News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by rossdavidh on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:49AM (#33344542)
If rates go from a low of 2% up to, say, 9%, then in order to keep the mortgage payment the same, the price of a $400,000 house would have to drop to around $230,000. This assumes a 30-year fixed rate mortgage, and the details will vary depending on money down, etc. but the basic fact remains that house prices will need to fall by a lot, down to levels of 5 years ago or more, before the current interest rate hiking cycle ends.

I don't think most people who invested in housing in the last couple years, are ready to believe that yet.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mattwest on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#33344872)
Most of the people I speak to who locked in <3.5% are not planning on selling in the next 10 years or more. Then to consider the scenario of renting throughout this period; how much cash is being torched compared to a mortgage payment? How will they save for a down payment during a period of inflation like this?

Current renters will have lower potential to save on a monthly basis, only to get 30-40% off on their first home with a >7% interest rate. If you sum the lost savings from rent plus the additional interest payment, it is uncertain whether that is the best strategy. That is also assuming real estate prices in certain regions wont hold stronger value, which they probably will. Some areas in the South East, Midwest, and Front Range will likely not see such a drop in value with respect to interest rates and mortgage payments. The demand is just too high.

Not to mention that rent is collected by people who are now in a better position to purchase newly discounted real estate without loans, further fueling price demand by competing against each other and shortening supply.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by matt_s on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:37AM (#33345350)
> locked in <3.5% are not planning on selling in the next 10 years or more

Not just that but looking further out at retirement, downsizing and staying in the same area is not looking possible. The house might be worth $X on paper at that point but if you sell you are then thrust into a market where everything is much higher. Its financially more palatable to just stay put even if you don't need the space. I imagine people within a couple years of this decision are staying put right now and this will keep demand up regardless of rates.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Mochsner on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:53PM (#33346381)
If you're downsizing, full cash or majority cash offers (if an option) would be the exception here.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:04PM (#33346521)
If you are downsizing you can cash out and then buy your next (smaller) place in cash without a loan. This all assumes you aren't in California, though, where prop 13 encourages you to stay put no matter what.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mirashii on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:16PM (#33346659)
Almost, except Prop 19, which allows you to transfer your property tax valuation under Prop 13 to a new property to allow people to downsize in retirement.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:18PM (#33346678)
Ooh, nice, I didn't know about that one. Seems like the right direction to go in.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:40AM (#33345385)
> are not planning on selling in the next 10 years or more.

Most people don't plan on selling their house when they buy it. Life usually forces you into the situation.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by fknorangesite on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:40PM (#33346925)
What makes you say that? People often consider places "starter" vs "forever" homes, for example.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:14PM (#33347362)
People often plan for marriages will be forever too. Life happens.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by antisthenes on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:00PM (#33348605)
Frankly, I don't know any peers (millenials), that are able to afford anything more than a starter home anyway. That seems like a very outdated concept for people who are very well-off.

I mean, most of us aren't even able to afford to buy a home, let alone casually upgrade to a "forever" home. In my high COL area, even starter homes are only affordable for top 20 percentile earners. Everyone else either lives with roommates or parents and rents.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by caeril on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:44PM (#33349940)
> don't know any peers (millenials), that are able to afford

> In my high COL area

Yes, it is a problem that Millenials refuse to live anywhere other than Instagram-worthy locations. God, what would Becky think if I posted a TikTok from flyover country? And imagine shopping at Walmart, I would literally die frfr no cap.

How we could ever solve this vexing self-inflicted problem, I have no idea. What a quandary.

> seems like a very outdated concept

Yes, much like the outdated concept that building tangible wealth in underpriced assets is worth the cost of a slightly lower number next to the heart icon. Fucking boomers, amirite?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by hotpotamus on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:46PM (#33350632)
Do the high COL Instagram-worthy locations happen to be wear all the jobs are? Not everyone can work remote.

Frankly, I'm vexed by the trends as well, but from the opposite direction - I liked when South Texas was the backwater and Austin was a weird little city, but I don't think there's any going back. My property taxes sure aren't. I'm just hoping that I can make enough to retire somewhere cheaper and cooler in the summer eventually.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by antisthenes on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:59PM (#33352106)
Thank you for the low-effort snarky response. I wasn't aware that starter homes in my area built in the 1950s are an instagram-worthy location.

Probably because I don't even use Instagram, so I wouldn't know what it looks like to be in one.

> And imagine shopping at Walmart, I would literally die frfr no cap.

I'm glad you were able to find Urban Dictionary on the internet, and not get lost. If only I was such a digital native like you.

> Yes, much like the outdated concept that building tangible wealth in underpriced assets is worth the cost of a slightly lower number next to the heart icon. Fucking boomers, amirite?

Yes, you are right. Not sure what about, though, since I'm not going to waste any effort parsing your word salad.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by floxy on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:37PM (#33350547)
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by antisthenes on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:01PM (#33352117)
Now go to each of those locations and see how muchs jobs pay.

