News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by datadata on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:45AM (#33358299)
The game theory of firms choosing to advertise seems to be prisoner's dilemma like. The only equilibrium is for both firms to advertise at a loss. If either firm stops advertising, the other firm's ads become more effective and it will steal market share.

As a consequence of this, I think advertising will always persist irrationally unless the system if changed to prevent this irrational behavior. A really high tax on any ad spend would probably work.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by potamic on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:06AM (#33358659)
Tax on advertising is a very interesting idea. Everyone understands that is a necessary evil and most parties would rather not do it given the chance. But how do you classify what advertising is? Buying adspace on a website or billboard might be obvious? What about other forms like content creation, influencer marketing etc. If you create some websites or videos related to your services, is that considered advertising?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by datadata on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:31AM (#33359099)
I think you only need to track financial transactions, advertising companies would have to report and be taxed on income. The government has shown moderate competence at being able to implement things like this (maybe there are some areas where there is a lot of tax fraud, but generally it works).

It is an interesting question you raise about second order effects-- would there be ways to work around this to get advertising for free?. For example maybe spam would become more common and intrusive and be used by more reputable companies. Note that ideas such as "hashcash" were solutions to effectively put a fee on email spam.

The root of what is troubling about this all is that free speech isn't a sufficient framework in the modern world where attention and time are constrained.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by r00fus on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:08PM (#33361549)
How do you separate advertisement companies and, say, entertainment companies that happen to just do product placement?

I'm in favor of taxing ads, but it'd need to be comprehensive definition unless you want some unintended consequences.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vlovich123 on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:43AM (#33369438)
Product placement is advertising. You only need to tax the transaction for the advertisement not “advertising companies”.

It does get more complicated about how you define that it’s an advertisement vs not. And there’s lots of “paid placement” stories even in “respectable” newspapers that masquerade as news but would be hard to pierce the veil on as advertisement instead of just “free speech”

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by sterlind on Friday October 28, 2022 @06:41AM (#33369725)
you don't have to pierce the veil. the newspaper is still free to publish whatever content it wants, including ads. it just has to pay a tax if it wants to accept money for it.

I would word the law very generally: an X% sales tax on any transaction made in exchange for publishing, or increasing the visibility of, content supplied by the payer.

this covers Facebook promoted posts, fake editorial articles, search ads, even NPR ad spots and YouTuber sponsors. it wouldn't affect product reviewers taking bribes from companies, unless the companies actually supplied review drafts.

sadly, this probably falls afoul of Citizens United, which was about the legality of ad money.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by whimsicalism on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:16AM (#33358822)
Exactly. It wouldn't survive a court challenge.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by whimsicalism on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:46AM (#33358327)
That's not what "at a loss" means and is also not irrational.

High tax on ad spend would be a throwback to our Christian moralist days where we decide that some spending is good spending that we like and other is bad spending. Most attempts to ban payment for boosting speech have failed, see citizens united.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by datadata on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:58AM (#33358525)
I'm sorry, but have we ever left "those days"? There are dozens of examples of sin taxes on things like Cigarettes, Gambling, Alcohol, Carbon Emissions, etc.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by softwarebeware on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:20AM (#33358887)
Taxes on cigarettes, in the US, at least, are not driven primarily by Christian moralists. I was part of a prominent US non-profit that is behind both higher cigarette taxes and laws that ban smoking in public areas. The motivation is health.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by whimsicalism on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:01AM (#33358584)
Carbon has clear negative externality. Most of those other taxes were first instituted during periods of much greater Christian beliefs in the US than now.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by datadata on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:05AM (#33358639)
So are you OK with a sin tax if it is on something with a negative externality? Do you think advertising does not have any negative externalities?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by whimsicalism on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:17AM (#33358848)
Carbon is not a sin and that is not the historical reason it is taxed, unlike say alcohol and cigarettes. Many of these other things may have externalities, both positive and negative, but not so clear cut as carbon.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by jlund-molfese on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:35PM (#33360159)
The reason you're getting downvoted is because you compared a tax on ad spend to "Christian moralist" taxation in the United States, otherwise known as sin taxes. But you changed your definition of a sin tax halfway through the thread.

These days, sin taxes like those on soda are often not motivated by religious concerns, at least in the US. They're taxes on goods or services that are harmful to individuals or society.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by qwytw on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:09AM (#33358697)
And Cigarettes, Gambling & Alcohol don't?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by whimsicalism on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:12AM (#33358757)
The primary impact of all of these things is on the purchaser. So not an externality.

Of course, there are arguments around the externalities of all of these things. I view most of those arguments as society contextual (people don't like others smoking, so it is an externality) as opposed to something like carbon which would have a negative externality regardless of this societal/cultural context.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by datadata on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:19AM (#33358883)
Some externalities of smoking for non-smokers include increases in health care coverage costs, reduced access to health resources, and loss of loved ones to smoking related health issues.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by at-w on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:13PM (#33360771)
>Of course, there are arguments around the externalities of all of these things. I view most of those arguments as society contextual (people don't like others smoking, so it is an externality) as opposed to something like carbon which would have a negative externality regardless of this societal/cultural context.

I agree with you here and find the obsession many people here have with advertising weird. Still, alcohol pretty clearly has a negative externality "regardless of societal/cultural context." The consistently high percentage of vehicular deaths, assaults, rapes, damage to developing babies through FAS, and so on are all largely borne by people besides the drinker themselves.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by dredmorbius on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:53AM (#33369490)
Among the sea-changes in the publishing industry was the abolition of exceptionally high taxation rates on advertising in the UK in the early 19th century (circa 1830 or so).

I've only read peripherally about this and don't have any good sources handy, but it's a historical fact which strikes me as quite interesting.