to grow at a measly 5% per year on average[0] (compare that to say like 10% on Software)
- Digital advertising's cannibalization (e.g. the pie shifts) of traditional media is slowing down and hitting diminishing returns
- We're hitting peak media use at 12 hours 9 minutes per day[1]. There's just physically not enough hours in the day to consume more media.
- There are more players trying to capture that consumption. Facebook's properties's use are diminishing compared to competitors (e.g. basically TikTok).
TL;DR - Pie only grows 5% per year, digital is getting close to eating a majority of the pie, and people that aren't Facebook are eating that pie and Facebook can't compete.
[0] https://www.imarcgroup.com/global-advertising-market
[1] https://review42.com/resources/how-much-time-do-people-spend...
Arguably, advertising initiated in bulk print (newspapers and magazines), see Benjamin Day's The Sun (1833). I've mentioned Hamilton Holt's Commercialism and Journalism (1909) many times, it's an excellent summary of early advertising-based publishing, and its many problems: <https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft>.
Radio stole the thunder from print as a more passive and accessible medium, television from radio. Targeted cable offerings sniped over-the-air broadcast. And now online advertising is dominating both print and broadcast. I'd argue that billboard advertising has shown similar patterns as well, expanding rapidly with highway construction, seeing a strong backlash (beginning in the 1960s, notably by Lady Bird Johnson: <https://www.sandiegoreader.com/news/2001/jun/21/what-happene...>), and over the past several decades, trending strongly to very low-value advertisers ("gentlemen's clubs", lottery and casino ads, the classic anti-goods of alcohol and tobacco, as well as the increasingly ubiquitous "your message here" placeholders, being strong indicators of this, particularly outside high-wealth metro regions).
I don't recall who made the observation, but in the content industry, it's interesting that music, film, and books are exceptions to the advertising-supported nature (mostly, there are a few exceptions, mostly minor, though the expanding length of trailer and pre-film advertising in theatres would also be an exception ... this may have been mentioned in an Ezra Klein episode).
And speaking of Klein: that podcast includes advertising. I find myself averse to listening when I know I'm going to have to hear those (e.g., I can't intervene to skip the ads, such as when I'm doing household tasks), and will avoid listening to it. There are a number of other podcasts which are similar, a surprisingly large number being of what are nominally public-radio programmes --- Freakonomics comes to mind. Combined with IMO lackluster quality, I'm actively avoiding many of these, and have unsubscribed to several. Independent and academic podcasts are more my style, History of Philosophy by Peter Adamson and Complexity from the Santa Fe Institute being among the best.
And more recently, the vast expansion of direct marketing over p2p networks, most notably landline and mobile telephony, is making the experience of subscribing to those services increasingly undesirable. Much in the same way as spam and simply information overload seems to be making open-standards, universal-access email much less widely used (many organisations no longer publish email addresses, or respond to emails where such addresses can be found), an overall frustration level can in fact kill general use of a medium or channel.
John Gottman's five-to-one ratio of positive to negative experiences, originating in relationships but apparently having broader applications, may well play a role here. If even a relatively small minority of experiences over time with a technology, medium, or channel are negative, that impression tends to strongly discourage long-term favourability. See: <https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-magic-relationship-ratio-ac...> (for the relationship side, the ad/media extension is my own suggestion, though I suspect others have argued similarly).
As Nextgrid's comment notes, the real problem with advertising is that it's a race-to-the-bottom market, especially where high-value / highly-attractive audiences flee. Higher-quality advertisers similarly depart, and both the products marketed and methods utilised tend to ever-increasing toxicity in both figurative and literal senses. As I mentioned a couple of months ago, advertising ultimately has a reverse-Midas touch: it turns gold to shit: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32669503>
Part of the constant-platform-migration trend seems to be explained by highly-valued audiences tending to be early adopters of such platforms. Early advertising returns are high, and for all parties (publishers, advertisers, and audiences) the initial experience tends to be positive. With both wider adoption and early-adopter defections (leaving the media/platform), that kicks off the death-spiral dynamic.