Zillow links don't prove whatever point you were trying to make with the low effort post.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by greenie_beans on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:20AM (#33345076)
i rent, and i'd pay over $1-$1.5k/month more on a mortgage if i wanted to live in the neighborhood where i rent. i'm doing an okay job saving for a down payment while waiting for everybody with low interest rates who need to sell because life happens.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bushbaba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:18AM (#33345029)
Demand was high. It’s dropped by 50% since the peak with inventory up by over 2x from the low
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by BuckRogers on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:42AM (#33345407)
Not only that, new listings are down YoY while inventory continues to grow. That's a bad combination if you want prices to continue to go up.

There's so many predictions but my take is simple, the only thing for sure is that prices are not going up anytime soon again.

I'm still renting as I moved around a lot for jobs. I've saved hundreds of thousands of dollars, and intend to strike in 2023. I'm still looking for deals in the meanwhile, but most of these sellers are bitter that the market from even at ~5% in the summer is gone. And by and large the buyers disappeared in March in my region.

At a certain point, prices do have to match the cost of borrowing money. That's the trap of cheap loans. Those that got ~3% loans are stuck in whatever home they chose without a loss. They can't sell because most used that cheap money to pay ahead on decades of gains. Finding a sucker at 7%+ is going to be impossible, because short-term minded people simply don't have the money or means. And there's only so many generous and wealthy fathers to go around. Even those dads or investors don't want to take a risk in a market that hasn't bottomed out yet.

Once again, as always, cash is king.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:11PM (#33346600)
Many home owners can wait if their plans are flexible.

But taking it at face value, selling when prices are high is often a net-zero since you have to buy back into the same hot market (likewise, selling in a cold market can make sense if you want to upgrade into the same cold market). Selling in a hot market is only a net win for investment properties or second/third homes, and those people often can wait out cold markets (but sometimes they are leveraged like crazy and can't!).

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mupuff1234 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:27AM (#33345182)
Not selling doesn't magically make your house keep it's market value.

As long as there's someone in the vicinity selling at a lower price your house would lose value either way. And there's always someone selling.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Test0129 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345211)
It does however make it irrelevant. If you never plan on selling and your mortgage rate is low then you're winning on inflationary terms.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by BuckRogers on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:01PM (#33345690)
I'm not sure if I'd call it irrelevant. People have to do fast home sales for many reasons, and it can come up as a necessity at any time. Life can be a twisty road that we can't foresee. I suppose I can't disagree that hoping for the best makes it irrelevant.

Your second statement I wanted to agree with but you never really win with any mortgage (other than getting a home, which is important).

You'll pay for any house at any rate 2-3+ times over if you just pay the minimum payments. When you go to sell it at the end, your home will not have doubled in value or more. Not for anyone born after 1980 at least.

The only way to win financially is to pay off the house, or beat out usury by producing reliable market gains or other income to outpace it. Easier said than done, I would just pay off a home as fast as possible.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by quonn on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:54PM (#33347113)
> but you never really win with any mortgage

Maybe not at 7%. Maybe not at 3,5% either. But at 1-2% fixed for 10-20 years and you don't have to refinance, you win. So your statement is a bit broad.

I think it's a good exercise to compute the total interest over the time of the credit and relate that to the cost of renting.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by lelanthran on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:43PM (#33348377)
> You'll pay for any house at any rate 2-3+ times over if you just pay the minimum payments.

Maybe that's the problem - making only the minimum payments?

The people making only the minimum payment due would probably have screwed themselves in other ways, financially, even if interest remained the same.

I bought my house in Dec-2016[0]. My outstanding principle owed to the bank right now is just a hair over 17% of what the original principle was when I was granted the loan.

Whenever my circumstances improved (wage increases due to moving jobs, cash bonuses in employment, etc), the extra money each month always went into my mortgage, despite complaints from my wife that we could do with a nice holiday in some other part of the world (or that she could do with a new car[1]).

That's basically 6 years. Now perhaps there are people who did not have their income improved over 6 years, but I don't think that the majority of borrowers experienced no income improvement[2].

The real problem is that borrowers have been making the minimum monthly payments, and spending the increased income elsewhere (new iShinies, new cars, new furniture, expensive holidays ... whatever).

People underestimate just how much inroads they could make into their principle if they didn't have high monthly car payments, or "need" a 24-month cell plan that basically sells them the phone at twice the price because "Look, I get all these minutes and data for free each month".

[0] I'm not in the US, although in the country I am in, I'm in a fairly middle-class and desirable area

[1] As someone who can rebuild just about anything in an ICE car, I keep her car running just fine, even though it's a 2011 hatchback.

[2] I admit, I experienced drastic income improvement (roughly 40% increase) when I switched from being an embedded developer to a backend developer. Completing an MSc didn't hurt either.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by shapefrog on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:08PM (#33345784)
If you dont plan on selling how are you're winning on inflationary terms?

If you do sell, and the prices are higher, then you have won.

