News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by ren_engineer on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:04AM (#33344792)
you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

This also ignores the fact that the Fed's stated goal with raising interests rates is to increase unemployment to slow inflation. You are already seeing the results in quarterly financials. Once layoffs start happening people won't have an option but to sell when they can't make payments

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345089)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

Yes?

Why wouldn't you?

It seems pretty short-sighted to just put your arms in the air, give up, get foreclosed on, lose your home, and have your credit be absolutely wrecked for the next 7 years.

Just keep making your payments and ride it out. The market will eventually recover.

I think the only reason to give up is if you fell for the scam that is an adjustable-rate mortgage and your payments are skyrocketing and you can't afford it anymore.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by pchristensen on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:29AM (#33345217)
I bought a house in the Chicago suburbs in August 2007 for $275k. I short sold it 4 years later for $115k. It sold 2 years ago (13 years afer I bought it) for $210k.

"Eventually" is doing a lot of work in your comment.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:45AM (#33345461)
People seem to look at aggregate housing, and pretend that every buyer's experience will be "about average".

Buying a house is akin to putting your retirement into the stock of a single company. In that situation, it doesn't matter what the S&P500 tends to do on a long enough timeline.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by supertrope on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:06PM (#33345765)
Which is why buying a house should be considered consumption. It's to have a residence. Asset appreciation in real estate is a very long game and is not guaranteed. Strategic default will wreck your credit.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:23PM (#33345982)
Chicago metro real estate is unique in its price changes due to outlier amounts of debt for state and local governments. Both Chicago and IL are multiple standard deviations above the norm for projected tax liabilities, so accounting for that reduces the amount people pay for the real estate.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:59PM (#33347180)
Really, I think I'm making three incorrect assumptions:

1. People that buy a house will stay in it for 10+ years. This assumption being wrong means you're more likely to be affected by market swings.

2. Market swings won't be massively significant, for some definition of "massive", and I consider 275k -> 115k massive. Meanwhile, the Z-estimate of my house peaked at $618K this April, and is now at $561K. I would not consider that one massive.

3. That people stopping making payments because it's underwater, and not some extenuating circumstance, like losing your job and being unable to afford payments, or having a need to relocate that is unrelated to your home being underwater.

But it's #3 that really gets me. I fail to understand the "My mortgage is underwater" -> "I should stop making payments" logic jump.

I think it's because I do not see my house as investment or even an "asset". It's my HOME. I agreed to pay $338K in 2015 to have a HOME. If there was a real estate crash immediately afterwards and I was underwater, my only regret would be that I could have bought the house cheaper if I had waited a little longer. I would not in any way feel incentivized to stop making payments and walk away, because not only would that mean I would still owe the bank money, but I wouldn't have a home and my credit would be destroyed, making it hard to get another mortgage.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by pchristensen on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:05PM (#33348656)
With taxes, mortgage, and maintenance, I was paying about $1k/mo more than I would have paid for comparable rent. We stayed, watching our house fall in value for over 3 years. Housing is housing, but it's also an investment, and paying $12k extra every year on an asset that would take decades to break even isn't smart. We took the option that was available to us. FWIW, the credit impact wasn't bad, because so many people defaulted on loans in that period so there was a lot of grace given.

That being said, I don't expect 2022-23 to be like 2008-10 for housing.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by andsoitis on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345196)
Concur.

As a relatively new first-time homeowner (a year), do you know whether a mortgage lender requires higher or additional insurance coverage for an underwater property?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#33345568)
I don't think so. The time for requirements is when the loan is originated. I think it's typical to require mortgage insurance when the loan is more than 80% of the value, and it's very uncommon to loan more than 95% of the value.

If the loan goes underwater later, usually because of market conditions, maybe because of creative loan features, then the lender has no leverage to require anything.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by avgDev on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#33345570)
No. Why would they?

You are required to have insurance when you have a loan on a property. The insurance rates could actually drop due to lower cost to replace your house.

Underwater property just means you owe more than it is worth. However, if your interest rate is low, you might be paying less than someone who is not underwater.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:26AM (#33345169)
> Why wouldn't you?

Well, you could ask the very large number of people who defaulted on their underwater mortgages in previous housing crashes.

Does everyone do it? No.

Do a significant number of people do it? Absolutely.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:56AM (#33345618)
That's not what happened in 2008. This exact scenario was the primary cause of the financial meltdown at the time. The prevailing wisdom was people would always pay their mortgage, so the securitization of real estate mortgages were viewed as a safe investment - and invest they did! When the housing bubble popped a lot of investment banks who thought they had safe assets suddenly found themselves upside down, further compounding the problem and turning it into a full-fledged crises necessitating congressional intervention. Perhaps you're too young to know this story, but this is what happened. There's no reason to believe homeowners won't behave in the same manner today. We can argue whether this behavior is rational or not, but we're rather infamous for not being rational creatures, are we not?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by b3morales on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:15PM (#33345875)
This is true, but it's also missing the key part where leading up to 2008 lenders offered mortgages to people they were pretty sure wouldn't be able to keep paying, and then laundered those into the so-called "safe" investment when it was anything but.

Is that part repeating now too?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @01:53PM (#33347099)
I think the laundering is a bit overstated. Yes, there were "risky" loans being made but those risks were being mitigated by bundling those loans with "safe" loans into a new securities product. No one was really surprised by the risky loans going under. It was the presumably "safe" loans going under that caught everybody off-guard and created the financial storm. The entire mortgage risk model turned out to be wrong.

