"Eventually" is doing a lot of work in your comment.
Buying a house is akin to putting your retirement into the stock of a single company. In that situation, it doesn't matter what the S&P500 tends to do on a long enough timeline.
1. People that buy a house will stay in it for 10+ years. This assumption being wrong means you're more likely to be affected by market swings.
2. Market swings won't be massively significant, for some definition of "massive", and I consider 275k -> 115k massive. Meanwhile, the Z-estimate of my house peaked at $618K this April, and is now at $561K. I would not consider that one massive.
3. That people stopping making payments because it's underwater, and not some extenuating circumstance, like losing your job and being unable to afford payments, or having a need to relocate that is unrelated to your home being underwater.
But it's #3 that really gets me. I fail to understand the "My mortgage is underwater" -> "I should stop making payments" logic jump.
I think it's because I do not see my house as investment or even an "asset". It's my HOME. I agreed to pay $338K in 2015 to have a HOME. If there was a real estate crash immediately afterwards and I was underwater, my only regret would be that I could have bought the house cheaper if I had waited a little longer. I would not in any way feel incentivized to stop making payments and walk away, because not only would that mean I would still owe the bank money, but I wouldn't have a home and my credit would be destroyed, making it hard to get another mortgage.
That being said, I don't expect 2022-23 to be like 2008-10 for housing.
As a relatively new first-time homeowner (a year), do you know whether a mortgage lender requires higher or additional insurance coverage for an underwater property?
If the loan goes underwater later, usually because of market conditions, maybe because of creative loan features, then the lender has no leverage to require anything.
You are required to have insurance when you have a loan on a property. The insurance rates could actually drop due to lower cost to replace your house.
Underwater property just means you owe more than it is worth. However, if your interest rate is low, you might be paying less than someone who is not underwater.
Well, you could ask the very large number of people who defaulted on their underwater mortgages in previous housing crashes.
Does everyone do it? No.
Do a significant number of people do it? Absolutely.
Is that part repeating now too?
Your second question is interesting, I really don't know whether the securitization of mortgages is still happening today at the same level it was then. I would presume so? With a different risk model being employed to assess those mortgages, maybe?
Your comment misses what created the popping of the bubble. The sibling comment talking about sub-prime mortgages talks about them, and I think they're right.
I was always under the impression that the crisis began with people that couldn't pay their mortgages because banks were handing them out to people that couldn't afford them. This created downward pressure as foreclosed houses flooded the market, and irrational people decided to abandon their mortgages because they were underwater, exacerbating the problem.
> Perhaps you're too young to know this story, but this is what happened.
I'm 40, if that helps. Though in 2008, when I was 26, I was managing a Subway restaurant for $10/hr and living in a $650/month apartment (Which is now a ridiculous $1,300/month, literally double), whereas now I own a house and work in cybersecurity for an order of magnitude more.
Because it's upside down? You can buy another place and owe less on it?
Yes?
Why wouldn't you?
It seems pretty short-sighted to just put your arms in the air, give up, get foreclosed on, lose your home, and have your credit be absolutely wrecked for the next 7 years.
Just keep making your payments and ride it out. The market will eventually recover.
I think the only reason to give up is if you fell for the scam that is an adjustable-rate mortgage and your payments are skyrocketing and you can't afford it anymore.