If you do sell, and the prices are lower, then you have lost.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by quonn on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:11PM (#33346594)
If you don't sell, the inflation makes your mortgage _relatively_ cheaper.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by quonn on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:48AM (#33345496)
If most people don't sell and there is high demand, then the few properties that will be on the market will be gone quickly and people will compete, driving up the prices.

So it really depends on how large the amount of people who don't want to but have to sell is compared to the amount of people who are looking to buy.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by UncleMeat on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:50AM (#33345529)
But no harm comes to me if my house value drops considerably if I'm not selling it. I keep on paying the same mortgage payment as before and I keep on living in my house. If the mortgage payment was worth it before, then it is worth it after.

The risk here is a home's value dropping a lot, putting somebody underwater, and then life circumstances forcing them to sell. That's bad. But for the rest of us that happily make our mortgage payments it doesn't mean a thing if the spam emails from Zillow show a new number.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by RhysU on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:30PM (#33350488)
Moreover, one's property taxes should fall as housing prices fall.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by SevenNation on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:26AM (#33345172)
> Most of the people I speak to who locked in <3.5% are not planning on selling in the next 10 years or more.

One way to look at this is to ask people what they plan to do. Another way is to look at what they've done.

According to this article, the average length of time spent in a house is 8 years:

> https://www.thezebra.com/resources/home/average-length-of-ho...

So unless those people you know just moved in, they're X years into a average 8 year occupancy.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kbelder on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:35AM (#33345313)
Only If you accept the wonderous concept that circumstances don't affect behavior.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mattwest on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:32AM (#33345265)
Agreed. I was just offering an anecdote from my personal circle, many of whom view their real estate purchases as an investment to tuck away. Mostly, these are people who divested a portion or their stock portfolio in mid-2021 and didn't want to sit on cash in anticipation of the current inflation we are seeing now.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by lelanthran on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:50PM (#33348480)
> According to this article, the average length of time spent in a house is 8 years:

>

> https://www.thezebra.com/resources/home/average-length-of-ho...

Okay, using your own reference, they also say that the median was 13.2 years.

Anyway, from that article you cited, a stunning 76% of homeowners stayed longer than 8 years.

It seems what more than 3/4 of homeowners do is simply live in the damn thing.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by diogenescynic on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:11AM (#33344923)
>Current renters will have lower potential to save on a monthly basis

It's cheaper to rent than to buy in many markets and if you own you have to factor in maintenance, property taxes, and insurance. It's definitely not as black and white as you're making it out to be.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Beldin on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @07:30PM (#33351037)
> if you own you have to factor in maintenance, property taxes, and insurance.

Around here, if you rent, your landlord factors those things into the rental price. Admittedly not necessarily the insurance; that typically is just a requirement of the lease.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by diogenescynic on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:00PM (#33351686)
The price to rent ratio compares the price to rent vs own. It’s definitely cheaper to rent than to own in many places. You can also get rent control in many cities so comparing renting to owning is going to vary with the specific situation.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Beldin on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:13AM (#33405954)
I'm sorry, I must be missing some subtelty here. If renting is indeed cheaper than owning, landlords would be subsidising renters. That can't be correct...
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ethbr0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:34AM (#33345302)
In the US at least, we really should simplify, ease, and mandate 401k loans/withdrawal options for first-time homebuying.

Doesn't help if rent eats all your paycheck, but if people are able to save they should be rewarded for doing so, and allowed to use that for a first home purchase.

https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/081815/can-i-take-m...

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:23PM (#33347462)
I'm not sure I understand. It's quite easy to take money out of your 401k without penalty for a first time home buyer. How could it be easier than just requesting the money?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ethbr0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:19PM (#33348834)
Loans are subject to plan administrators allowing it, and withdrawals are subject to taxes and penalties, unless one qualifies for a hardship exception which is nebulously defined and at IRS discretion for home purchases, no?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:48PM (#33349199)
Withdrawals are subject to taxes which is fair because you haven't paid taxes on it yet. While there may be some wiggle room for 401k administrators or the IRS, generally if you don't have other resources for a down payment on a house then you won't see any penalties for the withdrawal. The 401k loan will depend on your plan, but the terms are defined by your general plan, not something that the administrator will deny because you have poor credit.

That said, both of those generally sound like poor choices, but if you truly need it they are options(if your company allows loans). Saving for retirement is really meant to help you in retirement.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ethbr0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:33PM (#33349809)
We allow people to save for college in tax advantaged plans. Why not houses? And if so, why not use a vehicle that already exists (401k/IRA) instead of creating a whole new one?

The conventional wisdom that borrowing from your 401k to buy a house is always a poor move seems... overly reductive and a bit patronizing.

If someone isn't able to fund their 401k and save for a down payment, who am I to tell them that using a tax advantaged vehicle is a bad way to become a homeowner?

Mortgage rates, local rental prices, local home prices and inventory, living situation and likelihood of moving, tax situation, etc. all impact, and I don't know anyone's situation.