Your second question is interesting, I really don't know whether the securitization of mortgages is still happening today at the same level it was then. I would presume so? With a different risk model being employed to assess those mortgages, maybe?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by theGnuMe on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:46PM (#33348413)
The securities rating folks basically rated subprime crap as prime. Nobody could trust anything so everyone want to sell and not buy.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:13PM (#33347354)
> When the housing bubble popped

Your comment misses what created the popping of the bubble. The sibling comment talking about sub-prime mortgages talks about them, and I think they're right.

I was always under the impression that the crisis began with people that couldn't pay their mortgages because banks were handing them out to people that couldn't afford them. This created downward pressure as foreclosed houses flooded the market, and irrational people decided to abandon their mortgages because they were underwater, exacerbating the problem.

> Perhaps you're too young to know this story, but this is what happened.

I'm 40, if that helps. Though in 2008, when I was 26, I was managing a Subway restaurant for $10/hr and living in a $650/month apartment (Which is now a ridiculous $1,300/month, literally double), whereas now I own a house and work in cybersecurity for an order of magnitude more.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by taylodl on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:32PM (#33347560)
Maybe you and the other commenter were talking about the so-called "jumbo" loans or interest-only loans that had become popular at the time. This was at the height of "flipping" and the idea was you'd make into your house and after five years you'd flip it and make a fortune because home prices were soaring so high. I saw the writing on the wall, but a lot of home buyers apparently didn't realize this was a first-mover opportunity and they may be left holding the bag. As it turned out, that was only the tip of the iceberg and that is what caught everybody by surprise!
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by theGnuMe on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:44PM (#33348394)
Jumbo loans are for any house over $648k which is where FHA limits stop.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by HWR_14 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:25PM (#33346008)
> Why wouldn't you?

Because it's upside down? You can buy another place and owe less on it?

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by supertrope on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:44PM (#33346252)
Unless you can buy the next house in cash you'll be waiting seven years for your credit to recover.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:16PM (#33347394)
No, because no matter what, I'll still owe the bank the difference between the value of the house and the mortgage balance. If I was foreclosed on, then my credit is wrecked and I wouldn't be able to get a mortgage on the new house.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by frumper on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @02:44PM (#33347682)
I know several people that walked away from homes in 2008 and if they had a good job they bought another home for half the price down the street. Your fears didn't materialize for them. Every one of them bought nicer homes as well.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by polski-g on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:00PM (#33347868)
Have your spouse pay for the new house.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:07AM (#33344855)
In most states, lenders have recourse. So if you stop paying your mortgage, the bank will foreclose on your home and then come after your other assets to make up the difference in what you owe vs. what the home is currently worth.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345091)
I’ve defaulted on two mortgages in a recourse state, one primary residence, one investment property. Neither was pursued. While extreme, you can always move to Texas or Florida; they have incredibly strong creditor protections making you mostly judgement proof. Depends on your threat model, exposure, and risk tolerance.

(not legal advice, educational purposes only)

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:44AM (#33345447)
How much did you owe after the properties were sold?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:03PM (#33345713)
Zero. And I was eligible for a new FHA mortgage 3 years after.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by kotlin2 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:09PM (#33345807)
I mean what was the difference between your outstanding mortgage principal and the value of the homes at the time of default?
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:31PM (#33346093)
Roughly $300k in aggregate
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bxparks on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:31AM (#33345248)
Recourse versus non-recourse mortgages is an interesting difference that most people seem to be unaware of. I do not recall reading about it in any of the disclosures (running hundreds of pages) that I had to read. I only found out about it while researching on the internet.

Apparently, there are only 10 non-recourse states as of 2009: Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Oregon, Washington, and Nevada. The tricky thing is that only the initial mortgage is non-recourse. A refinanced mortgage becomes recourse, but interestingly, they don't seem to be required to disclose that in the disclosures.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:14PM (#33345863)
Refinance in California remains non-recourse as of maybe 10 years ago.

Washington isn't really non-recourse, lenders have the option of recourse or non when pursuing foreclosure, non-recourse is significantly faster and is predominantly chosen; but if it was known you had assets, they might choose to go recourse.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bxparks on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @03:45PM (#33348409)
According to https://www.bankruptcysoapbox.com/california-extends-protect..., you are correct for loans after Jan 1, 2013. The relevant statute SB-1069 is here: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by bushbaba on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:21AM (#33345093)
Always thought this was predatory. California does it right in being a no recourse state. CA mortgages cost the same as elsewhere.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by irrational on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33345206)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

Yes? Our home keeps the rain off our heads. I’m not going to risk that by not paying my mortgage just because I couldn’t sell my house right now for enough to cover the mortgage.

Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by rossdavidh on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#33344875)
Good point, and I wonder if the term "jingle mail" (mailing the bank your house keys instead of a monthly mortgage check) is going to make a comeback.
Re:U.S. mortgage interest rates jump to 7.16%, highest since... by toast0 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:40PM (#33346207)
> you think people are going to pay mortgages they are massively underwater on?

The payments might be comparable to if they got a current rate mortgage at the current value.

There's reasons it would be nicer to have a lower loan balance at a higher rate and the same stream of payments, but it's probably not worth the cost of moving and a foreclosure on your record.