It’s amazing how much more effective a 10 line change to App Store rules was in protecting user’s privacy than a bloated 99 section 11 chapter law - ie the GDPR.
You should remember this in the future, when Apple have become even worse than FB in terms of advertising. Device growth has stalled, and services (i.e. advertising) is gonna be their new iPhone.
From the dawn of mass media it has been subsidized by ads. Newspapers, radio, magazines, television, movies (through product placement), music (through sponsorship), podcasts, and even outside of media: sports, schools, mass transit, etc.
Ads have been a monetization strategy across a mind bogglingly broad cross-section of society for over 200 years.
Individualized ads may get regulated out of existence or maybe even out-competed by more consumer friendly options, but people by and large like the subsidies ads provide. Ad supported music, tv, and movie streaming is wildly popular. HN users often post archive.is links to bypass paywalls which actually opts into a paid-for-by-ads experience.
What we see with meta is their ads becoming less valuable and their stock reflecting that. I think it’s a huge mistake to draw any conclusions about the business of ads other than ads are controlled by the platform.
Apple is hoping these ad dollars flow to them, not that the ads go away.
Advertising can be a sustainable business model. Radio, television, billboards, etc. sustain themselves through advertising. We can quibble about their growth rates, but if advertising were unsustainable, then these industries wouldn't exist in their current form.
I think you're actually rejecting the idea that a company can sustain infinite growth through advertising. I think that's a little different from being wholly "unsustainable."
Ad based business models have a redistributive effect. Services like Facebook are paid for in proportion to spending power whilst usage has a completely different distribution. So wealthier users are effectively subsidising less wealthy users, which enables broad network effects and economies of scale.
People will always pay to influence other people. I think advertising while being annoying is one of the less malign forms of doing that. It also has privacy preserving characteristics as there is nothing more destructive for privacy than making a payment. That doesn't mean we shouldn't regulate to limit ad targeting. I think we should.
This is a very interesting take and I'd like to see some further delves into this.
Isn't the problem much simpler.
It's a shift in users attention to other social networks like TikTok, plus Meta already capture the total addressable market.
It's hard to continue growth when you've essentially plateaued and now users are spending less time on your site.
Like TikTok are losing money hand over fist, so it's not that the advertisers are moving to them, it's that advertisers have essentially been forced to give a bunch of the money they were previously giving to Fb to Apple.
https://www.newsguardtech.com/misinformation-monitor/october...
Complete control over that environment, combined with the new vr headset's eye tracking+other sensors, would likely make them the best A/B testing / irl ad performance data platform on the block... if it's successful.
Imo, they haven't really proven their case for their metaverse, the price point for the headset is wayyy too high for mass amounts of users to join in, and likely wouldn't join anyways since I'm not on fb/ig and don't trust em
Analysts explicitly think the VR effort is overfunded. It's the problem according those who are trading.
The problem in my opinion is that we have reached peak advertising. Advertising is ultimately a doomed business model as it works against your users' interests, yet requires those users to willingly use the product and engage with the ads.
Over time, users learn to ignore it (see "banner blindness") so a short-term response is just to include more ads to compensate, but there's only so much space before the entire product becomes saturated with ads and users leave completely because the inconvenience of advertising became greater than the value the product provides. Regulators are also wisening up to it with stronger privacy protections (that threaten non-consensual ad-targeting) all around the world.
Advertising is a time bomb and an unsustainable business model. It provides short-term revenue (and a lot of it if you play your cards right, as Meta's stock price until now reflects) but will never be sustainable in the long run. Advertising is a parasite and its host will always try to get rid of it - a pretty terrible business model when you can instead align the incentives by charging your users money and provide them a valuable service in exchange.
Is there value in Facebook's products (whether current, or future VR-based ones)? Yes. Is there enough value to justify a overinflated stock price that only got there due to a combination of monopoly position as well as temporary gap in regulation against spyware? Doubt it, and so does the market.