Besides, who wants all the money in the world if you have to spend most of your life living in a place you hate?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:53PM (#33350701)
I mean, I'd love to save for a home with a tax advantaged account. That sounds so good that if I ever planned on moving I'd want to max out my contributions to that, sell my house, take the money I earn from that house and dump it in my Roth 401k since I won't pay taxes on most of the capital gains, then take the distribution from the home savings account and put it towards the next down payment on a house and avoid taxes there too. As for why we don't allow you to do that from a 401k, for the same reason we have separate accounts for the education savings. 401k is designed to incentive retirement, not education or housing. Society could decide to make 401k's more broad, but I suspect that would just lead to the more well off people being able to better use them as tax shelters. Mortgages are already subsidized in other ways, including government down payment assistance, or low down payment requirements for loans.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by MuffinFlavored on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#33345462)
> Most of the people I speak to who locked in <3.5% are not planning on selling in the next 10 years or more.

If this keeps supply low, why does anybody have hope housing prices will fall in a meaningful way over the next 3 years? (aka, people on the sidelines waiting for a pullback)

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:16PM (#33345882)
Because it won’t keep supply low (nationwide) unless we figure out how to stop people from dying, or open immigration floodgates.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by 015a on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:50PM (#33350025)
Couple things to note about this:

1) Mortgages dropped below 3.5% in ~2019. The median duration of home ownership in the US is 8 years. So: asserting that "most people I speak to who have locked in <3.5% are not planning on selling in the next 10 years" is kind of like... That's normal. Statistics assert they weren't going to sell independent of rates.

2) People severely underestimate how many houses in the US have no mortgage against them. Its somewhere around 35-40%. That's oftentimes because: the typical home seller in 2021 was 56 years old. The friends you queried are (probably) an anomaly in the market.

3) The reasons cited for why home owners sell their properties is far more varied than financial. The most typical reasons are: current home is too small, want to live closer to friends or family, moving for work, the neighborhood is becoming undesirable, and... death. Even in lower interest rate environments, most of these reasons would have resulted in a higher monthly payment; that's reasonably normal. The monthly payments today are, well, much higher; but the fiction that "I'm not selling because I'll end up paying more" doesn't really have basis in the core motivations for home sales (they might in the absolute pits of a recession, but that doesn't usually last long; certainly not as long as elevated interest rates; and even if they did, plenty of people end up being forced to sell because of money; but they're not going to go buy a new home in this market).

4) Happening simultaneously with rising interest rates is: the largest transfer of wealth in the history of the united states. Boomers are dying. Its estimated that, as their deaths accelerate over the next ten years, $30T-$60T in wealth (most of it in: real estate!) will be inherited by younger generations. Those numbers are mind-boggling. Its estimated that millennials, as a generational cohort, currently hold something like $10T in total wealth.

Point being; there's a lot going on right now. Its really difficult to draw single-post conclusions about any of it.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US

https://www.thezebra.com/resources/home/average-length-of-ho...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/brendarichardson/2019/07/26/nea...

https://www.nar.realtor/research-and-statistics/research-rep...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/josephcoughlin/2021/11/16/mille...

https://www.magnifymoney.com/news/net-worth-of-millennials/

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by khuey on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:55AM (#33344629)
A lot of people simply won't sell in that situation which is going to further constrain supply.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by _huayra_ on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:58AM (#33344708)
This is another thing people don't consider: housing is priced at the margin. One house has to sell in the neighborhood because of divorce / death / etc, and boom you have the one comp that everything else is tied to.

Even if they stay in their home, people over-levered on their fake housing equity through HELOCs are in trouble.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ghastmaster on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:06AM (#33344826)
You are very correct. HELOCs, however, are not as big a factor as they used to be. They will become more popular though.

Wolf Richter shows some nice graphs in the article linked below. He states that mortgages in Q2 were $11.4T and HELOCs a mere $320B.

https://wolfstreet.com/2022/08/04/trip-back-to-reality-start...

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bushbaba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:20AM (#33345073)
Low rates meant that people could cash out refi at lower rates.

Don’t forget there’s a small but still notable number of homeowners with ARM mortgages.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by thatfrenchguy on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:23AM (#33345127)
And no more building because rates are high there so the next time rates go down there’s no supply…
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:14PM (#33346642)
Even worse than that: people in construction will change career paths, and apprentices won't enter the industry for the next 5-10 years leading to a dearth of experience when it comes time to build houses again.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ren_engineer on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:04AM (#33344792)
you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

This also ignores the fact that the Fed's stated goal with raising interests rates is to increase unemployment to slow inflation. You are already seeing the results in quarterly financials. Once layoffs start happening people won't have an option but to sell when they can't make payments

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345089)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

Yes?

Why wouldn't you?

It seems pretty short-sighted to just put your arms in the air, give up, get foreclosed on, lose your home, and have your credit be absolutely wrecked for the next 7 years.

Just keep making your payments and ride it out. The market will eventually recover.

I think the only reason to give up is if you fell for the scam that is an adjustable-rate mortgage and your payments are skyrocketing and you can't afford it anymore.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by pchristensen on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:29AM (#33345217)
I bought a house in the Chicago suburbs in August 2007 for $275k. I short sold it 4 years later for $115k. It sold 2 years ago (13 years afer I bought it) for $210k.

"Eventually" is doing a lot of work in your comment.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#33345461)
People seem to look at aggregate housing, and pretend that every buyer's experience will be "about average".

Buying a house is akin to putting your retirement into the stock of a single company. In that situation, it doesn't matter what the S&P500 tends to do on a long enough timeline.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by supertrope on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:06PM (#33345765)
Which is why buying a house should be considered consumption. It's to have a residence. Asset appreciation in real estate is a very long game and is not guaranteed. Strategic default will wreck your credit.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:23PM (#33345982)
Chicago metro real estate is unique in its price changes due to outlier amounts of debt for state and local governments. Both Chicago and IL are multiple standard deviations above the norm for projected tax liabilities, so accounting for that reduces the amount people pay for the real estate.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:59PM (#33347180)
Really, I think I'm making three incorrect assumptions:

1. People that buy a house will stay in it for 10+ years. This assumption being wrong means you're more likely to be affected by market swings.

2. Market swings won't be massively significant, for some definition of "massive", and I consider 275k -> 115k massive. Meanwhile, the Z-estimate of my house peaked at $618K this April, and is now at $561K. I would not consider that one massive.

3. That people stopping making payments because it's underwater, and not some extenuating circumstance, like losing your job and being unable to afford payments, or having a need to relocate that is unrelated to your home being underwater.

But it's #3 that really gets me. I fail to understand the "My mortgage is underwater" -> "I should stop making payments" logic jump.

I think it's because I do not see my house as investment or even an "asset". It's my HOME. I agreed to pay $338K in 2015 to have a HOME. If there was a real estate crash immediately afterwards and I was underwater, my only regret would be that I could have bought the house cheaper if I had waited a little longer. I would not in any way feel incentivized to stop making payments and walk away, because not only would that mean I would still owe the bank money, but I wouldn't have a home and my credit would be destroyed, making it hard to get another mortgage.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by pchristensen on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:05PM (#33348656)
With taxes, mortgage, and maintenance, I was paying about $1k/mo more than I would have paid for comparable rent. We stayed, watching our house fall in value for over 3 years. Housing is housing, but it's also an investment, and paying $12k extra every year on an asset that would take decades to break even isn't smart. We took the option that was available to us. FWIW, the credit impact wasn't bad, because so many people defaulted on loans in that period so there was a lot of grace given.

That being said, I don't expect 2022-23 to be like 2008-10 for housing.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by andsoitis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345196)
Concur.

As a relatively new first-time homeowner (a year), do you know whether a mortgage lender requires higher or additional insurance coverage for an underwater property?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#33345568)
I don't think so. The time for requirements is when the loan is originated. I think it's typical to require mortgage insurance when the loan is more than 80% of the value, and it's very uncommon to loan more than 95% of the value.

If the loan goes underwater later, usually because of market conditions, maybe because of creative loan features, then the lender has no leverage to require anything.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by avgDev on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#33345570)
No. Why would they?

You are required to have insurance when you have a loan on a property. The insurance rates could actually drop due to lower cost to replace your house.

Underwater property just means you owe more than it is worth. However, if your interest rate is low, you might be paying less than someone who is not underwater.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:26AM (#33345169)
> Why wouldn't you?

Well, you could ask the very large number of people who defaulted on their underwater mortgages in previous housing crashes.

Does everyone do it? No.

Do a significant number of people do it? Absolutely.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:56AM (#33345618)
That's not what happened in 2008. This exact scenario was the primary cause of the financial meltdown at the time. The prevailing wisdom was people would always pay their mortgage, so the securitization of real estate mortgages were viewed as a safe investment - and invest they did! When the housing bubble popped a lot of investment banks who thought they had safe assets suddenly found themselves upside down, further compounding the problem and turning it into a full-fledged crises necessitating congressional intervention. Perhaps you're too young to know this story, but this is what happened. There's no reason to believe homeowners won't behave in the same manner today. We can argue whether this behavior is rational or not, but we're rather infamous for not being rational creatures, are we not?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by b3morales on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:15PM (#33345875)
This is true, but it's also missing the key part where leading up to 2008 lenders offered mortgages to people they were pretty sure wouldn't be able to keep paying, and then laundered those into the so-called "safe" investment when it was anything but.

Is that part repeating now too?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:53PM (#33347099)
I think the laundering is a bit overstated. Yes, there were "risky" loans being made but those risks were being mitigated by bundling those loans with "safe" loans into a new securities product. No one was really surprised by the risky loans going under. It was the presumably "safe" loans going under that caught everybody off-guard and created the financial storm. The entire mortgage risk model turned out to be wrong.

Your second question is interesting, I really don't know whether the securitization of mortgages is still happening today at the same level it was then. I would presume so? With a different risk model being employed to assess those mortgages, maybe?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by theGnuMe on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:46PM (#33348413)
The securities rating folks basically rated subprime crap as prime. Nobody could trust anything so everyone want to sell and not buy.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:13PM (#33347354)
> When the housing bubble popped

Your comment misses what created the popping of the bubble. The sibling comment talking about sub-prime mortgages talks about them, and I think they're right.

I was always under the impression that the crisis began with people that couldn't pay their mortgages because banks were handing them out to people that couldn't afford them. This created downward pressure as foreclosed houses flooded the market, and irrational people decided to abandon their mortgages because they were underwater, exacerbating the problem.

> Perhaps you're too young to know this story, but this is what happened.

I'm 40, if that helps. Though in 2008, when I was 26, I was managing a Subway restaurant for $10/hr and living in a $650/month apartment (Which is now a ridiculous $1,300/month, literally double), whereas now I own a house and work in cybersecurity for an order of magnitude more.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:32PM (#33347560)
Maybe you and the other commenter were talking about the so-called "jumbo" loans or interest-only loans that had become popular at the time. This was at the height of "flipping" and the idea was you'd make into your house and after five years you'd flip it and make a fortune because home prices were soaring so high. I saw the writing on the wall, but a lot of home buyers apparently didn't realize this was a first-mover opportunity and they may be left holding the bag. As it turned out, that was only the tip of the iceberg and that is what caught everybody by surprise!
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by theGnuMe on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:44PM (#33348394)
Jumbo loans are for any house over $648k which is where FHA limits stop.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by HWR_14 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:25PM (#33346008)
> Why wouldn't you?

Because it's upside down? You can buy another place and owe less on it?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by supertrope on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:44PM (#33346252)
Unless you can buy the next house in cash you'll be waiting seven years for your credit to recover.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:16PM (#33347394)
No, because no matter what, I'll still owe the bank the difference between the value of the house and the mortgage balance. If I was foreclosed on, then my credit is wrecked and I wouldn't be able to get a mortgage on the new house.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:44PM (#33347682)
I know several people that walked away from homes in 2008 and if they had a good job they bought another home for half the price down the street. Your fears didn't materialize for them. Every one of them bought nicer homes as well.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by polski-g on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:00PM (#33347868)
Have your spouse pay for the new house.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:07AM (#33344855)
In most states, lenders have recourse. So if you stop paying your mortgage, the bank will foreclose on your home and then come after your other assets to make up the difference in what you owe vs. what the home is currently worth.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345091)
I’ve defaulted on two mortgages in a recourse state, one primary residence, one investment property. Neither was pursued. While extreme, you can always move to Texas or Florida; they have incredibly strong creditor protections making you mostly judgement proof. Depends on your threat model, exposure, and risk tolerance.

(not legal advice, educational purposes only)

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:44AM (#33345447)
How much did you owe after the properties were sold?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:03PM (#33345713)
Zero. And I was eligible for a new FHA mortgage 3 years after.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:09PM (#33345807)
I mean what was the difference between your outstanding mortgage principal and the value of the homes at the time of default?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:31PM (#33346093)
Roughly $300k in aggregate
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bxparks on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:31AM (#33345248)
Recourse versus non-recourse mortgages is an interesting difference that most people seem to be unaware of. I do not recall reading about it in any of the disclosures (running hundreds of pages) that I had to read. I only found out about it while researching on the internet.

Apparently, there are only 10 non-recourse states as of 2009: Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Oregon, Washington, and Nevada. The tricky thing is that only the initial mortgage is non-recourse. A refinanced mortgage becomes recourse, but interestingly, they don't seem to be required to disclose that in the disclosures.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:14PM (#33345863)
Refinance in California remains non-recourse as of maybe 10 years ago.

Washington isn't really non-recourse, lenders have the option of recourse or non when pursuing foreclosure, non-recourse is significantly faster and is predominantly chosen; but if it was known you had assets, they might choose to go recourse.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bxparks on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:45PM (#33348409)
According to https://www.bankruptcysoapbox.com/california-extends-protect..., you are correct for loans after Jan 1, 2013. The relevant statute SB-1069 is here: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bushbaba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345093)
Always thought this was predatory. California does it right in being a no recourse state. CA mortgages cost the same as elsewhere.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by irrational on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345206)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

Yes? Our home keeps the rain off our heads. I’m not going to risk that by not paying my mortgage just because I couldn’t sell my house right now for enough to cover the mortgage.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by rossdavidh on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#33344875)
Good point, and I wonder if the term "jingle mail" (mailing the bank your house keys instead of a monthly mortgage check) is going to make a comeback.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:40PM (#33346207)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

The payments might be comparable to if they got a current rate mortgage at the current value.

There's reasons it would be nicer to have a lower loan balance at a higher rate and the same stream of payments, but it's probably not worth the cost of moving and a foreclosure on your record.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by gedy on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:57AM (#33344681)
I hear this every cycle, but people forget even if the person who bought high won't, their neighbor who bought low (maybe a long time ago) will.

And a lot of people end up having to sell.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by dont__panic on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:59AM (#33344729)
And dropping prices mean that someone who's been holding out over the last few years of insane price growth might finally find a home elsewhere that they can afford.

As someone who was too young to climb aboard the price bubble of the last 5 years: here's hoping.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by falcolas on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:09AM (#33344888)
The price would have to drop dramatically (30%, the amount the last bubble dropped, would not be enough) to get a lower monthly mortgage payment.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by gedy on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:51PM (#33347068)
Your downpayment goes a lot further though.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by saiya-jin on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:12AM (#33344930)
Exactly, prices don't fall in symmetrical ways as they rise in happy times due to people's greed (or patience to wait). Seen it in 2008 and even before.

Now it we are facing truly cataclysmic long term situation down the road never ever seen before (or at least comparable to 1929) that's a different story, but few insiders believe that now.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by conception on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:59AM (#33344722)
There isn’t a supply issue. There is a corporations buying property issue.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:20AM (#33345058)
I sometimes hear people say this, but it makes zero sense to me, and I can never get anybody to explain what they mean by it. Could you try to explain how we have enough houses but somehow corporations are the problem?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by buscoquadnary on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:38AM (#33345368)
Basically RE prices went through the roof and became an object of investment that gained in value during a time when money was cheap and cash was a bad place to store it.

This caused management funds, BlackRock Berkshire etc, to start purchasing the homes as investment vehicles. These vehicles then will either sit on a house or simply rent the house out at a rate that makes fiscal sense, regardless of the economic realities.

This artificially restricts supply as they take these houses off the market, they don't care if the house sits empty for years as long as they can sell it at their target price, and then at the same time causes rents to be raised as the rental prices are set by an internal ROI formula and not what the local market can bear.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#33345460)
I can understand a small time house investor not renting out the house, and I see that all around me, in a very very tight housing market. Small time owners of 2-3 houses, especially those who have paid off the mortgage, avoid the hassle of renting because they have limited time to seek out tenants and deal with them, or limited tolerance for risk from a bad tenant.

But I can not for one moment understand a cooperate buyer not renting it out; they have more than enough capacity to rent out homes, they can spread risk across lots of properties, and any time not spent renting is merely money left on the table, which would come back to bite any manager that is leaving a lot of money on the table.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#33345573)
And some of those investors already lost their asses buying up SFH. I'm sure the rest see the writing on the wall. For example, BRG spun off a home trust division just this month, and it's the one that bought up all of these SFH during the boom. Could it be that they were expecting a massive drop in value of these investments?

SFH are a pretty insane choice of RE investment for institutions because they are so incredibly inefficient compared to apartment and office buildings.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by quonn on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:34PM (#33346128)
> This artificially restricts supply as they take these houses off the market, they don't care if the house sits empty for years as long as they can sell it at their target price

Private owners would also sit it out if they can. Unless they can't. You think that's better? People having to sell at a big loss?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kitsunesoba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:32AM (#33345272)
Corporate buyers are one of the many exacerbating factors, and I think that’s what most are saying when they say corporate home buying is a problem.

In other words, there aren’t enough homes and corporations sitting on some percentage of them is making the situation that much worse.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:48AM (#33345508)
I don't understand how a corporate purchaser is worse than any other investor; I live in an area with almost only single family homes, and a huge fraction of them are investor owned and rented out. The small time land lords have a huge variance in how well they behave, but I'm not sure why corporate landlords are worse.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kitsunesoba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:52AM (#33345551)
I think the idea is that corporate owners are helping keep prices propped up because they’re much less sensitive to vacancy. They can let a house sit unoccupied for much longer before dropping the price to get someone in compared to a small time landlord. Smalltimers don’t usually have the capital available to do that and will either need to drop prices to get someone in the house or sell the house.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:35PM (#33346132)
Perhaps I'm too used to the California market, where the carrying cost of a long-held property goes basically to zero, and most landlords are long time holders of property.

So those who have recently bought a property, even corporate buyers, are far far more likely to keep a property occupied than most landlords.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by insanitybit on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:04PM (#33345731)
I assume because it allows for what amounts to price fixing.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:18PM (#33345909)
They would have to consist of a huge fraction of the market in order to do price fixing, but the highest percentage of purchases I have ever seen referenced is about 10% of purchases in a time period, which doesn't get anywhere close to having a significant number of the housing stock.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by insanitybit on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:10PM (#33347995)
How huge, do you think? I imagine that in actuality 10% would be enough to move the market, especially if other players do the same.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by epistasis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:06PM (#33348667)
10% of a few quarters of purchases is still a tiny tiny tiny fraction of the market, and not enough to coordinate pricing.

I think a far bigger concern is shortages of housing as individual homeowners and landlords act as a group to suppress local supply of housing. Local city councils tend to be controlled by such real estate interests. Corporate purchasers can piggy-back on that sort of regulatory capture without expending a single dime.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by diogenescynic on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:04AM (#33344809)
You've got it backwards. The bigger issue is that we aren't building new supply to meet demand. Corporations buying property is only an issue because we've stopped/slowed new home development/supply to not keep up with demand. Allow supply to meet demand and the corporations don't have a market to monopolize. This is the law of supply and demand 101.

But the same people that are usually against corporations buying properties, are usually against new home development and increased housing density. I saw many housing activists in the Bay Area who were against new housing at market rates and thought all new housing should be at below-market-rate prices--which simply isn't possible.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by refurb on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:04AM (#33344793)
So too many buyers and not enough houses?

Sounds like a supply issue.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by qqqwerty on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:54PM (#33348534)
Most people only own one home and when they sell their current home they need to buy or rent another one. So for these owners, the supply/demand balance should be minimally impacted by their actions. This is certainly an over simplification of how things work, for example during COVID a flight to the burbs caused a drop in urban condos and rise in single family homes. But on balance, I think it is a good rule of thumb to consider when trying to evaluate the real estate market.

This means that prices are more likely going to be determined by the supply-demand balance between first time buyers, investor activity, new home builders, life events (death, divorce, etc...) and immigration vs emigration. I personally think that if employment holds steady, we will see more of a sideways market with some regional variances, but if employment starts going down then do does housing.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by irrational on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:25AM (#33345152)
We purchased a year ago with a 2.4% mortgage. We are planning on staying here till retirement. I don’t much care where home prices go in the short term, but I do wonder where they will be in decades from now.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by blhack on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:20AM (#33345069)
>I don't think most people who invested in housing in the last couple years, are ready to believe that yet.

Because it isn't going to happen. The people who invested in houses years ago locked in a low interest rate, and will happily just rent them out to cover the cost until they appreciate again.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by brink on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:55AM (#33344641)
I don't see how they're going to go down that low. To do that, you need to have oversupply, or you need to be able to build a house for that price (building prices are up and will likely stay up due to prices of materials, living cost, and energy).

Employers are having trouble finding labor, the government has its foot on the neck of the non-green energy sector, the world is not producing like it used to when prices fell in the past.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by trashtester on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:25AM (#33345145)
One thing about housing, is that if more people live in each unit, demand can go down quite a bit. This isn't happening during a 2 year bust, but if inflation becomes endemic, people may be forced to. Some unhappy couples may continue to live together, children don't leave their parents' homes, students that shared an apartment while studying continue to do so after they start working, etc. Also, more people who own houses may decide to rent out half.

The price at the margin will never exceed what the marginal buyer is able to pay, regardless of supply.

What you get in a case like thiswhere even parts of the middle class may be essentially homeless, is widespread social unrest. At that point, expect regulators and governments to take measures to make sure the supply of housing becomes big and cheap enough for at least the lower middle class to be able to afford a place to live (even if they have to rent). Unrest is more damaging to them than some unhappy homeowner lobbyists.

And by cutting the red tape, it's possible to make housing MUCH cheaper than it is today (at least per housing unit, if not by area).

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by allemagne on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:33AM (#33345293)
Prices don't have to fall back down to pre-inflation levels for inflation to end.

I'm not at all following why it's obvious that mortgage payments will have to be the same for the same house as they were at ~2021 for rate hiking to stop.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by tonmoy on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @10:58AM (#33344692)
People would just rent instead of buying house. Rent should not go down that much. So buyers with cash will just buy houses and rent it out.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by deathanatos on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345189)
Rents aren't going to go down. Raising mortgage rates makes housing more expensive, by raising the cost of the mortgage. That's going to force some would-be buyers to not be buyers, and to instead, rent. More demand on rent => prices go up.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by rossdavidh on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:10AM (#33344895)
I do see evidence of people renting, because they intend to buy next year when the prices are lower. So I do think rent will be a lagging indicator, and will keep going up for a while. That will keep the inflationary pressure on the Fed to raise rates higher and for longer.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bjornsing on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:58AM (#33345646)
Why only to $230,000? Wouldn’t the price have to drop to 400*(2/9)=89k to keep mortgage payments the same?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by simantel on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:16PM (#33347386)
Because some of your payment goes to principal, it's not all interest.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bjornsing on Thursday October 27, 2022 @04:17AM (#33354698)
Of course. Thanks. Didn’t realize that was standardized. Here in Sweden the terms are government mandated and different depending on your salary and money down.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by teeray on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:53PM (#33346375)
So everyone’s equity is now converted into more bank profits. Neat.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by caeril on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:41PM (#33348351)
> people who invested in housing in the last couple years

If you "invested" in housing, you get what you deserve.

My house serves a functional purpose. It is not a status symbol, it is not a means of extracting rents from others. It shelters and operates as a home base for my family.

Real estate "investors" who lose everything in this next cycle will elicit precisely zero tears.